I love the ending of II2 17 but I don’t like the ending of ONE 18 II2 17 thoughts I thought this was a ONE 18-esque scenario but done a lot better imo. Even if all of MeLife is just gone like that, I felt that it fit a lot, especially with the twist at the end of episode 16. Season 1 and half of season 2 being lower quality makes sense and it’s more watchable knowing that everything shown is just MePhone 4’s creations. The true nature of II2 was hidden canonically because that is exactly what MePhone wanted, II was meant to be an escape from reality but Cobs saw that, then III was also meant to be an escape from reality so MePhone (iirc) basically had to stop time. Watching the earlier stuff and knowing this was just the beginning of MePhone4’s MeLife stuff makes it genuinely interesting to watch, and it being initially just a bunch of humour based stuff also fits. It’s like MePhone4 just wanted to have fun. But then again this is a lot of rambling. I thought the ending of this episode itself was done well. We had connections to these characters, but we also knew they were just creations of MePhone4, and their purpose was to compete. So there’s no way this episode could end in a “happily ever after” moment at all because this is true. This has always been true though. The characters have always been MePhone4’s OCs. We got the main questions of the show answered before the ending, which I like. This ending actually did make me feel empty and sad because everything just got wiped out. This ending wasn’t even disappointing, the intended feeling actually got to me, I loved this episode. I can absolutely rewatch II and it would be so different it would be surreal, I love that. Can’t say the same about ONE 18 though ONE 18 thoughts I’ll just say it is written well and it does make sense, but this is clearly designed for a first watch. ONE was meant to get the viewer intrigued with the story but then it abruptly ended. After ONE 18 I honestly was disappointed and was no longer intrigued, and now I find that rewatching ONE would be pointless because well, you already know how it’ll end, it’s designed for a first watch. Nothing was really answered, which makes sense, but I still can’t be intrigued. Another factor is the lack of huge attachment towards characters like II has, tho tbf ONE ran for like 1-2 years. The whole episode just felt disappointing imo, not really an empty mysterious vibe to me, just disappointing. Another thing is that the ending is meant to be based on an object show getting cancelled but honestly? I don’t buy into that. It was way too sudden for me to think that it replicated it well. Maybe in a viewer’s perspective it did, but definitely not in a creator’s perspective. It felt like the “cancelling an object show” vibe didn’t exist until ONE 18. Cancellations though are very gradual for a creator, lots of thinking and even more stress, and also production hell. But canonically ONE was going just fine. I think this is well written but definitely not my cup of tea and I don’t get enough of a “cancelled object show” vibe for my liking. I indeed yap a lot, how did you know
I loved the episode, but that ending really upset me. Like, in an annoyed way, not an emotional way. 3 seasons of buildup and personalities put in these characters, just to delete them. Not even really finishing the plots for some characters. I understand in some way that's the point, but it just kinda feels upsetting. If it's genuinely the last episode (which I'm beginning to come to terms that it might be), it's just left a really bad stain in my mouth, and it will be hard to clean the stain off when rewatching the show again. It makes it feel like all the storylines, arcs, character progressions, relationships, growth was all for nothing. I came off as really negative in this comment, but this finale is definitely good, and I understand its probably the way they wanted to tell their story, its just disappointing the characters we've followed for so long have such an unhappy ending.
If this isn't the last episode though, I take back literally everything I said, this would retrospectively become the best thing this show has ever made.
mepad fell to his death, soap was deleted with everyone else, nickle is presumably a creation of me life, bow and dough are already dead and apple was also deleted with everyone else, since hitel oj was destroyed and was made by oj who is a creation of melife it can also be assumed bot, also made by a creation of melife is also gone. baxter survived
Personally I hated the ending. Inanimate insanity has always been willing to get darker to extents that bfdi wouldn’t, so I understand why they didn’t want a cliché happy ending. But it kinda feels like there was no ending rather than it was just darker. I bet thrarm can relate to this to but I feel like the characters didn’t really get a satisfying ending, it left me feeling that I just wasted the past five years of my life obsessing over character arcs that didn’t matter in the finale. I feel like if they wanted a darker ending they should’ve killed Cobs,followed by Mephone feeling guilty about the contestants and letting them live in the “real world” without ever having to see him again.
@@losertheloser1383 if they did it was after i made this, and i still haven't seen any word of that, although i suspect it's likely, however for this review i treated it as if it's the final part
this epiosde was released as "the final part" i treated it as if it's the final part. i am aware there is most likely an act 3 but that's irrelevant for the purposes of this review
It’s not even likely there’s a part 3! Seriously on the shorts they said this was final people just auto think sad endings are bad and want an ending where bot appears out of nowhere and kills cobs.
@@p1xik yeah I know DONT HAVE TO TELL ME……..I was just tryna look for an ending that finally fulfilled me and wasn’t too happy now my expectations are decent just hoping it’s good cause seeing from all the other episodes it could be anything..
4:09 “wh🦅🦅🦅🦅t that’s the end?”
Fan saying “I’m coming test tube” was the sweetest thing I’ve seen in this show, ever.
Erm actually, it was "see you, test tube"🤓
@@Enven37it was cya test tube
@@Qwaziop that's just an abbreviation, also, look at the captions
@@Enven37 it was cya test tibe
@@Qwaziop why are you trying to correct me when that's literally what I said?
I just wanted to make a joke chill
Phenominal finally the sad ending just fits more with the shows atmosphere but also i just wish it had a happy ending 😞
2:55
Taylor Grodin was his voice actor. So yeeeeaaah…
not the finale
You are the 69th comment
THANK YOU SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTANDS!
I love the ending of II2 17 but I don’t like the ending of ONE 18
II2 17 thoughts
I thought this was a ONE 18-esque scenario but done a lot better imo. Even if all of MeLife is just gone like that, I felt that it fit a lot, especially with the twist at the end of episode 16. Season 1 and half of season 2 being lower quality makes sense and it’s more watchable knowing that everything shown is just MePhone 4’s creations. The true nature of II2 was hidden canonically because that is exactly what MePhone wanted, II was meant to be an escape from reality but Cobs saw that, then III was also meant to be an escape from reality so MePhone (iirc) basically had to stop time. Watching the earlier stuff and knowing this was just the beginning of MePhone4’s MeLife stuff makes it genuinely interesting to watch, and it being initially just a bunch of humour based stuff also fits. It’s like MePhone4 just wanted to have fun. But then again this is a lot of rambling. I thought the ending of this episode itself was done well. We had connections to these characters, but we also knew they were just creations of MePhone4, and their purpose was to compete. So there’s no way this episode could end in a “happily ever after” moment at all because this is true. This has always been true though. The characters have always been MePhone4’s OCs. We got the main questions of the show answered before the ending, which I like. This ending actually did make me feel empty and sad because everything just got wiped out. This ending wasn’t even disappointing, the intended feeling actually got to me, I loved this episode.
I can absolutely rewatch II and it would be so different it would be surreal, I love that. Can’t say the same about ONE 18 though
ONE 18 thoughts
I’ll just say it is written well and it does make sense, but this is clearly designed for a first watch. ONE was meant to get the viewer intrigued with the story but then it abruptly ended. After ONE 18 I honestly was disappointed and was no longer intrigued, and now I find that rewatching ONE would be pointless because well, you already know how it’ll end, it’s designed for a first watch. Nothing was really answered, which makes sense, but I still can’t be intrigued. Another factor is the lack of huge attachment towards characters like II has, tho tbf ONE ran for like 1-2 years. The whole episode just felt disappointing imo, not really an empty mysterious vibe to me, just disappointing. Another thing is that the ending is meant to be based on an object show getting cancelled but honestly? I don’t buy into that. It was way too sudden for me to think that it replicated it well. Maybe in a viewer’s perspective it did, but definitely not in a creator’s perspective. It felt like the “cancelling an object show” vibe didn’t exist until ONE 18. Cancellations though are very gradual for a creator, lots of thinking and even more stress, and also production hell. But canonically ONE was going just fine. I think this is well written but definitely not my cup of tea and I don’t get enough of a “cancelled object show” vibe for my liking.
I indeed yap a lot, how did you know
the way i giggled at how long your comment is tierd lmao, i do agree with a lot of your points but yet again i got my own opinions lol
@@splitsee2526 splitsee cameo…
also W
This was a very shocking ending
Your everywhere
THE TITLE IS SO REAL
Also the shot with MePhone was where hotel OJ was but we didn’t see what happened in the remains of purgatory mansion
well i assume because hotel OJ was made by OJ and OJ was a product of melife that it also vanished with the rest of the melife creations
@@ThrarmClips yeah makes sense, I think that’s why we didn’t see mepad though
the lightbulb scene almost got me too
It got me I was in tears. Same with Fan.
I loved the episode, but that ending really upset me. Like, in an annoyed way, not an emotional way.
3 seasons of buildup and personalities put in these characters, just to delete them. Not even really finishing the plots for some characters. I understand in some way that's the point, but it just kinda feels upsetting.
If it's genuinely the last episode (which I'm beginning to come to terms that it might be), it's just left a really bad stain in my mouth, and it will be hard to clean the stain off when rewatching the show again. It makes it feel like all the storylines, arcs, character progressions, relationships, growth was all for nothing.
I came off as really negative in this comment, but this finale is definitely good, and I understand its probably the way they wanted to tell their story, its just disappointing the characters we've followed for so long have such an unhappy ending.
If this isn't the last episode though, I take back literally everything I said, this would retrospectively become the best thing this show has ever made.
I'm kinda just using this comment to share my thoughts now
After rewatching the finale many times, I'm beginning to appreciate it more
I believe they said there was gonna be an act 3
Bot survived
Bow survived
Apple survived
Dough survived
Mepad survived
Baxter survived
Soap survived
Nickle survived
mepad fell to his death, soap was deleted with everyone else, nickle is presumably a creation of me life, bow and dough are already dead and apple was also deleted with everyone else, since hitel oj was destroyed and was made by oj who is a creation of melife it can also be assumed bot, also made by a creation of melife is also gone. baxter survived
soap's phone survived... soap's phone and baxter will defeat steve cobs /j
Nice to still have baxter at least
@@ThrarmClipsbut MePad was at ground level in the haunted house
@@ThrarmClipsmephone X was the one who fell to his death, not mepad
4:19 he was on the haunted house remember, a few miles away from hotel oj
This cant be the finale, there wasnt even a song!
inanimate insanity lore
Thank you for the review John Linnell
Who is John Linnell
@@Timmy-Tury look it up silly goober
Are we gonna lay animation? Epic, what does happen so who’s with me?
I made a meme on it that’s really accurate
Also, bot isn’t part of MeLife either, also nobody has mentioned them like, fan, test tube, why are you not worried about your child
hotel oj vanished, seemingly everything made by someone in the melife system also disappears
@@ThrarmClipspresumably MePhone generated Hotel OJ just like he did all the other scenery. Bot was straight up made by Test Tube and Fan.
Personally I hated the ending. Inanimate insanity has always been willing to get darker to extents that bfdi wouldn’t, so I understand why they didn’t want a cliché happy ending. But it kinda feels like there was no ending rather than it was just darker. I bet thrarm can relate to this to but I feel like the characters didn’t really get a satisfying ending, it left me feeling that I just wasted the past five years of my life obsessing over character arcs that didn’t matter in the finale. I feel like if they wanted a darker ending they should’ve killed Cobs,followed by Mephone feeling guilty about the contestants and letting them live in the “real world” without ever having to see him again.
Now I actually feel we might be getting an act 3 just to answer all of the unanswered questions surrounding act 2’s ending.
No, I have an idea we’d teach them a lesson we give them a Deadpool and wolverine bye-bye are fighting animation, Epic characters. yeah characters.
Toilets voice actor got fired (same as ojs old)
Is it bad that i laughed when paintbrush cried?
yes
No
I really hope this isn't the end of AnimationEpic
If you’re not gonna give us a happier, did we force them to Will use Deadpool than wolverine power
Didn’t they say there was gonna be an act 3?
@@losertheloser1383 if they did it was after i made this, and i still haven't seen any word of that, although i suspect it's likely, however for this review i treated it as if it's the final part
Why does everyone think this is the finale? They literally said theres 3 acts
this epiosde was released as "the final part" i treated it as if it's the final part. i am aware there is most likely an act 3 but that's irrelevant for the purposes of this review
It’s not even likely there’s a part 3! Seriously on the shorts they said this was final people just auto think sad endings are bad and want an ending where bot appears out of nowhere and kills cobs.
@@SafAnimates so about that
@@p1xik yeah I know DONT HAVE TO TELL ME……..I was just tryna look for an ending that finally fulfilled me and wasn’t too happy now my expectations are decent just hoping it’s good cause seeing from all the other episodes it could be anything..
If im being honest the episode was good but the ending felt rushed in the 5 minute's
if i never post in the discord again youll know why
no i wont
AnimationEpic why you do this to me..😔