"I wouldn't have wanted anyone else to sing that" After I first heard the song this was exactly my thought! It is just so Onew~ There are some songs where you can immediately pinpoint someone that would sound great singing it as well, and this is such a stunning example of one where that's not the case at all. So beautiful🥺
Actually, the music video director lost his cat recently, he commented that the message of this song reflected how he felt and helped him to accept his cat passing, thus he planned for the puppet to appear! I think it's beautiful how he added his own insight of the song to the music video and that he was comforted by the song, truly an example of what onew music means to a lot of us 🥰
I honestly thought the whole time I had first watched the mv that the cat was an owl and was shocked to find out it was a cat after watching the choreographer react to it and someone in the comment section mentions it was a cat.
I have thought unquestioningly until today that the puppet was a dog. And I kept wanting Onew to pet the dog, but if that was a cat…that perspective makes sense. Thank you.
I have been a SHINee fan since 2008. There is no other voice in the world like Onew's. It was such a pleasure to watch people's faces as they heard him sing for the first time. He is a very special man. Think of the animal this way. Most of us have a special stuffed animal that was part of our childhood. As we get older, it changes and becomes a bit more scruffy, but it is loved every bit as much.
I have a gray lamb similar to that cat. It's legs are very floppy. I think was white originally. Still has It's pink nose but it's a tiny, tiny nose. That lamb is a survivor, just like the cat ❤
"Eight Stories about eternity" cats are believed to have nine lives. The cat looks like that because he has, in fact like you suggested, seen everything over the course of his other eight lives, and I suppose he is telling his stories in his last one.
When Umu spoke about her Mom not knowing it's SHINee singing until Onew sings is literally me with my parents. They're both singers and they love love love Onew's voice! Also, that avocado animation is so freaking cute!
this cat has seen every war 😭😂 loved kayla's point about the power of a performer who can pull you in without gimmicks or "doing" anything in particular, onew's voice alone has such a unique emotional draw (my mom also comments whenever onew sings in shinee songs LOL) and coupled with the calmness that jacob mentioned between the hectic string bits (that arguably mirror today's fast paced, info inundated society), circle mesmerizes you into introspection, appreciation, catharsis, harmony aka free therapy
i feel like this song is a masterpiece in itself, but what's stunning with onew's vocal is that, this song doesn't have that "big vocal moment" like high notes or the run, it's as the theme goes, more stable and tranquil throughout. and personally i think it's hard to pull off those kind of songs, only when the artist has a great voice/tone and a great control over it does it shine. and i agree, i wouldn't have wanted anyone else to sing this song
Many people don't appreciate real good voices and singers in kpop. People tend to think ALL kpop idols can sing just because they have debuted and even asking for more lines, but nah, that makes us underappreciate the ones who ARE really good singers.
This MV is overwhelming gorgeous and I thought Blue was a philosophical cinematic masterpiece. When I was watching it for the first time as soon as the starting montage begun, I found myself getting a lump in my throat. I froze there and got teleported to a dream-like trance. It's real poetry and made me think about how Jinki is letting us in into a veryy personal emotional space. It got me thinking of all the grief, loss, beauty unfairness and the inevitable end of life via an overwhelming amounts of emotions. I'm not convinced I understand what I felt in the moment and what I'm feeling right now as I'm writing this. I guess that's what art does to you. It all felt so divine. The quick frames and the countdown with the special effects made me feel like I was watching Dark (the show). For me, this was an outer body/spiritual experience as if it had opened up my chest and exposed my very soul to me. Now I know why the whole of Nolto cast became Jinki devotees lmao. There is something formidable about what he's expressing. Life, Death, Eternity and the laws of cyclical things are inevitable and will circle back whether you want it to or not, which can be both stifling and comforting. Circle is a kind of song that is made up of tapestry of emotions and it mirrors whatever that is you feel in the moment, which can be both grief or comfort. It connects and resonates with you. Overall, this MV was very philosophical and healing but sometimes when you leap up into broader emotional landscape and read through the lyrics and give it's themes a shot it's so saddening too. This whole album is a masterpiece and unlike anything you see in kpop. I expect a full album reaction from you guys.
when i first heard circle ( i'm new to shinee world just for context) i had a moment of catharsis, with the changing of seasons and the vocals of onew singing it, the lyrics and imagery all washed over me at once
Emotions plus vocals. There's so much restraint and thought put into the MV and song it's unmissable. It's powerful but not in your face. Onew has a quality of silence and resilience that shines through this song. I love it.
The ending comment is just so true. We love a good choreography but being able to just stand there and sing to draw people in just hits differently. I truly miss that about what Kpop is about now. I don't want an album full with songs where the choreography is the focus. I want ballads, emotions, stories,... That's why I love Onew and especially Shinee cause they give us that. I miss when title tracks didn't need a choreo to be a good song.
I have listened to this song exactly three times, and each time I have cried. His voice alone did it, then the lyrics, then just both because wow, Onew is amazing. I thought I'd be fine watching a reaction video but I still cried a little haha.
The song has that very Nostalgic feel. The song is very Onew like. I once heard someone say Onew uses his voice as an instrument so I like you trying to describe his voice with an instrumental. I will always say that this song is the closest thing to a Kpop + Gospel intersection I've heard.💙 So glad to hear you say that it has a Gospel-esque.
This song made me feel so many emotions. It's hard to put how much I love and appreciate it. The poetry if the lyrics with onews beautiful singing and the story filled MV... pure art. Top solo song of 2023
Omg! Thanks for the reaction. I appreciate the respect you have for k-pop artists. Like you said, it's not just dance or fashion, if you look hard you can find artists like Onew who can literally heal with his voice and convey a profound message. He makes it look easy but he has an incredible technique. PS: Umu, I'm waiting for your k-pop playlist 2023, ik CIRCLE will def be there ♡
We've been patiently waiting for this, FINALLY!!! Onew's VOICE is really something, and completely draws your attention for all the right reasons, as SHINee once said, Onew is SHINee's pride. Yes, he definitely is!
There's something in the lyrics, portraying the passage of time, with the seasons of the year, and it hit me the first time I listened to the song because that's the same figure BIGBANG used for their last song "봄여름가을겨울 (Still Life)", lyrics that are also in the chorus of "O (Circle)". But ONEW's voice is just transcendental, a happening in itself, and having him giving this kind of larger than life song it becomes just overwhelming. I loved having Jacob and Kayla Rae reacting to this song. Also Jason could have provided some philosophical insight, but usually Kayla Rae is just incredibly accurate in its way of explain emotions.
i'm glad i'm not the only one who drew the everything, everywhere all at once comparison!!! between the cinematography, the story of the music video, and the song itself, i mean... idk if onew (or the production team) intended for the film to be inspiration, but it pulls it off so WELL!!! and the song itself of course, did not disappoint!!
Thanks for the great reaction! I'm actually interested to know what they'd think seeing him perform the song *with* the choreography, because it's not standard K-pop choreo and definitely adds its own vibe to the song.
I've been waiting for your reactions since this song was first released. I totally agree with what you guys were talking about throughout the video. I can't wait for your reaction to the whole album.
I really love the comment about being able to attract a person, to draw someone without doing anything, and that is what onew is doing. He draws people in and it’s powerful. I really really liked that comment. I feel like it was perfectly put into words!
I love this song so much, and I adore this song so much. You worded this in a way that managed to express what I've been feeling since I first heard it. It is so powerful and I just felt so drawn to it. I think this song perfectly captures Onew and his voice, personality, and just essence as a performer. Thank you for reacting!!!!
I come to your channel in any yt acc I'm logged in to, but this time I'm subscribing! Thanks for taking the time to share your Circle experience and the SHINee bits. Plus the editing! just wow. I ⭕️ all of yous!
Thank you so much for doing this react. I was waiting bc you always have some good things and technical things to say and it’s so beautiful how SHINee can make all the experts in love with their work! Onew is a bless, and it was beautiful hear how he is artist from you guys. Thank you so much!
Thank you for providing such an interesting perspective! I really like the last feeling about powerful, and I think this can also explain why I can get so much comfort when I listen. Thank you, I hope everyone has a good day!
thank you! wow i would love for them to react to shinee vocals too especially when one of them was talking about classifying voices (ot5 would be ideal, but there are songs from the new album that also highlight the 4's voices/harmonies, especially onew's).
Is there any possibility that you guys can include a reaction of Onew recording the song? I watched it like 10 times already and would love to hear an analysis of it.
I will definitely say this brought me to tears, like it’s so soul full and I will really say that it’s definitely giving gospel worship vibes. The song that came to mine was grateful by hezekiah walker. And the walker gave it an extra pinch of salt and I’m here for it👏👏👏👏
Hello 〜〜😊 Thank you so 〜〜nice reaction to O！I’m huge fan of ONEW❣️ I agree with yours so much 👏👍 He looks calm,soft and kind…but not only that ！ His music is so strong in the bace 👍when all of the mixed …his singing goes brighting 〜🎶🐇🌸
Thank you! I always love & appreciate ReacttotheK reactions to SHINee because their music is truly appreciated the most by other artists. Always intelligent and insightful❤️ Onew’s vocals & Circle are art ❤️
Onew have a beautiful voice wether singing softly or powerful (i put him and daesung together).now do a reaction to the other talented shinee member (key )with his album gasoline. And also react to bts new songs they're all amazing.
"This is so satisfying to my ADHD-brain" YES GIRL! I don't often listen to ballads because they're too slow for my hyper brain, but Circle has been playing in my headphones and mind for weeks. It's satisfying my easily bored brain and yet it's also so calming. (And I don't like the cat either. 😅)
As Key and Taeyon said after hearing this - this is pure Onew. It suits him so much.
From where they talked about it?
"I wouldn't have wanted anyone else to sing that" After I first heard the song this was exactly my thought! It is just so Onew~ There are some songs where you can immediately pinpoint someone that would sound great singing it as well, and this is such a stunning example of one where that's not the case at all. So beautiful🥺
Actually, the music video director lost his cat recently, he commented that the message of this song reflected how he felt and helped him to accept his cat passing, thus he planned for the puppet to appear! I think it's beautiful how he added his own insight of the song to the music video and that he was comforted by the song, truly an example of what onew music means to a lot of us 🥰
I honestly thought the whole time I had first watched the mv that the cat was an owl and was shocked to find out it was a cat after watching the choreographer react to it and someone in the comment section mentions it was a cat.
I have thought unquestioningly until today that the puppet was a dog. And I kept wanting Onew to pet the dog, but if that was a cat…that perspective makes sense. Thank you.
It was actually not the music video director's cat but someone left comment about thier cat which the music director shared on their ig
@@minho_forever Yo what's the music director's IG?
@mangoo ^^^ this is true. director has a cat and loves cats but that comment was from a fan
ONEWS “Circle” album won Billboard’s best kpop album of 2023 (by the staff) LITERALLY THE MOST DESERVED!
I have been a SHINee fan since 2008. There is no other voice in the world like Onew's. It was such a pleasure to watch people's faces as they heard him sing for the first time. He is a very special man. Think of the animal this way. Most of us have a special stuffed animal that was part of our childhood. As we get older, it changes and becomes a bit more scruffy, but it is loved every bit as much.
I have a gray lamb similar to that cat. It's legs are very floppy. I think was white originally. Still has It's pink nose but it's a tiny, tiny nose. That lamb is a survivor, just like the cat ❤
@@lizsays3324 That is so sweet. I am sure the world is full of leftover friends who lived so much life with us.
This comment reminds me of the moving children's storybook The Velveteen Rabbit. Perfect. 😌
Onew's voice has always evoked warm golden caramel to me.
OMG I could taste it ❤
You could almost say it’s “Sweet like caramel” 🎵🎶 (get it just like caramel by giriboy and Onew from the album ahaha) 😂😂
Caramel chocolate ❤
For me Circle is like healing pill. It talk philosophy. And yeah.. pure art
I agree! It’s so liberating 😌
i agree!
"Eight Stories about eternity" cats are believed to have nine lives. The cat looks like that because he has, in fact like you suggested, seen everything over the course of his other eight lives, and I suppose he is telling his stories in his last one.
Wow.🥺
I didn't know that
When Umu spoke about her Mom not knowing it's SHINee singing until Onew sings is literally me with my parents. They're both singers and they love love love Onew's voice! Also, that avocado animation is so freaking cute!
this cat has seen every war 😭😂 loved kayla's point about the power of a performer who can pull you in without gimmicks or "doing" anything in particular, onew's voice alone has such a unique emotional draw (my mom also comments whenever onew sings in shinee songs LOL) and coupled with the calmness that jacob mentioned between the hectic string bits (that arguably mirror today's fast paced, info inundated society), circle mesmerizes you into introspection, appreciation, catharsis, harmony aka free therapy
i feel like this song is a masterpiece in itself, but what's stunning with onew's vocal is that, this song doesn't have that "big vocal moment" like high notes or the run, it's as the theme goes, more stable and tranquil throughout. and personally i think it's hard to pull off those kind of songs, only when the artist has a great voice/tone and a great control over it does it shine. and i agree, i wouldn't have wanted anyone else to sing this song
yesss that is Onew's power, standing there singing and making all of us emotional, literally crying
Many people don't appreciate real good voices and singers in kpop. People tend to think ALL kpop idols can sing just because they have debuted and even asking for more lines, but nah, that makes us underappreciate the ones who ARE really good singers.
he sang it live in his concert here, changed my life and he sounds like the same in the recording!!
This MV is overwhelming gorgeous and I thought Blue was a philosophical cinematic masterpiece.
When I was watching it for the first time as soon as the starting montage begun, I found myself getting a lump in my throat. I froze there and got teleported to a dream-like trance. It's real poetry and made me think about how Jinki is letting us in into a veryy personal emotional space.
It got me thinking of all the grief, loss, beauty unfairness and the inevitable end of life via an overwhelming amounts of emotions. I'm not convinced I understand what I felt in the moment and what I'm feeling right now as I'm writing this.
I guess that's what art does to you.
It all felt so divine. The quick frames and the countdown with the special effects made me feel like I was watching Dark (the show).
For me, this was an outer body/spiritual experience as if it had opened up my chest and exposed my very soul to me. Now I know why the whole of Nolto cast became Jinki devotees lmao.
There is something formidable about what he's expressing. Life, Death, Eternity and the laws of cyclical things are inevitable and will circle back whether you want it to or not, which can be both stifling and comforting. Circle is a kind of song that is made up of tapestry of emotions and it mirrors whatever that is you feel in the moment, which can be both grief or comfort. It connects and resonates with you.
Overall, this MV was very philosophical and healing but sometimes when you leap up into broader emotional landscape and read through the lyrics and give it's themes a shot it's so saddening too.
This whole album is a masterpiece and unlike anything you see in kpop. I expect a full album reaction from you guys.
when i first heard circle ( i'm new to shinee world just for context) i had a moment of catharsis, with the changing of seasons and the vocals of onew singing it, the lyrics and imagery all washed over me at once
Literally started SOBBING the first time i saw this mv and i still have no idea what came over me
When they were talking about instruments that describe his voice , I kept on thinking about his 'Caramel' mouth trumpet.
Emotions plus vocals. There's so much restraint and thought put into the MV and song it's unmissable. It's powerful but not in your face. Onew has a quality of silence and resilience that shines through this song. I love it.
I always appreciate hearing singers react to Onew's voice. He really is such a powerful singer/performer. Thanks for this one!
The choreography for Circle (you can find some music show performances) hit me in a way that nothing has since probably SHINee's Good Evening.
good evening choreo is next level
Both choreographies feel like art
The ending comment is just so true. We love a good choreography but being able to just stand there and sing to draw people in just hits differently. I truly miss that about what Kpop is about now. I don't want an album full with songs where the choreography is the focus. I want ballads, emotions, stories,... That's why I love Onew and especially Shinee cause they give us that. I miss when title tracks didn't need a choreo to be a good song.
Onew is the very best male vocalist in the whole kpop industry
I have listened to this song exactly three times, and each time I have cried. His voice alone did it, then the lyrics, then just both because wow, Onew is amazing. I thought I'd be fine watching a reaction video but I still cried a little haha.
The song has that very Nostalgic feel.
The song is very Onew like. I once heard someone say Onew uses his voice as an instrument so I like you trying to describe his voice with an instrumental.
I will always say that this song is the closest thing to a Kpop + Gospel intersection I've heard.💙
So glad to hear you say that it has a Gospel-esque.
Onew is a one of a kind artist and he's made us VERY proud with Circle. ❤ thank you
This song made me feel so many emotions. It's hard to put how much I love and appreciate it. The poetry if the lyrics with onews beautiful singing and the story filled MV... pure art. Top solo song of 2023
Omg! Thanks for the reaction. I appreciate the respect you have for k-pop artists. Like you said, it's not just dance or fashion, if you look hard you can find artists like Onew who can literally heal with his voice and convey a profound message. He makes it look easy but he has an incredible technique.
PS: Umu, I'm waiting for your k-pop playlist 2023, ik CIRCLE will def be there ♡
We've been patiently waiting for this, FINALLY!!!
Onew's VOICE is really something, and completely draws your attention for all the right reasons, as SHINee once said, Onew is SHINee's pride.
Yes, he definitely is!
really interesting when he mentioned about describing voice with instrument when onew did mouth trumpet in this album😁
Ending comment is literally me when SHINee sing ballads. I feel proud of Onew
There's something in the lyrics, portraying the passage of time, with the seasons of the year, and it hit me the first time I listened to the song because that's the same figure BIGBANG used for their last song "봄여름가을겨울 (Still Life)", lyrics that are also in the chorus of "O (Circle)". But ONEW's voice is just transcendental, a happening in itself, and having him giving this kind of larger than life song it becomes just overwhelming. I loved having Jacob and Kayla Rae reacting to this song. Also Jason could have provided some philosophical insight, but usually Kayla Rae is just incredibly accurate in its way of explain emotions.
Kim Eana is an amazing lyricist, there is a lot of her work out there if you wan more 😊
One of the best tracks in 2023 already
Jinki has an incredible voice and this song is art.
The way you describe Onew's voice as a mix between French Horn and flugelhorn is somehow accurate.
Onew was made for this song and it was made for him.
Also, did you notice that he is aging in reverse?!?!!!
The cat could represent what the poet Baudelaire writes in Le Spleen de Paris in his poem “L’Horloge” where the eye of the cat shows the Eternity.
Thank you for showing them this mv, it's so great to see Onew get the praise he deserves ^^
Amazing commentary ❤ Onew is really impressive. The way his singing evokes so many emotions 😭
Loved you guys' reaction! Hoping to see the reaction for the album as well, you guys won't be disappointed 😉
i'm glad i'm not the only one who drew the everything, everywhere all at once comparison!!! between the cinematography, the story of the music video, and the song itself, i mean... idk if onew (or the production team) intended for the film to be inspiration, but it pulls it off so WELL!!! and the song itself of course, did not disappoint!!
The comments about Onew’s power to draw people in…so spot on ❤
Yes! I’m so excited you reacted to Circle!
omg thankyou for this reactionnnnn
His voice is really so beautiful
Thanks for the great reaction! I'm actually interested to know what they'd think seeing him perform the song *with* the choreography, because it's not standard K-pop choreo and definitely adds its own vibe to the song.
i loveeee this song so much and his entire album is gorgeous ❤❤
waaaaaw thank you thank you sooo much for reacting to Onew!! i love Circle so much 😭😍
Coming back here to see Onew praises 🩵
Same .. That is Onew's superpower.
I've been waiting for your reactions since this song was first released. I totally agree with what you guys were talking about throughout the video. I can't wait for your reaction to the whole album.
I really love the comment about being able to attract a person, to draw someone without doing anything, and that is what onew is doing. He draws people in and it’s powerful. I really really liked that comment. I feel like it was perfectly put into words!
I love this song so much, and I adore this song so much. You worded this in a way that managed to express what I've been feeling since I first heard it. It is so powerful and I just felt so drawn to it. I think this song perfectly captures Onew and his voice, personality, and just essence as a performer. Thank you for reacting!!!!
wait until you listen Caramel, he did lip trumpet by himself 😁😁😁 Love your reaction as always thank u Umu, kayla and Jacob
YESSS I WAS HOPING YOU'D DO THIS SONG!!
In later years i hope "SM CLASSICS" does a rendition.
I was a bit iffy at first with the yawning but I love how hey just snap into focus and come alive the moment the song started 0:44
Lol mte 😂 they snapped indeed
thank you so much
Onew singing a ballad will always hit 😭😭
With lyrics by Kim Eana ^^
I come to your channel in any yt acc I'm logged in to, but this time I'm subscribing! Thanks for taking the time to share your Circle experience and the SHINee bits. Plus the editing! just wow. I ⭕️ all of yous!
His voice reminds me of Joey McIntyre's from New Kids on the Block. I was a massive Joey fan :)
I literally was just listening to this song when I saw that this was posted
So proud of Jinki
Loved the reaction. As classical vocalists, I think they would appreciate Onew's performance of Nessun Dorma.
Thank you so much for doing this react. I was waiting bc you always have some good things and technical things to say and it’s so beautiful how SHINee can make all the experts in love with their work! Onew is a bless, and it was beautiful hear how he is artist from you guys. Thank you so much!
Thankyou been waiting for this 🥹
Thank you for providing such an interesting perspective! I really like the last feeling about powerful, and I think this can also explain why I can get so much comfort when I listen. Thank you, I hope everyone has a good day!
Thank you for this wonderful reaction
thank you! wow i would love for them to react to shinee vocals too especially when one of them was talking about classifying voices (ot5 would be ideal, but there are songs from the new album that also highlight the 4's voices/harmonies, especially onew's).
Finally.. Finally.. So excited you made this video.. Thank youuu..
I'm genuinely surprised the name Philip Glass didn't come up. When I heard the opening he was the first thing that came to mind.
tysm for reacting onew-circle❤❤
Onew tiene una voz maravillosa. Puede cantar lo que sea, y siempre lo hace bien 😊
niiiiiiiiiiiiice hope you react to his whole album 🥰
Is there any possibility that you guys can include a reaction of Onew recording the song? I watched it like 10 times already and would love to hear an analysis of it.
I will definitely say this brought me to tears, like it’s so soul full and I will really say that it’s definitely giving gospel worship vibes. The song that came to mine was grateful by hezekiah walker. And the walker gave it an extra pinch of salt and I’m here for it👏👏👏👏
Hello 〜〜😊
Thank you so 〜〜nice reaction to O！I’m huge fan of ONEW❣️
I agree with yours so much 👏👍
He looks calm,soft and kind…but not only that ！
His music is so strong in the bace 👍when all of the mixed …his singing goes brighting 〜🎶🐇🌸
I love hearing from the vocalists since I was one in college!
I expect your onew full album reaction. Please.
This is the best song ever ❤❤❤ and Onew is the best singer.
Thank you for this!
The song is so goood 💜😫
Thank you! I always love & appreciate ReacttotheK reactions to SHINee because their music is truly appreciated the most by other artists. Always intelligent and insightful❤️ Onew’s vocals & Circle are art ❤️
OMGGGGG YAAAAS I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THISSSSS
great video thank u so much!!
Onew have a beautiful voice wether singing softly or powerful (i put him and daesung together).now do a reaction to the other talented shinee member (key )with his album gasoline.
And also react to bts new songs they're all amazing.
Circle을 듣고 “일시정지”상태가 되는건 만국공통이군요..ㅎㅎ
True 😅
"This is so satisfying to my ADHD-brain"
YES GIRL! I don't often listen to ballads because they're too slow for my hyper brain, but Circle has been playing in my headphones and mind for weeks. It's satisfying my easily bored brain and yet it's also so calming. (And I don't like the cat either. 😅)
please react to the whole album if possible. thanks!
Please do expectations or no parachute from this album!
Esta canción de Onew limpia el alma🥲. Su voz te lleva al cielo. Este es el gran líder de SHINee💎💎💎💎💎
마지막 코멘트 진짜 공감합니다! 그게 아티스트 온유의 면모이지요❤
“This is like art”
Literally all of SHINee: A R T
ONEW is great!!!!
I love how everyone reacts to the cat😂
its giving phillip glass koyanisqatsi vibes. the arpegios and the visuals for me.
The eeao referance.. he gets it😭!!!
o comentário final foi lindo demais ❤
i hope you guys would react to Onew’s post sm releases!