Classical Musicians React: SHINee 'Sherlock' vs 'Married to the Music'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ม.ค. 2017
- For the 13th video of this series, classical music majors react to SHINee!
Because SHINee's music is copyrighted, some people won't be able to view on mobile. So if it isn't loading for you, try watching on your computer!
I will now be starting to release this series sometimes once a week and sometimes twice. When I feel like 2 songs should be compared, they will be published in 1 reaction video on Monday. Other times, they will appear in their own video where one will be released Monday and the other one on Thursday.
I will be showing more SHINee MVs in the future: Lucifer, Ring Ding Dong, View, Dream Girl, Why So Serious, Everybody and Tell Me What To Do. I will not be showing them 1 of 1 since it's melody is so similar to married to the music.
Reaction video release dates:
1/16 MAMAMOO IS2 (Part 1) (Wait a Minute and Flying Deep into the Night)
1/19 MAMAMOO IS2 VOCALISTS REACT (Part 1) (Wait a Minute and Flying Deep into the Night)
1/19 BAP One Shot
1/23 Seventeen (Adore U)
1/25 Seventeen (Very Nice)
1/30 BEAST (Breathe)
2/1 BEAST (Fiction)
2/6 AKMU (Re Bye)
2/8 AKMU (Melted)
2/13 Big Bang (Fxxk it)
2/15 Big Bang (Last Dance)
2/20 EXO (Growl & Call Me Baby)
2/27 VIXX (HYDE & GR8U)
3/6-9 BTS HYYH (I Need You, Prologue, Run, Young Forever)- coming out on 4 separate, consecutive days
? INFINITE (The Chaser & The Eye)
? BLACKPINK (Playing With Fire & Stay)
? K.will Please don't...
Twice (Ooh Aah & Cheer Up)
IU (Red Shoes & You&I)
NCT U (7th Sense & Without U)
Super Junior (Mamacita & Swing)
Red Velvet (Ice Cream Cake & Automatic)
2NE1 (Come Back Home & Missing You)
....etc:
PLEASE check out this link for a longer list of the MVs i'll be showing my friends: • Playlist
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank you to everyone who is commenting with suggestions. The more requests I get for a group/song, the higher up on my to-watch list they will become.
HOWEVER, if it's a recent song from one my bias groups, (like Blood, Sweat & Tears, Decalcomanie, or Fantasy, those won't be shown until they've watched the groups' older songs so they can see them grow musically!)
Thumbnail credits to Nozomi Murayama (@nonchanyuzuru)
For channel updates and sneak peeks of reactions, follow my twitter: emcha
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram and twitter: @_emcha_
TH-cam (Kpop covers): EMCHA
Tumblrs: kpop-instrumental-covers.tumbl...
/ omg-horns
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Jenny
Tumblrs: / classic-jenny
/ beijingboi
Davis:
Instagram: @davisherndon9664
Kevin:
TH-cam: nerdymusicks
Shimon:
Instagram: @shimonohi
Leah:
Instagram: @leahlovesthesun13
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that.This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music. - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![[C.C] Key and Taeyeon think of the beautiful memory with Jonghyun #SHINEE #KEY](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vad27IQEVYo/mqdefault.jpg)
"SHINee is really weird." girl you don't know the half of it 😌😅
Born To SHINee they're clearly unaware of Ring ding dong's existence
Born To SHINee True
Taemin eats strange things.
th-cam.com/video/Ff-XAmZFQPM/w-d-xo.html this video just shows you how weird they are lmao
Shimon talked about the video, I cant believe it
Lara Mirley 😂😂😂
Lara Mirley ikr!
Lara Mirley haha same xD
he just usually * nods in approval * xD
Lara Mirley You can't just not talk about SHINee, Shimon is proof of that 😂
"SHINee is really weird"
SHAWOLs: IF YOU ONLY KNEW. 😂😂😂
Jonghyun really was married to the music, Rest In Peace angel~
"marriage is a slow death"
Homeboy thats always eating is my favourite. He seems super chill to be around.
Heather Deckers Shimon
He's like the most loved one XD
Shimon is cool xD
I thought the same thing. He's always eating when watching the kpop vids. lol
eh, he's hot but always seems bored and uninterested. it's annoying/boring to watch someone who shows no reaction in a reaction video.
Same, Shimon reminds me of a Pokémon idk if it's just me or... 😂
Jenny and Kevin: Talking about the music and chords and all that stuff (idek)
Leah and Shimon: "I like his voice" ... **slightly starts to nod**
Hahahaha I can't stop laughing at the "It's Henry violin, we found it" hahahahahahhahahahahhaa
I had to pause the video for a while
"SHINee's weird" .......we all know this.
jeffrey is weird yeah. And that's becuz they're unique asf 😂💖
no-more-paper-towels-move comment got me!!! literally lol!
me too, love their comments xD
that's like, one of the few dance moves i can follow on this song, and it won't be the same again after this comment lmao
lelmdrWHO lmfao me too 😂😂😂
lelmDR.WHO? 😂
me too! I always loved that part, but I'm always gonna think of this comment now when I see the mv again xD
I need a mukbang where shimon just eats and watched kpop music videos xD
Raz 7 I need that too 😂😂
that would be a really good idea!!!
I'd actually love to see a second set of Shinee reactions. These guys have some GREAT music. There's a reason that they're iconic.
Kevin: "that had a big impact, that will be remembered" he's totally right
"Shinee is really weird" ahah I love that they always have new concepts :))
ahahah "SHINee's really weird." YES they are complete dorks 😂😂
Tatty_Eternal lol when she said that I was like you have no idea.
"SHINee is really weird!" this why I'm so into them 😂😂
GREAT!!! Shinee is a must hear kpop group, for me one of the most vocally talented and always trying different music genres with success. Because they are so talented performing live I hope some day you can share with your friends some of their live performances like "Evil" from their third concert SWIII or "Stranger". Onew's Nessum Dorma can be of their interest to.
You should have mentioned that Sherlock is a hybrid song! It's a mix and match of the songs Clue and Note!
I shall petition for a whole series of just SHINee reaction
Don't worry Lindsey there's more disappearing girls -Jay
"casual decapitation" really cracked me up, idk why 😂😂😂
did they understand that at the end of married to the music, she put their face pieces together and made that random guy that show up at the end? lol
although i still don't understand what she used from minho...his body maybe?
セーラーグール / Sailor Ghoul yes a hot body 😂😂
セーラーグール / Sailor Ghoul she used minhos body, onews nose, keys head, taemins eyes, and jonghyuns mouth
jbest2514 i knew all that, i was just making sure if she used minho's body lol
セーラーグール / Sailor Ghoul Isn't she the representation of fans, well saesangs mainly, who complain at any normal/personal interaction idols have and that's why they're "married to the music". And yeah the pick and choose things to objectify, hence why the different bits being taken from the members.
Hobis K.A.R.D InfiredJams huh, never thought of it that way lol
The reason why I love Sherlock (and many SM songs in general) so much is because the chorus doesn't go where I think it will go. And those thicc harmonies, BRUH.
To give some explanation on the plot of the second music video, the guy we see at the end of the video is a combination of all the body parts the members had lost. He has Key's head (hair, ears, bone structure), Taemin's eyes, Onew's nose, Jonghyun's mouth and Minho's body. The girl we see on the bed cutting some things is the one who stole everything to combine all of their body parts to make the guy we see in the end. I don't know how it's related to title of the song tho.
probably like frankenstein and she's combining all their body parts to make her ideal husband
"I LIKE HIS VOICE" yas! I love his voice and i love jonghyun so much. Rest in peace our angel
That's why Shimon rarely talks
Because everytime he does, he will say something smart and that will blow our minds.
(Seriously I still love him. #1 Fan)
Am I the only one who can see this in mobile?
Chuunihan :3 I can XD
Chuunihan :3 me too.
Chuunihan :3 Same
Lucky you, i had to open my laptop just to see the reaction cause I really want to see it.
This might be selfish to request but... do you think you could do a special episode reacting to Jonghyun? ;___;
madstrawberrypie yes please 😖
madstrawberrypie yes a live performance
like Y Si Fuera Ella live performance. that was superb
madstrawberrypie yes
oh my god yes please
I guess i prefer when they talk more about the song, but I can understand their reaction to the videos bocose shinee's videos are so good
Im so glad they finally reacted to SHINee! I knew they would like them! And btw Kevin and Leah is me when i listen to SHINee and Fiona is me when i see Minho lmao
Thank you for posting!💖
I wanted to hug Fiona when I saw her face when Minho popped up. LOVE!
you should totally have them react to onew's cover to Nessum Dorma. Onew is one of the vocalist in this group
It's on their schedule!
Jeannette311 oh yeah thank you!
AHHH i replied in the wrong place, haha! It's not on the schedule for Onew, but I agree! Sorry about the confusion!!
Jeannette311 oh no worries you were right about k wills though, although there's a question mark I'll presume it'll most likely happen
I told my daughter they were doing that one and she almost cried. Such an incredibly emotional MV!
2:58 "I like his voice" made me happy hearing that, he was so talented and it's lovely hearing people appreciate him. :)
I'm not even a violinist but the way Taemin holds the violin made me cringe to death as a shawol 😂😂
I AM a violinist and I had to look away to avoid the cringe 😂 the longer I watch, the more problems I see xD I love Taemin, but just... no xD
@@codexone2194 ikr 😂 he probably would do some research if they were to shoot the mv today, he's a perfectionist now hehe
Wow, I think this is the longest Shimon has spoken in any video so far. I like him and Leah together. I'm wondering if you told any of them about how Sherlock was actually two songs spliced together. I was wondering if they were going to notice that but they were all so into the music video. Both of them which is different than usual. Everybody seemed so captivated by what was going on in both videos and not noticing the music as much. Or at least not critiquing it as much. Not a bad thing just interesting to note.
I think it would be cool to have them react to more Korean Americans like Ailee, Jay Park and Eric Nam, to see how the musical influences may be different. Also, those are all soloists so that would be interesting too.
redlady4 The song is actually two songs??
So interesting to see their reactions to the chorus in Sherlock, as it is a mash up of 2 songs, and it throws people off. Especially if you have trained ears I'm sure.
i want them to react to shinee's view as well.
Totally agreed
"I like his voice" ahh now I want to cry.
and that was the cherry on top of my birthday!
my favourite reactors reacting to my ultimate favourite band ..SHINee..
THANKYOUUUUU!!! best birthday gift from youtube.. after jimins log! :))
and no you are not a true shawol unltil u get the capitals and small letters right while writing SHINee
Asian PrincesS_Amy happy birthday :)
Am I the only one triggered when people write it as SHINEE or Shinee? Lol
Happy birthday btw!
Shimon kinda reminds me of Mark Tuan and Mark from nct 🙊
Am I the only one who sees Taecyeon in him? Except that he's smaller & not so hunky haha
timiniho from 2pm, right?
timiniho ohh yes you're right 😰 & Teacyeon is such a sweetheart 😍
Anna Henning yes he is, OMG now I need to go and watch again "gi crazy" dance practice, is like the best thing ever xD
AyAReI00 😂😂😂
It would be very interesting to how these guys would find Jonghyun's self-composed solos and taemin's experimental/performance based solo releases
"They didn't lose their ears. See, I'm onto something." Me: *is shook*
it's always so entertaining seeing them decipher the background track lmao
ANYWAYS
SHINee YEEEEEE MY FAVS WOOO
WHERE MY FELLOW SHAWOLS AT
I love the reactors and also love SHINee. 😂 I've been waiting for this. Thank you!💜
Is it too much to ask for a next time? 🙊 where you show off their amazing vocals?
I enjoyed watching this!! can't wait for more shinee reactions!
"I like his voice".... Jonghyun ):
Now that I listen to this song again, it sounds so much like 1 of 1.
same exact key, same exact melody. -Umu
Jinny Gui oh shit u right
I cannot unhear that now!!
The first time I heard I thought that. So every time I tried to sing along I sang the wrong song 😂
Xx1midnightcry1xX
SAME. I always end up singing "married to the music! 1 of 1 girrll~" -Umu
'no its called married to the music'
'it says marriage is a slow death'
'its calLLED MARRIED TO THE MUSIC'
I'm so excited and I can't wait for the B.A.P video!
I can't believe I didn't stumble onto your channel before today, this was cool to watch.
Omg i waited for this moment since you began the reaction series!!!!!!!!!!
If you are unable to watch this video on mobile, try watching it on computer. explanation in description...so sorry guys!
(also I did tell them that Sherlock was a mashup of two songs but off camera ehehe)
(and nope they didn't realize the gal was using shinee to combine the "perfect" man, but after seeing comments i let them all know :3) -Umu
ReacttotheK please react to of day6 please do a part reaction of they🙏🙏🙏
ReacttotheK React to Fx four walls and Red light
React to NCT 7th sense! Or f(x) 4walls.
ReacttotheK React to Oh Na Na by K.A.R.D :D
Yes to red light, but not 4walls (not that different from View and dull). React to Rum Pum Pum Pum; it's... "different" sounding when compared to other contemporary pop songs
Shimon is eating, thats new xD
"Everything is a slow death" 6:45... those 2 are my spirit animals :v
I really like that song 셜록. I espeically love voice of JoungHyun. Hope he got peace in heaven. R.I.P. 😢😭
Oh my, i couldn't watch this video before, i'm so happy i can now !!
SHINee are legends and these songs are such bops and always will be
I'm seriously diggin the no more paper towel dance
they're so funny! are you going to do another one with SHINee? Maybe throw some Tell me what to do at them? and one of the earlier SHINee songs?
Or Taemin solo ^^
I'm pretty sure they will do more SHINee! There's a whole list ov MS that she has linked and there's more SHINee in there. :)
I seriously love this channel though the reactions are so hilarious
I really love these videos! Thank you all so much! I can't wait for the HYYH!
thank you for this!.I read your description why wouldn't you want to show them 1 of 1 and lucifer for reactions?.they're so good..oh could you also do everybody please.
ReacttotheK ah ok I see what you mean..I appreciate you letting them react to SHINee tho!..lol I love it when non fans react..and ok cool.do you think they wouldn't like everybody as well?
Alondra R
I hope they'll like it! I added it to the reaction list but need to run it by a few musicians before deciding for sure. i'm leaning towards a yes ;) -Umu
ReacttotheK ok awesome!!.I'll look forward to their reaction..so far they've been really cool and funny.
I was gonna ask the same question :) Thank you for your answer +ReacttotheK ^-^
Alondra R change of plan!!! kevin's very pumped to analyze Lucifer... I quote "Lucifer is fucking amazing, please do it" -Umu
thank God for SHINee
My god, they never fail to amaze me. I love these reactors xD
is shimon any body else's favourite??:)
euphy Dil my fav!
euphy Dil mine😁😁😁
He's adorable and so dam relatable
Thanks for the reaction! Please do more SHINee reactions next! Maybe even some live shows!
Thank you so much for this reaction :3
I was wondering if you could show ReacttotheK team SHINee's lives ? I mean when I'm listening to picasso or lucifer lives, color of the seasons, odd eye ... I'm getting goose bumps -! __ !-
I really enjoy your channel anyway~ keep going, fighting !
ruckiie so true...live SHINee is so good!
ruckiie oh god, please react to Evil live, Picasso live, Like a fire live, Odd eye live.
This just makes me sad now
I really enjoyed this reaction and I'm happy that reactions to Infinite and Super Junior are planned as well!
!! THE REACTORS AAGGH THEY WERE SO GREAT. IM GLAD THEY WERE INTO SHINEE. Everyone please love SHINee :')
yeeeees now Im patiently waiting for SHINee part2 xD
Never seen this channel before but liked this video. Thanks for the reaction vid, would have liked to see more of their thoughts on what's going on musically in the songs since their musicians :)
Did anyone else catch the reference "it's Henry's violin " Ohhh ok I guess it just me
I've been waiting for this!!! I love your react videos!!!!!
omg Shimon spoke like 4 sentences such a improvement GOOD JOB 👏👏👏😂😂😂
i love this reaction series!! and i'm so happy that theres finally Red Velvet in the description, they're like my ultimate bias girl group, so thank you for that. Keep up the good work :D
love the reactions btw!!
"shinee's weird." yup, straight to the point 👍
i love how they pretty much always concentrate on the music more than on the video but then mttm comes on and everyone goes "what the actual heck is going on" :D
that moment when jenny said calling them pretty was like redundant .. i was like.. yep.. you reached that point where calling kpop artists handsome is so dumb.. cos thats like saying the orange is soo orange.. hahaha..
get me?
okay sorry...
I srsly started tearing up during that “Shinee’s Back” cause NOW they’ll never really be back 😞but still amazing reaction✨
SHINee...😭 We miss you Jonghyun
2:29 I've listened to Sherlock so many times I was like "where else could it possibly go?" I can't imagine it sounding any other way.
thank you so much for your reaction!!!!
PLEASE DO MORE SHINee SONGS!!!
View MV
SHINee in the House (KCON LA)
JoJo (concert video)
Excuse Me Miss (concert video)
(the concert videos by Winnie Chen)
Orgel too!
Omg I'm obsessed with these people. I'm binge watching all of the videos. I have a Spanish speaking assessment tomorrow but I'm watching these.
thanks for reacting to SHINee
"There's no more paper towels move" X'D
I laughed too hard at this video. Their reactions are wayyyy to funny...I’m tearing up. 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
i hope you show them day6 in the future
아니 이 양반들ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지금은 뮤비가 암만 와장창거려도 음악만 분석하는 음악처돌이들인데 ㅠ 지금은 뮤비 겁나 열심히 봐 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Shimon: you know what you should get married to? A saxophone.
her: EEWWWWWWWWW
most accurate reaction to that ever. (I'm a saxophone player)
love your reaction!!! rewatch this again.. heheh.. hope you guys can react to more SHINee's song.. Like A Fire live version is definitely worth it.. hihi.. anyway, love you guys.. thank you for spending time doing all this..
I'm absolutely loving this classical musicians thing I've just discovered. @Creator(s), DAMN THIS IS THE BEST KPOP REACT EVER. So much more objective. So much more analytical. So much more hilarious. This is brilliant.
**notifs on** I WANT MOREEEEE
Also, Shimon is hilarious. Thanks for being like this
And I haven't quite caught the names of the guy and girl who ALWAYS talk of chords and chord progressions, but I enjoy watching their reactions so much omg love
THANKS FAM YOUR COMPLIMENTS GIVE ME LIFE AND FUEL ME TO CONTINUE ON WITH MUCH PASSION OvO -Umu
Hi! How about SHINee's Ballads since there's more emotion and flavor to the music.. Close the door or an encore? :) Thank you for putting SHINee on your list
Shinee is one of those groups who are just better live that studio version. They are so good live
The editing is fucking hilarious. I love how it'll just zoom in on faces; your friends must really love you if they let you put their funny faces out to the world, lol
yeah man we're fam. they let me do whatever I want...and love it too xD -Umu
I go back to this video time and again. It's just so hilarious and fun, how they react to these weird shinee MVs hahahaha lovett
Could you please react to TAEMIN’s PRESS YOUR NUMBER and DRIP DROP? (Trivia: Bruno Mars produced Press Your Number. He even has a demo). Please, thank you! (And if you could add TAEMIN’S SAYONARA HITORI AND DANGER, THAT WOULD BE LOVELY!) THANK YOU SO MUCH AND MORE POWER TO Y’ALL ♥
please
"there's no more paper towel" move I'm-
Two of my most favorite Shinee songs!!!
The piano duo are the best, I just love their interactions, they are so cool.👌👍
I suggest you watch the live versions of SHINee songs. They tend to add a lot more vocal riffs and such to their songs. MttM had a really good live on MbcKpop I believe. I really enjoyed this. I hope you listen to more of their songs (especially non-title songs) and consider reacting for us. Great job!!
"I like his voice" refers to jonghyun. It's sad but we can't hear his voice again. Never
morryyy but we have his life to remember. His music and voice are still out there, we can still hear him. Maybe not live again, maybe no new songs, but we still have his memories
True! I've never had the chance to get deep into their music and his vocals... One of my regrets !!
I would love to see Lucifer vs Ring Ding Dong. I love these guys reactions! :D