I love them both, however I quickly become anosmic to the EDP version once I start wearing it, but it's indeed a masterpiece. The extrait version has a better overall performance, so it doesn't act as weirdly as the EDP one.
This perfume doesn’t have “notes.” It’s been designed around accords which are largely synthetic, which is why you can’t pick out notes. The medicinal quality that appears in the EDP is actually the saffron accord. It’s a magical fragrance.
I adore the extrait and it sits close to my body and I can smell it all day. However, I get 100 times more compliments when wearing the original, even though I go nose blind to it which is funny.
I heard so many opinions about Baccarat Rouge 540, I don't know what to think about it anymore! The idea is that most of the people I know say that it smells like medicine. But, you described it so nice! As far as I read reviews, it's a perfume that smells different on each person. My opinion is that this is a very complex perfume, that needs attention and a very careful examination, probably the price justifies itself this way. All in all, the comparison is interesting, and you give me such a good vibe,as usual.🤗♥️♥️♥️♥️
I have read a review that was saying the fact that Baccarat acts like a olfactive Rorschach test, what you get from it is part of who you are, your mood, etc. Thank you so much for always saying such nice things to me! I really appreciate it! ♥️♥️
I got decants of both and ended up falling in love with both. It took 5 wearing of each before deciding on which one I'd buy. Decided to get thr 200 ml of thr edp. It suits any season any reason a little better to me and wesrs better than thr extrait in casual situation. I'll still get the small bottle of the extract at some point. But that will be used for formal occasions and nights out. All n all both are absolutely amazing. I definitely suggest sampling both before deciding. A heavy price tag for a blind buy. Great review. Just now finding your channel. You got a subscription this way
First time to see your content on my TH-cam feed. Recently ordered samples of both the EDP and the extrait concentration, and wore each one, individually, then layered both on the third wearing. Others at my work didn't comment, but I did get lots of smiles and close contact with the ladies at my work. Not one of my coworkers were offput by the scent trail (or at least they said nothing if they *were* offended.) The positive attention could have been the layering, but who knows? Subscribed!
So happy I found this video! I ordered the edp from Bloomingdales and had them send a different one because I thought something was wrong with mine! I couldn't smell it at all and those around me said they couldn't either. The second one was the same so I ordered a sample pack from the mfk website including the extrait and don't have the same problem with that one! I'm planning on swapping the one I have now and just paying the extra amount because it is annoying, like you said. If I spend $300+ on a perfume, I want to smell it! Lol thanks for the info!
I'm so glad to have come across Oud Saffron by Orientica. The saffron on it is divine. This BR 540 on my skin fades to nothing and was a disappointment. Greetings from Colombia ,South America and keep up the great work !
Hey Noelle ! Great to hear from you ! I tried the Royal Amber and Amber Rouge which you uploaded 11 months ago. Still can't explain why I Oud Saffron Orientica made it onto my top 3 instantly . What a find !
Hey Noelle ! Hoping this finds you well. I eventually moved onto Baccarat Rouge EDP. I'm more than happy with it as my end of year signature scent .It works especially well with the weather on this side of the planet. Greetings from Colombia, South America.
Same. I don't have the extrait in my collection anymore at this point. I only have the Edp and I feel like lately I defintely prefer it to the extrait.
A lot of people say the baccarat rouge 540 is like a ghost on them but in my case when i wear it it stays on me and i can smell it the whole time... I also have tried the 540 extrait and on me it was not as strong as the 540.
Can you review MFK's BR540 & BR540 Extrait compared to Julianna's Perfumes Aurora and Aurora Extrait? I would really like to gain your feedback based on your nose. My nose tells me Aurora Extrait is almost identical to MFK. Lmk what you think?
This jumper's color is dreamy!! You look really good in it, suits you! I haven't smelled any of the two. I have although Cloud by A.Grande. I like it but it's just ok for me. Also, I can't really feel it a lot on me but a co-worker one time said that "it's really strong!! (emphasis on strong)" and one stranger said "I smell goood". I'm waiting on a decant of the extrait and I think I might prefer it because of the almond, which is one of my favorite note.
Yea, love the color as well, too bad it's a crop sweater :)) It's close to Cloud, but fluffier, creamier, smelling more expensive and less floral. Let me know when u get your hands on it. Would like to know your opinion. :)
I recently got the original. I get nose blind to the extrait very quickly. The extrait is a bit smoother and I can smell the almond note. Shame it doesn't work for me. I like to smell perfume I wear, to be wrapped in its cloud.
Great comparison! I sampled both and enjoyed the hell out of the edp but this "ghost like behaviour" really really bothers me. I've ended up buying the extrait since its indeed a touch more masculine
I own both of them and while I love both of the scents, I actually prefer the extrait versions scent due to the almond note, but the sillage of that extrait is not that good. The parfum lasts longer to me, so I'm not going to repurchase the extrait again. So I'm definitely buying the 6.8 version of the parfum when it runs out. I also own Gentle Fluidity Gold, Feminin Pluriel and Amyris Femme eau de parfum. This house is beautiful, I love it so much. MFK really is a master nose, his creations are the bomb!
MFK is a pretty amazing house, so many I like from them. I love Gentle Fluidity as well, Grand Soir, Aqua Celestia, Oud Satin and more... On me both the Edp and the extrait perform really good, but with Baccarat people have such different experiences. Thanks for stopping by and for the comment! 🤗
How to tell good from bad, juxtaposition, Noelle is the perfumery industry's biggest sensation, My own nose doesn't know what it knows, That's why I seek out the guidance of one who's surpassed all plateaus, Oh Zeita, how to put into words this poor heart's situation ;)
I must smell the original!! I love the extrait but the price is so high for me!!! I have a friend that he is noseblind in the extrait!! So thnks for the info!! I hope they are close and I will not have to buy the extrait!!! 😂🤣
@@IamNoelle ( 4 sprays EDP ) on skin no but the people around me said and on my shirt i can smell it loudly , i sprayed 4 on extrait does not have dat oomph in loudness category hence my money goes to the EDP 👌🏼
I can't help but wonder how popular this would be if it had been for 20 dollars at TJ MAXX ..i'll take the burnt sugar with vanilla on a cheap creme brulle any day over this way overpriced-for-what-you-get liquid
The ambergris I always have in my nose, but not all people can smell ambergris, that's with molecules mostly the case, MFK said its vanilla sugar that gives you this cotton candy vibe... It's just a magical fragrance, so soft, never to much, but at the same time that potent and long lasting, seductive, sexy and at the same time even appropriate for the office and just any occasion, plus, it's sooo amazing for layering, ufff, it layers with just every fragrance out there and gives them something special, today and the last 2, 3 weeks I'm absolutely obsessed w8th the Baccarat Rouge 540 EdP and Erba Pura (Xerjoff) combo, such an intoxicating, veeery potent in every way, seductive scent, yummy, if you own Erba Pura, you just have to try this combo, so, so good👌🤌🤪😘
@@IamNoelle yessss, love that you tried and liked it to🥰🤌💞😘 BR540 is just sooo good for layering, really stunning what this fragrance does, so many contrasts soft, but beast mode lasting power etc; etc...🤪 Stay safe, katharina👋😘💞
I love them both, however I quickly become anosmic to the EDP version once I start wearing it, but it's indeed a masterpiece. The extrait version has a better overall performance, so it doesn't act as weirdly as the EDP one.
Pretty much the same here 😝☺️ 🤗
My experience of them is the complete opposite. It's a strange one for sure. ❤
This perfume doesn’t have “notes.” It’s been designed around accords which are largely synthetic, which is why you can’t pick out notes.
The medicinal quality that appears in the EDP is actually the saffron accord.
It’s a magical fragrance.
Oh yes, I know it's done in the modern-synthetic way. Notes are listed, so of course I also took that into consideration.
Indeed magical! 🥰
I adore the extrait and it sits close to my body and I can smell it all day. However, I get 100 times more compliments when wearing the original, even though I go nose blind to it which is funny.
Interesting, this seems to be different for everyone 🤗🤗
I heard so many opinions about Baccarat Rouge 540, I don't know what to think about it anymore! The idea is that most of the people I know say that it smells like medicine. But, you described it so nice! As far as I read reviews, it's a perfume that smells different on each person. My opinion is that this is a very complex perfume, that needs attention and a very careful examination, probably the price justifies itself this way. All in all, the comparison is interesting, and you give me such a good vibe,as usual.🤗♥️♥️♥️♥️
I have read a review that was saying the fact that Baccarat acts like a olfactive Rorschach test, what you get from it is part of who you are, your mood, etc.
Thank you so much for always saying such nice things to me! I really appreciate it! ♥️♥️
Extrait for the win
Now if I really have to choose... 😝
I love looking at your face, hearing your voice, watching your feminine expressions, listening to the jazz, and admiring your beauty
Too bad I gave up the whole jazz thing ☺️☺️
I got decants of both and ended up falling in love with both. It took 5 wearing of each before deciding on which one I'd buy. Decided to get thr 200 ml of thr edp. It suits any season any reason a little better to me and wesrs better than thr extrait in casual situation. I'll still get the small bottle of the extract at some point. But that will be used for formal occasions and nights out. All n all both are absolutely amazing. I definitely suggest sampling both before deciding. A heavy price tag for a blind buy.
Great review. Just now finding your channel. You got a subscription this way
If you went for the 200 ml bottle, means you really enjoy it and hopefully will for a long time.
Welcome to my channel, happy to have you here! 🤗
@@IamNoelle absolutely!
First time to see your content on my TH-cam feed.
Recently ordered samples of both the EDP and the extrait concentration, and wore each one, individually, then layered both on the third wearing.
Others at my work didn't comment, but I did get lots of smiles and close contact with the ladies at my work.
Not one of my coworkers were offput by the scent trail (or at least they said nothing if they *were* offended.)
The positive attention could have been the layering, but who knows?
Subscribed!
I actually tried to layer them too and not just once, but I try all sorts of crazy layerings 😅
Happy to have you here! 🤗🤗
So happy I found this video! I ordered the edp from Bloomingdales and had them send a different one because I thought something was wrong with mine! I couldn't smell it at all and those around me said they couldn't either. The second one was the same so I ordered a sample pack from the mfk website including the extrait and don't have the same problem with that one! I'm planning on swapping the one I have now and just paying the extra amount because it is annoying, like you said. If I spend $300+ on a perfume, I want to smell it! Lol thanks for the info!
It's unfortunate you had to go through that whole hassle. 🤗🤗
Hopefully you get to enjoy your luxurious extrait soon. ☺️
I'm so glad to have come across Oud Saffron by Orientica. The saffron on it is divine. This BR 540 on my skin fades to nothing and was a disappointment. Greetings from Colombia ,South America and keep up the great work !
Happy you are enjoying the Orientica fragrances. Have you tried the new one?
Hey Noelle ! Great to hear from you ! I tried the Royal Amber and Amber Rouge which you uploaded 11 months ago. Still can't explain why I Oud Saffron Orientica made it onto my top 3 instantly . What a find !
The new one is called Velvet Gold and I think it’s worth a try at least, you might love it.
Hey Noelle ! Hoping this finds you well. I eventually moved onto Baccarat Rouge EDP. I'm more than happy with it as my end of year signature scent .It works especially well with the weather on this side of the planet. Greetings from Colombia, South America.
Same. I don't have the extrait in my collection anymore at this point. I only have the Edp and I feel like lately I defintely prefer it to the extrait.
Thanks for sharing the comparison review 👍👍👍
Thank you for watching! 🤗🤗🤗
A lot of people say the baccarat rouge 540 is like a ghost on them but in my case when i wear it it stays on me and i can smell it the whole time... I also have tried the 540 extrait and on me it was not as strong as the 540.
Well, you are lucky :) in that case you don't even need the extrait. :P
Can you review MFK's BR540 & BR540 Extrait compared to Julianna's Perfumes Aurora and Aurora Extrait?
I would really like to gain your feedback based on your nose. My nose tells me Aurora Extrait is almost identical to MFK. Lmk what you think?
I don't have them, but if I get them, I will 🤗
This jumper's color is dreamy!! You look really good in it, suits you! I haven't smelled any of the two. I have although Cloud by A.Grande. I like it but it's just ok for me. Also, I can't really feel it a lot on me but a co-worker one time said that "it's really strong!! (emphasis on strong)" and one stranger said "I smell goood". I'm waiting on a decant of the extrait and I think I might prefer it because of the almond, which is one of my favorite note.
Yea, love the color as well, too bad it's a crop sweater :)) It's close to Cloud, but fluffier, creamier, smelling more expensive and less floral. Let me know when u get your hands on it. Would like to know your opinion. :)
@@IamNoelle Of course, I'll let you know! :)
you changed so much from 3 years ago
Yes?
I recently got the original. I get nose blind to the extrait very quickly. The extrait is a bit smoother and I can smell the almond note. Shame it doesn't work for me. I like to smell perfume I wear, to be wrapped in its cloud.
That's too bad, sorry to hear that. You still using it even like that?! 🤗☺️
Great comparison! I sampled both and enjoyed the hell out of the edp but this "ghost like behaviour" really really bothers me. I've ended up buying the extrait since its indeed a touch more masculine
Thanks!! 🤗🤓 glad to know I am not the only one feeling this way about them both
This is so interesting, the extrait smells so much more feminine leaning to me!
I wonder what in it makes you feel that way 🤗
I totally agree with you I bought
both oh them EDP and EDP and
I was disappointed
Smell, lasting power? What disappointed you?
Thank you very much.I am a man and I want to buy a bottle of 200 ml (extrait de parfum).. Will I receive compliments?
Definitely! Of course it depends a lot on the country/region you live in, people can be less open about compliments in certain places.
@@IamNoelle thanks.. Can you tell me how long does this fragrance last (I speak about projection)?
On me it projects for about 7 hours, but I spray on clothes as well. The scent lingers for a long time on clothes, days and days.
@@IamNoelle thank you so much.
Hi, how is Baccarat rouge extrait de parfum doing in new releases 2021
I am not sure I understand your question 🤓
@@IamNoelle Haw is the performance of Baccarat rouge extrait de parfum in the new versions 2021
I didn't see any difference to be honest, did you?
I own both of them and while I love both of the scents, I actually prefer the extrait versions scent due to the almond note, but the sillage of that extrait is not that good. The parfum lasts longer to me, so I'm not going to repurchase the extrait again. So I'm definitely buying the 6.8 version of the parfum when it runs out. I also own Gentle Fluidity Gold, Feminin Pluriel and Amyris Femme eau de parfum. This house is beautiful, I love it so much. MFK really is a master nose, his creations are the bomb!
MFK is a pretty amazing house, so many I like from them. I love Gentle Fluidity as well, Grand Soir, Aqua Celestia, Oud Satin and more...
On me both the Edp and the extrait perform really good, but with Baccarat people have such different experiences.
Thanks for stopping by and for the comment! 🤗
How long does it take to go through a 6.8 oz?
I love them both actually...but most with the edp
Fluffier than the extrait?
How long does it take to go through a bottle like that?
Very long, but I decanted also, so I emptied it faster than normal.
Great review! Plus you look beautiful!! 😉
Thank you!! 😊
Which one will get you more compliments, sexier?
Hmm, hard to tell, I got compliments for both, people actually asking what it is because of the trail. Maybe slightly more with the EDP 🤗
@@IamNoelleThanks, I ordered the EDP but was thinking I made a mistake and should have gone with the `Extrait
How would you apply the extrait? Just blind ordered a bottle.
You mean where do I spray it? Back of my neck, arms, clothes as well, I like to soak in it 😅
@@IamNoelle Ok thanks hahaha how many sprays are that in total?
Umm between 6 and 15 I would say 😋
@@IamNoelle 15?! hahah alright, thank you!
Too much? 🤣
How to tell good from bad, juxtaposition,
Noelle is the perfumery industry's biggest sensation,
My own nose doesn't know what it knows,
That's why I seek out the guidance of one who's surpassed all plateaus,
Oh Zeita, how to put into words this poor heart's situation
;)
Oh my, such big words 😊😛
@@IamNoelle none is big enough for a Zeita 😉
Even the bottles say “light, daytime wear” and “stronger, evening wear” imo
Yep, pretty much 😝😘🥰
Nice video very cute
Thank you 🤗
i can't smell the edp 💔
That's sucks! 😔 What about the extrait?
Lovely 🥰👌🙈
Thank you 🥰
😍😍👏
🤗😘
Well spoken , respect ✊🏿 from England . The note 📝 listed are fake I don’t blame the maker who will bring out the real notes
That makes sense ☺️
Is English your second language?
So I like to believe 😅
I must smell the original!! I love the extrait but the price is so high for me!!! I have a friend that he is noseblind in the extrait!! So thnks for the info!! I hope they are close and I will not have to buy the extrait!!! 😂🤣
Oh yes, very close, unless you have a super trained nose. 😝 Tell me what you think when you get to smell the original. 🤗🤗
@@IamNoelle to me it smells like that pink cotton candy that kids buying on Luna parks in liquid form!! I really like it!!!
@@geomegalogiannis8161 oh yes, that too ☺️
i prefer your sweater ;)
Haha, now that's still something 😅
me too, I loove the color
i prefer EDP as it is louder
You can smell it all the time? ☺️
@@IamNoelle ( 4 sprays EDP ) on skin no but the people around me said and on my shirt i can smell it loudly , i sprayed 4 on extrait does not have dat oomph in loudness category hence my money goes to the EDP 👌🏼
I can't help but wonder how popular this would be if it had been for 20 dollars at TJ MAXX ..i'll take the burnt sugar with vanilla on a cheap creme brulle any day over this way overpriced-for-what-you-get liquid
Truth be told, now you can definitely find good clones for even less than 20 USD
Tfs
My pleasure 🤗
I have both of these (decants) and I slightly prefer the extrait
So do I 🤗
The ambergris I always have in my nose, but not all people can smell ambergris, that's with molecules mostly the case, MFK said its vanilla sugar that gives you this cotton candy vibe... It's just a magical fragrance, so soft, never to much, but at the same time that potent and long lasting, seductive, sexy and at the same time even appropriate for the office and just any occasion, plus, it's sooo amazing for layering, ufff, it layers with just every fragrance out there and gives them something special, today and the last 2, 3 weeks I'm absolutely obsessed w8th the Baccarat Rouge 540 EdP and Erba Pura (Xerjoff) combo, such an intoxicating, veeery potent in every way, seductive scent, yummy, if you own Erba Pura, you just have to try this combo, so, so good👌🤌🤪😘
Oh, I did try that combo and it was atomic 🥰
@@IamNoelle yessss, love that you tried and liked it to🥰🤌💞😘 BR540 is just sooo good for layering, really stunning what this fragrance does, so many contrasts soft, but beast mode lasting power etc; etc...🤪 Stay safe, katharina👋😘💞