This is my favorite Chopin piece, and probably my fav of all. I like your interpretation a lot. Much more than the "recital" versions that many have.. (you know, "I'm doing this because I have to and I spent numerous hours trying to get it perfect and so AAAH I'm going to be perfect now!!!) Ssssshhh! You do a good job feeling the song, and that's more important than anything. A big "like" for you! :)
Wow, this is great. The opening bars of this piece always give me chills up my spine! The emotion put in this performance was all in the right place. A few slips but those are easily looked over by the rubato. Nice job.
I've noticed that she mistakes seven times, one of them very well disguised i must say. But i don't censure her, since that she played with dedication and heart.
Antonvangrendel, the fact that you would call this a "song" and then pass musical judgement on her performance is shameful. You obviously don't know what you are talking about. It was stunning and anything but dry and feelingless. The dynamics were incredible (and unusual, I might add) and the piece was dripping with emotion and passion. Thank you so much, Elaine Lust, your performance was one of the best I've heard in a long time.
Superb playing and interpretation! Right up there with Pollini and Ashkenazy. Technical excellence is so evident, especially around 4:40. One of the most inventive solo pieces ever written in Western music. Chopin, Debussy, genius!
My only suggestion: slow down! Every note in this piece should be savored. This is such an emotional piece, and every phrase carries a feeling. The technical spots are scary, I know, but don't gloss them over. Milk them for all their worth! That's why Ch put them in in the firs place! Just feel it, and it will flow/. :)
oh wow you are just so amazing!!!!! really, bravo! excellent work! I could never get it that well! I'll practice for hours and hours and hours and I will still end up with so many screwups no matter what i play! but wow... wish i played like you!
I practice the same piece over and over again for about 2 hours a day, everyday day for a few weeks. Even after that, its still easy to forget notes and make mistakes. Nocturns however, are easy to play, esp. Chopin's....he's got certain formulas , u just gotta remember them :)
I enjoyed it more than Chaimovich's TH-cam performance - he sent me to sleep - Mme Lust is perhaps a shade too dramatic for an early Nocturne (at times it sounds like a Ballade) but absolutely magnetic playing. What colours! BUT where did she get the variant at bar 45? Are the extra octaves her own addition? They might not be Chopin but they fit pefectly into her conception. A performance to watch over again.
Is the Polish National Edition really that different from all the other editions out there? This nocturne sounds really different... I'm just really curious, because I play this nocturne. I don't have the new edition though, can't find it in stores around here. I have Alfred's and Paderewski ...
Wow ok. How does calling a piece of music a "song" have anything to do with "obviously don't know what you are talking about"? That doesn't make any sense at all. This said, I DISagree with antonvangrendel's comment. I loved this. However, everyone is entitled to their own opinion about interpretations of music. Perhaps sometimes it is wiser to not say anything at all nothing nice is to be said, but the user obviously allowed for comments, and thus negative feedback was always a possibility.
Indeed, HORRIBLE!!! Why for god's sake?? You also play wrong notes at 1:15. You play the rest of this piece very beautifully!! With a lot of emotion in it. But don't try making such variations... Go on with it! Michiel
Brava! The first youtube version of this piece that has the full emotional range and depth expressed. Very well done.
Chopin for me
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
I love watching your elegant hands! Magnificent Job!! I could listen to you anytime.
My personal interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Hearing her playing, I'd had what I call the Chopin's chill. And I didn't get that often. Thanks.
My chopin noturnes interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
She played my favorite Chopin Nocturne so beautifully! Thank you for posting!
Me too!
My Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
This is my favorite Chopin piece, and probably my fav of all. I like your interpretation a lot. Much more than the "recital" versions that many have.. (you know, "I'm doing this because I have to and I spent numerous hours trying to get it perfect and so AAAH I'm going to be perfect now!!!) Ssssshhh!
You do a good job feeling the song, and that's more important than anything. A big "like" for you! :)
My interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Wow, this is great.
The opening bars of this piece always give me chills up my spine!
The emotion put in this performance was all in the right place. A few slips but those are easily looked over by the rubato.
Nice job.
My personal interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
I've noticed that she mistakes seven times, one of them very well disguised i must say. But i don't censure her, since that she played with dedication and heart.
My interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
i absolutely love the first movement of nocturne op.9 :)
My interpretation of Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
OH miss Lust- What a beautiful song that touches my inner soul.Watching you play is the perfect touch that enters my heart. Bless You
My interpretation of Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
красивое исполнение красивой музыки. спасибо.
Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
A gripping perfomance...couldn't stop watching ;)
My Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
beautifull.
i love this song, and you play it splendidly.
My interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Well done! Congnratulations!
Antonvangrendel, the fact that you would call this a "song" and then pass musical judgement on her performance is shameful. You obviously don't know what you are talking about.
It was stunning and anything but dry and feelingless. The dynamics were incredible (and unusual, I might add) and the piece was dripping with emotion and passion.
Thank you so much, Elaine Lust, your performance was one of the best I've heard in a long time.
My personal interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
So beautiful!
My interpretation of Chopin Noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
one word, perfect!
Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Superb playing and interpretation! Right up there with Pollini and Ashkenazy. Technical excellence is so evident, especially around 4:40. One of the most inventive solo pieces ever written in Western music. Chopin, Debussy, genius!
My interpretation of Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
exquisite * flawlessly beautiful
this video should definably have more views
My interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
My only suggestion: slow down! Every note in this piece should be savored. This is such an emotional piece, and every phrase carries a feeling. The technical spots are scary, I know, but don't gloss them over. Milk them for all their worth! That's why Ch put them in in the firs place! Just feel it, and it will flow/. :)
My interpretation of Chopin Noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
oh wow you are just so amazing!!!!!
really, bravo! excellent work! I could never get it that well! I'll practice for hours and hours and hours and I will still end up with so many screwups no matter what i play! but wow... wish i played like you!
My Chopin noturnes.
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
This is great. Thank you for sharing :)
My Chopin interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
So fiery!
I practice the same piece over and over again for about 2 hours a day, everyday day for a few weeks. Even after that, its still easy to forget notes and make mistakes. Nocturns however, are easy to play, esp. Chopin's....he's got certain formulas , u just gotta remember them :)
My personal interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
now THIS is how this piece should be played. Unbelievable.
My Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
beautifull ... your very expressive.
My personal Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Thought the use of rubato was nicely done. This isn't an easy piece. But then again, Chopin didn't want easy. :)
Chopin noturnes my interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
well I like it, very emotional
My interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
bravo !! je félicite cette interprétation splendidie
j'essaie d' apprendre cette nocturne mais je cela n'est pas gagné d'avance !!!
My Chopin noturnes interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Eliane Lust, you are wonderful!
My interpretation of Chopin.
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
oh my god, thats...nice =)
Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
I enjoyed it more than Chaimovich's TH-cam performance - he sent me to sleep - Mme Lust is perhaps a shade too dramatic for an early Nocturne (at times it sounds like a Ballade) but absolutely magnetic playing. What colours! BUT where did she get the variant at bar 45? Are the extra octaves her own addition? They might not be Chopin but they fit pefectly into her conception. A performance to watch over again.
My Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
I agree
Is the Polish National Edition really that different from all the other editions out there? This nocturne sounds really different... I'm just really curious, because I play this nocturne. I don't have the new edition though, can't find it in stores around here. I have Alfred's and Paderewski ...
My personal interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
自由な、目が覚める演奏です
My interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
You probably have a different version of the score...there's so many of them! She plays all the right trills and acciaccaturas!
My Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
what audio devise did you capture this on? brightpath
It Is September, Summer will end then soon will be fall, and Winter arrive. Nocturne op.9 no1 Movement feel like snow falls.
My interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Very nice interpretation! Interesting improvisation at 3:15 (different to my notes).
shes my cousin
There is a mistake in 1:25 but it's not bad! I think you have to be more delicate!
My Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
cant explain what happened at 3:15-those arent the notes- at all. A little coaching on tempo and legato would be helpful, but well done.
My Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Looks so easy, as she is playing it
Im at the second page now and im having quite troubles
My Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
I like the way you play but I note that you add some in the end sound a little weird.
C'est beau... Mais vous jouez modifié ce nocturne, pourquoi ?
Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Guiomar Novaes, early 1950s:
watch?v=piipsVVZVe0
thanks and regards
My personal interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Once or twice. If not thrice and so on and so forth if you need more practice.
well Done! few mistakes. but well done!
My Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Wow ok. How does calling a piece of music a "song" have anything to do with "obviously don't know what you are talking about"? That doesn't make any sense at all.
This said, I DISagree with antonvangrendel's comment. I loved this. However, everyone is entitled to their own opinion about interpretations of music. Perhaps sometimes it is wiser to not say anything at all nothing nice is to be said, but the user obviously allowed for comments, and thus negative feedback was always a possibility.
My interpretation of Chopin
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
A wrong note here and there is not everything dude. Even Horowitz made mistakes once in awhile. Why point it out.
My personal interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
And you play wrong notes at 4:46 :)
excellent but the variation at 3:15 is horrible
My personal Chopin noturnes
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
Indeed, HORRIBLE!!! Why for god's sake?? You also play wrong notes at 1:15.
You play the rest of this piece very beautifully!! With a lot of emotion in it. But don't try making such variations...
Go on with it!
Michiel
My personal interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html
I don't like how you play this nocturne
My interpretation
th-cam.com/video/zhsdhpZUlHw/w-d-xo.html