something i love about the idw cast is that i always felt like they were built with gameplay styles in mind. tangle has her tail, whisper has her wispon, lanolin has her bell, surge/kit have their powers etc. their gameplay styles are already there, hoping to see them pop up in new games/spinoffs
I think that Tangle and Whisper in particular are stand-ins for the Avatar in Frontiers, with Tangle representing the grappling hook and Whisper representing the weapons.
I had a good feeling the Idw were canon it’s always good hearing more confirmation on it being canon bc one day we might get to see characters like Tangle, Whisper, and Surge in future. Like there is so much platforming potential with Tangle
There are two possibilities: Either A) Sonic Prime takes place in a branch reality, or B) Given the general characterization of our heroes, it could take place in the fairly sizable gap between Lost World and Forces/
I think it's cool that IDW is confirmed to be canon to the games. It definitely helps to expand the world of Sonic in between mainline titles while also giving spotlight to characters who might not make an appearance in a future game. I would love to see some of the IDW stories get adapted into games like Battle of Angel Island, Metal Virus, and Imposter Syndrome. I feel like those three specifically leave a lot of room to make a whole game out of, mainly the first two arcs though since they go hand in hand with each other. Adapting Battle of Angel Island first also has the benefit of making it clear to casuals and game only fans that Sonic met characters like Tangle and Whisper after Forces, but before Frontiers' events.
I think a healthy way to handle it is for the games to feed the comic with the world and location that way the world doesn't feel empty and for the comics to feed the games with character growth and developments that way we can't have something like the meta Era where every character felt washed out
Imagine how sick a Frontiers-style open zone Sonic game based on the post-Forces and Metal Overlord arcs of IDW would be. It'd be awesome getting to explore a huge world and save the different cities from the Badniks while also getting to team up with Tails, Amy, Knuckles, Blaze, Tangle, Silver, and Whisper. They could even do a whole Team Attack mechanic similar to Hi Fi Rush or something!
With the rumour there may be a Sonic Heroes Remaster/Remake, due to the Tails Tube imagery that was glitching, would be nice to fit in an extended, sequel to the Metal Overlord Arc as Heroes 2. The plot is more or less the same, throws new comers that were not around at the time such as Silver, Blaze, Tangle and Whisper, though maybe it could use some tinkering so it is not just a copy and paste of Heroes 1. More than anything, though, would love an open world Metal Virus game.
I think it would be smart if they were to introduce idw characters in a game, that game would have a museum like generations with descriptions of these characters and their debuts just to catch people up just so it wouldn’t seem so unnatural for sonic to just all of a sudden have a new friend
This means the following are canon: •Amy's characterization, development, and bonding moments with Sonic •Knuckles' heart to heart story about what it means to be a guardian •Tails' 30 anniversary •Surge, Kit, Tangle, Whisper, Lanolin, etc
@@emperortoho IDW Shadow kind of redeemed himself in the most recent issue. Bro teleported an entire city to space and pretty much saved everyone, all without acting like a knock off Vegeta.
And Belle, who STILL hasn't apologized to Sonic and Tails for almost getting them killed by repairing Metal Sonic, and Eggman being Final Fantasy villain levels of evil and the Metal Virus and Sonic gaslighting Shadow and Espio and Sonic and Tails being responsible for Eggman's return and Sonic's self-righteous speech to Surge AND Sonic ...putting his foot up against Surge's butt. >_
@@emperortoho Hey, at least he wasn't in almost every issue like Sonic was. Shadow only appeared in like 13 issues before the most recent arc, not counting his time as a Zombot. We had to see a WHOLE lot more of Sonic being unlikable.
Imagine having a system where the comics are like the manga where their plot points and story are already settled and done with and the games are like the anime where they animate and incorporate the plot points and moments in the comics into the gameplay. It would be interesting to see where this could go.
Honestly, I REALLY like the new characters introduced in IDW. They’re all such great additions to this world and I’d love to play as them sometime. In terms of introducing them, I wouldn’t mind if they don’t explain their backstory, they just need to have great introductions in the games, while being consistent with their writing in the comics. I’m not a fan of adapting stories FROM the comics per se, I’d just like to see what new stuff they’d get up to in the game’s on stories.
I think the best thing for them to do is have both the comic team and Sonic Team directly collaberating with each other characters and ideas that they can bith use but can keep the ongoing stories in both games seperate while having all the characters showing up and being canon
I'm really happy with what the comics have been doing. I love the way the characters are written in them and It also makes me happy to know that the comic characters exist in the game universe. I would be over the moon to see a game based on the metal virus saga. Also seeing the comic characters in the games fully fleshed out would be sick, there's so much potential!
One thing they could maybe add is they could have collectibles in a future game where getting them unlocks comic issues of IDW you could read in an extras menu.
I'd rather it be like how Archie and the games were. Exist separately but have the same characters. It's neat that the idw is cannon but like you said it is asking a lot to have fans invest in a ongoing comic series where things can get murky when you try to put a timeline of events and such. As neat as having the metal virus be a game id rather the stick to original stories for the time being. Ultimately I'll appreciate this idw cannon more when these characters ACTUALLY appear in these mainline games that aren't spinoff like in forces speed battle having tangle and whisper in them.
I also don’t like the idea of having to read the comics in order to understand the story of the games moving forward. I shouldn’t have to go looking into an external source just to understand the whole plot and the sudden appearance of the new characters, that’s just bad writing/storytelling.
I agree. I don't like IDW, which already adds to me not wanting it to be canon, but also it's true that I shouldn't have to read a comic to enjoy the games.
@@Probably_CLOUD fr making it that a casual has to read the comics to understand why random new characters just appeared and seem to know the rest of the cast is poor decision making especially since the comics are a 6/10 at best and not everyone will want to read them
As I've said: I'm conflicted. A. it's cool they're expanding the sonic universe with these existing characters and stories B. You can tell this wasn't 100% thought-out and it looks like it was originally intended to REMAIN it's own continuity and they definitely retroactively decided to put them into the canon. I think it might be too late to rework an Comic arc into it's own game. Something I think could work if they were to introduce them in a game, is by adding character bios (sort of like Generations) and preferably introducing them early on, if not immediately in the story.
I am once again asking for a new Sonic Fighters game which has both game and comic characters. I want Whisper to fight Infinite, I want Kit to tussle with Chaos, I want Classic Sonic to fight Shadow.
I love that the comics are canon to the games, it just makes the franchise as a whole seem more cohesive and united. Yeah, it might be difficult to introduce the IDW cast into the games, but I feel like the Open Zone format will be a good way to do so if the 3rd Update for Frontiers does super well. The next game could have an overall plot, but each area could have their own mini plot that focuses on or features specific characters. Like, Central City could have the Chaotix dealing with Clutch, Rough and Tumble while Sonic's doing his thing; heck, maybe they could be running the Black Market and take Big's shop role. Surge and Kit could be causing havoc somewhere and trying to lure out and destroy Sonic and Tails as optional reoccurring boss fights. Tangle, Whisper, and Lanolin could be scoping out an Eggman base. All you'd need is a database or repository that you can use to get the gist of the characters. Like what Ratchet and Clank: Rift Apart did. Heck, maybe spin-off games could be a good way to easily introduce IDW characters into the games. Maybe they can reuse the Sonic Chronicles title as a sub-series to use side characters. Like Sonic Heroes style ones for the Chaotix and Diamond Cutters. Or Sonic Rush style ones focusing on confrontations between Sonic and Surge and Tails' Adventure style ones for confrontations between Tails and Kit. There's a lot that can be done here.
Eh…. I’m still on the fence about it being canon. I’m still convinced Ian just snuck those lines into Frontiers as easter eggs. More likely, I think the plan will be to introduce the IDW characters into the mainline games with new storylines, since the fans like the IDW characters. MAYBE they adapt the IDW arcs into games, which I would like, but I’ll hold my breath on the canonicity of the comics until they are more explicitly mentioned in the games.
If IDW is canon, I want I TOTALLY WANT to see Scrapnik Island Mecha Sonic to be in a game. I want to see that sweet cute protective angstylord with his cool redemption arc and cape to grace my screen!
I still don't know how I feel about Prime being apparently canon to the games, I think I'd prefer for it to be its own thing but I'm absolutely a fan of IDW being canon! It means it's possible we can see all the characters from the comics appear in the games and thinking about that is just amazing.
what the sonic series needs is some sort of production bible: captures key story and design IP elements, rules of engagement, functionality and technical issues across multiple platforms, and an overview of the business/marketing plan. They sorta have it figured out for the marketing stuff, but with all the weird inconsistent things each game has done i really hope they find a way to make it somewhat coherent. give me back my blown-up moon in half from SA2 lmao
@@emperortoho I understand your point, however the character trait of him sparing people has always been consistent. Chaos, Merlina, Shadow, Blaze, Sage, Etc. There was no point (within the main series of games) that Sonic didn't spare someone who could have been reasoned with. Yes I understand that different eras had different takes, however Sonic is still Sonic. A person who values freedom, who's passionate about adventure, too cool to be oppressed or pressured. Has a sense of justice and stands up for those who can't. Stands for what's right. Likes to rest and take things at his own pace. Those are consistent traits, no matter what era. That's what makes Sonic, Sonic. If you fail to notice this, I think you are confused on what Sonic is about, and thus perceive him differently. I think people lose that understanding. I think different eras express it differently. I agree. But it's still there. I respect your opinion.
@@emperortoho Ooh I see. I didn't mean to come off as arrogant. I know people understand the heart of his character besides me. Tons of fans do. I'm just saying that it's clear to me, that many people don't. Twitter has shown me that a lot of fans have a fantasized understanding of Sonic's character rather than what he actually is. To mold him into the image they want. Slightly or even drastic. Just my opinion from what I've seen.
Most of the people you mentioned sonic spared can't be seen as evil, just misguided or are not inherently malicious. I do hear that chaos is dead though. Sonic neuralized him but apparently killed him in the process. Hence, why he just floats off with tikal at the end of the game.
So from what I’ve read, they are cannon but take place in different times. Hence why sonics personality contradicts other versions, because he grew up and his personality changed as well as his outlooks on things.
The best thing about this for me is that we finally got a character that is able to connect with Omega because Belle is canon now. I always felt like Omega was such a "solitary" character conceptually, with really the only other badnik betraying Eggman being Gamma (and we all know how he turned out) so with Belle being in the picture, we might be able to get some character development for Omega. ALSO HOLY SHIT IF SONIC TEAM MAKES A GAME ABOUT IDW I HOPE ITS WITH THE SURGE AND KIT ARC BECAUSE HOLY FUCK A PLAYABLE VERSION OF THE EGG EMPEROR AND SUPER EGGROBO MECH BATTLE WOULD GO SO FUCKING HARD LIKE I'M FUCKIN DROOLING JUST IMAGINING IT
To be honest it would be so cool to see the cast of IDW in the games as integral parts to the plot and maybe even playable if they go that route, they all have very distinct personalities and motives and i think they’d work perfectly in the games, feeling fresh to see a whole new cast, while still maintaining reasons to read the comics if you’re interested in seeing more of them
I'd love to see an adaptation of Surge and Kit's story in the games. Of course, that would mean introducing them as if Sonic and friends never met them before (not just imply the IDW story happened and them appearing in-game is a follow-up), so we can get the full emotional baggage.
My only worry about this is that new fans are going to find it hard to catch up not only to a full series worth of game lore, but now comics lore as well. That's going to be daunting to a lot of people, and I can only hope it doesn't push people away from the series
IDW integration is fascinating to me, largely because we have no clue what Sega of Japan thinks of any of this. Like yes, IDW characters are name dropped in Frontiers, but that’s all they are. Little Easter Eggs for fans. Only Sega of America employees and contractors have mentioned IDW’s ‘canonicity’ and outside some covers done for IDW, I haven’t seen IDW characters mentioned on the Japanese Twitter or Sonic Channel. So, to me, this feels like Sega of America keeping IDW relevant while Sega of Japan just keeps doing there own thing. But we’ll see, I mean, I’d love to see Surge or Tangle appear in a mainline game! Heck, I didn’t even know Surge was gonna be in Speed Battle, that owns!
I just wanna know who I gotta convince so the Archie characters can finally be apart of the modern franchise. They’ve been giving a lot of past characters new life, I’d love to see that for the Freedom Fighters. Also speaking of, I think you should get on Archie too
5:05 If you apply that when looking through Forces' story, Infinite is probably one of the villains that Sonic doesn't see any hope and expressed the closest thing to wanting him DEAD, as seen in their dialogue at the start of the final Infinite fight, the one where Infinite taunts him with an epitaph.
I'm down for IDW being canon (especially Whisper, Surge and Kit) but there is a piece of me that wishes they could salvage the original freedom fighters from Archie (most likely will never happen and I'm counting the cameos in Sonic Spinball). I really miss Bunnie Rabbot.
I haven't read any of the IDW comics but I've heard many good things about them. I do hope these do get adapted into games in the future especially since, as you've said, many people who are into Sonic do not read the comics and a lot probably don't even know they exist unfortunately.
I binged IDW in June '22 and I loved 'em (especially Whisper who has become my all-time second favorite character (Tails is first btw)). I had a good feeling they were canon, especially with Flynn at the helm in Frontiers. I want to see Whisper make a game appearance very much, especially a playable one. Overall, this is exactly what I wanted and I hope it gets acknowledged in the games. One downside (or upside, depending on how you see it) though: If Tangle, Whisper, etc made in game appearances, that would remove some amount of suspense since we would know they won't die.
I don't care if one or two IDW comics storyline are shown in the next Sonic game. I also wanna see Dr. Starline introduced as another Sonic villain. While Dr. Eggman aka Robotnik is the mainstay. It wouldn't hurt to change up the story and have those two work together for a time then have a falling out. Both would go their separate ways.
The only reason I'd want them to adapt the metal virus arc is to handle Shadow better, since I'm one of the many people that feel like he was done extremely dirty in that arc. I don't have a problem with the comic being canon, but I do think for those that aren't reading the comic its better to keep it as mostly references to not have people be completely lost on any of these things being included into the games out of nowhere.
I think they should be seperate. But i'd love an ideal where a game would have references, either in the world [posters, npcs talking] or through Cameos [tangle swinging around in the distance, etc] or Sonic referencing idw events, like the zombots or Neo Metal's return. And the references shouldn't be too on the nose. If you spot it and you know, then you know.
I think comics should be unlockable in later games so people who only buy games will have a chance to read them. Not the most recent issues, but some story arcs that are relevant to this specific games' events.
I think something they could do is if they want to use a character like whisper or surge or whatever, just have them in the story with maybe a brief dialog explaining who they are. Lots of modern games include lore logs or recaps to help new players, they could just include an older issue or two that explains the character or the comic that links into the games story. That way we don't have to retread comic arcs in game form or make weird lore problems where we have to pretend these characters are new. That said game adaptations of comic arcs would be a good idea too!
I'm honestly glad that IDW is canon because its the only other piece of Sonic media that fits in well in the main canon compared to Archie, the 90's Sonic cartoons, X, ect
All this means, to me, is that we’ll probably see characters from the comics in the games. Eventually, Tangle, Whisper and others will be in the main games rather than mobile spin-offs.
As someone who always assumed they were canon anyway since they pretty much Continued from Forces and just take place between the game adventures. so i guess it's nice to have confirmation.
@@reggielacey2235they (as of the IDW comics) still were always canon, most especially since it’s after the events of Forces, while having some during the events of Forces as flashbacks.
My main hope with this is that we get to see the new characters in the games, even if they’re just in spin-offs like TSR (even if that game sucked in terms of its roster), but preferably in the main series
Back in 2017 when SEGA announce that they will make a new Sonic comic series and it said that it will places after Forces, i immediately know that it will be canon to the Sonic Video Game Universe.
In my opinion I feel like these Comics should be adapted as a TV show it would make more sense like in Japan when animation companies adapt manga into anime.
Sonic Canon Material Sonic Prime Sonic IDW Comics Sticks the Badger Sonic StoryBook games Sonic Riders games Sonic 06 (Due to Time Eater restoring half of 06) Sonic 4 & 4 Ep:2 Sonic at the Olympic Games Tokyo 2020 (Mobile game) Sonic Channel art & Comics
Considering Sonic mentions Tangle by name in sonic Frontiers id very much believe so that IDW is canon and that makes me happy Seeing people get bent out of shape and genuinely upset by it being canon is really weird
Tbh I still think they need to fully map out what’s truly “canon” in Sonic or even what that means. We know due to the tailstube Classic Sonic after gens is a separate timeline so we this and the Sonic Twitter saying everything is canon leads me to believe there are multiple different timelines and universes with everything being canon in the sonic multiverse. So maybe IDW is just simply a different split timeline just like Classic Sonic, but again Sega really needs to layout an official Sonic timeline to make things more sense.
Ironic how Sonic Forces was received poorly by fans and critics alike. Yet the new comic series that takes place after the events of Forces, was liked by many people. I’d love to see the characters from the comics show up, it’d be interesting, seeing how Sage and others would interact with characters like Whisper or Mimic.
I don't think eggman should get as dark as he does in the comic because it becomes too hard to justify sonic continuing to let him live, and shadow even berates him for it saying he'll do it himself if sonic won't. The only thing that saved eggman there was that he lost his memory and became super nice. But an excuse like that can't be used again. But there's a balance to make him not too nice either, like in the boom series show where you just want them to hug and be friends and work together instead. Like imagine what tails and eggman could achieve together. And eggman finally gets to build a cool theme park if his dreams after all these years cuz there's room to compromise. Etc
Agreed, if the Metal Virus is canon to the games, then that means game Eggman deserves to be SHOT. If there's one thing I don't like about Ian Flynn, it's how he writes Eggman, which is basically Archie Robotnik in Eggman's body.
And also in Frontiers amy mentioned Stick. But in all idw comic i read i never even see Stick in any of the comic even in the background, so where is she 😕
According to Ken Penders the settlement for the Archie comics could've been settled for like $2 but he has a tendency to stretch the truth. EIther way while it is sad that we're probably not going to see the return of the Archie character (although I hope SEGA really does bring them back), it's nice to at least have Ian Flynn be able to write for Sonic and ensure that the characters don't get bad interpretations of themselves
And to get rid of doubt about some characters not being a thing (cause I had to deal with someone saying something like that) having Sonic know Tangle basically indirectly confirms all the other major IDW characters, with Tangle comes Whisper and Jewel, and probably Belle, and with Whisper comes Mimic, and with Belle we get Starline and Surge and Kit
I hope they do what Archie was doing at the end. Where they adapt the games to the comics (and maybe vice versa would be nice too). But I would love frontiers in the comics.
My personal opinion, I'm happy they're canon BUT I think they should've gone a super safe route where IDW is it's own timeline/canon. That way they can safely introduce the comic characters in Sonic Games for the first time as new characters and build their relationships from there. IDW will also be able to do whatever story they want without tying into the games.
I remember, I mentioned the IDW comics being canon, and then somebody told me they’re not all that happened after frontiers, and after the confirmation
Ah, ok so I'm not fully caught up but I've read a bit of IDW and heard things about it. I think honestly introducing the characters in the game now would be difficult from a narrative standpoint because the characters know who they are but the average consumer does not so you would have to account for that. It's not like it's a deal-breaker but I figure the best way to do that is Sonic Heroes 2. Now I just came up with that out of nowhere but honestly I think that's fair. Have three of the new characters be their own team and you can hear more about them there. I'm not too sure about Surge and Kit but also I haven't gotten past chapter 50 so I'll get to it soon I suppose.
It's amazing to know IDW is canon now. Imagine if we get a spinoff title with a Sonic Heroes style game that you get to play as the Diamond Cutters? The possibilities are now open thanks to this revelation.
It's not so much the characters being introduced for me. It's the world inconsistencies. The comics and games desperately need to explain the disparities between different parts of the world. Where was GUN during Forces? Why is the technology of the cities we see in the Sonic Riders games so vastly futuristic compared to others, and why isn't that tech used in other parts of the world? If the Chaos Emeralds are tied to Dark and Light Gaia who have been in a constant cyclical battle since the beginning of time, how did the Ancients get their hands on them in the first place? Things like this can't (and shouldn't) just be swept under the rug if they're trying to make all of it canon.
My concern about them making IDW Sonic canon with the games is, do I need to read the comics to understand any future Sonic game? Also another thing is, if characters in Sonic IDW are also now canon and they exist in the Sonic games universe that raises the question of where were they during the events of Forces along with other games before Forces? Ugh, Sega just had to make something great feel overwhelming to understand. Is this a bad habit of theirs or something? 🙄
honest talk If this becomes canon It also shows that in the world of Sonic, a dangerous person at the same level as Eggman is now released. Sonic and friends can fight other than Sonic Although it could be deployed for their spin-off
Tangle not being in the JP script nullifies any meaning this can have. (Yes I know Ian wrote the script, but JP came up with the base idea...so Sonic is still originating from there even if they are trying to americanize it more now) If you can't even mention the name of an IDW character...there's no way that said character will actually be in any future game... This is simply a case of the comics adhereing to the canon of the games but not the other way around. Similar to Prime...its a marketing stunt cause your better off saying your side project is "just as legit as the main stuff" if you can get away with it. A while ago I refined on a google doc every possible way the sonic games could take place in for fun (weird...I know)...what I took away from it after self reflecting on it was how little any of it mattered...but more than that it gave me perspective on what people actually mean when they say "canon"... Without realizing it...people use canon to essentially mean "what matters in the franchise in the current moment?" (examples: "SR is canon cause it was referenced in Gens" "The Super Emeralds aren't canon cause -they aren't used anymore- izuka said they aren't") We all know there's much more to stories than just a literal series of events...but the reason that gets reiterated so much is because "a literal series of events" is the easiest way to contextualize things. A franchise...therefore...builds upon what's been set up by focusing on different things with each iteration. Hence the "canon" is what matters to the ongoing development. Its the life blood of what current people will default to when they think of "X franchise". Its also the most shallow way of engaging with a franchise...as is usually the case with earlier instalments...they tried to tell a story on their own completely independant of future instalments...fixating too much on the details of the whole becomes problematic when you realize there was no whole to begin with...its an illusion...the reason any thing changes with Sonic is cause Sega chooses to change it based on what they think is best...that's literately it. (all this...admitedly...can just be summed up as "don't fixate on canon" lol) If you do insist on using the word canon when discussing sonic stories...I'd advise using "alternate canon" or "this game is canon to this other game" ect. Discussing stories and discussing authorial intent are 2 very different things. Do not conflate them...especially when talking about new stories made by different people with different views on things. Until JP Sonic Team decide to actively take more inspiration from other Sonic media sources...the games will remain their own continuity while the rest of the medias will take inspiration from them...loosely or otherwise. What's most important in a story is often debated, but it usually ends up agreeing to some form of "narrative consistency". Its only natural then, that the branch of media that is the most isolated and primal (in this case originating most original sonic ideas) will be what most people consider "canon" overall to the series/franchise...
@@GamesCage To further clarify Sticks was kept in the JP script while Tangle wasn't...which is kinda funny to think about lol (mainly cause Sticks was designed by Sonic Team I guess)
@@Alienrunokay that Just isn't true. Its actually reversed the Sticks mention was removed (as Amys whole Line was rewritten) The Tangel mention meanwhile is still in the JP Version. This is because the field dialouge wasn't translated by Kishimoto himself and instead by some one that made littel to no changes to Ian's skript. By the way I am someone that dislikes that the Comics are now Canon.
@@rynobehnke8289 If this is true then that changes things a lot. I swore I heard the opposite on 2 occasions and it made sense to me at the time. How did you know about the field dialoug thing if I may ask? Where can I find more info like this?
Wait, idw was cannon? I always assumed it was cannon from the get go, after all wasnt it implied the metal virus saga takes place soon after the events of forces?
something i love about the idw cast is that i always felt like they were built with gameplay styles in mind. tangle has her tail, whisper has her wispon, lanolin has her bell, surge/kit have their powers etc.
their gameplay styles are already there, hoping to see them pop up in new games/spinoffs
Hell yes
I think that Tangle and Whisper in particular are stand-ins for the Avatar in Frontiers, with Tangle representing the grappling hook and Whisper representing the weapons.
Yep
@@jacks1368 you meant Forces, right?
@@eleksitia Yes.
I had a good feeling the Idw were canon it’s always good hearing more confirmation on it being canon bc one day we might get to see characters like Tangle, Whisper, and Surge in future. Like there is so much platforming potential with Tangle
Frontiers mentions it
And a shooting game starring Whisper, Shadow and Eggman
And maybe Tails
Bro, Scrapnik Mecha Sonic, Knuckles and Sigma?
I honstley find idw being canon more logical than Prime being canon considering how Sonic was portrayed in the show
AGREE LOL
Sonic Prime being canon is BS, like apart of how Sonic acts in that show, since when does Rouge hang out with Sonic & friends?
@@cnk9822 To be fair, the series also takes that as a strange thing in the first chapter
There are two possibilities: Either A) Sonic Prime takes place in a branch reality, or B) Given the general characterization of our heroes, it could take place in the fairly sizable gap between Lost World and Forces/
@@andrewhall6479 The Show *IS* About Alternative Universes After All....
I think it's cool that IDW is confirmed to be canon to the games. It definitely helps to expand the world of Sonic in between mainline titles while also giving spotlight to characters who might not make an appearance in a future game. I would love to see some of the IDW stories get adapted into games like Battle of Angel Island, Metal Virus, and Imposter Syndrome. I feel like those three specifically leave a lot of room to make a whole game out of, mainly the first two arcs though since they go hand in hand with each other. Adapting Battle of Angel Island first also has the benefit of making it clear to casuals and game only fans that Sonic met characters like Tangle and Whisper after Forces, but before Frontiers' events.
YESSSSSS
I think a healthy way to handle it is for the games to feed the comic with the world and location that way the world doesn't feel empty and for the comics to feed the games with character growth and developments that way we can't have something like the meta Era where every character felt washed out
Right…
A game staring the metal virus would honestly be hype af🔥
MHM
FR
Facts
Goated comment
Would probably be too dark ngl
As long as I see Sonic Rush 3, where you play as Surge, Blaze, and Sonic, then I'm all game for the IDW comics to be canon.
Imagine how sick a Frontiers-style open zone Sonic game based on the post-Forces and Metal Overlord arcs of IDW would be. It'd be awesome getting to explore a huge world and save the different cities from the Badniks while also getting to team up with Tails, Amy, Knuckles, Blaze, Tangle, Silver, and Whisper. They could even do a whole Team Attack mechanic similar to Hi Fi Rush or something!
WOULD BE FIRE
With the rumour there may be a Sonic Heroes Remaster/Remake, due to the Tails Tube imagery that was glitching, would be nice to fit in an extended, sequel to the Metal Overlord Arc as Heroes 2. The plot is more or less the same, throws new comers that were not around at the time such as Silver, Blaze, Tangle and Whisper, though maybe it could use some tinkering so it is not just a copy and paste of Heroes 1. More than anything, though, would love an open world Metal Virus game.
And sally i hope
I think it would be smart if they were to introduce idw characters in a game, that game would have a museum like generations with descriptions of these characters and their debuts just to catch people up just so it wouldn’t seem so unnatural for sonic to just all of a sudden have a new friend
Agreeed
Sonic does mention tangle In frontiers
This means the following are canon:
•Amy's characterization, development, and bonding moments with Sonic
•Knuckles' heart to heart story about what it means to be a guardian
•Tails' 30 anniversary
•Surge, Kit, Tangle, Whisper, Lanolin, etc
@@emperortoho IDW Shadow kind of redeemed himself in the most recent issue. Bro teleported an entire city to space and pretty much saved everyone, all without acting like a knock off Vegeta.
@@emperortoho Lmao when you put it like that….
And Belle, who STILL hasn't apologized to Sonic and Tails for almost getting them killed by repairing Metal Sonic, and Eggman being Final Fantasy villain levels of evil and the Metal Virus and Sonic gaslighting Shadow and Espio and Sonic and Tails being responsible for Eggman's return and Sonic's self-righteous speech to Surge AND Sonic ...putting his foot up against Surge's butt. >_
@@emperortoho Hey, at least he wasn't in almost every issue like Sonic was. Shadow only appeared in like 13 issues before the most recent arc, not counting his time as a Zombot. We had to see a WHOLE lot more of Sonic being unlikable.
Imagine having a system where the comics are like the manga where their plot points and story are already settled and done with and the games are like the anime where they animate and incorporate the plot points and moments in the comics into the gameplay. It would be interesting to see where this could go.
Honestly, I REALLY like the new characters introduced in IDW. They’re all such great additions to this world and I’d love to play as them sometime.
In terms of introducing them, I wouldn’t mind if they don’t explain their backstory, they just need to have great introductions in the games, while being consistent with their writing in the comics.
I’m not a fan of adapting stories FROM the comics per se, I’d just like to see what new stuff they’d get up to in the game’s on stories.
LET THEM IN
Marvel games do it all the time
I think the best thing for them to do is have both the comic team and Sonic Team directly collaberating with each other characters and ideas that they can bith use but can keep the ongoing stories in both games seperate while having all the characters showing up and being canon
I'm really happy with what the comics have been doing. I love the way the characters are written in them and It also makes me happy to know that the comic characters exist in the game universe. I would be over the moon to see a game based on the metal virus saga. Also seeing the comic characters in the games fully fleshed out would be sick, there's so much potential!
This definitely has a lot of potential. Especially for gameplay, imagine swinging around like spider man as tangle.
So glad IDW’s canon!! Having any of the gang from idw in the games would be so cool!
AGREE
One thing they could maybe add is they could have collectibles in a future game where getting them unlocks comic issues of IDW you could read in an extras menu.
OH YEA
I'd rather it be like how Archie and the games were. Exist separately but have the same characters. It's neat that the idw is cannon but like you said it is asking a lot to have fans invest in a ongoing comic series where things can get murky when you try to put a timeline of events and such. As neat as having the metal virus be a game id rather the stick to original stories for the time being. Ultimately I'll appreciate this idw cannon more when these characters ACTUALLY appear in these mainline games that aren't spinoff like in forces speed battle having tangle and whisper in them.
This is it, I don't like the idea of having to read the comics to understand the games
I also don’t like the idea of having to read the comics in order to understand the story of the games moving forward. I shouldn’t have to go looking into an external source just to understand the whole plot and the sudden appearance of the new characters, that’s just bad writing/storytelling.
I agree. I don't like IDW, which already adds to me not wanting it to be canon, but also it's true that I shouldn't have to read a comic to enjoy the games.
@@Probably_CLOUD fr making it that a casual has to read the comics to understand why random new characters just appeared and seem to know the rest of the cast is poor decision making especially since the comics are a 6/10 at best and not everyone will want to read them
@@bowserbreaker2515 bro is exactly me
As I've said: I'm conflicted.
A. it's cool they're expanding the sonic universe with these existing characters and stories
B. You can tell this wasn't 100% thought-out and it looks like it was originally intended to REMAIN it's own continuity and they definitely retroactively decided to put them into the canon. I think it might be too late to rework an Comic arc into it's own game. Something I think could work if they were to introduce them in a game, is by adding character bios (sort of like Generations) and preferably introducing them early on, if not immediately in the story.
I am once again asking for a new Sonic Fighters game which has both game and comic characters. I want Whisper to fight Infinite, I want Kit to tussle with Chaos, I want Classic Sonic to fight Shadow.
I love that the comics are canon to the games, it just makes the franchise as a whole seem more cohesive and united. Yeah, it might be difficult to introduce the IDW cast into the games, but I feel like the Open Zone format will be a good way to do so if the 3rd Update for Frontiers does super well. The next game could have an overall plot, but each area could have their own mini plot that focuses on or features specific characters.
Like, Central City could have the Chaotix dealing with Clutch, Rough and Tumble while Sonic's doing his thing; heck, maybe they could be running the Black Market and take Big's shop role. Surge and Kit could be causing havoc somewhere and trying to lure out and destroy Sonic and Tails as optional reoccurring boss fights. Tangle, Whisper, and Lanolin could be scoping out an Eggman base.
All you'd need is a database or repository that you can use to get the gist of the characters. Like what Ratchet and Clank: Rift Apart did.
Heck, maybe spin-off games could be a good way to easily introduce IDW characters into the games. Maybe they can reuse the Sonic Chronicles title as a sub-series to use side characters. Like Sonic Heroes style ones for the Chaotix and Diamond Cutters. Or Sonic Rush style ones focusing on confrontations between Sonic and Surge and Tails' Adventure style ones for confrontations between Tails and Kit.
There's a lot that can be done here.
I always knew the comics were canon
They’re just slowly building up to the events of Sonic frontiers
Eh…. I’m still on the fence about it being canon. I’m still convinced Ian just snuck those lines into Frontiers as easter eggs. More likely, I think the plan will be to introduce the IDW characters into the mainline games with new storylines, since the fans like the IDW characters.
MAYBE they adapt the IDW arcs into games, which I would like, but I’ll hold my breath on the canonicity of the comics until they are more explicitly mentioned in the games.
If IDW is canon, I want I TOTALLY WANT to see Scrapnik Island Mecha Sonic to be in a game. I want to see that sweet cute protective angstylord with his cool redemption arc and cape to grace my screen!
I still don't know how I feel about Prime being apparently canon to the games, I think I'd prefer for it to be its own thing but I'm absolutely a fan of IDW being canon! It means it's possible we can see all the characters from the comics appear in the games and thinking about that is just amazing.
I really think Kitsunami's abilities would be pretty cool in a Sonic game, working kinda like Super Mario Sunshine.
Starline isn't a duck he is a platapuy like Parry.
what the sonic series needs is some sort of production bible: captures key story and design IP elements, rules of engagement, functionality and technical issues across multiple platforms, and an overview of the business/marketing plan. They sorta have it figured out for the marketing stuff, but with all the weird inconsistent things each game has done i really hope they find a way to make it somewhat coherent. give me back my blown-up moon in half from SA2 lmao
Agree LOL
You got your wish for the moon🫡
Bro the amount of games they could make with concepts from the idw comics will go super hard
10:55 gemerl does not come from idw it comes from Sonic advance 3
Sorry if I make mistakes in English I'm bad
No worries LOL
I'm pretty hyped that IDW is canon. Means Mecha finally got a good ending
Ian also wrote a large amount of the Archie books, man just gets Sonic
I think Sonic is very consistently written in IDW in regards to sparing enemies with hope. I think fans don't know Sonic like they think they do.
@@emperortoho I understand your point, however the character trait of him sparing people has always been consistent. Chaos, Merlina, Shadow, Blaze, Sage, Etc. There was no point (within the main series of games) that Sonic didn't spare someone who could have been reasoned with. Yes I understand that different eras had different takes, however Sonic is still Sonic. A person who values freedom, who's passionate about adventure, too cool to be oppressed or pressured. Has a sense of justice and stands up for those who can't. Stands for what's right. Likes to rest and take things at his own pace. Those are consistent traits, no matter what era. That's what makes Sonic, Sonic. If you fail to notice this, I think you are confused on what Sonic is about, and thus perceive him differently. I think people lose that understanding. I think different eras express it differently. I agree. But it's still there. I respect your opinion.
@@misterholmes221which brings back to the whole "fans don't get Sonic" argument it sounds too absolute and dismissive
@@infern209x I'm not offended at all. Just stating what I think it looks like.
@@emperortoho Ooh I see. I didn't mean to come off as arrogant. I know people understand the heart of his character besides me. Tons of fans do. I'm just saying that it's clear to me, that many people don't. Twitter has shown me that a lot of fans have a fantasized understanding of Sonic's character rather than what he actually is. To mold him into the image they want. Slightly or even drastic. Just my opinion from what I've seen.
Most of the people you mentioned sonic spared can't be seen as evil, just misguided or are not inherently malicious.
I do hear that chaos is dead though. Sonic neuralized him but apparently killed him in the process. Hence, why he just floats off with tikal at the end of the game.
So from what I’ve read, they are cannon but take place in different times. Hence why sonics personality contradicts other versions, because he grew up and his personality changed as well as his outlooks on things.
The best thing about this for me is that we finally got a character that is able to connect with Omega because Belle is canon now. I always felt like Omega was such a "solitary" character conceptually, with really the only other badnik betraying Eggman being Gamma (and we all know how he turned out) so with Belle being in the picture, we might be able to get some character development for Omega.
ALSO HOLY SHIT IF SONIC TEAM MAKES A GAME ABOUT IDW I HOPE ITS WITH THE SURGE AND KIT ARC BECAUSE HOLY FUCK A PLAYABLE VERSION OF THE EGG EMPEROR AND SUPER EGGROBO MECH BATTLE WOULD GO SO FUCKING HARD LIKE I'M FUCKIN DROOLING JUST IMAGINING IT
To be honest it would be so cool to see the cast of IDW in the games as integral parts to the plot and maybe even playable if they go that route, they all have very distinct personalities and motives and i think they’d work perfectly in the games, feeling fresh to see a whole new cast, while still maintaining reasons to read the comics if you’re interested in seeing more of them
Would be FIRE
I'd love to see an adaptation of Surge and Kit's story in the games. Of course, that would mean introducing them as if Sonic and friends never met them before (not just imply the IDW story happened and them appearing in-game is a follow-up), so we can get the full emotional baggage.
My only worry about this is that new fans are going to find it hard to catch up not only to a full series worth of game lore, but now comics lore as well. That's going to be daunting to a lot of people, and I can only hope it doesn't push people away from the series
Yea I DONT think they’d convolute it
IDW integration is fascinating to me, largely because we have no clue what Sega of Japan thinks of any of this. Like yes, IDW characters are name dropped in Frontiers, but that’s all they are. Little Easter Eggs for fans. Only Sega of America employees and contractors have mentioned IDW’s ‘canonicity’ and outside some covers done for IDW, I haven’t seen IDW characters mentioned on the Japanese Twitter or Sonic Channel. So, to me, this feels like Sega of America keeping IDW relevant while Sega of Japan just keeps doing there own thing. But we’ll see, I mean, I’d love to see Surge or Tangle appear in a mainline game! Heck, I didn’t even know Surge was gonna be in Speed Battle, that owns!
MHMMMM
I just wanna know who I gotta convince so the Archie characters can finally be apart of the modern franchise. They’ve been giving a lot of past characters new life, I’d love to see that for the Freedom Fighters.
Also speaking of, I think you should get on Archie too
5:05 If you apply that when looking through Forces' story, Infinite is probably one of the villains that Sonic doesn't see any hope and expressed the closest thing to wanting him DEAD, as seen in their dialogue at the start of the final Infinite fight, the one where Infinite taunts him with an epitaph.
Everyone forgot shadow writing
You can't tell me the same Sonic who Was scared of fodder motobugs is the same one who was willing to Die fighting the titans
MHM LOL
I just hope that this doesn’t cause any continuity errors in the games.
It probably will
I'm down for IDW being canon (especially Whisper, Surge and Kit) but there is a piece of me that wishes they could salvage the original freedom fighters from Archie (most likely will never happen and I'm counting the cameos in Sonic Spinball). I really miss Bunnie Rabbot.
I've seen mentions of the idw comic team trying to convince sega to bring back some of them but it's definitely a bit of a long shot
I haven't read any of the IDW comics but I've heard many good things about them. I do hope these do get adapted into games in the future especially since, as you've said, many people who are into Sonic do not read the comics and a lot probably don't even know they exist unfortunately.
I hope they make a sonic manga
I binged IDW in June '22 and I loved 'em (especially Whisper who has become my all-time second favorite character (Tails is first btw)). I had a good feeling they were canon, especially with Flynn at the helm in Frontiers. I want to see Whisper make a game appearance very much, especially a playable one. Overall, this is exactly what I wanted and I hope it gets acknowledged in the games.
One downside (or upside, depending on how you see it) though: If Tangle, Whisper, etc made in game appearances, that would remove some amount of suspense since we would know they won't die.
THATS TRUE
I don't care if one or two IDW comics storyline are shown in the next Sonic game. I also wanna see Dr. Starline introduced as another Sonic villain. While Dr. Eggman aka Robotnik is the mainstay. It wouldn't hurt to change up the story and have those two work together for a time then have a falling out. Both would go their separate ways.
The only reason I'd want them to adapt the metal virus arc is to handle Shadow better, since I'm one of the many people that feel like he was done extremely dirty in that arc. I don't have a problem with the comic being canon, but I do think for those that aren't reading the comic its better to keep it as mostly references to not have people be completely lost on any of these things being included into the games out of nowhere.
I think they should be seperate.
But i'd love an ideal where a game would have references, either in the world [posters, npcs talking] or through Cameos [tangle swinging around in the distance, etc] or Sonic referencing idw events, like the zombots or Neo Metal's return.
And the references shouldn't be too on the nose. If you spot it and you know, then you know.
I think comics should be unlockable in later games so people who only buy games will have a chance to read them. Not the most recent issues, but some story arcs that are relevant to this specific games' events.
L TAKE ON THE SEPARATION
I think something they could do is if they want to use a character like whisper or surge or whatever, just have them in the story with maybe a brief dialog explaining who they are. Lots of modern games include lore logs or recaps to help new players, they could just include an older issue or two that explains the character or the comic that links into the games story. That way we don't have to retread comic arcs in game form or make weird lore problems where we have to pretend these characters are new. That said game adaptations of comic arcs would be a good idea too!
5:35 I agree with all characters as well
I'm honestly glad that IDW is canon because its the only other piece of Sonic media that fits in well in the main canon compared to Archie, the 90's Sonic cartoons, X, ect
All this means, to me, is that we’ll probably see characters from the comics in the games. Eventually, Tangle, Whisper and others will be in the main games rather than mobile spin-offs.
As someone who always assumed they were canon anyway since they pretty much Continued from Forces and just take place between the game adventures. so i guess it's nice to have confirmation.
@@reggielacey2235they (as of the IDW comics) still were always canon, most especially since it’s after the events of Forces, while having some during the events of Forces as flashbacks.
10:55 Bro though we wouldn't notice Gemerl. 🗿
I wish we could get an anime adaptation for the IDW comics. We haven't had a Sonic anime since Sonic X.
OH YES
@@infern209xyeah it’s possible to have an anime tho
an anime adaptation would actually be a great idea, could appeal a bit more to the japanese audience who might not find the american comics accessible
As a metal sonic fan... this is a big BIG win for me
W W W W
id love to see a sonic adventure 3 style where you have sonic, shadow, and surge as different stories, tho thats a REALLY big ask
My main hope with this is that we get to see the new characters in the games, even if they’re just in spin-offs like TSR (even if that game sucked in terms of its roster), but preferably in the main series
Maybe the IDW can be introduced in a new racing game's story mode.
Back in 2017 when SEGA announce that they will make a new Sonic comic series and it said that it will places after Forces, i immediately know that it will be canon to the Sonic Video Game Universe.
In my opinion I feel like these Comics should be adapted as a TV show it would make more sense like in Japan
when animation companies adapt manga into anime.
OH THAT COULD BE SICK
I'd love to see them do something with the Metal Virus arc in the games.
Sonic Canon Material
Sonic Prime
Sonic IDW Comics
Sticks the Badger
Sonic StoryBook games
Sonic Riders games
Sonic 06 (Due to Time Eater restoring half of 06)
Sonic 4 & 4 Ep:2
Sonic at the Olympic Games Tokyo 2020 (Mobile game)
Sonic Channel art & Comics
Just hearing Sonic Rider being Canon now ,make me extremely happy
Considering Sonic mentions Tangle by name in sonic Frontiers id very much believe so that IDW is canon and that makes me happy
Seeing people get bent out of shape and genuinely upset by it being canon is really weird
Can you imagine the Metal Virus arc in the video games? That would be insane! My favorite arc by far
BROO, I HOPE THAT WE'LL GET THE IDW CHARACTERS IN THE GAMES (LIKE WHISPER AND TANGLE) !!!
I wonder if we'll get any of the IDW sonic characters in the sonic games
Tbh I still think they need to fully map out what’s truly “canon” in Sonic or even what that means. We know due to the tailstube Classic Sonic after gens is a separate timeline so we this and the Sonic Twitter saying everything is canon leads me to believe there are multiple different timelines and universes with everything being canon in the sonic multiverse. So maybe IDW is just simply a different split timeline just like Classic Sonic, but again Sega really needs to layout an official Sonic timeline to make things more sense.
Agree
BRO I ASKED THEM IF SONIC IS REAL
THEY SAID YES!! WHY IS NOBODY TALKING ABOUT THIS
LMAO
Ironic how Sonic Forces was received poorly by fans and critics alike. Yet the new comic series that takes place after the events of Forces, was liked by many people. I’d love to see the characters from the comics show up, it’d be interesting, seeing how Sage and others would interact with characters like Whisper or Mimic.
I adote that IDW is canon it's the only comic I actively follow anymore, the gremlin inside of me wants almost every arc to become an actual game.
Who’s the artist of that Amy print in the background on Fadel’s wall
I don't think eggman should get as dark as he does in the comic because it becomes too hard to justify sonic continuing to let him live, and shadow even berates him for it saying he'll do it himself if sonic won't. The only thing that saved eggman there was that he lost his memory and became super nice. But an excuse like that can't be used again. But there's a balance to make him not too nice either, like in the boom series show where you just want them to hug and be friends and work together instead. Like imagine what tails and eggman could achieve together. And eggman finally gets to build a cool theme park if his dreams after all these years cuz there's room to compromise. Etc
Agreed, if the Metal Virus is canon to the games, then that means game Eggman deserves to be SHOT. If there's one thing I don't like about Ian Flynn, it's how he writes Eggman, which is basically Archie Robotnik in Eggman's body.
@@videogollumerwhat are you talking about?
@@dark_nightwing_xl2797 What do you mean what am I talking about? What is there to question?
@@emperortoho Tell me about it, though that's probably because Sega had more control over him on that one.
@@emperortoho As in neutral or diabolical?
Woah, is that my goat on my screen??!?
And also in Frontiers amy mentioned Stick. But in all idw comic i read i never even see Stick in any of the comic even in the background, so where is she 😕
According to Ken Penders the settlement for the Archie comics could've been settled for like $2 but he has a tendency to stretch the truth. EIther way while it is sad that we're probably not going to see the return of the Archie character (although I hope SEGA really does bring them back), it's nice to at least have Ian Flynn be able to write for Sonic and ensure that the characters don't get bad interpretations of themselves
Love your videos man keep the good work up
And to get rid of doubt about some characters not being a thing (cause I had to deal with someone saying something like that) having Sonic know Tangle basically indirectly confirms all the other major IDW characters, with Tangle comes Whisper and Jewel, and probably Belle, and with Whisper comes Mimic, and with Belle we get Starline and Surge and Kit
I hope they do what Archie was doing at the end. Where they adapt the games to the comics (and maybe vice versa would be nice too). But I would love frontiers in the comics.
There's no point to
@@SillyTron_ there is a point to. They did it in Archie as a SEGA mandate. It could very easily happen again.
@@shadamyandsonamylover but since IDW is canon to the games, what's the point
@@SillyTron_ to have better art. I do get your point tho. Still, I’d like to see it.
Hence why IDW characters are featured in Speed Battle and Dash. 😎
MHM
My personal opinion, I'm happy they're canon BUT I think they should've gone a super safe route where IDW is it's own timeline/canon. That way they can safely introduce the comic characters in Sonic Games for the first time as new characters and build their relationships from there. IDW will also be able to do whatever story they want without tying into the games.
I remember, I mentioned the IDW comics being canon, and then somebody told me they’re not all that happened after frontiers, and after the confirmation
I have your ID, call that a W-HEY WHAT’S UP EVERYBODY
LMAO
Ah, ok so I'm not fully caught up but I've read a bit of IDW and heard things about it. I think honestly introducing the characters in the game now would be difficult from a narrative standpoint because the characters know who they are but the average consumer does not so you would have to account for that. It's not like it's a deal-breaker but I figure the best way to do that is Sonic Heroes 2. Now I just came up with that out of nowhere but honestly I think that's fair. Have three of the new characters be their own team and you can hear more about them there. I'm not too sure about Surge and Kit but also I haven't gotten past chapter 50 so I'll get to it soon I suppose.
Good to know that Fadel is deep in Sonic ❤
i think that idw sonic takes place before sonic frontiers
Ian Flynn confirmed that the current IDW comics take place in between forces and frontiers and then when Sage appears, it'll be post frontiers
Or they should make a game about the IDW Sonic Comics and about the arcs. Like, The Zombot Arc.
What is that super Sonic poster behind him?
This is how we win Fadel. Cue in SpongeBob's Sweet Victory because its time to CELEBRATE!!!
It's amazing to know IDW is canon now. Imagine if we get a spinoff title with a Sonic Heroes style game that you get to play as the Diamond Cutters? The possibilities are now open thanks to this revelation.
It's not so much the characters being introduced for me. It's the world inconsistencies. The comics and games desperately need to explain the disparities between different parts of the world. Where was GUN during Forces? Why is the technology of the cities we see in the Sonic Riders games so vastly futuristic compared to others, and why isn't that tech used in other parts of the world? If the Chaos Emeralds are tied to Dark and Light Gaia who have been in a constant cyclical battle since the beginning of time, how did the Ancients get their hands on them in the first place? Things like this can't (and shouldn't) just be swept under the rug if they're trying to make all of it canon.
Agreed
My concern about them making IDW Sonic canon with the games is, do I need to read the comics to understand any future Sonic game? Also another thing is, if characters in Sonic IDW are also now canon and they exist in the Sonic games universe that raises the question of where were they during the events of Forces along with other games before Forces? Ugh, Sega just had to make something great feel overwhelming to understand. Is this a bad habit of theirs or something? 🙄
imagine them doing a game going over the metal virus arc
or even going over surge's arc
it would be peak ngl..
Y'know who I'd love to see get an appearance in the games? *Rough & Tumble!* I love those two idiots so much.
HELL YEA
Hey, here's a question: What role do the Rings play in IDW?
Rings are mainly a game mechanic
honest talk If this becomes canon It also shows that in the world of Sonic, a dangerous person at the same level as Eggman is now released. Sonic and friends can fight other than Sonic Although it could be deployed for their spin-off
Tangle not being in the JP script nullifies any meaning this can have. (Yes I know Ian wrote the script, but JP came up with the base idea...so Sonic is still originating from there even if they are trying to americanize it more now) If you can't even mention the name of an IDW character...there's no way that said character will actually be in any future game...
This is simply a case of the comics adhereing to the canon of the games but not the other way around. Similar to Prime...its a marketing stunt cause your better off saying your side project is "just as legit as the main stuff" if you can get away with it.
A while ago I refined on a google doc every possible way the sonic games could take place in for fun (weird...I know)...what I took away from it after self reflecting on it was how little any of it mattered...but more than that it gave me perspective on what people actually mean when they say "canon"...
Without realizing it...people use canon to essentially mean "what matters in the franchise in the current moment?" (examples: "SR is canon cause it was referenced in Gens" "The Super Emeralds aren't canon cause -they aren't used anymore- izuka said they aren't") We all know there's much more to stories than just a literal series of events...but the reason that gets reiterated so much is because "a literal series of events" is the easiest way to contextualize things. A franchise...therefore...builds upon what's been set up by focusing on different things with each iteration. Hence the "canon" is what matters to the ongoing development. Its the life blood of what current people will default to when they think of "X franchise".
Its also the most shallow way of engaging with a franchise...as is usually the case with earlier instalments...they tried to tell a story on their own completely independant of future instalments...fixating too much on the details of the whole becomes problematic when you realize there was no whole to begin with...its an illusion...the reason any thing changes with Sonic is cause Sega chooses to change it based on what they think is best...that's literately it. (all this...admitedly...can just be summed up as "don't fixate on canon" lol)
If you do insist on using the word canon when discussing sonic stories...I'd advise using "alternate canon" or "this game is canon to this other game" ect. Discussing stories and discussing authorial intent are 2 very different things. Do not conflate them...especially when talking about new stories made by different people with different views on things. Until JP Sonic Team decide to actively take more inspiration from other Sonic media sources...the games will remain their own continuity while the rest of the medias will take inspiration from them...loosely or otherwise.
What's most important in a story is often debated, but it usually ends up agreeing to some form of "narrative consistency". Its only natural then, that the branch of media that is the most isolated and primal (in this case originating most original sonic ideas) will be what most people consider "canon" overall to the series/franchise...
I did not know Tangle wasn’t in JP script….Interesring
@@GamesCage To further clarify Sticks was kept in the JP script while Tangle wasn't...which is kinda funny to think about lol (mainly cause Sticks was designed by Sonic Team I guess)
@@Alienrunokay that Just isn't true.
Its actually reversed the Sticks mention was removed (as Amys whole Line was rewritten)
The Tangel mention meanwhile is still in the JP Version.
This is because the field dialouge wasn't translated by Kishimoto himself and instead by some one that made littel to no changes to Ian's skript.
By the way I am someone that dislikes that the Comics are now Canon.
@@rynobehnke8289 If this is true then that changes things a lot. I swore I heard the opposite on 2 occasions and it made sense to me at the time.
How did you know about the field dialoug thing if I may ask? Where can I find more info like this?
Iizuka stated they the SE are jn another dimension not that aren't canon
Ayo, Hopefully they put more IDW characters in the games
Something that still hurts me is that Gmerl ceased to exist in the main line since Advance 3
Wait, idw was cannon?
I always assumed it was cannon from the get go, after all wasnt it implied the metal virus saga takes place soon after the events of forces?