Anwar faces brickbats for ‘bullying’ student in a Q&A session
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ส.ค. 2023
- Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim has found himself in hot water again for his behaviour towards a teenage student, with netizens labeling him as a “bully”.
Malaysians have expressed their dissatisfaction on social media with Anwar’s response to a teenager who asked whether the government planned to do away with the Bumiputera quota system.
During a dialogue session at Kolej Matrikulasi Pulau Pinang in Kepala Batas yesterday, the student requested that she be given time to explain some context before posing her question.
However, Anwar cut her off before she could explain, saying he already understood the question, and had already answered a similar question. Anwar also said the student should have refrained from discussing the quota system and instead should have pointed out specific cases of non-Malays being denied entry, allowing the government to address the situation.
Here is the full excerpt of the question and answer session between the student and the prime minister.
Video source: / 673163030929627
Nothing wrong with his answer. He even saved her from going deep into the question which might harm her in the future by others.The only thing is he should made it softer than very straight forward answer.
Nothing wrong with her question also. He was too abrupt in interrupting and cutting her off when she was trying to qualify her statement. For someone who claims to fight for freedom of speech, this is the hypocrisy demonstrated by him. Well, it’s only freedom of speech when he and his party say it. When others say it, it becomes seditious and challenging authority.
He just saved her from continuing those sensitive questioned which will harm her more after that. She was tried to compare results from nons to bumi & thats will get her trouble in her daily life. All need to understand she still need to study & live with others & teachers or student or even her bumi friends which most probably will not give a decent reaction to this.
Benar, itu soalan sensitif ckap pasal hak2 orang2 melayu, tak perlu nak jelangkan panjang2, to PM, dia pun dah penah ditanya oleh pelajar namun bezanye pelajar yg tanya dia sebelum ni tanya dengan sgt berlapik,
@@shafar84ify yep, and this is pathetic
Guys, u won't feel for student as beneficiary of the quota system. Asking question can harm her future??? Yes, he giving an answer as No, indirectly. Why we need to ask for Rayuan when we are the most eligible (with good marks) to enter university. Appeal for something we are deserved but u guys saying no!!
Well done to the student for being brave to ask the question.
Complicated question but I think Anwar tried his best to explain … social justice can only come about if we help the lesser I guess 🤔
The girl reading text...so maybe some adults ask her to read it
Adakah anda telah membuat pasport palsu dan menyelinap ke negara-negara dan mengganggu?! Tidak baik menyelinap masuk ke negara dan bertanya soalan. Jika sukar untuk tinggal, anda boleh mendapatkan pasport dan pergi ke Kerala.
@@hasnizamhashim1739 Persediaan media yang lengkap.
Then again the question might have been prepared for her by someone else. Notice that she was just reading from a piece of paper?
We hope and pray that the girl will not suffer in the school or society for asking this question bcz this is a democracy country and all the people have to treat in the same way...and there is no any wrong to ask question...bcz she still young and she is a questioning generation.. i appreciate the girl to take a brave action in this young age...ALL THE BEST FOR YOUR BRIGHT FUTURE GIRL
MIC should give her scholarship to study foundation at AMIST university. Their superhero 🦸♀️
Migrate to Singapore - where the World meets!!
I don't think any one can even touch her but she will be respected
It's better to be straight forward and honest, than to lead a man to his death.
The student asked a very serious question and the PM answered with seriousness. Such a question is very sensitive, and I think he handle it well. The PM is trying his level best to help everyone, let him do his job.
She is a child she doesn't understand the happening in Malaysia, but the way Anwar answers can't be excepted, he should know how to answer the questions
@@anthonydavid7251being a child is no excuse! With social media she should inform.
@@anthonydavid7251 exactly, thank god he didn't ask for her phone number.
The child may be sent by someone to read the question out.
He had shown he is a Fox 🦊
good question from the student with excellent reply from PMX as leader of Malaysians’ focusing on greater Malaysia 😊
Why malay student were quite..no guts..
"There's no quick fix solution." As I grew older, I became more and more open to this harsh truth. Well-said DSAI 🎉
Tapi anwar sendiri yang cakap harini menang esok minyak turun. Sounds very quick fix solution to me 😂
@@FahimRidzwan Hat tu cerita lain. Hat ni cerita psl meritocracy vs affirmative action...
@@teh5671 oh so abaikan hat tu, cari yg dia betul saja then sokong dia ka mcm mna?
@@FahimRidzwanKita x sokong. Kita x bangkang. Kita cuma setuju dgn dia dlm hal ini...
@@teh5671 jawapan selamat tu..
saya rasa pm cuba selamatkan adik tu dari jadi bahan politik. jika dia terus tanya dan habiskan ayat, mungkin akan ada ayat yg singgong org melayu, akan dihentam dlm jangka masa lama. sbb tu pm jawab terus. sbb nampak budak tu masih naif lagi. ini pendapat saya
Ya betul tu, sebab tu PM Anwar stop dia tanya soalan lagi
Adik ni tak paham sensitiviti bumi.. naye die nanti.. undang kemarahan dan kebencian pada india.. sbb tu pmx tegas bgtau kena tau sejarah.. supaya adik ni lebih berhati2 soalan2 sensitif dlm negara demokrasi dan hak bumi..sejarah matrik (hanya utk bumi)
Betol to bro, budak to sngat naif, jika dia teruskan memang kena kecam teruk nanti, terus ke soalan je tk pyah nak terangkan pnjang2, pdahal ada pelajar dh tnya soalan sama ,tpi to la pelajar to tak tengok temubual pm yg sebelum ni
Pandai
Hahaha... Why don’t u let her finish her question?
Your answer is bullshit.
I didn't think Anwar was too harsh on the student. It was a sensitive topic that required a thorough explanation.
He was harsh - he overtalk her, cuts her and intimidated her because it is a sensitive question. Even in 2023 we are faced with so-called Bumiputera poor students who will be injected into the system even though they do not do well. Even mentris children get the benefit. Truth hurts.
Anwar is not the same person after becoming PM!!
He is now showing so much indifference towards the minorities!!
No previous PMs had been this foxy 🦊
@@jegak1009 Yes, I am seeing this over a period of time.
I think, he has given a very reasonable, well-considered logical and holistic explanation. What bullying are you talking about??
Don’t make promises u know u can’t keep. It is akin to lying.
@@shasniper500this is the problem existed for a long time, we need to gradually change the policy since the current govt is aware of the problem. Policy can only be solved gradually not immediately as is not easy is a very sensitive issue.
@@shasniper500 policy take time to implement, need to be logical abit, 9 months in power u want everything to change , hello? at least 2-3 years, for anything feasible
Very important to change the thinking of most Malays have been enjoying favoratism for 60 years. It is hard for them to give up. It is their tongkat! A good government should start reuniting the various races as over 60 years Malaysia has divided Malays and non Malays by the racist Mahathir.
@@utube3888yes, many of my malay friend said, if other race want same chance like a bumiputra (malay and sabah sarawak). Lets make only one sekolah kebangsaan.. no need sk tamil, sk cina.. this is one of reason we cannot be together..
The government must facilitate more matriculation classes to fulfill the needs of all qualified students so that NO one will missed from achieving their goals because these are the student going to be our next foundation for economic development of this country.
Is not open more matriculation. Is make sure only those who really qualified get an A in SPM. All of us know what is the actual quality of A in SPM.
May as well abolish STPM entirely since no non-Bumi students are taking it nowadays.
why need this kind of classes in the first place?
@@gwstws0
@@tengfswhy?
As a Malaysian Chinese i had and is still very supportive of Anwar. He is one Malaysian leader who dares to tread where others dare not and speak out when others prefer to remain dumb. He is open and clean, and has gone through the test of fire (10 years jail + a black eye + sleeping on hard cold concrete bed) where not another Malaysian leader had gone through. When i was working for the largest bumi contractor in our country back in the 1980s, my boss told me Anwar (then the DPM) is incorruptible. My boss knew best as he was then the Penang State Umno treasurer. Yes, i would agree that Anwar needed to be a bit more tactful and patient with the student, but again this sort of question, i am sure, must had been put to him countless times, and he must had been tired of answering the question. To be fair and given the reality of the matter (quota system in our institutions of higher learning) being set for decades by BN and the later ruling coalitions, we cannot and must not expect Anwar to make any drastic changes now or in the immediate future. A slip on this matter would be disastrous and tantamount to political suicide for Anwar and the Unity Government. Let's all be patient and realistic, and allow Anwar and his team a reasonable time to set Malaysia back on the right track before we demand for them to speed the badly long overdue changes that WE ALL deserve!
I waited for 9 months after Anwar took over to see reforms in the discriminatory education system, but now Anwar discloses that the lopsided quota system will remain and ruin the lives of non-Malay students. It is heartbreaking to see the bright non-Malay students' plight go in vain. I salute the students who brought the issue into public, letting the public know the truth and enabling them to make better-informed decisions in elections, rather than blindly voting and expecting good things to happen. However, it seems that this important education system reform might not happen, rendering all other reforms insignificant."
aiyaaaaa.... Where is DAP? Mana pehrgi? dulu banyak bising cakap tak mau sistem qouta? sekarang pigi manaaa? aiyaaaa... ini puak since 1960s cakap pusing manyak pandai looor...
Quite frankly, I feel that deep inside him, he wants meritocracy system but he knows as well that he will lose support immediately from malays if he were to implement it.
@@justiceseeker3213 Why give him only 9 months? Why didn't you posted these queries to the previous government? I was thinking the same thing as you are thinking. I am a victim also but when he answered it, I immediately understand. We cannot be too selfish. Yes, we achieved high marks but if we picked all the high-achiever it would mean that the student from the rural school will have no chance at all. If they attended school in the city where all facilities are available , they might have achieved a better result than us . Please have an open- mind.
Who said that is bullying? He explained it well. Now, I understand why this happens. He explains it as if he is a father explaining to a child. I used to think that system is not fair but now I really get it.
Yup PMX answer it well.
Lost all elections was Epic! Damn! It's damn true!
The bullying remark is mischievous.
Yes help all, by helping based on 'needs' not 'bumi' status. I agree with reserving places for underprivileged. Because amongst bumi there are rich and there are poor. So why not reserve places for best performing B40 students?
Example, if there are 100 matriculation spots - 60% can be pure meritocracy (Regardless poor rich what race). The other 40% reserved for underpriviledge B40 (best performers amongst the B40 group, they do not need to fight results with the more privileged students whom as Anwar puts it has the best education support). Isn't this a fairer system?
Ah ah ah....come on lah Anwar....you should answer like professional PM.
I disagree the way you answe
She's like a lawyer like to turned very long here and there while not solving mass problems but only her points. PMX has given the answer. Otherwise it will never be fair for rural Sabah, Sarawak bumiputra to competes with those from urban schools
Look at how poorly you write. You are the result of a failed education system.
She is not looking at her points. She was speaking on behalf on her friends who scored well but was not given a chance. Watch the video. She also said that some of other friends who did not do well was given places in the universiti. PM did not give her the chance to finish her sentences but was overtalking her. Be brave to point what is wrong is very needed in this country then only we can transparent.
Bold Student , people should appreciate the student .
I hope Anwar can make Malaysia progressed like Singapore
The students should know you will lose a war on a battle you may not even win.
@@ummfaizal progressed but surpressed. absolutely no.
@@Noptszmh3862 you mean mentally suppressed because everyone not lousy or malas?
@@TH-c1k2 Anwar is a good debater, he knew how to control the situation to make in his grasp
Full Meritokrasi measurement is only can be applied when all students from any part of states who their parents regardless any race are equally can afford good foods, good clothings, good books, good learning gadgets, good internet connections, good tuitions, transportations and good schools.
Agreed. In a perfect world, it will be an applicable theory but as humans, we are in an imperfect world
You got free gov education and still tak gheti cakap Inggeris
Nuh. There can never be a perfect world and the more u try to intervene the worse it will be. Do u know that the Malays in Singapore income difference with Chinese Singaporeans are a lot less than the Malays vs Chinese Malaysians? If that is the case why should we still continue with the NEP policy? In the US they have this affirmative action policies where they put quotas for Black people at universities, civil servants, etc. When u look at the income difference between White Americans vs Black Americans and u compare that with White vs Black Canadians or Europeans. The income gap is bigger in the US. Moral of the story is, quota doesn't help anybody. It makes u complacent. Plus, what kind of values are u teaching your kids? You are telling them that you all are born as a loser therefore no need to work hard compared to other races. If u get 1-2 A's is good already u can go to the university because the government has already set quotas for u. If this is the message we are telling our kids then there is something wrong with us. Don't see yourself as a loser and u need the quota system to survive. See yourself as a winner and you don't need handouts. Teach them this value first.
Wrong! All students regardless of race and religion should be given equal opportunity without discrimination.
@@CWJ0725 go back to school learn some important histories of Malaysia.what the colonial British had done by practising divide and rule and what were the social economic impacts to the bumiputras and brought in immigrants.
After listening to the whole Q&A , I concluded that PM has answer this sensitive question brilliantly.
PMX should explain his views more kindly and not defensively
@@laurawong2509ask sensitive issue, when the answer not into your liking you bash anwar. Strange..
What about PM accuse her envy of the Malay student got into Matrix in first selection is that ok for your PM??????, some blind followers
PM given proper answers..don't politicise pls
And its ok for PM to politise his anwser.. 😂
@@bezybeez7296 he's a politician after all. When the going gets tough the tough gets going.
His answer is genuine and frank actually. If he tried to be popular with non Malay, he will be punished by extreme malay majority.
Too young to understand the reality and challenges we need to face in this country.
age 18 or 19 is not too young, it just means the girl is ignorance ....or the parent didn't play their role.
If yes why do we allow them to vote at 18?
u know what ? if this goverment = BN / PN .. what not i just go with them if all the same ? to old ma that not dare to steer wheel
@@guardian7keysproposed by Sadiq and approved by his atok
So young and yet treated with such unfairness.imagine you on the chopping block
PMX is broadening the student's view, showing her the bigger picture. Not just between her classmates and schoolmates. Well done PMX, whether the student can digest is a different story. No bully there for sure.
Broad your grandfather head, young people don’t bother to vote anymore, harapan without haparan , joker only
@@leehyunsong7001then vote PAS and PN. thanks
@@theramleon they will not vote. You still dont get the point lol.
Nah that girl is in the wrong time and in the wrong place. PM answer is just to win malay votes. Pity that brave girl
She is brave and wat pm said is true but I just don't think pm's way of answering which is the tone and etc is proper. Felt pity for the girl but then again it is the truth. Some things can't be done rashly
Dato Sri Anwar answered very professionally to a small girl to make her understand. He treats her as an adult by explaining to her beautifully what is a "quota" system is all about. The innocent girl will understand everything once she go back and watch the video again. Respect to Anwar. A true leadership quality.
In my opinion. i think the question was planted by opposition supporting management!!.
I see bullying to the maximum to cover up the political agenda of inserting more Bumiputra children into the system and making non-Bumiputra to beg or so-called appeal to get places in universities. It is okay to PM to see the poor and weaker scores to go to universities than those who worked hard to get a place. Do not sugar-coat things to make something bad look good. No wonder a lot of good brains are leaving the country for better pastures.
Good job for the student ...there is no bullying. Please be mature!
There is bullying. Be mature enough to acknowledge. Look at the way he cuts her off. Overtalk her. And do not let her finish her sentences.
@@stelfran1546He understand the question well, and avoiding the student to be used in future politicking as PRN is near..
We must look at the broader perspective then we will understand his response in this video.
Remember, we are watching "news reporting"... viral keywords are used to gain views! No harm in that as long as we understand.
Be mature, broaden ur perspective friend :)
the first 5 minutes, i was so angry on PMX's response to the girl, its seem too rude. but after explanation, PMX clearly explain the situation and how and what we should achieve. No big thinking from me, but at least we have a good leader to consider the benefits of country and rakyat. Its a long journey that we need to work out together.
At least PM is down to earth and share the same thinking with us. PM is really trying his best to guide and lead the country to a better future. Hidup Anwar, our future is in your hand.
I've the same feeling like u. I think it's rude that PM answered her at the beginning, but when he explained further, then i understand his points better. But if PM can interrupt and answer her in gentler manner, i think people will give him even greater respect! I love Malaysia and I do hope to see Malaysians living in unity and respect one another. Let Malaysia be a role model to the world that despite our differences, we can still live in the same house, if we understand and respect one another.
Malaysia, where I call home!
PMX is looking at BIG pictures (Macro perspectives). {👁👃👁}
Anwar amat sensitive dgn 3R
Jgn sesekali bangkitkan soalan yg boleh bangkitkan sensitivity agama bangsa
3R - race, religion n ?
@@feezyaRosmah
@@feezyaRoyal 😂😂
Kalu betul abg non sensitive ttg 3r,Napa dia ckp yg non Malay akn lebih teruk sekiranya PAS yg memerintah???
Mengapa rakyat Malaysia takut untuk bersuara? Adakah sensitif bermakna tidak adil dan cuba menutup mulut?
Saya sarankan lebi anak-anak muda bangkit dan tanya soalan. Jangan takut dimalukan, di sindir, dibuli dan sebagainya. Barulah kamu betul2 Malaysia Madani.
I don't see any bullying here, if can't accept the answer, don't ask the question
Don't do the Q&A session
And she asked stupid question, I noticed in every dialogues with students the same question will pop up, like it's already scripted, obviously she doesn't know abt what social contract is and yet demanded to abolish the meritocracy, minorities of 6-7% expect to be excepted every single of them? even there are many malays are being denied for matriculation because they too have to compete with each other in terms of qualifying results and the nons always thinks they are the best of the best and always playing racial card on almost everything. As malaysian she should study more on Malaysia's history and what is social contract all about and being living abroad for many2 years, these are the same people (not all) who talk bad things abt Malaysia all the time!!
Nk ckp pasal meritokrasi..tpi dlm pkrjaan kilang swasta semuany org dia jer naik dulu..gaji pon lain..
Sokong benar cina A india B Melayu C .....
Ye ke? Bagi nama kilang tu?
@@guardian7keyspengalaman aku dulu berkerja dgn sen Heng electric sbgi store keeper..kalo kat warehouse gaji memang lain2 ikut kaum..tak tahulah skrg mcm mana sbb dah berhenti sejak 2010
Kelang getah ada
Dorang apa takut, bila dah kenyang sapu subsidi, sedap je balik ke negara asal. Patriot bahasa mandarin dan tamil.
Student asked a political question so got a political answer.....
True
What political question it is long 65 years education discrimination issue that need to abolished, million of bright brain suffered from this 95% Malay quota system.
@@justiceseeker3213Yup, the PM already answered that...
@@justiceseeker3213 note that PM did say "gradually" he is trying to give others a fighting chance, to change their fates by slowly giving some of the unlucky ones a chance. Also note that he hasn't been PM over a year...TBH, on my point of view..yes the kid got a point...but PM Anwar gave her a direct answer which of course in my opinion is the truth but could have been delivered in a more softer tone
@justiceseeker3213 understand first contract social if you wants touch about malay quota, malay also can abolish tamil and Chinese language all speak malay no more sjkt sjkc
Faham je point anwar.Nak berubah tak boleh drastik nanti hilang kepercayaan undi majoriti.Benda ni makan masa.Sabarlah ramai lagi bumiputra terhimpit .
Boleh kalah pilihan raya kalau dia terus kata mansuh kauto😂,
itulah dah lah nak dekat PRN. sbb tu anwar cakap stop2 nnti tau lah pihak lawan cakap apa
@@amirism91Alangkah bgs nmpk langkah seterus spy kemenangan x tecapai...
Someone scripted this for her, could can see clearly she struggles...because its not written by her. Most probably some nonsense people wrote for her simple to attack PMX. I salute PMX the answer he gave .
Betul, kawan2 Aku dulu ramai je dpt A tapi ramai xdpt u, kena wat rayuan lagi. Tapi alhamdullillah berjaya dlm hidup. Dan sy jugak pernah mengajar Di kapit, Sarawak. Sekolah sgt uzur, dengan perjalanan yg mencabar untuk SMP ke sekolah dlm 5 jam perjalanan dari sibu, 3 jam perjalanan Dr kapit, belum lagi yg masuk jalan balak jalan mmng teruk atau naik sampan dgn perjalanan yg agak lama, dgn kemudahan kurang untuk pergi ke sekolah tersebut. Bila dh mengajar ada je anak2 kaum iban yang pandai tapi tak berpeluang untuk lanjut pelajaran dan sukan sbb tak mampu dan fakir Dr segi ekonomi keluarga, sebab kerajaan wat kuota cm ni baru mereka berpeluang nk masuk u atau masuk maktab perguruan.
betul..bila sebut bumi..majoriti akan fikir orang melayu, padahal suku bangsa dari borneo tu bumiputra juga, sana lagi mencabar nk dpt akses pendidikan ni
Indeed, sbb kan kuota ni lah org bumiputra sabah sarawak boleh menaikkan mobiliti sosial orang2 bumiputera
Ramai yg anggap bumiputera hanya melayu tetapi sebenarnya bumiputra itu orang asli, iban,kadazan juga bumiputera
banyak melayu semenanjung masih fikiran sempit ingat bumiputra ni hanya merujuk kepada mereka saja sampai lupa orang asli sabah dan sarawak
Ya memang patut mereka meneruskan pelajaran ke peringkat tinggi. Tetapi biar merken benar-benar laka untuk berbuat demikian. Jangan sebab miskin dan tak mampu tetapi gred tak kesampaian di masukkan dalam üniversiti atau maktab. Mereka yang tidak mampu patut di beri peluang yang lain atau menyediakan kolej yang lain dimana mereka boleh bersaing. Bayagkan markah SPM tak berapa maktab dan mengharapkan sistem meritocracy menolong mereka lagi. Saya dengar tildak sema yang menghabiskan semester mereka. Ramai yang telah kecundang. Di negara seperti Finland mereka hanya akan memilih sesiapa yang dapat markah yang baik dan berkeinginan untuk menjadi guru saja untuk masuk universiti. Mereka-mereka inilah yang akan menjadikan negara mereka lebih madani.
As a Chinese, I think what Anwar says actually makes sense.
Ya ke??? You ni chinese ke??😂😂😂😂
@@kindhearted9233 So? What's so funny about it?
@chngdexter2008 u too serious lah, kadang2 tak sakit pon kalau kita kurangkan emosi serius tu
Malaysia aren't ready for meritocracy yet. Better to get other alternatives like scholarship from private colleges.
"Meritocracy is a flawed argument if you don't talk about fairness"
I don't think I have ever heard a Malaysian prime minister respond on issues regarding school quotas in such an eloquent and affirmative way. I think the students who were present today have certainly been blessed to hear it in person. I am grateful to be alive in a time where I can witness such a great person leading our country.
👍🏻👍🏻
Problem with quota policy is that it is not based on income levels of families regardless of race. Rich malay students getting government scholarships to study overseas but poor outstanding Chinese and Indian students can't get access to government funds. Same with housing. Quota policy should be based on income levels, not race.
@@elimlinrr6898that mean you are failed to understand the social contract…
My cousin is straight 12A spm, Malay female but didnt receive any scholarship due to her parent wealth,,, she persue her medic school without any funding/scholarship..
is the same all the case or just few cases?I mean theres probaly some chinese, indian rich get the scholarship and poor malay didnt get it. Which mean it was special case one! or overlooked.Happened everywhere in the world@@elimlinrr6898
It's great for to have a leader who's opened for questions... Similarly we who questioned should be opened for answers...
SPM straight A's not offered anything
But, those 2 A's offered matrics.
You never know the pain
Yeah especially the ipg one, straight A also still won't get😂
That's why 47% of illiterates are actually muslims
We all know the pain
those with 2 A's are probably orang asli who live in jungle with lions and orangutans without basic amenities like clean water and electricity and their schools probably have no chairs and they need to walk 2 hours to school every day.
There way more better place than matrics.
No bullying la
Hanya anti Anwar saja banyak kecho..
Mulut bawang
@@loveme6067
Sy non partisan.
Dalam hal ini sy kata info Anwar buli itu tak benar.
Dalam banyak2 hal lain seperti janji2 palsu dari Anwar itu adalah benar.
Bravo PM. Tegas tapi lembut. The right answer amd the right approach, couldnt have said it any better.
Soalan ni sbenarnya da berzaman bersilih ganti PM orang bertanyakan tentang Meritokrasi..tapi isu ni tak dijelaskan sebaiknya malah politician pula ambil chance politikkan isu ni..Meritokrasi bukan tak dilaksanakan tapi execute by stages in accord with the constitution by the government but those extremist so selfish insist to get it secure by amend the constitution. no mean no la, dont test toleransi antara warganegara..lets educate our young so they dont get involve into confusion and live in harmony
I can’t agree more Sir, you’ve said the right thing and PMX has stood firm, walau pun dia baru saja masuk balik dlm Gomen. Policy cannot change overnight, yg tak dapat first round tu appeal lah.
Yang lagi satu. Ini adalah persediaan media.
pmx dah jawab,"faham dulu kontrak sosial"...kau je bingai tak faham
Isu meritokrasi adalah berasaskan pencapaian. Jika anak Tuan mencapai keputusan cemerlang tetapi tidak ditempatkan ke Matrikulasi mahu pun YTP Mara, mau pun mana tawaran, apakah perasaan Tuan? Fikirkan perasaan seorang budak yg telah bertungkus lumus utk mencapai keputusan tersebut. Sekiranya Tuan terpaksa menjawab kpd anak Tuan, "sudahlah nak, anda bukan bumiputera, takde lah peluang tersebut" Apakah rasanya anak Tuan akan jawab?
@@klzbd she was asking for policy of matrikulasi, was that termaktub in perlembagaan? masa tu takde matrikulasi pun bro. Jika PMX nak relate pasal kemiskinan, then show us the figure how many in the matric ctr are the hardcore miskin.
We shared similar experiences and frustrations with the young lady during our study lives. Knowing that your results are far better than others but have been rejected for further tertiary education.
Instead of harping on Malay special privileges and social contracts, the NEW government can increase allocation to expand and enhance infrastructure for matriculation courses. As the pie grows bigger, everyone will get a fair share, and there will be fewer complaints.
Secondly, maintain the current quota intake at existing universities, but we can establish at least two totally new universities where the intake will be based on meritocracy.
Thirdly, build more semi-government universities to cater for those who have been declined entry due to the present quota system.
My daughter got 9As for SPM years ago.. she did NOT get a scholarship let alone first batch.. i understand her frustration.. where do we go from here? Brain drain loh
no . matriculation should only for malay. love to see so many malay student admitted into matric in this video 😊
@@ayamjaguh2547should add other bumiputera also not only Malay we need to jaga our Sabahan and Sarawakian people also
@@ayamjaguh2547 yea. should allocate all and expand . then in the future, our medical field can save a lot of $$ bcos all those politicians, sportsman, entrepreneurs, businessmen... .... will get their medical treatments in neighborhood country.
She thinks she is the only person who knows this.
She is too young to understand the social problems the country faces.
PM cannot just change it overnight.
It takes time ..
I’m a Malay, very fortunate to have a son obtained 10As in his SPM. Despite applying for scholarships and attempting to get accepted into IPTA. he was not successful, and as a result, he is now studying in IPTS. I understand that there might be various factors contributing to this situation. As a Muslim, I am deeply grateful for the providence given by God, understanding that He guides our paths, even though I have observed there are students from different races comparatively receiving better opportunities. Franky its a bit disturbing for me hearing this kid making such simplistic assumption about bumiputra simply getting help although with just 1A, 2As, 3As with C and D...
U are in the same gang actually .the issue simplified to let everyone understand by dividing to bumi and non bumi.. we want Meritocracy to ensure those like your kid will have a fair chance.
So now you understand how it feels to be at the receiving end of this policy and system when you were most probably part of the problem
Dia nak bagitau seolah melayu bodoh pun masuk. Inilah idealism yg Di ajar untuk memusuhi bangsa bumiputera
@@XDLBY with all due respect, i think your are missing the point from @morpheus 5553. he/she was saying that bumi or non bumi will not ensure acceptance in IPTA. Anwar said himself that meritocracy is a flawed conception if the playing field is not same for everyone. we should not simply resort to bumi/non bumi argument whenever one's fail to get a place into IPTA because eventually even the meritorious bumi also do not get the place.
Biasala..play victim
Kalau PN memerintah pun sistem kuota masih tdk dpt dihapuskan.. there will be never be..kompeni besar2 pun yg taukenya bkn bumiputra pun tdk akan ambil byk kaum bumiputra espacially in management betul tak??
Entah, belum tahu lagi kerana PN belum ada PM yang kerajaannya beroperasi seperti normal
What PMX explained is very true..Thank you.❤❤❤
It's precisely people like you that we're forever in this situation in the first place and for years to come.
@@Popupong and there is different kind of "Tang" ,who is always act & think like penda"tang". But never achieved anything in real life because always pancut awal. This kind never seen the bigger picture in life. Can't even compete with own race & then blame the other race. You think China & India(country) will give free privilege's to malay(bumi) just because he/she was born there ? how is that fair. Malaysia give so much to chinese&indian here, but they(Motherland) never give the malay the special OKU school like them. Got any bumiputera school/special bumiputera quoata on those countries ke ? They(motherland) never give money to bumiputera organization like Malaysia did. Now let's relax & let that sink in.
I see nothing wrong with Anwars answer. Its not a personal attack, its a switch tactic to make a stern understanding for masses. That kid did nothing wrong either, its just soft skills to be learned in times to come.
Exactly, totally
I disgree with the headline from Malaysiakini. I don't see the 'bullying' here. It's unfair
Why must there be an appeal if the student has already proved his or her achievements with good results?
Why can’t the Govt take in these students on their first application without wasting the time and process to take in valid applicants?
It is very easy to understand what the PMX said. Quota must be in place otherwise the Bumiputera who is the majority in this country will not support the government. If the Bumiputera don't support the government and vote for the PN who are mostly the Malays, and PN rule the country the rights of non bumiputera will totally abolished. The non bumiputera will suffer more. We must balance between the social contract that we have agreed long time ago when we accept Indian and Chinese to get nationality of Malaysia. No countries in this world in which the majority race in that country will give their right to others. That's the fact.
What is wrong if give education to all.
So your are saying their proxy from private college cant make money..
how much tax do you pays yearly?
@pincominco6996 pls think before commenting. If better to have something, then nothing.
@@Anonymous-od3kh the thing is it is not the students role to understand why he or she is getting a good results but still rejected at local u.. i feel so sad for Msia.
@@pincominco6996 sure la can give all education no problem. after that lose election then you go out all wear long pants cannot wear shorts la. no big deal one hehe.
This is Anwar's style. If you follow him for long time you will know he sometimes talking too straight because he knows the fact.
Nothing wrong with PMX explanation…
Ingatkan Anwar Ibrahim tak ambik tau langsung psl kami org2 dayak dan bumiputera Sabah Sarawak 😂. Nasib baik lah tuyu2 pun ada jua isi.
Yg x ambil tau tu din cirit
Zaman PN lah bumiputra Sabah Sarawak tak diambil peduli, ingat kes remaja Sabah nak panjat pokok kerana nak cari line internet di pedalaman, satu pemimpin PN pun tak tolong.
@@pigdictator4558aku xseberapa percaya pemimpin d sebelah sana, dorg mana pikir psal kita, orang ambil exam atas pokok mahalan dorg argue lagi video tu ndak sma dgn waktu exam. Mmg bongok la, ndak kn kita lepas exam terus upload. Mau edit2 lagi, ini contoh lah salah satu
No Bullying Here. Anwar is stating the FACT! Non-bumi need to accept this. Such enthic quota can actually make the non-bumi stronger in one's lives as we have to work harder to achieve what we want. It also train us to be more independent and non-reliance on our government. We just need government to work harder for our economy and make everyone's life easier. I have full trust in UNITY GOVERNMENT!
then you better pray and make sure you have at least half a million ringgit set aside to send your children to local private institutions or at least 1-2 million to send your children to UK, US, Canada, Australia and NZ or even Japan/Korea/China/Russia/India.
Honestly this is a loaded question - if he answered the way she wanted, likely pn will demand he is charged with 3 R incitement. Just think for ourselves with a clear mind before throwing brick bats
Tapi boss budak tu belum lagi habis keluar kan soalan dia baru setengah pertanyaan
@@heloredzarul3938tapi saya rasa pm cuba selamatkan adik tu dari jadi bahan politik. jika dia terus tanya dan habiskan ayat, mungkin akan ada ayat yg singgong org melayu, akan dihentam dlm jangka masa lama. sbb tu pm jawab terus. sbb nampak budak tu masih naif lagi. ini pendapat saya
@@heloredzarul3938 Budak tu awal-awal lagi dah tanya bila PMX nak hapuskan sistem kuota dan gantikan dengan meritokrasi. Awal-awal dah sentuh hak bumiputra.
@@brokacakbrohensem5811 betul saya tak nafikan tapi budak tu sentuh bab madani saya pun bumiputera dan saya paham tapi budak tu bijak senang cerita lah budak tu menggunakan istilah madani dan dia pegang anak cina anak saya anak India anak saya..makan diri lah
@@assalamualaikum134 betul tapi budak tu bijak sbb bijak? Sebab dah 18 boleh mengundi sebab budak tu paham konsep madani dan budak tu paham Anwar ckp anak cina anak saya anak India anak saya saya bukan nak salah sapa2 tapi konsep madani tu tak sesuai tu sebab bangsa lain akan menunjukkan dan menuntut patut pmx guna istilah lain saya bukan nak sebelah sapa2 tapi benda Niee tak patut jadi budak-budak sekarang bijak tak mcm saya dulu2 leka carik duit nak dapatkan Nokia 3310 budak sekolah skang from 3 dan ifone 14 so bijak dia lain
PM had to cut off her questions for her own good before irresponsible content maker cut out that clip and turn it into racism bullets.. With that brief answer, it answered well too other questions like why PKR had to work with corrupted politicians even temporarily, why good policies are not being implemented yet; the government is still finding supports to be stable. Everyone wants results now but nobody willing to take the bullets.
Adik belajar sejarah , jangan bangkit kan soalan sensitiviti orang Malaysia. Terima kasih PM sangat membantu adik dengan soalan ini.
Kalau orang Melayu tak mundur, tak miskin dan senang mcm Cina, maka tak ada masalah nak buat sistem meritocracy. Lagi satu Malaysia dipecahkan kepada tiga aliran sekolah. Kalau nak meritocracy, hapuskan semua aliran sekolah berasaskan kaum dan hanya benarkan sekolah kebangsaan. Baru betul sama rata mcm Indonesia dan Thailand
Isu ini bukan isu sensitif. Tetapi isu benar yg melambangkan kepahitan pelajar yg telah belajar bertungkus lumus, cuba bayangkan ini anak tuan sendiri. Lagikan, sebenarnya sbg PMx tak usah lah bangkitkan isu sosial kontrak sebab mmg tak ade bukti kukuh yg menunjukkan kewujudannya
Semis sama
If talking about taking care of all anak2 msia, make sure at least 60% for top results students be accepted. This is to safeguard our country's future. Our country can't do well without talents. No talents no hope. This is the fundamental of education.
Anwar has clarified that matriculation accepts students in the first, second, and third intake, considering all eligible candidates. He additionally pointed out instances where there are Malays with 8A-9As couldn't secure matriculation spots. It's a direct response. Do you believe that matriculation slots are adequate for everyone? Also, the belief that Malays are currently underperforming in education, similar to the 90s? There are numerous high-achievers from all ethnicities, but matriculation also aims to include students from underperforming backgrounds, such as from rural schools. One of my friend which is Indian, got 3 As also accepted in matriculation. Why no mention? I believe many knows this, as it is a hit or miss luck in entering matriculation
No matter what reason, education is the backbone of the country. You may judge yourself how is the performance of the fresh graduates. Our uni ranking compare to nearest Singapore is far behind, that is the best indication of our competitiveness.
Appreciate our pmx, the student have to understand the situation in this country.
Meritocracy will disadvantage the have not, regardless. Leveling the playing field will benefit everyone .
Yes that’s true 🤔
We should be leveling the playing field at a far younger age, at the school level. Not at the university level. Higher education like universities should not be paying the price of incompetent schools by rejecting brighter students. Incompetence at the school level should be resolved at the school level, not giving preferential treatment at the university level.
If level playing field me from sabah interior would never be able to go to university when we don't even have Internet and electricity.
PMX said it well…but the education minister must be more concerned and put more efforts.
So you’re fine and okay with the quota system in varsities as a non-Bumi?
Why not you seat in PM shoes to make immediate changes did you listen to what did the PMX address to the students?I don’t agree with the quota system we need more of this type of brave girl to speak up and challenge the current system but do we have the capacity?
I admire the braveness of this girl who asked the question. The PM was brilliant in his anwers but it aslo seem to be the PM was impatient for the girl to finish her whole question.
PMX try to help her actually by not going too deep into 3R and sensitive issue.
She should have fully practice at home,B4 asking Q..🥴
@@loveme6067 She had written it out but abandon it when she was interrupted.
PMX saved her by stopping her early
The Q&A has to be done in a controlled manner. Many time I've seen this issue in these Q&A series. If everyone drags their question, then not many questions can be brought forward. Just ask the damn question. Don't take too long. Also please don't ask stupid questions!!! Kena tahu tentang sejarah is being a role of a student. What Anwar mentioned here is timing issue. You want a quick fix, you wait for stability to be achieved first. Especially when our political turmoil and national image has been heavily tarnished since a decade ago.
What do you expect from a secondary school student in public speaking - like our politicians? She did say upfront that she would need a minute or two to pose the question, didn't she?
@@yokng3778 ... You want voting rights, you should be able to take the uppercut. Our unprecedented Q&A sessions are still in an infant stage. Hopefully in years to come, the audience could be more mature throughout the nation. You could digest what Anwar mentioned by writing down the pointers he made at a clearer picture. Bear in mind, he is not anti other race. He is working on being fair to all in accordance with the stipulated legislation. At the same time, he hopes everyone is doing their respective parts as well to work on nation building. He is pulling the reins and the wild dogs are hard to be tamed. Takes time but sooner than later.
@@knock-knockwhosthere9933 u think time is not important for her? u think how many years needed for her become a voter? PM stop her to continue her question, mayb she will ask how many years needed then?
@@tiatine9752 ... This is where the MEDIATOR should've stepped up and intervened. The guest(s) for Q&A sessions should always be safeguarded. Since the first sesi dialog months ago until today, students are urged to go straight to the question.
So apparently this lady is questioning about abolishing bumiputera rights. That question alone shows her ignorance to the whole contemporary situation of national political climate. It also shows that she didn't watched the previous sessions done elsewhere just because it's not her homework.
But Anwar didn't reject her the moment she dropped that bombshell. He asked her to go straight to her real question because he didn't expect the same question. Then she resume by 'saya mahu memberi justifikasi kpd...' As you can see, clearly she already asked the intended question which she should kept it short without any long-winded story. So many similar question about this topic weeks back from previous temu bual or sesi dialog and still we are stuck with this topic.
Anwar urged the rakyat to follow his Q&A tour from media platforms as he emphasized "I understand.... Kalau you follow temu Anwar, ada yg tanya soalan tu saya (sudah) jawab. Lain kali follow this... "
It's impossible to provide a realistic answer to your question isn't it. One year? Two year?
Unfortunately he was always referred with such immature feedback similar to like asking bila harga nak turun when the explanation has been provided countless times...
In fact, the young lady should hold her head up high for this rare opportunity. She would know there's nothing to be ashamed of. Hopefully she would mature up from this experience. What doesn't kill you makes you stronger. She and everyone else should start following his Q&A tour and be less apolitical in interest.
@@knock-knockwhosthere9933
every1 talk on tis will go thru self assessment. She is brave enough to touch on it.
N she is a student, she wan to know PM's point of view and determination on the topic. Every questions should be appreciated by the politician bcos tat is the questions related to them n their votes, no matter being asked for how many times. (he has the time to edit his answer more perfectly after being asked for N times, right? )
Every party has their manifesto. N tis time there is 1 party touch on tis issue wif solution , PM's answer definitely will impact on the votes. i think she ask the question in good timing.
Kudos to Anwar for not shying away from difficult issues. A brave leader who tries his best to handle conflicts Great Job!
As much as pmx sounds a bit brash and overtoned,i would annoyed too if someone asked me long long question that can be shorten haha
Me too 😂
She is still very young. Understand that.
@@bernarddsilva9492 🥱🥱zzzz
I understand her frustration. I understand his frustration too. She felt it's unfair. He on the other hand his hands are quite tied too because like he said very clearly and frankly, if he were to demolish the quota system the Malays will vote the opposition bersatu and pas and we're back to square one. But at least now we will see changes. Give dsai and his cabinet time. Let them tackle this issue with caution so that we will not allow the opposition to take advantage. Patience is the key
Anwar has clarified that matriculation accepts students in the first, second, and third intake, considering all eligible candidates. He also highlighted instances where Malays with 8A-9As couldn't secure matriculation spots. It's a straightforward response. Do you believe that matriculation slots are sufficient for everyone? Additionally, do you hold the belief that Malays are currently underperforming in education, similar to the 90s? There are numerous high-achievers from all ethnicities, but matriculation also aims to include students from underperforming backgrounds, such as those from rural schools. On a related note, one of my Indian friends with 3 As was also accepted into matriculation. Why isn't this aspect mentioned? Many are aware of this situation, as entering matriculation can also be a matter of luck.
@@theramleon it's good to hear what you say. But if based on luck then something is not right coz it concerns our children's future. Hopefully the government will improve better the education system
To be honest , biar la budak itu ckp dulu apa yg ada dlm hati dia nanti baru jawab ..saya sokong jawapan pm anwar tapi suara itu jgn la mcm nak begaduh dengan bdk itu .
Setuju. Remaja kot. Mana paham hal politik. Jawab lah dengan lemah lembut dan kasih sayang. Budak tu la esok yg akan mengundi utk pilih kerajaan nanti
Yes, why kept cutting her off?
Dia dah penat explain tu..yg bukan melayu tak paham2 bahasa...baru jadi kerajaan nak tuntut macam2...waklu la.
.😂
@@Epiderm91 bukan soal tdk faham bahasa itu geng ...itu kan dia sedang Tanya soalan Kasi la dia peluang becakap nanti baru la jawab ..PM bukannya sedang becakap dengan orang mcm bung moktar Tapi dengan budak2 pula itu dia sedang becakap jadi tiapaya la mau becakap mcm style nak begaduh .
Kesian budak tu. Cuba buat mcm presiden Jokowi jwb dgn budak2 senyum dan ketawa. Ni serius sgt mcm nk makan budak tu. Dhlah budak tu cemas menggeletar.😅Mungkin dia potong soalan budak tu nk pertahankn budak tu takut lama2 budak tu tercakap benda yg melibatkn 3r tpi intonasi tu biarlah tenang sikit jgn la buat dia mcm lawan politik😅
if I agree to PMX, why not the quota should be given to less developed area/state instead of bumiputra? PMX is just trying to twist and turn around
As the elite Bumiputras can take advantage of the system as it doesn’t say it’s only for the poor Bumiputras
because once you gave away the quota advantage, the malays vote will turn against him and everything will be back to square one. you'd get PN+PAS as the central gomen and they would assume all the chinese are rich and all the indians are drunkard and none of the non-bumis will get to enter the public unis and the rest i leave it to your imagination. i'm a malay myself and i will still vote for PH, but i can't guarentee the others will do the same especially since the parliamentary seats spreads more towards the less developed areas where the majority voters are kampung malays and orang asli bumis especially in sabah and sarawak.
@@tengfs Nope.. the system did consider the poor people.. though quotas are more for Bumi's compared to non -bumi's coz they are majority.
Good answer fr PMX. Should nt question the bumi privilage and the quota.
Similarly should not question the existence of vernacular schools and non-Muslim places of worship
Good and reasonable answer from PMX but he could have used a gentler tone with that very brave student. To the young lady, don't be discouraged. Keep asking the tough questions. Kudos to you! 🎉
He explained properly nothing wrong with PM he gave proper answers
Nothing wrong with the answer. Rather the way PMX listens to the question and answers it should be better. The questioner is just teenager who doesn't understand current politic well enough.
@@asamoah631 i disagree. Muda has very strong point based on same topic . 'Nothing lose to choose Muda to b representatives, it wont affect the final leadership of the country' + Muda wan elites education system.
If PM wan every residents ( esp 18yo voters and their parents) to understand their hardship, then dont give blank cheque on education system in the beginning.
If the Quota system really benefit the poor, I'll support. But, if Rich Bumi using the Quota by sidelining the poor Bumi, that's where problem start. Plus, politicians misusing quota for their cronies
Belum abis lagi soalan nk disampaikan ko dh potong..apa ni
Bodoh berlagak pandai cm tu la
Which part of the PMX answer considered “bullying”? Nothing wrong with PMX’s answer! PMX has given a pragmatic and most rational answer! Change and reform need time to yield result…
For god's sake la Anwar, she's not your opponent in a GE sesi perbahasan. Adjust your tone and thought process according to your audience la.
Idea pn
do you think other PM will treat her well if anwar is not PM? You think Mahathir will treat her better? Mahiadin? Najib? Even Ismail? Be grateful when necessary because you don't know when the right extremist will become PM..
that s her fault, she s not a kid, she s an adult with no sensitivity and ignorant about the reality....she knows really well the retaliation she will get so she should be organizing her question without antoganizing anybody. She should be asking the question among her friends first, it seems like she has no friends?
@@Janggutan She has no friends? You got all that from that 1 clip? Nice projection, perhaps you should head outside more, meet some people and maybe just maybe one of them would educate you that kids in school uniforms are indeed kids; teenagers at best. Way to go trying to justify her being an adult, guys like you probably say that to yourself to cope as you try to wed one.
No part of her question was antagonizing towards anyone, what I just said to you on the other hand is. Know the difference.
Who is behind this student? 😂
I’ve been wondering it too
Yup, suspicious!
Respect her courage.
I don’t see it a bully at all. He saying it as is. And also it helps the students to think critically before even asking about a particular question. What Anwar said is true. I would prefer to have an affirmative actions in place rather than having a ‘taliban’ to govern the country.
Yes.. but the body language seems didn’t prove that..
It's how he cut short her asking of her question and talked down to her with a condescending tone. That's not good for optics in this day & age of the Internet. He should not have kept interrupting, let her ask freely and complete her questioning. Then he should answer in a calm tone and stop attacking her for assuming she's thinking unjustly.
Don't get me wrong, I agree with Anwar's answer and his handling of this very sensitive issue.
@@tweedy4sgAt beginning Anwar is not cutting her question but few times asking her to ask the question but she ignored him by carrying with her talk/explanation. At last Anwar has to cut her as she is not asking the question despite Anwar mentioned he already understand the question.
@@tweedy4sgit was supposed to be the last question, even before her turn the moderator did ask anyone who wants to ask the question to simplify the final question. But she took quite awhile to ask her question. I was watching throughout the whole program. Plus the same question had been answered previously in a different session with PMX with students
@@tweedy4sgtapi saya rasa pm cuba selamatkan adik tu dari jadi bahan politik. jika dia terus tanya dan habiskan ayat, mungkin akan ada ayat yg singgong org melayu, akan dihentam dlm jangka masa lama. sbb tu pm jawab terus. sbb nampak budak tu masih naif lagi. ini pendapat saya
He asked the girl what is meritocracy and then went on to explain what is not meritocracy.
PM biar lah pelajar habis Tanya dulu baru jawab.
pm cuba selamatkan adik tu dari jadi bahan politik. jika dia terus tanya dan habiskan ayat, mungkin akan ada ayat yg singgong org melayu, akan dihentam dlm jangka masa lama. sbb tu pm jawab terus. sbb nampak budak tu masih naif lagi. ini pendapat
ade benda yg disembunyikn la tu, kesian adik tu xabis tnye, pmx koyak rabak🤣
PM Anwar answered brilliantly. Watch the whole video. He said dont talk about quota if you are referring to justice. Justice means giving equal opportunity to all including the poor. Poor students may not score high but they need the seat to improve their life. Meritocracy is ideal
U r right
Totally agree
We don't know the result of poor rural student.
But, within same school in KL, Rich Bumi 4A get offer, straight A poor non Bumi don't get offer. It's a clear oppression.
Meritocracy is an exaggerated virtue. I would suggest that we consider other philosophical perspectives: utilitarian, libertarian and Rawlsian principles, to name a few.
The PM is in a unenviable position between a huge ROCK and a VERY HARD PLACE as the saying goes .
So all those who are demanding justice and fairness and meritocy please bear in mind the society we live in
We have to be more patient and give this UNITY GOVT a chance to govern justly . Or the alternative described by him will lead to disaster for everybody and the country as a whole .
MALAYSIA WILL END UP A FAILED STATE . GOD FORBID!
At this moment this is the best government under these circumstances . We have no better choice .
S .KULASINGHI
Anwar already give a good answer ...
Did he say "Don't change the system or I won't be prime minister any more and you will suffer more? ???
Solute to a very courageous girl. 10 for you 0 for the Atuk!Bravo👏👏
Then go vote for more extreme leader, see what kind of answers u get pulak
I bet u that she will get more propper answers by the ‘extreme ones’.. because i can see anwar is only desperate to hold on to his PM position..
@@nadakamaruzaman1027 ye la tu, dah pergi main lato lato
She's like Greta the puppet environment activities kid all her question are written for her,
You must be crazy
Status quota ini tidak akan dimansuhkan selama-lamanya.
Tengoklah dalam kabinet pun sama juga.😊
Sebab termaktub dalam perlembagaan
This is at least a honest answer and takes into account the political realities in the country. All should think carefully before even asking questions!
In Singapore, no student is left behind bcos of race or religion! My government puts in 💯% effort to help everyone complete the education marathon. And there are hundreds 9f foreign students studying here
Like one Malaysian Malay journalist said,
"Give the man the power, and you can see his True Colour!".
Anwar is showing his colour!
I'm not Malaysian but I can see that answer by the PM is very clear and educating. Something that Indonesian politicians should learn response clearly like him. I don't understand why some politicians in Malaysia is using it to attack him. I think Indian people should see what happens in India. How many Muslims were intimidated and denied access to education?
lain kali suruh PM jelaskan tentang kontrak sosial baru la budak ni faham..ada orang pergunakan budak ni untuk tanya soalan pening..pastu salahkan PM pulak
Kontrak sosial perlu dimasukkan didalam silibus semua jenis sekolah rendah agar anak2 ini terbuka mindanya dengan realiti kehidupan di negara ini
sape yg pergunakn bdk tu? tlg bg pnjelasan, ke sekadar nk tuding jari? fitnah?
@@kayrool3357 jangan la marah.bukan cakap ko pun
Good question and bad answer.
Brave & courage girl well-done.. hope more such young people across all Malaysian..
Bad question & great answer. The girl looks above 18 & should be responsible for her own actions.
Isu kuota pendidikan ini amat sensitif di Malaysia sbb keperluan kuota utk bumiputera telah termaktub dlm Perlembagaan.
Namun, peratus dan garis panduan dlm pembahagian kuota itu mungkin boleh diteliti semula.
Sesiapa saja yg menjadi kerajaan yg cuba utk menukar Perlembagaan akan berdepan dgn tentangan politik yg mencabar.
Malaysia belum lg bersedia buat masa kini. Jika nak dibuat pun, ia perlu melalui kerelaan golongan bumiputera itu sendiri.
Jadi nasihat saya buat pelajar2 bukan bumiputera, jadikan lah ini sbg pedoman dan cabaran buat diri utk lebih gigih berusaha tanpa diberi tongkat
sbb tu PM kena berhati2. nnti backup cina & india nnti cakap anwar komunis oleh pihak PERTIKAIAN NASIONAL tambah lagi dkt PRN ni. tapi nnti Pertikaian ni nnti spin anwar pun sama tak pandai jaga hati cina & india. abis tu cer bagi suggestion mcm mana nak solve benda ni. wahai Pertikaian
Boleh set kuota utk anak T20 bumiputra juga, anak mereka mampu belajar di swasta jika tidak masuk matrikulasi. Biar lebih ramai yg tidak mampu dapat belajar matrikulasi tanpa kira bangsa
Kenapa dia tak bangkit soal kewujudan sekolah venakular? Bahasa Malaysia India di Kelantan Kedah Dan Perlis jauh lebih baik dari lisan BM dia.
Xkira pembangkang atau kerajaan, yg ni xboleh dinafikan hak keistimewaan Melayu sebagai bumiputra
Mudahnya sembang bab kuota ya...hapuskan dulu SKJK Tamil,SKJK Cina...tak kira peringkat rendah ke menengah ke...dah settle semua tu baru bule sembang bab kuota Matrikulasi...nak keistimewaan sangat kan...tak pun mohon dari Kerajaan buka IPTA jenis Kebangsaan Tamil dan Jenis Kebangsaan Cina...bule camtu...adoi betol apa yang dia tanya dan apa yang dia rasa...tapi dia belajar sejarah ke tak???I'm not try to be a racist here but I try to say a fact...jangan nanti seperti pepatah Melayu mengatakan dah diberi betis nak peha plak dah dapat peha nak dada pulak...
Perjanjian.. kontrak sosial . Toleransi Orang Melayu tak cukup lagi ke?
PMX has his point. But I think it’s good for PMX to allow this bold young student to say first without cutting her off. Then you can explain to her your point of view as much as you think you’ve been repeating the same points while thanking her to voice out. Just a bit of patience to listen will do a lot of wonders. Give these future generations to voice out whether their point of views are naive or not.
I think he is trying to protect her. She can finished her questions but she may later be taken action or people around her will have emotional reaction against her questions. So it is better to avoid asking this in front of so many people under quota system.
@@gwstws I think you have a point, he was trying to protect her by taking this measure. Whatever the answer given, I am very satisfied with PMX. Even-though Im not Bumi.
She just repeating her lack of understanding in social fabrics of Malaysia. What else she want…..?
@@nizamcheani4182 She is brave enough to bring up this question in the event. But she is still young, and we do need this kind of brave and young generation. To be honest, quota system needs improvement or change is needed. Anwar acknowledged this also but as he mentioned it needs time. Please give him some times.
We really support PMX brilliant reply . It is not that anyone can change the mindset of an entire community . Let PMX find the solution .
To all the students who laughed, giggled whilst she was talking ... You should be ashamed of yourselves.
Rohingya yg dihalau myanmar beranak di Malaysia sudah bergenerasi pon nak hak sama rata, hak kewarganegaraan. Nak tanah. Nak meniaga. Nak free education.
Ada yg jd kontraktor. Bawa masuk byk2 orang asing yg tak faham sosial kontrak mmg akan masalah.
Bumiputra sudah byk tolak ansur boleh jd warganegara, bekerja, hak mengundi, jd tokey hartanah, jadi menteri.
BUMI sendiri pon tak dpt semua berapa byk yg tak dapat peluang pendidikan yg lebih baik, berapa byk yg tak ada rumah tak mampu beli hartanah.
Tak payah la nak play victim dan mempersoalkan apa yg termaksub dalam perlembagaan.
Betul kata anwar cara soalan tu boleh diolah dengan lebih baik.
Some haters composed the question using the poor girl
A well asked question by the student but our PM answer was not to a student but more to a political adversary. His tone must be softer and melodious not harsh. Learn from mistakes.
Terbaik PMx dlm menjawab soalan ini.
Kena tahu sejarah, social contract dan latar blkg sekolah2 yg daif di pendalaman esp Sabah Sarawak dan kampong2.
Hak kuota Bumiputra pulak yg nak dipertikaikan. Bagi betis nak peha, bagi peha nak dot dot dot..
Tidak buly...Penjelasan yg jujur...We Malaysian must understand Our polisi .PMX know what to do for non bumi.
I can see that most of the questions regarding quota in public universities are asked by Indians. You lot should know better that there is no way under this or even the next, next or next generation of Malay citizen in this country will allow this to happen. In the age of Tik Tok, TH-cam, IG, ChatGPT and climate change, a paper qualification in tertiary education is no longer a guarantee of employment. The people needs to move ahead of time. I am not saying that paper qualification is not important but one should not limit yourself to only public university. Vocational education can be promising and other technical skills which will not be disrupted by AI. Until a time where majority of Malaysians reached the kind of wisdom where they no longer see or play 3R card in politics, education, economy and social, the quota in public university entrance will still be around for awhile.
Tanah Melayu nama asal Negara ini. Kami dah gadai nama negara ini. Toleransi termahal. Dah tiada nama tanah Melayu tapi Negara India, Cina atau Indonesia ...kamu tak nak tanya ke?
Jgn lupa org Bangladesh dan Pakistan yg banyak membuka perniagaan di Malaysia. Buka lah mata
The headline is definitely misleading. So much care and respect has been given in Pmx response to the question.
Sbnrnya awl2 mmg agak defensive, even as a Malay, i would feel bad bila dijawab sebegitu. 🤣
tp sbnrnya dia cover last2 tu dgn baik. In the end, this happened for a reason. Hrpnya lebih ramai yg fhm lps ni. It’s a lesson for me too.
Jgn lah sbb PMX keras sikit kali ni kita pn attack kemain lagi. Sikit2 dah la.
Selama2 ni dia dok jwb elok2 kita x bg credit pula kn.
This not first time. Previously a young chinese boy also treated similarly. It's not about the question, but the way he treats them as if his trying to show his ultra side, maybe to attract opposition votes, while using fear mongering tactics to keep minorities in line. Minorities had started feeling he turned his back on them as soon he embraced his former rival parti. Not forget minorities are still his largest voters, a major challenge to opposition. If he continues this way, his coalition members might start worrying about their own political survival next election and loses faith in him leading them. Once he unable to retain his position, his new partners most likely abandoned him too, just like they did to muhyiddin.
So what and how should he answer it to satisfy both - Malays and non-Malays?
He is in dilemma. Not wanting to lose Malays but also the safe-deposit of non-Malays votes.
This is always a lose-lose situation. Must choose side eh?
Then we all should abandon PH & vote for PN/PAS. I'm very sure PN/PAS will favour the minorities. Boleh?
Don't be another naive youngster la. You don't have a choice. You can either vote for PN/Pas or choose not to vote. Both ways you still LOSE BIGTIME as a minority under Muhyiddin or Hadi. Anwar is still the best person to lead Malaysia and at least he's trying to make Malaysia a better place for everyone but it has to be gradual as the Malay vote is of paramount importance. Be understanding la
@@DK-ks4idmaybe not to vote at all or cast a spoilt vote or best is vote with your feet. Why do we have to be forced to choose between the two, either this or that?
So, PN , PAS and bersatu is your alternative to PMX?
Masy'Allah Allahuakbar Permudahkan urusan kami semuanya aamiin
She's very good🎉❤
Please answer these questions and never interrupt the student.
PMX menyelamatkan pelajar perempuan tu dari terus menyentuh isu 3R yang sngt snsitif.
Dia tanya soalan pun x nampak adil. And PMX dgn bijak cepat2 matikan soalan dia dan tahu kemana arah soalan budak tu. PMX dah bijak menjawab. Kebenaran itu pahit tpi kena bertegas supaya x jadik peluru bagi pihak pembangkang.
Sir PM... Sejarah? Since merdeka until now its almost 60 years... Who is running this country ? Rulers are Malays , Pm is Malays , First to be served is Malays... Whatever benefits is giving to Malays because they was been left behind... Ok !! 🤔 If i get the opportunity to ask a question..
1. What the government been doing for 66 years and until now the malays are suffering...
2. Bumiputra is to be served first in many things for 66 years but why sir pm pointing there are some malays schools is left behind ? What the gov been doing for 66 years ? How many schools are left behind 1million? Gov can throw billions for unnecessary things in just few months but can't spend for malays schools in this 66 year's?
3. EDUCATION System and government jobs is occupied by Malays 80% for 66years and why they can't come out from the left behind status...
Other religion in Malaysia respect the Perlembagaan and following the law and order that been fixed by our elders ( sejarah ) as what sir pm said...
My Dear Malay Friends and Family... You guys must do some sejarah research as our dearest pm said... For 66 years malays got all the rights and all the opportunities to raise up but until now is left behind means sure something is wrong... Left behind is Rakyat Melayu and the people who incharge of bringing them up for 66years is well settled... Do some research sejarah for 66 years what is the reason why malay community is left behind and who is the reason... Do you guys really think politicians cares about their citizens ? Hopefully our pm sir will safe us Malaysia... Settle this matter and wont further it for another 66years more...
Theres nothing wrong with PM's answer. Its just the tone of his answer and how he constantly interrupts the girl that made him look like a bully. I mean anwar could've taken a softer friendlier approach but he was definitely a little bit harsh here.
i dont he is harsh. But Anwar try to save the young student to go deep into 3R issue, that's why he just proceed to explain, so the burden will be at him, not to the student.
@@ahmadwiraputraselamatphd4303 which she already did with the 3R topic