You sir, are a real life hero. Took me 8 hours, 30 + attempts, but we did it as Arthur in Chapter 2. 2024 still works. I have no idea how you figured this out. Honestly kind of hilarious the length people will go not to do this as John. What a journey.
Lol he didn't figure it out. This method has been around for years, pretty much since R* patched the Bronte glitch. There's many other videos on how to use this method on YT. Some people use different wagons, like the one with large canvas cover, because this small buggy is a lot more fragile, and can be easily destroyed by pinkertons with 1 stray bullet to the lantern or the wheel. Also the big wagon can be found in Strawberry, so you don't have to ride from St. Denis across the entire map every time you die. But the buggy does provide better cover against the sniper, so it's still a better option imo.
This seems pretty complicated, but I guess I can give it a try. I mean, it's kinda unfair that Arthur can complete almost all of the challenges only for John to finish them when there's only two left. Specially when John can become his own legend in RDR1. Arthur deserves to be the Legend of the East.
I've tried this twice so far. My next attempt, I'm going to turn off the camera following just as I'm leaving St. Denis. That should give me enough practice. Controlling the horse, direction and the camera all at once, is the hard part. Both times I've been sniped through the back window.
I completed this. But I highly suggest you practice a lot before going down to New Austin. Turn off all camera settings when you're heading west out of St. Denis. Keep watch on your back window to make sure you don't ever see Arthurs head. Then practice with the camera angles when you're picking herbs. I tried this without practicing, and got killed so many times that I just gave up. But later I practiced it for about 10 minutes and was able to get all the herbs in one shot.
N'oubliez pas de casser les deux lanternes du chariot. Les pikerton peuvent tirer dessus et bruler le buggy avec une balle. ( Don't forget to break the 2 Lanterns. The pikerton may shoot them and the buggy will burn.) My apologies for my poor englesh.
@@jjpenny1 It was probably to keep players from exploring around the area of Blackwater and the Great Plains because of the Blackwater massacre. R* must’ve thought that if players managed to evade the Pinkertons, they shouldn’t be able to explore the area of New Austin, which’s most likely why they added the sniper.
spoilers the games plot wouldn't make sense. when arthur gets diagnosed w tb the doctor tells him to get some place "warm and dry" which is new austin. and his tb wouldnt be bad as it was when he died
It's definitely not ideal, but I think it's ok. It's just the herbalist challenge should've been something else so Arthur can complete it without doing any of this. Maybe they could've made it "collect all types of orchid" or something like that.
There's actually an easier way to get The Legend of The East outfit without doing any of the Herbalist Challenges. And it works, I just did it. You have to complete all the other challenges, but you have to complete Gambler 10 last, and you have tp do it in the mission where you play poker and save Reverend Swanson from the train. There's a video on TH-cam for it.
OMG I JUST FINISHED HOLY CRAP THANK YOU. But for everyone’s intro, after I finished I was like “I wonder if I’ll die in first person” cause I was too scared to test it before I finished. YOU DONT DIE IN FIRST PERSON IN THE WAGON WTF. WOULD OF MADE IT SO MUCH EASIER
@@theocharles3929 You don't have to save. the collection counts even if you die afterward. Also for gold bars from treasures hunting. you can just jump off the cliff if you can't find the safe way back. They will be in your satchel after you respawn.
Same...I get off the buggy just fine, but I lose cover once I go to pick the herb. Almost like the camera follows me through the action of picking it up
I have a question. At what level should I put my look sensitivity to be? I got wild feverfew with this method and I need 3 more, but I think my sensitivit makes it harder for me to adjust the camera properly
@@Brother_FrankI just wanted to come on here and say that I finally did it it took a bit of practice but as soon as I got the hang of it it became so easy thnx again
Just did it first try! Well, first try after not trying for a couple years haha. Really helpful video, thanks a lot! Now imma try and get those dinosaur bones as well!
Can you still get an Appleseed wagon after they've finished up there? I'm in Ch 4 and had done the missions (selling supplies, killing wolves) before I realised Did the Bronte glitch for trinkets, treasure, fish and animals but still need the herbs, a condor and a black-tailed rattlesnake for Survivalist 9 and Skin Deep/Zoologist
@@astroterf. Yeah, it´s the one with white fabric roofing. One always goes into Strawberry everyday between 8 - 9 AM from east (road with stagecoach). The roofing is big and it´s much easier to cover behind it in compare with Saint Denis buggy. Only be careful as the wooden parts are not bulletproof! So always keep camera in such angle so Arthur is covered with fabric.
So how do you get out you save your game then reload, or you save the game then let sniper kill you or do you have to drive the buggy all the way out?? Plz help me
@miw7376 No after collecting every herb I let the sniper kill me after that I respawn near Dakota river then I save the game and reload it. Don't forget to check if you collected every herb or not.
@@Brother_Frank thx for the fast comment I just died by the sniper trying to get the legendary cougar and I’ve just spawned by the river and yea the herbs are good, so why do you save and reload? Is there a reason?
After you've collected those herbs, I supposed you can simply set up camp and respawn in the safe part of the map? Even if you get sniped, it'll still say you've completed the challenge, right?
Is it possible to do this after the chapter 2 mission when we have to save sean?? Bcoz whenever I go into blackwater pinkertons kills me instantly after that mission is done
hai, do you have any recommendations, as i keep dying getting killed by pinkertons even before reaching beachers hope? how to survive the pinkertons in a buggy
I have 41 herbs collected becaus of this guide, thank you. But there is a problem. Even with "Camera Follow Level" Off, the camera still centers when i move and i have to manually position it so i don't get sniped. Is that a bug and how do i fix it? I play on PS5.
Thank you for the quick reply. I will try again and hopefully get the last New Austin plant i need. And afterwards go dillo and gila hunting if my luck allows it.
I cant even arrive to new austin because pinkertons break the buggy's tires. A couple times they even broke when law shoot them in saint denis, how is it possible?
@@Brother_Frank oh i thought i was doing something wrong, but if you tell me that it is normal then i'll keep trying, thank you btw you made a great vid. 💪
I’ll try it out soon! I’m in Chapter II and never finished the Epilogue as John but want to do this as Arthur! Can Arthur get the Legend of the East outfit, meaning can I complete all challenges as Arthur?
Complete the Survivalist, Herbalist, Weapons Expert, Master Hunter, Sharpshooter, Explorer, and up to nine on either the Gambler or Horseman Challenge. Bandit is unnecessary for exploiting a glitch to get Legend of the East. Choose either or, but the other must be completed beforehand. So if you decide Gambler, then complete Horseman. Here it goes. 1. The final Gambler challenge is to win three poker hands in a row. This can be achieved by winning two on your own then replaying He who is without sin(the mission where you save Swanson from the train). You're guaranteed to win the first hand, but shoot for a second win during the mission replay. If you're successful, then complete the mission. Completing the final challenge in a mission replay glitches the Legend outfit into your inventory afterward. 2. If you choose Horseman, tame all the required horses but the Hungarian Halfbred, complete Gambler, then replay the same mission as before. After saving Swanson from the train and loading him on your horse, beeline to West Elizabeth. You typically get shot at by law men, but they won't be there during this part of the mission. Avoid Blackwater, and don't try for New Austin(you'll still get sniped). A Hungarian is almost guaranteed to spawn over here, so just keep an eye out as you explore the open prairie. Once you find one, tame it, don't go to far from Swanson, complete the final challenge, and finish the mission. Once replay is completed, the outfit will glitch into your inventory.
@@Juggler1525do these still works in latest patch?and it still difficult coz we need to complete herbalist which getting to new austin for the remaining herbs is too hard to do.
Missions? No. Challenges? Yes. As John you can only do missions in the epilogue, John is not a playable character until you finish the main story. You can also do most of the stranger missions as John, if you ignore them as Arthur the entire game. But all the side activities like challenges, hunting legendary animals, catching legendary fish, and so on, are available for both Arthur and John.
this can be done in any moment? im in chapter 2 yet, about 35 hours doing everything i can in my second playthrough, and i just finish herbalist 8. i wat to do this first and pick herbs from new austin, then i go back and do the "easier part" in the regular map for arthur. and i just let the sniper shot me, or go back after i complete the herbs?
John's story in epilogue is just a bonus that has not much meaning. The logic here is why Rockstar makes us wait to complete all the challenges as John to get LOTE costume when we play 80% of the game as Arthur?
Arthur fans like and subscribe the channel😄
@@Brother_Frank one for all '& all for one
You sir, are a real life hero. Took me 8 hours, 30 + attempts, but we did it as Arthur in Chapter 2. 2024 still works. I have no idea how you figured this out. Honestly kind of hilarious the length people will go not to do this as John. What a journey.
Happy for you brother😇
How do you aquire such patience
Lol he didn't figure it out. This method has been around for years, pretty much since R* patched the Bronte glitch.
There's many other videos on how to use this method on YT. Some people use different wagons, like the one with large canvas cover, because this small buggy is a lot more fragile, and can be easily destroyed by pinkertons with 1 stray bullet to the lantern or the wheel. Also the big wagon can be found in Strawberry, so you don't have to ride from St. Denis across the entire map every time you die. But the buggy does provide better cover against the sniper, so it's still a better option imo.
You sir,are a fish
This seems pretty complicated, but I guess I can give it a try. I mean, it's kinda unfair that Arthur can complete almost all of the challenges only for John to finish them when there's only two left. Specially when John can become his own legend in RDR1.
Arthur deserves to be the Legend of the East.
I've tried this twice so far. My next attempt, I'm going to turn off the camera following just as I'm leaving St. Denis. That should give me enough practice. Controlling the horse, direction and the camera all at once, is the hard part. Both times I've been sniped through the back window.
I completed this. But I highly suggest you practice a lot before going down to New Austin. Turn off all camera settings when you're heading west out of St. Denis. Keep watch on your back window to make sure you don't ever see Arthurs head. Then practice with the camera angles when you're picking herbs. I tried this without practicing, and got killed so many times that I just gave up. But later I practiced it for about 10 minutes and was able to get all the herbs in one shot.
Thank you!
This means a lot to me
I finally got the herbs thanks to you😁
❤️
N'oubliez pas de casser les deux lanternes du chariot. Les pikerton peuvent tirer dessus et bruler le buggy avec une balle.
( Don't forget to break the 2 Lanterns. The pikerton may shoot them and the buggy will burn.)
My apologies for my poor englesh.
I didn't know this well thanks brother👍
I didn't see any poor English at all.
How did you break the lantern without burning the cart yourself though?
@@MrSpannners use the tomawak.
I just die in the buggy and when I save a video of it my head isn't even visbile
There is a hole in the back of the buggy maybe the sniper shot you from from that hole.
@@Brother_Frank I didn't know no parth of Arthur has to be visible although the sniper is shooting the horse😭
Yes it happened with me as well.
Hate the sniper element. I'm lost as to why they felt it so necessary.
They wanted to reserve some items of the game for John Marsten in the Epilogue I assume...?
@@jjpenny1 It was probably to keep players from exploring around the area of Blackwater and the Great Plains because of the Blackwater massacre. R* must’ve thought that if players managed to evade the Pinkertons, they shouldn’t be able to explore the area of New Austin, which’s most likely why they added the sniper.
Just to artificially give Marston playing time
spoilers
the games plot wouldn't make sense. when arthur gets diagnosed w tb the doctor tells him to get some place "warm and dry" which is new austin. and his tb wouldnt be bad as it was when he died
It's definitely not ideal, but I think it's ok. It's just the herbalist challenge should've been something else so Arthur can complete it without doing any of this. Maybe they could've made it "collect all types of orchid" or something like that.
There's actually an easier way to get The Legend of The East outfit without doing any of the Herbalist Challenges. And it works, I just did it. You have to complete all the other challenges, but you have to complete Gambler 10 last, and you have tp do it in the mission where you play poker and save Reverend Swanson from the train. There's a video on TH-cam for it.
Yes there is a way.
do you know if it can still register for 100% completion?
@@cedrus.forest_.it won’t register because u need to do all challenges for completion but u can still get the outfit as Arthur.
OMG I JUST FINISHED HOLY CRAP THANK YOU. But for everyone’s intro, after I finished I was like “I wonder if I’ll die in first person” cause I was too scared to test it before I finished. YOU DONT DIE IN FIRST PERSON IN THE WAGON WTF. WOULD OF MADE IT SO MUCH EASIER
Next time I'll try this
They should have put these herbs in Guarma
Well I finally did herbalist 9 as Arthur last night 😀
👍
When i complete them do i let the sniper kill me so i respawn faster or i have to ride back to safety
I think you gotta save and then you may die
@@theocharles3929 You don't have to save. the collection counts even if you die afterward. Also for gold bars from treasures hunting. you can just jump off the cliff if you can't find the safe way back. They will be in your satchel after you respawn.
@@toon.jane.or just set up camp, it will teleport you to safety
How r u setting up camp from wagon@@tataru1298
Even with the camera following off, every time I get off the buggy, Arthur doesn't get covered by the wagon. Is it a patch by any chance?
I didn't try in the latest version I'll let you know after I try myself.
So what's it ?@@Brother_Frank
Same...I get off the buggy just fine, but I lose cover once I go to pick the herb. Almost like the camera follows me through the action of picking it up
Same, second I leave the buggy I die
I have a question. At what level should I put my look sensitivity to be? I got wild feverfew with this method and I need 3 more, but I think my sensitivit makes it harder for me to adjust the camera properly
I uses the default sensitivity and I play in console but I think it is not about the sensitivity If you try 2 to 3 times you will get used to it.
@@Brother_Frank Thanks I figured it out.
BRO I LOVE YOU 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 THANK YOUUUUU I REALLY WANTED THAT OUTFIT
👍
@@Brother_FrankI just wanted to come on here and say that I finally did it it took a bit of practice but as soon as I got the hang of it it became so easy thnx again
Well done👍
Just did it first try! Well, first try after not trying for a couple years haha. Really helpful video, thanks a lot! Now imma try and get those dinosaur bones as well!
❤️
IMO, that big Appleseed wagon is much better for it than buggy.
Can you still get an Appleseed wagon after they've finished up there? I'm in Ch 4 and had done the missions (selling supplies, killing wolves) before I realised
Did the Bronte glitch for trinkets, treasure, fish and animals but still need the herbs, a condor and a black-tailed rattlesnake for Survivalist 9 and Skin Deep/Zoologist
@@astroterf. Yeah, it´s the one with white fabric roofing. One always goes into Strawberry everyday between 8 - 9 AM from east (road with stagecoach). The roofing is big and it´s much easier to cover behind it in compare with Saint Denis buggy. Only be careful as the wooden parts are not bulletproof! So always keep camera in such angle so Arthur is covered with fabric.
So how do you get out you save your game then reload, or you save the game then let sniper kill you or do you have to drive the buggy all the way out?? Plz help me
@miw7376 No after collecting every herb I let the sniper kill me after that I respawn near Dakota river then I save the game and reload it. Don't forget to check if you collected every herb or not.
@@Brother_Frank thx for the fast comment I just died by the sniper trying to get the legendary cougar and I’ve just spawned by the river and yea the herbs are good, so why do you save and reload? Is there a reason?
Does anyone know why every time a new Austin came in the sniper kills the horse driving my buggy?
After you've collected those herbs, I supposed you can simply set up camp and respawn in the safe part of the map? Even if you get sniped, it'll still say you've completed the challenge, right?
Yes
Can you also do this method to go to the stores in Ambarino and Tumbleweed?
Yes I also did this in video
Is it possible to do this after the chapter 2 mission when we have to save sean?? Bcoz whenever I go into blackwater pinkertons kills me instantly after that mission is done
Yes you can
@ thanks mate
Finally got a good run got the currant, got the first sage and then i die picking the last sage as arthur decides to move extra low ;-; the pain
🥲
@@matthewcolquhoun8486 you manage to get them?
hai, do you have any recommendations, as i keep dying getting killed by pinkertons even before reaching beachers hope? how to survive the pinkertons in a buggy
Follow the path which I took, keep going without slowing down and drink health tonics.
I have 41 herbs collected becaus of this guide, thank you. But there is a problem. Even with "Camera Follow Level" Off, the camera still centers when i move and i have to manually position it so i don't get sniped. Is that a bug and how do i fix it? I play on PS5.
No it happens with me as well
Thank you for the quick reply. I will try again and hopefully get the last New Austin plant i need. And afterwards go dillo and gila hunting if my luck allows it.
@@LivefromCBP best of luck👍
I cant even arrive to new austin because pinkertons break the buggy's tires. A couple times they even broke when law shoot them in saint denis, how is it possible?
I know brother but it is the only way.
@@Brother_Frank oh i thought i was doing something wrong, but if you tell me that it is normal then i'll keep trying, thank you btw you made a great vid. 💪
Wait so you have to constantly look above the cart so the invisible sniper doesn’t kill you?
Not particularly, you can drive the cart normally but there is a hole in the back of the cart so there is a risk.
THANK YOU
Aren’t there 6 herbs in the area? How do you get the other two?
I think there are only four herbs
There's 5: prairie poppy, wild feverfew, red sage, desert sage, blackcurrant
English mace can be safely got near O'Creaghs Run 🤠
You should see my version. Shots instantly.
It happened with me also in my first attempt.
@@Brother_Frank no I mean sniper shoots faster
In which are you currently playing?
@@Brother_Frank v 1.00 special or ultimate edition.
@@MRRZ-tn3vh Ohh I think it's a version problem because I did in the latest version at that time.
I think those are lawmen's, not Pinkertons.
is there an easier way to get in New Austin with arthur? i have done this way to complete the challenge long time ago , but it was hard and risky...
I don't think there is another way accept the Pronghorn method and that method is even risky than this
@@Brother_Frank i guess your right 🤣
I’ll try it out soon! I’m in Chapter II and never finished the Epilogue as John but want to do this as Arthur! Can Arthur get the Legend of the East outfit, meaning can I complete all challenges as Arthur?
I think there is a to get the Legend of the East outfit without completing all the challenges But I forgot how to do it I'll tell you later.
Complete the Survivalist, Herbalist, Weapons Expert, Master Hunter, Sharpshooter, Explorer, and up to nine on either the Gambler or Horseman Challenge. Bandit is unnecessary for exploiting a glitch to get Legend of the East.
Choose either or, but the other must be completed beforehand. So if you decide Gambler, then complete Horseman. Here it goes.
1. The final Gambler challenge is to win three poker hands in a row. This can be achieved by winning two on your own then replaying He who is without sin(the mission where you save Swanson from the train). You're guaranteed to win the first hand, but shoot for a second win during the mission replay. If you're successful, then complete the mission. Completing the final challenge in a mission replay glitches the Legend outfit into your inventory afterward.
2. If you choose Horseman, tame all the required horses but the Hungarian Halfbred, complete Gambler, then replay the same mission as before. After saving Swanson from the train and loading him on your horse, beeline to West Elizabeth. You typically get shot at by law men, but they won't be there during this part of the mission. Avoid Blackwater, and don't try for New Austin(you'll still get sniped). A Hungarian is almost guaranteed to spawn over here, so just keep an eye out as you explore the open prairie. Once you find one, tame it, don't go to far from Swanson, complete the final challenge, and finish the mission. Once replay is completed, the outfit will glitch into your inventory.
@@Juggler1525do these still works in latest patch?and it still difficult coz we need to complete herbalist which getting to new austin for the remaining herbs is too hard to do.
Is it still working on PC?
I didn't try but it should
@@Brother_Frank tks bro, ill try
What about the English mace ?
sorry🙂
@Brother_Frank it's OK
Can be found around O'Creagh's run
@theocharles3929 oh yes thank you
@@theocharles3929yep, just east of O'Creagh's Run at the crossroads north of Martha's Swain.
Frank can’t you do it with the Bronte glitch
No it doesn't work.
Herbs and Legendary Animals won’t spawn during the glitch
Can you complete all the missions with John or any other character in the game?
Yes with John.
Missions? No. Challenges? Yes. As John you can only do missions in the epilogue, John is not a playable character until you finish the main story. You can also do most of the stranger missions as John, if you ignore them as Arthur the entire game. But all the side activities like challenges, hunting legendary animals, catching legendary fish, and so on, are available for both Arthur and John.
Versão 1.00 spiner invisível é muito rápido 😂😢
Yes he doesn't even give you time to come out from the wagon
what if i just install a mod menu and turn on invincible? am i still gonna ded?
I don't know brother I never played on pc or used mod.
@@Brother_Frank im gonna do it after i eat my dinner, looks like it worth a try i'll give an update after
@@LzTwoFive ok👍
@@Brother_Frank IT WORK
great👍
this can be done in any moment? im in chapter 2 yet, about 35 hours doing everything i can in my second playthrough, and i just finish herbalist 8.
i wat to do this first and pick herbs from new austin, then i go back and do the "easier part" in the regular map for arthur.
and i just let the sniper shot me, or go back after i complete the herbs?
yes and yes
I tried my best , it aint good enough
Bro do the chapter 4 new austin glitch why even bother? Anyways nice toturial❤
but you can't get the herbs in Angelo Bronte glitch.
@@Brother_Frank yes you can try it out you have to do a extra step for the herbs to spawn and its tricky
@@adrienhaydari961 I didn't know that I'll try someday.
@@adrienhaydari961I just tried it and I got shot how’d you do it
The Angelo Bronte mission still has the sniper in new austin I just tried it
Does this still work?
yes.
@@Brother_Frank thank you, I just tried to get the Mustang by doing the angelo bronte skip and john shot him before I could tame him 😭😭
🥲
You can do this challenge as John also. No need to take the risk. Even the buggy method also don't go fine
Obviously, you can do it as John, but the whole point of this trick is so you can do it as Arthur and get him the legends of the East outfit.
Why have a challenge that you can't complete to play the game with cool clothes what's the point to this ..huh rock star
can you do all poi as arthur with this
poi means?
@@Brother_Frank point of interest (journal entries )
Yes I think so because you can inspect on buggy but you have to very careful.
Can someone please explain the point of doing this while you can wait till John
For legends of east and permanent 1 bar health stamina and dead eye
John's story in epilogue is just a bonus that has not much meaning. The logic here is why Rockstar makes us wait to complete all the challenges as John to get LOTE costume when we play 80% of the game as Arthur?
Because John doesn't count, any idiot can get it with John.
Good 👍 😊
thanks brother😇