The way Mr. choreographer silently sing along to the song i can tell his sincerity that he like the song! I love the way he explain about his reaction to the mv! Thank youu for the reaction and yes for the choreography, it really suit onew!
I always say on my comment in every music show that Circle choreography is magnificent. It really complimented the magnificent voice of Onew. I'm glad to see the master behind the choreography. Congrats to both of you dance Master and Onew.
이번 온유 앨범 수록곡 중 Anywhere 작사가분께서도 가사 쓰시면서 생각한 제스처가 안무에 그대로 나와서 신기하다고 온유 콘서트 후기에서 말씀해주셨는데 안무가님께서도 생각하셨던 이미지가 뮤비 감독님과 일치하셨다니 진짜 창작하는 분들은 생각이 비슷한가봐요... 신기하다
It's so interesting to see how Youngjun interpreted MV! It's cool how he and the MV director had the image of a ladder to the sky when listening to the song and wanted to incorporate it in their respective works. You can tell that Youngjun loved working on the choreography for Circle. It's a unique, profound song and it can be tricky to portray through dance; and he did an amazing job!! He seems to genuinely love the song and was awed by the MV since he had to replay it over and over :') anyway thank you for your hard work, Jinki and Youngjun! ❤
Yes omg his image of a prince climbing up to the sky and looking down on earth... I love how he managed to incorporate that with the eye formation at the beginning with jinki at the centre and then at the climax where the dancers kind of lift him up so he looks like he's floating?? And jinki just wandering around the stage was so theatrical, I hope they get to work again in the future 🤞🏽🤞🏽
일단 안무가 선생님은 신이십니다.. 처음 무대보고 됐다 했어요. 섬세한 터치, 흐름, 입체감 시간감각... 마치 타임랩스로 보는 세상 같았어요. 안무가 노래가 가진 기품을 절대 해치지 않고 오히려 더 끌어올려 주는 신기한 경험을 했어요. 그리고 편집하시고 자막 다시는 선생님께선 모르시는 게 없네요. 샤파고..
When i hear this song, i get goosebumps. When i watch Onew perform it with the choreography, i get goosebumps. Thank you for the your choreograph, it's very beautiful.
I really enjoyed this reaction, thanks for being honest and I think you feel the same as Shawol feel, at least I could see his reaction on the same places as I did. Ofc I agree, Onew is the Charming Prince! I found this reaction very satisfactory and I can relate with it. I can feel the choreographer becoming in Shawol. Thanks for Onew's support. The choreography was great I enjoyed it a lot, for me was like the sensation of a play in a theater so I related it with Onew's scene on the scenario. Thanks and claps to Onew and his choreographer.
Great reaction video. Loved the creative perspective of someone who worked on a separate aspect of Circle. You did a great job with the choreo! It has a lovely, dream-like feeling to it.
Actually each set,each outfit and each verse can be interpreted differently if you put them in different sequence. And each interpretation can give different feel. What I love the most is sincerity in his voice. Thank you for the reaction video and supporting Onew in your own way!
why is the choreographer so nice!!! all the compliments make me feel so happy for Onew to be surrounded by not only such excellent professionals but also nice people!
This is the best MV reaction I've ever watched! I just agree with EVERYTHING he said! He's so talented too for creating such a beautiful choreography! Thank you so so so much 🩷
콘서트에서 처음 써클 라이브 퍼포먼스를 접했을때의 그 소름 돋는 감동은 말로 표현할 수 없었고 온몸이 마비되고 숨도 못 쉴 정도였는데 할 수만 있다면 안무가님을 위해 리액션 해드리고싶을 정도!! 창작자의 애정과 고민이 가득한 뮤비 리액션 그 어떤 누구의 리뷰보다 소중하고 감사합니다!!
He put a lot of thought in this reaction i appreciate a lot! Also i can tell he has heard the song so much because he sings along with the adlibs😂 this is one of the most enjoyable and interesting mv reactions i've watched thank you for this❤
As this song has so many meanings it was nice to hear the choreographer-nim feedback on the mv .....can see how big of an art circle is every time i see the mv and performances
I think this is the best reaction vid on the SHINee channel! Thank you so much Choreographer Youngjun!! Actually, I was hoping to see something like a choreo draft etc because I looove the performance for Circle too. I’m glad I got to hear a little about his thoughts from this video!
the description and some stories behind the work make it more precious, the meaning of circle itself maybe different for some people but I love how the creators got same ideas. CIRCLE DAEBAK FOREVER ONEW FIGHTING
The choreography is AMAZING! Thank you so much for working on it and not giving up. The performance goes perfectly with the song and it suits Onew so much! The dance team was amazing too! I couldn't imagine how the song would be choreographed, but it ended up beyond perfect. Thank you thank you thank you!
the most wholesome reaction video i've ever seen. seriously, his review is so satisfying because he mention every aspect as a professional. youngjun-ssi, thank you for your choreography. thank you for your hard work! 🙇♀️
It so nice to hear his interpretation of the music video. You can see he's really into it which made the video very fun to watch. The music video and the song is really quite something. It has so many artistic elements but it somehow was able to keep its simplicity and genuineness.
I don't think any choreography would been better than this one. When you watch the performance, every movement and hand flick feel like it has a meaning that you have to focus on, it's really beautiful and meaningful ⭕❤️⭕❤️
I love that Onew got to work with a choreographer who is obviously very passionate about his work. The result was great. I love his choreography for this song.
fatia and aqsar have watched the MV circle, it's good the MV is good the circle song is good the songs on the circle album are all good fatia and aqsar always support oppa onew ☺️😊☺️☺️☺️😊☺️☺️☺️😊😊☺️😊😊😊😊
'the prince vibes suit him so well' ... BUT OF COURSE!!! HE's THE ONE AND ONLY CROWN PRINCE OF SOUTH KOREA MY FRIEND. THE MOST GORGEOUS MAN TO EVER BEEN BORN IN KOREAN SOIL... nothing less😎❤️
오ㅏ 이렇게 정성스런 리액션영상이라니…. 컷마다 세심히 코멘트 해주시는 것도 너무 좋지만 안무가님 일에 대한 열정과 사랑이 엿보여서 보면서 입꼬리가 계속 올라갔어요 :) 큰 애정으로 힘써주셔서인지 써클 안무 곡과 진기랑 너무 잘어울리더라구요 ! 유려한 … 왕자님의 산책… 하늘 위에서 세상을 구경하는 … ❤️
Thank you for the reaction, it good to see pov from the choreographer and he keep praising onew so i feel even more happy❤ I hope there will be reaction from kim eana as the lyricist also if can, i hope someone who has vocal teaching skill or vast knowledge about vocal to do reaction for circle so i could know their opinion about onew vocal and singing technique
와 안무 영준님이 만드셨구나..........어떻게 이 음악에 저런 퍼포가 나올 수 있는건지 진짜 놀랐는데 안무가가 탑이었네....
맞습니다 이진기는 왕자가 맞습니다
JinKi*
The way Mr. choreographer silently sing along to the song i can tell his sincerity that he like the song!
I love the way he explain about his reaction to the mv! Thank youu for the reaction and yes for the choreography, it really suit onew!
콘서트에서 처음 무대 공개됐을 때 말씀하신 특유의 숭고한 분위기 때문에 샤월들이 응원봉도 못흔들 정도로 숨죽여 집중해서 봤던 것 같아요 찰떡 같은 멋진 안무 만들어주셔서 감사합니다! 개인적으로 댄서분들이 온유 위로 들어올리는? 부분 특히 좋아해요
콘서트에서 무대 처음 보고 너무 놀랐어요.. 웅장하고.. 숭고하고.. 뭉클하고.. 그때의 감정을 잊을수가 없어요ㅠㅠ 써클에 어울리는 멋진 안무 만들어주셔서 넘 감사합니다 영준쌤!!
저도 콘서트에서 안무와 연출보고 일시정지 상태였어요. 마스크 안에서 입벌리고 봤어요. 써클무대 정말 멋졌습니다!!!
콘서트를 언제했지
Lucky
I always say on my comment in every music show that Circle choreography is magnificent. It really complimented the magnificent voice of Onew. I'm glad to see the master behind the choreography. Congrats to both of you dance Master and Onew.
맞아요 온유도 언급했듯이 작사가와 안무가분들이 서로 뭔가 대화도 안 나누고 공유한 적은 없지만 비슷한 이미지로 비슷한 디렉팅을 해주셨다고!! ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 너무 신기하고 진짜 써클이 좋은 작품이라는 걸 느끼게 해주는 대목 :)
이번 온유 앨범 수록곡 중 Anywhere 작사가분께서도 가사 쓰시면서 생각한 제스처가 안무에 그대로 나와서 신기하다고 온유 콘서트 후기에서 말씀해주셨는데
안무가님께서도 생각하셨던 이미지가 뮤비 감독님과 일치하셨다니 진짜 창작하는 분들은 생각이 비슷한가봐요... 신기하다
칭찬 감옥 이다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 와 안무 짜기 너무 어려울것 같고 힘들거 같았는데 무대보고 진짜 잘어울려서 감탄했는데 안무 진짜 최고였어요
내가 본 리액션 중에 단연 최고
참 이번에 보다보면 온유 주위에 그를 아끼고 사랑하는 사람들이 많고 지금의 그를 위해 노력해 주었다는것이 느껴져요. 팬으로써 너무 고맙습니다.
It's so interesting to see how Youngjun interpreted MV! It's cool how he and the MV director had the image of a ladder to the sky when listening to the song and wanted to incorporate it in their respective works.
You can tell that Youngjun loved working on the choreography for Circle. It's a unique, profound song and it can be tricky to portray through dance; and he did an amazing job!! He seems to genuinely love the song and was awed by the MV since he had to replay it over and over :') anyway thank you for your hard work, Jinki and Youngjun! ❤
Yes omg his image of a prince climbing up to the sky and looking down on earth... I love how he managed to incorporate that with the eye formation at the beginning with jinki at the centre and then at the climax where the dancers kind of lift him up so he looks like he's floating?? And jinki just wandering around the stage was so theatrical, I hope they get to work again in the future 🤞🏽🤞🏽
콘서트에서 처음 공개됐을때 정말 충격 받아서 응원봉 흔들 생각도, 영상으로 찍어야한다는 생각도 못하고, 말씀하신것처럼 웅장함과 숭고함이 무슨 뜻인지 알게 됬어요....ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 모든 샤월이 충격 받았으리라 생각합니다....
안무도 진짜진짜 채고였어여 영준쌤ㅠㅠㅠ컷마다 유심히 봐주는 리액션 너무 재미따ㅠ 안무영상도 꼭 주시기ㅠㅠㅠ
일단 안무가 선생님은 신이십니다.. 처음 무대보고 됐다 했어요. 섬세한 터치, 흐름, 입체감 시간감각... 마치 타임랩스로 보는 세상 같았어요. 안무가 노래가 가진 기품을 절대 해치지 않고 오히려 더 끌어올려 주는 신기한 경험을 했어요. 그리고 편집하시고 자막 다시는 선생님께선 모르시는 게 없네요. 샤파고..
1:02 STOP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THIS IS EXACTLY HOW I LOOK AT ONEW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
the choreographer seems to be such a nice person :') so sweet!
Congratulations on your choreography for Circle. I hope to see the full choreography on SMP floor.
이번 안무 진짜 예뻐요... 무대보면 뮤지컬 보는 느낌
전문가 리뷰가 이렇게 흥미진진하다니...최고세요
여윽시 크리에이터라 감상이 남다르시네요. 서클 표현 했다는 거 저도 이마치고 갑니다!
When i hear this song, i get goosebumps.
When i watch Onew perform it with the choreography, i get goosebumps.
Thank you for the your choreograph, it's very beautiful.
창작자의 감상 너무 좋아요!! 써클 안무도 엄청 멋있었습니당 콘서트 3일 내내 손 모으고 바라보기만 했을 정도로요ㅠㅜ
이렇게 정성스러운 리액션이라니 ❤❤❤❤❤ 최영준씨 너무 고마워요
I really enjoyed this reaction, thanks for being honest and I think you feel the same as Shawol feel, at least I could see his reaction on the same places as I did. Ofc I agree, Onew is the Charming Prince! I found this reaction very satisfactory and I can relate with it. I can feel the choreographer becoming in Shawol. Thanks for Onew's support. The choreography was great I enjoyed it a lot, for me was like the sensation of a play in a theater so I related it with Onew's scene on the scenario. Thanks and claps to Onew and his choreographer.
Great reaction video. Loved the creative perspective of someone who worked on a separate aspect of Circle. You did a great job with the choreo! It has a lovely, dream-like feeling to it.
この曲は いわゆるKpo的ではないので、振付は既存の枠を超えた、ものでなければならないのかと思います。うるさすぎず、歌詞の邪魔をせず、それでいて雰囲気があって。永遠を感じるような。この曲、歌詞、そしてオニュさんにぴったりの振り付けでした。
どなたが創作したんだろうと、興味を持ちました。ほんとうに素晴らしい、最高の振付でした。ありがとうございます。
Actually each set,each outfit and each verse can be interpreted differently if you put them in different sequence. And each interpretation can give different feel. What I love the most is sincerity in his voice.
Thank you for the reaction video and supporting Onew in your own way!
Your choreoghraphy was so brilliant and expressed the song so well👏
I am so happy Onew has so many good people beside him
Thank you🙏
I love how he reacted to Onew!!!! that is so sweet!! he seems so proud of the choreo he created! it really fits the song well!
why is the choreographer so nice!!! all the compliments make me feel so happy for Onew to be surrounded by not only such excellent professionals but also nice people!
최영준안무가님 리액션보며 저 처음 써클뮤비봤을때 감정 생각한점이 비슷해서 놀랐어요^^
This is the best MV reaction I've ever watched! I just agree with EVERYTHING he said! He's so talented too for creating such a beautiful choreography! Thank you so so so much 🩷
안무가님 써클 안무에 의미가 많이 담겨있다고 하셨는데 안무 의미 설명하는 컨텐츠도 나왔음 좋겠어요
콘서트에서 처음 써클 라이브 퍼포먼스를 접했을때의 그 소름 돋는 감동은 말로 표현할 수 없었고 온몸이 마비되고 숨도 못 쉴 정도였는데 할 수만 있다면 안무가님을 위해 리액션 해드리고싶을 정도!! 창작자의 애정과 고민이 가득한 뮤비 리액션 그 어떤 누구의 리뷰보다 소중하고 감사합니다!!
영준히 안무였구나… 어쩐지 넘 좋았어요 리액션 감사합니당
영준쌤이 만든거였군요 너무 좋았어요!!
He put a lot of thought in this reaction i appreciate a lot! Also i can tell he has heard the song so much because he sings along with the adlibs😂 this is one of the most enjoyable and interesting mv reactions i've watched thank you for this❤
이번 써클 앨범은 진짜 들으면 들을 수록, 뮤비도 보면 볼 수록 너무 다양하고 깊은 감정들이 느껴져서 정말정말 잘 만든 앨범이라고 생각됩니다🥹🥹🥹 사람들이 더 많이 보고 또 많이 생각 해봤으면 좋겠어요
As this song has so many meanings it was nice to hear the choreographer-nim feedback on the mv .....can see how big of an art circle is every time i see the mv and performances
진짜 완전 진심 200% 리액션 너무 감사하고 소듕하다❤
onew has spell a magic to all choreographers, dancers, staff and to us. everyone fall foe him
This is such a lovely & thoughtful reaction ♥️ Circle choreo is perfect! Thank you for supporting our Jinki♥️🙏
This dude has a great reaction to OneW new song
와 리액션 영상인데 내가 느낀 감정을 그대로 표현해주고계심 ㅠ
써클 안무가이시구나!!!!!리액션 너무 좋으시다
I think this is the best reaction vid on the SHINee channel! Thank you so much Choreographer Youngjun!! Actually, I was hoping to see something like a choreo draft etc because I looove the performance for Circle too. I’m glad I got to hear a little about his thoughts from this video!
안무가님 감사합니다! 콘서트에서 첫 무대 직접보고 아직까지 소름돋아 있는 사람입니다... 하나의 작품을 만들어낸 창작자의 시선으로 보는 뮤비는 역시 다르네요ㅠㅠ 너무나 애정가득한 마음으로 리액션 해주심이 막 느껴집니다❤
the description and some stories behind the work make it more precious, the meaning of circle itself maybe different for some people but I love how the creators got same ideas. CIRCLE DAEBAK FOREVER ONEW FIGHTING
This was such a lovely reaction - please react to more from now on!
Prince Jinki Agenda!!! One of us!! One of us!! 😁😁😁
ONEWの歌はもちろん素敵だけど、この振り付けとダンサーさん達がさらに曲を盛り上げていて、本当にウットリします🥹💖
皆さんで作り上げた曲というのが凄く伝わってきます❣️素晴らしい振り付けをありがとうございました💖
안무 노래에 너무 잘어울리고 멋있어요😊
와아!!사람 생각은 다 같은가봐요😊
영준님ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 혼자 해석하시다가 깨닫고 홀린듯 재생하시는거 넘웃겨 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 귀여우시네요 흡사 샤월의 모습❤ 쉬지않는 칭찬과 리액션 최고 T^T
써클 안무 너무너무 좋아요 예쁘게 만들어주셔서 감사합니닷 🙇🏻♀️♥
Thank you for your hardwork and the honest reaction, I love your reaction so much
Aww this reaction is so sweet and genuine. Love the choreography, thank you for your great work!!
The choreography is AMAZING! Thank you so much for working on it and not giving up. The performance goes perfectly with the song and it suits Onew so much! The dance team was amazing too! I couldn't imagine how the song would be choreographed, but it ended up beyond perfect. Thank you thank you thank you!
너무너무 예쁘고 멋진 안무 만들어주셔서 감사합니다
와아아 나는이 반응 비디오를 좋아한다! 디테일도 많이 짚어주시고 팬보이 하는 모습도 너무 귀여워요! Circle 안무 감사합니다! 난 그것을 너무 좋아한다! 😍😍😍
창작하시는 분들 정말 대단해요. 안무가 어떻게 나올까 엄청 궁금했다가 딱 보고 우와 했거든요. 뮤비팀과 역시 통하는 게 있는. 리뷰보면서 저도 다시 생각하게 되는! 감사합니다!
the most wholesome reaction video i've ever seen. seriously, his review is so satisfying because he mention every aspect as a professional. youngjun-ssi, thank you for your choreography. thank you for your hard work! 🙇♀️
I love the choreography. Some of the moves are hard but delivered gracefully. It's beautiful!
It so nice to hear his interpretation of the music video. You can see he's really into it which made the video very fun to watch.
The music video and the song is really quite something. It has so many artistic elements but it somehow was able to keep its simplicity and genuineness.
안무가님 정성스런 리액션 감사합니다 ❤
I don't think any choreography would been better than this one. When you watch the performance, every movement and hand flick feel like it has a meaning that you have to focus on, it's really beautiful and meaningful ⭕❤️⭕❤️
I love that Onew got to work with a choreographer who is obviously very passionate about his work. The result was great. I love his choreography for this song.
ヨンジュン先生すばらしい振り付けをありがとうございます！
あの振りがあってこの曲は一層完成しますね！
新しい世界観をオニュもファンも手に入れることができました。
I loved the reaction and the comments 😍 Now I would like to hear the MV director's feedback on the choreography 😭💖
Thank you for making such a beautiful choreography for Onew ❤❤❤❤❤
홀린듯이 다시 재생하는 거 넘나 저으 모습인것.... 근데 정말 창작하는 분이라서 그런지 표현력이 남다르시네여ㅜㅜ 혜자 리액션 감사합니다❤
와 직캠 풀버전보고 너무 멋있어서 저런 안무는 누가 만들었을까 했는데.. 정말 가사가 느껴지는 바람도 느껴지고 시간도 느껴지는 안무였어요. 뒤늦게 감사드립니다
이거 뮤비보고 안무 대체 어떻게할까 궁금했는데 노래랑 너무 잘어울려요 안무영상만 몇번을봅니다
안무 진짜 너무 좋아요 ㅜㅜ 리액션도 넘 정성스럽고 영준쌤 최고! 감사합니다
안무영상도 주세여... ㅠ.ㅠ
This reaction is so good!! Thank you for supporting Onew ♥️
Why this reaction feel so lovely❤❤❤
OMG, he's SO GOOD at interpreting the video's meaning and details. SOOOO SMART. We need him to do a reaction video in any SHINee MV!!!!!!!!!
애정 넘치는 리뷰 남겨준 영준쌤 감사해요!! 안무 정말 하나의 극 같고, 최고예요…. 감탄을 금치못하는 ,,,
되게 진실만을 말씀해주는 분이네요 무한감사🫶🏻
Love the reaction!
저는 사무치게 외로웠을때 부분 안무가 좋아요
ㅠㅠ 뮤비도 좋고 안무도 좋아요! 진짜 함께 만들어주셔서 엄청 좋은 활동이 됐다고 생각합니다!!
振り付けした方ってどんな方なんだろ すごいなぁってパフォーマンス見る度に感動してたのですがその方のお話が聞けてとても嬉しい😊
2:33 PERIODT!!!!!!!!!!! I totally agree
こうやって何度も何度も見てくれる人は、オニュさんにとってとても素晴らしい財産だと思います。
もちろん、MV担当してくださった方々も。
今回、素敵なMVと振り付けを見せてくださって、ありがとうございます❤
オニュさんも、ありがとう❤
내가 본 뮤비리액션중에서 제일 쟈밌어요 선생님 🥺
말씀을 되게 잘하시네요 와 넘 재밌게 봤습니다!
fatia and aqsar have watched the MV circle, it's good the MV is good the circle song is good the songs on the circle album are all good fatia and aqsar always support oppa onew ☺️😊☺️☺️☺️😊☺️☺️☺️😊😊☺️😊😊😊😊
이런 게 거울치료구나 선생님의 모습에서 제가 자꾸 보이네요 하하하하하하 안무 짱 멋져요!!! 쌤 너무 웃기고 귀여워..😊
안무연습영상도 보고 싶네요ㅠㅠ 둘이 이야기하는 것도 궁금해졌어요 정성들린 리액션 감사합니다!!
'the prince vibes suit him so well' ... BUT OF COURSE!!! HE's THE ONE AND ONLY CROWN PRINCE OF SOUTH KOREA MY FRIEND. THE MOST GORGEOUS MAN TO EVER BEEN BORN IN KOREAN SOIL... nothing less😎❤️
오ㅏ 이렇게 정성스런 리액션영상이라니…. 컷마다 세심히 코멘트 해주시는 것도 너무 좋지만 안무가님 일에 대한 열정과 사랑이 엿보여서 보면서 입꼬리가 계속 올라갔어요 :) 큰 애정으로 힘써주셔서인지 써클 안무 곡과 진기랑 너무 잘어울리더라구요 ! 유려한 … 왕자님의 산책… 하늘 위에서 세상을 구경하는 … ❤️
Thank you for the reaction, it good to see pov from the choreographer and he keep praising onew so i feel even more happy❤
I hope there will be reaction from kim eana as the lyricist
also if can, i hope someone who has vocal teaching skill or vast knowledge about vocal to do reaction for circle so i could know their opinion about onew vocal and singing technique
I always wanted to know who Made the choreo ,
Seriously The choreo is a Masterpiece 🥺🥺 i loved it!!! 🥺🥺 You are a genius
I’m happy someone else saw The Little Prince references in the MV thank you to the choreographer👌
써클 노래 티저를 듣고 이노래에 과연 어떤 안무를 할까 궁금했었는데 기대보다 더 좋은 안무였어요😊
작가신가요. 모든 말씀들이 모든 핵심과 재미 솔직 다 완벽해서 놀랍니다!! 최고의 mv 리뷰^^
Love watching Circle choreography 😍it compliments the song really well
What a nice personality you have! Thanks for the nice reaction.
온유 옆에 좋은 사람들이 많아서 너무 좋아요:) 항상 아낌없는 사랑만 받았으면!