The Great Conversation: Marx's On the Jewish Question
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 มิ.ย. 2024
- This video is a recording from the February 17th session of The Great Conversation: How Should We Live? We are currently in Volume IV of the series, focusing on themes of Ideology and Emancipation. Join the conversation at www.abigailadamsinstitute.org... and subscribe for more videos!
His real name was Moses Mordecai Levi.............
Mordecai my ass you liars the gig is over these Nietzsches are not jews non of them are
I don't trust a nazi to tell me Marx's real name
.
Wrong, it was Herschel Halevi, later changed to Heinrich Marx.
@@matthewgallant3622 that was his fathers name clown.
Is this the complete video? Is there a longer video of this discussion at the Abigail Adams Institue Home Page? Was this part of a previously offered course at the institute?
Hello! We typically only record the introductions to each session, as to allow for a better discussion between participants! This was part of the Great Conversation series, a 4 semester, 4 volume survey through the Western Intellectual Tradition! We discussed this during Volume IV: Ideology & Emancipation, and will discuss it again in the spring of 2023.
Marx's vision seems zero sum'ed in regards to our labor and the capital(ist) extracting labor.
There's no place for value added by commerce and thus presumes that the laborer must lose out in this system. Marx was a fool or a liar.
Sorry for the horriblr structure of my question.
Wasn't sure if I was going to watch this. Orthodox icons in the background? Okay. I'm in. Excited to hear whatever you have to say.
Exact opposite for me but I'll give it a chance.
was good.
what Orthodox icons?!
Same thought
@@Trowa71 same, it's just more jew nonsense under a different banner
@@chingonbass Jew nonsense? I don't think we are on the same page. It's religious nonsense in general, no individual religion is specifically bad. They are all equally bad.
I found your video because I am seeking to find the possible connection between marx, in his analysis, not necessarily as go to for political orientation, and ancient ways of life of the Jewish. I suspect the hate that Romans, and other civilizations hated about the Jewish was that they figured out a way of being free, and happy, by living a simple life.
The Romans did not hate the Jews, as they did not hate the Gauls, the Hiberians, the British Celts, the Greeks or the Egyptians. They found nothing specifical in the Jews, they just handled their revolt the old way. Jesus instead had lot to say about Jews way of life.
Well if we are going to get technical about language, let us remember that this is not exactly an academic, nor genuinely intellectual venue. Therefore, no one will be able to tear down a whole notion, and the importance what is expressed by nit picking at words. Especially when we are trying to speak in ways that the internet generation can understand. If the Romans hated all such cultures it is because they were considered a danger to their monopoly. The Jewish ways, however, showed an alternative that, in spirit, philosophically goes against the wealth, and power Romans, and their competitors were all about. During those times, however, the Roman influence began to seduce many of the Jewish leaders, and that is part of what Christ did not accept.
@@flaviodrusovalerio2825 Thys is not an academyc venue. So do not even try, being disrespectful, by nit picking at people's comments. It is so typical of systemic thought to consider irrelevant any notiion that does not fit its paradigm of power. The Romans were constantly warring for economic domain, and seduced Jewish leaders away from their frugal, if practical way of living.
Super "in the weeds" tush here. This separation of "State" from society makes the West a laughing stock to the Islamist of exceedingly strange manfulness.
It’s called integrity and humanity lol
I would say it's other things like liberalism instead. I know many secular states that did great. Europe was greater than any Islamic society we ever built only because the European had greater Ethics by strictly following their religion more and even when they lose their religion they still had those ethics for a while.
Muslim barely followed their own religion after the murder of Caliph Ali, son in law of Muhammad. But many Muslim majority society which had strong ethics even though they were living Islam behind were still doing great. Like Iraq before the invasion.
It boils down to the ethics of society.
Liberalism opened the door to Commercial ethics of Society and State as the police of the wealthy. As against the ethics of the Whole Country as Dugin is guided by.
of course marx wasn't jew non of them are he was anti-Semitic anti jew
Marx est juif ,un juif lucide ,espèce très rare
@@pierre3982
no he wasn't his father and mother were Christian baptized
@Critique Everything
no he wasn't ,non of them were , even hertzel his grandfather was Serbian christian orthodox but they call him jew today how did that happened I don't know
@@messianic_scam his grandfather was Orthodox Jew.
Marx's family was originally non-religious Jewish, but had converted formally to Christianity before his birth. His maternal grandfather was a Dutch rabbi, Marx's family was originally non-religious Jewish, but had converted formally to Christianity before his birth. His maternal grandfather was a Dutch rabbi, while his paternal line had supplied Trier's rabbis since 1723, a role taken by his grandfather Meier Halevi Marx. while his paternal line had supplied Trier's rabbis since 1723, a role taken by his grandfather Meier Halevi Marx.
Credit: Wikipedia