What are the chances of habitable life existing on a circumbinary planet? And,are there any binary star systems which currently exist in our universe and many other exoplanets?
There is quite a bit of work being done on stability in gravitationally dynamic systems. There is are 2 zones of stability, inner and outer zones. a = semimajor axis e = eccentricity mu = mass ratio between bodies (X/(X+Y)) and (Y/(X+Y)) Inner Zone : a_max=((0.464+(-0.006)*(LN(mu^0.5+(1-0.5^0.5))))+(-0.38*mu)+(-0.631*e)+(0.586*mu*e)+(0.15*e*e)+(-0.198*mu*e*e))*a(sep) : this is the maximum distance a body can orbit a primary and remain stable. Outer Zone : a_min=((1.6+(-0.04)*(LN(mu^0.5+(1-0.5^0.5))))+(5.1*e)+(-2.22*e*e)+(4.12*mu)+(-4.27*e*mu)+(-5.09*mu*mu)+(4.61*e*e*mu*mu))*a : this is the minimum distance a body can orbit relative to barycenter and remain stable.
I was able to make a sorta acurate GOT solar system, i had a giant star with a smaller star in a 10ish year slightly elipitcal orbit with Westeros orbiting that smaller star.
I’d like to know how common circumbinary systems are in distant galaxies,and if so,how many of these systems currently exist? Would it also be realistic for all of our planets in our solar system to achieve stable orbits if there were two suns in our solar system?
Your videos are totally awesome, I adore them, you and this channel. I would like to see something about binary planets from you. Have you thought about it? Thank in advance.
If trying to build a binary star system with many habitable Earth-like planets, try placing the stars at distances in-between 5 and 50 AUs from eachother.
They should put a feature where you can keep track of life (if any) in a planet and see how they evolved and a ton of other things. Wish I have this game though...
Would the planets maintain their current orbits or would the orbits change greatly? When the solar system first developed,what were the chances that instead of our sun developing,a binary star system would’ve developed instead? Oh,and what were the chances that the planetary orbits would’ve become elliptical,causing unstable climate changes?
Will be funny a binary star system stable with planets, but with the othe star at the distance of Jupiter or Neptune..how move the planets around both stars?
Hey guys at anytime when he is talking about where the planets could be in the binary system,focus on 1 star then put your finger on it and notice it doesn't move away from your finger. (I was bored)
You should do a video on the gas giant that's 650 AU from its star and talk about the theories about it and show just how far it is compared to our solar system. I think that's be cool.
Awesome video!!!What causes the planet which orbits these binary stars to experience such wild climate swings? Are there any planets which orbits other stars which have elliptical orbits? I heard that they too experience wild climate shifts. Is that true?
Are most binary stars Yellow dwarf stars or Red dwarf stars? What if a planet in the habitable zone has a moon like us. Wouldnt it stabilize the Axis alot more?
If all of the planets were to orbit a binary star,including Earth,what things would happen as a result? Would it affect our climates,and what other things?
2 things: A, would it be possible that when two solar systems collide both stars are of equal mass and eventually their orbits stabilize and thus creating a binary star system. And B, what does AU stand for?
I'd imagine it's possible with two stars that are moving towards the same point; however, with two solar systems, you would have to take into account the gravitational influences of all of the planets and other minor bodies. There would have to be some really specific conditions for that to occur.
I looked this up because the Last Jedi, Luke was sitting on an island in the middle of an ocean looking up at two suns. I thought the two suns would cause an irregular orbit and weather would be terrible. I started to wonder if life as we know it would even be possible. Maybe if one sun had very little mass. The smallest suns found have a mass 7% of our sun. Maybe if the small 7% sun's orbit was far away, like oort cloud distance away. Then a stable orbit of an Earth like planet could exist orbiting the central sun. I wish I had this program to test these ideas. Of course then the second sun would just be a dot in the sky, you would never see two large suns in the sky from a planet with calm weather. A few sci-fi movies have done this binary sky. I guess it looks cool and exotic.
Anton,I just now watched a new you tube video called “First Planet Ever Found Orbiting A Triple Star System”. I was under the impression that triple star systems with planets orbiting them already existed. Is that fact true? How many triple star systems with planets orbiting them exist in our known universe?
if the planet is far enough, it will orbit like it was orbiting 1 star, its basic physics. Look at the new planet they found not long ago, It is orbiting Proxima Centauri(a sun) Proxima centauri is itself orbiting alpha centauri which is a binary star system
SirPetterTheFirst Thanks to your answer i wasn't good in physics when i study..the idea i was thinking is how the planets are orbiting if are between the gravity of 2 stars..(and diferent posibilities of distance open diferent stars mas variations..) the nearest of star 1 orbit in that like our Sun, and the nearest to star 2 the same, but other farest planets orbit both? I'm curious about how if we Earth stay in a binary system, how that afect of the diferent cosmovisions in the human history..(sorry to my english..)
SirPetterTheFirst Thanks to your explanation, i was trying to imagine weird planetary systems without knowing the rules..imagining a planet between both star habitable zone..i supose that wasn't posible being stable..it crash with other planet to it's weird orbite, it will be eated by 1 of the stars or throw away..and i sopose the individual star habitable zone, change at being add's both star radiation if stay between.. I think the same about nacionalisms..was stay in chains of the dusty bone rulers phantasmagories..only bacause actual rulers conveniences..1 thing is know the history and other that obstacle the present and future..like if actual astronomers bellieve in the old 2D geocentric constelations..
Ardiak Beltz well soon the old farts will die, hopefully the next generation will not be nationalist of conservative. we will probably get away from the risk of the 3rd world war
A good planet needs figure 8’s to be habitable IF BINARY STARS ARE FAR AND GOOD ZONES CROSS EACHOVER Or a big star and a small star is binary then gas giants are okay
Just think how exciting it would be if the Earth orbited a curcumbinary star system,such as this one and it was still habitable. Just think how exciting though it’d be to wake up to two sunrises? Couldn’t you just imagine that? Would that ever be realistic?
Do you know that isn't true? I it was true, everyone should know about it. When you place the red dwarf star Barnard's Star at half a light year distance it would be visible in a bright night.
Planets don't just instantly form, so this simulation proves nothing. I imagine that a proto-planetary disk is much like the allowed orbitals of an electron: regions that are prohibited are empty, leaving only the orbits that "work" behind. From an evolutionary perspective, matter in the prohibited regions is either incorporated into the star or is shunted into the allowed regions, which then changes their mass distribution.
This request will be the most unusual request that you have ever had,but I was just quite curious about this: my request is there any possible way that you could do a simulation of what would happen to the planets in our solar system if they orbited 5 (not 4) suns? I’m just curious as to how their orbits would be affected by having 5 suns? If you thought having a binary star system would be bad,having that many “stars” would be nothing more that complete and utter planetary chaos.
Could you create a System with the earth in the Middle and the sun and moon with the same size Orbitating around the earth like your binary star System.
3:00 You added mercury with balance mode on, of course you disrupted the orbit. Try doing it without....
Imagine going there then watching the sunset and film it, then go back to earth and add the Force theme.
Good job on the 1600
In the binary star system shown at 4:05, what would the orbit of a planet in the middle of the circle be like?
at barycentre? it would orbit around the middle point
What are the chances of habitable life existing on a circumbinary planet? And,are there any binary star systems which currently exist in our universe and many other exoplanets?
There is quite a bit of work being done on stability in gravitationally dynamic systems.
There is are 2 zones of stability, inner and outer zones.
a = semimajor axis
e = eccentricity
mu = mass ratio between bodies (X/(X+Y)) and (Y/(X+Y))
Inner Zone : a_max=((0.464+(-0.006)*(LN(mu^0.5+(1-0.5^0.5))))+(-0.38*mu)+(-0.631*e)+(0.586*mu*e)+(0.15*e*e)+(-0.198*mu*e*e))*a(sep) : this is the maximum distance a body can orbit a primary and remain stable.
Outer Zone : a_min=((1.6+(-0.04)*(LN(mu^0.5+(1-0.5^0.5))))+(5.1*e)+(-2.22*e*e)+(4.12*mu)+(-4.27*e*mu)+(-5.09*mu*mu)+(4.61*e*e*mu*mu))*a : this is the minimum distance a body can orbit relative to barycenter and remain stable.
Nerddddddddddd JK
Can you do a vídeo about Júpiter vs 2 Saturns or the solar sistem vs another solar sistem
I was able to make a sorta acurate GOT solar system, i had a giant star with a smaller star in a 10ish year slightly elipitcal orbit with Westeros orbiting that smaller star.
I’d like to know how common circumbinary systems are in distant galaxies,and if so,how many of these systems currently exist? Would it also be realistic for all of our planets in our solar system to achieve stable orbits if there were two suns in our solar system?
Your videos are totally awesome, I adore them, you and this channel. I would like to see something about binary planets from you. Have you thought about it? Thank in advance.
thank you for compliment and the suggestion
Good video! Keep it up!
thank you
Thank you for informing me on all this cool binary stars stuff!
Video on Wolf-Rayet stars or variable stars?
+LucasFlecoRepe thanks for the idea!
If trying to build a binary star system with many habitable Earth-like planets, try placing the stars at distances in-between 5 and 50 AUs from eachother.
No. It's between 0.15AU and 6AU or 200AU and 600AU
They should put a feature where you can keep track of life (if any) in a planet and see how they evolved and a ton of other things. Wish I have this game though...
Would the planets maintain their current orbits or would the orbits change greatly? When the solar system first developed,what were the chances that instead of our sun developing,a binary star system would’ve developed instead? Oh,and what were the chances that the planetary orbits would’ve become elliptical,causing unstable climate changes?
Is Tumnus like Earth,meaning that it is in the habitable zone,and what drastic climate changes and gravity changes are evident?
How did you select the barycenter to make the rings around it and not the individual stars?
+LucasFlecoRepe you just left click on it. it doesn't work well though
Will be funny a binary star system stable with planets, but with the othe star at the distance of Jupiter or Neptune..how move the planets around both stars?
Hey guys at anytime when he is talking about where the planets could be in the binary system,focus on 1 star then put your finger on it and notice it doesn't move away from your finger.
(I was bored)
You should do a video on the gas giant that's 650 AU from its star and talk about the theories about it and show just how far it is compared to our solar system. I think that's be cool.
+KingOfZorgon
You mean the possible 9th planet?
He already did that. It's right there in the suggestions.
Oh and what would it take for planets to maintain stable orbits in a circumbinary system? Is that virtually possible?
What is the link for this "Universe Sandbox". When I google I get many dodgy looking downloads options.
Nice video. What happens when you replace Sol with binary stars like this = 1 solar mass?
Awesome video!!!What causes the planet which orbits these binary stars to experience such wild climate swings? Are there any planets which orbits other stars which have elliptical orbits? I heard that they too experience wild climate shifts. Is that true?
Are most binary stars Yellow dwarf stars or Red dwarf stars? What if a planet in the habitable zone has a moon like us. Wouldnt it stabilize the Axis alot more?
If all of the planets were to orbit a binary star,including Earth,what things would happen as a result? Would it affect our climates,and what other things?
Can a planet orbit 2 stars but the stars don't orbit one another like a figure 8 around the two stars?
Something is wrong with algorithm, how can a "planetary mass" totally disrupt a stellar orbital pair?
2 things: A, would it be possible that when two solar systems collide both stars are of equal mass and eventually their orbits stabilize and thus creating a binary star system. And B, what does AU stand for?
the collision is very unlikely due to distances involved. au is 1 distance of earth from the sun. 150 mil km
+Anton Petrov (WhatDaMath) I understand that, but theoretically would it be possible?
I'd imagine it's possible with two stars that are moving towards the same point; however, with two solar systems, you would have to take into account the gravitational influences of all of the planets and other minor bodies. There would have to be some really specific conditions for that to occur.
How do you add a barycentre
I know this is an older video but anyone know how to create a barycenter in Uni Sand 2. It is easy in 1 but i can't find out how in 2.
I figured it out.
Either that or they added the feature in the time that I wasn't paying attention to it.
I looked this up because the Last Jedi, Luke was sitting on an island in the middle of an ocean looking up at two suns. I thought the two suns would cause an irregular orbit and weather would be terrible. I started to wonder if life as we know it would even be possible. Maybe if one sun had very little mass. The smallest suns found have a mass 7% of our sun. Maybe if the small 7% sun's orbit was far away, like oort cloud distance away. Then a stable orbit of an Earth like planet could exist orbiting the central sun. I wish I had this program to test these ideas. Of course then the second sun would just be a dot in the sky, you would never see two large suns in the sky from a planet with calm weather. A few sci-fi movies have done this binary sky. I guess it looks cool and exotic.
How do you make a barycenter?
Anton,I just now watched a new you tube video called “First Planet Ever Found Orbiting A Triple Star System”. I was under the impression that triple star systems with planets orbiting them already existed. Is that fact true? How many triple star systems with planets orbiting them exist in our known universe?
how did you add the barycenter?
hold ctrl and aelect the 2 star
select*
Cool video. Something new. BTW, could you create your own solar system (I know this suggestion is very often in your comments, but plz).
+Marcel Gerhardt (Marcelboy) I will try, although I'm not creative enough to make my own system :D
How can you go about getting this game because I’d find it very interesting to play!!! I’ve enjoyed watching your videos.
a stable Binary system with gas giants is possible if the planets are far enough
Maybe can be posible to with a star similar than sun and the other a red dwarf at Neptune distance or more..will be funny see how the planets move..
if the planet is far enough, it will orbit like it was orbiting 1 star, its basic physics.
Look at the new planet they found not long ago, It is orbiting Proxima Centauri(a sun) Proxima centauri is itself orbiting alpha centauri which is a binary star system
SirPetterTheFirst Thanks to your answer i wasn't good in physics when i study..the idea i was thinking is how the planets are orbiting if are between the gravity of 2 stars..(and diferent posibilities of distance open diferent stars mas variations..) the nearest of star 1 orbit in that like our Sun, and the nearest to star 2 the same, but other farest planets orbit both? I'm curious about how if we Earth stay in a binary system, how that afect of the diferent cosmovisions in the human history..(sorry to my english..)
SirPetterTheFirst Thanks to your explanation, i was trying to imagine weird planetary systems without knowing the rules..imagining a planet between both star habitable zone..i supose that wasn't posible being stable..it crash with other planet to it's weird orbite, it will be eated by 1 of the stars or throw away..and i sopose the individual star habitable zone, change at being add's both star radiation if stay between..
I think the same about nacionalisms..was stay in chains of the dusty bone rulers phantasmagories..only bacause actual rulers conveniences..1 thing is know the history and other that obstacle the present and future..like if actual astronomers bellieve in the old 2D geocentric constelations..
Ardiak Beltz well soon the old farts will die, hopefully the next generation will not be nationalist of conservative. we will probably get away from the risk of the 3rd world war
Could you please tell me how you added a barycenter?
+Milaud Talebi you have to select both objects and then right click on their description on the right
Anton Petrov but how do you select two objects?
@@lucasxxl4692 hold ctrl
If there were 2 suns wouldn't the gravity shift a lot on the planet as well?
What are the name of two Binary stars
S-type binary stars are very rare, only about 1 to 3 at most exoplanets can orbit. But the system can only last millions of years.
Wow that planet is Melbourne everywhere
what if the stars are larger though?
What if the rotation axis of our Earth was parallel to its orbit?
HisMajestyGuigui good thinking we are the pleiangels 800 million years go rist prays to our ancestor to pray to us to pray to them.
hey you game doesn't lag at all what are you computer specification or specs?
+Super Saiyan KidFastDD mine game lags as well
A good planet needs figure 8’s to be habitable
IF BINARY STARS ARE FAR AND GOOD ZONES CROSS EACHOVER
Or a big star and a small star is binary then gas giants are okay
The outer space rocks in the binary system could be called the rock cloud
Do you think there could be a planet in the middle of the stars?
it's possible if one get stuck in the barycentre
+Anton Petrov (WhatDaMath) ya that's want I was thinking.
+Alex Hanson It's very possible. If it does, the planet gets tidal locked, which means, it actually won't orbit the stars nor will it rotate
hello again
Just think how exciting it would be if the Earth orbited a curcumbinary star system,such as this one and it was still habitable. Just think how exciting though it’d be to wake up to two sunrises? Couldn’t you just imagine that? Would that ever be realistic?
Why orbits are circular.how about perihelion and aphelion
its complitly posibal and hard for au to find and imposibal in Universe Sandbox 2
Why do the sun orbiting in a perfect circle? How is that possible?
Swiss Mapping because most of the planets are in somewhat a perfect circle
Are there stable binary planets ?
No lololol 😂😂😂😂
why not recreate the doctor who twin earth planet mondas home of the cybermen
thanks for the suggestion
P-Type system
+Anton Petrov (WhatDaMath) remember mondas orbit must come unstable and exit the solar system without destroying the system
You know that in our solar sitem there are two stars?
One is the Sun, the other one is a very small red star who orbit at half light year from the Sun
Do you know that isn't true? I it was true, everyone should know about it. When you place the red dwarf star Barnard's Star at half a light year distance it would be visible in a bright night.
Sergente A oh are binary system is true.
All of the planets should be affected by the star instead of be a reliving circular orbit
Planets don't just instantly form, so this simulation proves nothing. I imagine that a proto-planetary disk is much like the allowed orbitals of an electron: regions that are prohibited are empty, leaving only the orbits that "work" behind. From an evolutionary perspective, matter in the prohibited regions is either incorporated into the star or is shunted into the allowed regions, which then changes their mass distribution.
This request will be the most unusual request that you have ever had,but I was just quite curious about this: my request is there any possible way that you could do a simulation of what would happen to the planets in our solar system if they orbited 5 (not 4) suns? I’m just curious as to how their orbits would be affected by having 5 suns? If you thought having a binary star system would be bad,having that many “stars” would be nothing more that complete and utter planetary chaos.
try to get 6 stars to orbit around each other. 2 red dwarfs, 2 orange stars, and 2 G class sun like stars.
Kenny Carter the only way to have six stars within 35,000,000,000 km of each other is to have a hypergiant star in the center (for a stable system)
Cool
Is there a 4 star system
yes there are even six star systems
Anton Petrov how is a six star system be stable?
create the sun from scratch pls🌞
+ΚΩΣΤΑΣ ΓΚΙΩΝΑΚΗΣ this is in the planning. thanks for the idea
Could you create a System with the earth in the Middle and the sun and moon with the same size Orbitating around the earth like your binary star System.
hi
How can you make a barycenter.
Why do people never show it on camera.
Your albedo is way too high, no wonder the planet is constantly dropping in temp.
Take off all water on Westeros you will see earth
I see all astroid’s
vladamir will approve of this.
150th view c:
350 View!
+Ethan Carpenter 430th view
2293th!
putin.
does any1 play roblox
i do