I watched it at my early youth back in 91 or 92. Very hard to watch it even at the age of 45. Sad to see a young and beautiful girl being humiliated by the locals, whose crime was fall in love to the "enemy". Also sad to understand the love of her older husband trying hard to make happy. Not to mention the Major, suffering of war PTSD. One of the best pictures I've ever watched. Changed myself and made me more empathetic towards other people's problems and emotions. Timeless classic !
@Puppet Comhairle Yeah, getting the accents not-quite-right means the entire film was shit -- genius comment, and with you "yelling" it out (i.e. writing in caps), it's like someone from this deranged mob came to life and grabbed a keyboard...
Such a moving scene, and the climax of the film. Rosie getting betrayed by her father to the mob, Shaughnessy's sense of heartbreak and defeat, the Father breaking it up and shaming the townspeople. So hard to watch every time I see it.
"Easy Father, I think you're taking advantage of your Cloth". His response of "That's what it's for" indicates that he's a no-nonsense priest with attitude.
Within the context of the movie that's true, but the mobs of today are usually extreme liberal types... particularly on social media@@subkontrabasklarinet
Uh ... no, I think their goal is to help the victims get justice. They'd be intervening here to help Rose, but I suspect dishonest / blind people like you would be nowhere to be found.
Film juste merveilleux ! Décors sublimes,sur fond de lutte armée entre l’Irlande et l’Angleterre ,acteurs prestigieux tous excellents !!! Mitchum (mon acteur fétiche) a contre emploi mais sublime ! J’adore!
Great film especially the performance of Sir John Mills. And Sarah Miles was so pretty, even with her head shorn, a disgrace in those times, adorable! Made her look even more waif-like. I won't comment on the civil war except to say, how is war ever "civil" ...
This scene drew inspiration from how kangaroo courts in countries that had been occupied by the Nazis took the law into their own hands during the Liberation in 1944-45.
This film isn't set in the Irish Civil War period. It's set in the war for independence. The civil war erupted after the independence war and the signing of a treaty with Britain.
I went alone at 12yrs old and saw this..I realised how venal and cowardly a mob is ...I was struck how beautiful the country..ugliness always lurks in such places
Hermosa película. Tengo años buscándola para poder verla otra vez. Me gustaría que la pudieras SUBIR TODA LA PELÍCULA Y CON SUBTÍTULOS EN ESPAÑOL. GRACIAS
It’s a great example of the evil of mob rule. But there’s dramatic licence too: people in Ireland in that period would not have been as universally on the side of the gun runners. Public opinion was only in the process of shifting then to the independence movement. Nevertheless, it’s powerfully done?!
As is well known, Leo McKern who is best remembered for playing Rumpole of the Bailey plays Tom Ryan. I have always thought that the guy leading the mob in this scene looks awfully like John Mortimer.
Just to say that particular actor was my Dad and if he was still with us he would be delighted with your comparison to J Mortimer! He was a great admirer of his writing and absolutely lived Rumpole of course. ✨💚✨☘️✨
I've remembered that I've seen this film, late at night on television, in the same week that I've watched Hiroshima mon Amour. I was in my pre-teen/teenager years then. Both films had a strong impression on me since then. At the end, it's always on women which the worst heavy of wars lays on. I think it's still hard to watch this (superb) scene, with a bunch of amazing actors.
@djfhfh It wasn't her affair with a British solider that bothered them. They accused her of being an informer to the enemy soliders when it was actually her own father.
Well, I can count dozens of films with similar scenes involved with colaboracionism and angry mo: this movie, Hiroshima Mon Amour, The Boxer (in an urban environment and in the 90s). And, yes, there's a lot of films about different issues whose "angry mobs scenes" are famous (Breaking the Waves, Danton, The Day of the locust, etc etc etc). Angry people who are reunited always look really bad, stupid and vile, it doesn't matter which kind they are in their "normal lives".
The most destructive conformist mobs in history were made up of the most highly educated populations. Germany was the most educated and cultured country in Europe and rolled over as the Nazis took over. The educated elites of the Russian intelligentsia fueled the Russian Revolution and Bolshevism. Mao used the children of educated elites during the Cultural Revolution. Pol Pots Khmer Rouge elite was made up of the highly educated products of French pedagogy. All of these extremists were educated into imbecility with a love of terror and mob violence.
Well, I've watched this film on Brazilian television, in mid 80s, and this scene was on it. BTW, it's the stronger of all film and I remember it perfectly well.
Crazy people. Shows how mob mentality is dangerous. Theyre acting like they wouldn't have done the similar if the opportunity wasn't presented to them... 🤔 People have issues.
Toni Sumblin ) yeah, like how the comment above claims this "the democrats mentality" when really ANY group that isn't completley pacifistic can act like this, this is WRONG no matter what.
![🔴 ฟุตบอลแชมป์กีฬา 7HD แชมเปียน คัพ 2024 [รอบรองชนะเลิศ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zPm8ClLVhoE/mqdefault.jpg)
I watched it at my early youth back in 91 or 92. Very hard to watch it even at the age of 45. Sad to see a young and beautiful girl being humiliated by the locals, whose crime was fall in love to the "enemy". Also sad to understand the love of her older husband trying hard to make happy. Not to mention the Major, suffering of war PTSD. One of the best pictures I've ever watched. Changed myself and made me more empathetic towards other people's problems and emotions. Timeless classic !
Heartbreaking! A brilliantly written directed and performed scene, unforgettable.
Trevor Howard, amazing actor. May his soul be in Peace ❤
This is the best scene. Magistral actors and extras
@Puppet Comhairle Yeah, getting the accents not-quite-right means the entire film was shit -- genius comment, and with you "yelling" it out (i.e. writing in caps), it's like someone from this deranged mob came to life and grabbed a keyboard...
Such a moving scene, and the climax of the film. Rosie getting betrayed by her father to the mob, Shaughnessy's sense of heartbreak and defeat, the Father breaking it up and shaming the townspeople. So hard to watch every time I see it.
"Easy Father, I think you're taking advantage of your Cloth". His response of "That's what it's for" indicates that he's a no-nonsense priest with attitude.
Magnificent scene and so fitting for today's climate where we have social justice warriors forming mobs on twitter to destroy people's careers.
BLTKellys EXACTLY
It's interesting that you see SWJs in the scene. I see the opposite - uneducated masses and "ordinary people" destroying people's lives.
Within the context of the movie that's true, but the mobs of today are usually extreme liberal types... particularly on social media@@subkontrabasklarinet
Uh ... no, I think their goal is to help the victims get justice. They'd be intervening here to help Rose, but I suspect dishonest / blind people like you would be nowhere to be found.
@@DeepScreenAnalysis 'Extreme liberal'? WTF is that?
Film juste merveilleux ! Décors sublimes,sur fond de lutte armée entre l’Irlande et l’Angleterre ,acteurs prestigieux tous excellents !!! Mitchum (mon acteur fétiche) a contre emploi mais sublime ! J’adore!
Trevor Howard was amazing
Great film especially the performance of Sir John Mills. And Sarah Miles was so pretty, even with her head shorn, a disgrace in those times, adorable! Made her look even more waif-like. I won't comment on the civil war except to say, how is war ever "civil" ...
This scene drew inspiration from how kangaroo courts in countries that had been occupied by the Nazis took the law into their own hands during the Liberation in 1944-45.
This film isn't set in the Irish Civil War period. It's set in the war for independence. The civil war erupted after the independence war and the signing of a treaty with Britain.
I went alone at 12yrs old and saw this..I realised how venal and cowardly a mob is ...I was struck how beautiful the country..ugliness always lurks in such places
I was 10 and it still grabs my heart.
Hermosa película. Tengo años buscándola para poder verla otra vez. Me gustaría que la pudieras SUBIR TODA LA PELÍCULA Y CON SUBTÍTULOS EN ESPAÑOL. GRACIAS
My mother going through Alzheimer’s this is the only film that seem to calm her down.i now wonder what she was thinking
How is she doing?
Word of advice...you NEVER piss off a priest!
We've been hearing that for ages, and just look at all the tomfoolery the priests have gotten away with as a result.
:(
Poor Rose. She didn’t do anything wrong but love someone.
She should never have married that schoolteacher, but having an affair with a British solider was also a no-no.
Adultery is wrong.
@@DedicatedSpartan
Mob justice is worse
Clásico del cine immortelle !!
Congratulations .
It’s a great example of the evil of mob rule.
But there’s dramatic licence too: people in Ireland in that period would not have been as universally on the side of the gun runners. Public opinion was only in the process of shifting then to the independence movement.
Nevertheless, it’s powerfully done?!
Superb movie...
As is well known, Leo McKern who is best remembered for playing Rumpole of the Bailey plays Tom Ryan. I have always thought that the guy leading the mob in this scene looks awfully like John Mortimer.
Just to say that particular actor was my Dad and if he was still with us he would be delighted with your comparison to J Mortimer! He was a great admirer of his writing and absolutely lived Rumpole of course. ✨💚✨☘️✨
God Bless ya Tim O`leary.its so funny this scene.
My grandmother was an extra in this film , she is standing behind the man in the glasses ,wearing a black cloak x
Inhumane ... what vile people
It reminds me of what the French also did to French female collaborators at the end of WWII.
I've remembered that I've seen this film, late at night on television, in the same week that I've watched Hiroshima mon Amour. I was in my pre-teen/teenager years then. Both films had a strong impression on me since then. At the end, it's always on women which the worst heavy of wars lays on. I think it's still hard to watch this (superb) scene, with a bunch of amazing actors.
She went with a British soilder you just didn't do that
@djfhfh It wasn't her affair with a British solider that bothered them. They accused her of being an informer to the enemy soliders when it was actually her own father.
It’s a shame that the setting of this film is now demolished or in ruins ☹️ Google it
Very Good movie.
Filme lindo, perfeito!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Eu tambem gosto muito deste film muito bonitas as paisagens
Her father should be ashamed
A beauty
Long live the Brits! Long live England!
Very like my village
me recuerdan a los de la pelicula silent hill
Man im glad i wasnt around in those days
I'd bet also that the priest did plenty of excommunications that day...
This scene was powerful but wuold have been better if the villagers hadn't, all throughout the film, been depicted as yokels.
They were though. They lived in a remote and god fearing area of Ireland, why do you think any of them would be sophisticated?
Well, I can count dozens of films with similar scenes involved with colaboracionism and angry mo: this movie, Hiroshima Mon Amour, The Boxer (in an urban environment and in the 90s). And, yes, there's a lot of films about different issues whose "angry mobs scenes" are famous (Breaking the Waves, Danton, The Day of the locust, etc etc etc). Angry people who are reunited always look really bad, stupid and vile, it doesn't matter which kind they are in their "normal lives".
@ThePlataf
Would* learn to spell you Yokel
The most destructive conformist mobs in history were made up of the most highly educated populations. Germany was the most educated and cultured country in Europe and rolled over as the Nazis took over. The educated elites of the Russian intelligentsia fueled the Russian Revolution and Bolshevism. Mao used the children of educated elites during the Cultural Revolution. Pol Pots Khmer Rouge elite was made up of the highly educated products of French pedagogy. All of these extremists were educated into imbecility with a love of terror and mob violence.
This scene was cut from the original
Charon58 they did? Why?
No it was not.
Well, I've watched this film on Brazilian television, in mid 80s, and this scene was on it. BTW, it's the stronger of all film and I remember it perfectly well.
@@Ignatius1972 Just the part where they rip her shirt open to reveal her breast was cut. Not the whole scene.
@@Charon58 How did you know? And where can I watch the deleted scene?
Beyond brutal. cruel people
What was that being tossed at 5:11?
Rosy's clothes. They stripped her naked.
This is what it was almost like at the US Capitol on January 6th...
hahahahahahahahaha🤣
What was wrong with her?
Crazy people. Shows how mob mentality is dangerous. Theyre acting like they wouldn't have done the similar if the opportunity wasn't presented to them... 🤔 People have issues.
The catholic church.
Makes me sick 😫
Horrible
西方版浸豬蘢🤣
They learned that from the English.
monjiaitaly Plenty of evil from inside themselves
@Toni Sumblin fornication came from the english and still does
Toni Sumblin ) yeah, like how the comment above claims this "the democrats mentality" when really ANY group that isn't completley pacifistic can act like this, this is WRONG no matter what.
the angry mob that's the democrats mentality right there
old democrats, now republicans.
or just any extrimist of any kind.
alos the villagers are natioanlists.
@@steamboatwill3.367 You are absolutely right Steamboat Willie.
@@steamboatwill3.367 thanks you.