Was looking forward to your take on this one. It causes me angst because I've repeatedly read that SK says it's his favorite of his own work, but I've tried twice to read it and abandoned the effort both times. I fully agree, though, with your comment about the effectiveness and elegance of the flashbacks.
This is in my top 3 for King. The inside/relationship language was wonderful to me, really made me feel I was their with them. And I didn't feel she was demeaned by relating so much of her life to her husband. When you love someone that much they're in your thoughts all day, and you can't help talking about them. Woodsmucky and others who looked at her like a groupie were the demeaning ones. I've re-read so many times!
I think the flashbacks to childhood were incredibly memorable and by far the strongest part of this book. And, Boo'ya Moon has many fantastic elements, including the shrouded entities around the pool. But I couldn't stand the stupid phrases that are everywhere. Perhaps worse, also that a lot of the time I felt that Lisey was written in a condescending way, always defined by Scott, often referring back to him in her internal monologues - "Scott had a word for this...", "Scott would have done this...". I feel that if this was rolled back / reframed (if only slightly), this would be a superb book, but as it it really sucked enjoyment out of it. I wonder if that is why King says Tabitha is not a fan...
Just finished it tonight and really had to work to finish the last 100 pages or so. The plotting just seemed needlessly complicated and it distracted from the strength of the story which was their central relationship. And the actual Lisey’s story? And the language…oof. Glad I finished it but I can’t imagine returning to this one again
SPOILERS Unfortunately I didn’t like this one too much. The biggest problem was the dialogue which made me fucking cranky when reading it😤😡. I also thought it was extremely boring and all the stuff about Scott’s childhood was dumb. I wanted to at least have an idea on what the ‘bad gunky’ was but no, his brother just went all nutty. And I hated the way that huge chunk of backstory was told with Scott doing his baby voice. And in the end, I found the payoff really underwhelming. Nearly 700 pages just to get to Scott talking about how he killed his dad. I was just reading it like ‘oh for fuck sake is that really what everything was building up to?!’. But I found Boo Ya Moon to be a really cool place. The atmosphere was very haunting and it was like a sigh of relief every time we went there. Anyway, it’s not a favourite of mine, it kind of reminds me of The Talisman which I’ve just recently had to put down for similar reasons. Shitty dialogue, characters who are fucking annoying, extremely sluggish pace and a cartoonish villain. EDIT: can I ask what the hell is the backdrop on the thumbnail??!?!?
I obviously disagree on Lisey’s Story but enjoyed hearing your take - and am glad to see Boo’ya Moon was still powerful enough to make an impression too! I do, however, *love* your summary of The Talisman 😂 The background on the thumbnail was some weird pic I found on Canva - I thought it fitted the aesthetic of the Lisey’s Story miniseries
I also think many authors become forgotten or write a few books which are seen as critical failures. The same thing happened to Dean Koontz - as a young teen I read a lot of Dean Koontz early works up until Tick Tock and that was it for me...... His later works didn't grab me - with the exception of "The Taking". It was enjoyable but didn't have the same feel as his earlier works like Winter Moon, Midnight etc etc.
@@DaveReadsKing the problem is some fans will only like a particular era and anything different is seen as #notmyKing lol. I mean some fan really hate Cell but rave about The Stand ..... Yet both books are very very similar in tone and story. I'm always surprised by Kings output and routine.
I'd have to reread it again but I remember thinking it was boring at first but got into it and thought it was pretty good. Not great though like Blaze. Blaze is fucken great wish I didn't give all my books away
I liked it and got frustrated by it! In fact, I recorded some thoughts with my friend Casual Comic Fans right here: th-cam.com/video/7NdY-RrSibk/w-d-xo.html
Dave, why do you own the late 00"s SK books with those generic cover arts. Lisey"s Story looks like a loada Shite!!! Just like Insomnia, The Tommyknockers, Dreamcatcher, The Jack Sawyer books etc., I'll stay from this one too, it's nothing personal. Interesting review!😬👍
Just finished this one and I didn't like it at all. Terrible plot, insufferable characters and the awful, over used 'kiddy' language made the book a slog to get through. This is easily in my worst 5 King books. 😒
oof. As the series was better without the googoo talk, your video would be better without the idiotic beeps. FFs I can't I have to tap out. Sorry that beep is messing with my autism horribly.
Ok, farewell and sorry that it affected your viewing experience. As it happens, I really like the beep and don’t think it ‘idiotic’ at all, and I don’t think that’s a fair word to describe something just because you personally don’t like it. Anyway, I appreciate you at least trying to watch my video and if you ever feel like coming back it would be great to see you again. The beeps are in every one, which I know you won’t like but at least if you do try again you can be prepared for them being there.
I adored Lisey's Story. It broke my heart in a million pieces and made me cry, and it was fantastic.
I’m with you all the way - a magnificent piece of work
Was looking forward to your take on this one. It causes me angst because I've repeatedly read that SK says it's his favorite of his own work, but I've tried twice to read it and abandoned the effort both times.
I fully agree, though, with your comment about the effectiveness and elegance of the flashbacks.
it's definitely I've seen a lot of people struggle to get into
This is in my top 3 for King. The inside/relationship language was wonderful to me, really made me feel I was their with them. And I didn't feel she was demeaned by relating so much of her life to her husband. When you love someone that much they're in your thoughts all day, and you can't help talking about them. Woodsmucky and others who looked at her like a groupie were the demeaning ones. I've re-read so many times!
Nice! I think it’s terrific 😊
SOWISA 🙂 I struggled a bit in the beginning but once i got to know Lisey, i fell in love with her and the book.
Yes!
I've read it twice..so far..I literally love this story
So good, right??
I think the flashbacks to childhood were incredibly memorable and by far the strongest part of this book. And, Boo'ya Moon has many fantastic elements, including the shrouded entities around the pool. But I couldn't stand the stupid phrases that are everywhere. Perhaps worse, also that a lot of the time I felt that Lisey was written in a condescending way, always defined by Scott, often referring back to him in her internal monologues - "Scott had a word for this...", "Scott would have done this...". I feel that if this was rolled back / reframed (if only slightly), this would be a superb book, but as it it really sucked enjoyment out of it. I wonder if that is why King says Tabitha is not a fan...
Yeah, it's certainly an interesting take. it still very much feels like a book written by a man!
❤❤❤❤ I’ve watched the the tv series and I’m now reading the book I’m loving it
Nice! That series was excellent
Just finished it tonight and really had to work to finish the last 100 pages or so. The plotting just seemed needlessly complicated and it distracted from the strength of the story which was their central relationship. And the actual Lisey’s story? And the language…oof. Glad I finished it but I can’t imagine returning to this one again
Thanks for sharing - I can totally see your point, and Lisey's actual story is a bit of comedown, but I still loved this one!
SPOILERS
Unfortunately I didn’t like this one too much. The biggest problem was the dialogue which made me fucking cranky when reading it😤😡. I also thought it was extremely boring and all the stuff about Scott’s childhood was dumb. I wanted to at least have an idea on what the ‘bad gunky’ was but no, his brother just went all nutty. And I hated the way that huge chunk of backstory was told with Scott doing his baby voice.
And in the end, I found the payoff really underwhelming. Nearly 700 pages just to get to Scott talking about how he killed his dad. I was just reading it like ‘oh for fuck sake is that really what everything was building up to?!’.
But I found Boo Ya Moon to be a really cool place. The atmosphere was very haunting and it was like a sigh of relief every time we went there.
Anyway, it’s not a favourite of mine, it kind of reminds me of The Talisman which I’ve just recently had to put down for similar reasons. Shitty dialogue, characters who are fucking annoying, extremely sluggish pace and a cartoonish villain.
EDIT: can I ask what the hell is the backdrop on the thumbnail??!?!?
I obviously disagree on Lisey’s Story but enjoyed hearing your take - and am glad to see Boo’ya Moon was still powerful enough to make an impression too! I do, however, *love* your summary of The Talisman 😂
The background on the thumbnail was some weird pic I found on Canva - I thought it fitted the aesthetic of the Lisey’s Story miniseries
I haven't watched the lisey story adaptation yet 📺
It's well worth it!
Tried the book, couldn't get into it. Tried the miniseries, quit after the first episode. Loved your review, though!
Thanks - and sorry neither the book nor the series clicked for you!
Good review. I’ll add it to my list.
Nice! Enjoy!
I also think many authors become forgotten or write a few books which are seen as critical failures. The same thing happened to Dean Koontz - as a young teen I read a lot of Dean Koontz early works up until Tick Tock and that was it for me...... His later works didn't grab me - with the exception of "The Taking". It was enjoyable but didn't have the same feel as his earlier works like Winter Moon, Midnight etc etc.
Fair - I'm just constantly impressed that someone as prolific as King manages to keep the quality consistently high, even this far in!
@@DaveReadsKing the problem is some fans will only like a particular era and anything different is seen as #notmyKing lol. I mean some fan really hate Cell but rave about The Stand ..... Yet both books are very very similar in tone and story. I'm always surprised by Kings output and routine.
Would love to see book to movie reviews of King!
That's a great idea plus the new adaptation of firestarter just came out in theaters 😃🤔
Funny you should say that - I'll be reaching the end of the books this year and my plan is to start on the adaptations in 2023 - sound like a plan?
@@angelaholmes8888 Yes! I saw it on Saturday - I'm guesting on another page to talk about it soon!
Nice Overlook wallpaper.
Thanks!
I'd have to reread it again but I remember thinking it was boring at first but got into it and thought it was pretty good. Not great though like Blaze. Blaze is fucken great wish I didn't give all my books away
I'll be covering Blaze next!
Beautiful book. One of my favorite love stories.
It’s sooo good!
@@DaveReadsKing And the adaptation was just gorgeous. Magical realism is probably my favorite sub-genre in fantasy and horror.
@greywaren621 yes! I’m really looking forward to rewatching that soon
I did like the character lisey but the book for some reason I just couldn't connect with it
Fair enough!
How was the new Firestarter did you like it
I liked it and got frustrated by it! In fact, I recorded some thoughts with my friend Casual Comic Fans right here: th-cam.com/video/7NdY-RrSibk/w-d-xo.html
Oh same I thought some scenes were good but I thought the ending wasn't that good
@@samtubebackagainramey6971 totally
Big YES with #7! The language is super annoying!
Yeah - smucking annoying!
@@DaveReadsKing had to put it down unfortunately, now reading Revival 🤠
Hope you enjoy that one more!
Great book.
It absolutely is!
This is one of his most boring books in my opinion. I liked Dreamcatcher better than this book.
Interesting! Lisey's Story definitely seems to be a divisive one
Unfortunately I didn't enjoy this book as I thought I would because most of kings underrated books I have enjoyed like insomnia and the talisman 👎😔
Oh well - they can't all be hits for everyone!
@@DaveReadsKing so true
Dave, why do you own the late 00"s SK books with those generic cover arts. Lisey"s Story looks like a loada Shite!!! Just like Insomnia, The Tommyknockers, Dreamcatcher, The Jack Sawyer books etc., I'll stay from this one too, it's nothing personal. Interesting review!😬👍
You mean my rainbow editions? They’re my pride and joy - I love them!
Just finished this one and I didn't like it at all. Terrible plot, insufferable characters and the awful, over used 'kiddy' language made the book a slog to get through.
This is easily in my worst 5 King books. 😒
Fair enough, they can’t all be winners for everyone!
oof. As the series was better without the googoo talk, your video would be better without the idiotic beeps. FFs I can't I have to tap out. Sorry that beep is messing with my autism horribly.
Ok, farewell and sorry that it affected your viewing experience. As it happens, I really like the beep and don’t think it ‘idiotic’ at all, and I don’t think that’s a fair word to describe something just because you personally don’t like it. Anyway, I appreciate you at least trying to watch my video and if you ever feel like coming back it would be great to see you again. The beeps are in every one, which I know you won’t like but at least if you do try again you can be prepared for them being there.