Extrema Ratio Task J Field Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2017
- Extrema Ratio TASK J review. The Extrema Ratio TASK J has been designed by the Jagdkommando unit in Austria. The name despite it's similarity to the pre existing TASK, the TASK J is really a totally new knife. The exception being the basic profile of the TASK has been kept but with many heavy duty modifications. Being able to put the emblem of the Jagdkommando onto the blade is basically giving this knife it's credentials as a performer. My initial tests and later field tests over 3 days only confirmed what I thought upon picking up the TASK J, WOW What a knife! Of course this is no surprise as the the TASK J was designed by the material designers of the Jagdkommando unit who are experts in their field. The Task J then brought into realisation by Extrema Ratio. Built from the proven N690 cobalt stainless tool steel, the TASK J really rocks.
You can also see it here:
www.extremaratio.com/prodotti/...
and here:
www.extremaratio.com/prodotti/...
Also see my blog about the Extrema Ratio Task J here:
hardcorecampingtools.blogspot....
The Extrema Ratio Task J handles very nicely and lived up to what Extrema Ratio call a "Multi-purpose knife" as far as I was concerned.
You be the judge. - กีฬา
Well..it's nothing short of capable! It looks like a very well thought out piece of kit. Good review mate.
Hi mate thanks and thanks for watching! Yeah surprised me a bit with this "revamped" blade design. I was looking at it when it first appeared on their web site and thought, well what's the point, as it looked just like the original Task but of course the web images on their site and others really didn't show it properly at all.
Hey, that is the knife from our Jagdkommando (Austrias special forces). Nice to see that it gets some love here. Greetings from Vienna
Yes indeed it is! And it's a damn good knife design too!
Являюсь профессиональным военным и любителем активного образа жизни , в своём арсенале имею много ножей различного назначения и функционала , данного производителя знаю по некоторым изделиям военного назначения . Данный нож приобрёл недавно и уже успел ощутить весь его положительный функционал, дороговат конечно но это лишь его единственный недостаток . Отличный инструмент и как боевое оружие и как нож для выживания и как охотничий помощник , всегда имею при себе вспомогательный малый нож , но этот заменяет его с лихвой , спасибо производителям , эта серия должна развиваться .
Hi many thanks for your comments here! I would like to provide a Google translation (I'm sure it is not adequate) so that other readers who do not understand the Russian/Cyrillic will be able to also view the following:
"I am a professional military man and lover of an active lifestyle, in my arsenal I have a lot of knives for various purposes and functionality, I know this manufacturer from some military products. This knife was purchased recently and has already managed to feel all its positive functionality, it is expensive, of course, but this is only its only drawback. An excellent tool both as a combat weapon and as a survival knife and as a hunting assistant, I always have an auxiliary small knife with me, but this one replaces it with interest, thanks to the manufacturers, this series should develop."
I am glad you like this model and I too believe this to be a very versatile design and as you mention, a : "hunting assistant" because as you indicate the importance of having another smaller knife handy. You have effectively summed up the applications of this product.
Hello Mate. Great Zero BS Review (As Always) Another Solid Design From Extrema Ratio. Have a Good One Fella...Cheers!
Hey man, thanks! and thanks for watching!
Outstanding Mate! This ones a must for my collection I would love to see you do a review on the Selvans by ER since buying that one I've hardly touched the Ontos , Fulcrum it's on another level again.
Hi, yeah I've heard people saying that re the Selvans and I think it's all about that slightly longer reach if you like and the "improved grip" (my words) for swing that baby. Plus many don't like having serrations on that upper surface but I got used to mine and of course as you know can also strike your steel there too. But all that being said, I think the Ontos is still what they say it's good for. As for the Fulcrum..... :)!
Selvans is a great knife, I sold my Fallkniven A1 to help fund mine.
@@dazzpol Good move there!
Hey Shane BTW mate are you still around, pity about Blade Mates
А что вы можете сказать про Fulcrum? Стоит покупать его или нет?
Looks like a Really nice blade bro. Thx for sharing my friend. Cheers mate
Thanks mate! Yeah it's a top performer for sure.
Great knife and great review, I have the 3909 and the AMF (the modernized version of the Gerber BMF). I can only speak more than highly of Extrema Ratio for the superb craftsmanship quality of their knives.
That is a good summary of their products. I too have the AMF and love it, maybe because of that retro look. I always wanted one of those Gerber BMFs but never bit the bullet. I see they are for sale on Ebay at times for ridiculous amounts of money, although I guess not if one is a collector! I bet that 3909 is great too. Thanks for watching!
@@BushCampingTools I have the BMF mint in box , it has a 440A stainless steel blade. The Mint in Box items can be pricey but it cuts well . I have bought it as a collector item. I also have a Mint in Box buckmaster 184 with a 425m blade and a mint al mar sf 10 with a 440 c seki japanese blade. The AMF was a too good deal to pass up. Yes the 3909 is one of the best knives I have ever had.
@@georgeszaslavsky OMG, two classic blades of "modern times" and you own them mint! I also lusted after that Buckmaster and had it out of the display cabinet so many times, the only reason I never got chucked out of the shop was because I knew the guy (although we weren't what u would call friends, more of business colleagues LOL!). When I was living in Tokyo, I also saw the BMF for sale in a big outdoor store but at that time I was more into tick mountain bike parts for a downhill bike I had. (Ok I did buy loads of knives there LOL, but sadly not the Gerber). I'm sure the AMF will also become a collectors item like the 3909.
@@BushCampingTools I bought the BMF alongwith its smaller cousin the LMF and the Gerber Bowie from a Gunshop 6 years ago which used to have an insane amount of new old stock Gerbers, Bucks and Randalls back then. Any Extrema Ratio is built very solid and tough. I do have one Russian Knife the Rosarms Zlatoust Baionet which is an incredible knife considering the price I paid.
Great review! Thanks a lot! Btw, you should try some Bark River knives. I think you would like it!
Yes for some reason I don't own any Bark River knives yet but I am def aware of their quality and usefulness in the field, especially for hunting. They are on the Radar!
Another great video with another great knife. Man that sheath is really nice, maybe you could demonstrate how well it holds up jumping out of an airplane! Hey do you own all these beauties or do you have to give them back?
Thanks Michael! Well we have good friends who are crazy sky divers, just watching their mobile videos gets my heart racing LOL. I might have to get a divorce first though LOL. No I own them although the other half would be more than happy if I gave them away/back. The Task J really rocks and is one of my fav knives.
I pulled the trigger and bought the Task J and the T4000 S.
great! My T4000S gets used everyday
An autentic beast, extreme ratio is sign of quality but a lot expensive.
Regards!.
Yes, at least in my experience it is a sign of quality, I won't disagree here. Many speak of the price, something I never discuss on this channel as it really depends on many things. I think, if we have to compare them to knives from other manufacturers within Europe and in the USA of similar prices then I'd say they are a better deal. Although I could write much on this subject which is too much for here but I think your comment has prompted me to write properly about this aspect and I'll post it to the blog or on facebook, so stay tuned.
Great review. I have owned a few of ERs blades. Fulcrum, Task, t4000, Shrapnel. I have since sold them and only have the Selvans now. All great knives but they didn’t fit my intended purpose and was a shame having them gather dust. With regards the task, I couldn’t get on with the finger choil. It seemed to increase the length of the blade (which sounds daft I know) but I like to use the blade near the handle for controlled cuts, together with the serrations I just couldn’t get on with it. Slicing with the fine edge was ok, but again this seemed too far away to get control. Now this looks right! I was looking to get the Dobbie IV but that recurve keeps putting me off. The Task J looks the business and might just fit the bill! That curved cutting edge looks like a capable wood worker and the thicker tip gives me a little more confidence when poking stuff.
Does that top guard interfere much?
I had some initial doubts re the top guard of the Task J but in my hands no, not at all infact when cutting vegetables (I'll post some video) I hook my index finger around the top guard (then no chance of slippage!). But yeah I know what u mean re the original Task and the choil. Now that's it gone it is much much better. I wonder if the Task was a early prototype LOL for the Task J?? But seriously, I still like my Task too, but yep I understand your views totally here. Thanks for watching!
Gotta say too the Dobby 4 is a very nice knife.
Thanks for that. It's now on the list. Just got to source a supply
I now have my task j. Although I’ve not had chance to get this outdoors as yet I can agree with your review. Comfortable grip, stout but usable blade and the usual excellent sheath system.
I’ve bought this as a replacement for the Fallkniven A1 I owned previously. Let’s get some use out of it and see how she performs.
Great to hear! The A1 is a well respected blade of course but I think, somewhat over rated for what it is (IMHO). I've had one i my hands many times but never decided to actually buy one. Let's know how you find the Task J out in the field. There will be more videos of my Task J as time goes on as it's now in my Favourite knife lists LOL!
I Just Wish they will make an Full Black Version of that Task J Knife
Not sure if i replied to you as i'm having tech issue here wit YT as in posts are not getting posted LOL but you could probably buy a black handle from them although it wouldn't match (if that was concern) the sheath and i know theFulcrum sheaths don't fit it either (ie the black ones, so u just can't swap it out for one of those sheaths).
@@BushCampingTools i just wish they would make a Black Version because i like a more neutral color 😅
@@thick9996 Yes I see what you mean now. All that aside, it is a very nice design.
@@BushCampingTools Thats true ... do you have a Video about the Extrema Ratio KS Kukri ??? :D
@@thick9996 No, unfortunately I don't. I'm not sure where u live but if it isn't in the tropics or close to the tropics then i think all Kukris are not so good outside of these areas in my experience. They take a lot of practice for the foreigner to master like fore example i watched Nepalese not only harvest timber with them but also build damn houses (in place of a hammer and saw LOL) and Indonesians use similar shaped blades from every day agricultural stuff to cutting open fruit for me at home LOL. But on saying all of that, who doesn't want to own one LOL, I have one and also a hand made parang which was made right in front of my very eyes.
Nice vid! Does the inner plastic sheath part lock into the outer nylon sheath, or is just a very snugg fit?
Hi, no it locks in there and these sheaths are top dollar and very well constructed and thought out. BTW this model knife is very good.
@@BushCampingTools Thank you for your reply! That knife is definetly added to the buy-list!
@@mattis1600 It's one of my favourite ER knives as in design.
That's it. Now I want a Task J. And it's all your fault, BCT! Cursaaaa youuuuu.... XD
Hi, yes I must admit I have probably caused many a: relationship breakup; getting into debt; irresponsible spending when the roof needs fixing; car needs attention; kids don't have any new clothes etc LOL! It is a very nice knife. You won't regret getting it. As to not spending any more hard earned cash on more knives, I'm afraid I can not be responsible for that either :)!!
👍
Say Heah Francis, That Tusk J is in my sights, Thanx You for sharing it. But I brought out one of my Vintage TactiKewl Knives, I like the Ka-Bar U. S. M. C. but the new ones the hand guard loosens easy not like my Vintage W. W 2 versions, I even have a Camillus model too. But the knife I really like is my Vintage Cold Steel O. D. A. The handle and Quillions are one piece of Kraton. So it won't loosen. The Steel is their Vintage Proprietary CarbonV and it's a extremely tough knife. Infact it's my Fav's to my Ka-Bar. But yeah, I really like that Tusk J.,,. p
Thanks mate. Yes the Task is a good knife mate Godd to see the old knives are surfacing. I regularly try and do this and it's great!
Probably K Bar cutting corners re the guards, not good!
Уважаемый автор, подскажи пожалуйста: что на твой взгляд лучше Task J, Fulcrum или Fulcrum Bayonet NFG? Что тебе больше нравится самому?
Hi there. This is a good question and I can say without hesitating that the Fulcrum NFG is more serviceable in the field and more useful (at least for me) Do not get me wrong the Task J is a very very good knife but is a little bit harder to sharpen and you can not press into the butt because of the protruding tang (more useful as a persuader device however, it too can be applied to bushcraft things with some imagination.
@@BushCampingTools понял, спасибо за ответ!🤝
I think i prefer t havea a tip upswept
Disassemble the handle，What is the specification of the Allen wrench？
Hi sorry for the late reply your message for some reason went into the Spam folder. The Allen wrench is a 4mm or slotted screw driver and some coins also work (along with a metal keychain thingy I have too LOL) so it's pretty easy to disassemble in the field.
Ok, thank you very much for your reply！
No problems!
When walking, the arm moves on the horizontal line. The protection is rather hindering in the movement
Hi, you mean the cover over the handle yes?
i wish their fulcrum s would come back in stock :(
I didn't know they were out of stock, bummer. I do love my Fulcrum S, especially after I cut off the top guard! It's a good knife for sure.
I got their fulcrum c instead a while back, its a very very nice knife besides the large amount of serrations over the edge, which isn't that big of a deal since it still serves me handy :)
yes the Fulcrum C is also very strong. (I think they did some crazy bending tests on this model ages ago). I'm sure it's a knife to be used!
hello,u prefere this or fulcrum ? the tip have more penetration this or fulcrum?
Ooo, I like both but the Task J may slightly rank higher than my Fulcrum. Although, that being said, on solo wilderness hikes/camps, I usually take the Fulcrum, especially in winter. (you can see it being used on a video here, a solo hike in the winter. harder to film because I'm alone.
Both are very good at penetrating objects
@@BushCampingTools thanks, have you ever seen the extrema ratio "tuscania" (carabinieri special forces (a type of police) ? very rare
No but I do know about this knife. I think I saw a pic of it once on the FB page
@@roberto903
Is it better in your opinion than the Ka-Bar Tanto- even though this knife is actually a Japanese Tanto as the Ka-Bar is a regular Tanto? It's a beast I can tell that much!!
While I have never held, nor (at present :)) used a KBar Tanto, I can see no reason why: 1) it wold not be comfortable to use as those grips are of course very ergonomic and of course also grippy, if I use my Ontario Spec Plus to go on. 2) the slight belly/Japanese looking blade design works, I know this from the Kizlyar Supreme Senpai and how well it does in the bush. The biggest difference is the steel of course but I'd say you can't go wrong with the KBar tanto. As to whether it is "Better than", I can't say whether it is "Better than" anything else as this is really opinion and the designs are different, plus as I said I don't have it to make a direct and fair comparison. Eg I love Subaru's, and in fact own a WRX but is it better than a EVO? LOL!
Oh yeah see Paul'ie 4X's comment below comments re the new Kbar's. He is a big knife user, so I'd trust his info.
Say Heah Francis, Outstanding Video, Yup, It's definitely on my Wanna Wanna List. Dilly Dilly.,,.p
Hi Mate, yeah it's a really good model from them and very beefy but easy to use.
Bush Camping Tools Thanx You, Friend. Dilly Dilly.,,.p
It looks weird, probably doesn't stop it from stabbing, but still looks weird.
yes it does look a bit "weird" but rest assured, it works fine