Silver vs Gold Violin G String: Can you hear the difference?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- Looking for a great sounding G string for your violin? I test and compare the Thomastik Dominant, Pirastro Evah Pirastro Gold Silver and Gold G strings. What's your favorite?
Buy your favorite violin strings here: bit.ly/2ASF4HD
Looking to improve your playing on the G string? Here's my tutorial on how to reach all the notes, get a big sound and lush vibrato on the G string: • VIOLIN G STRING LESSON...
Thomastik Dominant vs Fiddlerman strings comparison: • Thomastik Dominant vs ...
For those who requested about the Czardas I played: Here's a full tutorial with sheet music download: • How to Play Czardas by...
SUBSCRIBE: www.youtube.com...
Violin Bow Technique Lessons: www.violinloung...
Violinist Zlata plays:
Antique German violin: bit.ly/2KwVPvs
Arcus S9 round violin bow: bit.ly/2CMYzAQ
Pirastro Evah Pirazzi Gold violin strings: bit.ly/2EccbVG
Pirastro No 1 E string for violin (soft): amzn.to/2GvqW69
FOLLOW VIOLIN LOUNGE
Instagram: / violinlounge
Facebook: / violinlounge
Twitter: / violinlounge
TH-cam channel: / zlatabrouwer
4:20 Gold
5:00 Silver
5:50 Thomastik
Thank you
James Musser and thank you! 😊
4:23 gold g string
5:53 silver g string
Gold sounds reel nice, but it's good to know you can get away with silver in an emergency if one knows how it affects the experience and then compensate for that
Yes, they both have something I like about them.
Thanks.
Violin related emergency!!! Someone tripped over their violin and broke the G string( given they almost never break on their own)😊😊😊.
@@earthearth5188Mi é appena saltata la G string mentre accordavo😟
Thank you so much for this comparison.
Wow you really made the dominant string sound good! The gold seemed the most "mellow" but to me not worth the expense. I liked the silver best. String comparisons are always interesting. Thank you for doing this one!
Thanks, haha, had to try real hard with the Dominant!
I also use Evah Pirazzi strings on my humble violin, which make a Chinese made fiddle sound like an Italian one! Thanks for sharing, Best wishes :) PS: the silver G String sounds better ;)
Awesome!
Interestingly I thought the Dominant punched out the sound better than the other two. I have tried all three myself. I found the gold sounded great initially but lost its flavor relatively quickly. I’m tending to use the Infeld Pi’s more often as they work well with my violin and seem to last longer. To my ear, the gold does not sound $64 better! Currently went back to Evah Pirazzi and great at first, now starting to decline after about 6 weeks.
Yes, that's definitely a problem with the gold. I guess it's a soft material that wears down quite quickly.
I like the gold one more
But it might be just the piece
Like the colour needed a much darker and gloomy texture
OMG, GOLD by a mile, maybe a light year. The silver sounds like my overly bright inexpensive but nice looking violins made in a certain Asian country (I have several of them). Thank you for making this video, and making it with high quality sound, and for the explanation of what you had to do on the Dominant string. I was thinking it sounds like the silver, but then you explained how much work you had to do. I have one violin with a set of dominants, and I can relate to that fading unless one is very careful on all of the strings. It is my first time to try the dominants, and I was a bit disappointed. Needless to say. Sometimes the brightness of the Evah Pirazzi is hard to deal with, but I have never tried the gold, and needless to say, I'm going to order the gold with the gold G immediately! Thanks again!
Wonderful, enjoy your new strings!
Honestly, the two silver strings sounded better. But, I felt that the Thomastik was a more appealing sound.
I really like the tone of the silver a lot!
Just about to put on new ones 😌
Eva Pirazzi Gold is more warm and open. I liked the gold.
Me too!
Thank you.
I like Gold
I'm still doubting! 🙈
😂
I've been using Dominant strings for over 40 years so I've gotten very comfortable with their response and timbre. The others you played sounded fine.
I think if you could record the comparison using a professional quality ribbon mic in an acoustically neutral room it would be easier to hear the difference.
Also, the string is just part of the tone production. I have Dominants on my 3 main violins, and of course they all sound and respond differently.
Thank you for the video.
Oh yes, a studio upgrade is definitely on my wishlist! And yes, strings are only a small part of the whole picture.
Interesting film ! :)
I always though dominants were good. But because you put them up against the others. I really like the silver sound. That will be my go to when I need to replace my strings. Thanks Zlata. I'm Still learning new things everyday x
Erika Wilson great to read that, Erika!
I love anything in Gold 🤩😍😊
The Gold sounds fuller ,and warmer to me
Love your Violin Sound
I love the 🤩G String anyway
Thank you!
Thank you. Very interesting. You can certainly hear the difference.
When (if) I ever reach the giddy heights of Grade 5, I might treat myself to a $35 g string. In the meantime I'll just have to stick with the Dominants.
Can I suggest a video comparing student level strings? That might well be useful for more of us.
Sure, how about this one? violinlounge.com/product-review/thomastik-dominant-vs-fiddlerman-violin-string-review-violin-lounge-tv-331/
Dank u. Dat is erg aardig.
Silver was better , Do they make nickel or Stainless steel wrap?
I'm sure the Gold or Silver are just plated not solid
No wonder I am so frustrated with playing my G string, a Dominant. To me the gold sounded fuller than the silver but it was quite good.
Haha, yes, I played Dominants throughout my whole childhood, but getting back to it they were difficult (or I'm spoiled).
I think gold string more colourfull than silver ones also the tone and vibrant of gold string more dominant than the silver
I liked the gold the best. But if you consider it along with its price, ehhhh its much more about how much you're willing to spend on strings.
Silver ❤️❤️❤️❤️
I still think the gold and fold and gold/silver seem so much louder. The gold silver seems to have a tighter cleaner sound the gold some sounds louder but the tone doesn't seem as tight. The silver was okay but I don't think it's at the same level. The gold are probably for pros due to the volume the create the silver are probably for amateurs.
The Gold string is the best.
Fuller sound with more overtones.
I suspect it also has a wider dynamic range and easier to play...expression tonal sounds better.
I think the silver is a bit more one dimensional and not as full in presence
The silver is easier to play, but there are many things I like about the gold.
VIOLIN LOUNGE by Violinist Zlata for me the Gold has the soloist sound 😊
Gold ❤️
👍🏻
I prefer Gold... It's really interesting how big the difference is! Thanks Zlata... 😎
My pleasure!!
Hello. Very interesting comparision. I prefer the second string. The gold Eva P. G string gives a warm but old fashioned sound. The silver Dominant gives sometimes a weak sound. I think that the more "actual" sound, warm but also light and clear, in comparision, for this piece of music, is the Gold Silver Eva P. G string.
Thanks for sharing!
I use Evah Pirazzi Green strings and I am very happy with them.....
Yes, William, those are beautiful strings. Gold give a little more warmth.
By far , the gold is superior... Warmer. It all depends on taste through.. Thanks for the comparison..
You're welcome!
Yes sliver warmer nice sound.
The gold has a richer and fuller tone on some deeper notes but sounds empty with higher ones imo. Czardas honestly sounds the best with the dominant string. Full, rich sound with the perfect amount of muddiness.
When I personally play that song, I need my g string to be able to hold up to my bow pressure bc I like to play with emotions and want that beginning heavy sounding
Or ... you could buy two full sets of Tonicas for the price of the gold G. I think it all depends on the match with your fiddle. On a neutral violin the Tonicas can be a good as anything, and half the concert pros on the planet use the Dominant, which is very similar. I think there's a sense that if you pay more you're getting a better string but it doesn't really follow - it's all about the match with your fiddle, your bow and your sound production technique.
Exactly!
That's hard to pick which is the best string, Zlata. They both sound good, though. Hugs from America!
Yeah, I'm still doubting myself!
The silver one, as you said sounded clearer and the gold a little richer/grittier. I've always been a fan of clean vibrant strings, but again it's a thing of preference. My personal opinion is that the silver Evah suits best your general playstyle and the Gold would be more for some specific pieces you want to add that richness.
Yes, I think I agree. My violin is quite bright and loud, so the Gold compensates for that.
Silver sounds better
I'm still doubting! 🙈
I like the silver one better. The gold one sounds more nasal to me.
The silver sounds fine, but most pieces use more than just one string. It would be good to hear how they sound in combination with the other strings both in chords or in an excerpt like the opening of the Tchaikovsky concerto.
Good tip for a next review!
I thought this was a video about you wearing a G string. Bet that would get a lot of views ! The gold sounds much better.
Haha, certainly saw some weird stuff when Googling about G strings!
I liked the silver over the gold in the piano room by a hair. Gold was darker, but I liked the tightness and prescience of the silver. However, in the next segment, I couldn’t tell much of a difference between the two. I have played dominants for years until switching to Il Cannone mediums, and I know exactly what your talking about with the Dominant G. Too much tension to get a good sound in the upper registers.
How do you like the Il Cannone strings?
@@violinlounge To me, they are fairly supple and expressive; they have a focused sound that is not as bright as they purported to have. I use the "warm and broad" A, which is an option for the Il Cannone set and also use a Pirastro Gold Label E. It fits my violin just fine, which is a mid-19th century Mittenwald. Thanks for asking.
Я так не фальшивил даже в школе. Извиняюсь заранее, спасибо за обзор хороших струн.
I agree with you on your analysis.
I presume that if I were a professional violinist I would let it depend on the music I had to play which strings I would use.
Some music needs warm and soft, some music needs bright and outspoken.
Exactly, I think I will use both and change between them.
@@violinlounge Succes with that!
I think I have to change my first D string. Exciting! But I have a spare and my teacher can help me.
Anka Voskuilen you can do it! 💪🏻
If I was playing on a stage I would pick golden evah pirazzi because it makes bigger sound but silver is has way clearer sound than goledn one
and dominant would be my last choice
Thanks for sharing!
Gold 4:30
Silver 5:55
Thanks!
I prefer the slightly warmer gold but the silver cuts through a bit more if that's what you're looking for. Obviously your amazing playing is generating a large portion of the tone and if I played on your violin, it's not going to sound good ;-) ;-) ;-)
Haha, you’re welcome!
gold one suits the sad emotion felling song
I like the gold best. The gold is mellow enough to sweeten up a violin but brilliant enough to give a violin projection. The Evah Pirazzi Gold golden G sounded too brilliant and the dominant silver g sounded too brilliant!
Yes, however I like both Pirastro G strings.
Silver
Eva Pirazzi silver wound has a brighter and slightly clearer sound than the gold wound. I like the sound from the silver wound better. And Thomastik Dominant? Well, it's a good student string but what's to like?
4theRun exactly!
Gold sounds more driven in this video
Question
Can I keep my strings on until they break
Sam Ash said the G string could be changed
Thanks- usually on my guitar ukulele and banjo I would only change the string that would break
Thanks
Mrs Sheridan
Change them when they waddle in intonation or don’t sound as good anymore. I’ve got a video on that soon to show the difference 😊
I'm not a professional, but I really like the crisp sound of Gold strings. I think those are the best. 😃
Glad you like them!
I favor gold
Gold - by a mile!
would you use the silver G and not change the other strings with the same brand or quality?
Glenn Schrieber strings need to be matched to each other to have a consistent sound.
The gold sounds muffled, the silver sounds like it has more soul, and the thomastik sounds good in a clinical way. I think the silver sounds best on your violin
Thank you
Gold all day- deeper fuller sound. Disappointed with Thomastik- not buying those anytime soon.
Why do you change strings soo often
Because that's when they wear down.
@@violinlounge quite quick must say
Great content but REALLY get a good microphone and sound proofing for tone demonstrations! Thats my only critique. Oh and PUT TIME STAMPS!
Those things are why guitar tone channels have millions of subscribers!
Have a good one!
Thanks, the latest video on my channel I recorded in my new studio with better sound and lighting, but I keep learning :).
Gold is the best sound
Yes, I think so too, but I use silver now and then to save some bucks, haha!
I like silver better. It's warmer
And could you believe that a dominant set cost a 100 dollars in India
Wow!
@@violinlounge 🥲
Dominant g is not good.Silver or gold for me that not change much!You play slow bow,if you tried them with a fast,like the passage of Sibelius concerto,which is played only on the g we would judge better
Thanks for the suggestion!
Definitely prefer the gold...
Love it's mellow sound!
to be honest if the Thomastik G string is good enough for Anne-Sophie Mutter its good enough for me!!!!
Felix Hesse I need great strings to compensate that I’m not as good as Mutter 🤣
@@violinlounge indeed, we need all the help we can get!!!
I enjoyed this video. I definitely prefer the warmth of the gold but then I am not the one paying for it😉
Zlata, would you please consider making a video on the different types of violin sounds? I am interested in knowing the difference between "bright", "warm", "sweet" etc sounds. Can you give a definition or example of each? Just a thought.🙂
Thanks for your suggestion! Do you mean how to create different sound colors on the same violin? Or to demonstrate different violins that have a different timbre?
I mean different violins with different timbre. I want to know what my violin is so I can buy strings to complement it's specific sound. I want to be able to hear the timbre and know if this is what people call sweet or bright or whatever. People talk alot about this but I don't know what it means exactly. But how to achieve these sounds on one violin would also be interesting to me. 🙂
Silver is better, brighter, Gold is too warm for your violin. Dominant lacks tension to play in high positions.
Exactly!
Evah Pirazzi is Just loud and shouting. I was initially attracted by its clear pitch and used evah Pirazzi Gold set for years, but now I felt no artistic feel in it. No sweeter than dominant, especially for old classical melodies. Dominant feels singing with my pressure. Those who prefer to mimic the real gut strings, they surely go for dominants.
Thanks for sharing!
The gold sounds fatter and louder
Gold win
I like the warmth.
Silver