Thank you, Russian John & Yoko, I've had 20 hours of Max so far. I understood only 30 % of this, but I understand you. Eta katastrofa, pravda. Much love from Mainz in Germany
Thanks for the video. I have been looking foward to hearing your position about the current situation as I have been following you and respecting you for a good while. I am so glad I was not disappointed at all hearing your objective opinions, opinions of people with common sense and humane attitude. Hope we will see the world where peace prevails some day
Your channel is wonderful Max. I think at times of conflict and war the best form of protest is coming together through language learning and refusing to hate. May love flood us all
Макс и Юлия! Трудно мне выразить словами как Вас обоих уважаю и даже обожаю! Будьте добры и берегитесь! Вы должны быть посолами России. Я люблю и Украинский народ и Русский народ.
Я живу в США и уже год смотрю ваши видео. Я изучалa русский язык много, много лет назад и почти все забылa. Просмотр ваших видео помог мне вспомнить то, что я забылa! Ваши уроки интересны и очень полезны. Я надеюсь, что вы оба здоровы и что этот ужас скоро закончится.
Дорогие друзя--спасибо вам за то, что вы так откровенно и смело поделились своими взглядами с нами. Я американка, и я давно надеялась на развитие мирных, нормальных отношений между нашими странами--сердце сейчас болит от огорчения. Я глубоко сожалею о всех страданиях, которые война принесёт украинцам, россиянам, и всему миру. Вы очень терпеливо ответили сегодня на комментарии людей, которые плохо понимают сложности вашего настоящего положения. Может быть стоит вспомнить слова Пушкина в этот момент--"Не оспоривай глупца." Пожалуйста, берегите себя. Я буду держать вас в своих мыслях.
Макс и Джулия, я впечатлен вашей честностью. Всегда смотрю "уроки" Макса, который для меня, голландца, очень четко и понятно говорит по-русски. На самом деле, он всегда веселый и позитивный, поэтому мне было любопытно, как - и если - он расскажет о войне, которую развязал Щебень в Украине. Мои искренние комплименты. Я понимаю, что это требует мужества. И у тебя есть!
Thank you for this film. I found your channel and I immediately loved it, but I could not subscribe without knowing what kind of people you are and what you think about the war. Now I know I can and I know I'm going to enjoy learning Russian with you so much! Greetings from Poland
Oh you two, Max and Julia! I love you. I love your youtube channel, all the subjects, the road trips and my heart is with you. You are in a very delicate situation and I think you are very courageous to open your heart . I have so many friends in Ukraine without houses anymore, or hiding in basement or fighting with what they can find. My heart is with them, not knowing if I will see them again. My heart is also with my friend in Russia who thinks I will hate them. Who are not able to do anything. My heart goes to the older russian, misleaded by tv. To the young soldiers thinking they were doing an exercice, who have been lied to. Thank you for this video. You are great, interesting, courageous, dedicated, open minded, good teacher and very funny. Take care and long live to russian with Max. ~danielle from Montreal
Max and Julia, in the hope you receive this message, I wish you and your families safe and well in these difficult times. Thank you for your wonderful lessons. I'm sure all your followers are thinking of you, looking forward to when we can hear from you again. With great sadness I say 'until we meet again'. Much love.
Макс и Юля.Спасибо большое.Пожалуйста, продолжайте в том же духе. Я изучаю русский язык со времен холодной войны. Мы, простые люди, не хотим ненависти и войны.
Я постараюсь выразиться дипломатично. Мы живем в мире, где борьба за ресурсы - это постоянная борьба за власть. Основные игроки выше системы. Если они хотят войны, отвечающей их интересам, война будет. И получать прибыль от оружия, наркотиков и информационного контроля. Однако простые люди, те, кто принял на себя основную тяжесть агрессии, должны объединиться. Забудьте о флагах и обойдите стороной пропаганду. Вы отличный учитель, я ценю ваши усилия по продвижению изучения языка, чтобы однажды хорошие люди мира могли объединиться и вместе стремиться к лучшему, независимо от национальности, и вам всегда будут рады в моем доме. твоя семья и друзья мой дом твой дом. МИР.
I don't blame Russians for the actions of the leadership. No reasonable person can do that. Dear Max and Julia, I respect you ! I also love to hear you speak Russian. I hope to be able to do so one day and you are helping me to do so. Thank you from Berlin. Let me know when you come.
I was shocked when Max was reading the comment which says that all Russian people should go protesting in the street. There is nothing wrong when ordinary people want to avoid arrest, suppression, or persecution. Those who have the bravery to take the risk and protest should be applauded. But those who are afraid of saying anything also deserve sympathy and understanding. Ordinary people are innocent, yet are always harmed.
Спасибо из Украины за ваше здравомыслие и за вашу позицию! Теперь могу спокойно рекомендовать ваш канал своим иностранным друзьям, изучающим русский :)
Max and Julia, the American media all around is making sure to tell everyone that many Russians are against this war, and that Putin is the one responsible. Americans actually have a lot of affection for Russian people ❤️ Thank you for this wonderful video.
Really good to hear that, Liza! Sadly, here in the UK, the media is very hostile to Russia and Russians in general at the moment. But speaking to ordinary people, lots of them have expressed the sentiment that the Russian people should not be blamed for the current conflict. Such a horrific situation for Ukrainians, for Russians, for everyone in the world :(((((
@@themultilingualfamilyhub The problem is that someone is to blame for all the deaths and destruction in Ukraine. Besides the fact that the decision was made by one man, hundreds of thousands of Russians collaborate in this work of destruction. And all my Russian friends, because they are in their forties, ALL of them, voted for Putin. Max with Julia and thousands of other Russians are carrying the consequences of actions they had no influence on, and that's wrong. But the indifference to the evil that politicians cause - is also bad. This indifference and taking care of "just my family, because I have no influence on anything else" - is a typical Russian quote I've heard hundreds of times. The indifference leads to violence. The Russians, unfortunately, like the Americans, have a greater responsibility in electing their president. They elect this president for all of us, in some way. They can decide the war for all of us... The second thing is, that it's too late for anything at this point. All the evil has already happened, mothers will not recover their murdered children, Ukrainian women have already been raped, cities have been turned to ruins. But... where did it begin? For example, from my language partner who lives in the outskirts of Moscow - he was my partner before I found out - who works with his wife as translators at an arms factory. Ah, because "I have to live", right? And "I have three children, you know? Look how cute they are. It is so difficult to find a job for translators near Moscow". Right. All the time we are making decisions. Some of them leave blood on our hands. Who is to blame here? Certainly, the Russian murderers and rapists now operating in Ukraine and calling themselves "the military." But also those who live comfortably in Russia and did not react to the Russian aggression against Georgia, the occupation of Crimea, and the "hybrid war" in Donbas. They did not care that the Russians were bombing civilians in Syria - after all, the Russians had been invited by Assad, right? They were there "legally". I also heard this quote in Russia. I visited Russia three or four times. One of them in order to explain what is happening in Syria to my Russian friends. Who is to blame for this Russian war on Ukraine? I think the translators and secretaries who work in gun factories, as well. And the trolls on the internet as well. They all contribute to the murder and destruction, ultimately. They are in Putin's team. I have Russian and Ukrainian friends, I've been working in Donbas, as a humanitarian worker, doing our projects, for the last few years. Donbas is the area that has been occupied by Russians and pro-Russia Ukrainians separatists. I could see the destruction and instability. I heard the everyday shelling, I saw the lack of services, the poverty caused by the "hybrid war". As I was working in a Russian-speaking area of Ukraine, I decided to polish my Russian. Among other thanks to Navalny and to his channel, thanks to Zelenski and his comic group Kvartal 95, and thanks to Russian and Ukrainian vloggers, such as Max and Julia. I appreciate all the work they've done. I wish them luck. In a better place. The place we will build for ourselves and for our children. Taking responsibility. Saying NO to the war. There are no "fair wars". And every war starts many, many years before. Because of our little selfish approvals and betrayals.
Привет из Испании, я вчера посмотрела ваше видео, большое вам спасибо за то, что высказали нам свое мнение об этой войне. На мой взгляд, ужасной ошибке, в любом случае, я надеюсь, что скоро все разрешится наилучшим образом, и мы все сможем продолжать наслаждаться вашими замечательными видео и изучать замечательный русский язык. пока пока
Макс и Джулия, я не смогла принять участие в прямом эфире в день, когда его показывали, но я только что посмотрела его и хочу поздравить вас с тем, что вы поделились своими мыслями и откровенно говорили в это трудное время. Я лично не намерен прекращать изучение русского языка. Моя учительница в Бразилии родом из Одессы, и у нее там до сих пор есть семья, и мы намерены продолжить наши занятия. Я всегда был русским с тех пор, как начал изучать язык в средней школе в Северной Ирландии почти 50 лет назад. Мне все равно, кто там у власти. Моя любовь к русскому народу и, в первую очередь, к русской культуре и музыке никогда не умрет. Продолжайте хорошую работу.
Я высоко оцениваю прозорливость и откровенность, которые Вы демонстрировали в течение последних нескольких дней. Спасибо вам большое, вы очень умные, храбрые, честные. А теперь я боюсь для вас. Что вы будете делать если вы не можете продолжать свою работу? Где и как вы будете жить?
Love you guys and am praying all is well with you and your families. I just rewatched the proposal video - needed that sort of cheering up. I have Estonian/Russian roots and this just feels like the most surreal nightmare - like the world just unexpectedly and completely changed in the blink of an eye. My heart breaks for both the Ukrainians and the Russians. May something end this soon. Very, very soon.
Good luck and thank you!! Watching your videos has really helped me learn Russian while I was living in Uzbekistan. This is a sad and difficult time for Russia and its people...while censorship and propaganda happens in every country, it's particularly startling right now and demonstrates how dangerous it can be when so many lives are at risk. Thanks and godspeed.
Давно смотрю ваши видео и они мне всегда нравились. Вы замечательные учители русского языка и очень приятные люди. Но этим видео вы доказали, что это еще не все. Огромный респект за ваши ясные мысли, за вашу честность, за вашу храбрость. Огромный респект всем россиянам, осмеливающимся выступить против войны.
Hi Max and Julia! I’d like to know how you’re coping with the situation.Are you back in Moscow? Will you continue your videos? If so, in which way? I appreciate both of you a lot and hope you’ll be able to go on, and make your living.I’ve decided to go on learning Russian because it’s such a big culture though politics has always be awful through history. Happy too to have visited Moscow in December before the war. Please give us news! Thanks for everything.
Also ... apart from all suffering because of war in Ukraine... I feel sorry for all Russians not supporting war who currently are outside Russia. Hope people will be smart and not blame them for what is happening.
This was a courageous video to make, Max and Julia. It gives me hope. I imagine the current situation will not be good for your business - if you ever need help from the other side of the new iron curtain, let me know.
Спасибо большое за вашу работу!! Я нашла ваш канал четыре года назад, когда я начала изучать русский язык в Испании. Сейчас я могла понять ваши аргументы и я благодарю вас. Я ненавижу войны, я не понимаю как это происходит. Я буду продолжать с русским языком, а я надеюсь что война закончится и Украина станет свободной снова!! Спасибо друзья!!!
i will not take sides on this issue of war in the ukraine! Opinions are never based on facts!! And, i do not have the facts! My humble opinion is this; Conflict between nations is terrifiying for both sides!! Women and children are usually the most vulnerable victims in any war! I hope in 2023 this conflict will end for the good of the world! Thanks Max, and Julia for speaking on this subject!! Great russian language lesson always!!
Я студент русского языка. Я часто посмотрю на видеоролик у вас Спасибо большое за это объяснение, это помогает. я согласен, я тоже ненавижу войну. это ужасная ситуация.
Thanks for all your wonderful videos, Max and Julia. Before this video your work encouraged me to persist with learning Russian; after watching this, I say a massive 'thank you' for your brave and honest answers. You two are wonderful, true ambassadors for your fellow citizens; I'm sure you've made many friends both in Russia and around the world. Good luck for your futures, whatever may befall!
Big respect to you both and to all Russians who oppose the bloody war,be careful please and thank you for sharing your knowledge and opinions, greetings from Belgium ✌️ and stay open-minded and very strong,we are not against the people of Russia but against the war where there is a lot of blame, sincerely continue your right to be heard!!!!
Thank you so much for sharing this and for speaking out. Your courage is so inspiring and will help make this world a better place. I hope you are both doing well. ❤️
But you can’t solve the conflict without war because the countries backing Ukraine want war, they don’t want Ukraine to make peace or negotiate with Russia, Russia can’t just abandon Luhansk and Donbas. Sure their propaganda increased the desire for those regions to want to rejoin Russia, but they were also under consistent attack by nazi militants that everyone used to talk about but suddenly stopped. In The Minsk agreement (the first one) Ukraine agreed to them being independent but didn’t honour the agreement.
Are you guys ok after your video. I study Russian everyday. You are one of my favorites. I am happy that Max and Julia found each other. It is sad the elite treat us as cattle. I understand many words in Russian, but like a baby I can't speak much YET!
Thank you very much for speaking your thoughts. And you include many aspects. Well done, (so far, I just listened to the first 15 minutes, rest follows later. I understand 60%, Anis).
1. Max and Yulia - two gentle souls! Here, too, it can be seen that the interests of young Russians align with those of young people worldwide. It's just some bald dwarfs who haven't noticed the world has moved on. 2. If Kiev is considered the “mother of Russian cities”, is the attack by the Russian army like beating up your own mother? Thank you for sharing your opinion Max and Yulia!!
Hello Max and Yulia. First congratulations on your recent marriage. And bravo for your courage. Some day if I have time I will write down your dialogue, in order to understand all of it.
надеюсь что ваш стриминг останется на Ютубе :/ я рад что я ещё мог прислушиваться к вашу мнению. Ситуация в Украине мне очень тяжелая, и поэтому хорошо узнать что и в России люди так чувствует себя. Хотя я никогда ее верил что было бы по-другому. Кто вообще-то хочет войну? Никто кто нормальный, обычный, хороший человек. Как и вы. И я уверен что и большинство людей в России так. Я надеюсь что вам не будет слишком трудно из-за санкций и желаю вам всего хорошего. Нет войны!
Dear Max and Yulia, I appreciate your courage and I understand your indignation - no people, wherever they come from, can ever approve of war, which is always a destruction of the innocent and a way for certain elites to make profit (by selling arms etc. …). I’d just like to say that most of the independent, alternative media in Europe point out that the military provocations of the USA and most importantly, their commercial interests (they wanted to sell shale gas to Europe, and Russia was their no.1 concurrent - well now they’ve managed to do it, which is, by the way, an ecological disaster…), their manipulation of the Ukrainian elites (which, by the way, did nothing to respect the Minsk agreement, and apparently really are led by Nazis - yes, literally Nazis, cheering Hitler and so on -, financed by Washington), and their disrespect of the international law (they are in war in the Middle East, in Africa etc., since more than 20 years, then there is also that story of NATOs intervention in Yugoslavia - I mean, they’ve never respected the international law and they’ve never been sanctioned for it, so now Russia does the same - which isn’t cool, of course, but the sanctions show the double standards of the Europeans who are nothing but America’s avant-garde), are the cause of this crises. I’m horrified by the hypocrisy of the West and its medias, who dare to judge this war and diabolise Russia, while in fact, they are as guilty as the Russian government for it, if not even more. Not to mention that they are arming the Ukrainians and helping them to resist (instead of helping with diplomatic dialogue), which only increases the violence and the number of deaths (while at the same time, they call themselves peacemakers and the apostles of democracy). Currently, there is no democratic country in the world. A ‘democratically elected’ candidate in the West is almost always the one who had spent the biggest amount of time in the media space - and 90% of the medias are owned by the 1-2% of the richest people. It’s an autocracy of the rich capitalists (who make money with this war) - it’s just that it’s hidden better than it is in Russia or in China, covered with all these lies about ‘freedom’ (egoism), democracy and peace, an excuse for the USA to make war everywhere but on their own continent, because that suits their market’s interest. It’s naïve to think that the USA only use the soft power to assure their hegemony, and it’s naïve to think that there is more freedom or democracy in the West - it’s all lies and illusions (except maybe for the freedom of speech). I’m just trying to say that USA or Europe are not better then Russia or China in any way - all the imperial states and all violent actions bring us where we are today. Ukraine is just a crystallisation of much bigger problems of our world. The tension between the elites (the leading class) and the people isn’t just Russia’s karma - it’s our worlds destiny and it will eventually lead to the end of our civilization.
Привет Макс и Юля! Если возможно, не могли бы ты сделать субтитры к этому видео? Это важний ролик, и хотел бы быть уверен, что я поймал. Спасибо за ваш трудолюбие, и я хочу, чтобы всё пришло в норму в мире. Сейчас всё очень сумасшедшее.
Mi ruso no es tan bueno como para entender sin subtítulos, o en inglés. Pero leyendo los comentarios, creo que estamos en la misma sintonía. Espero que esto termine pronto :( es algo muy triste, no puedo creer que ocurra en esta época.
Привет друзья, я с большим удовольствием время от времени смотрю ваш очень интересный канал. Я хотел бы сказать что очень оцениваю вашу искренность и ваше мнение. В двух словах: Путин и его окружающих - не вся Россия и обязательно не будущее вашей прекрасной страны. Будущее России - это вы и оно прекрасное. Я абсолютно уверен в этом. Желаю вам от всего сердца всего доброго из Голландии.
May God bless the courageous and brave Russians who protest and stand up against their leaders, who have woefully chosen the path of war. мир за все! Господи ромилуй!
У нас в Бразилии стыдно, что наш президент за Путина. Он любит авторитаризм, вот почему он его поддерживал. К счастью, вице-президент, генерал, сказал что он против войны и Бразилия так голосовал в безопасности совет ООН.
Yeah, cause sh*tlibs all around the world use the same NATO narrative. It`s pretty easy boy, the more your narrative and your talking points resemble CNN narrative and talking points, the more you are the opposite of sane and logic. These young people don`t know anything about Russia in the 90`s. And they were fed too much Hollywood movies like yourself.
Thankyou for your excellent lessond! I haave to writr this in Englis because of visuall impairedness. But your dialogue I can easily follow. Here in Finland, we feel great synpathy for Ukrainians. The aktionsart of Putin remind us of 1939, Wien Stalin and Molotov attacked Finland staring the so-called winter war. The prext for the invasion was alleged bombing of Russian territory at Mainila on the Karelian isthmus. I Also with to thank Max and Julia for their courage and sincerety to use the rnes of things, not Orwellian Newspeak. WAR is WAR, not militarismia special operation! Please, overloo the mispellings!
Hello Max, I love your channel. I am in the US in contact with relatives and close friends in southern Ukraine. I am uncertain if you are getting accurate news in Russia. I am still in contact although it is very difficult. My family is outside Mykolaiv, in a village called Kalinovka. Mykolaiv has been bombed extensively. Much of the cities infrastructure is destroyed, and civilian areas receive shells. A hospital was hit. The village also received a shell and 5 people died. My friends have no heat, intermittent electric, and are in a basement on a mattress. They are very cold and frightened, dirty, where they are hiding has no toilet. They are using a slow cooker to cook, put under a blanket when in bed. The ages are 3 women, 6, 40, 67. There are not Nazis in southern Ukraine, there are 60 year old grandmothers and 80 year old men defending houses. This is not propaganda, this is my life and first hand knowledge. It is brutal attack, being defended by people that love their home. I believe that unless Putin looses power, expect an exchange of nuclear weapons, because I do not see Putin accepting defeat by a much smaller country. I also believe they lost control of the facts, which will create problems as this spirals out of control. I am sorry.
Спасибо Макс и Юля!! Вы молодцы, и Я всегда вас поддержу! Я люблю русский язык и русских людей - Путин и его правительство НЕ представляют русские или Россию. Мне жаль украинцев и русских:-( Спасибо вам, большое, что вы говорите об этом, поделитесь своим мнением - это очень важно. Мы вас любим! Андрей
Horrible news after two awful years of pandemic. What next?! I do hope that despite the economic sanctions that you can continue to teach us all Russian online, and that your own livelihood is not affected by a decision you had nothing to do with.
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you, Russian John & Yoko, I've had 20 hours of Max so far. I understood only 30 % of this, but I understand you. Eta katastrofa, pravda. Much love from Mainz in Germany
Mainz is such a great City. So viele Freunde und Spaß dort!
I've had 2000 hrs and I understand 10 %
You can turn on subtitles in English in the 'Settings' symbol - if that's any help
@@scarletred8888 At this point, I can listen to the entire live without any subtitle, that's that max's chanel is for
@@cactusowo1835 Very good ! I am not there yet - and I really wanted to hear what they were feeling so subtitles were on !
My heart bleeds for all innocent people involved against their will in this conflict. Thank you for this video.
Thanks for the video. I have been looking foward to hearing your position about the current situation as I have been following you and respecting you for a good while. I am so glad I was not disappointed at all hearing your objective opinions, opinions of people with common sense and humane attitude. Hope we will see the world where peace prevails some day
You have been a great teacher and I appreciate all the passion you put into your lessons and videos. Prayers for you and Julia.
Peace and love to you both during these difficult times.
You're good generous people, I hope you don't get in trouble for expressing your opinion.
Your channel is wonderful Max. I think at times of conflict and war the best form of protest is coming together through language learning and refusing to hate. May love flood us all
Макс и Юлия! Трудно мне выразить словами как Вас обоих уважаю и даже обожаю! Будьте добры и берегитесь! Вы должны быть посолами России. Я люблю и Украинский народ и Русский народ.
This is very true. I trust them the most. They are really important teachers.
Я живу в США и уже год смотрю ваши видео. Я изучалa русский язык много, много лет назад и почти все забылa. Просмотр ваших видео помог мне вспомнить то, что я забылa! Ваши уроки интересны и очень полезны. Я надеюсь, что вы оба здоровы и что этот ужас скоро закончится.
Вы очень храбрые люди. И вы правы: нельзя постоянно молчать!
I watched with tears in my eyes. Thank you for your opposition. Thank you for your courage in speaking out. Nyet voine.
I've loved your channel for years, but I will NEVER forget that you spoke up in a moment of truth. Bog s vami. Moya blagodarnost ne znaet granits.
Спасибо за то, что сказали правду. ❤️ Эта война. Ужасная война. Спасибо за важное видео.
Дорогие друзя--спасибо вам за то, что вы так откровенно и смело поделились своими взглядами с нами. Я американка, и я давно надеялась на развитие мирных, нормальных отношений между нашими странами--сердце сейчас болит от огорчения. Я глубоко сожалею о всех страданиях, которые война принесёт украинцам, россиянам, и всему миру.
Вы очень терпеливо ответили сегодня на комментарии людей, которые плохо понимают сложности вашего настоящего положения. Может быть стоит вспомнить слова Пушкина в этот момент--"Не оспоривай глупца." Пожалуйста, берегите себя. Я буду держать вас в своих мыслях.
Будьте осторожен, друзья.
Макс и Джулия, я впечатлен вашей честностью. Всегда смотрю "уроки" Макса, который для меня, голландца, очень четко и понятно говорит по-русски. На самом деле, он всегда веселый и позитивный, поэтому мне было любопытно, как - и если - он расскажет о войне, которую развязал Щебень в Украине. Мои искренние комплименты. Я понимаю, что это требует мужества. И у тебя есть!
Thank you for this film. I found your channel and I immediately loved it, but I could not subscribe without knowing what kind of people you are and what you think about the war. Now I know I can and I know I'm going to enjoy learning Russian with you so much! Greetings from Poland
Oh you two, Max and Julia! I love you. I love your youtube channel, all the subjects, the road trips and my heart is with you. You are in a very delicate situation and I think you are very courageous to open your heart . I have so many friends in Ukraine without houses anymore, or hiding in basement or fighting with what they can find. My heart is with them, not knowing if I will see them again. My heart is also with my friend in Russia who thinks I will hate them. Who are not able to do anything. My heart goes to the older russian, misleaded by tv. To the young soldiers thinking they were doing an exercice, who have been lied to. Thank you for this video. You are great, interesting, courageous, dedicated, open minded, good teacher and very funny. Take care and long live to russian with Max. ~danielle from Montreal
And now...there are no videos since 8 days ago......
@@jjns5600 pray hard
Bless you both! Я давно влюбился в ваш подкаст. This simply solidifies my opinion that you are the best Russian podcast, period. 🙏🙏🙏
Max and Julia, in the hope you receive this message, I wish you and your families safe and well in these difficult times. Thank you for your wonderful lessons. I'm sure all your followers are thinking of you, looking forward to when we can hear from you again. With great sadness I say 'until we meet again'. Much love.
Макс и Юля.Спасибо большое.Пожалуйста, продолжайте в том же духе. Я изучаю русский язык со времен холодной войны. Мы, простые люди, не хотим ненависти и войны.
Thank you Max and Julia for such an informative content. Respect for Russians and Ukrainians✊
Every video you make, I love you two more. No matter what happens, you will always be welcome in our home.
Я из США. Я понял 70% ваши стрима без субтитров. Это из-за вас и всех учителей русского языка на TH-cam. Огромное Огромное спасибо! поддерживаю вас.
Я постараюсь выразиться дипломатично. Мы живем в мире, где борьба за ресурсы - это постоянная борьба за власть. Основные игроки выше системы. Если они хотят войны, отвечающей их интересам, война будет. И получать прибыль от оружия, наркотиков и информационного контроля. Однако простые люди, те, кто принял на себя основную тяжесть агрессии, должны объединиться. Забудьте о флагах и обойдите стороной пропаганду. Вы отличный учитель, я ценю ваши усилия по продвижению изучения языка, чтобы однажды хорошие люди мира могли объединиться и вместе стремиться к лучшему, независимо от национальности, и вам всегда будут рады в моем доме. твоя семья и друзья мой дом твой дом. МИР.
Скажи мне, друг, кто в Украине убивает, насилует, сжигает, истязает? Это сам Путин? Или этим занимаются эти простые русские в военной форме?
I don't blame Russians for the actions of the leadership. No reasonable person can do that. Dear Max and Julia, I respect you ! I also love to hear you speak Russian. I hope to be able to do so one day and you are helping me to do so. Thank you from Berlin. Let me know when you come.
I was shocked when Max was reading the comment which says that all Russian people should go protesting in the street. There is nothing wrong when ordinary people want to avoid arrest, suppression, or persecution. Those who have the bravery to take the risk and protest should be applauded. But those who are afraid of saying anything also deserve sympathy and understanding. Ordinary people are innocent, yet are always harmed.
Спасибо из Украины за ваше здравомыслие и за вашу позицию! Теперь могу спокойно рекомендовать ваш канал своим иностранным друзьям, изучающим русский :)
Ребята, надеюсь, вы в безопасности. Держитесь.
Спасибо!
Max and Julia, the American media all around is making sure to tell everyone that many Russians are against this war, and that Putin is the one responsible. Americans actually have a lot of affection for Russian people ❤️ Thank you for this wonderful video.
Really good to hear that, Liza! Sadly, here in the UK, the media is very hostile to Russia and Russians in general at the moment. But speaking to ordinary people, lots of them have expressed the sentiment that the Russian people should not be blamed for the current conflict. Such a horrific situation for Ukrainians, for Russians, for everyone in the world :(((((
@@themultilingualfamilyhub No war! #NoWar (I'm from Russia) )
@@themultilingualfamilyhub The problem is that someone is to blame for all the deaths and destruction in Ukraine. Besides the fact that the decision was made by one man, hundreds of thousands of Russians collaborate in this work of destruction. And all my Russian friends, because they are in their forties, ALL of them, voted for Putin.
Max with Julia and thousands of other Russians are carrying the consequences of actions they had no influence on, and that's wrong. But the indifference to the evil that politicians cause - is also bad. This indifference and taking care of "just my family, because I have no influence on anything else" - is a typical Russian quote I've heard hundreds of times. The indifference leads to violence. The Russians, unfortunately, like the Americans, have a greater responsibility in electing their president. They elect this president for all of us, in some way. They can decide the war for all of us...
The second thing is, that it's too late for anything at this point. All the evil has already happened, mothers will not recover their murdered children, Ukrainian women have already been raped, cities have been turned to ruins. But... where did it begin? For example, from my language partner who lives in the outskirts of Moscow - he was my partner before I found out - who works with his wife as translators at an arms factory. Ah, because "I have to live", right? And "I have three children, you know? Look how cute they are. It is so difficult to find a job for translators near Moscow". Right. All the time we are making decisions. Some of them leave blood on our hands.
Who is to blame here? Certainly, the Russian murderers and rapists now operating in Ukraine and calling themselves "the military." But also those who live comfortably in Russia and did not react to the Russian aggression against Georgia, the occupation of Crimea, and the "hybrid war" in Donbas. They did not care that the Russians were bombing civilians in Syria - after all, the Russians had been invited by Assad, right? They were there "legally". I also heard this quote in Russia. I visited Russia three or four times. One of them in order to explain what is happening in Syria to my Russian friends. Who is to blame for this Russian war on Ukraine? I think the translators and secretaries who work in gun factories, as well. And the trolls on the internet as well. They all contribute to the murder and destruction, ultimately. They are in Putin's team.
I have Russian and Ukrainian friends, I've been working in Donbas, as a humanitarian worker, doing our projects, for the last few years. Donbas is the area that has been occupied by Russians and pro-Russia Ukrainians separatists. I could see the destruction and instability. I heard the everyday shelling, I saw the lack of services, the poverty caused by the "hybrid war". As I was working in a Russian-speaking area of Ukraine, I decided to polish my Russian. Among other thanks to Navalny and to his channel, thanks to Zelenski and his comic group Kvartal 95, and thanks to Russian and Ukrainian vloggers, such as Max and Julia.
I appreciate all the work they've done. I wish them luck. In a better place. The place we will build for ourselves and for our children. Taking responsibility. Saying NO to the war. There are no "fair wars". And every war starts many, many years before.
Because of our little selfish approvals and betrayals.
Привет из Испании, я вчера посмотрела ваше видео, большое вам спасибо за то, что высказали нам свое мнение об этой войне. На мой взгляд, ужасной ошибке, в любом случае, я надеюсь, что скоро все разрешится наилучшим образом, и мы все сможем продолжать наслаждаться вашими замечательными видео и изучать замечательный русский язык. пока пока
Макс и Джулия, я не смогла принять участие в прямом эфире в день, когда его показывали, но я только что посмотрела его и хочу поздравить вас с тем, что вы поделились своими мыслями и откровенно говорили в это трудное время. Я лично не намерен прекращать изучение русского языка. Моя учительница в Бразилии родом из Одессы, и у нее там до сих пор есть семья, и мы намерены продолжить наши занятия. Я всегда был русским с тех пор, как начал изучать язык в средней школе в Северной Ирландии почти 50 лет назад. Мне все равно, кто там у власти. Моя любовь к русскому народу и, в первую очередь, к русской культуре и музыке никогда не умрет. Продолжайте хорошую работу.
A massive thank you for your work. You just earned yourself a new fan!
Я высоко оцениваю прозорливость и откровенность, которые Вы демонстрировали в течение последних нескольких дней. Спасибо вам большое, вы очень умные, храбрые, честные. А теперь я боюсь для вас. Что вы будете делать если вы не можете продолжать свою работу? Где и как вы будете жить?
Thank you for doing this. Спасибо большое!!! 🙏❤️
Love you guys and am praying all is well with you and your families. I just rewatched the proposal video - needed that sort of cheering up. I have Estonian/Russian roots and this just feels like the most surreal nightmare - like the world just unexpectedly and completely changed in the blink of an eye. My heart breaks for both the Ukrainians and the Russians. May something end this soon. Very, very soon.
Very interesting. In Italy students are very scared and worried about this war. We talk a lot about that at school. Thanks for your video.
I was sad about It until see that 90% of ukranian soldiers had nazi tattoos.
Good luck and thank you!! Watching your videos has really helped me learn Russian while I was living in Uzbekistan. This is a sad and difficult time for Russia and its people...while censorship and propaganda happens in every country, it's particularly startling right now and demonstrates how dangerous it can be when so many lives are at risk. Thanks and godspeed.
Давно смотрю ваши видео и они мне всегда нравились. Вы замечательные учители русского языка и очень приятные люди. Но этим видео вы доказали, что это еще не все. Огромный респект за ваши ясные мысли, за вашу честность, за вашу храбрость. Огромный респект всем россиянам, осмеливающимся выступить против войны.
Looks like Putin just declared war on the world saying the sanctions was a declaration of war good luck you’re against the world now
I hope you guys are okay and I'm impressed you spoke out about this.
Привет Макс и Юлия. Я из Норвегии и моя жена из Украине. Мы любим вас. Храни вас Бог.
Hi Max and Julia!
I’d like to know how you’re coping with the situation.Are you back in Moscow? Will you continue your videos? If so, in which way? I appreciate both of you a lot and hope you’ll be able to go on, and make your living.I’ve decided to go on learning Russian because it’s such a big culture though politics has always be awful through history. Happy too to have visited Moscow in December before the war. Please give us news! Thanks for everything.
Definitely... Please give us an update, Max and Julia!! WE're all thinking of you. Hope you're all coping okay !
Скоро будет стрим
@@RussianWithMax Спасибо!!!
Also ... apart from all suffering because of war in Ukraine... I feel sorry for all Russians not supporting war who currently are outside Russia. Hope people will be smart and not blame them for what is happening.
Please provide English translation, we love you guys and hope that you are well, give peace a chance!
Макс и юлия, вы молодцы! Браво за вашу храбрость! Нам нужны люди как вы!
This was a courageous video to make, Max and Julia. It gives me hope. I imagine the current situation will not be good for your business - if you ever need help from the other side of the new iron curtain, let me know.
Я согласен с вами. Это катастрофа. Ужасно. Страшно. Я против. Нет войне!!!!!!!
Война - это кошмар, как можно было в 21 веке развязать войну и погрузить наши страны в ад и деградацию...
I hope you're safe. Thank you! We're working for peace here too. A big hug from Italy.
Спасибо большое за вашу работу!! Я нашла ваш канал четыре года назад, когда я начала изучать русский язык в Испании. Сейчас я могла понять ваши аргументы и я благодарю вас. Я ненавижу войны, я не понимаю как это происходит. Я буду продолжать с русским языком, а я надеюсь что война закончится и Украина станет свободной снова!! Спасибо друзья!!!
Но реально я магу сказать что я понял 50% этого разговора!!!!!!
Думал что я просто буду понимать немногие слова!!!!
Макс, вас спасибо за все 🙏
Вау, отличный результат!!
i will not take sides on this issue of war in the ukraine! Opinions are never based on facts!! And, i do not have the facts! My humble opinion is this; Conflict between nations is terrifiying for both sides!! Women and children are usually the most vulnerable victims in any war! I hope in 2023 this conflict will end for the good of the world! Thanks Max, and Julia for speaking on this subject!! Great russian language lesson always!!
Thank you. I've put my Russian learning efforts on ice since last week. But I gladly made an exception for you.
Я студент русского языка. Я часто посмотрю на видеоролик у вас Спасибо большое за это объяснение, это помогает. я согласен, я тоже ненавижу войну. это ужасная ситуация.
Thanks for all your wonderful videos, Max and Julia. Before this video your work encouraged me to persist with learning Russian; after watching this, I say a massive 'thank you' for your brave and honest answers. You two are wonderful, true ambassadors for your fellow citizens; I'm sure you've made many friends both in Russia and around the world. Good luck for your futures, whatever may befall!
Привет из Италии! Спасибо вам, Макс & Юлия - вы строили мосты.
Спасибо за это видео. Макс и Юля, вы хорошие люди. Пусть восторжествует мир.
Thank you very, very much for your opinion :) I hope, there will be no problems for you
Спасибо за мудрые слова, друзья 👍. Поддержка для русских, белорусов и украинсев из Польши ❤️.
Big respect to you both and to all Russians who oppose the bloody war,be careful please and thank you for sharing your knowledge and opinions, greetings from Belgium ✌️ and stay open-minded and very strong,we are not against the people of Russia but against the war where there is a lot of blame, sincerely continue your right to be heard!!!!
Very nice talk. It is a crazy time. We had the same nonsense under Bush 2. I hope we can all survive these leaders.
Thank you so much for sharing this and for speaking out. Your courage is so inspiring and will help make this world a better place. I hope you are both doing well. ❤️
Agree and I hope the UK and US citizen rise up one day after countless wars against others.
But you can’t solve the conflict without war because the countries backing Ukraine want war, they don’t want Ukraine to make peace or negotiate with Russia, Russia can’t just abandon Luhansk and Donbas. Sure their propaganda increased the desire for those regions to want to rejoin Russia, but they were also under consistent attack by nazi militants that everyone used to talk about but suddenly stopped. In The Minsk agreement (the first one) Ukraine agreed to them being independent but didn’t honour the agreement.
Спасибо большое, что записали это видео!
Макс и Юлия, что случилось? Это было ваше последнее видео.
Все хорошо с вами? Надеюсь это кошмар скоро закончится. Надеюсь у вас все в порядке.
Спасибо Вам…. мне так важно узнать всё что Вы скажите
Thanks for the video, hope you two are well!
Are you guys ok after your video. I study Russian everyday. You are one of my favorites. I am happy that Max and Julia found each other. It is sad the elite treat us as cattle. I understand many words in Russian, but like a baby I can't speak much YET!
Thanks so much for your honest (and courageous !) evaluation of this tragic situation!!!!
Макс и Юлия, спасибо большое! Я захотела все больше изучать русский язык, чтобы сообщать друзьям об этом видео. Желаю мир из Японии...
Thank you very much for speaking your thoughts. And you include many aspects. Well done, (so far, I just listened to the first 15 minutes, rest follows later. I understand 60%, Anis).
I just hope nothing will happen to you because of this video. Let's hope the war will end very soon.
1. Max and Yulia - two gentle souls! Here, too, it can be seen that the interests of young Russians align with those of young people worldwide. It's just some bald dwarfs who haven't noticed the world has moved on. 2. If Kiev is considered the “mother of Russian cities”, is the attack by the Russian army like beating up your own mother?
Thank you for sharing your opinion Max and Yulia!!
Z
Макс и Июня,
Я очень люблю ваш канал. Я смотрел много вашего видео.
Спасибо за всё!
Шарон из Израиля
Hello Max and Yulia. First congratulations on your recent marriage. And bravo for your courage. Some day if I have time I will write down your dialogue, in order to understand all of it.
Brothers killing each other it brings tears to my eyes 😪
надеюсь что ваш стриминг останется на Ютубе :/ я рад что я ещё мог прислушиваться к вашу мнению. Ситуация в Украине мне очень тяжелая, и поэтому хорошо узнать что и в России люди так чувствует себя. Хотя я никогда ее верил что было бы по-другому. Кто вообще-то хочет войну? Никто кто нормальный, обычный, хороший человек. Как и вы. И я уверен что и большинство людей в России так. Я надеюсь что вам не будет слишком трудно из-за санкций и желаю вам всего хорошего. Нет войны!
Dear Max and Yulia, I appreciate your courage and I understand your indignation - no people, wherever they come from, can ever approve of war, which is always a destruction of the innocent and a way for certain elites to make profit (by selling arms etc. …).
I’d just like to say that most of the independent, alternative media in Europe point out that the military provocations of the USA and most importantly, their commercial interests (they wanted to sell shale gas to Europe, and Russia was their no.1 concurrent - well now they’ve managed to do it, which is, by the way, an ecological disaster…), their manipulation of the Ukrainian elites (which, by the way, did nothing to respect the Minsk agreement, and apparently really are led by Nazis - yes, literally Nazis, cheering Hitler and so on -, financed by Washington), and their disrespect of the international law (they are in war in the Middle East, in Africa etc., since more than 20 years, then there is also that story of NATOs intervention in Yugoslavia - I mean, they’ve never respected the international law and they’ve never been sanctioned for it, so now Russia does the same - which isn’t cool, of course, but the sanctions show the double standards of the Europeans who are nothing but America’s avant-garde), are the cause of this crises.
I’m horrified by the hypocrisy of the West and its medias, who dare to judge this war and diabolise Russia, while in fact, they are as guilty as the Russian government for it, if not even more. Not to mention that they are arming the Ukrainians and helping them to resist (instead of helping with diplomatic dialogue), which only increases the violence and the number of deaths (while at the same time, they call themselves peacemakers and the apostles of democracy).
Currently, there is no democratic country in the world. A ‘democratically elected’ candidate in the West is almost always the one who had spent the biggest amount of time in the media space - and 90% of the medias are owned by the 1-2% of the richest people. It’s an autocracy of the rich capitalists (who make money with this war) - it’s just that it’s hidden better than it is in Russia or in China, covered with all these lies about ‘freedom’ (egoism), democracy and peace, an excuse for the USA to make war everywhere but on their own continent, because that suits their market’s interest. It’s naïve to think that the USA only use the soft power to assure their hegemony, and it’s naïve to think that there is more freedom or democracy in the West - it’s all lies and illusions (except maybe for the freedom of speech).
I’m just trying to say that USA or Europe are not better then Russia or China in any way - all the imperial states and all violent actions bring us where we are today. Ukraine is just a crystallisation of much bigger problems of our world. The tension between the elites (the leading class) and the people isn’t just Russia’s karma - it’s our worlds destiny and it will eventually lead to the end of our civilization.
Thank you for this Jula i Max
Привет Макс и Юля! Если возможно, не могли бы ты сделать субтитры к этому видео? Это важний ролик, и хотел бы быть уверен, что я поймал. Спасибо за ваш трудолюбие, и я хочу, чтобы всё пришло в норму в мире. Сейчас всё очень сумасшедшее.
Yes, subtiles here would be very, very useful, as it such an important matter
I love you guys. You are so courageous!
Eta voina! Thank you beautiful, brave people!
Спасибо за откровенность и честность,но я уже начала беспокоиться за вас
Mi ruso no es tan bueno como para entender sin subtítulos, o en inglés. Pero leyendo los comentarios, creo que estamos en la misma sintonía. Espero que esto termine pronto :( es algo muy triste, no puedo creer que ocurra en esta época.
I know around 400 words and I'm starting to understand you
Привет друзья, я с большим удовольствием время от времени смотрю ваш очень интересный канал. Я хотел бы сказать что очень оцениваю вашу искренность и ваше мнение. В двух словах: Путин и его окружающих - не вся Россия и обязательно не будущее вашей прекрасной страны.
Будущее России - это вы и оно прекрасное. Я абсолютно уверен в этом. Желаю вам от всего сердца всего доброго из Голландии.
Bless you, Ralph, for such great words.
May God bless the courageous and brave Russians who protest and stand up
against their leaders, who have woefully chosen the path of war. мир за
все! Господи ромилуй!
У нас в Бразилии стыдно, что наш президент за Путина. Он любит авторитаризм, вот почему он его поддерживал. К счастью, вице-президент, генерал, сказал что он против войны и Бразилия так голосовал в безопасности совет ООН.
I love your lessons and applaud your heart.
Очень Хорошо! «Чем хороша война? Совершенно ничего!» - Эдвин Старр (1970)
I've heard more sane & logical thinking in this livestream in the first 15 minutes than in last two months on any other channel!
Yeah, cause sh*tlibs all around the world use the same NATO narrative. It`s pretty easy boy, the more your narrative and your talking points resemble CNN narrative and talking points, the more you are the opposite of sane and logic. These young people don`t know anything about Russia in the 90`s. And they were fed too much Hollywood movies like yourself.
Thank you for making this video. Очень приятно и важно видеть, что еще есть порядочные люди в мире.
Sending love Max and Julie ❤️ thank you
Thankyou for your excellent lessond! I haave to writr this in Englis because of visuall impairedness. But your dialogue I can easily follow. Here in Finland, we feel great synpathy for Ukrainians. The aktionsart of Putin remind us of 1939, Wien Stalin and Molotov attacked Finland staring the so-called winter war. The prext for the invasion was alleged bombing of Russian territory at Mainila on the Karelian isthmus. I Also with to thank Max and Julia for their courage and sincerety to use the rnes of things, not Orwellian Newspeak. WAR is WAR, not militarismia special operation! Please, overloo the mispellings!
мы знаем, что русские люди не начинали это. мы любим вас, ребята. мы любим ваши семейные ценности и культуру.
Hello Max, I love your channel. I am in the US in contact with relatives and close friends in southern Ukraine. I am uncertain if you are getting accurate news in Russia. I am still in contact although it is very difficult. My family is outside Mykolaiv, in a village called Kalinovka. Mykolaiv has been bombed extensively. Much of the cities infrastructure is destroyed, and civilian areas receive shells. A hospital was hit. The village also received a shell and 5 people died. My friends have no heat, intermittent electric, and are in a basement on a mattress. They are very cold and frightened, dirty, where they are hiding has no toilet. They are using a slow cooker to cook, put under a blanket when in bed. The ages are 3 women, 6, 40, 67. There are not Nazis in southern Ukraine, there are 60 year old grandmothers and 80 year old men defending houses. This is not propaganda, this is my life and first hand knowledge. It is brutal attack, being defended by people that love their home. I believe that unless Putin looses power, expect an exchange of nuclear weapons, because I do not see Putin accepting defeat by a much smaller country. I also believe they lost control of the facts, which will create problems as this spirals out of control. I am sorry.
I am very sorry too 😞
I am very very sorry to what is happening to your family and friends and to the Ukrainian people as a whole!
Спасибо вам большое
Спасибо Макс и Юля!! Вы молодцы, и Я всегда вас поддержу! Я люблю русский язык и русских людей - Путин и его правительство НЕ представляют русские или Россию. Мне жаль украинцев и русских:-( Спасибо вам, большое, что вы говорите об этом, поделитесь своим мнением - это очень важно. Мы вас любим! Андрей
Merci pour votre message de paix.
Спасибо Макс и Юля!❤️
Horrible news after two awful years of pandemic. What next?! I do hope that despite the economic sanctions that you can continue to teach us all Russian online, and that your own livelihood is not affected by a decision you had nothing to do with.
Yes I hope you carry on your teaching channel!
Спасибо за искренность это воодушевляет именно в настоящее время