Being 72, I'm finding my D-28 more of a trial to play. My 000-28 is my go to instrument now so I really understand your CEO-7 opinion. Short scale with 11s makes it so comfortable to play, it's such a mood changer. Whatever the world throws at you, a few minutes playing (fingerstyle) washes frustration away. I find myself often just playing the same beautiful, melodic chords over repeatedly, away in a world of my own (the fingers know what to do so I can just let them get on with it). Unless I win a lottery I'll probably not buy another guitar, if I did it would indeed be the CEO-7. So sticking with my 000-28 is not a problem as it's SO rewarding. Thanks for telling us your list. I wish I'd had the opportunity to play so many, but am deeply content with the two I own.
I am 66 and I have a D18GE. My shoulder was hurting and I decided I wanted a CEO 7. My doctor gave me a shot and fixed my shoulder but I bought the CEO 7 anyway and it is very fun. If I win the lottery I will buy a 000 28. Merry Christmas.
I also have a 000-28VS. Vintage Series. I flew half way across the country to a left handed guitar shop in Houston, immediately bought the owner a pizza- to show him I was serious, and played all his acoustics for 2 days. My favorite was the 00028VS. I'm old like you so the smaller guitar is easier. And now I'm testing lighter strings which helps tremendously. I'll tell your wife to bury you with your guitar when the time comes.
I've always avoided trying to "buy expertise" by having gear that exceeded my skill level. Except...took the guitar up at age 65. After practicing for a year diligently and making very slow but steady progress, I purchased a Martin OOO-18. If I waited until I was "good enough", at best, I'd have few years to play it, at worst, I'd never have it. My Martin is not played nearly as well as other Martins, but it's a happy guitar because it's played every day.
I've found (far too late in life) that I should have plumped for a guitar FAR better than me so I grew into it, rather than buy cheap and 'reward' myself at sometime down the line. Now playing my 000-28 or the CEO-7 I find I've just improved beyond what I expected of myself.
My "go to guitar" is a Martin SC13e. I think it is, by far, the best price / value in the Martin line. I ordered mine before it was even available and got mine a week before the official release date! The neck attachment geometry and lack of a traditional neck heel makes it play like a Fender Stratocaster! Getting up to the high "C" on the high E string is a breeze! Since introducing the SC-13e, Martin recently came out with a new line of SC body shaped guitars. It's incredibly comfortable to play with its unique asymmetrical shape.
Tony, I can't believe you said nothing about the Martin D15. It is the Absolute Bass Monster of all Martin's. It plays even better in Drop D tuning and I absolutely love it for acoustic metal or hard rock!
A review of yours convinced me to get a 000-15SM. Light as a feather. 12 fret. Slotted headstock. Dust Bowl vibe. Honest sound. And I got it from Music Villa! Couldn’t be happier. Named her Brown Sugar. Let’s just add her to the list for an even dozen.
This brought a big smile on my face 😊 I was lucky to buy one a couple of years ago. It sounds so big for its size with clarity and bass response. It has so much dynamic. You can play it softly and it almost creates a compression effect that makes each note jump out of the guitar. Good choice for #1
Woooo proud ceo-7 owner here! I ordered mine back in 2021 and it finally came in a few weeks ago. I’m a lefty and mine sings beautifully! Played it every day since I’ve gotten it. I had a 0015m years ago but wished I had gotten the ceo7, although the mahogany 15 was amazing too.
I've played several different Martin models and eventually put together a criteria for determining what would be the perfect martin model for me. It turned out that the OOO28 EC fit my criteria so I sold my D28 and got one. At first I was disappointed the tone was not as bright as I expected but my affection for the guitar grew over time. Now, nothing feels as good as that guitar in my hands or sounds as good. I look forward to playing every day.
I flew from Long Beach to Houston to buy a 00028 Clapton model but some other guy flew from Japan and beat me out. So I got the next best thing. 00028VS. Vintage series. Why are we flying from all over the globe to a Houston guitar shop? We're leftys and in Houston is the world's largest guitar shop.
I've had a Martin d-35 since 1973. I have played many many mountains through the years and many other guitars this is still my favorite my bestie my friend
Hey Tony! Great show as always! I agree wholeheartedly with the D-18 in the top 5 at number 4! I finally got a new one last month. It sustains for days! And the tone is amazing! I was surprised to hear no mention of the D-41, D-42. or Martin's flagship D-45. Based on construction and tone woods, wouldn't they be as desirable as the HD-28?
I play a CEO-7 that I just love. When I started watching this video I didn't expect that the CEO-7 would even get a mention, since it is far from the main stream of Martin guitars. Needless to say I was really happy to see you placed it at #1! Great guitar!!!
I have completely redefined myself as a player because of my D 35S. After decades of playing classical and jazz on a nylon string guitar, I was able to easily transition to this neck, but it was the sound that hooked me.
Interesting video. I'm 73, owned over 30 Martins through the decades, retired with my 4 lifetime favorites: 2005 OM-45 TB (curly Engelmann over Flamed Tasmanian Blackwood, alternate torch headstock), Custom Shop OO-42 (Premium Adirondack over Premium Madagascar), first year OM-18 Authentic (pre VTS), and my lifetime favorite Custom Shop OM-28 (fine herringbone, 50's burst, Alpine over Madagascar). Dreads are long gone (arthritis), fingers are starting to go, but I have nothing but gratitude for a lifetime filled with Martins............
Tony, I tried the CEO-7 when it first came out. The V-Neck caused a lot of fatigue in the palm of my hand. After owning several Martins over the years my two favorites are 0-18 and D28MD.
D-28 Martin is just one of the best playing , I grew up playing 12 string acoustic fender! The day I played the D-28 Martin!! Well felt like a 12 string to me !! But that's me !!! Johnnypotatoes!! Peace out✌️😎
Cool list. I'm a big fan of the Martin Dreadnought Jr. All solid wood, very comfortable to play and really nice tone especially for a small-bodied guitar.
I would not have guessed the CEO-7 as #1! My personal favorite is the 000-16e with Granadillo back and sides. Granadillo is such a cool tone wood. It is like a bell chime at times and has a nice bass response too.
Tony, I love Martins and own a DSS-17, it’s great….I’m falling in love with Breedlove guitars also….please cover more Breedlove…. I’m a disabled Marine Desert Storm Vet and when going through the toughest struggles and physical problems, I learned playing bass to start and now acoustic guitar has gotten its grip on me….I became aware of guitars4vets through you….thank you, I’m now a supporter ….I’m over 50, and I want people to know it’s never too late to start learning….playing music, helps deal with pain, it’s a welcome distraction…thanks for the show! Greatly appreciated!
Always respect Tony’s opinion, but for me the HD-28 is #1 on my list. Also absolutely love the Dreadnought Jr. for amazing value and a great ‘couch’ guitar, and the LX1-E for a relatively low-cost travel guitar (…fits nicely in the overhead bin on the plane). Martin guitars are just amazing and not only hold their value but often go UP in value, making them a potentially good ‘investment’ too (…not that I’d sell any of mine!).
JC-16 RE Aura I’m an electric guy at my core. I’ve wanted a Martin for a long time, but I was always drawn to dreadnoughts. For years I kept trying to force myself to accept a dread. Until one day when I finally gave in and decided I needed a cutaway. Until recently when I tried a beautifully worn and broken in JC-16RE Aura from like 2006. I was shocked at how good it sounded. I had somehow convinced myself that dreads were the best. But this thing is so friggin nuanced. It has boomy bass, but when you use a light attack the highs just marinate around with eachother like it has a sort of natural vibrato. For whatever reason it reminds me of good fender electric amps the way they swirl, butin an acoustic sort of way. It’s fantastic. I’m a Gibson/Fender electric guy- but man this Martin stole my heart. Great budget guitar too- used for 1200-1500$ solid sitka spruce top, solid rosewood back and sides, ebony fretboard and bridge. It has all the stuff I’d expect from a $3500 Martin. Completely in love. Haven’t tried the Aura system yet, but the build in tuner seems like a win at the very least. This is one of those guitars that instantly felt like an old friend, and one of the guitars that will change the way you play, in a good way.
Hey Tony, Seasons Greetings from Swansea, South Wales 🏴. Thank you for another superb episode. The quailty of content and production is only eclipsed by your infectious enthusiasm for the joy of music. I wish this inspiration was availble 40 years ago when I was in school or when our kids were in school. Thank you for your time and commitment, we in the community love being part of the famil. Happy Holidays to all ❤️
The CEO-9 is my favorite. It has similar specs as the CEO-7, but with mango wood all over, and it sounds very similar. But that sound is as it it was already been recorded and mastered... unreal! I also own an amazing vintage ‘46 00-18. I should mention how amazing (and still affordable, at least for a studio) mid 50’s D18’s are. HDV-28 from late 90’s, great recording guitar... So many options. Great episode! ⚡️
Nice list, Tony! I saved for 8 months to buy my first guitar, a d28... 45 years later my go to guitars are the ceo 9 and a 00018 custom shop. I spy Spoon Phillips and following Maury's Music, a must for Martin owners.
22:03 Tony, great selections for favorite Martins…I am in love with my Authentic series…1939 D 18…why did you not include any from the Authentic Series?
I've only owned a GPCPA4 Rosewood which is one of my biggest regrets selling it years ago, but the best ones I've played are the CEO7, OM21, D35 and M36.
Two Martin guitars I'm super impressed with is the Road Series D-10E and the D-X2E (HPL with spruce top and mahogany neck). Two really great sounding guitars that retail for $949 and $649 respectively. The D-X2E is pretty high on my list for my next acoustic guitar. I always like your show Tony. So much good information.
The Martin Special 16 is a hell of a deal. It’s basically a HD28 without the fancy trim and hard case which makes it cost less. Also has satin finish on back and sides. Same bracing, same rosewood back and sides. Made in Nazareth PA. Not the same as the 16E model…it had a ooo body depth. The Special 16 is full depth dreadnaught. 1800 for a new one at guitar center. I paid 1000 for mine used. I call it the poor boys HD28 lol 😎 Can only buy them new at guitar center and one other place ( can’t remember if it’s musicians friend or sweetwater). They special ordered a 16E with the full depth body and called it the special 16. As I said before it’s 99% the same guitar as a HD28. But due to the satin finish and no hard shell case the cost is way less. I shot a video on the difference between the 16 special and HD28 if anyone wants to check them out. Not a lot of info on them out there I’ve had a HD28V before. The Special 16 is not a lesser guitar in any way. Matter of fact I like the special 16 more than I did the HD28V I had.
Late to the party but I own both a D35 and an OMC16e Ovangkol. I play the OMC more. A lot more. It is just more comfortable both sitting or standing at a mic. Additionally it has a really nice balance across the tonal spectrum and is a good support for a voice, particularly capo'd up as high as the 5th fret behind my baritone voice. As they say, size matters, but sometimes that means smaller.
D18 Golden Era. Monster guitars. In small bodied guitars I'd likely look for an 18 GE. In rosewood 28 GE or Marquis. I agree that the CEO7 is great. Also, I'd like to see some love for the 12 fret Martins, many of which are great.
Hey Tony, Another great video! One of the many things that drew me to your website initially was the TAC social connection. I was disappointed that your annual get together was postponed due to COVID, as well as, the local connection with the TAC family. I was wondering if you are considering firing up the social aspect anytime soon?
I have an LX1 that is my dearest pal. A K&K pickup with Fishman loudeBox, and believe it or not, a Strymon BigSky is about as much fun as is possible. Also MXR carbon copy. I live in a tough climate for guitars. So even though I have far more expensive Martins, they are always cased and humidified. The LX1 is always out and within reach though, so it gets played the most. great little guitar and a good friend
I was not partial to the Martin sound until I played a very special D18 in 1995. There is a sublime magic to the D18 that hooked me in that instant for life. There has never been a time that I picked it up and wasn't completely in awe. There are many amazing instruments out there, but this is the one that speaks to me! Thanks for the vid.
Hi Tony, great job. My choice is the 000-28. I don't know if I would buy the CEO - great guitar, of course - Maybe I'd pick a custom shop Gibson L-series, or a 'clone' like Atkin or Collings or Waterloo
Me too with the 000-28, my go to guitar as I don't have the funds to buy a CEO too. I will never part with the 000-28 as it is so rewarding and after 60 years playing, I owe myself a beautiful guitar.
At the world's largest left handed guitar store, I bought the owner a pizza to show him I was serious and for 2 days played every acoustic in the place. Bought my favorite. 00028VS. Vintage Series.
Always educational and considered, Tony, although the title is a bit misleading, since you'd be doing well to still be able to get some of these new. I did check back with your 6 year old 'guitars I bought after testing 500' and you are very faithful. Pretty much all the Martins have survived from those days. I cannot get away from the HD35, although I also love my J40 and hoped to see it in the mix. I'm less convinced by the HPL guitars. For that money you could get solid wood guitars from the far east (but you couldn't take them to the pool, of course). Not good enough for a good guitar - like you, I've heard this a million times and everything you say is true; buy the best you can afford. Even if you don't end up getting into guitar, you can sell it on and regard the money you lost as a rental fee. Get a cheap one and you'll be less likely to continue and you'll either have that cheapie staring down at you or you'll sell it for pennies. Hmm.
I've played and owned several guitars through the years . When I stepped up in quality builds, Martin was my final selection . Having HD28, my advice to anyone buying a guitar would be to go to a sales guy or someone who can pick your guitar at about 25 feet away from you and then you hear what it sounds like. Trust me , this tells what the crowd hears .
@@tinman8518 Some day, God willing and the river don't flood, I'm upgrading myself to bronze instead of tin.. Eric made of tin plays a 00028VS. (vintage series).
@@ericmadeoftin8206 HAHAHAHA Good one! The 00028VS is a beautiful guitar. I found a 1934 0-18 in an antique store years ago for a stupid low price. And, I have a D-42. Now you see why I say I'm not good enough for my guitars. LOL
I just did buy a Martin DC16GTE, it is already retired like Martin calls it, according to the serial number it is from 1999 which makes it 25 years old, and I do agree with the D16 series comment, Dreadnought sound at a affordable common people price, the sound it is just spectacular, I'm glad I paid the best $600 for a american made Martin with the original case, I just love it!
CEO-7 great choice. I've always said the best Gibson I've heard was a Martin CEO-7. A few years ago Chris Martin made a appearance at a local shop. There was a Q&A after. I raised my hand and said "No Question, just wanted to say thanks fir the CEO-7"
My friend, do we ever differ. Not even one 12 fret Martin? They still make several. While they only now make it via the custom shop, the 00-212 12 fret would be my pick (they are making a 00-12 fret 28 (as well as an 0 and a 000). Nothing sounds quite like the 12 fret (short scale) Marting.
@@bryanolsen7557 I've been playing a 00-21 12 fret since 1964; absolutely incredible instrument (same model played by the Kingston Trio, Brothers Four, Frank Hamilton and many, many other).
I've owned at least 10 Martins over the years and played many more. The best were a 58 D-28, my 000-28EC (my fave), and an HD-28 Adi top. I've played D-28 and D-18 models that were great and some were duds. Thank you for your input on a few models that I haven't played yet.
I flew to the world's largest left handed guitar shop in Houston to buy a 00028EC but some guy flew all the way from Japan and beat me out. So I settled for a 00028VS, Vintage Series. "Settling" works too.
Among the bang-for-the-buck mentions, I think that the Martin DM was outstanding. Everyone that I knew who had one absolutely thought the world of them. The CEO7's that I played were all gorgeous instruments with impeccable sound. Unfortunately the money never seemed to be around when the instrument was available. Finally had that urge satisfied however when I came across a OO-28 from the custom shop that was all that and more. That and my Reimagined D28 seem to be all that I need these days. (at least in those particular categories)
Very nice list! Thanks. I agree that large sound hole, Adi topped D-16 was exceptional, my favorite 16 from that era. As for the OM-28 Marquis neck, it has the 1930's heel shape that was used on the Golden Era and Marquis models. It effects the curve or slope of the barrel all the way down the neck and is slightly different (rounder to my brain) than the Modified V neck used on the Vintage Series. But the OM-28 Marquis (and the earlier GE) also has 2-3/8" string spacing. The OM-28V and OM-28 Authentic has 2-5/16", which also contributes to the feel and playabilty. The CEO-7 has that 30's heel and the short-scale version of that neck shape.
Yes Spoon, I love that Martin gave the new 1937 000-28 Custom Shop Authentic the neck profile of the now discontinued OM-28 Authentic 1931. I have Aged model of that 000-28, and it's one of my favorite Martin's. Thanks for all of the great work you do with Maury's!
@@ericecklund676 Thank you Eric. And congratulations! They are wonderfully successful guitars. Yes, it is a short-scale neck based on the OM-28A 1931 neck shape. I played Mike Seegers 1931 OM-28 the day Martin was starting to come up with the profile based on it, and again later once the Authentic version was completed. Seeger's actual neck is freakishly lopsided, with the bass side of the V quite bulbous while the treble side has a fast slope. That was typical for the 1930s necks, but not to the extent of that particular OM. Martin chose not to attempt an exact recreation, choosing instead to keep it symmetrical like the other Authentic Series necks. I find that CS 000 neck very comfy as vintage V necks go. Only the OM-45 Deluxe Authentic 1931 has an asymmetrical neck profile. The Modern Deluxe profile eventually adapted that same profile, but without the big 1930s heel and thicker mahogany barrel.
Loved the 11 best Martins. I'll share 3 stories of my 3 Martins. I spent many Sundays watching football with my dad. One of the last Sundays before passed I asked if he had any regrets in life. He didn't pause long before saying no. The very next Sunday during halftime of one of the games he said I been thinking about what you asked last week and I do have one regret. I sold my Martin D 28 when I went in the Army and I never played again. I wished I had of asked him what year it was. He started in the Army in the 1950s. Upon my retirement I bought myself a gift of a new Martin HD 28. It was the closest I could afford to what he had. My right shoulder needs replaced and I found that I couldn't play a dreadnought for over 30 minutes without pain. I was hooked on Martins so I bought a 000-28 in sunburst. It's beautiful and I could play longer without pain. Then I learned about the CEO-7. I thought about it's 00 body size and convinced myself that I should buy one. WARNING MARTINS ARE ADDICTIVE!!!!! I don't regret it a bit. The CEO is so small and comfortable. It has a big rich voice for such a small guitar. I spend alot of time with it on my lap watching TH-cam until something inspires me to pause and play. (Thats how I found you). As for my favorite. They each have different voices and just like my grandsons, I can't chose witch I love the most.
A very nice budget Martin is the special edition for GC Martin Custom MMVs, they came in dreadnaught and 000. It's a sleeper. NOT from Custom Shop, but they were called 'Custom' I guess due to the special factory run and have that embossed on neck heel inside of guitar. I own the 000, sort of a poor man's (which I am unfortunately LOL) 000-28. I think they were made in very small batches starting in 2005 and stopped in 2015, maybe? (don't quote me) Bought mine new in 2014 and it's opened up quite nicely now. Went in my local GC to buy strings that day, picked it up while looking around and somehow it followed me home. American made, sounds like a true Martin, all solid woods, spruce top/rosewood back and sides, not scalloped braced, but X bracing, but still sounds great and it has an 11/16" nut. I know these latter specs are a no go for a lot of folks, but I'm mainly an electric and bass player and very happy with it. It makes a good partner for my old Tacoma dreadnaught. Ok, so it's not exactly a 000-28, doesn't have quite the intricate detailed herringbone binding, rosette, etc. nor the projection or finesse of one, but it's pretty damn close for very little money and just a great deal. There's a reason why you rarely see them on the used market these days. If you're in the market for a good budget Martin, wouldn't hurt to have this on your radar. Also, I have a buddy who owns an M-36 and that's another Martin sleeper.
I would have put the HD-35 at top of the list as I have lusted for one for over 15 years. Also I’d have put the discontinued D-16GT over the X series choices. I bought one nearly on a lark about 12 years ago when I found money in my pocket and my wife’s blessing. I couldn’t convince her to ease up on the purse strings on that HD-35 but I just couldn’t warm up to the rosewood D-16RGT. The mahogany version has that wonderful mix of clarity, warmth and even overtones thanks to the semi scalloped lower arms of the X brace and single lower face tone bar. Never in my mind would I think I would ever own a mahogany/sitka dread but this one spoke to me. By the way, this was pre 2012 so I tried the former version of the D-18 and this less expensive model simply put it to shame. I could also almost forgive Martin for using Richlite instead of ebony for the fingerboard and bridge, though I would have preferred streaked ebony like other US based makers like Taylor and Larrivee use. Speaking of single tone bars and lightly braced dreadnoughts. I’d have also included the GC MMV which is basically a D-15 built using the HD-28 Tonewoods of East Indian rosewood and sitka spruce. This was another model that was at least more achievable than the HD-35.
I kept waiting for the only Martin I have and could purchase 22 years ago...the Martin DM. I realize it's not on a par with any of those you highlighted but I still enjoy playing it.
I purchased a Martin MMV ten years ago on black Friday as an early retirement present to myself and still am amazed at the sound. Having a Guild G-37 for nearly forty years, and a Zager ZAD 80, neither compare to the Martin sound, although the Zager is easier to play. I am interested in the Martin D35 series, but undecided on which version.
My CEO 7 is in my hands every single day. Best sounding guitar I've ever played. Easy, comfortable, brilliant across the highs and lows. Can't put the damn thing down.
Would installing a pickup on this be an absolute sin? I have the opportunity to purchase the CEO-7 and will have no regrets. However, I can also have a pickup installed. The one recommended by the seller is the Trance Amulet M. I will never be playing with a band, but in a pub setting by myself or with one other acoustic player. What do you think? just use a mic or have the pickup installed. Great videoes BTW, I've learned a lot
The best sounding guitar I ever played was my niece's husbands D45 that he inherited from his granfather, built in the early 60s. Also one of the easiest playing guitars.
Tony, I am the dog under the master's table hoping for some crumbs and a little spilled wine. I saw this topic and I had to sneak in the back door. As a proud owner of a D-18GE and a CEO 7, I actually think you are brilliant! A great Christmas present. Thank you
Everyone will probably have their own #1 Martin, and everyone will be right! If you love a guitar, you will want to spend more time playing it. Although not a specific model, I think an honorable mention should go to the Custom runs made for various music stores (NOT a Custom Shop). These are often very affordable guitars, made in Nazareth, PA, with a true Martin sound. BTW: If I didn't enjoy the show, I would not have watched every episode (and I think all the demos you did for Music Villa)!
When I was shopping for a nicer guitar it was between Martin and Taylor and ultimately I went with a Taylor 314CE that I like for the brighter tone and the feel of the neck. When I play various Martins, the fingers don't seem to slide up and down the fretboard as well and just feel stickier. Does anyone else feel this distinction when playing the neck? Is it the strings, the neck wood, the neck finish? It bothers me so much that I go back to the Taylor for the neck feel. Is there a Martin series that feels like Taylor neck? I'd love to own a Martin eventually but it's hard to fine one that feels "right" (in my own weird subjective way).
I have the same problem,I own nine guitars and eight are Taylor's,I have a 1980 Martin D-28 in mint condition and original case and key to lock the case,This guitar is one of the best sounding guitars and the easiest playing Martin I've ever played but the neck feels like my fingers is a sticky glue feeling this guitar is all original and I can't figure out why it feels sticky,It drives me nuts,I have two Taylor 614ces one is the Builder's Edition and the other is 2015 614ce standard and my favorite guitars,I have 914ce,816ce,814ce DLX v brace,K-24 ce, Baby Taylor, Epiphone Dove.I bought all my guitars brand new except the D-28,I love all guitars.
I thought Martin was the pinnacle until I picked up a Gibson J45 slope shoulder. I can't say it is a better than a Martin but mahogany really sings to me, I can comfortably play for hours and it can take anything I throw at it without getting muddy or buzzing.
I have a Martin OMe Cherry. I bought it because I liked the sustainable aspects of the guitar. It sounds really good and I like it. But I have been lusting after a CEO7 for some time. I may have to sell the OMe Cherry to finance a CEO7.
Hi Tony, I'm looking for a 12-string acoustic-electric. What I care for most is the deep rich sound. I'm looking at a Fender cut away but the sound is too tinny and it struggles to stay in tune. After seeing your video, I am very impressed with your knowledge, familiarity and expertise ( in addition to your playing skills). And you sold me on Martin, especially given the reasonable prices for the ones you featured. Is there one you would recommend for about $1,000? I am a novice. Thank you very much. Peter
I always love your videos! In this one, apples and oranges. Was a bit surprised to see the HD-28 come in so low. I own a number of these instruments and my HD-28 is righteous. Concerning your number one guitar, the CEO-7, I owned one. Loved it. However, the back split TWICE. Had it repaired TWICE. I know. Anything can happen. Anyhoo, sold it. Gruhn now has some new 12 fret D-28s that are amazing. Really amazing. Probably my next purchase. Again, I really enjoy your videos. Boogie forth.
G'day Tony..I'm thinking about a Martin D18...your video has sealed it! I already own a 0015m, a 1980 Tokai D18 copy as well as a Sigma J45 copy. Over the years I have owned 2 taylors...a T5 and an Ad 17 blacktop...time for the 'ultimate' Martin. By the way... the only way to make your videos better is to swap out that blackhawk jersey for a 'spoked B'...go Bruins!...lol
If the CEO7 was a dreadnought it would be a D18 Golden Era. I remember you playing it (short bearded) and saying, "Well to be honest, I really want it". I still have mine! These two guitars just resonate with my soul. Great choice though, just different sizes.
IMO, The D-18GE is the most wonderful mahogany Martin ever made. I traded 000-18GE for it, also a great Martin, but I love my 000x1AE so much. It’s really my go-to guitar, which is sayin’ somethin’ cuz I have 6 Martins, 5 Taylors and many others.
Being 72, I'm finding my D-28 more of a trial to play. My 000-28 is my go to instrument now so I really understand your CEO-7 opinion. Short scale with 11s makes it so comfortable to play, it's such a mood changer. Whatever the world throws at you, a few minutes playing (fingerstyle) washes frustration away. I find myself often just playing the same beautiful, melodic chords over repeatedly, away in a world of my own (the fingers know what to do so I can just let them get on with it).
Unless I win a lottery I'll probably not buy another guitar, if I did it would indeed be the CEO-7. So sticking with my 000-28 is not a problem as it's SO rewarding.
Thanks for telling us your list. I wish I'd had the opportunity to play so many, but am deeply content with the two I own.
@yumpladukfoo thank you for not saying a Taylor, but you should really try a Martin.
I am 66 and I have a D18GE. My shoulder was hurting and I decided I wanted a CEO 7. My doctor gave me a shot and fixed my shoulder but I bought the CEO 7 anyway and it is very fun. If I win the lottery I will buy a 000 28. Merry Christmas.
I also have a 000-28VS. Vintage Series. I flew half way across the country to a left handed guitar shop in Houston, immediately bought the owner a pizza- to show him I was serious, and played all his acoustics for 2 days. My favorite was the 00028VS. I'm old like you so the smaller guitar is easier. And now I'm testing lighter strings which helps tremendously. I'll tell your wife to bury you with your guitar when the time comes.
@yumpladukfoo I did, that's why I chose a Martin . . . probably not the answer you wanted, sorry about that.
To cut a long story short, I bought a CEO-7 and it's every bit and more as wonderful as you've said. I couldn't recommend it more.
I've always avoided trying to "buy expertise" by having gear that exceeded my skill level. Except...took the guitar up at age 65. After practicing for a year diligently and making very slow but steady progress, I purchased a Martin OOO-18. If I waited until I was "good enough", at best, I'd have few years to play it, at worst, I'd never have it. My Martin is not played nearly as well as other Martins, but it's a happy guitar because it's played every day.
I've found (far too late in life) that I should have plumped for a guitar FAR better than me so I grew into it, rather than buy cheap and 'reward' myself at sometime down the line.
Now playing my 000-28 or the CEO-7 I find I've just improved beyond what I expected of myself.
D35 is the best I have played or heard or owned. I have tried about 8 of these and one of HD35s. All 35s are consistent in sound and set up.
That CEO-7 is a little monster of a guitar! One that will never leave me! Great pick!
Same here
Amen!
Best new Martin in decades..
My "go to guitar" is a Martin SC13e. I think it is, by far, the best price / value in the Martin line. I ordered mine before it was even available and got mine a week before the official release date! The neck attachment geometry and lack of a traditional neck heel makes it play like a Fender Stratocaster! Getting up to the high "C" on the high E string is a breeze! Since introducing the SC-13e, Martin recently came out with a new line of SC body shaped guitars. It's incredibly comfortable to play with its unique asymmetrical shape.
Tony, I can't believe you said nothing about the Martin D15. It is the Absolute Bass Monster of all Martin's. It plays even better in Drop D tuning and I absolutely love it for acoustic metal or hard rock!
I believe that he has the Guild version (the M-20?). But I like the 15-SM.
acoustic metal!
Tony - another great list. Surprised not to see the M-36 on top of the list. I do appreciate the thought you put into your prioritization.
I feel like a lot of people don't even know that model exists!
Yep, the CEO7 is hands-down my favorite guitar! It’s the one guitar I’ll never let go.
A review of yours convinced me to get a 000-15SM. Light as a feather. 12 fret. Slotted headstock. Dust Bowl vibe. Honest sound. And I got it from Music Villa! Couldn’t be happier. Named her Brown Sugar. Let’s just add her to the list for an even dozen.
I agree!
Only Martin I have and I love it, picking it back up again I just put some Martin Retro Monels on and it sounds even better and they feel great.
This brought a big smile on my face 😊 I was lucky to buy one a couple of years ago. It sounds so big for its size with clarity and bass response. It has so much dynamic. You can play it softly and it almost creates a compression effect that makes each note jump out of the guitar. Good choice for #1
Woooo proud ceo-7 owner here!
I ordered mine back in 2021 and it finally came in a few weeks ago. I’m a lefty and mine sings beautifully! Played it every day since I’ve gotten it. I had a 0015m years ago but wished I had gotten the ceo7, although the mahogany 15 was amazing too.
I've played several different Martin models and eventually put together a criteria for determining what would be the perfect martin model for me. It turned out that the OOO28 EC fit my criteria so I sold my D28 and got one. At first I was disappointed the tone was not as bright as I expected but my affection for the guitar grew over time. Now, nothing feels as good as that guitar in my hands or sounds as good. I look forward to playing every day.
I flew from Long Beach to Houston to buy a 00028 Clapton model but some other guy flew from Japan and beat me out. So I got the next best thing. 00028VS. Vintage series. Why are we flying from all over the globe to a Houston guitar shop? We're leftys and in Houston is the world's largest guitar shop.
I've had a Martin d-35 since 1973. I have played many many mountains through the years and many other guitars this is still my favorite my bestie my friend
My favorite is the one I have owned since 2017. It’s a 1998 Martin 00-21GE ❤
Lots of great models on your list. Well done.
To my mind the Martin D28 Authentic 1937 is THE standout acoustic guitar you can buy off the shelf today. Incomparable!
I'm sure many rolled their eyes at the LX1 choice, but I love mine. It surprises me every day.
Agreed. My first Martin! :)
Hey Tony! Great show as always! I agree wholeheartedly with the D-18 in the top 5 at number 4! I finally got a new one last month. It sustains for days! And the tone is amazing! I was surprised to hear no mention of the D-41, D-42. or Martin's flagship D-45. Based on construction and tone woods, wouldn't they be as desirable as the HD-28?
I play a CEO-7 that I just love. When I started watching this video I didn't expect that the CEO-7 would even get a mention, since it is far from the main stream of Martin guitars. Needless to say I was really happy to see you placed it at #1! Great guitar!!!
Me too, I really wondered what the #1 would be and then spookily I expected it to appear . . . and then it did.
@@BrianWMaysame
Me too!
I have completely redefined myself as a player because of my D 35S. After decades of playing classical and jazz on a nylon string guitar, I was able to easily transition to this neck, but it was the sound that hooked me.
Interesting video. I'm 73, owned over 30 Martins through the decades, retired with my 4 lifetime favorites: 2005 OM-45 TB (curly Engelmann over Flamed Tasmanian Blackwood, alternate torch headstock), Custom Shop OO-42 (Premium Adirondack over Premium Madagascar), first year OM-18 Authentic (pre VTS), and my lifetime favorite Custom Shop OM-28 (fine herringbone, 50's burst, Alpine over Madagascar). Dreads are long gone (arthritis), fingers are starting to go, but I have nothing but gratitude for a lifetime filled with Martins............
Best bang for your buck is the OOO15M. A truly great little guitar.
Tony, I tried the CEO-7 when it first came out. The V-Neck caused a lot of fatigue in the palm of my hand. After owning several Martins over the years my two favorites are 0-18 and D28MD.
OMC-35 ties with my OM-28(non-electric) for my favorite guits. Happy tunes, everybody!
D-28 Martin is just one of the best playing , I grew up playing 12 string acoustic fender! The day I played the D-28 Martin!! Well felt like a 12 string to me !! But that's me !!! Johnnypotatoes!! Peace out✌️😎
Cool list. I'm a big fan of the Martin Dreadnought Jr. All solid wood, very comfortable to play and really nice tone especially for a small-bodied guitar.
Me too. I have one now. It was in the right price range and I've got a smaller frame so it's the best of all worlds for myself.
I picked up one of these Jrs for my kid for a song, and it was a pleasant surprise. The sustain on it is crazy.
I would not have guessed the CEO-7 as #1! My personal favorite is the 000-16e with Granadillo back and sides. Granadillo is such a cool tone wood. It is like a bell chime at times and has a nice bass response too.
Tony, I love Martins and own a DSS-17, it’s great….I’m falling in love with Breedlove guitars also….please cover more Breedlove….
I’m a disabled Marine Desert Storm Vet and when going through the toughest struggles and physical problems, I learned playing bass to start and now acoustic guitar has gotten its grip on me….I became aware of guitars4vets through you….thank you, I’m now a supporter ….I’m over 50, and I want people to know it’s never too late to start learning….playing music, helps deal with pain, it’s a welcome distraction…thanks for the show! Greatly appreciated!
Tony, don’t change a thing about your show. Yammer all you want! I look forward to watching this every single Tuesday! Christopher_H from TAC btw.
I couldn't agree with you more. I just got my CEO7 this year and it is my go to guitar since getting it. All my others just sit in their cases now.
I just got a new 000-15M. GR8 guitar. Never had a Martin b4. Now I understand the hype. This thing plays & sounds great.
Just bought my first Martin 2 weeks ago. HD28 Custom Shop and it has blown me away. Only ever played one other Martin prior a couple years ago.
Always respect Tony’s opinion, but for me the HD-28 is #1 on my list. Also absolutely love the Dreadnought Jr. for amazing value and a great ‘couch’ guitar, and the LX1-E for a relatively low-cost travel guitar (…fits nicely in the overhead bin on the plane). Martin guitars are just amazing and not only hold their value but often go UP in value, making them a potentially good ‘investment’ too (…not that I’d sell any of mine!).
Hey Tony, thanks for the shout-out! 👊
And you can check out MY top 10 here th-cam.com/video/Cei3MWgfTtQ/w-d-xo.html
JC-16 RE Aura
I’m an electric guy at my core. I’ve wanted a Martin for a long time, but I was always drawn to dreadnoughts. For years I kept trying to force myself to accept a dread. Until one day when I finally gave in and decided I needed a cutaway. Until recently when I tried a beautifully worn and broken in JC-16RE Aura from like 2006. I was shocked at how good it sounded. I had somehow convinced myself that dreads were the best. But this thing is so friggin nuanced. It has boomy bass, but when you use a light attack the highs just marinate around with eachother like it has a sort of natural vibrato. For whatever reason it reminds me of good fender electric amps the way they swirl, butin an acoustic sort of way. It’s fantastic. I’m a Gibson/Fender electric guy- but man this Martin stole my heart.
Great budget guitar too- used for 1200-1500$ solid sitka spruce top, solid rosewood back and sides, ebony fretboard and bridge. It has all the stuff I’d expect from a $3500 Martin. Completely in love. Haven’t tried the Aura system yet, but the build in tuner seems like a win at the very least.
This is one of those guitars that instantly felt like an old friend, and one of the guitars that will change the way you play, in a good way.
Wholesome ... this show and Rosa string works are the best 2 acoustic shows on the internet ... cheers man.
Hey Tony, Seasons Greetings from Swansea, South Wales 🏴. Thank you for another superb episode. The quailty of content and production is only eclipsed by your infectious enthusiasm for the joy of music. I wish this inspiration was availble 40 years ago when I was in school or when our kids were in school. Thank you for your time and commitment, we in the community love being part of the famil. Happy Holidays to all ❤️
I have a 1971 custom detailed by Martin, D-35 with a satin finish and one strip of de-stressing relief, shored up by the factory... it's stunning!
The CEO-9 is my favorite. It has similar specs as the CEO-7, but with mango wood all over, and it sounds very similar. But that sound is as it it was already been recorded and mastered... unreal! I also own an amazing vintage ‘46 00-18. I should mention how amazing (and still affordable, at least for a studio) mid 50’s D18’s are. HDV-28 from late 90’s, great recording guitar... So many options. Great episode! ⚡️
Nice list, Tony! I saved for 8 months to buy my first guitar, a d28... 45 years later my go to guitars are the ceo 9 and a 00018 custom shop. I spy Spoon Phillips and following Maury's Music, a must for Martin owners.
Two to consider: 000-15s or sm. Classic hog design. Also, a guitar you have praised: M-36, the almost official guitar of Nashville studio life. Right?
22:03 Tony, great selections for favorite Martins…I am in love with my Authentic series…1939 D 18…why did you not include any from the Authentic Series?
I've only owned a GPCPA4 Rosewood which is one of my biggest regrets selling it years ago, but the best ones I've played are the CEO7, OM21, D35 and M36.
Two Martin guitars I'm super impressed with is the Road Series D-10E and the D-X2E (HPL with spruce top and mahogany neck). Two really great sounding guitars that retail for $949 and $649 respectively. The D-X2E is pretty high on my list for my next acoustic guitar. I always like your show Tony. So much good information.
My pick is the D-18; does it all and records well!
The Martin Special 16 is a hell of a deal. It’s basically a HD28 without the fancy trim and hard case which makes it cost less. Also has satin finish on back and sides. Same bracing, same rosewood back and sides. Made in Nazareth PA. Not the same as the 16E model…it had a ooo body depth. The Special 16 is full depth dreadnaught. 1800 for a new one at guitar center. I paid 1000 for mine used. I call it the poor boys HD28 lol 😎
Can only buy them new at guitar center and one other place ( can’t remember if it’s musicians friend or sweetwater). They special ordered a 16E with the full depth body and called it the special 16. As I said before it’s 99% the same guitar as a HD28. But due to the satin finish and no hard shell case the cost is way less. I shot a video on the difference between the 16 special and HD28 if anyone wants to check them out. Not a lot of info on them out there
I’ve had a HD28V before. The Special 16 is not a lesser guitar in any way. Matter of fact I like the special 16 more than I did the HD28V I had.
Where could I find your video on the difference between the 16 special and HD28?
@@wilwrenn2009 I deleted it. I found out I don’t like all the attention it attracts lol.
Late to the party but I own both a D35 and an OMC16e Ovangkol.
I play the OMC more. A lot more. It is just more comfortable both sitting or standing at a mic.
Additionally it has a really nice balance across the tonal spectrum and is a good support for a voice, particularly capo'd up as high as the 5th fret behind my baritone voice.
As they say, size matters, but sometimes that means smaller.
D18 Golden Era. Monster guitars. In small bodied guitars I'd likely look for an 18 GE. In rosewood 28 GE or Marquis. I agree that the CEO7 is great. Also, I'd like to see some love for the 12 fret Martins, many of which are great.
Hey Tony, Another great video! One of the many things that drew me to your website initially was the TAC social connection. I was disappointed that your annual get together was postponed due to COVID, as well as, the local connection with the TAC family. I was wondering if you are considering firing up the social aspect anytime soon?
What’s with the hockey jersey?
I have an LX1 that is my dearest pal. A K&K pickup with Fishman loudeBox, and believe it or not, a Strymon BigSky is about as much fun as is possible. Also MXR carbon copy. I live in a tough climate for guitars. So even though I have far more expensive Martins, they are always cased and humidified. The LX1 is always out and within reach though, so it gets played the most. great little guitar and a good friend
I think the reamangined D28 doesn't get the love I dig mine. Straight backing does it's thing.
I was not partial to the Martin sound until I played a very special D18 in 1995. There is a sublime magic to the D18 that hooked me in that instant for life. There has never been a time that I picked it up and wasn't completely in awe. There are many amazing instruments out there, but this is the one that speaks to me! Thanks for the vid.
I had that with a d18 too. I almost cried. Lol
Hi Tony, great job. My choice is the 000-28. I don't know if I would buy the CEO - great guitar, of course - Maybe I'd pick a custom shop Gibson L-series, or a 'clone' like Atkin or Collings or Waterloo
Me too with the 000-28, my go to guitar as I don't have the funds to buy a CEO too. I will never part with the 000-28 as it is so rewarding and after 60 years playing, I owe myself a beautiful guitar.
At the world's largest left handed guitar store, I bought the owner a pizza to show him I was serious and for 2 days played every acoustic in the place. Bought my favorite. 00028VS. Vintage Series.
I've owned the CEO 7 for 3 years. I preferred Taylor for several years. Just an opinion, the CEO 7 is the best guitar that I've played.
Always educational and considered, Tony, although the title is a bit misleading, since you'd be doing well to still be able to get some of these new. I did check back with your 6 year old 'guitars I bought after testing 500' and you are very faithful. Pretty much all the Martins have survived from those days. I cannot get away from the HD35, although I also love my J40 and hoped to see it in the mix. I'm less convinced by the HPL guitars. For that money you could get solid wood guitars from the far east (but you couldn't take them to the pool, of course). Not good enough for a good guitar - like you, I've heard this a million times and everything you say is true; buy the best you can afford. Even if you don't end up getting into guitar, you can sell it on and regard the money you lost as a rental fee. Get a cheap one and you'll be less likely to continue and you'll either have that cheapie staring down at you or you'll sell it for pennies. Hmm.
Martin OOO/D 15 is on every list of best guitars to buy ( at least I have read ) except this one. Has it gone bad?
No. He's just being a little "out there" picking little heard of and unknown Martins that he thinks we should know about.
@@ericmadeoftin8206 If that’s the case I would say he accomplished his goal. The average person would not be able to purchase most of them.
My fave is my OM-42 Custom Shop.
I would add the 12-fret Martin 000-15sm. A beautiful sounding, balanced instrument that is, in relative terms, a steal.
Tony, I have been a full time guitarist fos close to 39 years, I still just love your videos
I've played and owned several guitars through the years . When I stepped up in quality builds, Martin was my final selection . Having HD28, my advice to anyone buying a guitar would be to go to a sales guy or someone who can pick your guitar at about 25 feet away from you and then you hear what it sounds like. Trust me , this tells what the crowd hears .
I'm not good enough for the guitars I own but that's my life-long challenge. To get better.
Tin Man ? What kinda name is that?
@@ericmadeoftin8206 My life career was in metal fabrication. Hence the name: Tin Man.
Nice to meet you Eric. I don't think I made you though.
@@tinman8518 Some day, God willing and the river don't flood, I'm upgrading myself to bronze instead of tin.. Eric made of tin plays a 00028VS. (vintage series).
@@ericmadeoftin8206 HAHAHAHA Good one! The 00028VS is a beautiful guitar. I found a 1934 0-18 in an antique store years ago for a stupid low price. And, I have a D-42. Now you see why I say I'm not good enough for my guitars. LOL
It's better to have guitars you can grow into than to have guitars that drag you down.
I just did buy a Martin DC16GTE, it is already retired like Martin calls it, according to the serial number it is from 1999 which makes it 25 years old, and I do agree with the D16 series comment, Dreadnought sound at a affordable common people price, the sound it is just spectacular, I'm glad I paid the best $600 for a american made Martin with the original case, I just love it!
I would love to get my hands on Martin D-28 Modern Deluxe
CEO-7 great choice. I've always said the best Gibson I've heard was a Martin CEO-7. A few years ago Chris Martin made a appearance at a local shop. There was a Q&A after. I raised my hand and said "No Question, just wanted to say thanks fir the CEO-7"
My friend, do we ever differ. Not even one 12 fret Martin? They still make several. While they only now make it via the custom shop, the 00-212 12 fret would be my pick (they are making a 00-12 fret 28 (as well as an 0 and a 000). Nothing sounds quite like the 12 fret (short scale) Marting.
Agreed! I've played their 000-17sm for a decade now and couldn't be happier.
@@bryanolsen7557 I've been playing a 00-21 12 fret since 1964; absolutely incredible instrument (same model played by the Kingston Trio, Brothers Four, Frank Hamilton and many, many other).
00028VS. Vintage Series.
@@ghergen I have a 63 00-21 and it is an unbelievable little guitar.
I've owned at least 10 Martins over the years and played many more. The best were a 58 D-28, my 000-28EC (my fave), and an HD-28 Adi top. I've played D-28 and D-18 models that were great and some were duds. Thank you for your input on a few models that I haven't played yet.
I flew to the world's largest left handed guitar shop in Houston to buy a 00028EC but some guy flew all the way from Japan and beat me out. So I settled for a 00028VS, Vintage Series. "Settling" works too.
@@ericmadeoftin8206 The 000-28ec is the first 000 Martin I have ever owned. I'm thinking your VS series equally nice.
Among the bang-for-the-buck mentions, I think that the Martin DM was outstanding. Everyone that I knew who had one absolutely thought the world of them. The CEO7's that I played were all gorgeous instruments with impeccable sound. Unfortunately the money never seemed to be around when the instrument was available. Finally had that urge satisfied however when I came across a OO-28 from the custom shop that was all that and more. That and my Reimagined D28 seem to be all that I need these days. (at least in those particular categories)
Very nice list! Thanks.
I agree that large sound hole, Adi topped D-16 was exceptional, my favorite 16 from that era. As for the OM-28 Marquis neck, it has the 1930's heel shape that was used on the Golden Era and Marquis models. It effects the curve or slope of the barrel all the way down the neck and is slightly different (rounder to my brain) than the Modified V neck used on the Vintage Series. But the OM-28 Marquis (and the earlier GE) also has 2-3/8" string spacing. The OM-28V and OM-28 Authentic has 2-5/16", which also contributes to the feel and playabilty. The CEO-7 has that 30's heel and the short-scale version of that neck shape.
Yes Spoon, I love that Martin gave the new 1937 000-28 Custom Shop Authentic the neck profile of the now discontinued OM-28 Authentic 1931. I have Aged model of that 000-28, and it's one of my favorite Martin's. Thanks for all of the great work you do with Maury's!
@@ericecklund676 Thank you Eric. And congratulations! They are wonderfully successful guitars. Yes, it is a short-scale neck based on the OM-28A 1931 neck shape.
I played Mike Seegers 1931 OM-28 the day Martin was starting to come up with the profile based on it, and again later once the Authentic version was completed. Seeger's actual neck is freakishly lopsided, with the bass side of the V quite bulbous while the treble side has a fast slope. That was typical for the 1930s necks, but not to the extent of that particular OM. Martin chose not to attempt an exact recreation, choosing instead to keep it symmetrical like the other Authentic Series necks. I find that CS 000 neck very comfy as vintage V necks go.
Only the OM-45 Deluxe Authentic 1931 has an asymmetrical neck profile. The Modern Deluxe profile eventually adapted that same profile, but without the big 1930s heel and thicker mahogany barrel.
Loved the 11 best Martins. I'll share 3 stories of my 3 Martins. I spent many Sundays watching football with my dad. One of the last Sundays before passed I asked if he had any regrets in life. He didn't pause long before saying no. The very next Sunday during halftime of one of the games he said I been thinking about what you asked last week and I do have one regret. I sold my Martin D 28 when I went in the Army and I never played again. I wished I had of asked him what year it was. He started in the Army in the 1950s. Upon my retirement I bought myself a gift of a new Martin HD 28. It was the closest I could afford to what he had. My right shoulder needs replaced and I found that I couldn't play a dreadnought for over 30 minutes without pain. I was hooked on Martins so I bought a 000-28 in sunburst. It's beautiful and I could play longer without pain. Then I learned about the CEO-7. I thought about it's 00 body size and convinced myself that I should buy one. WARNING MARTINS ARE ADDICTIVE!!!!! I don't regret it a bit. The CEO is so small and comfortable. It has a big rich voice for such a small guitar. I spend alot of time with it on my lap watching TH-cam until something inspires me to pause and play. (Thats how I found you). As for my favorite. They each have different voices and just like my grandsons, I can't chose witch I love the most.
Every time I see you play a demo, I say to myself “I need to learn that.” You should take that as a compliment.
A very nice budget Martin is the special edition for GC Martin Custom MMVs, they came in dreadnaught and 000. It's a sleeper. NOT from Custom Shop, but they were called 'Custom' I guess due to the special factory run and have that embossed on neck heel inside of guitar. I own the 000, sort of a poor man's (which I am unfortunately LOL) 000-28. I think they were made in very small batches starting in 2005 and stopped in 2015, maybe? (don't quote me) Bought mine new in 2014 and it's opened up quite nicely now. Went in my local GC to buy strings that day, picked it up while looking around and somehow it followed me home. American made, sounds like a true Martin, all solid woods, spruce top/rosewood back and sides, not scalloped braced, but X bracing, but still sounds great and it has an 11/16" nut. I know these latter specs are a no go for a lot of folks, but I'm mainly an electric and bass player and very happy with it. It makes a good partner for my old Tacoma dreadnaught. Ok, so it's not exactly a 000-28, doesn't have quite the intricate detailed herringbone binding, rosette, etc. nor the projection or finesse of one, but it's pretty damn close for very little money and just a great deal. There's a reason why you rarely see them on the used market these days. If you're in the market for a good budget Martin, wouldn't hurt to have this on your radar. Also, I have a buddy who owns an M-36 and that's another Martin sleeper.
I would have put the HD-35 at top of the list as I have lusted for one for over 15 years. Also I’d have put the discontinued D-16GT over the X series choices. I bought one nearly on a lark about 12 years ago when I found money in my pocket and my wife’s blessing. I couldn’t convince her to ease up on the purse strings on that HD-35 but I just couldn’t warm up to the rosewood D-16RGT. The mahogany version has that wonderful mix of clarity, warmth and even overtones thanks to the semi scalloped lower arms of the X brace and single lower face tone bar. Never in my mind would I think I would ever own a mahogany/sitka dread but this one spoke to me.
By the way, this was pre 2012 so I tried the former version of the D-18 and this less expensive model simply put it to shame. I could also almost forgive Martin for using Richlite instead of ebony for the fingerboard and bridge, though I would have preferred streaked ebony like other US based makers like Taylor and Larrivee use.
Speaking of single tone bars and lightly braced dreadnoughts. I’d have also included the GC MMV which is basically a D-15 built using the HD-28 Tonewoods of East Indian rosewood and sitka spruce. This was another model that was at least more achievable than the HD-35.
I kept waiting for the only Martin I have and could purchase 22 years ago...the Martin DM. I realize it's not on a par with any of those you highlighted but I still enjoy playing it.
I purchased a Martin MMV ten years ago on black Friday as an early retirement present to myself and still am amazed at the sound. Having a Guild G-37 for nearly forty years, and a Zager ZAD 80, neither compare to the Martin sound, although the Zager is easier to play. I am interested in the Martin D35 series, but undecided on which version.
Tony, you're still very young :) Great video !
My CEO 7 is in my hands every single day. Best sounding guitar I've ever played. Easy, comfortable, brilliant across the highs and lows. Can't put the damn thing down.
My favorite Martin that I've played is the GE D18. I've owned a D18 since 1971 and played many guitars.
Would installing a pickup on this be an absolute sin? I have the opportunity to purchase the CEO-7 and will have no regrets. However, I can also have a pickup installed. The one recommended by the seller is the Trance Amulet M. I will never be playing with a band, but in a pub setting by myself or with one other acoustic player. What do you think? just use a mic or have the pickup installed. Great videoes BTW, I've learned a lot
Stunned that 0000/M did not make this list.
The best sounding guitar I ever played was my niece's husbands D45 that he inherited from his granfather, built in the early 60s. Also one of the easiest playing guitars.
I don't doubt you for a minute.
Tony, I am the dog under the master's table hoping for some crumbs and a little spilled wine. I saw this topic and I had to sneak in the back door. As a proud owner of a D-18GE and a CEO 7, I actually think you are brilliant! A great Christmas present. Thank you
Doyle Dykes would say that you are guitar poor.
I’ve got a D-16R from 2004 that I love dearly. I heard they stopped making them as people were choosing to buy them instead of D-28s.
Everyone will probably have their own #1 Martin, and everyone will be right! If you love a guitar, you will want to spend more time playing it.
Although not a specific model, I think an honorable mention should go to the Custom runs made for various music stores (NOT a Custom Shop). These are often very affordable guitars, made in Nazareth, PA, with a true Martin sound.
BTW: If I didn't enjoy the show, I would not have watched every episode (and I think all the demos you did for Music Villa)!
Thank you !!! like the idea of HPL for traveling and low maintenance.
When talking Martin price always hold me back so for now Fender is my go to.
Went back and listened again. OM 28 Marquis hands down. Best tone in the crowd.
Tony, have you tried a Super D Koa? I agree with the CEO-7.
I can't believe you rated an HD28 lower than an LX!
I've got a Martin MC-28 that I've had since the early 90s. Don't know much about it, but its an amazing instrument. I enjoyed this, thanks!
Great video as always. Love what you do. My favorite martin has to be the HD-28. What are your thoughts on the martin J-40?
When I was shopping for a nicer guitar it was between Martin and Taylor and ultimately I went with a Taylor 314CE that I like for the brighter tone and the feel of the neck. When I play various Martins, the fingers don't seem to slide up and down the fretboard as well and just feel stickier. Does anyone else feel this distinction when playing the neck? Is it the strings, the neck wood, the neck finish? It bothers me so much that I go back to the Taylor for the neck feel. Is there a Martin series that feels like Taylor neck? I'd love to own a Martin eventually but it's hard to fine one that feels "right" (in my own weird subjective way).
I have the same problem,I own nine guitars and eight are Taylor's,I have a 1980 Martin D-28 in mint condition and original case and key to lock the case,This guitar is one of the best sounding guitars and the easiest playing Martin I've ever played but the neck feels like my fingers is a sticky glue feeling this guitar is all original and I can't figure out why it feels sticky,It drives me nuts,I have two Taylor 614ces one is the Builder's Edition and the other is 2015 614ce standard and my favorite guitars,I have 914ce,816ce,814ce DLX v brace,K-24 ce, Baby Taylor, Epiphone Dove.I bought all my guitars brand new except the D-28,I love all guitars.
I slide up and down the neck alot so I always put a small amount of baby powder on my fretting hand.
Die hard Gibson guy here, but my D35 is a beautiful guitar!
I thought Martin was the pinnacle until I picked up a Gibson J45 slope shoulder. I can't say it is a better than a Martin but mahogany really sings to me, I can comfortably play for hours and it can take anything I throw at it without getting muddy or buzzing.
I have a Martin OMe Cherry. I bought it because I liked the sustainable aspects of the guitar. It sounds really good and I like it. But I have been lusting after a CEO7 for some time. I may have to sell the OMe Cherry to finance a CEO7.
Hi Tony, I'm looking for a 12-string acoustic-electric. What I care for most is the deep rich sound. I'm looking at a Fender cut away but the sound is too tinny and it struggles to stay in tune. After seeing your video, I am very impressed with your knowledge, familiarity and expertise ( in addition to your playing skills). And you sold me on Martin, especially given the reasonable prices for the ones you featured. Is there one you would recommend for about $1,000? I am a novice. Thank you very much. Peter
The CEO-7 is a blues beast. nice shout.
I always love your videos! In this one, apples and oranges. Was a bit surprised to see the HD-28 come in so low. I own a number of these instruments and my HD-28 is righteous. Concerning your number one guitar, the CEO-7, I owned one. Loved it. However, the back split TWICE. Had it repaired TWICE. I know. Anything can happen. Anyhoo, sold it. Gruhn now has some new 12 fret D-28s that are amazing. Really amazing. Probably my next purchase. Again, I really enjoy your videos. Boogie forth.
Great choice. I go between my CEO7 and a Collings OM2H as my favorite acoustics.
G'day Tony..I'm thinking about a Martin D18...your video has sealed it! I already own a 0015m, a 1980 Tokai D18 copy as well as a Sigma J45 copy. Over the years I have owned 2 taylors...a T5 and an Ad 17 blacktop...time for the 'ultimate' Martin. By the way... the only way to make your videos better is to swap out that blackhawk jersey for a 'spoked B'...go Bruins!...lol
If the CEO7 was a dreadnought it would be a D18 Golden Era. I remember you playing it (short bearded) and saying, "Well to be honest, I really want it". I still have mine! These two guitars just resonate with my soul. Great choice though, just different sizes.
IMO, The D-18GE is the most wonderful mahogany Martin ever made. I traded 000-18GE for it, also a great Martin, but I love my 000x1AE so much. It’s really my go-to guitar, which is sayin’ somethin’ cuz I have 6 Martins, 5 Taylors and many others.
My favorite is my 77 D35.