I hate to admit that Americans give better Canadian news coverage than Canadians. CBC news is unwatchable, it's a giant Alberta / conservative propaganda circle jerk.
Tyler, you doing these weekly news reactions is more news than many Canadians read or listen to. A byelection is held when a MP resigns, dies, or for some other reason loses their seat. A byelection must be held within a certain amount of time after a seat becomes vacant.
Yes, the 'by election' is a mini election that takes place only in the riding in which that mister had jurisdiction, or responsibility for. Through the by election, the Liberal held seat will be filled by a Bloc Quebecois member in this traditional Liberal riding. Similar to the people electing a Democrat to Congress in a solid Republican state. Fear by the Liberals that a change in trend is taking place.
I am Canadian but I watch American news all week because Canadian news is so boring, then I catch up once a week by getting my Canadian news from this guy
The stabbing story is also insane. I think most Canadians feel they should face a more severe sentence. Whether she delivered the fatal blow or not, it was attempted murder and he probably would have bled out regardless. it was murder, and many of us do not understand the sentencing.
And the article implying that ADHD is a valid reason to go lightly on her is sickening. ADHD is not uncommon, and while it results in unruly children hard on their poor moms, the vast majority of them are not psychopaths.
to me, a case like this suggests indefinite psychiatric confinement. Also, ADHD makes it hard to pay attention. It has nothing to do with stabbing people.
@@danmac-d7w What a smoothbrain thing to say. Whats not to trust about polls that have him in supermajority position and nearly doubling Trudeaus popularity? Perhaps you'd prefer a diffrent sample group? A larger one? a more biased one? What makes you think they arent representative of Canadians views? Is it the outcome?
Our judicial system is definitely more lenient. The first one that comes to mind was the “brutal rape and murder “ of a young teenage girl . Her murderer was found, tried, convicted, served his time and was released all within 13 years. It makes absolutely no sense to me.
We also dont have any kind of registry to know if you live near a potential predator, this has claimed many lives. A good example being the McHale Busch case in Edson, a RELEASED sexual offender was living next door and he killed a mother and her infant in a brutal way. They never knew he was there, nobody did.
A bye-election is what the US calls a special election. The BQ winning this seat off the Liberals, is like a Democratic candidate winning in Marjory Taylor Green's district.
Tyler, you're reaction is correct... You SHOULD find it shocking when hearing about violent assault and murder. Not bc you're American and don't expect to hear such news in Canada, but bc that's how we as humans should react EVERY TIME we hear about such acts against another living being. No matter who, how, where, or how frequently it's done, it should be shocking. Every. Time. And no one should ever get used to it.
These attacks happen because, like our American neighbours, the mental health system is failing and we have our own percentage of bat sh!t crazy people.
The main goal of the Bloc Québécois is to defend and protect the Québécois interest at a federal level. However, this party could never be elected to govern over Canada. Its ultimate goal is to pave the way towards an independant Québec. What is too bad is that voting for the Bloc Québécois at a federal election takes away a vote for a party that could govern. In my opinion, if we want to remove a party, we are better to vote for its biggest adversary. We should vote according to our personal aspirations and convictions, but voting for the Parti Québécois is a "lost vote" if we want to remove a party from governing. 😏
Strategic voting is spitting upon democracy and makes you part of the problem. This isn't a hockey game, vote for the candidate who best represents you, not to 'win'.
The Bloc should be blocked as a federal party because they don't have candidates in elections outside of Quebec. The rules need to be changed so that if you want to be a federal party you must run candidates in all provinces and territories.
Sometimes the biggest adversary is also not the best adversary. That is totally the Quebec way of voting. After 50 years living there, I now have a broader choice of who to vote for.
If I had a bloc candidate here in NS, I would vote for that person over the greasy libs or pathetic PC party... they should really make a move to gain seats outside of Quebec, I bet there could be some seats thrown their way. Especially in NB and the many French speaking parts of NS.
A by-election, also known as a special election in the United States, is an election used to fill an office that has become vacant between general elections.
A "By-Election" in Canada (and the UK) is the same as what the Americans call a "Special election". It's an election held in one district in between elections to fill it when it goes vacant early.
The bear attack one is kind of a "glass is half full" situation. Yes, he was attacked by a bear (major bummer), but...he's still alive (major winner winner chicken dinner)! 🫠
Many ADHD persons are hightly impulsives, its one of the main characteristic of this pathology... An impulsive person won't think and react like most people...
The big deal of it all is that Trudeau is from Montreal so it was also considered a home-town riding for him. The parties look like this: Bloc - want Quebec to separate from Canada NDP - left wing Liberal - Centre left Conservative - right wing Green - left wing but most concerned about the environment Tyler, you're doing a great job understanding our country! The effort you put in is awesome!
Bloc isn’t technically there to “help” the separatists movement, they are there mainly to do anything they can to help quebec “while” they are a canadian province. I mean they are of course pro-separation but they don’t “work for it” necessarily
Ndp aren’t central. They are more left than liberal. They only took socialism out of the party constitution in 2008. They still have the NDP socialist caucus as part of their party
Sad story of Kenneth Lee: He was going through mental struggles and his wife kicked him out of his own home. While he was on the streets, he made a girlfriend. Those 'usual suspects' group of 14 year old girls demanded cigarettes, didn't get any, and proceeded to beat up the girlfriend. Kenneth naturally stepped in to defend his woman, and that's when he was deleted for it! All those girls got very lenient punishments! . . . Here in Canada, the usual suspects always hate and try to delete Asians! Government and law enforcement don't give a shit either! Conservatives want to make a White Canada! Canada is phooked!
If you need more of an escape from the Dumpster fire that is the US Presidential Election, we have at least three provincial general elections in the next month, (In British Columbia, Saskatchewan, and New Brunswick) in Canadian Politics to keep you distracted.
The US is definitely harsher on violent crime, while canada can have a bit of a Viking mentality on violence where it can be more acceptable to fight out disputes. Remember, Canada is the reason for many things being listed as war crimes 🤷♂️
The the Lloyd minister shootings happened in Saskatchewan. I wish you had covered it because these things don’t happen that often in Saskatchewan. It’s actually a few hours from where I live and my coworker actually knew the people :(
Re the border situation. There is a pipeline coming up through SA, which you may know about. Migrants are shipped from the US southern border to the north. Then, thousands were walking across at Roxham Road (Quebec). They were met by Canadian officials and shipped to lodgings in PQ, NB and NS, and held for processing. Lodgings - hotels and rentals. If you google Roxham Road border crossings, the story is on this platform. The justice system is in shambles, police don't come to calls, and lawlessness has taken over. jmo
We (most of Canada) are so sick of the Trudeau scandals, corruption and wasting taxpayer money ( enriching family, friends and cabinet members), while Canadians are suffering, living on the streets, and the crime rate has significantly risen under the liberal party. I'm so done with them!! We feel the same way about that girl getting away with a violent crime resulting in death. The liberals are very soft on crime, the Conservatives plan to be tougher on crime, no catch and release with them. I'll definitely be voting Conservative as soon as I can.
@@dianedee7919 once upon a time I may have agreed that they were a viable alternative, but today’s Canadian conservatism concerns me deeply. I worry this is one of those “cut off your nose to spite your face” situations..
@@deegee5526 at this point we’re just switching back to the other mechanic that also did a substandard job. Poilievre has been around for a long time. We’ve seen him in government. He has a track record. It isn’t very good. I’ll give him credit though, as an opposition MP, he’s an ornament to any parliament.
@@vicfak3915 I understand your concerns, and I usually vote liberal, but after everything they've done over the last 9 years, I just can't do it. I don't like where the NDP is going , Jack Layton was their best leader. Conservatives seems like the lesser of the evils to me.
As for the teen swarming/stabbing. It appears that she MAY have been mistreated while incarcerated - a number of strip searches, not always allowed to be brought to the court for her sentencing & sent to a remote facility where it was hard for her family to see her. AT BEST - I think they need to find her a closer, possibly better managed facility (then again I don't know the details of why the things happened to her there. She MAY have tried to steal a knife from her dinner etc. I just don't know the circumstances.) What I DO know, Tyler, is that YOU ARE RIGHT. MANY TIMES Canadians including myself - think sentences should be longer - including myself with this one.
I’m glad you spoke of Northern boarder,because no one does. There was Jhiad here in Montreal heading NY via Roxham Rd. Before this incident we had ISIS in Toronto planning bomb attack. I’m very concerned for all citizens of North America!🇨🇦🫶🇺🇸
The rest of Quebec varies a lot in federal elections, but most of Montreal usually heavily favors the Liberal party in both federal and provincial elections, so this is a big deal for Justin Trudeau's party, but le Bloc Québécois remains a very center-left party too.
Hey Tyler. Always great to see your interest in Canada and offering up another perspective. What I would say to you is that much of what happens in the US & Canada are interconnected. Our major political parties share the same sub-contracted consulate groups that are used down in the states and many of the tactics used are tested on one side of the border, then if they work, they try them on the other side. Much like the US, we share a lot of the same polarization and division that is going on. I find that there is a giant lean currently to stomp out Canadian's ability to get the true news going on and the push is on to see more similar results to what the US has. Where a lot of the time, you just can't get the news, even from one state to another, without going to look for it. And even then, it might be curated and leaning more left or right than what the truth is actually. It's impossible to talk about politics here without people getting worked up, just like down there. My own opinion is that people came out of the pandemic and really had time to think... And realized just how much everyone was not on the same page. And the political parties and business community now want to capitalize on this and divide the country further. There is a lot that we take for granted here, that I know Americans often look at and say, something like that would be amazing to have here (health care for example). What you don't see is how much we become under pressure to conform to the US model of how to do things. Canadian's, again in my opinion, tend to care deeply and get very upset when things are moving in a direction that doesn't feel like it's true to our identity. Saying that, I think people just want change for the sake of change. They actually don't know what they want... Which is kinda a big deal and even dangerous. I somehow think you and other Americans can relate with... You know there and what is going on. I find, atm, we moved a lot more left leaning for some of what the country (and especially the businesses and politicians) would have liked and the push is on to flip it back. People can give there own opinions, but let me use Alberta as an example. They went from roughly 50 years of the conservative party being in power (our version of what the old Republic party was sorta like) to skipping over the liberal party (which was sorta like the democratic party... But really... I kinda feel the Dems are even more right leaning than our liberal governments) to going all the way to the NDP (who for many, would be seen more extreme left - depends on who you talk too). Regardless... They went hard left... And they lost there minds over it XD Next thing you knew, they voted in the UCP - which is bordering the line of trump level extremism (again, my opinion - I'm sure that would upset some people). Remember the proud boys originated (sadly) from Western Canada. Also, the first act of the UCP was to vet, block and filter news there. And it's a policy that many of the right leaning parties feel strongly about. The current push by the Conservatives is to try and get the country to move back towards the right, but there is definitely a aggressive mix of opinions on how much they will want to match to "trumpism". It kinda feels like when trump was first elected down there. People wanted change and just didn't want the same old thing. I feel like there is also an attempt to shield and silent the younger generations of Canadians, who are becoming more powerful to vote and tend, again in my opinion, to lean much more left than any of the political parties would like. But I feel also that people don't feel represented or have someone they see and feel comfortable to call a leader. Many have long forgotten the original reason Canada voted Justin Trudeau and the liberal government in. And having the minority government shouldn't have been a bad thing, if the system was working and they were actually trying to work for the interests for Canadians. Instead, we can't even have school groups visit the House of Commons because, they all act worse than a baby going through their terrible twos. Canada has so much and their are so many positives. But we definitely are going through many of the same pains as Americans are. And while some of it is different, there is a lot that is being affected by how linked we truly are. I just hope in the end, people don't loose sight of how unique and precious our US / Canadian relationship real is. We may not always agree and we might have our differences, but I think in our hearts, we want to believe in each other and be able to know we have each other's backs in the good times and the bad. Maybe I'm too sentimental and hopefully, but I love my American family and friends. And just to make sure you know I'm Canadian - Sorry eh for the long winded message. And as one great Canadian said many a time - Keep your stick on the ice! 😉
Tyler: you do understand. In Canada we don't have the death penalty, but murder is serious. The Conservative Party is campaigning on increasing punishment for serious crime.
Tyler, our judicial system here in Canada is absolutely disgusting. Criminals get next to no punishment and our homicide crime rate has went up 100% in the past few years. Our Government has a "catch and release" policy they made and follow and criminals are rampant here now, unfortunately. We aren't even allowed to defend ourselves because if we do, We will be prosecuted and punished befiee the Criminal would. It's awful and shameful 😞
I’m not going to speak about the leniency of Canada’s justice system vs. the USA… but just Google Canada vs. USA crime rate. I remember hiring a US consulting firm to look at how to improve our police operations, and they laughed at us being concerned about our major crime rate.
To help you understand the Canadian government system (also used in UK, Aus, NZ), the Executive branch is chosen from the Legislative Branch of the Government. That is to say, all executive members are also members of the legislature. However, very few members of the legislative branch are members of the executive branch. In the federal government, there are 338 MPs (members of the legislative branch.) There are also 105 Senators. However, there are fewer than 40 cabinet ministers (executive branch.) Under the US system, there are three separate branches of government, the executive (pres and cabinet), the legislative branch (House and Senate), and the judicial. A byelection is an election to replace a vacant seat in the House of Commons. I think they're called special elections in the US.
I thank you so much for what you do always looking for the positive. I love your insights into seeing this news in Canada.And it makes me go back and look at the stories and see them.A book from the information I get. I love how you approach all this and how you try to be.Kind in what you're doing.Thank you
😢 I believe that Canada's forces would do well to force dangerous individuals, regardless of age, to join the front line. These are people who clearly have a need for violence that is not being met, but are too concerned with their own self-preservation to enlist themselves. I killer instinct in our forces could be an asset. It would rid our streets of these dangerous individuals. It would free up places in prisons. And it may instill a sense of pride in their otherwise wasted lives. If they die in battle, they will have died a hero's death. If they return home, they will be heroes worthy of respect that had repented for their transgressions. The same applies for American inmates with a predilection to violence. Make it useful! Men like Gus March-Phillipps were amazing soldiers, despite their attitudes. That's who we need in our militaries
On the topic of house prices, you may find it interesting that in Canada, there is no interest deductability for income tax. All mortgages are paid out of pocket
Just heard of this. On the 21st In Kalamazoo, they're having Canadiana fest. Just seen the commercial while watching the red green show lol. Apparently they'll have a booth there as well.
I know this has been mentioned a few times over the last week or so , But are you going to finish the Halifax explosion video ? seems a fair bit of people are waiting for that xD.
There was never a coalition. The only coalition in Canada was in 1917. It was a confidence-and-supply agreement. Educate yourself about parliamentary democracies.
My boyfriend was stabbed in the heart and killed in 2009 by a 15 year old. Kid got 3 years served 6 months. Canadas justice system is awful. The kid lives free while myself and children live with the loss. If I spoke my truth you tube would likely ban me
I don't get the legal system in Canada. If he was able to protect himself and survive the attack, he probably would've faced a long jail sentence for doing so. That's how "balanced" the system is. You can't protect yourself without serious repercussions, no you aren't allowed to shoot a burglar if they break into your house and you're a licensed responsible gun owner
The teen getting probation: most media outlets are shockingly bad at covering legal proceedings. I'm sure court transcripts would put the decision into context. "Journalism" is far too click-baity these days.
Other comments: - a 🇨🇦'n army problem.. not a sleeping bag problem - Calgary has been rationing water since early spring. Mayor got cheap on the budget
In this case, the one seat makes very little difference to the division of seats among the parties. It's important because it suggests that the Liberals' traditional areas of strength are getting weaker. It suggest bad things for them in the next general election. A byelection occurs when a seat becomes vacant in between elections. Also, the Bloc Quebecois is a party that only runs candidates in Quebec. It was formed based on the idea that Quebec's interests were not being adequately served by the traditional parties.
@@noseboop4354 No, that is not why. It had nothing to do with native people. It was simply about representing the interests of Quebecers, who have long been untrusting of the federal government.
*which is still weird to me because I worked at the elections and at my table, the woman representing the liberal party here had the most votes, and only beat the conservative one by a few votes, and the one that apparently won had MUCH less votes than these two (and as much as another similar one) and the green party sadly only one vote, and it’s the least bad one…*
Its ok Tyler, s lot of Canadians know less than you do about politics. In brief, whenever any political party in any political system starts losing electorate, its a sign of things to come.
that's the minimum, they are eligible for parole after 25 years, thus is from the Gov website "Under paragraph 745(a) of the Criminal Code of Canada (CCC), an offender serving life for 1st degree murder is eligible for full parole 25 years after the date they were taken into custody. Eligibility does not mean automatic release. Full parole must be granted by the PBC."
This is a by-election in a Montreal constituency. This riding was represented by a Liberal MP but this time it was the Bloc Québécois who won. The Bloc Québécois has been in the majority in Quebec for years. We have 33 Quebec independence MPs in the Canadian parliament. Justin Trudeau risks losing power in the next federal election because the PCC is currently in the majority in Canada except in Quebec. In the Quebec parliament we only have 4 deputies from the Parti Québécois. But the polls give a majority in the next Quebec elections. It is possible that we will have another referendum in the coming years for the independence of Quebec.
Canadians have to ask themselves if they feel like renovating 24 Sussex Drive again. Americans have to ask themselves what type of country they want. Do they want to emulate Canada or Hungary.
it's 25 years minimum for 1st degree murder, that's regulated federally, not provincially and this is from the Gov website "Under paragraph 745(a) of the Criminal Code of Canada (CCC), an offender serving life for 1st degree murder is eligible for full parole 25 years after the date they were taken into custody. Eligibility does not mean automatic release. Full parole must be granted by the PBC."
I have heard you say "" I don't understand Canadian Politics "" about 25 times !!!!! Fricking LEARN about our System !!! 20 Minutes is all it TAKES !!! I learned the American way in Junior High School !!!! 👎🏿👎🏽👎✌🖖🍁🌻💛💙🇺🇦
I lean more left and I consider myself more progressive, but even I believe our sentencing of crimes is ridiculously soft. A group of guys murdered, decapitated, and hid parts of bodies around our area, and they got like 7 years. Our life sentence is 25 yrs and usually, people don't serve the whole time. There are serial killers who are living normal lives here. You can't sue someone without a lawyer, so if someone screws you over, there ain't a whole lot you can do about it. My town has gone to 💩. We have like 70, 000 ppl and like 6 murders a year for like the last 5 years. Ppl dying of overdoses daily passed out in the street or lighting themselves on fires in dumpsters. No help.
A byelection happens when a politician leaves their position before a general election happens. If there is too much time before the next general election, a “byelection” will happen to elect a new politician in that specific area.
Canada's justice system is very broken. US is as well but it seems to be getting worse in Canada where people are more easily allowed bail now which causes repeat offenders.
To clarify. The liberals already have the minority of seats. The NDP, convertives and the bloc; the opposition parties have more seats collectively. The liberals is just the one party which currently has the most seats. I think 154. Which means they are a minority government, being propped up until recently by the ndp.
Funny thing is, as a Canadian, I'm grateful to get Canadian news from you, an American!
I hate to admit that Americans give better Canadian news coverage than Canadians. CBC news is unwatchable, it's a giant Alberta / conservative propaganda circle jerk.
Same here from French Quebecer🤣🤣🤣
Tyler, you doing these weekly news reactions is more news than many Canadians read or listen to.
A byelection is held when a MP resigns, dies, or for some other reason loses their seat. A byelection must be held within a certain amount of time after a seat becomes vacant.
Yes, the 'by election' is a mini election that takes place only in the riding in which that mister had jurisdiction, or responsibility for. Through the by election, the Liberal held seat will be filled by a Bloc Quebecois member in this traditional Liberal riding. Similar to the people electing a Democrat to Congress in a solid Republican state. Fear by the Liberals that a change in trend is taking place.
On the CBC website, top of the page there is a drop down tap to bring up different provinces, see local news for each province in Canada.
I am Canadian but I watch American news all week because Canadian news is so boring, then I catch up once a week by getting my Canadian news from this guy
The stabbing story is also insane. I think most Canadians feel they should face a more severe sentence. Whether she delivered the fatal blow or not, it was attempted murder and he probably would have bled out regardless. it was murder, and many of us do not understand the sentencing.
And the article implying that ADHD is a valid reason to go lightly on her is sickening. ADHD is not uncommon, and while it results in unruly children hard on their poor moms, the vast majority of them are not psychopaths.
The US is far too harsh and we're far too soft.
to me, a case like this suggests indefinite psychiatric confinement. Also, ADHD makes it hard to pay attention. It has nothing to do with stabbing people.
nobody is getting charged anymore in Canada. there are stories all over the place.
The Youth Criminal Justice Act, also known as the “You Can’t Jail Anyone Act”.
The polls show that Trudeau and the Liberals are toast!
😁😁😁😁
right and you believe in polls?
@@danmac-d7w What a smoothbrain thing to say. Whats not to trust about polls that have him in supermajority position and nearly doubling Trudeaus popularity? Perhaps you'd prefer a diffrent sample group? A larger one? a more biased one? What makes you think they arent representative of Canadians views? Is it the outcome?
They win every time - I no longer believe in our system
@@ae-vil polls take a very small sample and are only done via antiquated land lines
but you go right ahead and put your faith in them
Justin Trudeau took part in a Terry Fox Run event last weekend. Did Polievre? Nope. (pronounced Pol-lee-EV-re, just for future reference)
Our judicial system is definitely more lenient. The first one that comes to mind was the “brutal rape and murder “ of a young teenage girl . Her murderer was found, tried, convicted, served his time and was released all within 13 years. It makes absolutely no sense to me.
We also dont have any kind of registry to know if you live near a potential predator, this has claimed many lives. A good example being the McHale Busch case in Edson, a RELEASED sexual offender was living next door and he killed a mother and her infant in a brutal way. They never knew he was there, nobody did.
yah lets just turn into a police state like USa bahahahahahah go move there then freedummie.
A bye-election is what the US calls a special election. The BQ winning this seat off the Liberals, is like a Democratic candidate winning in Marjory Taylor Green's district.
*by
@@personincognito3989 actually its BI
Tyler, you're reaction is correct... You SHOULD find it shocking when hearing about violent assault and murder. Not bc you're American and don't expect to hear such news in Canada, but bc that's how we as humans should react EVERY TIME we hear about such acts against another living being. No matter who, how, where, or how frequently it's done, it should be shocking. Every. Time. And no one should ever get used to it.
Sword and machete attacks happen because hand guns are harder to get ahold of here.
These attacks happen because, like our American neighbours, the mental health system is failing and we have our own percentage of bat sh!t crazy people.
The main goal of the Bloc Québécois is to defend and protect the Québécois interest at a federal level. However, this party could never be elected to govern over Canada. Its ultimate goal is to pave the way towards an independant Québec. What is too bad is that voting for the Bloc Québécois at a federal election takes away a vote for a party that could govern. In my opinion, if we want to remove a party, we are better to vote for its biggest adversary. We should vote according to our personal aspirations and convictions, but voting for the Parti Québécois is a "lost vote" if we want to remove a party from governing. 😏
I’ve often wondered though if the liberals will form a coalition with the bloc thus giving the bloc the power to govern the country
Strategic voting is spitting upon democracy and makes you part of the problem. This isn't a hockey game, vote for the candidate who best represents you, not to 'win'.
The Bloc should be blocked as a federal party because they don't have candidates in elections outside of Quebec. The rules need to be changed so that if you want to be a federal party you must run candidates in all provinces and territories.
Sometimes the biggest adversary is also not the best adversary. That is totally the Quebec way of voting. After 50 years living there, I now have a broader choice of who to vote for.
If I had a bloc candidate here in NS, I would vote for that person over the greasy libs or pathetic PC party... they should really make a move to gain seats outside of Quebec, I bet there could be some seats thrown their way. Especially in NB and the many French speaking parts of NS.
A by-election, also known as a special election in the United States, is an election used to fill an office that has become vacant between general elections.
A "By-Election" in Canada (and the UK) is the same as what the Americans call a "Special election". It's an election held in one district in between elections to fill it when it goes vacant early.
The bear attack one is kind of a "glass is half full" situation. Yes, he was attacked by a bear (major bummer), but...he's still alive (major winner winner chicken dinner)! 🫠
ADHD is not a "mental health" condition that makes you assault people I'm sorry. The article seems to imply that is a valid reason to go easy on her.
Many ADHD persons are hightly impulsives, its one of the main characteristic of this pathology... An impulsive person won't think and react like most people...
The big deal of it all is that Trudeau is from Montreal so it was also considered a home-town riding for him. The parties look like this:
Bloc - want Quebec to separate from Canada
NDP - left wing
Liberal - Centre left
Conservative - right wing
Green - left wing but most concerned about the environment
Tyler, you're doing a great job understanding our country! The effort you put in is awesome!
Bloc isn’t technically there to “help” the separatists movement, they are there mainly to do anything they can to help quebec “while” they are a canadian province. I mean they are of course pro-separation but they don’t “work for it” necessarily
@@YoshMaster good point, good point. that was a generalization for me. for them Quebec comes first.
Ndp aren’t central. They are more left than liberal. They only took socialism out of the party constitution in 2008. They still have the NDP socialist caucus as part of their party
Doesn't matter, choosing bloc quebecois or ndp over liberals is like replacing joe biden with kamala Harris and expecting things to be different.
agree, Tyler watch a bit of everything: news, memes, culture videos, history. I like this channel.
Yes. The Americans are harsher on sentences. The fact that this girl get off so easily is disgusting.
you could always move down stateside
Sad story of Kenneth Lee: He was going through mental struggles and his wife kicked him out of his own home. While he was on the streets, he made a girlfriend. Those 'usual suspects' group of 14 year old girls demanded cigarettes, didn't get any, and proceeded to beat up the girlfriend. Kenneth naturally stepped in to defend his woman, and that's when he was deleted for it! All those girls got very lenient punishments! . . . Here in Canada, the usual suspects always hate and try to delete Asians! Government and law enforcement don't give a shit either! Conservatives want to make a White Canada! Canada is phooked!
@danmac-d7w at this point I'd love to.
@@danmac-d7w.. you can have Trudeau.
@@1Daryle i didnt say who i wanted
i just said you cant believe in polls
try actually reading before you post
If you need more of an escape from the Dumpster fire that is the US Presidential Election, we have at least three provincial general elections in the next month, (In British Columbia, Saskatchewan, and New Brunswick) in Canadian Politics to keep you distracted.
What you’re missing is that the Canadian legal system is far too lenient for serious crime.
Yes, the government is more concerned with policing political dissent than it is on actual justice.
Indeed! Everyone off to a healing hut now! Heaven forbid you be placed behind bars for whatever heinous crime you committed.
Our justice system is a complete joke. The criminal has more rights then the victim!
First place only getting 1.9% more than 3rd place is wild
Right? Seems too close to call
@@TheDopekittyHe won by over 200 votes. Pretty clear victory.
I'm new to your chanel. You present your view 0f Canada in a pleasant manner
Thanks.
The US is definitely harsher on violent crime, while canada can have a bit of a Viking mentality on violence where it can be more acceptable to fight out disputes.
Remember, Canada is the reason for many things being listed as war crimes 🤷♂️
The the Lloyd minister shootings happened in Saskatchewan. I wish you had covered it because these things don’t happen that often in Saskatchewan. It’s actually a few hours from where I live and my coworker actually knew the people :(
Re the border situation. There is a pipeline coming up through SA, which you may know about. Migrants are shipped from the US southern border to the north. Then, thousands were walking across at Roxham Road (Quebec). They were met by Canadian officials and shipped to lodgings in PQ, NB and NS, and held for processing. Lodgings - hotels and rentals. If you google Roxham Road border crossings, the story is on this platform. The justice system is in shambles, police don't come to calls, and lawlessness has taken over. jmo
Love these News videos.. Thanks!
We (most of Canada) are so sick of the Trudeau scandals, corruption and wasting taxpayer money ( enriching family, friends and cabinet members), while Canadians are suffering, living on the streets, and the crime rate has significantly risen under the liberal party. I'm so done with them!!
We feel the same way about that girl getting away with a violent crime resulting in death. The liberals are very soft on crime, the Conservatives plan to be tougher on crime, no catch and release with them. I'll definitely be voting Conservative as soon as I can.
The Conservatives are no better..
@@vicfak3915 but they may be the lesser of the evil.
@@dianedee7919 once upon a time I may have agreed that they were a viable alternative, but today’s Canadian conservatism concerns me deeply. I worry this is one of those “cut off your nose to spite your face” situations..
@@deegee5526 at this point we’re just switching back to the other mechanic that also did a substandard job. Poilievre has been around for a long time. We’ve seen him in government. He has a track record. It isn’t very good. I’ll give him credit though, as an opposition MP, he’s an ornament to any parliament.
@@vicfak3915 I understand your concerns, and I usually vote liberal, but after everything they've done over the last 9 years, I just can't do it. I don't like where the NDP is going , Jack Layton was their best leader. Conservatives seems like the lesser of the evils to me.
Tyler in Canada our courts laws on youth crime is to try to rehabilitate
rather than solely punish young offenders.
The punishment should fit the crime, regardless of the offender's age. Our justice system is so stupid.
As for the teen swarming/stabbing. It appears that she MAY have been mistreated while incarcerated - a number of strip searches, not always allowed to be brought to the court for her sentencing & sent to a remote facility where it was hard for her family to see her. AT BEST - I think they need to find her a closer, possibly better managed facility (then again I don't know the details of why the things happened to her there. She MAY have tried to steal a knife from her dinner etc. I just don't know the circumstances.)
What I DO know, Tyler, is that YOU ARE RIGHT. MANY TIMES Canadians including myself - think sentences should be longer - including myself with this one.
I’m glad you spoke of Northern boarder,because no one does. There was Jhiad here in Montreal heading NY via Roxham Rd. Before this incident we had ISIS in Toronto planning bomb attack. I’m very concerned for all citizens of North America!🇨🇦🫶🇺🇸
Thanks for our weekly news.
The rest of Quebec varies a lot in federal elections, but most of Montreal usually heavily favors the Liberal party in both federal and provincial elections, so this is a big deal for Justin Trudeau's party, but le Bloc Québécois remains a very center-left party too.
Hey Tyler. Always great to see your interest in Canada and offering up another perspective.
What I would say to you is that much of what happens in the US & Canada are interconnected.
Our major political parties share the same sub-contracted consulate groups that are used down in the states and many of the tactics used are tested on one side of the border, then if they work, they try them on the other side.
Much like the US, we share a lot of the same polarization and division that is going on.
I find that there is a giant lean currently to stomp out Canadian's ability to get the true news going on and the push is on to see more similar results to what the US has. Where a lot of the time, you just can't get the news, even from one state to another, without going to look for it. And even then, it might be curated and leaning more left or right than what the truth is actually.
It's impossible to talk about politics here without people getting worked up, just like down there.
My own opinion is that people came out of the pandemic and really had time to think... And realized just how much everyone was not on the same page.
And the political parties and business community now want to capitalize on this and divide the country further.
There is a lot that we take for granted here, that I know Americans often look at and say, something like that would be amazing to have here (health care for example). What you don't see is how much we become under pressure to conform to the US model of how to do things.
Canadian's, again in my opinion, tend to care deeply and get very upset when things are moving in a direction that doesn't feel like it's true to our identity.
Saying that, I think people just want change for the sake of change. They actually don't know what they want... Which is kinda a big deal and even dangerous. I somehow think you and other Americans can relate with... You know there and what is going on.
I find, atm, we moved a lot more left leaning for some of what the country (and especially the businesses and politicians) would have liked and the push is on to flip it back.
People can give there own opinions, but let me use Alberta as an example.
They went from roughly 50 years of the conservative party being in power (our version of what the old Republic party was sorta like) to skipping over the liberal party (which was sorta like the democratic party... But really... I kinda feel the Dems are even more right leaning than our liberal governments) to going all the way to the NDP (who for many, would be seen more extreme left - depends on who you talk too). Regardless... They went hard left... And they lost there minds over it XD
Next thing you knew, they voted in the UCP - which is bordering the line of trump level extremism (again, my opinion - I'm sure that would upset some people).
Remember the proud boys originated (sadly) from Western Canada. Also, the first act of the UCP was to vet, block and filter news there. And it's a policy that many of the right leaning parties feel strongly about.
The current push by the Conservatives is to try and get the country to move back towards the right, but there is definitely a aggressive mix of opinions on how much they will want to match to "trumpism".
It kinda feels like when trump was first elected down there. People wanted change and just didn't want the same old thing.
I feel like there is also an attempt to shield and silent the younger generations of Canadians, who are becoming more powerful to vote and tend, again in my opinion, to lean much more left than any of the political parties would like.
But I feel also that people don't feel represented or have someone they see and feel comfortable to call a leader.
Many have long forgotten the original reason Canada voted Justin Trudeau and the liberal government in. And having the minority government shouldn't have been a bad thing, if the system was working and they were actually trying to work for the interests for Canadians.
Instead, we can't even have school groups visit the House of Commons because, they all act worse than a baby going through their terrible twos.
Canada has so much and their are so many positives. But we definitely are going through many of the same pains as Americans are. And while some of it is different, there is a lot that is being affected by how linked we truly are.
I just hope in the end, people don't loose sight of how unique and precious our US / Canadian relationship real is.
We may not always agree and we might have our differences, but I think in our hearts, we want to believe in each other and be able to know we have each other's backs in the good times and the bad.
Maybe I'm too sentimental and hopefully, but I love my American family and friends.
And just to make sure you know I'm Canadian - Sorry eh for the long winded message. And as one great Canadian said many a time - Keep your stick on the ice! 😉
The Canadian law system is a fucking joke.
Criminals (especially female criminals) are barely punished.
Even serial killers can get only 12 years
Tyler: you do understand. In Canada we don't have the death penalty, but murder is serious. The Conservative Party is campaigning on increasing punishment for serious crime.
Tyler, our judicial system here in Canada is absolutely disgusting. Criminals get next to no punishment and our homicide crime rate has went up 100% in the past few years. Our Government has a "catch and release" policy they made and follow and criminals are rampant here now, unfortunately. We aren't even allowed to defend ourselves because if we do, We will be prosecuted and punished befiee the Criminal would. It's awful and shameful 😞
You have to be stupid not to defend yourself, regardless of what the law says.
You are allowed to defend yourself but your response must be appropriate and not excessive
Yeah remember that guy in Ontario that was arrested and charged for killing an armed home invader? Wild!! Vote Trudeau out!!
I’m not going to speak about the leniency of Canada’s justice system vs. the USA… but just Google Canada vs. USA crime rate. I remember hiring a US consulting firm to look at how to improve our police operations, and they laughed at us being concerned about our major crime rate.
Sad I hear of news from here in Canada and I live here. Yes our legal system is broke.
To help you understand the Canadian government system (also used in UK, Aus, NZ), the Executive branch is chosen from the Legislative Branch of the Government. That is to say, all executive members are also members of the legislature. However, very few members of the legislative branch are members of the executive branch. In the federal government, there are 338 MPs (members of the legislative branch.) There are also 105 Senators. However, there are fewer than 40 cabinet ministers (executive branch.)
Under the US system, there are three separate branches of government, the executive (pres and cabinet), the legislative branch (House and Senate), and the judicial.
A byelection is an election to replace a vacant seat in the House of Commons. I think they're called special elections in the US.
I thank you so much for what you do always looking for the positive. I love your insights into seeing this news in Canada.And it makes me go back and look at the stories and see them.A book from the information I get. I love how you approach all this and how you try to be.Kind in what you're doing.Thank you
I want a bye- bye election.😂
Canada needs to a justice system overhaul.
😢 I believe that Canada's forces would do well to force dangerous individuals, regardless of age, to join the front line.
These are people who clearly have a need for violence that is not being met, but are too concerned with their own self-preservation to enlist themselves.
I killer instinct in our forces could be an asset. It would rid our streets of these dangerous individuals. It would free up places in prisons. And it may instill a sense of pride in their otherwise wasted lives. If they die in battle, they will have died a hero's death. If they return home, they will be heroes worthy of respect that had repented for their transgressions.
The same applies for American inmates with a predilection to violence. Make it useful! Men like Gus March-Phillipps were amazing soldiers, despite their attitudes. That's who we need in our militaries
When is the real 🇨🇦 experience? Way past a typical American now. You earned a spot here. 🍻
On the topic of house prices, you may find it interesting that in Canada, there is no interest deductability for income tax. All mortgages are paid out of pocket
you are getting really good with the canadian politics there mr tyler ~ cbc is a good source ~
I just realized I’m living in Edmonton Alberta and I get 75% of my Canadian news from Tyler Bucket lol definitely living in a simulation
Just heard of this. On the 21st In Kalamazoo, they're having Canadiana fest. Just seen the commercial while watching the red green show lol. Apparently they'll have a booth there as well.
I totally enjoy how you are pronouncing Pierre Poilievre’s name 😂
I know this has been mentioned a few times over the last week or so , But are you going to finish the Halifax explosion video ? seems a fair bit of people are waiting for that xD.
The positive news is Trudeau lost 2 more by-elections😂
You are not being too critical. That swarming was repulsive and the sentence should have been life.
well trudeau has lost 3 by-elections and his coalition in the last few months MPs are jumping ship from the liberal party
There was never a coalition. The only coalition in Canada was in 1917. It was a confidence-and-supply agreement. Educate yourself about parliamentary democracies.
Oh please....
Canadians follow US politics very closely.
My boyfriend was stabbed in the heart and killed in 2009 by a 15 year old. Kid got 3 years served 6 months. Canadas justice system is awful. The kid lives free while myself and children live with the loss. If I spoke my truth you tube would likely ban me
“The Tragically Hip: No Dress Rehearsal” - I dare you not to cover it in a video. 😁
I don't get the legal system in Canada. If he was able to protect himself and survive the attack, he probably would've faced a long jail sentence for doing so. That's how "balanced" the system is. You can't protect yourself without serious repercussions, no you aren't allowed to shoot a burglar if they break into your house and you're a licensed responsible gun owner
The teen getting probation: most media outlets are shockingly bad at covering legal proceedings. I'm sure court transcripts would put the decision into context. "Journalism" is far too click-baity these days.
Other comments:
- a 🇨🇦'n army problem.. not a sleeping bag problem
- Calgary has been rationing water since early spring. Mayor got cheap on the budget
Calgary makes me laugh. Conservative karma. But hey, at least everyone gets to drive big trucks, right?
There is a short documentry by Peter Santenello it is called AT US/CANADA BORDER with Sheriffs' Office (exclusive access). It explains it all.
In this case, the one seat makes very little difference to the division of seats among the parties. It's important because it suggests that the Liberals' traditional areas of strength are getting weaker. It suggest bad things for them in the next general election. A byelection occurs when a seat becomes vacant in between elections. Also, the Bloc Quebecois is a party that only runs candidates in Quebec. It was formed based on the idea that Quebec's interests were not being adequately served by the traditional parties.
It was formed because the British carried out cultural genoclde on the French and aboriginal minorities.
@@noseboop4354 No, that is not why. It had nothing to do with native people. It was simply about representing the interests of Quebecers, who have long been untrusting of the federal government.
*which is still weird to me because I worked at the elections and at my table, the woman representing the liberal party here had the most votes, and only beat the conservative one by a few votes, and the one that apparently won had MUCH less votes than these two (and as much as another similar one) and the green party sadly only one vote, and it’s the least bad one…*
Our judicial system in Canada is a joke. It's a revolving door. Much to soft on criminals here.
Its ok Tyler, s lot of Canadians know less than you do about politics. In brief, whenever any political party in any political system starts losing electorate, its a sign of things to come.
The Canadian truck convoy. The frindge minority lol
Can someone tell me where part 3 for Halifax explosion??
The population density in that area is outrageous.😂
Most Canadians don't know Canadian news. I am 🇨🇦 and I love what you do!
No we unfortunately are not harsher on punishment. We're disgusted by it.
1. People do come here from other countries
2. We have still managed to keep things well below "florida man" levels
Many Canadian sports fans care deeply about the NFL, usually much more so than the CFL. Local bars have weekly NFL pools, that type of thing.
In Canada maximum sentence for murders 25 years
that's the minimum, they are eligible for parole after 25 years, thus is from the Gov website "Under paragraph 745(a) of the Criminal Code of Canada (CCC), an offender serving life for 1st degree murder is eligible for full parole 25 years after the date they were taken into custody. Eligibility does not mean automatic release. Full parole must be granted by the PBC."
Bye bye Justin.
This is a by-election in a Montreal constituency. This riding was represented by a Liberal MP but this time it was the Bloc Québécois who won. The Bloc Québécois has been in the majority in Quebec for years. We have 33 Quebec independence MPs in the Canadian parliament. Justin Trudeau risks losing power in the next federal election because the PCC is currently in the majority in Canada except in Quebec. In the Quebec parliament we only have 4 deputies from the Parti Québécois. But the polls give a majority in the next Quebec elections. It is possible that we will have another referendum in the coming years for the independence of Quebec.
You pronounced bloc quebecois beautifully. 😊
His name is pronounced like poly-ehv ehv is pronounced with a short "E"
Canadians care about the NFL starting because it means hockey is just around the corner.
Not all Canadians care about hockey 👋
Canadians have to ask themselves if they feel like renovating 24 Sussex Drive again. Americans have to ask themselves what type of country they want. Do they want to emulate Canada or Hungary.
Our young offenders act is a joke.
The House O Commons is kinda similar to your House of Representatives or Congress , having 338 MP's
To quote Jagmeet Singh Canada is done with Trudeau.
American life sentences 25 years here in Ontario a life sentence is only 10 years
it's 25 years minimum for 1st degree murder, that's regulated federally, not provincially and this is from the Gov website "Under paragraph 745(a) of the Criminal Code of Canada (CCC), an offender serving life for 1st degree murder is eligible for full parole 25 years after the date they were taken into custody. Eligibility does not mean automatic release. Full parole must be granted by the PBC."
I have heard you say "" I don't understand Canadian Politics "" about 25 times !!!!! Fricking LEARN about our System !!! 20 Minutes is all it TAKES !!! I learned the American way in Junior High School !!!! 👎🏿👎🏽👎✌🖖🍁🌻💛💙🇺🇦
Tyler - you should do a react video to "The Beaverton" a Canadian Satirical news site. Sort of like our "Onion".
Canada's justice system is kind of a joke honestly
I lean more left and I consider myself more progressive, but even I believe our sentencing of crimes is ridiculously soft. A group of guys murdered, decapitated, and hid parts of bodies around our area, and they got like 7 years. Our life sentence is 25 yrs and usually, people don't serve the whole time. There are serial killers who are living normal lives here. You can't sue someone without a lawyer, so if someone screws you over, there ain't a whole lot you can do about it. My town has gone to 💩. We have like 70, 000 ppl and like 6 murders a year for like the last 5 years. Ppl dying of overdoses daily passed out in the street or lighting themselves on fires in dumpsters. No help.
I've never been so ashamed of my country.
18:16
Just make sure it has the TESTED label on it.
as a canadian i do not get electoral college, fahrenheit, tipping, guns
The Canadian justice system is a joke.
The migrants go marching two by two...
God Bless Québec Land of the Saints ⚜️⚜️⚜️💯
A byelection happens when a politician leaves their position before a general election happens. If there is too much time before the next general election, a “byelection” will happen to elect a new politician in that specific area.
I'm from Montreal it's like hockey night in Canada loll
Canada's justice system is very broken. US is as well but it seems to be getting worse in Canada where people are more easily allowed bail now which causes repeat offenders.
To clarify. The liberals already have the minority of seats. The NDP, convertives and the bloc; the opposition parties have more seats collectively. The liberals is just the one party which currently has the most seats. I think 154. Which means they are a minority government, being propped up until recently by the ndp.
The big story in Montreal is 91 candidates on the ballot.
The Canadian criminal code and sentencing is far far to lax - a Canadian.
Politics is in a different dimension from me. I don’t care who is running the show. They all are from the same boat.
Yeah. It's time Trudeau get the Hell out of there...
Too bad it's probably be the Conservative Party...
PC = MAGA North. Not much choice. Maybe NDP?
@@susieq9801 Obvy NDP It's been too long that we let the PC and Liberals battle it out without giving the NDP a shot
@@susieq9801 That is bulls..t. Trudeau needs to go. NDP no way, Green Party a wasted vote so not much else out there!
@@susieq9801ndp is a socialist party that only took socialism out of the party constitution in 2008
@@susieq9801 NPD, maybe. Would be better than PC or Liberals...