And what's funny about Ginny's poem to Harry is that at the time that she wrote it, she had the diary, and chances are she probably confided in it and it gave her some advice to make it better, so it's possible that Voldemort wrote Harry a love poem.
I don't think so - Ginny had tried to flush the diary a few weeks earlier and found out on Valentines day that Harry had it when his bag ripped and Malfoy picked it up (Harry was trying to get away from one of the cupid dwarves at the time)
The tatto thing is exactly the opposite of what they thought, romilda thought it was a hipogriff and Ginny said it was a Hungarian Horntail cuz she thought it was more badass
I'm surprised that Professor Slughorn never remarked on Harry's family inventing these Popular Potions. As a Potions Master, wouldn't he know those facts?
And a seeker of skillful people he would have most definitely have looked into Harry's family because the books support the narrative that magical and potion making skill is genetic.
Imagine if all of these comments were what Ollivander said to Harry, and imagine if he told other people that, and then people would have started to question the fact that he was Sorted into Ravenclaw... That would actually be pretty funny-- no offense to Ollivander, though.
Good way to remember! I remember Stonewall High because of this iconic exchange, "'They stuff people's heads down the toilet the first day at Stonewall,' he[Dudley]told Harry. 'Want to come upstairs and practice?' 'No, thanks,' said Harry. 'The poor toilet's never had anything as horrible as your head down it --- it might be sick.' Then he ran, before Dudley could work out what he'd said.'
I feel so bad that somebody literally went up to Ben and accused him of not reading the books when he is literally half of a channel partially based around Harry Potter. RUDE.
He knows enough but he mentions that he listens to it ,the people that read it for audiobooks tend to skip details that seem unimportant ,therefore reading it is better from the prespective that he theories about it for his job, Oh and maybe he’s like me and can’t remember small details
Matt Robinson at 28:31 I think jay is surprised because Ben got it right and it wasn’t even a sweet he considered. He also says “that’s amazing!!” but he doesn’t seem like he didn’t recognize the name, even though they didn’t know what it was
5:22 I think people forget that these brothers usually answer the questions without the multiple choices; that is a HUGE handicap. If I wanted to answer all these questions correctly (in the same manner) I would need to study for it by taking notes, highlighting passages, and using flashcards to remember the seemingly unimportant details. That would ruin the story for me. It makes me sad that some Harry Potter "fans" think that you didn't read the books if you can't remember all the nitty gritty details.
yeah, and I really hate that Ben is so self-conscious about disappointing us. I always root for him but I'd never call him a fake fan over getting some of the answers wrong.
I myself have always noticed that I very easily pick up on tiny details and remember them, so these quizzes are often no problem for me, but I can see why it might be tough on someone that isn’t as capable of remembering tiny details. I love that we have an underdog to cheer for in these video’s, it adds more excitement when ben actually manages to win.
I'm pretty sure the reason lupin didn't send a birthday cake was because he was dirt poor and out of a job, also umbridge made an anti werewolf thing to make it virtually impossible for lupin to get a job
I think it was because Harry didn't write to him about Dudley's horrible diet. He wrote to the others asking for real food and received the cakes and other goodies!
Doesn't Ron say the "Yeah, we'll call you, if we ever need anyone mental" line to sir Cadogan the first time he shows them the way to the Divination classroom ?
anyone notice that when Harry lost his bones due to Lockhart's spell in Chamber of Secrets, he is given Skelo-Gro to get his bones back? "Thanks family!" - Harry
I like how they make it sound like Harry failed his OWL just because he passed out when he actually barely remembered anything and then after he passed out was given the option to continue but said he was done.
I thought troll was a joke answer. Has it been confirmed as an actual grade one can get? I specifically remember that Fred and George try to cheer Harry up when he receives a D by saying that at least it wasn’t a T from the first time I read the Harry Potter books (but it was in Swedish, my mother tongue, so the letters were different) because Harry was trying to figure out what T might stand for that’s worse than Dreadful.
@Dr Who Yes, but the Weasleys are a family which can depend on one another. Remus is an individual who has been ostracised from most of the Wizarding community because he's a werewolf.
Harry, after getting the diary: my name is Harry Potter. Tom Riddle, remembering Ginny brainstorming the poem: ...imma kill this boy AND his little girlfriend.
Is it possible that Ben is more visual than auditory? So listening to the books isn’t as good for memorizing facts from the book for him? Or is it just the messy desk problem? Hehe. I would do worse than Ben if I didn’t get multiple choice so still good job. Good job both of you! 👍
@@lordvika2526 He never does that much worse than J does though...? And he has won a few. These quizzes are ridiculously challenging w/o multiple choice sometimes. And his reasoning behind many incorrect answer choices is sound, e.g. for the Patronus question
@@mattc3788 I know this, I was just giving a response to what this person commented. I have watched every single J vs Ben. One thing I noticed is the they both do really well. Ben usually wins the Pixar quizzes more often and Jay wins the HP quizzes more often. But both are great at them
I bet you are so right! I used to be a teacher, and there is a difference between people who are visual and people who are auditory. Thank you for bringing that up.
“Wouldn’t it be really weird to learn math with letters?” Programmers: Yes. Yes it is. What is c minus a? Easy. 2. If you had c points you’d be killing it.
@@pigi1004 but it all falls under the group of math. You don’t add s to something because it has a subgroup. Do you say: let’s study our science or let’s study our sciences. There’s also many types of algebra, geometry, I could do this forever.
I thought Lupin said this, but apparently Dumbledore did it: «remembered the most unusual form your Patronus took, when it charged Mr. Malfoy down at your Quidditch match against Ravenclaw» :) sort of implies that it was a corporal form.
Could also just be a painterly explanation, I mean I think it means the same but it's pretty vague to base a quiz on because it's open to interpretation.
@@RupeeRhod it is definitely a corporal form. dumbledore made the connection between Harry's patronus James after finding out that James became a stag when he transformed. he says the line about remembering it from the quidditch match then says something like "in a way, you did see your father last night, in you".
Yeah, Dumbledore even comments something to the effect of “How else could you produce that particular patronus?” Before explaining that Sirius told him about them all becoming animagi, and that is how he recognized it from when Harry cast it at the Slytherins during the quidditch match
@@sykosirkusklown I do remember that, I just connectéd that to Harry's physical appearance and not the patronus, he saw James literally in himself as he was embodying his father's best features. Sometimes we make different connections, but I sorta agree with Ben here, the fact that it just seems to happen at the Quiddich match then undercuts the weight of it, that when he needed it most he projected his father's image in a more metaphorical way to protect him. But I think you guys must be right the intention was something different than what I interpreted it as, clearly the details seem to insinuate it was corporal already then, I just preferred it that way I originally interpreted.
9:43 Romilda asked Ginny if Harry had a hippogriff tattooed on his chest but Ginny told her it was a Hungarian Horntail because it’s “much more macho” 😉
Just realized that Hagrid was having a drink with Fudge in the 3 Broomsticks, even tho less than a year prior, Fudge had Hagrid arrested. Hagriiiiiid you deserve better friends
Tbh Ben actually would get most or a lot of the questions correct but he confuses himself or thinks too hard about it and second guesses himself a lot 😅, Don't worry Ben I'm still rooting for you and your memory Don't be down! 👍 Edit: Dang I didn't think this would get over 100 likes 😶, this would Definetly help show Ben that we are all still rooting for him! 😂
I also think with the multiple choice he would do alot better. I know that's part of the difficulty for them, but seeing the options he would probably easily be able to decipher the correct answer.
Line B, the time he does it at the edge of the lake is when he first does it in front of real dementors, and he saves three people, so it seems pretty impressive to me
I NEVER understood that it was a corporal patronus on the quidditch ground ! Lupin says it's impressive, that's all, it never sounded like it was a stag to me... And I stick with Ben, it's weird that no one would tell him that it was a stag, like I don't know HERMIONE who was at the quidditch match AND with Harry when he cast it by the lake...
@@Azeleen16 I think I remember some conversation between him and ron/hermione where he asked what it was and they said they couldn't tell but it was big and horned. At that point little me was deadass convinced that his patronus was a rhino.
Hey guys the Patrons reference is from Dumbledore not Lupin, he says at the very end of the book that Sirius told him how they all became animagi and remarks on how Harry's patronus matches prongs. He then goes on to say "and then I remembered the most unusual form your patronus took when it charged Mr Malfoy down at your Quidditch match". He never explicitly says I saw a stag at the match but it is very heavily implied that, that is what he means.
Absolutely agree with Ben about Harry's patronus! It makes narratively no sense that he would cast THE stag in the middle of a quidditch game. I always interpreted as being "something" four-legged but not quite yet the stag we all know and love, and I'll keep doing that because if not I'm going to be shattered, I love everything Harry casting the patronus at the lake represents.
Except it was really easy at the quitich pitch to do so. With no actual dementors around while he's literally doing one of the things he loves the most. It makes complete sense, the fact that he has the ability. What he did at the lake was so very different they were surrounded by a hundred dementors and the fact that he could do it under those circumstances is an entirely different thing. Not to mention Dumbledore says he saw the Stag on the Quidditch pitch.
Didn't Dumbledore elaborate about the quidditch one when he was talking about the unusual form his patronous took, and said "prongs rode again", talking about the forest one?
to be honest if he didn't conjure the patronous then Lupin would of said something along the lines of "Keep trying you will get it soon" but instead he did comment on it, maybe he thought Harry had seen it and he was congratulating him but Harry misinterpreted it seeing as he hadn't noticed it.
To the people who worked on the Goblet of Fire movie. Instead of wasting your money to get a rock band to appear in your movie, you could've used that money to CG some Skrewts and a sphinx.
I also find it unlikely that Harry hasn't been burnt by the Blast-ended Skrewt. They were walking them in class. Like come on. I do not for a single moment believe every single student who had to take care of them didn't at least once get treated for a burn.
Hey guys! I have a question I have always wanted to ask about the pensieve! If snape removes a memory from his mind whilst teaching harry occlumency, then does it entirely remove it from your mind? Can you not remember what the memory is until you "re-insert it back into your mind?" Unless what would be the point of Snape even borrowing the pensieve to remove the memory? so! About to watch the video now! Sorry for the hijack! Have always wondered! Loving the twitch streams also!!
I don’t think it Makes it so that you can’t remember the memory. Dumbledore still remembered his memories about going to meet Tom in the orphanage even though he removed it from his mind and kept it in one of those bottles
Yeah I'm with Ben about the patronus answer. I've never interpreted the Quidditch scene as the first time Harry produced a Corporeal Patronus. Obviously not anyone on the SCB teams fault but feels like he got cheated out of that point and if he got it instead of J, it would've been a tie
I have but I feel like it's not as impressive or important because it's not too hard to produce a patronus when facing two people under a cloak compared to actual dementors
right, his explanation for being able to produce a corporeal patronus to save Sirius was that he saw himself do it across the water, if he had already produced one at the quidditch match that whole plot point is lost.
Dumbledore says while in Lupins office and Sirius has told him about the being animagi that he realized why Harry's patronus took that perticular shape att the quidditch match
Technically, you could do base 36, because you would have the 10 digits + all the letters. Other advantages of base 36 include high divisibility of the base, because it can be divided by 2, 3, 4, 6, 9, 12, 18. So for example, if I'm 26, my age in base 36 is K. I'm K years old. If you're 37, you're 11 years old in base 36. If you're 71, you're 1Z years old in base 36... etc. etc.
The question about when Harry casts his first corporeal patronus hits on one of the inconsistencies in the books. It was the quiddich pitch, partly because of Lupin's reaction, and I think that Dumbledore makes reference to that event later on... maybe in another book even. *BUT* When they have their first DA meeting at the Hog's Head and they are listing all of the things that Harry can do, they marvel that he can cast a corporeal patronus (Susan Bones asks him about it). But the whole school would have seen him do it during the match, and no doubt it would be a topic of conversation, so none of them should have seemed surprised by it.
Atsuko Kagari the weather was perfect aside from a light breeze for that match I just read past it. It says and I quote “Something silver-white, something enormous, erupted from the end of his wand. He knew it had shot directly at the Dementors but didn’t pause to watch; his mind still miraculously clear, he looked ahead - he was nearly there. He stretched out the hand still grasping his wand and just managed to close his fingers over the small, struggling Snitch.”
Don't know if anyone has commented on this yet, but to add another cute gold and Harry connection, the another name for main ingredient in the filling of treacle tart is actually "golden syrup"
Harry's Patronus When Dumbledore is talking to Harry, after Lupin resigns as a Professor, Dumbledore tells Harry, 'Last night Sirius told me about how they became Animagi ... And then I remembered the most unusual form your Patronus took, when it charged Mr. Malfoy down at your Wuidditch match against Ravenclaw. You know, Harry, in a way, you did see your father last night... You found him inside yourself.' I just heard it yesterday listening to the books again. :)
As much as people love to talk trash about houses other than their own, I would like to just take a moment to say that I love everyone no matter what house you're in for being a part of this fandom and loving these books/films :).
I 1000% agree with Ben on the patronus question! Sorry you guys were so off your game today. I got 21/25 but I did look at the multiple choice way more than you did.
I don't, he was able to create it then because it was easy no actual dementors. We're as in the lake were as in the lake there were hundreds of real demetors, and he only was able to do it because he already knew he had done it. As for it being corporal, Dumbledore mentions seeing the stag on the quitich pitch
Amelle Kyre you are correct, I will say I find it interesting though that in the 5th book when the first meeting to create the DA Susan bones asks Harry if it’s true he can create a corporial patronus and they all seemed shocked.. even lee Jordan says he didn’t know Harry could do that..... but I mean they were all at the match when he did, lee would have even been commentator. Odd. 🤔
@@marcAB10 I don't think it's that weird Dumbledore knew what it was on sight maybe other people thought he just sent somthing at Malfoy, and they don't recognize it on sight.
Yeah I agree cause I remember him casting the spell but I don’t remember a corpeal patronous coming out (also I know I can’t spell I know my Harry Potter stuff but I can’t spell any of it lol)
After Lupin leaves at the end of the 3rd book, Harry and Dumbledore have a chat and Dumbledore says he recognized the shape of the patronus Harry cast at the quidditch match: a stag.
I absolutely loved the look of pure ecstasy on Ben's face with that 'treacle tart' question. His happiness when he gets a difficult question right and J gets it wrong is infectious. Also, how did nobody comment about the minor mistake in the book about the 'mobile library'? Ron says the quote but we know that it is firmly established canon that he doesn't say Voldemort's name.
I always thought Harry had messy hair as part of Lilly’s love charm. James always messed up his hair intentionally and Lilly found it endearing, so when she sacrificed herself to protect Harry an inadvertent side effect was to bestow unto Harry James’s messy hair
I'm with Ben on that Patronus question. I've always interpreted it as Harry just blasting Draco with a big shot of silvery light that he was able to aim, but it was never described as having any distinct shape. And it would undercut the drama of the scene where Harry saves Sirius. Ben, I am in your corner on this. We can fight J together.
near the end of the book Dumbledore remarks on the shape it took during the quiditch match. I forget the exact line but ut basically reveals that it was a stag
For the record, it is stated in the books, at the end, that Harry's corporeal patronus came out on the quidditch pitch. Lupin or Dumbledore mention something about "the surprising shape of his patronus" on that occasion. And I don't think it undercuts the significance of him doing it on the lake, because it's the first time that he does it when there are dementors around...
Exactly! Like it's easier for someone to shake off something that's mildly distressing than to shake off an actual depressive episode (which is what the dementors are an allegory for).
It’s been eight months and I’m just going to go out and say it, I think that this is by far the funniest quiz video you guys have done together. I’ve watched it probably 70 times and I laugh so hard every time. They’re are so many laugh out loud moments in this vid and I’ve just been eating dinner with my family when this video crosses my mind and I think about ‘flexible’ and I burst out laughing and making my family question all of my sanity
I'm someone with dyslexia and I never got into Harry Potter, they were just to hard for me to read I tired again last year and now I'm half way through Half-blood Prince and I finally realise what all the Potter hype is about ❤️❤️
I think it would be really cool to have supercarlinbrothers phone cases or pop sockets with supercarlinbrothers logo on 😝 Also you guys are the BEST Edit: Thx for likes 😁
Have you ever thought about making the 'select all that apply' questions point based? This would mean that each option would have a point, thereby upping the number of points.
fishbowl peculiar doesn't necessarily mean stag shaped though. i've read prisoner of azkaban like three times and i never realised he was meant to have casted a stag there
Yes but he is explaining to harry how he knew what his patronus was and why harry wasn't foolish for thinking it was his dad at the other side of the lake
Mowgli Ledbury ‘An extraordinary achievement - not least, keeping it quiet from me. And then I remembered the most unusual form your Patronus took, when it charged Mr. Malfoy down at your Quidditch match against Ravenclaw. You know, Harry, in a way, you did see your father last night. . . . You found him inside yourself’ He wouldn’t have brought up the quidditch pitch if it wasn’t a Stag
35:20 Dumbledore is the one who explains to Harry about the quidditch pitch patronus, at the end of the book, when he also explains "Prongs rode again".
i believe that ginny might have asked the diary, which held the memory of young tom riddle, to help her with the poem. therefore, theres a chance that voldemort helped right a love poem for harry potter.
14/25 I NEARLY got the last question but I DOUBTED myself Also I agree with Ben about the patronus question! I thought him defending Sirius was when the stag emerged
@@XxGreymoonxX Didn't harry also think to himself something along the lines of" Oh I did it that time but only because no ACTUAL dementors were the enemy"
it's the first time harry sees it and the first time he's able to cast it while under the influence of actual dementors. Which is of course as Harry himself says in OotP that it's very different to cast a patronus in an empty room than it is in front of a dementor.
I laughed super hard when J wrote down flexible! It wasn't even acknowledged for a second and then when he finally realized what he wrote it made my day!
Ben, the point with the casting of the corporeal Patronus at the Quidditch match is that there are *no actual Dementors* there this time. Harry is able to cast clearly, in the moment (Harry tends to do his best work when he doesn't have to think about it) because there isn't anything sapping his strength. Him casting the Patronus charm to protect Sirius is truly amazing when you consider that there's something like a hundred Dementors trying to feast on their souls. Oh, and I got P/Y.
it was the other way with the tattoo question Romilda Vane asked if he had a hippogriff and Ginny tells the golden trio "I told her it was a hungarian horntail"
Think you can stump us with your own Harry Potter Questions?!
Check out our Patreon to become a Quiz Master! :: www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
SuperCarlinBrothers hi
What was the seventh line of these fourth stanza in the sorting hats song in Harry’s 4th year.
What would you do if suddenly a flying muffin appeared? It’s VERY IMPORTANT!!!
Oh I can most DEFINITELY stump you. Maybe. 😂
What was the first sentence of the first book.
I know the new intro is a higher quality audio and visual but the old one is so nostalgic and I miss it.
I agree. I like the new graphics. But the "Hey, brother!" in this new one is very weak. Not enough punch to it.
Agreed
couldn't agree more
I agree plz bring it back
Also I loved the spiralling and smashing together in the old one, which is now missing.
21:46
Harry: how flexible is my wand.
Olivander: yEs, SuRe
Harry: what type of tree is it made of.
Olivander: a WoOdEn OnE
candylover 123 my wands tree wooden is the wooden type, and my flexibility is the flexible type
All of these comments about this are killing me 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
And what's funny about Ginny's poem to Harry is that at the time that she wrote it, she had the diary, and chances are she probably confided in it and it gave her some advice to make it better, so it's possible that
Voldemort wrote Harry a love poem.
Very interesting thought
I don't think so - Ginny had tried to flush the diary a few weeks earlier and found out on Valentines day that Harry had it when his bag ripped and Malfoy picked it up (Harry was trying to get away from one of the cupid dwarves at the time)
@@lynmurray4331bold of you to assume she hasn't been working on that poem for a while.
J's wand specs:
Wood: wood
Flexibility: flexible
Core: yes
Ben's wand specs:
Name: Susan
Length: somewhere around I and A/B inches
Stickiness: expelliarmus-resistant
ROTFL!!!!!
Thank you, this is amazing.
I made the mistake of reading this while drinking and almost died choking on coffee. My dog is concerned.
That sums it up pretty good
wait, harry is 39???
How flexible is Harry’s wand?
Yes
Susan
PhilBagels Suzanne*
Depends....
Reese Walker I know it can be spelt either way, but at 18:46 Ben spells it as “Suzanne”.
@@caseygreyson4178 But he pronounces it "Susan". And I think "Susan" is funnier.
The tatto thing is exactly the opposite of what they thought, romilda thought it was a hipogriff and Ginny said it was a Hungarian Horntail cuz she thought it was more badass
according to the book it it has more macho
@@ashleymelton7484 I'm going to pencil in badass just because of this reply
@@ashleymelton7484 according to book Ginny to be exact.
good old ginny lol
I was screaming it at the screen lol
I laughed so hard at this one 😂 Grandpa Suzanne and Flexible Flexibility
"I told her it was a Hungarian horntail, much more macho"
Janae Woolley I literally just watched that part in the video and then immediately scrolled to the comments to find this exact thing so thank you
YES
@@TardisTed lol you're welcome I hope that's right I wrote from memory lol
@@janaewoolley it is exactly how it was written
Ohhh I thought it was the other way around
I'm surprised that Professor Slughorn never remarked on Harry's family inventing these Popular Potions. As a Potions Master, wouldn't he know those facts?
And a seeker of skillful people he would have most definitely have looked into Harry's family because the books support the narrative that magical and potion making skill is genetic.
Well isn't that whole information retconned anyway? Had JKR written about Harry's family history before Half-Blood?
He didn't know it yet, because JK hadn't written about it on pottermore yet.
@@leadnitrate2194 Right 😁
Derek should do audio books. With a voice that sounds that smooth any book would sound great!!!
YES
Omg yes!!!!
bigbadboy2001 Harry Potter Audiobooks lol
Fifty shades
Yes please and thank you ! He could even read harry potter quizzes to us without the brothers taking it !
The look of pure joy and surprise on Ben’s face when he got Treacle Tart was absolutely amazing. 28:30. Proud of you Ben 🙌🏻
Quiz: How flexible was Harry's wand?
J: Yes.
Memento Mori, friend.
@@Mearmar Memento Mori ◾◽
ollivander: "aah... the flexibility of your wand, mr. potter, is... flexible."
"How flexible was it?"
Yes
"Made of wood, taken from a wooden tree. And remarkably, it has a birds tail feather, given to us by a bird, from its tail."
Hmm yes
The floor here is made out of floor
Imagine if all of these comments were what Ollivander said to Harry, and imagine if he told other people that, and then people would have started to question the fact that he was Sorted into Ravenclaw...
That would actually be pretty funny-- no offense to Ollivander, though.
*susan
I always remember Stonewall High because Aunt Petunia was dyeing some clothes grey, stone grey.
Oh that's a nice way of remembering it, I never do. Mind always jumps straight to St. Brutus's :D
All I knew was that it was the state school or non-boarding school
Good way to remember! I remember Stonewall High because of this iconic exchange, "'They stuff people's heads down the toilet the first day at Stonewall,' he[Dudley]told Harry. 'Want to come upstairs and practice?' 'No, thanks,' said Harry. 'The poor toilet's never had anything as horrible as your head down it --- it might be sick.' Then he ran, before Dudley could work out what he'd said.'
I always remember because I end up imagining Harry siting on a giant stone wall... just stuck up there...
Yeh that’s how I remember too
I feel so bad that somebody literally went up to Ben and accused him of not reading the books when he is literally half of a channel partially based around Harry Potter. RUDE.
Right?
Not having a naturally trivia oriented brain doesn't mean you know nothing about the information.
Literally.
that person should have been kicked out
He knows enough but he mentions that he listens to it ,the people that read it for audiobooks tend to skip details that seem unimportant ,therefore reading it is better from the prespective that he theories about it for his job,
Oh and maybe he’s like me and can’t remember small details
@@AnnaVaubel i listen to the audiobooks constantly, and i can say without a doubt, it does not hinder my comprehension ability one bit.
Ben’s face when Derek said Treacle Tart was priceless 😂
That made me so happy! It was adorbs!
Jay’s face too! They were both so surprised and happy! ❤️
More surprised about not knowing what treacle is.
Matt Robinson at 28:31 I think jay is surprised because Ben got it right and it wasn’t even a sweet he considered. He also says “that’s amazing!!” but he doesn’t seem like he didn’t recognize the name, even though they didn’t know what it was
"Listen. I don't make up the quizzes." 😂😂😂
Read this as he said it
This needs more likes...
Tyler L I was exactly looking for a comment like this because it was so funny and it deserved a shoutout lol, thank you
"How flexible was it"
"It was"
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Grandpa Susan's flexible wood tree.
Jose Fuentes Suzanne’s*
Idk why, but this made me laugh so hard!
From whence he sources switches with which to subdue the errant Fleamont.
17:27
No one:
Ben's brain: I'm about to end this man's career
By 15:47 I had more points than Ben. For someone who read the books once, I felt triumphant. But this was all to it.
5:22 I think people forget that these brothers usually answer the questions without the multiple choices; that is a HUGE handicap. If I wanted to answer all these questions correctly (in the same manner) I would need to study for it by taking notes, highlighting passages, and using flashcards to remember the seemingly unimportant details. That would ruin the story for me.
It makes me sad that some Harry Potter "fans" think that you didn't read the books if you can't remember all the nitty gritty details.
yeah, and I really hate that Ben is so self-conscious about disappointing us. I always root for him but I'd never call him a fake fan over getting some of the answers wrong.
I've just started calling myself a lazy fan to justify my lack oh minor detail knowledge lol
Maybe that person was new to the SCB channel ,don't feel bad Ben
I’ve done some of these quizzes after spending a week rereading the whole series, with the multiple choice, and I do worse.
I myself have always noticed that I very easily pick up on tiny details and remember them, so these quizzes are often no problem for me, but I can see why it might be tough on someone that isn’t as capable of remembering tiny details. I love that we have an underdog to cheer for in these video’s, it adds more excitement when ben actually manages to win.
I'm pretty sure the reason lupin didn't send a birthday cake was because he was dirt poor and out of a job, also umbridge made an anti werewolf thing to make it virtually impossible for lupin to get a job
I think it was because Harry didn't write to him about Dudley's horrible diet. He wrote to the others asking for real food and received the cakes and other goodies!
They weren't writing each other?
18:38 I LOVE Ben's "I'm giving up" guesses 😂😂😂
Voldemort
Brittany
Suzanne
Angela Davidson
My default answer when I’m sure I don’t know on a test is now Voldemort.
@@arandomuser9459 same
Doesn't Ron say the "Yeah, we'll call you, if we ever need anyone mental" line to sir Cadogan the first time he shows them the way to the Divination classroom ?
I thought it was to Lockhart in the second book...?
You are correct. In the north tower
Yeah he does
Yes he does!
Yup he does
Silly Ben, only Hermione has read Hogwarts a History.
Honestly I made the same mistake but thats hilarious
Ikr...it be like “ why would Harry and Ron do their homework on their new school “
She's the 0nly current student who does
"'Are't you two EVER going to read Hogwarts, A History.' 'What's the point? We can just ask you.'"
@@joshuadesautels LOL and soooooo true
How flexible is harry's wand
J: flexible
What kind of wand is the first want harry holds?
J:Wood
😂🤣😂🤣😂
anyone notice that when Harry lost his bones due to Lockhart's spell in Chamber of Secrets, he is given Skelo-Gro to get his bones back? "Thanks family!" - Harry
E Ice yeah, I did
I did 😂
I like how they make it sound like Harry failed his OWL just because he passed out when he actually barely remembered anything and then after he passed out was given the option to continue but said he was done.
I thought troll was a joke answer. Has it been confirmed as an actual grade one can get? I specifically remember that Fred and George try to cheer Harry up when he receives a D by saying that at least it wasn’t a T from the first time I read the Harry Potter books (but it was in Swedish, my mother tongue, so the letters were different) because Harry was trying to figure out what T might stand for that’s worse than Dreadful.
@@tovekauppi1616 T indeed stands for Troll, otherwise known as one of the dumbest creatures alive.
Well jeez, Remus is poor, he can't just be sending people pastry. Give the poor bloke a break, lol.
It was also after Severus told the wizarding community he was a werewolf so he couldn't find a job
Poor Remus he probably inherited grandpa Suzanne's clothes
yeah...
@Dr Who Yes, but the Weasleys are a family which can depend on one another. Remus is an individual who has been ostracised from most of the Wizarding community because he's a werewolf.
Katelyn Myers 😂😂
I think this was definitely the funniest J vs. Ben video yet!
I want a J vs Ben shirt with SUSANNE and FLEXIBLE on them
and.. wood LOL
@@robynnm9899 YES JUST YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
All the shirt sizes are just letters
Mykal Mashack Yesss 😂😂
Omg yesssssss
"Yeah, we'll call you - if we ever need someone mental." - quote from Ron, regarding Sir Cadogan
That awkward moment when you realize Tom Riddle helped Ginny write Harry a love song, since it was his diary.
Harry, after getting the diary: my name is Harry Potter.
Tom Riddle, remembering Ginny brainstorming the poem: ...imma kill this boy AND his little girlfriend.
Is it possible that Ben is more visual than auditory? So listening to the books isn’t as good for memorizing facts from the book for him? Or is it just the messy desk problem? Hehe. I would do worse than Ben if I didn’t get multiple choice so still good job. Good job both of you! 👍
If he is listening to the books then that could be the problem. Maybe actually reading them would be a better choice
@@lordvika2526 He never does that much worse than J does though...? And he has won a few. These quizzes are ridiculously challenging w/o multiple choice sometimes. And his reasoning behind many incorrect answer choices is sound, e.g. for the Patronus question
@@mattc3788 I know this, I was just giving a response to what this person commented.
I have watched every single J vs Ben.
One thing I noticed is the they both do really well. Ben usually wins the Pixar quizzes more often and Jay wins the HP quizzes more often. But both are great at them
I bet you are so right! I used to be a teacher, and there is a difference between people who are visual and people who are auditory. Thank you for bringing that up.
that’s what i thought
I love how when Jay gets one wrong he’s like wait, no, uh wait no oh yeah cause of the yeah I get what I did wrong and Ben is just like yeah okay
Until the patronus question
“Wouldn’t it be really weird to learn math with letters?”
Programmers: Yes. Yes it is. What is c minus a? Easy. 2. If you had c points you’d be killing it.
I was like yup welcome to hex where you use both
You say Maths not math there are many kinds: algebra, geometry...
@@pigi1004 in america it's just math
@@pigi1004 but it all falls under the group of math. You don’t add s to something because it has a subgroup. Do you say: let’s study our science or let’s study our sciences. There’s also many types of algebra, geometry, I could do this forever.
@@tebo9334 fair.
Fresh pickled toad “DING!”
I had toad
Good enough “ing”
11:10 if anyone is wondering :)
I thought Lupin said this, but apparently Dumbledore did it: «remembered the most unusual form your Patronus took, when it charged Mr. Malfoy down at your Quidditch match against Ravenclaw» :) sort of implies that it was a corporal form.
Could also just be a painterly explanation, I mean I think it means the same but it's pretty vague to base a quiz on because it's open to interpretation.
@@RupeeRhod it is definitely a corporal form. dumbledore made the connection between Harry's patronus James after finding out that James became a stag when he transformed. he says the line about remembering it from the quidditch match then says something like "in a way, you did see your father last night, in you".
Yeah, Dumbledore even comments something to the effect of “How else could you produce that particular patronus?” Before explaining that Sirius told him about them all becoming animagi, and that is how he recognized it from when Harry cast it at the Slytherins during the quidditch match
@@sykosirkusklown I do remember that, I just connectéd that to Harry's physical appearance and not the patronus, he saw James literally in himself as he was embodying his father's best features.
Sometimes we make different connections, but I sorta agree with Ben here, the fact that it just seems to happen at the Quiddich match then undercuts the weight of it, that when he needed it most he projected his father's image in a more metaphorical way to protect him.
But I think you guys must be right the intention was something different than what I interpreted it as, clearly the details seem to insinuate it was corporal already then, I just preferred it that way I originally interpreted.
I love how much the guys were cracking themselves up in this video😂 “grandpa Susan”.. “flexible”
Is no one gonna talk about J’s Cow during the intro?
Reminds me of Heffer from Rocko's Modern Life
That’s hilarious and dumb at the same time
*IT WAS SO CUTE*
@@justgiz now that you mention it, it does lol
Nope
Ben - “Wouldn’t it be really weird to learn hot to do math using letters instead?”
Me - “You Mean Like ALGEBRA???”
Right! 😂😂😂
Hot? You mean how?
or rather you mean Hexadecimal system ? (hex uses 0-9 and a-f for numbers 10-15)
I did think algebra. But then I actually thought hexadecimal too.
Smo Cloud same here also c-a=2. Not b
34:00 Ben’s face when Derek gives the answer and tell’s Ben that he is right. That is the most relateble reaction i habe ever seen
9:43 Romilda asked Ginny if Harry had a hippogriff tattooed on his chest but Ginny told her it was a Hungarian Horntail because it’s “much more macho” 😉
For real? I don't remeber that part... But I haven't re-read the books in like forever so...
Ben evrn recites that scene. He just overthought it.
Do magic tattoos als move like photos and paintings.
@@Anonym-iv3tz I actually think they do
@@Anonym-iv3tz I think I saw that in fantastic beasts
At 3:13 It really is Stonewall. Once Harry starts disappearing for months on end they need an excuse so the Dursleys say he is at St. Brutus's.
Just realized that Hagrid was having a drink with Fudge in the 3 Broomsticks, even tho less than a year prior, Fudge had Hagrid arrested. Hagriiiiiid you deserve better friends
Yea but i feel like prior to order fudge was always apologetic when he did stuff like he was pressured by the school board to do something
Tbh Ben actually would get most or a lot of the questions correct but he confuses himself or thinks too hard about it and second guesses himself a lot 😅, Don't worry Ben I'm still rooting for you and your memory Don't be down! 👍
Edit: Dang I didn't think this would get over 100 likes 😶, this would Definetly help show Ben that we are all still rooting for him! 😂
I also think with the multiple choice he would do alot better. I know that's part of the difficulty for them, but seeing the options he would probably easily be able to decipher the correct answer.
This is why I think Ben is Ravenclaw! He overthinks everything
@@hannahsonnenburg7718 Agreed 😂
I'm still ALWAYS rooting for Ben, yes!! 😄 And he got TWO right that J didn't, today!
Agreed
I stand with Team Ben on the Patronus question
Nope Dumbledore mentions it was a stag at one point.
Same. It makes it so much less impressive for Harry to do it at the edge of the lake, when he just did it in a match.
Line B, the time he does it at the edge of the lake is when he first does it in front of real dementors, and he saves three people, so it seems pretty impressive to me
I NEVER understood that it was a corporal patronus on the quidditch ground ! Lupin says it's impressive, that's all, it never sounded like it was a stag to me... And I stick with Ben, it's weird that no one would tell him that it was a stag, like I don't know HERMIONE who was at the quidditch match AND with Harry when he cast it by the lake...
@@Azeleen16 I think I remember some conversation between him and ron/hermione where he asked what it was and they said they couldn't tell but it was big and horned. At that point little me was deadass convinced that his patronus was a rhino.
Forever rooting for Ben, because my brain works exactly like his.
Always love it when you guys do J vs. Ben!
Hey guys the Patrons reference is from Dumbledore not Lupin, he says at the very end of the book that Sirius told him how they all became animagi and remarks on how Harry's patronus matches prongs.
He then goes on to say "and then I remembered the most unusual form your patronus took when it charged Mr Malfoy down at your Quidditch match".
He never explicitly says I saw a stag at the match but it is very heavily implied that, that is what he means.
I love all of them just laughing together. It’s very strangely wholesome.
"According to Ollivander, how flexible is Harry's wand?"
J: "Flexible... duh." 🤣🤣🤣
Absolutely agree with Ben about Harry's patronus! It makes narratively no sense that he would cast THE stag in the middle of a quidditch game. I always interpreted as being "something" four-legged but not quite yet the stag we all know and love, and I'll keep doing that because if not I'm going to be shattered, I love everything Harry casting the patronus at the lake represents.
Except it was really easy at the quitich pitch to do so. With no actual dementors around while he's literally doing one of the things he loves the most. It makes complete sense, the fact that he has the ability. What he did at the lake was so very different they were surrounded by a hundred dementors and the fact that he could do it under those circumstances is an entirely different thing.
Not to mention Dumbledore says he saw the Stag on the Quidditch pitch.
And Remus is visibly shaken as well as proud.
Didn't Dumbledore elaborate about the quidditch one when he was talking about the unusual form his patronous took, and said "prongs rode again", talking about the forest one?
I always thought people were shocked at him being able to almost make a patronus. Like it was the silvery mist but closer to the stag.
to be honest if he didn't conjure the patronous then Lupin would of said something along the lines of "Keep trying you will get it soon" but instead he did comment on it, maybe he thought Harry had seen it and he was congratulating him but Harry misinterpreted it seeing as he hadn't noticed it.
To the people who worked on the Goblet of Fire movie.
Instead of wasting your money to get a rock band to appear in your movie, you could've used that money to CG some Skrewts and a sphinx.
Alucard, More Awesome Than Chuck Norris! Agreed
Agreed
And actually follow the books and not reveal Barty Crouch Jr in the dream
I also find it unlikely that Harry hasn't been burnt by the Blast-ended Skrewt. They were walking them in class. Like come on. I do not for a single moment believe every single student who had to take care of them didn't at least once get treated for a burn.
Jaris cocker was worth it
I was shouting at Ben the whole time "YOU KNOW THESE!!"
Hey guys! I have a question I have always wanted to ask about the pensieve! If snape removes a memory from his mind whilst teaching harry occlumency, then does it entirely remove it from your mind? Can you not remember what the memory is until you "re-insert it back into your mind?"
Unless what would be the point of Snape even borrowing the pensieve to remove the memory? so! About to watch the video now! Sorry for the hijack! Have always wondered!
Loving the twitch streams also!!
It doesn't remove the memory from the person's mind as far as I know. Just a way to save it / show it.
That's my number A questions I always ask myself
I don’t think it Makes it so that you can’t remember the memory. Dumbledore still remembered his memories about going to meet Tom in the orphanage even though he removed it from his mind and kept it in one of those bottles
Ben Jackson I always ask myself this question !!!
Also can you remember putting the memory in. Like which memory you chose to put in??
Yeah I'm with Ben about the patronus answer. I've never interpreted the Quidditch scene as the first time Harry produced a Corporeal Patronus. Obviously not anyone on the SCB teams fault but feels like he got cheated out of that point and if he got it instead of J, it would've been a tie
I have but I feel like it's not as impressive or important because it's not too hard to produce a patronus when facing two people under a cloak compared to actual dementors
doesnt dumbledore say something about harrys patronus at the quiditch match when harry tells him he thought he saw his dad cast the patronus
100% agree, we know it was a powerful blast of .... Patronus energy, but there is nothing about it taking a corporeal form...
right, his explanation for being able to produce a corporeal patronus to save Sirius was that he saw himself do it across the water, if he had already produced one at the quidditch match that whole plot point is lost.
Dumbledore says while in Lupins office and Sirius has told him about the being animagi that he realized why Harry's patronus took that perticular shape att the quidditch match
“Nice and breaky” “kinda sticky” I’m watching this on a road trip trying not to cry from laughter over this😂
I have a math degree and... Great, now I'm trying to figure out how a base 26 system using letters would work.
With congruence and a dictionary?
Matt Babineau
Have you come to conclusion yet?
Technically, you could do base 36, because you would have the 10 digits + all the letters. Other advantages of base 36 include high divisibility of the base, because it can be divided by 2, 3, 4, 6, 9, 12, 18. So for example, if I'm 26, my age in base 36 is K. I'm K years old. If you're 37, you're 11 years old in base 36. If you're 71, you're 1Z years old in base 36... etc. etc.
like algebra
The standard library in the C programming language recognizes up to base 36, with the letters A/a to Z/z taking the place of the numbers 10 to 35.
The question about when Harry casts his first corporeal patronus hits on one of the inconsistencies in the books.
It was the quiddich pitch, partly because of Lupin's reaction, and I think that Dumbledore makes reference to that event later on... maybe in another book even.
*BUT*
When they have their first DA meeting at the Hog's Head and they are listing all of the things that Harry can do, they marvel that he can cast a corporeal patronus (Susan Bones asks him about it). But the whole school would have seen him do it during the match, and no doubt it would be a topic of conversation, so none of them should have seemed surprised by it.
same Book. Last Chapter. Dumbledore says that prongs rode again after mentioning that the stag ran on the quidditch field
@@GirlInThought Wow.... that is just terrible writing... That makes no sense..
JoRiver11 I think, because of the weather, no one could actually see Harry casting the spell. Only the flash of light, and the Patronus itself.
@@SakuraAvalon I feel like that's grasping at straws to fix a plot hole at that point
Atsuko Kagari the weather was perfect aside from a light breeze for that match I just read past it. It says and I quote “Something silver-white, something enormous, erupted from the end of his wand. He knew it had shot directly at the Dementors but didn’t pause to watch; his mind still miraculously clear, he looked ahead - he was nearly there. He stretched out the hand still grasping his wand and just managed to close his fingers over the small, struggling Snitch.”
Derek: “The correct answer is treacle tart!”
Ben: 😯
28:30
"What tree was it made out of?" "Wood". Made me laugh so hard 😂😂 omg!!
Don't know if anyone has commented on this yet, but to add another cute gold and Harry connection, the another name for main ingredient in the filling of treacle tart is actually "golden syrup"
Harry's Patronus
When Dumbledore is talking to Harry, after Lupin resigns as a Professor, Dumbledore tells Harry,
'Last night Sirius told me about how they became Animagi ... And then I remembered the most unusual form your Patronus took, when it charged Mr. Malfoy down at your Wuidditch match against Ravenclaw. You know, Harry, in a way, you did see your father last night... You found him inside yourself.'
I just heard it yesterday listening to the books again. :)
I obsessively check for potter trivia every week and every time one gets uploaded I immediately watch it
Exactly my reaction as well
Same to me
Bradon Higgins same!!
If your pfp is you, thank you for your service
As much as people love to talk trash about houses other than their own, I would like to just take a moment to say that I love everyone no matter what house you're in for being a part of this fandom and loving these books/films :).
You must be a Huffelpuff! And if not, what house are you in?
Its Alpha That’s such a Hufflepuff thing to say ;)
you must be a hufflepuff or ravenclaw
Imma Ravenclaw
Hey u sound like a fellow huffle friend
'Mr. Ollivander, how would you describe the flexibility of Harry's wand?'
Mr. Ollivander, according to J: "Yes."
My wand: Yesn’t
I 1000% agree with Ben on the patronus question! Sorry you guys were so off your game today. I got 21/25 but I did look at the multiple choice way more than you did.
I don't, he was able to create it then because it was easy no actual dementors. We're as in the lake were as in the lake there were hundreds of real demetors, and he only was able to do it because he already knew he had done it.
As for it being corporal, Dumbledore mentions seeing the stag on the quitich pitch
Amelle Kyre you are correct, I will say I find it interesting though that in the 5th book when the first meeting to create the DA Susan bones asks Harry if it’s true he can create a corporial patronus and they all seemed shocked.. even lee Jordan says he didn’t know Harry could do that..... but I mean they were all at the match when he did, lee would have even been commentator. Odd. 🤔
@@marcAB10 I don't think it's that weird Dumbledore knew what it was on sight maybe other people thought he just sent somthing at Malfoy, and they don't recognize it on sight.
Yeah I agree cause I remember him casting the spell but I don’t remember a corpeal patronous coming out (also I know I can’t spell I know my Harry Potter stuff but I can’t spell any of it lol)
@@NosamTheWise But it did both Dumbledore and Lupin comment on it.
After Lupin leaves at the end of the 3rd book, Harry and Dumbledore have a chat and Dumbledore says he recognized the shape of the patronus Harry cast at the quidditch match: a stag.
I absolutely loved the look of pure ecstasy on Ben's face with that 'treacle tart' question. His happiness when he gets a difficult question right and J gets it wrong is infectious.
Also, how did nobody comment about the minor mistake in the book about the 'mobile library'? Ron says the quote but we know that it is firmly established canon that he doesn't say Voldemort's name.
Laughing so hard with y’all when J answered “flexible” 😂
I always thought Harry had messy hair as part of Lilly’s love charm. James always messed up his hair intentionally and Lilly found it endearing, so when she sacrificed herself to protect Harry an inadvertent side effect was to bestow unto Harry James’s messy hair
I like that
I don't know where you read that Lily found that show-off endearing
I'm with Ben on that Patronus question. I've always interpreted it as Harry just blasting Draco with a big shot of silvery light that he was able to aim, but it was never described as having any distinct shape. And it would undercut the drama of the scene where Harry saves Sirius.
Ben, I am in your corner on this. We can fight J together.
near the end of the book Dumbledore remarks on the shape it took during the quiditch match. I forget the exact line but ut basically reveals that it was a stag
Bens face when he got treacle tart was priceless pls do a meet and greet in the uk ❤️❤️
For the record, it is stated in the books, at the end, that Harry's corporeal patronus came out on the quidditch pitch. Lupin or Dumbledore mention something about "the surprising shape of his patronus" on that occasion. And I don't think it undercuts the significance of him doing it on the lake, because it's the first time that he does it when there are dementors around...
Exactly! Like it's easier for someone to shake off something that's mildly distressing than to shake off an actual depressive episode (which is what the dementors are an allegory for).
21:56
DK: How flexible is Harry's wand?
J: Flexible. Duh
😂😂😂
28:08 Also in the books it mentions how Treecle Tart is Harry's favorite pudding.
and since Mrs. weasley makes it a lot, Ginny might smell/like it which is the point of amortentia
@@not_abbyy No, the smell related to Ginny was her perfume, with a flowery scent.
It’s been eight months and I’m just going to go out and say it, I think that this is by far the funniest quiz video you guys have done together. I’ve watched it probably 70 times and I laugh so hard every time. They’re are so many laugh out loud moments in this vid and I’ve just been eating dinner with my family when this video crosses my mind and I think about ‘flexible’ and I burst out laughing and making my family question all of my sanity
I'm someone with dyslexia and I never got into Harry Potter, they were just to hard for me to read
I tired again last year and now I'm half way through Half-blood Prince and I finally realise what all the Potter hype is about ❤️❤️
Audiobooks might be something for you, have you tried them?
Wow! Good on you. I’m glad you’re able to read them now
Sarah Smith have you ever tried audiobooks?
I think it would be really cool to have supercarlinbrothers phone cases or pop sockets with supercarlinbrothers logo on
😝
Also you guys are the BEST
Edit:
Thx for likes 😁
Have you ever thought about making the 'select all that apply' questions point based? This would mean that each option would have a point, thereby upping the number of points.
And then if you select one that is not correct do you lose a point?
I wanted Ben ( or should we say, King Ben? ) to win this so much. Gold to anyone who know what video 'King Ben' is a reference from.
I thought you were referencing "Weasley is our King"
About his patronus you're forgetting Dumbledore saying he remembered the peculiar shape his patronus took at the quidditch match
fishbowl peculiar doesn't necessarily mean stag shaped though. i've read prisoner of azkaban like three times and i never realised he was meant to have casted a stag there
@@tyledbury5606 dont forget he had just told harry prongs rode again last night before explaining how he knew
@fishbowl Wasn't that after the dementors kiss though?
Yes but he is explaining to harry how he knew what his patronus was and why harry wasn't foolish for thinking it was his dad at the other side of the lake
Mowgli Ledbury ‘An extraordinary achievement - not least, keeping it quiet from me. And then I remembered the most unusual form your Patronus took, when it charged Mr. Malfoy down at your Quidditch match against Ravenclaw. You know, Harry, in a way, you did see your father last night. . . . You found him inside yourself’
He wouldn’t have brought up the quidditch pitch if it wasn’t a Stag
35:20 Dumbledore is the one who explains to Harry about the quidditch pitch patronus, at the end of the book, when he also explains "Prongs rode again".
Ben's face at 28:36 is my reaction when I met him today at work 😂😂
Gotta appreciate the three minutes of uncontrolled laughing halfway through the video.
i believe that ginny might have asked the diary, which held the memory of young tom riddle, to help her with the poem. therefore, theres a chance that voldemort helped right a love poem for harry potter.
i just love how HP is still this popular years after. Love these quizzes!
14/25
I NEARLY got the last question but I DOUBTED myself
Also I agree with Ben about the patronus question! I thought him defending Sirius was when the stag emerged
At the end of PoA Dumbledore talks about Harry’s patrons being a stag and how he saw it chase down draco and them
@@XxGreymoonxX they are both right harry sees it at the forest but Dumbledore sees it at the match first
21\25
@@XxGreymoonxX Didn't harry also think to himself something along the lines of" Oh I did it that time but only because no ACTUAL dementors were the enemy"
it's the first time harry sees it and the first time he's able to cast it while under the influence of actual dementors. Which is of course as Harry himself says in OotP that it's very different to cast a patronus in an empty room than it is in front of a dementor.
26:20
J: I'm not gonna remember it off the top of my head
*Timer falls off of Headwig's head*
Me: Yer a wizard, J
YER A HARRY GIZARD JARRY!
It's hEdWig not hEaDwIg
This was really funny, loved it.
Still team Ben, I really think he will win before I die. I hope 😂
20:30
Quiz: According to Mr. Ollivander, what is the flexibility of Harry's wand?
J: Flexible!
6:40 Lupin was having a hard time as a werewolf who recently lost his job, so I don't think he could afford to send Harry a birthday cake
j n ben: harry what r u thinking?
harry: ABOUT BOOKS
I laughed super hard when J wrote down flexible! It wasn't even acknowledged for a second and then when he finally realized what he wrote it made my day!
Since supple is a synonym for flexible, Olivander basically did just describe the flexibility of Harry's wand as flexible.
Rather bendy
Ben, the point with the casting of the corporeal Patronus at the Quidditch match is that there are *no actual Dementors* there this time. Harry is able to cast clearly, in the moment (Harry tends to do his best work when he doesn't have to think about it) because there isn't anything sapping his strength. Him casting the Patronus charm to protect Sirius is truly amazing when you consider that there's something like a hundred Dementors trying to feast on their souls.
Oh, and I got P/Y.
Have been listening to the quizzes all day long and thought this was an old one. Then the new intro kicked in and I was pleasantly surprised!
it was the other way with the tattoo question Romilda Vane asked if he had a hippogriff and Ginny tells the golden trio "I told her it was a hungarian horntail"