Please consider subscribing th-cam.com/channels/gb-p291xQ_hUx7hQtOb72A.html and check out the rest of our 2021 golf club reviews here: th-cam.com/play/PLdGvztYGPaFW8IJ_YlcfVehW1p1uRrLwL.html
I played my first round with my new Sim2"s and couldn't have been happier with my purchase. I usually shoot around a 92-95 and got an 88 on the first round of the year. And I don't even know my yardages yet for these new clubs. All I can say is that they are very forgiving and long.
Bought Wilson D9's in December 2020.....got em early in Australia....absolutely love em.....i wen't from Ping Raptures...so Forged to Steel.....i give em an A+
I like this review. Rather than watching some 300 yards scratch handicapper hit balls all day long on here, while trying not to fall asleep, you just get to the stats. I dont know good you play so the only thing I would add is a mid and high handicappers stats too. Thanks!
I just got the sim 2 max in today. They were on sale, $100 off and I had a gift card. I’m pumped as my irons before these were blades and not very forgiving (im somewhat new and the guy at golfsmith, when it existed, said they would be a great club for me). Your reviews pushed me toward the maxes! Thank you!
This is the best irons review on the web and its not close! Thank you, keep up the good work! Interested to see what Taylormade does with their Stealth irons in feb, gimme a review as soon as you get your brilliant paws on them!
Just got my new Pung G425s and I haven't even got to play a round with them yet and after watching your video I'm ready to go right now to bad it 11:37 pm so guess I'll have to wait , thanks for the input keep up the great reviews.👍
Just went for a fitting at American golf. They tried me with the d9 and I hit the 7 iron 238yards! Unbelievable club, the control is some of the best I've tried.
I've been hitting my ping eye 2's since 1989😳 and been very happy with them. albeit I haven't hit anything else. I did find recently an old set of Taylor made TD's at a goodwill and I'm loving those as well😁. I'm a SS budget now, so golf club money isn't a priority😜. good review👍
Nice review. I knew after your aesthetics rating you weren't choosing the Ping G425. However, I disagree about the looks and also feel you over weighted that part of the scoring considering they all look a little thick on top and you aren't looking at the back during the most critical phase of any shot. Based on the more important, IMHO, areas for any game improvement iron, and the ratings from the other areas, I think the Ping G425 would've won as it did well in every category, other than looks. Again, its all subjective. I'll be trying out the Ping soon, and may try the Sim2. I've already hit the Callaway Apex, Taylormade P790, Mizuno 921's and the Srixon ZX5s. Of those, the Apex and P790 worked best for me with P790 being ever so slightly better, but I need to swing the G425s to compare. Thanks again for a great review!
Honestly, you may be right. I might've weighted looks too heavily. We all have our biases, and I could've been a bit too shallow here. Beyond looks though, bigger does mean harder to get out of the rough. So there is that, but your point is valid none the less. Its' a solid club and the best choice for many out there, no doubt. For me it was splitting hairs but that added distance / spin put the SIM 2 over the top. Just depends on your needs. I did a review of the p790s a few weeks back. I'll try to work in a comparison with the ones you've suggested, but in the meantime here's the standalone review: th-cam.com/video/sZb3dZeBfjM/w-d-xo.html
Hi I have watched many of your videos however as a playing 79 year old I have yet to see any tests with Senior shafts in woods and irons. May I ask for a couple to be done by you. Thanks.
Another great review with a golfer with a similar swing speed to me. It seems over 20000 people have watched this but the channel has less than 4000 subscribers? Come on people, its great content give the guy a hand and subscribe geez.
I will be looking to get some new irons over the winter and have the Mizuno JPX 921 Hot Metal irons at the top of my wish list. Since you did not review them until after this video, I am wondering where you would rank them on this list. I also have the Apex DCB and Sim2 Max on my list as well and possibly the Ping 425. Want to keep the fitting down to a reasonable amount of time. Good comparison - I like the criteria set but would have liked to see you add sound along with feel. It is hard sometimes to tell the sound watching videos. One thing I like about my Mizunos is the sound. Anyway, thanks for the videos and I wish you well with your upcoming ankle surgery and look forward to seeing you back as soon as possible. AE
Great review! I was wondering if the Callaway Apex DCB are rated the same as the regular Apex and so you decided to just have one of the Callaway Apex's in this review.
I’m a 15 to 20 handicap golfer and hit my 7-iron 115 120. Wish you would have someone on in that range to test. Would the sim 2 Max Irons and the drivers you like to still be applicable to me. I am playing with some old ram FX two graphite irons and old Taylor made burner driver now. FYI I don’t like chunky looking irons. My ram FX2 is pretty slim. Wonder if I would see any improvement? Or is it really a matter of improving my skills?
Hell yea man. I just got a set of the TaylorMade Sim 2 Max. They are 100x better than my previous iron set. I wanna say I’ve gotten better this year, but maybe it’s just the new irons. Who knows
I cannot fault anything in your analysis, but for me, my second start at golf, was a set of Ping Eyes Irons, gifted from my father. To this day I carry the 1 iron. Today I still carry and play Ping i3's but today I, as a registered Old man, at 68, am about to buy a set of Ping 410's.
I left a comment on another video of yours the 2021 best Driver video, and just wanted to drop you another positive comment here, great video, great job! Just fyi, I currently play Cobra Radspeed irons.
Just missing the Titleist 300s! Thank you for the review. Ordered Sim2 max irons today and thought now would be the perfect time to make sure i didnt pick wrong 🙂 oops
This is a really good review. Thanks for the nice review.. I know it hard to review all the new game imprvment irons.. But have you had a chance to hit the new generation of easy to hit irons.. Like the Wilson Launchpad, Cobra T-rails and Cleveland HB turbo irons? Be great to get your opinion of these..
Love the detailed review of all these amazing clubs. I thought you would have chose the Apex #1 overall, but looks like all these clubs are so tight in comparison that one doesn't really stand way above the others. This has to be the best iron review that I have seen! Keep it up Gabe!
Great information I currently play Cleveland launcher iron but looking for a bit more distance have you tried the titleist t300 So the 425 don’t look so different to me and forgiveness is important and also a bit more yardage Really enjoy your reviews happy Xmas and keep up the great work
So I have had 137 rds for chemotherapy starting playing golf at 33 years old when I got cancer almost 10 years ago. It also took me 10 years to test days after chemo to test what I would play 90% of the time vs the 3 to 5 days when I was at my physical prime so testing 3 to 5 after then 10 to 14 then 17 to 21 days after treatment and the ping g425 with a Graphic shaft and there power plus lofts were the best to find for me the Callaway Epic Speed was the best driver 3 wood off tee plus super hybrid has been the best off the deck and the cobra 7 wood best 5 iron in my bag hahahaha. Thanks so much to Peninsula golf in San Mateo California for working with me so closely and helping me out with everything I needed it such a long process. !!! And another questions feel free and ask. He even let me use reg and stiff shafts during the month until we can up with a plan reg flex driver and 3 wood the shift 75 gram 3 super hybrid and shift cobra speed 7 wood. Took my ego almost 10 years to even think about this way and my game is talking off breaking 85 weekly at the home course next goal break 82 then shoot 79!!!
I keep hearing from many reviews that the Ping G425’s, both driver and irons, are the most forgiving clubs of the new releases. I’m leaning towards getting Pings. Great review.
@@ufukgoksu9851 the fairway Woods sound like a hammer hitting a 2x4 board and the driver a little but not as bad. I’m already use to it and regardless whether that’s an issue, the results are well worth it. The irons I see or feel no difference from my old ones. They have improved my game tremendously. NO REGRETS
Stopping power with these irons isn’t really about spin numbers. It’s descent angle. The D9 and Callaway with their peak height will make up their stopping power that way.
@@bnzstheboy6520 probably best you stick to talking about your own thoughts on the review rather than worrying about what others think. I stand by point and if you read his response then you’d see he’s not offended.
Probably wouldn’t change it all that much to be honest. Shaft choice really just depends on your swing speed. If that’s the right shaft for you these will work great.
Nice review. Currently some #4 irons have 18 loft, such as Wilson D9, TM-SIM-2-MAX-OS, Callaway MAVRIK, and Callaway ROGUE-X-20. Hopefully you will do #4 irons comparison among those irons. It is good alternative for hybrid replacement.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The line down the center of the top of the Cobra RadSpeed would be a total distraction for me. I don’t think I could hit them. For me I can’t seem to hit a Taylor made iron well. I have tested them and for some reason, other than having a bad swing, I can’t hit them vs other irons. I will be testing irons in the near future and for me the longest, straightest will be the winner for me.
Indeed, that's why I always preface that category saying how subjective it is. Didn't give too much weight to it in the overall ranking for that reason too.
I have ordered a set of Sim2 irons myself. Looking for better turf interaction here in Florida and I like the way these go thru the turf. And the distance. Good review.
I haven’t gotten a new set of clubs in about 10 years. After watching your driver and iron review I am leaning towards the SIM2s. Also, you said in an earlier video you had a mixed bag. What’s is your opinion of a complete set from the same manufacturer? How do I select shat flex, length, weight etc?
Congrats on taking the sport back up! I personally don’t think you need to stick with one manufacture for the entire bag. You are right my back is a hodgepodge. I picked the right club that works for the job no matter what the brand is. If you are really serious it might be worth finding a fitter. But if you were just casually getting back into the game, my advice would be to simply visit your local golf shop and a competent sales associate should be able to get you a relatively decent setup.
Very close...I play the MP20 HMB. I might swap but I’d def have to play with them on course a few rounds to decide. One thing about my HMBs is although they aren’t exceptionally long, they are forgiving and hold greens really well and I can work them enough. So they tick off a few big boxes for me. Contenders would be the top 3 listed in this video.
You did not mention the ball you used in the test, and the best way to get more spin (should you need that) is to play a high spin ball. For example, take most accurate Callaway Apex, pair it with a high spin ball, and you then increase your green holding power.
Any of these irons is going to improve my 12 handicap game with my fathers(was a pro in late 60s to early 80s) old custom made blades. 1971 Palmer Originals😲
Should probably mention that the Ping was the Power Loft Spec if the 7 iron was 28.5*. The regular loft is 30*, wouldn't carry as far, but would spin more. (My G425 set is coming this week.) Great video.
This is a great review. Just put the G425s in my bag a month ago and I’m just starting to get a feel for them. Couldn’t be any more spot on with your descriptions.
Great review, will be a huge. Help with my search. One question, you referred to the Taylormade as the Sim2, was the club the Sim2 or the Sim2 Max? In the video it was the Max.
I wanted Cleveland launcher XL in stiff flex but PGA superstore only had Wilson D9 4-sw in stiff for 799.00. I like them. You’re basically short a 7 iron. You have either a weak lofted 6i or strong lofted 8i
Thx for this! I’m in the process of buying new clubs and new driver. Have been watching a ton of videos to get some good ideas, and I’m still confused. Lol We all want to bomb the ball but have the forgiveness. Seems like every manufacturer has that this yr. I’m a mid handicap! Far as drivers go, really impressed with Ping G425 and SIM 2 Max. Irons are a huge question mark. Going to hit some at the local simulator. Like SIM2 Max and Pings.
Thanks for coming to check it out. Hope it helps on the hunt. BTW, We’ve been doing a lot of driver reviews as well. We will be having a big driver wrap up video this Sunday.
Nice review. I haven't played in years and have a set of 704.cb's. Hit the Sim2's today and was very surprised. These are not the GI's from circa 2002-2004, which the rest of my equipment is from. The jacked up loft 7iron was going 170 on the fly and very tight dispersion. I hit the mizuno hot metal and those felt pretty good too. I'd like to hit the Sim 4iron, 19*. Always been a decent iron and wedge player, much better than driving anyway. I'll be playing pretty much all small, tight 9 hole courses around my house with my boy for the next few years.
Not to get personal but how do your MP20 HMB's compare to any of these clubs? I am a softtee and would go for graphite shafted. I also am not up to the work ability yet.
they def don't fly as far :), but they are more workable than most of these. I have specific reviews of each and generally tested side by side with my HMBs so if you dive into those you'll see the H2H.
@@LetsPlayThru OK, thanks, Gabe. Your reviews are most engaging and I believe that you are a much better golfer than you hold yourself out to be. I am most excited about Apex DCB and Radspeed for me, once my game becomes a bit more consistent. Something to look forward to!
Very, very good comparison and review. I'm going Ping. I've played Ping G series for quite a while and the looks don't bother me one bit. I actually don't like the looks of the Cobra, that carbon on the topline actually makes the topline look thicker to me.
Going to hit the sim 2 max and sim 2 max os irons Friday, still playing Ping eye 2's, ive been leaning towards the taylormades, after your reviews im leaning a little harder,,anxious to try them.
i am getting a new set for my B/day mid year so i am doing my home-work now, have you hit the srixon ,mizuno and Sub 70 irons. Sorry i haven't looked through your lists yet. After a 25yr hiatus golf clubs have come a looong way. i will need a good set as i am not getting younger and cannot see my self getting to single figures (low teens i hope) . Every bit helps.
Sounds like a great way to celebrate a birthday! Mizunos would def be a contender here too. Really only reason I didn’t include them is because I was sticking with the 2021 releases and those had come out in the fall.
Well, now I'm totally confused on what to buy. I've been hitting Ping Eye 2's for years but I want a new set of irons, I'm old (74) and a 15 handicap, and I'm losing distance with my irons. I'm just not sure what would be best for me. All these clubs sound good....
Good review. However , think of the buyers in the category of “Game Improvement”. Workability is a very suspect category. Workability has to be very low (well almost non existent) for these buyers - they want it go straight. I had mostly same experience, Ping 425 on open range is hard to hit a bad shot, but the didn’t feel better than a forged club. Sorry not my experience nor the golfers that day hitting Callaway, Sims and Pings. I would have put the Callaway DCB’s in this category not the regular Apex. Finally, I am impressed with Ping ‘s cheaper price for an exceptional iron and they include Arccos grips standard which is HUGE. Ping is an amazing value all the things considered. But without question Callaway’s felt the best and had the best dispersion on the open range. Just overpriced - ugh.
Very valid point in regards to workability. Although I do think for folks who are getting a bit older and need more distance but still want the feel of their old players irons this could be a selling point for them. That’s why I decided to include it. You are also right about the feel. None of these Clubs are going to be as good as my Mizuno forged irons 😀 - but I think they’ve all improved significantly over the last few years. The Apex dispersion is incredible. I was blown away.
My boss is a 62 year old scratch golfer that’s been playing 50 plus years and plays 100 rounds a year. He shapes shots all the time and plays Pings (g410s). He just likes the forgiveness they provide on less than perfect hits.
I just got my 425’s for my 1st fitted clubs and love them. I don’t think carry distance should be as much of a factor because all of these minus maybe the Williston’s your going to get fitted for and you always decrease your loft if you need the extra range. My ranges are similar to yours thou I don’t know why you would need more range when you should be hitting 220-230 with your 4 iron off the deck any longer and I go to 5 or 3 wood it’s not like your going to hit 200+ out of the rough with anything.
Great review!! I would like your opinion on my situation as I am considering one of these game improvement irons. I've been playing 5-6 y so far. Took about a year off just to get back to it at the beginning of this year. Before the break, I was hitting 85 consistently and then it went to 95 when I got back to it. Recently scores have been going down quickly to 82-85 (GHIN from 21 to 15) and I'm sure I can bring it down some more soon. I have been using Mizuno JPX 900 tour for the last 3years. Just now I notice that my clubs' lofts are very weak cuz it's tour version. I can't even hit 160y carry with 7 iron. Average 155y only. I should've gotten game improvement irons back then. I begin to struggle as I go down to 4 iron with which I hit 185y average only because there is like 25 y gap between 4 iron and 4 hybrid I hit. I have 3 driving iron (gapr mid) which I hit 230y. between 3-9 irons, hydrid, 3 wood, driver, puttter and 3 wedges, I already max out to 14 clubs and there are this huge gap between 4 hydrid and 4 iron and between pitching(46) and 52 wedge. I am pretty decent to shape the ball and don't want to lose the ability. I lose lots of strokes on putting and approach (huge gap between P and 52). I keep practicing 52 wedge in order to hit 100 y but I can hit it barely with full shot on the condition that there is no up slope and face wind. So I end up being short lots of times on the course so recently started hitting pitching wedge for 100y shot with grip down but it's not consistent as it's a 2/3 shot. Since these clubs go miles compared with mine, the gapping at 4iron would be very small or in fact, I probably wouldn't even need to carry 4 iron anymore. My 4 iron is 24 degree and Sim2 max and Cobra Radspeed's 6 irons have same loft lol. And I noticed that most of the clubs you reviewed also have 42-45 pitching wedge (similar to mine). would you change the clubs to one of these or would you just keep trying to work on your game? I am very confident that I can break 80 in a few months and I would really hate to have to change clubs again to players irons when the time comes. Thanks!
Well first off, congrats on getting those scores lower. Sounds like you're making some great improvements. These irons are squarely in the game improvement category. Sounds like you're past that a bit, or at least in the process of moving past it. I think my suggestion would be to find something in between. Something like a JPX Hot Metal or Taylor Made P790. These will provide the best of both worlds, a slightly stronger loft with a more forgiving face. Hope that helps.
Ping G425 last on looks? Those look great. Just bought a set of irons with the black graphite shaft and black/red Winn grips and they feel and look amazing. However, coming from Callaway clubs, I returned their driver, wood, and hybrid. I could not stand them. Went with Callaway Epic for those 3.
Take into consideration delivery timeframe, I ordered Ping in late June with a quoted delivery time of 6 weeks. I was updated and told expect delivery in November or December. I hit the Ping better than the Sim2 so I chose Ping and had played Taylor Made in my past.
Hey Gabe, just looking through the comments and saw that others had mentioned the Apex DCB and was wondering if you had a chance to check them out yet. I think they might be the most game improvement in the Apex line. I was looking at getting a set as a not 100% game improvement but not blades either. Something as my game improves I won't think that the clubs would be holding me back.
Great review. I recently tested all these irons with the exception of the Wilson D 9 and I went with the Mizuno 921 HM Pros with the UST Recoil ESX 460 shafts. I will agree with you that the Ping G 425s surprised me on how great they felt but were short on distance for me. They were my second choice. Like I said in a previous comment check out the new Tour Edge 721 irons and the new Srixon ZX 4’s.
@@LetsPlayThru I tried those just wasn’t consistent enough. I’ll be 58 in June and my swing speed has drastically decreased (due to an early release). I’m now in a R Flex graphite. I’m looking forward to getting my HM pros in a few weeks.
Have a question for you! Have a solid discount to get Sim2's for the cheapest of them all, but when I went to get fitted I hit the D9's better than all of the rest. I felt like it was heavier with a lower center of gravity and it was translating to a more consistent swing for me. HOWEVER, I am a bad and inconsistent golfer, and it is highly possible I just got into a little rhythm with the D9s, like fools gold... Would I be crazy to pay more money for a set of D9's than Sim2s because i hit them better for a bit at the range? Thanks!
Well I think my best advice would be to give it another shot if you can. That way you can confirm if it was just a fluke or if it was the real deal. But I will say the Wilson’s are very fairly priced. And if you are able to purchase at a place like Edwin Watts they offer a 90 day moneyback guarantee. Just in case you have any buyers remorse.
One thing I've found about the Sim2 is that it seems to be intended for slightly better, lower handicapped golfers who don't need the control of the others. RadSpeed great, as long as you have good loft, otherwise you won't get the longer distance they claim. Apex the best, Callaway has a knack when it comes to high handicappers, but also the most expensive by far. I went with the D9s for what Gabe calls all around value. Very close to any of the others except price wise.
Had the d9s after getting upgraded for free from the d7s (after having to send 2 sets back for the same fault!) what a shock, the d9s had the same fault! The power holes on the bottom after 6 rounds of golf popped inside the club head. Word of warning!
@@LetsPlayThru got my money back and changed to the g425s Contrary to the opinion I think the g425s look really nice. Love the bevelled top line to make the club head look narrower and the shorter blade length front to back than the d9s.
I just got fitted today and went with the JPX 921s. I can’t wait to get to the range and the course. Compared to my very old Cleveland irons, these should be a massive improvement.
Hi Keith. Curious to know what you went for the mizuno over the others. I’m going for a fitting in early May and i have Mizuno on the list. The reviews look excellent!
@@peterkelly9655 I got fitted today and had every intention of buying the Mizuno Hot Metal 921's.. After an hour and hitting Mizuno, Ping, Callaway, Titleist and Sim2 I ended up picking the SIM2. Came down to the MIzuno and Sim2. I just felt like I couldn't hit a bad shot with the SIM2. I think it may take a few rounds to get used to the distance.. They are very long.
@@timmiller4840 Thanks for the response Tim. appreciate that. I suppose that shows the importance of a fitting. you go in with preconceived notions but they can be altered so quickly. Like you I have the JPX921 range in my head (either the forged or the HM Pro) but I will be completely guided by the results and which feel best. we aren't sponsored so why stick with a set of clubs that aren't best for you! When you get back on the course with brand new clubs the main feeling you want is 100% confidence that the clubs you are hitting are the right ones for you! best of luck with the Sim2 - I will give them a hit as well to see! is there a big waiting time on the Sim?
Points assigned for each category, possible 30 points total. TM Sim2 - 24 points Ping G425 - 20 points Cobra RadSpeed - 18 points Callaway Apex - 17 points Wilson D9 - 11 points Pricing 5-PW + Gap (7 clubs) (Prices based on current pricing at Dick’s Sporting Goods 02/23/21) Wilson - $650 TM Sim2 - $800 Ping G425 - $875 Cobra RadSpeed - $903 Callaway Apex - $1295 Based on this review, TM Sim2 is by far the best value for the money. Paying $150 to move up from the worst rated on the list, to the best, you’d almost be silly not to.
Great round-up, Gabriel! Wow. Ping winning a "Best Feel" category! That's a definite change from years past.So many great iron choices these days. I play the Apex 19s and love the feel and distance. Amazing how the Apex 21s have so much carry despite being 2º or 3º weaker than the others. They've really dialed in that CG for high launch/low spin. I've never had any trouble stopping the Apex 19s, but I also play a little fade, so I'm spinning shots more anyway. I tried the previous TaylorMade Sim Max irons and was surprised how solid the feel was. Not that clicky at all. Nice solid "thud."
Just got my sim 2s in yesterday and wow blown away they looks fantastic even my wife forgave me for the price I payed for them haha she said they looked worth it lol Ima take them to the range tomorrow and the course Monday and put these bad boys to test I’m shooting 92 rn just might hit in the 80s now
Please consider subscribing th-cam.com/channels/gb-p291xQ_hUx7hQtOb72A.html and check out the rest of our 2021 golf club reviews here: th-cam.com/play/PLdGvztYGPaFW8IJ_YlcfVehW1p1uRrLwL.html
I'm going Ping. Feel, workability & forgiveness says it all.
I played my first round with my new Sim2"s and couldn't have been happier with my purchase. I usually shoot around a 92-95 and got an 88 on the first round of the year. And I don't even know my yardages yet for these new clubs. All I can say is that they are very forgiving and long.
what do you shoot now haha
Bought Wilson D9's in December 2020.....got em early in Australia....absolutely love em.....i wen't from Ping Raptures...so Forged to Steel.....i give em an A+
ordered mine today ... I've been swinging forged Lynx irons for 15 years and I'm looking forward to something more forgiving.
I like this review. Rather than watching some 300 yards scratch handicapper hit balls all day long on here, while trying not to fall asleep, you just get to the stats. I dont know good you play so the only thing I would add is a mid and high handicappers stats too. Thanks!
Seriously impressive and in depth review. The effort you’ve put in here is 10 times more than most of the big channels, hats off to you!
Many thanks 🙏 That one took a lot out of me, but I really enjoyed doing it. Hope it helps a few folks.
I just got the sim 2 max in today. They were on sale, $100 off and I had a gift card. I’m pumped as my irons before these were blades and not very forgiving (im somewhat new and the guy at golfsmith, when it existed, said they would be a great club for me). Your reviews pushed me toward the maxes! Thank you!
This is the best irons review on the web and its not close! Thank you, keep up the good work! Interested to see what Taylormade does with their Stealth irons in feb, gimme a review as soon as you get your brilliant paws on them!
Thank you. And yes, I’m def hoping to get hands on soon.
Great review, very well thought out with a good set of criteria! I would like to see your review of Mizunos and Ben Hogans in the future also.
Just got my new Pung G425s and I haven't even got to play a round with them yet and after watching your video I'm ready to go right now to bad it 11:37 pm so guess I'll have to wait , thanks for the input keep up the great reviews.👍
Sweet congrats!! 🎈
Just went for a fitting at American golf. They tried me with the d9 and I hit the 7 iron 238yards! Unbelievable club, the control is some of the best I've tried.
Great review and you aren’t a Brit! Seems to be a lot of them reviewing clubs on TH-cam nowadays. 😉
Thank you 🙏 Yes most of the best ones are.
Brit….is not a dirty word! ;)
Saw your video Sim2 vs Mizuno 921 and you chose Sim2. have you tested thew Stealth irons and how do you rank them compared to Sim2? Thanks
Can’t believe the mizunos or PXGs aren’t on your lists, how much was the roll out
These are insanely expensive
I've been hitting my ping eye 2's since 1989😳 and been very happy with them. albeit I haven't hit anything else. I did find recently an old set of Taylor made TD's at a goodwill and I'm loving those as well😁. I'm a SS budget now, so golf club money isn't a priority😜. good review👍
Ping eye 2 sand wedge is the best club I have ever used
Nice review. I knew after your aesthetics rating you weren't choosing the Ping G425. However, I disagree about the looks and also feel you over weighted that part of the scoring considering they all look a little thick on top and you aren't looking at the back during the most critical phase of any shot. Based on the more important, IMHO, areas for any game improvement iron, and the ratings from the other areas, I think the Ping G425 would've won as it did well in every category, other than looks. Again, its all subjective. I'll be trying out the Ping soon, and may try the Sim2. I've already hit the Callaway Apex, Taylormade P790, Mizuno 921's and the Srixon ZX5s. Of those, the Apex and P790 worked best for me with P790 being ever so slightly better, but I need to swing the G425s to compare. Thanks again for a great review!
Honestly, you may be right. I might've weighted looks too heavily. We all have our biases, and I could've been a bit too shallow here. Beyond looks though, bigger does mean harder to get out of the rough. So there is that, but your point is valid none the less. Its' a solid club and the best choice for many out there, no doubt. For me it was splitting hairs but that added distance / spin put the SIM 2 over the top. Just depends on your needs.
I did a review of the p790s a few weeks back. I'll try to work in a comparison with the ones you've suggested, but in the meantime here's the standalone review: th-cam.com/video/sZb3dZeBfjM/w-d-xo.html
Hi I have watched many of your videos however as a playing 79 year old I have yet to see any tests with Senior shafts in woods and irons. May I ask for a couple to be done by you. Thanks.
Here here! Plus there are two ladies flexes, L and LL for more choice.
Another great review with a golfer with a similar swing speed to me.
It seems over 20000 people have watched this but the channel has less than 4000 subscribers?
Come on people, its great content give the guy a hand and subscribe geez.
Many thanks Wayne 🙏
When you test these, do you have custom fitted lie and length or are you just hitting off the shelf irons?
I will be looking to get some new irons over the winter and have the Mizuno JPX 921 Hot Metal irons at the top of my wish list. Since you did not review them until after this video, I am wondering where you would rank them on this list. I also have the Apex DCB and Sim2 Max on my list as well and possibly the Ping 425. Want to keep the fitting down to a reasonable amount of time. Good comparison - I like the criteria set but would have liked to see you add sound along with feel. It is hard sometimes to tell the sound watching videos. One thing I like about my Mizunos is the sound. Anyway, thanks for the videos and I wish you well with your upcoming ankle surgery and look forward to seeing you back as soon as possible. AE
Great review! I was wondering if the Callaway Apex DCB are rated the same as the regular Apex and so you decided to just have one of the Callaway Apex's in this review.
I am waiting on my pre-loved condition of an Apex DCB set this afternoon after work.
I couldnt believe how well I hit the G425's. Instantly purchased as soon as the G430's came out and got them for a steal.
I’m a 15 to 20 handicap golfer and hit my 7-iron 115 120. Wish you would have someone on in that range to test. Would the sim 2 Max Irons and the drivers you like to still be applicable to me. I am playing with some old ram FX two graphite irons and old Taylor made burner driver now. FYI I don’t like chunky looking irons. My ram FX2 is pretty slim. Wonder if I would see any improvement? Or is it really a matter of improving my skills?
Hell yea man. I just got a set of the TaylorMade Sim 2 Max. They are 100x better than my previous iron set. I wanna say I’ve gotten better this year, but maybe it’s just the new irons. Who knows
sim2 Max or MAVRIK Irons
, for high handicappers? thanks
The feel of Pings is hard to match, but for price, the Wilson D9. The only one that I wouldn't go for is the Sim2. Everything else I will have to try.
Why wouldn't you go for the SIM2?
@@Hamchuck112 Too much dispersion for me, other clubs out there that are more suitable. It's a matter of preference.
@@midnight4109 I gotcha. I just got a set of SIMs for a great deal but haven’t hit them yet. I’m a new golfer.
I cannot fault anything in your analysis, but for me, my second start at golf, was a set of Ping Eyes Irons, gifted from my father. To this day I carry the 1 iron. Today I still carry and play Ping i3's but today I, as a registered Old man, at 68, am about to buy a set of Ping 410's.
I left a comment on another video of yours the 2021 best Driver video, and just wanted to drop you another positive comment here, great video, great job! Just fyi, I currently play Cobra Radspeed irons.
Just missing the Titleist 300s! Thank you for the review. Ordered Sim2 max irons today and thought now would be the perfect time to make sure i didnt pick wrong 🙂 oops
Solid choice. I think you’ll love them. Congrats
See I went to get fitted for the 425s and ended up falling in love with the sim 2 got those in my bag right now great video
Congrats William!
@@LetsPlayThru thank you for these videos I found you by accident and love them all!!!!
This is a really good review. Thanks for the nice review.. I know it hard to review all the new game imprvment irons.. But have you had a chance to hit the new generation of easy to hit irons.. Like the Wilson Launchpad, Cobra T-rails and Cleveland HB turbo irons? Be great to get your opinion of these..
Thanks so much. I’ll try to get some of those up. Keep checking back.
Love the detailed review of all these amazing clubs. I thought you would have chose the Apex #1 overall, but looks like all these clubs are so tight in comparison that one doesn't really stand way above the others. This has to be the best iron review that I have seen! Keep it up Gabe!
Thank you Mark! Man, the Apex sure are solid. Could’ve easily gone that way. Wade did last time he got fitted. Appreciate your support!!
Apex and Radspeed for players struggling with control issues like I am. Opinions vary with regard to the Sim 2 Max dispersion.
Great information I currently play Cleveland launcher iron but looking for a bit more distance have you tried the titleist t300
So the 425 don’t look so different to me and forgiveness is important and also a bit more yardage
Really enjoy your reviews happy Xmas and keep up the great work
So I have had 137 rds for chemotherapy starting playing golf at 33 years old when I got cancer almost 10 years ago. It also took me 10 years to test days after chemo to test what I would play 90% of the time vs the 3 to 5 days when I was at my physical prime so testing 3 to 5 after then 10 to 14 then 17 to 21 days after treatment and the ping g425 with a Graphic shaft and there power plus lofts were the best to find for me the Callaway Epic Speed was the best driver 3 wood off tee plus super hybrid has been the best off the deck and the cobra 7 wood best 5 iron in my bag hahahaha. Thanks so much to Peninsula golf in San Mateo California for working with me so closely and helping me out with everything I needed it such a long process. !!! And another questions feel free and ask. He even let me use reg and stiff shafts during the month until we can up with a plan reg flex driver and 3 wood the shift 75 gram 3 super hybrid and shift cobra speed 7 wood. Took my ego almost 10 years to even think about this way and my game is talking off breaking 85 weekly at the home course next goal break 82 then shoot 79!!!
I keep hearing from many reviews that the Ping G425’s, both driver and irons, are the most forgiving clubs of the new releases. I’m leaning towards getting Pings. Great review.
Very forgiving indeed, solid in all respects really - especially the irons
How is the feel, I mean the contact Feedback? Thanks.
@@ufukgoksu9851 the fairway Woods sound like a hammer hitting a 2x4 board and the driver a little but not as bad. I’m already use to it and regardless whether that’s an issue, the results are well worth it. The irons I see or feel no difference from my old ones. They have improved my game tremendously. NO REGRETS
I tried the ping g425 I wasn't impressed at all I've always played with blades I couldn't hit them.
@@donniebutler5918 How do you like Radspeed or Apex? They are both easy to hit and go straight. Probably better for me than Sim2 Max or G425.
Stopping power with these irons isn’t really about spin numbers.
It’s descent angle.
The D9 and Callaway with their peak height will make up their stopping power that way.
Great point. I tried to factor that into the equation as best I could.
Wrong, His review was spot on, stop trying to confuse people and move on to some other channel with your "I know better than you attitude".
@@bnzstheboy6520 probably best you stick to talking about your own thoughts on the review rather than worrying about what others think.
I stand by point and if you read his response then you’d see he’s not offended.
@@paulhawkins5800 I am
Great and excellent review. How about Clevenland Launcher HB Turbo ?
I’m going with the Ping 425. Thanks for the excellent feedback!
Awesome 🍾
Let me know how you like them
Great review! I’m leaning towards the SIM 2 but was wondering how the OS and/or graphite shafts would change your assessment? Thanks.
Probably wouldn’t change it all that much to be honest. Shaft choice really just depends on your swing speed. If that’s the right shaft for you these will work great.
I've had a go with the ping and absolutely love it that much I'm going for a fitting in July .
Excellent review! I have confidence in your judgement and playing experience. And, your presentation style simply works for me. Keep up the good work!
Appreciate the kind words and thanks so much for watching.
Nice review.
Currently some #4 irons have 18 loft, such as Wilson D9, TM-SIM-2-MAX-OS, Callaway MAVRIK, and Callaway ROGUE-X-20.
Hopefully you will do #4 irons comparison among those irons. It is good alternative for hybrid replacement.
If I can get my hands on some, I'd love to. Thanks.
@@LetsPlayThru Thank you.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The line down the center of the top of the Cobra RadSpeed would be a total distraction for me. I don’t think I could hit them. For me I can’t seem to hit a Taylor made iron well. I have tested them and for some reason, other than having a bad swing, I can’t hit them vs other irons. I will be testing irons in the near future and for me the longest, straightest will be the winner for me.
Indeed, that's why I always preface that category saying how subjective it is. Didn't give too much weight to it in the overall ranking for that reason too.
Just subscribed. Enjoy the reviews. I’d probably go DCB, 425 and SIM2 as my 1,2, 3. DCBs are pin seekers.
Thank you 🙏
Thank you for putting out such quality and in-depth videos. So much work goes into this, really appreciate all your effort.
Thanks so much for the kind words. 🙏
“I was able to work these balls right & left with ease”. Gotta love this guy.
Great review. Taylormade ticked all the boxes. Already purchased. Thanks.
Have you tried the Titleist T300 or T400 or maybe the Mizunos?
I have ordered a set of Sim2 irons myself. Looking for better turf interaction here in Florida and I like the way these go thru the turf. And the distance. Good review.
Nice, great choice. My current gamers
@@LetsPlayThru What shaft do you have in them?
I haven’t gotten a new set of clubs in about 10 years. After watching your driver and iron review I am leaning towards the SIM2s. Also, you said in an earlier video you had a mixed bag. What’s is your opinion of a complete set from the same manufacturer?
How do I select shat flex, length, weight etc?
Congrats on taking the sport back up! I personally don’t think you need to stick with one manufacture for the entire bag. You are right my back is a hodgepodge. I picked the right club that works for the job no matter what the brand is. If you are really serious it might be worth finding a fitter. But if you were just casually getting back into the game, my advice would be to simply visit your local golf shop and a competent sales associate should be able to get you a relatively decent setup.
Thank you!! I have been going back and forth between the Pings and TM. This has been really helpful.
Awesome happy to help
I think you play hotmetals pro? I play forged, but want more help. Would you swap your irons for any of these?
Very close...I play the MP20 HMB. I might swap but I’d def have to play with them on course a few rounds to decide. One thing about my HMBs is although they aren’t exceptionally long, they are forgiving and hold greens really well and I can work them enough. So they tick off a few big boxes for me. Contenders would be the top 3 listed in this video.
Thanks for ur test results. For me the Taylor made SIM II is the club with graphite shafts
Nice!
Thanks for making this video. I just bought the Cobra’s
You did not mention the ball you used in the test, and the best way to get more spin (should you need that) is to play a high spin ball. For example, take most accurate Callaway Apex, pair it with a high spin ball, and you then increase your green holding power.
Great point. I used an OnCore Vero X1 for all tests. Incredible ball btw.
You sure do a review on that ball
Any of these irons is going to improve my 12 handicap game with my fathers(was a pro in late 60s to early 80s) old custom made blades. 1971 Palmer Originals😲
Should probably mention that the Ping was the Power Loft Spec if the 7 iron was 28.5*. The regular loft is 30*, wouldn't carry as far, but would spin more.
(My G425 set is coming this week.)
Great video.
You are correct. Thanks.
Hey man how have these clubs been for you? I got a second hand set today and curious how you liked them?
Any chance of testing DTC clubs like the sub70 699s?
This is a great review. Just put the G425s in my bag a month ago and I’m just starting to get a feel for them. Couldn’t be any more spot on with your descriptions.
Nice pick up!
what flex did you have on the shaft?
Great reviews. Thinking about ordering sim2, do you think changing loft by 2° weaker could help give it more spin? Used to 7 iron being 35°
Thanks D B, Yes that would def give more spin but I'd highly recommend speaking to a fitter to make sure that's the right move for you.
Great review, will be a huge. Help with my search. One question, you referred to the Taylormade as the Sim2, was the club the Sim2 or the Sim2 Max? In the video it was the Max.
Awesome, happy to help. Yes these were the regular SIM 2 Max Irons - not the oversized version.
I wanted Cleveland launcher XL in stiff flex but PGA superstore only had Wilson D9 4-sw in stiff for 799.00. I like them. You’re basically short a 7 iron. You have either a weak lofted 6i or strong lofted 8i
Please explain what you meant In your last 2 lines,- is the 7i a worthless club here because if the loft?
Thx for this! I’m in the process of buying new clubs and new driver. Have been watching a ton of videos to get some good ideas, and I’m still confused. Lol
We all want to bomb the ball but have the forgiveness. Seems like every manufacturer has that this yr. I’m a mid handicap!
Far as drivers go, really impressed with Ping G425 and SIM 2 Max. Irons are a huge question mark. Going to hit some at the local simulator. Like SIM2 Max and Pings.
Thanks for coming to check it out. Hope it helps on the hunt. BTW, We’ve been doing a lot of driver reviews as well. We will be having a big driver wrap up video this Sunday.
Those are the best for a mid handicap. G425 likely more expensive where the SIM 2 Max a better overall value.
Great review,I just got the Sub70 699 game improvement ok but a bit hard of the face
Nice review. I haven't played in years and have a set of 704.cb's. Hit the Sim2's today and was very surprised. These are not the GI's from circa 2002-2004, which the rest of my equipment is from. The jacked up loft 7iron was going 170 on the fly and very tight dispersion. I hit the mizuno hot metal and those felt pretty good too. I'd like to hit the Sim 4iron, 19*. Always been a decent iron and wedge player, much better than driving anyway. I'll be playing pretty much all small, tight 9 hole courses around my house with my boy for the next few years.
Thanks. You’re 100% right, these game improvement clubs have come a very long way.
Not to get personal but how do your MP20 HMB's compare to any of these clubs? I am a softtee and would go for graphite shafted. I also am not up to the work ability yet.
they def don't fly as far :), but they are more workable than most of these. I have specific reviews of each and generally tested side by side with my HMBs so if you dive into those you'll see the H2H.
@@LetsPlayThru OK, thanks, Gabe. Your reviews are most engaging and I believe that you are a much better golfer than you hold yourself out to be. I am most excited about Apex DCB and Radspeed for me, once my game becomes a bit more consistent. Something to look forward to!
Very, very good comparison and review. I'm going Ping. I've played Ping G series for quite a while and the looks don't bother me one bit. I actually don't like the looks of the Cobra, that carbon on the topline actually makes the topline look thicker to me.
They are so solid. It’s a very good choice.
Going to hit the sim 2 max and sim 2 max os irons Friday, still playing Ping eye 2's, ive been leaning towards the taylormades, after your reviews im leaning a little harder,,anxious to try them.
You should also test Titleist T100-300 and Mizuno 221-225. They are supposed to be the best irons.
can you please do the wedge review? that would be the bomb
i am getting a new set for my B/day mid year so i am doing my home-work now, have you hit the srixon ,mizuno and Sub 70 irons. Sorry i haven't looked through your lists yet. After a 25yr hiatus golf clubs have come a looong way. i will need a good set as i am not getting younger and cannot see my self getting to single figures (low teens i hope) . Every bit helps.
Sounds like a great way to celebrate a birthday!
Mizunos would def be a contender here too. Really only reason I didn’t include them is because I was sticking with the 2021 releases and those had come out in the fall.
Very engaging,very thorough, very informative and very enjoyable video.
Thank you 🙏
Well, now I'm totally confused on what to buy. I've been hitting Ping Eye 2's for years but I want a new set of irons, I'm old (74) and a 15 handicap, and I'm losing distance with my irons. I'm just not sure what would be best for me. All these clubs sound good....
Well if you’ve got the comfort factor with PING I think it’s at least worth trying the new G425s. They are incredible.
Good review. However , think of the buyers in the category of “Game Improvement”. Workability is a very suspect category. Workability has to be very low (well almost non existent) for these buyers - they want it go straight. I had mostly same experience, Ping 425 on open range is hard to hit a bad shot, but the didn’t feel better than a forged club. Sorry not my experience nor the golfers that day hitting Callaway, Sims and Pings. I would have put the Callaway DCB’s in this category not the regular Apex. Finally, I am impressed with Ping ‘s cheaper price for an exceptional iron and they include Arccos grips standard which is HUGE. Ping is an amazing value all the things considered. But without question Callaway’s felt the best and had the best dispersion on the open range. Just overpriced - ugh.
Very valid point in regards to workability. Although I do think for folks who are getting a bit older and need more distance but still want the feel of their old players irons this could be a selling point for them. That’s why I decided to include it.
You are also right about the feel. None of these Clubs are going to be as good as my Mizuno forged irons 😀 - but I think they’ve all improved significantly over the last few years.
The Apex dispersion is incredible. I was blown away.
Oh and you are right about Value, that’s a category I will add in next time. Thank you for the thoughtful feedback.
My boss is a 62 year old scratch golfer that’s been playing 50 plus years and plays 100 rounds a year. He shapes shots all the time and plays Pings (g410s). He just likes the forgiveness they provide on less than perfect hits.
Great review. The Cobra Radspeed worked for me . Got the hight, distance and accuracy I needed
Nice!
My top pick for 2021 are the 1990 Ping Eye2's.
Sweet. Throw in some pleated pants and you’ve got a party 🎈
I just got my 425’s for my 1st fitted clubs and love them.
I don’t think carry distance should be as much of a factor because all of these minus maybe the Williston’s your going to get fitted for and you always decrease your loft if you need the extra range. My ranges are similar to yours thou I don’t know why you would need more range when you should be hitting 220-230 with your 4 iron off the deck any longer and I go to 5 or 3 wood it’s not like your going to hit 200+ out of the rough with anything.
Great review!! I would like your opinion on my situation as I am considering one of these game improvement irons. I've been playing 5-6 y so far. Took about a year off just to get back to it at the beginning of this year. Before the break, I was hitting 85 consistently and then it went to 95 when I got back to it. Recently scores have been going down quickly to 82-85 (GHIN from 21 to 15) and I'm sure I can bring it down some more soon. I have been using Mizuno JPX 900 tour for the last 3years. Just now I notice that my clubs' lofts are very weak cuz it's tour version. I can't even hit 160y carry with 7 iron. Average 155y only. I should've gotten game improvement irons back then. I begin to struggle as I go down to 4 iron with which I hit 185y average only because there is like 25 y gap between 4 iron and 4 hybrid I hit. I have 3 driving iron (gapr mid) which I hit 230y. between 3-9 irons, hydrid, 3 wood, driver, puttter and 3 wedges, I already max out to 14 clubs and there are this huge gap between 4 hydrid and 4 iron and between pitching(46) and 52 wedge.
I am pretty decent to shape the ball and don't want to lose the ability. I lose lots of strokes on putting and approach (huge gap between P and 52). I keep practicing 52 wedge in order to hit 100 y but I can hit it barely with full shot on the condition that there is no up slope and face wind. So I end up being short lots of times on the course so recently started hitting pitching wedge for 100y shot with grip down but it's not consistent as it's a 2/3 shot.
Since these clubs go miles compared with mine, the gapping at 4iron would be very small or in fact, I probably wouldn't even need to carry 4 iron anymore. My 4 iron is 24 degree and Sim2 max and Cobra Radspeed's 6 irons have same loft lol. And I noticed that most of the clubs you reviewed also have 42-45 pitching wedge (similar to mine). would you change the clubs to one of these or would you just keep trying to work on your game? I am very confident that I can break 80 in a few months and I would really hate to have to change clubs again to players irons when the time comes.
Thanks!
Well first off, congrats on getting those scores lower. Sounds like you're making some great improvements. These irons are squarely in the game improvement category. Sounds like you're past that a bit, or at least in the process of moving past it. I think my suggestion would be to find something in between. Something like a JPX Hot Metal or Taylor Made P790. These will provide the best of both worlds, a slightly stronger loft with a more forgiving face. Hope that helps.
@@LetsPlayThru Thanks a million!
Ping G425 last on looks? Those look great. Just bought a set of irons with the black graphite shaft and black/red Winn grips and they feel and look amazing. However, coming from Callaway clubs, I returned their driver, wood, and hybrid. I could not stand them. Went with Callaway Epic for those 3.
I have the Cobra Radspeeds. I have to say, they’re awesome clubs.
I have a set of Mizuno clubs and Taylormade clubs. I love them both.
Take into consideration delivery timeframe, I ordered Ping in late June with a quoted delivery time of 6 weeks. I was updated and told expect delivery in November or December. I hit the Ping better than the Sim2 so I chose Ping and had played Taylor Made in my past.
You’re right, delivery times are crazy right now
Excellent review.
Hey Gabe, just looking through the comments and saw that others had mentioned the Apex DCB and was wondering if you had a chance to check them out yet. I think they might be the most game improvement in the Apex line. I was looking at getting a set as a not 100% game improvement but not blades either. Something as my game improves I won't think that the clubs would be holding me back.
Hi Joel, Yes I will try to do a comparison on the entire APEX line.
@@LetsPlayThru Awesome! Thanks!
Great review. I recently tested all these irons with the exception of the Wilson D 9 and I went with the Mizuno 921 HM Pros with the UST Recoil ESX 460 shafts. I will agree with you that the Ping G 425s surprised me on how great they felt but were short on distance for me. They were my second choice. Like I said in a previous comment check out the new Tour Edge 721 irons and the new Srixon ZX 4’s.
Yes Mizunos are so nice too. I currently game the HMBs
@@LetsPlayThru I tried those just wasn’t consistent enough. I’ll be 58 in June and my swing speed has drastically decreased (due to an early release). I’m now in a R Flex graphite. I’m looking forward to getting my HM pros in a few weeks.
Congrats!🍾 those are solid
I would be curious to see how the new Tour Edge clubs compare. My only fear is that they are too low handicap for me.
Have a question for you! Have a solid discount to get Sim2's for the cheapest of them all, but when I went to get fitted I hit the D9's better than all of the rest. I felt like it was heavier with a lower center of gravity and it was translating to a more consistent swing for me. HOWEVER, I am a bad and inconsistent golfer, and it is highly possible I just got into a little rhythm with the D9s, like fools gold... Would I be crazy to pay more money for a set of D9's than Sim2s because i hit them better for a bit at the range? Thanks!
Well I think my best advice would be to give it another shot if you can. That way you can confirm if it was just a fluke or if it was the real deal. But I will say the Wilson’s are very fairly priced. And if you are able to purchase at a place like Edwin Watts they offer a 90 day moneyback guarantee. Just in case you have any buyers remorse.
One thing I've found about the Sim2 is that it seems to be intended for slightly better, lower handicapped golfers who don't need the control of the others. RadSpeed great, as long as you have good loft, otherwise you won't get the longer distance they claim. Apex the best, Callaway has a knack when it comes to high handicappers, but also the most expensive by far. I went with the D9s for what Gabe calls all around value. Very close to any of the others except price wise.
One of the best golf channels
Many thanks Brian
Had the d9s after getting upgraded for free from the d7s (after having to send 2 sets back for the same fault!) what a shock, the d9s had the same fault! The power holes on the bottom after 6 rounds of golf popped inside the club head. Word of warning!
Oh wow, sorry that happened
@@LetsPlayThru got my money back and changed to the g425s
Contrary to the opinion I think the g425s look really nice. Love the bevelled top line to make the club head look narrower and the shorter blade length front to back than the d9s.
Awesome happy to hear you got something you love
Got the Sim2's and I love them. Nice review
Just ordered my sim 2 on your recommendation in uk stay safe LPT 👍
How would the Titleist T300 rank compared to these?
The Titleist T300 2021 is one of the front runners. Awesome feel, distance and control.
Just bought the D9 irons,love the feel& distance &got the height that I was missing 😀
Good choice! Actually have an on-course review of those coming out tomorrow on the channel.
That's why I chose the D9 over RadSpeed.
You have to put the JPX Hotmetal into this mix, they are the best seller's in this category. There's a good reason for that.
They are absolutely excellent clubs. I’m a Mizuno fanboy myself. But I was sticking with the 2021 releases for this video.
I just got fitted today and went with the JPX 921s. I can’t wait to get to the range and the course. Compared to my very old Cleveland irons, these should be a massive improvement.
Hi Keith. Curious to know what you went for the mizuno over the others. I’m going for a fitting in early May and i have Mizuno on the list. The reviews look excellent!
@@peterkelly9655 I got fitted today and had every intention of buying the Mizuno Hot Metal 921's.. After an hour and hitting Mizuno, Ping, Callaway, Titleist and Sim2 I ended up picking the SIM2. Came down to the MIzuno and Sim2. I just felt like I couldn't hit a bad shot with the SIM2. I think it may take a few rounds to get used to the distance.. They are very long.
@@timmiller4840 Thanks for the response Tim. appreciate that. I suppose that shows the importance of a fitting. you go in with preconceived notions but they can be altered so quickly. Like you I have the JPX921 range in my head (either the forged or the HM Pro) but I will be completely guided by the results and which feel best. we aren't sponsored so why stick with a set of clubs that aren't best for you! When you get back on the course with brand new clubs the main feeling you want is 100% confidence that the clubs you are hitting are the right ones for you! best of luck with the Sim2 - I will give them a hit as well to see! is there a big waiting time on the Sim?
I have the Ping G425, I noticed you had the loft as 28.5 for the 7 iron.
The loft is actually 30.5. Great review though.
Power loft is what you should have got. You got the regular loft - take them back
PING has 3 loft configurations. As BNZS mentioned above, I used the Power Spec lofts to get as close to an apples to apples comparison as possible.
How do you know which ones you got?!
You get a thumbs up for time stamping
Points assigned for each category, possible 30 points total.
TM Sim2 - 24 points
Ping G425 - 20 points
Cobra RadSpeed - 18 points
Callaway Apex - 17 points
Wilson D9 - 11 points
Pricing 5-PW + Gap (7 clubs) (Prices based on current pricing at Dick’s Sporting Goods 02/23/21)
Wilson - $650
TM Sim2 - $800
Ping G425 - $875
Cobra RadSpeed - $903
Callaway Apex - $1295
Based on this review, TM Sim2 is by far the best value for the money. Paying $150 to move up from the worst rated on the list, to the best, you’d almost be silly not to.
Very cool that you took the time do that. That’s awesome!
Yeah but it depends on the player and what is most important. For example, price, workability, etc.
Great round-up, Gabriel!
Wow. Ping winning a "Best Feel" category! That's a definite change from years past.So many great iron choices these days.
I play the Apex 19s and love the feel and distance. Amazing how the Apex 21s have so much carry despite being 2º or 3º weaker than the others. They've really dialed in that CG for high launch/low spin. I've never had any trouble stopping the Apex 19s, but I also play a little fade, so I'm spinning shots more anyway.
I tried the previous TaylorMade Sim Max irons and was surprised how solid the feel was. Not that clicky at all. Nice solid "thud."
Just got my sim 2s in yesterday and wow blown away they looks fantastic even my wife forgave me for the price I payed for them haha she said they looked worth it lol
Ima take them to the range tomorrow and the course Monday and put these bad boys to test I’m shooting 92 rn just might hit in the 80s now