Whenever u ask a question u should have the equal courage to listen to the answer to whom u question... Its a great descipline...and art of being a human and a learner
@Ayush Sharma shut up , don't say anything if you don't know the ground truth ,who said you gdp is the lowest, update your self and learn how gdp is being calculated.
@@RAHUL-kl1ec left wing can not understand or comprehend long term things. The only know that refute everything, anything that's done by the current gov.
The person raising this question has been proven incredibly wrong now as now every vegetable vendor, fruit seller & all are now using UPI linked to their bank accounts...
@@akhilbansal5507 but small vendors are using these UPI for transactions. I only use cash when i pay to e rikshaw otherwise fruit seller, auto rikshaw they all accept Payment through UPi
If you think milkmen and farmers all over India know how to use pay TM and phone pe then you are wrong , In Tamil Nadu there are lot of farmers and milkmen who do not know phone pe or Paytm .
And that took so many things and even pushed india way back where we would have suppose to stand. Online transaction were just an option and still it's just an option! Govt literally forced especially local vendors to adopt digital payment (this is even when govt didn't had hard currency ) digital transaction were just an coat to hide Govt failures
I am not a big fan of BJP but at least she had the decency to hear the question without interrupting. Got to have an open mind and ability to listen. This type of attitude only discredits him.
@Shaswata Chatterjee shows how disrespectful you are and how mean u are .. More over this is a 2016 video ,that guy should realise that now in 2019 every one has a Paytm account a banking card. No matter who.
@@pep8221 nobel laureate abhijit bannerjee, S jaishankar, nirmala sitharaman, sitaram yechury, amitabh kant , prakash karat , maneka Gandhi, srijit mukherjee, jawed habib aur kai saare national politicians JNU se hai, apne sarkaar ke khilaaf awaaz uthaana desh droh nahi hai, ye ek democracy ki pehchaan, agar aap sarkar ke fan ban jaate hai aur question karna bandh kar dete hai to aapki sarkaar tanashahidictatorship) main badaljaati hai, kisi party ko support karna ya nahi karna apko desh drohi ya desh premi nahi bana deta, dissent or questioning your governments work is a constitutional right and everyone has right to exercise it! Aur baat hai jnu ki, ye desh ke best educational institutions main jaha admission poori tarah se merit pe hota hai, yaha pe bacche ameer se ameer aur gareeb se gareeb parivaron se ate hai, aur education pe 7 lakh kya 10 lakh kharch karna chahiye
@@AbhishekMishra-hh5kq let me add more alumni from JNU Founder of Emirates PM of Nepal PM of Libya Finance minister of Afganistan Secretary general of ASEAN Indian Ambassador to USA Indian Ambassador to Netherlands Indian Ambassador to Ireland and of other 13 countries Indian parmanent representative to UN- Sayed Akabaruddin First secretary at India's UN mission- (women that had exposed Pakistan's representative of UN) Fomer RAW chief Former IB chief CEO of Niti aayog Former deputy governor of RBI Former Indian Deputy National Security Advisor R. Subramanyam - HRD Secretary Sanjaya Baru - Media advisor and chief spokesperson of former PM, Manmohan Singh Amitabh Rajan - Former Additional Chief Secretary (Home) of Maharashtra (Responsible for Ajmal Kasab's hanging) Deepak Rawat Pranjal Patil - Country's first visually challenged IAS officer Any many more.....
typical jnu grandstanding. These dari wallahs always try to win an argument by only one means. They will not let the other party speak. Only they will speak & their word is the last word.
@@historyeditz8326 ye tera defense h JNU ke padho ko unke saath compare kar raha h? We all know wahi comparison ho sakta h JNU walo ka. Kisi dusre college ya institution se thodiya.
Theye tend to be presented as factual and intellectuals, but can't actually speak the same. Totally fallacious to speak they all comprises of, again the same atteibutes, but not the case for everyone. Guy like him and the one have constant tendancies to literally revolt on anything to everything, cuz being a part of this institution says so.
Here i am watching this video after 5 years and more importantly paying my doodhwala and sabjiwala via paytm or gpay .......and also understanding that there is a great difference between a policy made by bureaucrats and a college student OPINION!
@@rohankabadi389 I Bihar many of local shops have started using to accept digital payment however its not in large number but it has started and not gonna stop until 100% digitalisation for transaction.
@@sahasss7100 What's wrong in defending that guy... he is asking some real questions and she's not able to answer them rather she's blaming JNU for it or its culture
Ekant Pathak jnu standard has gone down big time and his parents must teach him how to behave with a senior person I bet he speaks same way to his mom too
He actually didn't want to hear an answer. He just wanted to create a scene. now if this doesn't make people question the atmosphere in JNU after bharat tere tukde honge stuff, then what will?
For all those who blame the guy should be able to understand his question. He asks a question and the minister's answers are totally unrelated. He is asking about informal economy and she is talking about ministers. She doesn't understand the question for which te guy is trying to explain.
She is India's symbol of an empowered woman and serves as the Minister of Finance and Corporate Affairs since 2019. I am very happy to live in this era. Jai hind!
@@Nil-kd9wz watch the uncut version of the whole meetup. She deflects questions not just from the one guy but also from almost anyone. People do listen when one is earnest and uses logic rather than using rhetorics and losing the favour of the crowd.
@@u.b.5773 The guy was giving anecdotal evidence. The guy said that he knows the plight of the marginalised section. Nirmala Sitharaman told him the representatives are called representatives because they come from those marginalised and those strata too. They are their representatives so she has the idea as to what may occur because of govt. policies. And those representatives are not only selected and went to parliament from her party, but from other parties too. So he can be assured as to they will be listened to.
Now even the smallest vendors use Paytm, Gpay. The startup sector is booming, this is what great leaders are they force others to reach to their desired level and not adjust to make everyone happy we need even stronger leaders to take this country forward
@@vedagyasharma6453 he is already here. Danka bajj raha h uska to sari duniya me. COP26 meet, saw some glimpses of him what did UK and Israel PM said about him??
@Saarthak Kapoor exactly. And with the current situation going on the same marginalised people he's trying to depict are themselves requesting to pay via UPI to ease the payments and reduce the contact. Not a party propaganda but at least there is a new technology the whole society has moved on to.
@@jyoti8927 Did You abuse your parents when they refused something you liked for your betterment only? No right? Why didn't you forget that in the first place?
See there are lot of people in India are earning a salary less than 20,000 , My relative's were earning less than 20,000 at that time , In super markets the cost is more when compared to local grocery shops and vegetable shop . If we do not have much money to buy in a super market and if we do not have change for Rs.2000 what we have to do ?
@@RahulSharma-se5nq Madam FM sorry to say you do not have any idea about how common people deal their normal life in India. MP,MLA and ministers even they are from marginalised society do not represent poor /common people. They get beds and treatment at covid times, but common man do not. You are trying to confuse the young boy.
@@sudhirkumarnayak2693 There are too many problems, and only a few good things, still many people ask to not question the problems. IMO, they can be called ignorant without a doubt. Progress is not made by "acknowledging good things" but by questioning the problems.
@@saurabhbatheja progress is made by both encouraging good things and criticising bad things. Just tell a kid to do maths. Criticise every wrong answer( made by kid).. And for every right answer... " YOU ARE TOO SLOW IN CALCULATION" Result: depression and hate in maths.
Nostalgic feelings struck my dad looking at these students as he sat on the couch lecturing my 18 yo daughter on how important it was to have a good career, he was from this jnu batch..." Sigh, those were the days" he said..
Because she wasn't allowed to even blabber, that Urban Naxal just wanted to showcase that he's a know all, he didn't have a question, he didn't have anything to hear from Nirmala, he had a few points to make and he brushed it, when Sitaram tried to answer he displayed his arrogance.
Lol what do you expect from a parliament? To conduct polls of each and every bills acts initiatives? Elect your representatives and expect them to handle things. That how it works
@@armstrong2450 yes bro it should be in some matters. Nothing is bad in that no of bills are very bad even passed by some of members. We have too have a right to challenge it even after passing it.
@@Nonecares452 Yeah we can see that in the video who done what.. hahahaa.. That future "andolan jeevi" dont want her to answer because if she answer him properly he will be a dumb joke next day on wards.
The person who is questioning is president of NSUI. Student wing of Congress. Stood for JNUSTUDENT Presidency this year and came 4th. what more can we expect from him!!!!!
Latha Baradwaj Dr.Subramnian Swamy always surprise me with the bold answers. He have brilliant mind, we never know what would be the answer from Dr.Swamy.
Hello mister, the age group you mentioned they are doing phd, can you complete your phd in 25 years?? Can you?? If not then shut up.... In all universities of India students do their phd from 30-50 age... why are you only accusing JNU students while whole India doing the same?? Edit: I am not a JNU student.
@@surajmulik7927 Actually the thing is only students in our country raise issues and riots and protests against Government because the country is not going in the right direction... This country rulers also did the same thing in their earlier days, nirmala sitaraman ji did so many protests , i did read in my text books... Don't you think there is something wrong in India in these circumstances that's why the protests are happening?? Not just JNU students, farmers, doctors, ssc students, teachers, bank workers everyone are protesting , why?? Because they love to ?? No,, because their patience has come to its limit. Agar kuch sahi nahi hai to protest hona kya kharabi hai?? Main to nahi dekh rahi India mein kuch achcha ho raha hai, mehengai bar rahi hai, garibi nei gayi, jobs nahi hai....agar koi layak ho to yeh sab issues to chala jana chahiye right jitni bhi opposition ho ( jin log international issues itni achchi tarha handle kar sakte hai, duniya mein jhagre kam kar sakte hai, duniya ko inspire kar sakte hai, woh national issues ko solve nahi kar pa rahe hain?? Strange!!) ... This is a humble discussion,,I am not debating, just say what is happening in India.
@@Annie-uq1md problem is not with protest but with how these protests are becoming against a party or are for politics than for genuine social cause. JNU students do protest on CAA but they never did protest for so many years on our education system. If they have did that national education policy would have come many years before. I was actually shocked on how much disrespectly he was talking,this is how a JNU student should ask a question complaining like a child even not meating the eye of minister while minister were answering the question. After all his question and many big leaders analysis become rubbish because today a small wender also uses digital payment. They planned the scheme very smartly with the lauch of jio and decreasing amount of interest services
01:48 see that girl's reaction to that JNU student The whole nation had same reactions to these pseudo intellectuals. Jnu students were biggest boon for modi and bjp
@@state_warrior In case you didn't get the joke political leaders always try to change the topic whenever you ask them a difficult question. So if Nirmala Ji was your maths teacher then she would have taught you Biology
They qualify the Exam , you don't give them money , they deserve it ....also aukat hai to rokar dikha de funding.... feku ki bhi fat jati hai ...chala tha NDTV ban karne , SC kya pahuche mut diya paint me
A vast majority of these naxalite students join after being members of one or other party or being pushed through by some MP-MLA backing. They make sure to extract their pound of flesh demanding what they have done in this and that regard. It is a very dirty business here just like Bollywood. Even the professors etc need to show some amount of troublemaking to ensure that they get recommended for being sent abroad etc. The massive network of filth that surrounds JNU is unimaginable.
For heaven's sake where did she win ? She didn't even answer him plus was trying to mock him and twist his questions....and finally shut up coz she obviously had no answer
This bearded guy who is only interested in lecturing not listening has a bright future in the circles of pseudo-intellectuals in India. Who knows - he may even find himself as a 'news analyst' in this channel!! On a serious note, this guy personifies the intellectual dishonesty seen in certain campuses and regressive left. He has no answers to India's corruption problem. His only job (similar to many anchors on this channel) is to punch as many holes as possible in the plan purely based on anecdotal references (my dhoodhwaala or vegetable vendor!!) What a joke!!
@@dibyakantidas9116 So You can do one THING go BACK to 1980's KOLKATA , Stand in Line in Bank for MONEY Withdrawl, Don't use smart PHONE, Don't Use EARPHONE, Don't Use GOOGLE, Don't Use COLOR TV, and Plz Use..BAEIL GADDIYou Don't Belong to 2020..which is Changing.. You Belong TO CALCUTTA OF 1890 OR 1980 .. Mr Bangali.. ANGA BONGO VONGO.
@@dibyakantidas9116 BTW, Ambani Vision Was Giving GHAR GHAR Telecom.. I think 3gb/day of 4g for 3months with 400 ₹ is coz of JIO otherwise you cAN GO BACK to AIRTEL 2016 of using 2gb/month of 3g for 560₹ 🤣🤣
@@amoghkarambelkar5476 What he asked and tried to replicate was ignored by Nirmala ji..... SHe tried to make it political influenced. and started on marginal section of MP's and MLA's ,....... Mtlb yarr...... If our so called fakir admi is on rock in his tenure,, so do you expect his MP's to be Discriminated by others in wealth, caste, community......
Exactly what she was trying to say. The guy picks one example he saw and tried to paint the whole section. She was about to say there are people in the parliament who represent these marginal communities and the case is not so. Street vendors are switching to digital. He never let her finish the answer and the commentators here on TH-cam drew a conclusion that she was diverting.
@@microg5139 Rg gusai is also speaking from one observation "his dhudhwala". Also, I agree that vegetable sellers and vendors are also switching to Paytm and online banking, but most of them still have no idea what online banking is. It's not about the vendors who are using online banking, it's about the ones not using them. I don't blame you if u didn't see how smartly she was trying to divert the point from 'poor' to 'lower-caste', she was doing it so elegantly by trying to make the guy look like that he was not respecting the constitution, to make it a patriotic argument, watch the video again to see if u can point it out this time how she smartly jumped out of the question and didnt have to answer it. Never underestimate the cleverness of a politician, there is a reason they got hundreds of millions of people to follow them, cuz they know how to talk people into stuff
@@isNamanSharma brother online system u r talking about ...govt only want to earn tax ..that is what I want to say ....my milk seller is a gujjar .....he doesn't even knows totalling. .we total n tell him 31 days month ..u didn't deliver milk on 3 days so this much total ...there are street vendors who earn 200-300 n want money daily ..how will they buy vegetables etc mostly are illiterate. ..even literate don't know all these stuffs
IITians are building fintech companies to promote cashless economy. JNU students everything but studying. Anyway JNU should learn from China how they transformed into mobile payments. They are ahead of US in digital payments. Btw I dare them to speak in this tone to Akhiesh Yadav or Mayawati or Mamta Didi. Their party workers will see to that you are bed ridden for whole semester.
U r certainly mistaken... Nirmala Sitharaman herself is a JNU passout...and many national n international leading lights are JNU passouts. Just at not all IITians or IIM pass outs are no great shakes, some are infact miserable failures, similarly donot form ur opinionss based on such short clips...even after 6 years of the current govts ruthless efforts to discredit JNU, it has still ranked as the top most university in the country
@@z_l_275 LOL. Graduation outcome of JNU is 99.12 which is highest than any other institution of india. And this score is a measure of placements. Tu apna narrow mentality apne pas hi rakh. Ilitrate fellow.
@cyrus cyrus First of all I am not a JNU student. And it is not good to say anything without having proper knowledge and saying that social science doesn't have any job is just absurd and it shows his narrow mentality.
This is so low level attitude that fellow has..she is defence minister of India..mind your expressions..if u r congress agent be it..go and shout on roads with mike..
JNU is one of the most overrated Universities in India. If he is one of the frontbenchers of the Universities ( GENERALLY the bright one's) and somewhat of a mascot, who can talk and talk and don't have the basic quality to listen this University has great days ahead. In this context, of the often repeated common man-uncommon man, poor-rich debate he raises, in the great days of the caveman clothes, cooked food and currency was unthinkable. But change is the only constant, the caveman understood and got dressed, cooked his food and later got food from restaurant with paper. Getting a card is free. So too opening a "zero balance" bank account these days if you know. There is no finance involved, only some basic changes are required. Yes all changes are slow and comes with some discomfort, but if it is for the overall good than it is only wise to endured for a better future. A financially poor man would not get rich by using cash, but would definitely get some benefits using a card (just one example your pocket gets picked cash gone. Card gets stolen still nothing lost.) Mr. JNU wannabe Che Guevara "poor man" are the one's who refuses change and remains in their fancy cocoons.
Atul Kumar Dwivedi I think you don't have a proper information regarding RSS cadres. I am an RSS cadre and earned my master degree from IIT dhanbad which is far better than JNU .
If you spend five minutes asking a question, have the patience to listen an answer. You didn't let her complete even one sentence. Left parties have existed in India for one hundred years, and they have ruled in just three states, not taken root anywhere else. I feel so sad, the student raised valid and vital points, but he destroyed a great chance to put the BJP minister on the spot, make her give some straight answers. You have to engage in actual give and take conversations, back and forth dialogues to convince your audience. That's democracy. Shutting down the lady every time she started to speak, will not work. We don't have Communist comrade commissars and general secretaries here, thank goodness.
@@abhyudaysingh7930 The question of 2000 rs notes, with the next lower denomination being only 100 Rs was valid, if he had known how to behave properly.
@@sreeravi25 he was talking on behalf of rickshaw drivers and tea stall owners. These guys hardly transacted with bigger amounts than 100 Rs notes to begin with.
@@abhyudaysingh7930 Yes, but even in those cases, there are situations where amount of 1000 odd would be needed. How will they pay for the raw materials if bill comes for 700 Rs? How will they pay for 3-4 day's diesel costing 900 Rs? Not every person deals with less than 100 rs cash a day. The question was valid, and in the end, instead of catching them on point, the guy misbehaved and lost his respect. But, hey, all is well that ends well :)
@@sreeravi25 well then the people who dont deal with less than 100 rupee per day would just transact a 2000 Rupee note or more if they need it won't they. Also I said 100 rupee notes not less than 100 in case you read it wrong. Problems can't be solved with the same attitude which created them. You need to be able to see the bigger picture. And everyone in the country knew what was happening and was understanding towards others problems. Only the so called liberals and the ones who stashed away all the black money were having a problem with this change and used it negatively to gain publicity and TRP. Today every chaiwala, rickshaw Walla is using Paytm, phonepe and all these apps. All because of notebandi. That guy knew his question was bogus and she had an answer for it so he started stalling and beating around the bush and made sure she eventually diverts away from the question and he gets his 5 minutes of fame from his tukde tukde gang
Thats not how the scene looks like. Those people are so unruly that they are not even allowing her to talk. That guy just grabbed the mike and started to blabber away on top of her while expecting the other person to listen which she did. When it was her chance to answer, let her finish her sentence. The girl next to him started to ask a question despite being said a while ago that she would get back to her after she answers to his question. I can only see the pathetic state of their classroom lecturers/professors. I have been to many countries both far east and the west but I have always observed that people from many cultures never talk over others and apologize if it happens by accident. Its a reflection of bad upbringing. Dont get to my political stand here infact I’m more leaned towards dem than republicans; more liberal than right winged but this sort of behavior has nothing to do with politics.
Nd what about that man who doesn't want to shut his mouth he forget to take tables of clozapam so he was not able control his emotion....bht fikr hai tum logo ko dudhh walo ki reddi walo ki bhai unko dikkat hui hai pr kuch achaa hua hai kuch ache k liye kast saha h bhltai nhii election k result dekh liya hoga to pta chal gya hoga pichli bar se jayda seat thee thande rahhh ab
nirmala madam . true respect to you . u handled it like a BOSSS.. JNU must be proud of u mam. i wonder what these "so called students " real ambition in life is. i see no future in them.....quality of conversations.. all aged 30 to 35 ..
Nobody even wants to !!! cuz everyone knows you become a hypocrite when u enter JNU ! I know JNU mentality. they live in constant inferiority complex of IITians and IIMians and other professionals. They see these students being successful at a really fast pace and just to hide their jealousy , start coming up anti-capitalism, anti-nationalism rhetoric. They keep abusing Ambani, and the next day will buy a Jio sim. They keep abusing Bill Gates, but have Windows OS. They talk about hungry poor people and themselves gobble up dominoes pizza! hmmmm tasty capitalism! They talk about a classless India society but themselves provoke Dalit sentiment by using the name of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar. If you are so against the classification of Dalits, then why use the same term to classify a certain sect of the society. They have tarnished the name of the legendary Bhagat Singh by associating him with their stupid anti nationalism ideas. Bhagat Singh would be ashamed to see ppl using his name like this. So its good to stay away from a place like this !
This is the attitude of college revolutionaries... When i was in college these leftist students talk to the principal the same way.... They don't even have the patience to at least listen to his clarification..... They always have this mob mentality bahut logonko ekhatta karo aur azadi azadi bhokthe raho......
@Varghese Manakalathil if you have the power to raise a question than you must have the. patience to listen to answer did you see the at the end of the vedio if you call this formality idk what else to say
@Varghese Manakalathil just look at her face before asking a question and after getting interrupted her they were not only interupting but wrongly interpreting her and and please watch her other interviews before making any allegations
How does one look like a student? Do you have even the slightest idea the time it takes to do a PhD? Have you been to any university aside from maybe an engineering institute where mostly students study for 4 years in order to get a job at the pvt sector. You don't even have an inkling about higher studies and here you are bullshitting in TH-cam comments.
@@rohitmunshi9573 i have done my double masters from one of the top universities on the planet...where u cant even dream to get an admission...dont get judgemental about people and i know about JNU..so dont give me that bullshit...heard the younger gen in India have some brains but never thought there could be exceptions like u..u live in a shell.. come out of it and see the real world..i did not study in any of those b grade colleges u mentioned as my grades were far higher than people such as u could imagine...
@@rohitmunshi9573 yes when i say i dont prefer hiring such people, its coz i have that academic credentials, awareness and privilege to say that...so please a big FO
@@roxyvo Wow you have a double masters from a 'top university of the planet' and yet you buy into the cheap asinine narrative of tukde tukde gang. What a joke.
@@rohitmunshi9573 weren't u the one praising them few hours back buddy...choose a side..dont be double sided...now they became cheap suddenly... see u carry on with ur fucking theory n please dont bother people like us anymore...
Yeh JNU mein sab uncle n Aunties kyun hai 😂 Also, look at all sabziwalas now, how will India move forward if they will not keep up with the changing times.. Change is the only constant.
He should have let her finished her whole answer first , only then we could have judge her answer whether it was diverting or to the point , but unfortunately people just don't want to listen or discuss , they just want to argue and try to prove they know better than others.
The dude can chill now. India has surpassed China, USA in cashless transactions. It was a legit question, but have hope with the country's vision as well.
Whenever u ask a question u should have the equal courage to listen to the answer to whom u question... Its a great descipline...and art of being a human and a learner
@Ayush Sharma shut up , don't say anything if you don't know the ground truth ,who said you gdp is the lowest, update your self and learn how gdp is being calculated.
@@AyushSharma-dn5mo emplyoment hogi nhi kaise jab nalle log lamba lamba paragraph youtube mai likh rhe hai
@@SHUBHAMSHARMA-li5uq 😂
@@AyushSharma-dn5mo All your statement I can hear the BITC* is crying.
@@AyushSharma-dn5mo true asf
I'm in chennai for 4 years and here from a vendor to a auto rikshaw wala to grocery store, everywhere the upi payment is accepted...
This video was before 4 years
@@sreehari972 today is the result of what actions they took in the past, only if you could assess.
@@RAHUL-kl1ec left wing can not understand or comprehend long term things. The only know that refute everything, anything that's done by the current gov.
@@sreehari972 demonetization ke baad hi to online transaction push Kia tha. This intellectual was predicting ki isko ni lagta ye log UPI use krenge
The way she talks, her wide eye and that hand gestures reminds me of that principal who slapped and punched me LOL
The attitude of the student is also not appropriate
Some students deserve it
Ouch
Same here
You deserve that
The person raising this question has been proven incredibly wrong now as now every vegetable vendor, fruit seller & all are now using UPI linked to their bank accounts...
Even still cash is the king .. we r not in 2050 yet 😂
@@akhilbansal5507 been 6 years b=now
@@akhilbansal5507 but small vendors are using these UPI for transactions. I only use cash when i pay to e rikshaw otherwise fruit seller, auto rikshaw they all accept Payment through UPi
Rural India still needs cash transaction.
Online payment is danger in 3000 also bec data stealing
Today in 2020, even every shopkeeper, panwala is using online transaction methods
Yes 😁
We wants Azaadi -JNU playcard
Teramera rishtha kya hey masala dosa....masala dosa...jnu slogan
Someone may opt and someone may not
Lol no it's just a shitty trend but now it got lost it value and nobody is fucking accept money in digital way
2016 - milkmen farmers dont do paytm
2019 - milkmen and farmers now only do pay tm and phone pe
some have vision and some dont
Yes some have vision.....and happy we youth also have vision.
2014 - youth, No mission and vision
2019 - YOUTH, With vision and mission.
Seriously that's a vision lol do u know who gets Paytm profit
Also people are using internet more effectively because of price cut in internet charges.
@iGiggin Khongsai true
If you think milkmen and farmers all over India know how to use pay TM and phone pe then you are wrong , In Tamil Nadu there are lot of farmers and milkmen who do not know phone pe or Paytm .
you can use JNU videos as anger and irritation management practices
Hahahaha right
🧘♂️
Hahaha
Bhakti Joshi well said .
😂
If this person is still alive..he saw different india which he never imagined
😂😂😂😂
And that took so many things and even pushed india way back where we would have suppose to stand. Online transaction were just an option and still it's just an option! Govt literally forced especially local vendors to adopt digital payment (this is even when govt didn't had hard currency ) digital transaction were just an coat to hide Govt failures
@@AddyBox pushed back.... seriously 😂
@@doordie5145 now just adding "😂" laughing emoji doesn't make you more sensible 😊
@@AddyBox Online transactions are a part of their narratives that our government has been throwing around to cover the mess they had created.
I am not a big fan of BJP but at least she had the decency to hear the question without interrupting. Got to have an open mind and ability to listen. This type of attitude only discredits him.
Shaswata Chatterjee I am actually giving her credit. I don’t know what you are trying to do. And I dare you to “smack” her keyboard warrior.
@Shaswata Chatterjee black money stasher spotted 😂 kya huwa jal gayi? Bol Bharat Mata ki jai aur imaandari se kamaa paise
@Shaswata Chatterjee shows how disrespectful you are and how mean u are ..
More over this is a 2016 video ,that guy should realise that now in 2019 every one has a Paytm account a banking card. No matter who.
@@Rmm1236 not everyone has it..
@Shaswata Chatterjee U r right dear
That guy just can't control himself. messed it up.
These people r with iota of knowledge
Yes ! Exuberance of youth, trying to act smart in front of a national leader, he should have let her speach and then dissect her step by step
@@AbhishekMishra-hh5kq yes bro JNU ke ek student pe har sal 7 lac ruppes karch hota h. Maro salo ko.
@@pep8221 nobel laureate abhijit bannerjee, S jaishankar, nirmala sitharaman, sitaram yechury, amitabh kant , prakash karat , maneka Gandhi, srijit mukherjee, jawed habib aur kai saare national politicians JNU se hai, apne sarkaar ke khilaaf awaaz uthaana desh droh nahi hai, ye ek democracy ki pehchaan, agar aap sarkar ke fan ban jaate hai aur question karna bandh kar dete hai to aapki sarkaar tanashahidictatorship) main badaljaati hai, kisi party ko support karna ya nahi karna apko desh drohi ya desh premi nahi bana deta, dissent or questioning your governments work is a constitutional right and everyone has right to exercise it! Aur baat hai jnu ki, ye desh ke best educational institutions main jaha admission poori tarah se merit pe hota hai, yaha pe bacche ameer se ameer aur gareeb se gareeb parivaron se ate hai, aur education pe 7 lakh kya 10 lakh kharch karna chahiye
@@AbhishekMishra-hh5kq let me add more alumni from JNU
Founder of Emirates
PM of Nepal
PM of Libya
Finance minister of Afganistan
Secretary general of ASEAN
Indian Ambassador to USA
Indian Ambassador to Netherlands
Indian Ambassador to Ireland and of other 13 countries
Indian parmanent representative to UN- Sayed Akabaruddin
First secretary at India's UN mission- (women that had exposed Pakistan's representative of UN)
Fomer RAW chief
Former IB chief
CEO of Niti aayog
Former deputy governor of RBI
Former Indian Deputy National Security Advisor
R. Subramanyam - HRD Secretary
Sanjaya Baru - Media advisor and chief spokesperson of former PM, Manmohan Singh
Amitabh Rajan - Former Additional Chief Secretary (Home) of Maharashtra (Responsible for Ajmal Kasab's hanging)
Deepak Rawat
Pranjal Patil - Country's first visually challenged IAS officer
Any many more.....
In any debate I have seen JNU students behaviour is indesciplined.
Bhai ya indiscipline hai toh bajrang dal vala toh tumha devta lagta honga.
typical jnu grandstanding. These dari wallahs always try to win an argument by only one means. They will not let the other party speak. Only they will speak & their word is the last word.
@@historyeditz8326 ye tera defense h JNU ke padho ko unke saath compare kar raha h? We all know wahi comparison ho sakta h JNU walo ka. Kisi dusre college ya institution se thodiya.
@S bhai they don't have anything logical to say.... They know 4-5 words which they use in every ill informed opinion...
@@historyeditz8326 bajrang dal walo se problem kya hai bhai
JNU students : We only want to ask questions, we don't want replies.
Theye tend to be presented as factual and intellectuals, but can't actually speak the same. Totally fallacious to speak they all comprises of, again the same atteibutes, but not the case for everyone. Guy like him and the one have constant tendancies to literally revolt on anything to everything, cuz being a part of this institution says so.
She addressed a student in the end Maam. That shows her dignity
When you completed 10 years in JNU and you still want to study 🤣🤣🤣..
Taxpayers ka paisa babu bhaiya. Udaye jao, Udaye jao. Fictional Azaadi ki guhar lagaye jao, lagaye jao.
😂
Actually he wants to say " that A is his father, but he wants deny it by saying his right to deny,. And wants to opt B as his father".
I am 40 year old and I want to study.
And they protest on a hike from ₹10 rent to 300%, as if the country has snatched away their existence.
Dil wale Puch de ne jaaaaaa oooooh ooooo oooooh 😂
Funniest FM...EVER.....IN HISTORY OF ALL COUNTRIES
100%😂
Exactly 😂😂😂
Hahahahha seriously
Yeah
It's so relatable
Here i am watching this video after 5 years and more importantly paying my doodhwala and sabjiwala via paytm or gpay .......and also understanding that there is a great difference between a policy made by bureaucrats and a college student OPINION!
This is what happens when u don’t get placements for centuries 😂
Are you the popular Quoran?
Jiooooooooooooooooo
And he became a kanhiya kumar
Hahaha...😂
Do you think communists ever get employed? They don't want to work under a boss... They all want to be the boss...
I went to Hogenakkal falls, dude who ran boat accepted google pay. That is a damn change.
The questioner and the answerable person, both are made for each other... To keep their attitude intact.
2:00 Fast forward to 2021: doodhwallas, thelawallahs are using digital payment--probably more than other merchants. So, welcome to the future😉
Now none of these so called JNU fanboys will accept it. It doesn't fit their narrative dude.
Sorry but I belong to a rural area & there aren't any dhoodhwalas aur thelawalas using digital payment..
@@riapandit5888 well that depends on which state you are in. In Karnataka alot of people IN the rural area use UPI PAYMENTS.
@@rohankabadi389 I Bihar many of local shops have started using to accept digital payment however its not in large number but it has started and not gonna stop until 100% digitalisation for transaction.
@@awesomeankit good bro
This man here is the prime example why JNU students have such a bad reputation in the country. Having said that , we should not generalise.
Bhai Nirmala sitharaman is also from JNU
Akshay Dongre different generation. He’s talking about the current situation
@@akshaydongre7249 these students thinks that now they r in JNU that means they r equal to these alumnis.
Damn.!! That guy is too good at embarrassing himself.
Best comment i read today
Hahahhaha
Damm you're too good at embarrassing your parents
@@animeshnanaware8288 Well someone got offended😂..... are you really trying to defend that guy?😂😂
@@sahasss7100 What's wrong in defending that guy... he is asking some real questions and she's not able to answer them rather she's blaming JNU for it or its culture
His speech and language will tell you this piece of Scrap is from JNU.!
Ekant Pathak jnu standard has gone down big time and his parents must teach him how to behave with a senior person I bet he speaks same way to his mom too
Get lost who thinks jnu is a scrap
Questioning is not a crime
@@Badbayafternoon. lol
@@animeshnanaware8288 there is a proper way to do it
She didn't win.... The guy was questioning on poor people she took it as religion and backward class
Ok uncle
@@marendranodi2693 Ok boomer
@@pep8221 bruh..xD
@@noobperfect69 tera aukat bhi nahi h Nalsar me admission lene ka
@@pep8221 Ok dear
He actually didn't want to hear an answer. He just wanted to create a scene. now if this doesn't make people question the atmosphere in JNU after bharat tere tukde honge stuff, then what will?
😂😂😂 Nirmala ma'am diverted the issue.Look at an MP's earning and a street vendor's earning from the same community.
She doesn't want to answer.. just created scene...then, why he wants to hear??
She should have not visited to this place. She is capable of interacting with low class people of party cadres.
For all those who blame the guy should be able to understand his question. He asks a question and the minister's answers are totally unrelated. He is asking about informal economy and she is talking about ministers. She doesn't understand the question for which te guy is trying to explain.
She is not capable of answering questions in such places.
Even I am from Bangladesh and I have irrited by this students!...Salute to this lady for her patients..
She is India's symbol of an empowered woman and serves as the Minister of Finance and Corporate Affairs since 2019. I am very happy to live in this era. Jai hind!
But in all honesty, she just deflected the questions with rhetorics -_-
All BJP members do the same
U. B. Exactly
@@Nil-kd9wz watch the uncut version of the whole meetup. She deflects questions not just from the one guy but also from almost anyone. People do listen when one is earnest and uses logic rather than using rhetorics and losing the favour of the crowd.
@@u.b.5773 The guy was giving anecdotal evidence. The guy said that he knows the plight of the marginalised section. Nirmala Sitharaman told him the representatives are called representatives because they come from those marginalised and those strata too. They are their representatives so she has the idea as to what may occur because of govt. policies. And those representatives are not only selected and went to parliament from her party, but from other parties too. So he can be assured as to they will be listened to.
@@ackshayshukla So? What's your point?
Now even the smallest vendors use Paytm, Gpay. The startup sector is booming, this is what great leaders are they force others to reach to their desired level and not adjust to make everyone happy we need even stronger leaders to take this country forward
I wonder when the strong leaders will come🙂
@@vedagyasharma6453 DEEEEP 😂😂😂😂
@@pratiksingh6035 it's not deep it's sasta sarcasm
@@vedagyasharma6453 he is already here. Danka bajj raha h uska to sari duniya me. COP26 meet, saw some glimpses of him what did UK and Israel PM said about him??
@@vedagyasharma6453 pappu is never coming , sit down. Coz for people like you only he's the definition of a "true leader" lol
Most hated teacher of my school...who gets angry when a student ask a very honest question
That student is not ready to listen honest answers. Most hated student of the school who do not let others answer.
That is he jnu student. Radicalised foolish behaviour
@@Bharatiya1907 lol no the teacher is just incompetent to answer to the point. She deflected from the question.
@Saarthak Kapoor exactly. And with the current situation going on the same marginalised people he's trying to depict are themselves requesting to pay via UPI to ease the payments and reduce the contact. Not a party propaganda but at least there is a new technology the whole society has moved on to.
as a student first he should learn how to give respect to elders.....
its easy to give suggestions.. bt when it comes to our own head na.. we wil forget al this
No need
@@jyoti8927 Did You abuse your parents when they refused something you liked for your betterment only? No right? Why didn't you forget that in the first place?
@@vinayakkapoor1 wht u r saying man.. parent kahan se aa gye yhn pr.
What can we expect from JNU students🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
He is fed up of demonetization coz inko canteen mein udhari hai 😅.
- Kunal karma (anti national)
😂😂😂😂
See there are lot of people in India are earning a salary less than 20,000 , My relative's were earning less than 20,000 at that time , In super markets the cost is more when compared to local grocery shops and vegetable shop . If we do not have much money to buy in a super market and if we do not have change for Rs.2000 what we have to do ?
Kamaal ka zawaab.
The actual question was ignored and reply was avoided jnu question was reality of that day
@@Nonecares452 Teach your relatives how to use Mobile Payment tats it.
The way she diverted the topic is next level😂😂😂🔥🔥🔥
She isn't diverting, he isn't even allowing her to talk
She didn't allowed to complete her answer..
The way she started talking about MP and comparing them with the low economy section people itself show she was diverting the topic
The way he started blabbering shows how he wants to suppress her voice.
@@RahulSharma-se5nq Madam FM sorry to say you do not have any idea about how common people deal their normal life in India. MP,MLA and ministers even they are from marginalised society do not represent poor /common people. They get beds and treatment at covid times, but common man do not. You are trying to confuse the young boy.
In Hyderabad, the lady who sells Flowers near my house she use phonePe.☺
Here every small vendor use phonepe and paytm ... Except the aged one
Not every city is Hyderabad and not everyone sells flowers. their are people who can't even dial a number on their own
What about the remaining 99 people
Watch Cobrapost sting operation on Paytm
Hyderabad is a more or less a digitalized city
Jnu people always represent themselves as personal assistant of God.
Because they know about the real issues, unlike other ignorant people.
@@saurabhbatheja the ignorant people are those who don't acknowledge good things but instead they search for some stupid problem to question against
@@sudhirkumarnayak2693 There are too many problems, and only a few good things, still many people ask to not question the problems.
IMO, they can be called ignorant without a doubt.
Progress is not made by "acknowledging good things" but by questioning the problems.
@@saurabhbathejaI am glad gov. Replied him with action than arguing for no reason. Now everyone accepting payments through upi.
@@saurabhbatheja progress is made by both encouraging good things and criticising bad things.
Just tell a kid to do maths.
Criticise every wrong answer( made by kid)..
And for every right answer... " YOU ARE TOO SLOW IN CALCULATION"
Result: depression and hate in maths.
Nostalgic feelings struck my dad looking at these students as he sat on the couch lecturing my 18 yo daughter on how important it was to have a good career, he was from this jnu batch..." Sigh, those were the days" he said..
She didn't win, she didn't have a point....just blabbering and getting things on ego...doesn't make u win
True
Because she wasn't allowed to even blabber, that Urban Naxal just wanted to showcase that he's a know all, he didn't have a question, he didn't have anything to hear from Nirmala, he had a few points to make and he brushed it, when Sitaram tried to answer he displayed his arrogance.
@@shreenandandas6479 correct
I want my tax money back, it's going for these people? I want it back, I would rather give it to the poor people
N sitharaman is also from JNU
@@shashank1062 look like a kanaiya kumar supporter.......
@@AryanSingh-xi8de jz kidding . . I want to kill these jnu batch basically
Nirmala tai: I only care about members of parliament.
Lol what do you expect from a parliament? To conduct polls of each and every bills acts initiatives? Elect your representatives and expect them to handle things. That how it works
Name also fake ideology also fake
@@armstrong2450 yes bro it should be in some matters. Nothing is bad in that no of bills are very bad even passed by some of members. We have too have a right to challenge it even after passing it.
Wo! Stephen sir you are still alive! What an honor.
I really don't like this kind of vids where the questioners don't allow the person to respond. Bogus
Did she Won the argument , she really escaped .
Escaped
She didn't allowed to talk by thos commis
@@SanthoshKumar-so8tq : Yeah, she did not allow others to talk 😂😂😂.
@@Nonecares452 Yeah we can see that in the video who done what.. hahahaa.. That future "andolan jeevi" dont want her to answer because if she answer him properly he will be a dumb joke next day on wards.
@@SanthoshKumar-so8tq : First ask the FM to answer for his questions. 😂😂😂😂.
The person who is questioning is president of NSUI. Student wing of Congress. Stood for JNUSTUDENT Presidency this year and came 4th. what more can we expect from him!!!!!
just imagine if subramanian swamy in the place of Nirmala sitharaman 😂😂 it would have too good
Nagaraju Anjanappa Subrahmanyam Swamy would've answered to the point about ATM cards instead of making it a dalit issue.
Latha Baradwaj Dr.Subramnian Swamy always surprise me with the bold answers. He have brilliant mind, we never know what would be the answer from Dr.Swamy.
This kid would've been badly thrashed verbally with facts by swamy to the point of constipation.
It will never happen, these bugs will never show up before him, he will surely make them land in jail
@@Iamlatha True.
She didn't answer anything, she is playing with rhetorics.
Koi to Tiwari mila jo asliyat janta hai Vahi
She is trying to act like Trump😂😂
she wasn't even allowed to answer by that guy. That was rude
Ha chutiye
Did he allow her to talk. Just observe. It's okay to respond after she replies.
JNU where people studying at the age more than ३५-४० 😂😂😂😂
Hello mister, the age group you mentioned they are doing phd, can you complete your phd in 25 years?? Can you?? If not then shut up....
In all universities of India students do their phd from 30-50 age... why are you only accusing JNU students while whole India doing the same??
Edit: I am not a JNU student.
Because I didn't see any other Students making riots on every matter in country 😂
@@surajmulik7927 Actually the thing is only students in our country raise issues and riots and protests against Government because the country is not going in the right direction...
This country rulers also did the same thing in their earlier days, nirmala sitaraman ji did so many protests , i did read in my text books...
Don't you think there is something wrong in India in these circumstances that's why the protests are happening??
Not just JNU students, farmers, doctors, ssc students, teachers, bank workers everyone are protesting , why?? Because they love to ?? No,, because their patience has come to its limit.
Agar kuch sahi nahi hai to protest hona kya kharabi hai?? Main to nahi dekh rahi India mein kuch achcha ho raha hai, mehengai bar rahi hai, garibi nei gayi, jobs nahi hai....agar koi layak ho to yeh sab issues to chala jana chahiye right jitni bhi opposition ho ( jin log international issues itni achchi tarha handle kar sakte hai, duniya mein jhagre kam kar sakte hai, duniya ko inspire kar sakte hai, woh national issues ko solve nahi kar pa rahe hain?? Strange!!) ...
This is a humble discussion,,I am not debating, just say what is happening in India.
@@Annie-uq1md problem is not with protest but with how these protests are becoming against a party or are for politics than for genuine social cause. JNU students do protest on CAA but they never did protest for so many years on our education system. If they have did that national education policy would have come many years before. I was actually shocked on how much disrespectly he was talking,this is how a JNU student should ask a question complaining like a child even not meating the eye of minister while minister were answering the question. After all his question and many big leaders analysis become rubbish because today a small wender also uses digital payment. They planned the scheme very smartly with the lauch of jio and decreasing amount of interest services
@@user-bh6mz2kf6o got your point.
She is like a matron of a woman hostel, so funny.
Matron of a maternity hospital ...!
Brilliant ma'am, but Mr separatist won't hear
This boy will be quickly promoted in the Congress Party. What a beautiful sickular state we have!!!!
S-e-c-u-l-a-r
@@israeldevadason563 s-i-c-k-u-l-a-r
@@splitsecondblackswan dafuq is sickular ?
I never understood that insult
Just like Kanhaiyaan kumar, shaila rashid, jignesh entered Indian politics with the support of Congress
Now at 2024...when i see qr code in vegetable vendor
He is not even coherent ....if thats the standard of JNU ...God help India .
His arguements are absurd .
What else can be expected of NDTV.
this beared man is making argument without knowledge
Thats the culture of JNU....for them it is like I am the knowledgeable ...and you are to answer me...these guys are rogues...
High confidence with less knowledge
These are chutiya modern man
01:48 see that girl's reaction to that JNU student
The whole nation had same reactions to these pseudo intellectuals.
Jnu students were biggest boon for modi and bjp
Nirmala ji always sounds like my maths teacher... She was my favorite teacher... U r great Nirmala mam
Then she must have teached Biology.
@@Relpendeituq what I said.. sounds like my maths teacher
@@state_warrior In case you didn't get the joke political leaders always try to change the topic whenever you ask them a difficult question. So if Nirmala Ji was your maths teacher then she would have taught you Biology
These are all students from quota!!
Dogs bark hahaha.what about A P J Abdul Kalam ?quota?
@@BBASFArnold how dare u compare this idiot with hon'ble Abdul Kalam sir???????
Don't generalise everything buffoon
No KOTA
please stop all Government Fundings to JNU
I don't want to waste my tax on such cheap peoples
Vikram A - Nirmala Sitharaman graduated from jnu .......Modi is a Fraudi
Vibhor S - Looser! Get a life
Vibhor S
What ever I think these beggers should not be fed by my Tax .
If they have guts build your own pvt college of Leftist and separatist ideology
They qualify the Exam , you don't give them money , they deserve it ....also aukat hai to rokar dikha de funding.... feku ki bhi fat jati hai ...chala tha NDTV ban karne , SC kya pahuche mut diya paint me
70-80% High ranking army officers have JNU degree .... half of expert of Modi's team are from JNU
what a bunch of disrespecting imperialistic type of ppl who dont want 2 hear other's viewpoint
A vast majority of these naxalite students join after being members of one or other party or being pushed through by some MP-MLA backing. They make sure to extract their pound of flesh demanding what they have done in this and that regard. It is a very dirty business here just like Bollywood. Even the professors etc need to show some amount of troublemaking to ensure that they get recommended for being sent abroad etc. The massive network of filth that surrounds JNU is unimaginable.
He is such a moron! By only arguing n not letting her speak proves what an idiotic fool he is.
Rip logic
Welcome to "modern" India.
😂😂😂 accepting jumlas are respectful.
Upi knows Biggest digital payment method
These students are what I refer to as,'the five point someones of JNU'.
Damn.!! He lost it so badly, he would be searching it for couple of days to come..
Thank god she didnt say that i dont eat vegetables 🤣
@@krishnarajagopalan528 they are jholla jnu chap
For heaven's sake where did she win ? She didn't even answer him plus was trying to mock him and twist his questions....and finally shut up coz she obviously had no answer
Idiot first watch full video
abe jnu ke lavde woh ladka bol hi nhi de rha kaise bolegi
She must be really stressed
Imagine if she's our FM! oh wait!
We will be fucked. Oh wait
Oh she is .
This bearded guy who is only interested in lecturing not listening has a bright future in the circles of pseudo-intellectuals in India. Who knows - he may even find himself as a 'news analyst' in this channel!! On a serious note, this guy personifies the intellectual dishonesty seen in certain campuses and regressive left. He has no answers to India's corruption problem. His only job (similar to many anchors on this channel) is to punch as many holes as possible in the plan purely based on anecdotal references (my dhoodhwaala or vegetable vendor!!) What a joke!!
Joker is very impolite... not letting her answer
Manje kai re
He will be the next editor in Wire or Quint
And Today each and every small businesses having e-payment options like Paytm, Gpay or phonepe..
So their vision is correct i feel
That was ambani's vision lol
@@dibyakantidas9116 So You can do one THING go BACK to 1980's KOLKATA , Stand in Line in Bank for MONEY Withdrawl, Don't use smart PHONE, Don't Use EARPHONE, Don't Use GOOGLE, Don't Use COLOR TV, and Plz Use..BAEIL GADDIYou Don't Belong to 2020..which is Changing.. You Belong TO CALCUTTA OF 1890 OR 1980 .. Mr Bangali.. ANGA BONGO VONGO.
@@dibyakantidas9116 BTW, Ambani Vision Was Giving GHAR GHAR Telecom.. I think 3gb/day of 4g for 3months with 400 ₹ is coz of JIO otherwise you cAN GO BACK to AIRTEL 2016 of using 2gb/month of 3g for 560₹ 🤣🤣
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 that's not the point. I support his vision but giving this credit to modiji is foolishness
No doubt why she is the worst Finance Minister.
Haaaa aap kyu nahi bann jaate fir?
@@sohini2702 wo uk,us,france ke reh chuki hai India ki kaha aukaat itne buddhimaan finance minister ki
Its because act of god
@@sohini2702 tu bnegi
@@footballartisan8990 nahi chaiye ese बुद्धिमान log
Let her speak for crying out loud ! She has a point too. The guy loves the sound of his own voice
And these people think they can run a nation? These students don't give a ratsass about dhoodhwala and dahiwala.
something's wrong with his patience
He about the one who’s answering?? She doesnt know a thing
Did she even understand the context and points made by him😂😂😂😂
How do we know, he didn't even let her answer.
If he allowed her to answer .. We would have known.. But he keeps on talking.. No decency of listening
@@amoghkarambelkar5476 What he asked and tried to replicate was ignored by Nirmala ji..... SHe tried to make it political influenced. and started on marginal section of MP's and MLA's ,....... Mtlb yarr...... If our so called fakir admi is on rock in his tenure,, so do you expect his MP's to be
Discriminated by others in wealth, caste, community......
did he even f"kin care to let her answer what if in the course of her answer she would have answered the question?
@@mohammadnizam4073 if se would have made a sensible point in starting only,, He would have not come across in her hypocrite answers....
Man our Finance Minister is PURE CLASS.
My dudhvala has Paytm, Google pay now. I pay him with Google pay 😀
Exactly what she was trying to say. The guy picks one example he saw and tried to paint the whole section. She was about to say there are people in the parliament who represent these marginal communities and the case is not so. Street vendors are switching to digital.
He never let her finish the answer and the commentators here on TH-cam drew a conclusion that she was diverting.
Your reply came 3+ years after demonetization. Sorry.
@@microg5139 Rg gusai is also speaking from one observation "his dhudhwala".
Also, I agree that vegetable sellers and vendors are also switching to Paytm and online banking, but most of them still have no idea what online banking is. It's not about the vendors who are using online banking, it's about the ones not using them.
I don't blame you if u didn't see how smartly she was trying to divert the point from 'poor' to 'lower-caste', she was doing it so elegantly by trying to make the guy look like that he was not respecting the constitution, to make it a patriotic argument, watch the video again to see if u can point it out this time how she smartly jumped out of the question and didnt have to answer it. Never underestimate the cleverness of a politician, there is a reason they got hundreds of millions of people to follow them, cuz they know how to talk people into stuff
@@microg5139 do you even know that Google pay was released in 2017??
@@isNamanSharma brother online system u r talking about ...govt only want to earn tax ..that is what I want to say ....my milk seller is a gujjar .....he doesn't even knows totalling. .we total n tell him 31 days month ..u didn't deliver milk on 3 days so this much total ...there are street vendors who earn 200-300 n want money daily ..how will they buy vegetables etc mostly are illiterate. ..even literate don't know all these stuffs
IITians are building fintech companies to promote cashless economy. JNU students everything but studying. Anyway JNU should learn from China how they transformed into mobile payments. They are ahead of US in digital payments.
Btw I dare them to speak in this tone to Akhiesh Yadav or Mayawati or Mamta Didi. Their party workers will see to that you are bed ridden for whole semester.
U r certainly mistaken... Nirmala Sitharaman herself is a JNU passout...and many national n international leading lights are JNU passouts.
Just at not all IITians or IIM pass outs are no great shakes, some are infact miserable failures, similarly donot form ur opinionss based on such short clips...even after 6 years of the current govts ruthless efforts to discredit JNU, it has still ranked as the top most university in the country
Are yaar IITs are tech institutions while JNU is a social science and humanities institution. Ab kyua tujhe history ke students rocket bana ke denge
@@z_l_275 LOL. Graduation outcome of JNU is 99.12 which is highest than any other institution of india. And this score is a measure of placements. Tu apna narrow mentality apne pas hi rakh. Ilitrate fellow.
@cyrus cyrus First of all I am not a JNU student. And it is not good to say anything without having proper knowledge and saying that social science doesn't have any job is just absurd and it shows his narrow mentality.
This is so low level attitude that fellow has..she is defence minister of India..mind your expressions..if u r congress agent be it..go and shout on roads with mike..
lol yet she is not even elected by people.
He looks like a future "Andolan Jeevi" lol 😂
JNU is one of the most overrated Universities in India. If he is one of the frontbenchers of the Universities ( GENERALLY the bright one's) and somewhat of a mascot, who can talk and talk and don't have the basic quality to listen this University has great days ahead. In this context, of the often repeated common man-uncommon man, poor-rich debate he raises, in the great days of the caveman clothes, cooked food and currency was unthinkable. But change is the only constant, the caveman understood and got dressed, cooked his food and later got food from restaurant with paper.
Getting a card is free. So too opening a "zero balance" bank account these days if you know. There is no finance involved, only some basic changes are required. Yes all changes are slow and comes with some discomfort, but if it is for the overall good than it is only wise to endured for a better future. A financially poor man would not get rich by using cash, but would definitely get some benefits using a card (just one example your pocket gets picked cash gone. Card gets stolen still nothing lost.) Mr. JNU wannabe Che Guevara "poor man" are the one's who refuses change and remains in their fancy cocoons.
Which one is not overrated and better ?
RSS shakha.....lol
Atul Kumar Dwivedi I think you don't have a proper information regarding RSS cadres. I am an RSS cadre and earned my master degree from IIT dhanbad which is far better than JNU .
You do know that Nirmala Sitharaman herself is from JNU.
AT PRESENT THE JNU TALKS ABOUT DIVIDING THE COUNTRY AND BEFORE IT WAS TALKING ABOUT ONLY NEHRU AND THE CONGRESS
If you spend five minutes asking a question, have the patience to listen an answer. You didn't let her complete even one sentence.
Left parties have existed in India for one hundred years, and they have ruled in just three states, not taken root anywhere else.
I feel so sad, the student raised valid and vital points, but he destroyed a great chance to put the BJP minister on the spot, make her give some straight answers. You have to engage in actual give and take conversations, back and forth dialogues to convince your audience. That's democracy.
Shutting down the lady every time she started to speak, will not work. We don't have Communist comrade commissars and general secretaries here, thank goodness.
He made zero valid points to start with.
@@abhyudaysingh7930 The question of 2000 rs notes, with the next lower denomination being only 100 Rs was valid, if he had known how to behave properly.
@@sreeravi25 he was talking on behalf of rickshaw drivers and tea stall owners. These guys hardly transacted with bigger amounts than 100 Rs notes to begin with.
@@abhyudaysingh7930 Yes, but even in those cases, there are situations where amount of 1000 odd would be needed. How will they pay for the raw materials if bill comes for 700 Rs? How will they pay for 3-4 day's diesel costing 900 Rs? Not every person deals with less than 100 rs cash a day.
The question was valid, and in the end, instead of catching them on point, the guy misbehaved and lost his respect. But, hey, all is well that ends well :)
@@sreeravi25 well then the people who dont deal with less than 100 rupee per day would just transact a 2000 Rupee note or more if they need it won't they. Also I said 100 rupee notes not less than 100 in case you read it wrong. Problems can't be solved with the same attitude which created them. You need to be able to see the bigger picture. And everyone in the country knew what was happening and was understanding towards others problems. Only the so called liberals and the ones who stashed away all the black money were having a problem with this change and used it negatively to gain publicity and TRP. Today every chaiwala, rickshaw Walla is using Paytm, phonepe and all these apps. All because of notebandi. That guy knew his question was bogus and she had an answer for it so he started stalling and beating around the bush and made sure she eventually diverts away from the question and he gets his 5 minutes of fame from his tukde tukde gang
looks like she forgot to take her BP tablets
rahul sahani BJP tablets
Thats not how the scene looks like. Those people are so unruly that they are not even allowing her to talk. That guy just grabbed the mike and started to blabber away on top of her while expecting the other person to listen which she did. When it was her chance to answer, let her finish her sentence. The girl next to him started to ask a question despite being said a while ago that she would get back to her after she answers to his question. I can only see the pathetic state of their classroom lecturers/professors. I have been to many countries both far east and the west but I have always observed that people from many cultures never talk over others and apologize if it happens by accident. Its a reflection of bad upbringing. Dont get to my political stand here infact I’m more leaned towards dem than republicans; more liberal than right winged but this sort of behavior has nothing to do with politics.
Nd what about that man who doesn't want to shut his mouth he forget to take tables of clozapam so he was not able control his emotion....bht fikr hai tum logo ko dudhh walo ki reddi walo ki bhai unko dikkat hui hai pr kuch achaa hua hai kuch ache k liye kast saha h bhltai nhii election k result dekh liya hoga to pta chal gya hoga pichli bar se jayda seat thee thande rahhh ab
Siya Ram pls explain Kya acha ho raha hai.. note bandhi par bhi aisa hi bola tha
@@SiyaRam-wg7rpAaj Kal Bjp IT cell wale educated logon ko recruit kar rahe hai... Kitna bhi try karlo jo point hai uspe toh baat nai hoti inse
6 years passed, and now everybody uses Paytm, even if you want to give cash, nobody is ready to give change. they ask sir PhonePe kardo.
JNU students are impatience.
Shame on ☻☻
JNU has NIRF rank 2
@@ANONYMOUS-wc5fq It doesn't matter. It's only good for arts.
Nirmalaji also did her post-grad & M.Phil in Economics from JNU.
ANONYMOUS terrorists producing rank no. 1
Kyu admission nahi mila kya ..?
nirmala madam . true respect to you . u handled it like a BOSSS.. JNU must be proud of u mam.
i wonder what these "so called students " real ambition in life is. i see no future in them.....quality of conversations..
all aged 30 to 35 ..
She speaks Lyk a teachr😁
Strict teacher
Sahi pakde hai
At least she's letting him talk not like our honourable you know who
I happy m not in JNU or Delhi
me too
Me also
SAURABH PAHADE you could not have made it to them
Nobody even wants to !!! cuz everyone knows you become a hypocrite when u enter JNU ! I know JNU mentality. they live in constant inferiority complex of IITians and IIMians and other professionals. They see these students being successful at a really fast pace and just to hide their jealousy , start coming up anti-capitalism, anti-nationalism rhetoric.
They keep abusing Ambani, and the next day will buy a Jio sim.
They keep abusing Bill Gates, but have Windows OS.
They talk about hungry poor people and themselves gobble up dominoes pizza! hmmmm tasty capitalism!
They talk about a classless India society but themselves provoke Dalit sentiment by using the name of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar. If you are so against the classification of Dalits, then why use the same term to classify a certain sect of the society.
They have tarnished the name of the legendary Bhagat Singh by associating him with their stupid anti nationalism ideas. Bhagat Singh would be ashamed to see ppl using his name like this.
So its good to stay away from a place like this !
@@parklinkin6624 Do you know Nirmala Sitharaman is also from JNU ?
She's the kind of person who would say "let them have cake"
Madame Antoinette reference
However just to clarify it was a myth, she never said such thing, it was made up story
She can boil milk in 20 seconds. She's boiling too fast!
She instead of bringing the MPs MLAs and getting into quotas ... should have directly answered his question...with one single statement...
Only if there was one
@@leftplusright6230 waha fasne wali baath kya hei uss question me?
I am not very fan of this government but this guy must listen to others if he is asking something
This is the attitude of college revolutionaries... When i was in college these leftist students talk to the principal the same way.... They don't even have the patience to at least listen to his clarification..... They always have this mob mentality bahut logonko ekhatta karo aur azadi azadi bhokthe raho......
Bhai dekh jnu me adhe se jyada students hote h bher chaal wale chaman chutiye jidhr le chalo udhr hi jaenge..to inse jyada expect krna sahi h nahi
Legend says The guy still didn't get the answer (of his question) 😂
because he didn't let her answer 🤣😂
@@prajwalnl07 Thats somewhat true the guy was also a little eager but still she wasn't answering what he had asked.
@Varghese Manakalathil bro she didn't even finished her first sentence and that guy interupted her and yoy say she didn't touch the answer correctly
@Varghese Manakalathil if you have the power to raise a question than you must have the. patience to listen to answer did you see the at the end of the vedio if you call this formality idk what else to say
@Varghese Manakalathil just look at her face before asking a question and after getting interrupted her they were not only interupting but wrongly interpreting her and and please watch her other interviews before making any allegations
Title: She took on a student and won
Me who wanted to see her winning: 🤔🤔🤔
Do at least one of them look like a student??? JNU is a lost cause... would never hire anyone from that place which produces tukde tukde gang
How does one look like a student? Do you have even the slightest idea the time it takes to do a PhD? Have you been to any university aside from maybe an engineering institute where mostly students study for 4 years in order to get a job at the pvt sector. You don't even have an inkling about higher studies and here you are bullshitting in TH-cam comments.
@@rohitmunshi9573 i have done my double masters from one of the top universities on the planet...where u cant even dream to get an admission...dont get judgemental about people and i know about JNU..so dont give me that bullshit...heard the younger gen in India have some brains but never thought there could be exceptions like u..u live in a shell.. come out of it and see the real world..i did not study in any of those b grade colleges u mentioned as my grades were far higher than people such as u could imagine...
@@rohitmunshi9573 yes when i say i dont prefer hiring such people, its coz i have that academic credentials, awareness and privilege to say that...so please a big FO
@@roxyvo Wow you have a double masters from a 'top university of the planet' and yet you buy into the cheap asinine narrative of tukde tukde gang. What a joke.
@@rohitmunshi9573 weren't u the one praising them few hours back buddy...choose a side..dont be double sided...now they became cheap suddenly... see u carry on with ur fucking theory n please dont bother people like us anymore...
Yeh JNU mein sab uncle n Aunties kyun hai 😂 Also, look at all sabziwalas now, how will India move forward if they will not keep up with the changing times..
Change is the only constant.
I am not a BJP bhakt but that guy after Ur question listen carefully their return speach 🤦
rajan rajan either u don’t comprehend or you don’t, she used what he said about marginalised people not answer.
cyrus cyrus why should I know her answer if she decide to dance around and not give an answer
I salute you mam Nirmal devi hats up to you and master modhiji
I have seen many ghupchup vendors using paytm... This is true ,if you sees everything from your perspective, you could never achieve anything..
I was totally surprised to see this video on this channel and say 'she won' .🙏👏👏
I think it was saracsm
Hahahahahah... Amazing illiterate over aged students of JNU 😂😂
He is talking about below poverty line people, she did not answer the question she just directed it to backward class people who are mps and MLAs
one word answer thodi hai yaar..... pura bolneto de...
He should have let her finished her whole answer first , only then we could have judge her answer whether it was diverting or to the point , but unfortunately people just don't want to listen or discuss , they just want to argue and try to prove they know better than others.
These nonsense jnu student don't have a courtesy how to speak Hon'ble defense minister of the country....
JNU is losing it's credibility year after year.
Now I got the answer why 'students' in jnu get beaten up by police.
Nice recommendation
The dude can chill now. India has surpassed China, USA in cashless transactions. It was a legit question, but have hope with the country's vision as well.