This Worthy person studied so diligently to make this knowledge available to those interested persons who lack time\ ability\ opportunity to conduct their own studies. This is one good use of 'specialization'. Blessed be God.
This is a very important element that is not just overlooked, but ignored within the Christian Faith. This understanding of Scripture plays a role in today's society, and in the end times. Since learning this, it has opened up scriptures and my faith. It is wonderful to hear it spoken of!
we are seeing this happen today, in our lifetime!!! Israelis and Arabs are coming to know Jesus as their savior and Lord in #'s not seen since well since Jesus resurrection. Hallelujah🙏🏻🙌
Wow thank you so much Dr. Heiser this cleared up so much for me I've been studying this topic for months and had basically come to this same conclusion but this just makes it make so much more sense! God bless brother!
Excellent video/ Podcast. I wish I could have all of these on CD and DVD. I ordered The Unseen Rhelm Finally after 2 years wait for Amazon. For the kingdom.!! Keep up the good work, always keep these Mike Heiser videos up for us all , the brethren, the Kingdom. Thank you.
I am just loving and absorbing these last two podcasts. Wish you did more on Eschatology as I have for awhile now believed that many modern eschatology tecachers/teachings have missed the marked. Thank you so much Mike for all of your content. Your t-shirt idea by the way is great and excatly what T-Spring is for. I would buy one for I am Isreal too!
5th view would be commonwealth/grafting/placement theology. Jacob"s prophecy over Ephraim that he would be "the fullness of the nations/gentiles" per Romans 11. We former aliens and strangers (gentiles) are now of/in the commonwealth of Israel. Grafted/placed/adopted in to God's nation of Israel. But recognizing how the Bible treats the distinction bw BOTH the house of Judah AND the house of Israel. Judah, the natural branches that did not lose its national Israel identity, will be grafted back at the end of the age per Zechariah and the other prophets. The key is to see how the Bible makes distinctions between Judah and Israel but the 2 houses/sticks will be reunited.
I think confusion of who the whole of Israel is sets in when the reader begins reading the Bible in Matthew rather than genesis. Things just sort of snap into place when one begins at the beginning. Israel are those who are in covenant with God. :)
Maria thats not what Dr Heiser teaches. I agree with Paul and Dr Heiser. I think that one day a remnant of ethnic Jews or a bigger remnant than already will turn to Jesus and be saved and counted in the body of Christ. In the end all who believe will be Israel.
Democrats Only Believers are those who are in covenant with God, so you are both correct. Even though the New Testament (i.e., New Covenant) teaches this, it is usually glanced over because most teachers don't really understand what it means to be in covenant with God, so they don't teach the subject.
Totally agree with the analysis, but one practical issue bothers me... if Paul is essentially saying, "all of the redeemed will be saved", isn't that just "a duh"? Why state something so obvious in that way?
Then how come the idea of the hardening of Israel is contrasted with the fullness of the gentiles? If the gentiles are coming how can they do so if they were hardened. I think Paul is referring specifically to the 12 tribes of Israel.
Paul is contrasting Israel with gentiles throughout Romans 11. So I think the implication would be that he is referring to a remnant of Jews to join the Church.
Mike, thank you for this message. I agree that it is all Israel, but it also does include the 10 tribes. God divorces Israel but tells them he will bring them back to him. I think it’s in Isaiah where it talks about the two sticks; one is the house of Judah and the other Is the house of Israel. The 10 tribes became assimilated into the nations and forgot who they were. But now we are waking up! We are remembering that we are Israel and coming back to God thru his son Jesus. So it is spiritual but also ethical, and includes Jews and Gentiles and Torah and Jesus. In Revelation it says they keep the commandments of God and have the faith of Jesus. Stephen used the church to describe All the Hebrews gathered at the mountain after God freed them from Egypt. So, as believers in Jesus, we are grafted in to the vine of Abraham. We are Israel! And we should not have anything to do with idolatry, including Saturnalia or Tammuz.
I believe this terminology that Paul uses “all Israel will be saved” is directly linked to the story of Joseph when he sends his brothers back to his fathers house (Israel) for the purpose of gathering them unto himself in the new land. All the families of Israel where saved bye the brothers evangelism to the entire house of Israel. Genesis chapter 47 and 48 make this clear. Romans chapter 11 when read in its entirety is a parallel to the story of Joseph. Furthermore it is the only instance in Scripture where the entire house of Israel was saved. In the book of election which is Genesis. The Church is not a substitute, but it is interesting to note how The Egyptians/Gentiles people played a role in the life of the families of Israel and how the fullness of Egypt was saved. One more thing of interest is the terminology that is used in regards to the land of Goshen directly parallels the terminology that is used in conjunction with the promised land. I believe Paul is referring to the millennial rain When all things are set in order. Another point of interest, Joseph utilizes the word remnant to describe the salvation of the 12 tribe families that are represented in genesis 47 and 48.
All Israel is a spiritual concept and refers to all the branches of the olive tree of Israel, whether grafted in or natural. Simply being a descendant of Jacob doesn't make you of Israel. You must be righteous in the sight of the God of Israel to be of true Israel (either through the covenant of Moses or the covenant of Christ). This is according to the name "Israel" itself. The name can be translated "prince of God" in view of the coming Kingdom of God and the rulership of the sons of God. If the Jews of Christ's time were true children of Abraham, they would have done the works of Abraham. It is the spirit, not the flesh which determines who is of Israel.
The church view (#1) obviously does not exclude Jews since Jesus, all of the apostles, and the early church were Jewish. What replacement theologians is Heiser talking about? 14th Century Catholics?
Not the Catholics! One replacement theology hotbed is the seventh day Adventists. Read their own books that explain their theology. I knew two members pretty well. The man wanted me to attend services. I asked him to bring their teachings before I went. It was in their own book. The man had no idea. The lady I left alone because her heart was right. She probably had no idea, and she wasn't trying to get me to join her church.
Catholics do not hate Jews. The history books you have read were likely written by 17th to early 20th century Englishmen, protestants who hated Catholics. Let me know if you want evidence of this bias.
I'm not advocating Replacement Theology, but doesn't it teach that the old covenant has been replaced by the new covenant, and therefore the people of it who had access to God and His grace by that null and void covenant system are replaced; not because of their ethnicity as Jew, but because that path to citizenship in the kingdom of priests no longer exists? Now they must come to God by means of the new covenant, as does everyone else. If I understand it correctly, then none of the reasoning used to dismiss that interpretation works sense he dismissed it based on ethnicity not being the meaning of Israel, and stated that Israel is a covenental term.
Replacement theology basically says the Church is the new Israel. Old Israel is superfluous. We don't need any Israelite. We can be Juden-free, just like Adolph planned for Germany. Who cares to where the Jews have disappeared? The seventh day Adventist church has this theology written in their books, but who reads? It looks like a church that upholds the Sabbath. Ha.
people will read your comment and just see antisemetic bigotry. If you dont respect ethnicity you are racist. Reminds me of the hypocrisy of Liberal Progressive types slanderings.
As much as I resist the first view, the claim that replacement is anti Jewish is absurd. It's not as if every person doesn't have opportunity to accept Jesus. And what does every Christian say about every other hand who might reject Jesus? I say respecting of persons is wrong.
He is splitting hairs to avoid the boogey man charge of “replacement theology”. If All Israel means all believers, then it means the church since believers, Jew & gentile, are the ekklesia. Great episode nonetheless.
You do such a good job baby you’re the only one maybe we will find out someday there’s a few others but you truly are the only ones that I know of powers too although there was lots of people that we don’t know
? If ‘all of Israel’ is a name for everyone in Christ as Mike says…. Then why does Paul make the division and say: ‘until the fullness of the gentiles’. In context. I don’t want to argue just want it explained to hold to Mikes view
Why couldnt the first view be a little more reasonable? Like Israel is not ethnic, which it isnt. But all people, through a faith like Abraham, become the people of God. Jew or otherwise. Faith in Christ, like Abraham had, is what makes you saved, or a spiritual "Israelite". According to the grace of God. Oh, he does go onto explain this truth....
Romans 2:28,29 maybe? But Jesus did tell Nicodemus, you must be born again by the incorruptible seed of God by water and the Spirit and as it was the Jews and Israel broke covenant with God...God made a New Covenant with both houses with Jesus being the surety ...
God promised Abraham that his descendants would number As the stars, as the sands (if you can number the stars, sands), there are not that many Jews, the vast majority of Israel were not Jews then and are not Jews now. God promised that Israel would be the richest, most powerful. When looking for the sky don't look under a bush.
What you are describing sounds to me like replacement theology without the strawman criticisms you levied against it. I dont know of any modern theologian that holds to replacement theology who thinks Israel is garbage and can't be saved. They simoly think "Israel" is a collection of believing Jews and gentiles, and not an ethnic based nation state. What is the difference between that and what you are saying?
Warning; I never heard of Dr. Michael Heiser’s teaching before this one but I do need to warn Michael of the error of this form of teaching. What I mean is this, to discover what a phrase means like; "All Israel will be saved", you not only must read the verses that surround it but also the context of the passage. I was hoping that his listeners below who commented on the video would have pointed this out. Unfortunately, just 1 suggested; "Would it not be better to interpret the verse in context?..." All the rest were sidetracked by the fact that Michael never mentioned the context so neither did the listeners pay any attention to it either (at least those who commented). I challenge anyone to read the passage below carefully and I doubt too many would be left wondering who was Paul referring to. Obviously, it can only be Michael's 4th option of the miracle of the remnant suddenly breaking down and weeping as they see Him coming and as they look upon the one whom they have pierced and this being at the very end, after most of Israel is destroyed and killed, then there is a pause in the fighting as they celebrate the death of the 2 witnesses and then those that remain have the scales removed from their eyes and the hardness of their heart is taken away. These are natural born descendants of Abraham that are living in the land of Israel that Yahuah has gathered from the 4 corners of the earth. Rom 11:1 I say then, has Elohim rejected His people? Let it not be! For I also am of Yisra’ěl, of the seed of Aḇraham, of the tribe of Binyamin. 2 Elohim has not rejected His people Psa_94:14 whom He knew beforehand.......... 4 But what does the answer of Elohim say to him? “I have left for Myself seven thousand men who have not bowed the knee to Ba‛al.” 1Ki_19:18. 5 So therefore also, at this present time a remnant according to the choice of favor has come to be. 6 And if by favor, it is no longer of works, otherwise favor is no longer favor. .... 7 What then? Yisra’ěl has not obtained what it seeks, but the chosen did obtain it, and the rest were hardened. 11 I say then, have they stumbled that they should fall? Let it not be! But by their fall deliverance has come to the nations, to provoke them to jealousy. Deu_32:21. 12 And if their fall is riches for the world, and their failure riches for the nations, how much more their completeness! 13 For I speak to you, the nations, inasmuch as I am an emissary to the nations, I esteem my service, 14 if somehow I might provoke to jealousy Deu_32:21 those who are my flesh and save some of them. 15 For if their casting away is the restoration to favor of the world, what is their acceptance but life from the dead? 16 Now if the first-fruit is set-apart, the lump is also. And if the root is set-apart, so are the branches. 17 And if some of the branches were broken off, and you, being a wild olive tree, have been grafted in among them, and came to share the root and fatness of the olive tree, 18 do not boast against the branches. And if you boast, remember: you do not bear the root, but the root bears you! 19 You shall say then, “The branches were broken off that I might be grafted in.” 20 Good! By unbelief they were broken off, and you stand by belief. Do not be arrogant, but fear. 21 For if Elohim did not spare the natural branches, He might not spare you either. 22 See then the kindness and sharpness of Elohim: on those who fell sharpness, but toward you kindness, if you continue in His kindness, otherwise you also shall be cut off. 23 And they also, if they do not continue in unbelief, shall be grafted in, for Elohim is able to graft them in again. 24 For if you were cut out of the olive tree which is wild by nature, and were grafted contrary to nature into a good olive tree, how much more shall these who are the natural branches, be grafted into their own olive tree? 25 For I do not wish you to be ignorant of this secret, brothers, lest you should be wise in your own estimation, that hardening in part has come over Yisra’ěl, until the completeness of the nationsa has come in. Footnote: a Gen_48:19. 26 And so all Yisra’ěl shall be saved, as it has been written, “The Deliverer shall come out of Tsiyon, and He shall turn away wickedness from Ya‛aqoḇ, 27 and this is My covenant with them, when I take away their sins.”
You may be over literalizing the prophetic concepts. God often speaks in types and seemlessly and suddenly flows into the great concept, in its fullness. Spanning an idea that may cover vast spans of history. As we all accept when we tease out the meaning of the king of Tyre, in Ezekiel for example, and who God speaks of ultimately. I believe we have to remember this type of typological teaching when we recieve the OT prophets words!. Especially all those which use "Thus says the LORD." God Bless
@@rockyseverino9230 I can't remember, maybe the Jewish names version. But that isn't relevant. Everyone knows that Elohim is translated as God in English. N ok one disputes that, so why even question this.
"Ethnic Jews" are not all of "Ethnic Israel". "All Israel" is meaningless unless taking into cognisance the nine tenths of all the tribes of Israel that were taken into captivity by Assyria, leaving only a "tenth" part in the land. Why is this overlooked ?
All Israel will be saved - exactly what it states - all descendants of Jacob will be saved except those (Romans 9:6 > ... For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel) of the synagogue of Satan. Revelation 3:9 > Behold, I will make them of the synagogue of Satan, which say they are Jews, and are not, but do lie; ... Every word of God is pure and that's why HE chose Jacob and his descendants excluding the satanists . Romans 9:15 > For HE saith to Moses, I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. Further, line of Ishmael ( descendent of Abraham ) and then line of Esau (descendant of Isaac) are also not of Israel. Shalom
My understanding of all Israel will be saved is that the Messiah came to his own and his own received him not. That's not to say that no Jewish people believe in Jesus but very few did so in God's merciful plan he turned to the Gentiles when that number is filled he turns back to the Jewish people to give them another chance because God is gracious and merciful not every Jew will believe that Jesus Christ is the messiah just like not every Gentile will believe that Jesus Christ is the messiah but the fullness of all Israel will be all of those that belong to Jesus both Jew and Greek AKA Gentile that is all Israel and that none of them will be lost.
If all Israel meant all tribes of Israel as in OT then that would cause even more problems, as tribe of Dan and Efraim has already vanished. The author of the book of revelation names us twelve tribes Just like they are listed in 1 Chronicles 1-8. Books of chronicles are focused only on kingdom of Juda. That explains lack of Dan. Because Dan lived in northern kingdom of Israel. Also Efraim was often used in prophetic books as Synonim to northern kingdom. Probably that is why in book of revelation it is changed to tribe of Joseph instead of Efraim. Meaning that there are only Jews left. Northern kingdom was gone/ they have vanished. You won't find these tribes I guess. So all Israel as all tribes seems impissible to me.
Perhaps a representative number if the twelve tribes of Israel. God knows who they are. Events still to occur can draw them into Palestine as an ethnic group under a common rule. God sees the big picture and knows all this before we see it.
Abraham was a wanderer, waiting for a city built by God. The promise was always restoration in its fullness. Everything else was a type to build the faith by those who trust(ed) God until He comes back again, in person.
Only Spiritual Israel will be saved. As the Gentile Body of Christ, and Jews that Believe and Accept Yeshua of Nazareth as Messiah, are the current community of Belief, these will be saved and to include Israelites of All Time that believed the Torah and Levitical Law and did their best to adhere to the ordinances and commandments. Those First Advent Israelites, including Jews, that believed prior the incarnation, did so on the basis of Messiah ultimately forgiving their sins that were covered, but not forgiven, by animal sacrifice. So, All Israel, means those who Believed, Believe, or will Believe, past, present and future, including those Jews that will recognize Jesus as Messiah at His Second Advent.
It's a melchisedek phrase ; Melchi and Zadok or Michael and Samael (both, 'the twin' also known with various other names), the princes, urges, manners, left- right- hand, the elected, the beloved/rejected, the watchers, the demi-urg or lesser gods, the actual creators of everything. Especially the Voice, the Word, the warrior, Israel, the thundering angel of death is connected with the creation, the killing of the dragon (Behemoth) that triggers what follows. His 'brother' Jakob the obedient priest is a life-giving spirit that floats above the 'dead waters' a spiritual guy that revives the dragon as living Earth. The material guy (man is made from stuff/dust/ashes) is considered to be the father of all flesh/mankind ; we are his children/offspring, all nations far-off or nearby. If the readoption of this fallen angel happens, now what else will that mean then the forgiving of sins for his offspring as well. It comes close to a potential all-conciliation. Does it include jews ? (pointing this question is basical antisemitic). Honestly saying 'Paul' doesn't explicit say so to make it clear. He keeps it hanging almost as if he is not interested.
With all due respect to Dr. Heiser, though it seems like he is correct in how Paul is using the term "all Israel" I think his logic is flawed in saying that it has no bearing on the modern state of Israel or some future period of largescale conversion of the Jews as an ethnic group. The passage in its context, based on a plain reading, shows that Paul is making comparisons between natural Israel (just the Jews) and spiritual Israel (Jew and Gentile) and he suggests that the inclusion of the gentiles was designed to make Israel "jealous" (hinting at a time of them being grafted back in). He also refers to a time of the Jews "full inclusion" and a time of their "acceptance" as compared to their current rejection. And he suggests that God has the power to "graft them back in again." Taken as a whole, it would seem to strongly suggest there will come a time of large scale Jewish acceptance of the gospel, even if the term "all Israel" does not refer exclusively to natrual Israel.
With all due respect, "All Israel" does not include the church which is Christ's body. We are 'partakers' of God's promise in Christ by the gospel...Eph. 3:6. Would it not be better to interpret the verse in context?... Rom.11:26,27 , is from Is. 59:20,21 . This is definitely covenant people in view.
B Wendelin "the church" is not even found in the original languages. The term used is the Greek "ekklessia," which means "assembly", and is equivalent to the Hebrew "qahal." The whole assembly of people at Sinai, Israelite and gentile alike, were included in the covenant. The northern house of Israel was later divorced and put out of covenant. It is through the death of Messiah/God, the husband, that Israel, who having been dispersed to the Gentiles is able to be brought back into covenant. Therefore, "all Israel" can now be part of the "new" covenant. The books of Hebrews and Romans speak to these things, but you really need to understand the Old Testament context, especially Jeremiah, Isaiah, and Ezekiel, to understand the New Testament commentary on these theological subjects.
There is no seperation of Gods people if you look at the Greek. Church and Jew are not two different people of God. Such ideas are artifacts derived from the translating into English. Ironically, a false concept invented from the anti-semetic feelings of the monarchy which funded our English bible. I second that which is said in the first response to tour comment. Study the Greek word 'ekklessia' and how it is used and where.
So Heiser can't do eschatology. Sad. If we're going to use the Old Testament, let's use the passage Paul quotes from. Isaiah 59, like many other prophetic passages, is of the national people of Israel rejecting God, being punished/exiled/judged by Him, and then being restored to Him eternally in fulfillment of Exodus 6:7. Isaiah 59:19 describes the salvation of the Gentiles: "From the west, people will fear the name of the Lord, and from the rising of the sun, they will revere his glory. For he will come like a pent-up flood that the breath of the Lord drives along" The very next verse describes Jacob repenting when the Redeemer comes to Zion. If this is not a clear indication of the future salvation of (ethnic) Israel, then nothing is. There is no difference between Jew and Gentile when it comes to the means of their salvation. The same Lord saves them both through his atoning death. They are saved on the basis of faith, not adherence to the law or works. But the order of their salvation does differ. Israel is temporarily hardened so that the nations can receive salvation. But once that time is up, all Israel will be saved. National Israel. Ethnic Israel. God has not rejected His people forever; only temporarily as both judgment against them and as grace for the nations. For context, let's finish what God says in Hosea so that we don't have erroneous eschatology. God will restore (ethnic) Israel because He is faithful and has promised He will. Hosea 2:29 I will plant her for myself in the land; I will show my love to the one I called ‘Not my loved one.’ I will say to those called ‘Not my people,’ ‘You are my people’; and they will say, ‘You are my God.’
YAH never made any Covenant with Jews. He made a Covenant with the Children of Israel. All Israelites were not Jews. A Jew is one who adheres or live up to the precepts of the Lawa Statutes and Commandments which is Jewry i.e The Fullness. So a Jew is noevwho Lived in The Fullness. The Way of Life was not limited to biological Israelites. There were many proselytes....strangers who had adopted the religeon. Paul defined for us who is " a Jew ". Roms.2:28-29
All Israelites shall be saved . Christ came to save His people from their sins... and He did just that. Regardless of whether an Israelite accepts Christ or not he still shall be saved. How about this unpopular but true view.? Being saved means that you will not go into the lake of fire. It is sin that would cause you to be thrown into the lake of fire. Sin does not only send you to Hell. Sin will also cause you to be cast into the lake of fire 🔥 And the blood of Jesus atoned for Israel's sins. Regardless of whether you believe it or not. There shall no Israelites in the lake of fire. However, all those who rejected the Gospel and and are not waiting on His return shall reap what they sow. They are cultivating rejection and they shall reap rejection. Only to those who check for Him shall He appear to. " So Christ was once offered to bear the sins of many; and UNTO THEM THAT LOOK FOR HIM SHALL HE APPEAR the second time without sin unto salvation.- Heb 9:28 Nevertheless, The prophecy of Ezekiel 37:10-14 has to be fulfilled literally. All deceased Israelites shall be taken out of their graves and shall be placed into their own land. That shall be the first Resurrection . All Israelites shall make the 1st resurrection Also, whether you believe it or not , the 1st resurrection shall occur sometime after Satan is casted into the lake of fire. Christ's Second Coming to this earth shall not be His last. However I must say that His 2nd Advent has nothing to do with the 1st resurrection. Resurrection is for the dead and those that died in Christ are ASLEEP and not dead. They all shall rise when the loud Trumpet blows They and only they shall rise ..[.not the dead dead.] That shall not be counted for a resurrection.
Which translation is that? In the KJV Rom.9 reads like this : "Not as though the word of God hath taken none effect. For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel" How about this view of that verse. Paul is explaining that it not everyone in the Nation of Israel is a biological Israelites and in the same breathe he was making it clear to his audience that it is the biological Israelites that are the seed. Though he pointed out that it was in Issac that the seed be called, he had to deal with Esau who also came from Issac. Basically he was reaffirming what he said in Roms.9:4-5. I don't see how you arive at that. But wait... it is the translation that says that. Well I disagreed with that breakdown.
1 JOHN 4:1 “Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world.” BEFORE I BEGIN DONT BE OFFENDED BY THE CAPS MY EYES HURT TODAY NOTHING IS REPLACING ANYTHING JESUS IS STILL CARRYING OUT HIS COVENANT WITH ABRAHAMS CLAN A PEOPLE WHO WILL OBEY BY FAITH IN HIM NOTHING HAS CHANGED JUST THE PLAYERS AND EVEN THAT HASNT CHANGED MUCH ITS NOT LIKE GOD DIDNT TRY WORKING WITH THEM 😳 “But I ask, have they not heard? Indeed they have, for “Their voice has gone out to all the earth, and their words to the ends of the world.” But I ask, did Israel not understand? First Moses says, “I will make you jealous of those who are not a nation; with a foolish nation I will make you angry.” Then Isaiah is so bold as to say, “I have been found by those who did not seek me; I have shown myself to those who did not ask for me.” But of Israel he says, “All day long I have held out my hands to a disobedient and contrary people.”” Romans 10:18-21 ESV ISRAEL IS NOT THE VINE ISRAEL IS NOT THE STUMP NOR IS IT THE ROOT ITS A BRANCH-JUST LIKE US ““I am the true vine, and my Father is the vinedresser.” “For if their rejection means the reconciliation of the world, what will their acceptance mean but life from the dead? But if some of the branches were broken off, and you, although a wild olive shoot, were grafted in among the others and now share in the nourishing root of the olive tree, For if God did not spare the NATURAL BRANCHES neither will he spare you. Note then the kindness and the severity of God: severity toward those who have fallen, but God’s kindness to you, provided you continue in his kindness. Otherwise you too will be cut off.” THE ISRAELITES WERE GIVEN THE MESSAGE AND REJECTED IT REJECTED HIM …SOOOOO CUT OFF BUNDLED AND TOSSED SO NOW THE VINE WILL OPEN THE DOOR TO ALL WHO WILL RESPOND LISTEN TRUST AND OBEY PAUL WARNS US NOT YO BE ARROGANT/STIFF NECKED LIKE THEM OR LIKE THEM WE CAN BE CUT OFF BUNDLED AND TOSSED PLEASE KEEP IN MIND GOD THE FATHER ALWAYS HAD SOME SOLDOUT CHILDREN AMONGST THE REBELS …THE ELECT SOOO JUST LIKE THIS DUTCH/ JEW GAL YOU MUST RESPOND AND TURN NOT TWO TIERS JUST ONE WAY THOSE WHO BY FAITH OBEY THESE ARE HIS ISRAEL I STARTED WITH 1 JOHN 4:1 THAT MEANS YOUR FAVOURITE TEACHERS ESPECIALLY SHALOM
Paul was from the tribe of Benjamin. The bulk of the 12 tribes of Israel had left the middle east and migrated up into Europe more than 700 years before Paul was even born. If you do not have a clear understanding of that then your whole idea is flawed. BTW...the USA is the tribe of Manasseh, which holds the remnant of Jacob.
Marilyn , if you are going to make such statements, do the scholarly thing and provide proof for your statements. You can't just say "the USA is the tribe of Manasseh" because it's just not a credible statement. It's rather absurd to claim that everyone in the US is descended from Manasseh, seeing as how the USA is literally made up of people from all over the world.
I just started walking with Jesus and I found Dr heiser,I love his teachings...thx u for his work
This Worthy person studied so diligently to make this knowledge available to those interested persons who lack time\ ability\ opportunity to conduct their own studies. This is one good use of 'specialization'. Blessed be God.
This is a very important element that is not just overlooked, but ignored within the Christian Faith. This understanding of Scripture plays a role in today's society, and in the end times. Since learning this, it has opened up scriptures and my faith. It is wonderful to hear it spoken of!
The more literal we take God's word the more beautiful his word.
This is so helpful! I am so thankful I have found Dr. Heiser’s podcasts this week!
we are seeing this happen today, in our lifetime!!! Israelis and Arabs are coming to know Jesus as their savior and Lord in #'s not seen since well since Jesus resurrection. Hallelujah🙏🏻🙌
This had cleared so much confusion! Praise God!
Wow thank you so much Dr. Heiser this cleared up so much for me I've been studying this topic for months and had basically come to this same conclusion but this just makes it make so much more sense! God bless brother!
Thank you so much for this. I am new to bible study and these podcasts have been awesome! God bless you guys!❤️🙏🏻🇺🇸
Excellent video/ Podcast. I wish I could have all of these on CD and DVD. I ordered The Unseen Rhelm Finally after 2 years wait for Amazon. For the kingdom.!! Keep up the good work, always keep these Mike Heiser videos up for us all , the brethren, the Kingdom. Thank you.
Thanks Dr Mike .
Your work makes a gigantic positive difference in my daily walk with Jesus.
Grateful for all you share. ( XL T Shirt for me)
I am just loving and absorbing these last two podcasts. Wish you did more on Eschatology as I have for awhile now believed that many modern eschatology tecachers/teachings have missed the marked.
Thank you so much Mike for all of your content.
Your t-shirt idea by the way is great and excatly what T-Spring is for. I would buy one for I am Isreal too!
This is most helpful thank you
Thank you!
Just like believing,once saved,,always saved.
5th view would be commonwealth/grafting/placement theology.
Jacob"s prophecy over Ephraim that he would be "the fullness of the nations/gentiles" per Romans 11.
We former aliens and strangers (gentiles) are now of/in the commonwealth of Israel. Grafted/placed/adopted in to God's nation of Israel.
But recognizing how the Bible treats the distinction bw BOTH the house of Judah AND the house of Israel.
Judah, the natural branches that did not lose its national Israel identity, will be grafted back at the end of the age per Zechariah and the other prophets.
The key is to see how the Bible makes distinctions between Judah and Israel but the 2 houses/sticks will be reunited.
I think confusion of who the whole of Israel is sets in when the reader begins reading the Bible in Matthew rather than genesis. Things just sort of snap into place when one begins at the beginning. Israel are those who are in covenant with God. :)
Dorrene M the TORAH (1st 5 books of the Bible) :)
Maria thats not what Dr Heiser teaches. I agree with Paul and Dr Heiser. I think that one day a remnant of ethnic Jews or a bigger remnant than already will turn to Jesus and be saved and counted in the body of Christ. In the end all who believe will be Israel.
Democrats Only Believers are those who are in covenant with God, so you are both correct. Even though the New Testament (i.e., New Covenant) teaches this, it is usually glanced over because most teachers don't really understand what it means to be in covenant with God, so they don't teach the subject.
Have these videos been taken down??? None of them will open for me.
Totally agree with the analysis, but one practical issue bothers me... if Paul is essentially saying, "all of the redeemed will be saved", isn't that just "a duh"? Why state something so obvious in that way?
Then how come the idea of the hardening of Israel is contrasted with the fullness of the gentiles? If the gentiles are coming how can they do so if they were hardened. I think Paul is referring specifically to the 12 tribes of Israel.
They must be separated as he’s contrasting hardening of Israel with the fullness of gentiles
Paul is contrasting Israel with gentiles throughout Romans 11. So I think the implication would be that he is referring to a remnant of Jews to join the Church.
Mike, thank you for this message. I agree that it is all Israel, but it also does include the 10 tribes. God divorces Israel but tells them he will bring them back to him. I think it’s in Isaiah where it talks about the two sticks; one is the house of Judah and the other Is the house of Israel. The 10 tribes became assimilated into the nations and forgot who they were. But now we are waking up! We are remembering that we are Israel and coming back to God thru his son Jesus. So it is spiritual but also ethical, and includes Jews and Gentiles and Torah and Jesus. In Revelation it says they keep the commandments of God and have the faith of Jesus. Stephen used the church to describe All the Hebrews gathered at the mountain after God freed them from Egypt. So, as believers in Jesus, we are grafted in to the vine of Abraham. We are Israel! And we should not have anything to do with idolatry, including Saturnalia or Tammuz.
I believe this terminology that Paul uses “all Israel will be saved” is directly linked to the story of Joseph when he sends his brothers back to his fathers house (Israel) for the purpose of gathering them unto himself in the new land. All the families of Israel where saved bye the brothers evangelism to the entire house of Israel. Genesis chapter 47 and 48 make this clear. Romans chapter 11 when read in its entirety is a parallel to the story of Joseph. Furthermore it is the only instance in Scripture where the entire house of Israel was saved. In the book of election which is Genesis. The Church is not a substitute, but it is interesting to note how The Egyptians/Gentiles people played a role in the life of the families of Israel and how the fullness of Egypt was saved. One more thing of interest is the terminology that is used in regards to the land of Goshen directly parallels the terminology that is used in conjunction with the promised land. I believe Paul is referring to the millennial rain When all things are set in order. Another point of interest, Joseph utilizes the word remnant to describe the salvation of the 12 tribe families that are represented in genesis 47 and 48.
P.S. The colors you use & background music are comforting.....MUCHO GRACIAS TO ALL!!!!
Mind 💥
All Israel is a spiritual concept and refers to all the branches of the olive tree of Israel, whether grafted in or natural. Simply being a descendant of Jacob doesn't make you of Israel. You must be righteous in the sight of the God of Israel to be of true Israel (either through the covenant of Moses or the covenant of Christ). This is according to the name "Israel" itself. The name can be translated "prince of God" in view of the coming Kingdom of God and the rulership of the sons of God. If the Jews of Christ's time were true children of Abraham, they would have done the works of Abraham. It is the spirit, not the flesh which determines who is of Israel.
The church view (#1) obviously does not exclude Jews since Jesus, all of the apostles, and the early church were Jewish. What replacement theologians is Heiser talking about? 14th Century Catholics?
I agree. "The Church" just means any that believes in Jesus Christ for forgiveness of sin and redemption from the world.
Not the Catholics! One replacement theology hotbed is the seventh day Adventists. Read their own books that explain their theology. I knew two members pretty well. The man wanted me to attend services. I asked him to bring their teachings before I went. It was in their own book. The man had no idea. The lady I left alone because her heart was right. She probably had no idea, and she wasn't trying to get me to join her church.
Catholics do not hate Jews. The history books you have read were likely written by 17th to early 20th century Englishmen, protestants who hated Catholics. Let me know if you want evidence of this bias.
I'm not advocating Replacement Theology, but doesn't it teach that the old covenant has been replaced by the new covenant, and therefore the people of it who had access to God and His grace by that null and void covenant system are replaced; not because of their ethnicity as Jew, but because that path to citizenship in the kingdom of priests no longer exists? Now they must come to God by means of the new covenant, as does everyone else. If I understand it correctly, then none of the reasoning used to dismiss that interpretation works sense he dismissed it based on ethnicity not being the meaning of Israel, and stated that Israel is a covenental term.
Replacement theology basically says the Church is the new Israel. Old Israel is superfluous. We don't need any Israelite. We can be Juden-free, just like Adolph planned for Germany. Who cares to where the Jews have disappeared? The seventh day Adventist church has this theology written in their books, but who reads? It looks like a church that upholds the Sabbath. Ha.
Even Jews had to believe in god
I am Israel...
Amen.
Ethnicity only apllied up to Abraham's seed who was Jesus
people will read your comment and just see antisemetic bigotry. If you dont respect ethnicity you are racist. Reminds me of the hypocrisy of Liberal Progressive types slanderings.
As much as I resist the first view, the claim that replacement is anti Jewish is absurd.
It's not as if every person doesn't have opportunity to accept Jesus. And what does every Christian say about every other hand who might reject Jesus? I say respecting of persons is wrong.
jamie Russell l
@@gordonbeattie5259 ?
He is splitting hairs to avoid the boogey man charge of “replacement theology”. If All Israel means all believers, then it means the church since believers, Jew & gentile, are the ekklesia. Great episode nonetheless.
I'm ready to go YESTERDAY.....HELP!!!
In the mean time I FAST, PRAY & HELP OTHERS IN ANY WAY I CAN.....SHALOM * PEACE * PEACEFULLY.......
You do such a good job baby you’re the only one maybe we will find out someday there’s a few others but you truly are the only ones that I know of powers too although there was lots of people that we don’t know
? If ‘all of Israel’ is a name for everyone in Christ as Mike says…. Then why does Paul make the division and say: ‘until the fullness of the gentiles’. In context. I don’t want to argue just want it explained to hold to Mikes view
I would buy that shirt
Why couldnt the first view be a little more reasonable? Like Israel is not ethnic, which it isnt. But all people, through a faith like Abraham, become the people of God. Jew or otherwise. Faith in Christ, like Abraham had, is what makes you saved, or a spiritual "Israelite". According to the grace of God.
Oh, he does go onto explain this truth....
Romans 2:28,29 maybe? But Jesus did tell Nicodemus, you must be born again by the incorruptible seed of God by water and the Spirit and as it was the Jews and Israel broke covenant with God...God made a New Covenant with both houses with Jesus being the surety ...
God promised Abraham that his descendants would number As the stars, as the sands (if you can number the stars, sands), there are not that many Jews, the vast majority of Israel were not Jews then and are not Jews now. God promised that Israel would be the richest, most powerful. When looking for the sky don't look under a bush.
whats your point?
1 Kings 4:20
What you are describing sounds to me like replacement theology without the strawman criticisms you levied against it. I dont know of any modern theologian that holds to replacement theology who thinks Israel is garbage and can't be saved. They simoly think "Israel" is a collection of believing Jews and gentiles, and not an ethnic based nation state. What is the difference between that and what you are saying?
The seventh day Adventist church believes in replacement theology
Don't believe me. Read their own book on their theology.
Israel
Theological construct
Totality of God's people.
All believers followers of Christ regardless of ethnicity.
Warning;
I never heard of Dr. Michael Heiser’s teaching before this one but I do need to warn Michael of the error of this form of teaching. What I mean is this, to discover what a phrase means like; "All Israel will be saved", you not only must read the verses that surround it but also the context of the passage. I was hoping that his listeners below who commented on the video would have pointed this out. Unfortunately, just 1 suggested; "Would it not be better to interpret the verse in context?..." All the rest were sidetracked by the fact that Michael never mentioned the context so neither did the listeners pay any attention to it either (at least those who commented).
I challenge anyone to read the passage below carefully and I doubt too many would be left wondering who was Paul referring to. Obviously, it can only be Michael's 4th option of the miracle of the remnant suddenly breaking down and weeping as they see Him coming and as they look upon the one whom they have pierced and this being at the very end, after most of Israel is destroyed and killed, then there is a pause in the fighting as they celebrate the death of the 2 witnesses and then those that remain have the scales removed from their eyes and the hardness of their heart is taken away. These are natural born descendants of Abraham that are living in the land of Israel that Yahuah has gathered from the 4 corners of the earth.
Rom 11:1 I say then, has Elohim rejected His people? Let it not be! For I also am of Yisra’ěl, of the seed of Aḇraham, of the tribe of Binyamin.
2 Elohim has not rejected His people Psa_94:14 whom He knew beforehand..........
4 But what does the answer of Elohim say to him? “I have left for Myself seven thousand men who have not bowed the knee to Ba‛al.” 1Ki_19:18.
5 So therefore also, at this present time a remnant according to the choice of favor has come to be.
6 And if by favor, it is no longer of works, otherwise favor is no longer favor. ....
7 What then? Yisra’ěl has not obtained what it seeks, but the chosen did obtain it, and the rest were hardened.
11 I say then, have they stumbled that they should fall? Let it not be! But by their fall deliverance has come to the nations, to provoke them to jealousy. Deu_32:21.
12 And if their fall is riches for the world, and their failure riches for the nations, how much more their completeness!
13 For I speak to you, the nations, inasmuch as I am an emissary to the nations, I esteem my service,
14 if somehow I might provoke to jealousy Deu_32:21 those who are my flesh and save some of them.
15 For if their casting away is the restoration to favor of the world, what is their acceptance but life from the dead?
16 Now if the first-fruit is set-apart, the lump is also. And if the root is set-apart, so are the branches.
17 And if some of the branches were broken off, and you, being a wild olive tree, have been grafted in among them, and came to share the root and fatness of the olive tree,
18 do not boast against the branches. And if you boast, remember: you do not bear the root, but the root bears you!
19 You shall say then, “The branches were broken off that I might be grafted in.”
20 Good! By unbelief they were broken off, and you stand by belief. Do not be arrogant, but fear.
21 For if Elohim did not spare the natural branches, He might not spare you either.
22 See then the kindness and sharpness of Elohim: on those who fell sharpness, but toward you kindness, if you continue in His kindness, otherwise you also shall be cut off.
23 And they also, if they do not continue in unbelief, shall be grafted in, for Elohim is able to graft them in again.
24 For if you were cut out of the olive tree which is wild by nature, and were grafted contrary to nature into a good olive tree, how much more shall these who are the natural branches, be grafted into their own olive tree?
25 For I do not wish you to be ignorant of this secret, brothers, lest you should be wise in your own estimation, that hardening in part has come over Yisra’ěl, until the completeness of the nationsa has come in. Footnote: a Gen_48:19.
26 And so all Yisra’ěl shall be saved, as it has been written, “The Deliverer shall come out of Tsiyon, and He shall turn away wickedness from Ya‛aqoḇ,
27 and this is My covenant with them, when I take away their sins.”
You may be over literalizing the prophetic concepts. God often speaks in types and seemlessly and suddenly flows into the great concept, in its fullness. Spanning an idea that may cover vast spans of history. As we all accept when we tease out the meaning of the king of Tyre, in Ezekiel for example, and who God speaks of ultimately. I believe we have to remember this type of typological teaching when we recieve the OT prophets words!. Especially all those which use "Thus says the LORD."
God Bless
What translation are you quoting?
Elohim is a Hebrew word, Romans was written in Greek. That can't be an accurate translation.
@@rockyseverino9230 I can't remember, maybe the Jewish names version. But that isn't relevant. Everyone knows that Elohim is translated as God in English. N ok one disputes that, so why even question this.
Be patient, you will catch up one day 😅
Why wont all Gentiles be saved also?
I would buy one of those shirts!!! I am Israel 😁
❤️🙌❤️ Seriously!!!!
"Ethnic Jews" are not all of "Ethnic Israel".
"All Israel" is meaningless unless taking into cognisance the nine tenths of all the tribes of Israel that were taken into captivity by Assyria, leaving only a "tenth" part in the land.
Why is this overlooked ?
1x(9/29/21)…1….10…..
All Israel will be saved - exactly what it states - all descendants of Jacob will be saved except those (Romans 9:6 > ... For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel) of the synagogue of Satan. Revelation 3:9 > Behold, I will make them of the synagogue of Satan, which say they are Jews, and are not, but do lie; ...
Every word of God is pure and that's why HE chose Jacob and his descendants excluding the satanists .
Romans 9:15 > For HE saith to Moses, I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion.
Further, line of Ishmael ( descendent of Abraham ) and then line of Esau (descendant of Isaac) are also not of Israel.
Shalom
My understanding of all Israel will be saved is that the Messiah came to his own and his own received him not. That's not to say that no Jewish people believe in Jesus but very few did so in God's merciful plan he turned to the Gentiles when that number is filled he turns back to the Jewish people to give them another chance because God is gracious and merciful not every Jew will believe that Jesus Christ is the messiah just like not every Gentile will believe that Jesus Christ is the messiah but the fullness of all Israel will be all of those that belong to Jesus both Jew and Greek AKA Gentile that is all Israel and that none of them will be lost.
If all Israel meant all tribes of Israel as in OT then that would cause even more problems, as tribe of Dan and Efraim has already vanished. The author of the book of revelation names us twelve tribes Just like they are listed in 1 Chronicles 1-8. Books of chronicles are focused only on kingdom of Juda. That explains lack of Dan. Because Dan lived in northern kingdom of Israel. Also Efraim was often used in prophetic books as Synonim to northern kingdom. Probably that is why in book of revelation it is changed to tribe of Joseph instead of Efraim. Meaning that there are only Jews left. Northern kingdom was gone/ they have vanished. You won't find these tribes I guess. So all Israel as all tribes seems impissible to me.
Perhaps a representative number if the twelve tribes of Israel. God knows who they are. Events still to occur can draw them into Palestine as an ethnic group under a common rule. God sees the big picture and knows all this before we see it.
Original promise to OT saints will be during the Millennial reign
Abraham was a wanderer, waiting for a city built by God. The promise was always restoration in its fullness. Everything else was a type to build the faith by those who trust(ed) God until He comes back again, in person.
Not synonymous'
Only Spiritual Israel will be saved. As the Gentile Body of Christ, and Jews that Believe and Accept Yeshua of Nazareth as Messiah, are the current community of Belief, these will be saved and to include Israelites of All Time that believed the Torah and Levitical Law and did their best to adhere to the ordinances and commandments. Those First Advent Israelites, including Jews, that believed prior the incarnation, did so on the basis of Messiah ultimately forgiving their sins that were covered, but not forgiven, by animal sacrifice. So, All Israel, means those who Believed, Believe, or will Believe, past, present and future, including those Jews that will recognize Jesus as Messiah at His Second Advent.
It's a melchisedek phrase ; Melchi and Zadok or Michael and Samael (both, 'the twin' also known with various other names), the princes, urges, manners, left- right- hand, the elected, the beloved/rejected, the watchers, the demi-urg or lesser gods, the actual creators of everything. Especially the Voice, the Word, the warrior, Israel, the thundering angel of death is connected with the creation, the killing of the dragon (Behemoth) that triggers what follows. His 'brother' Jakob the obedient priest is a life-giving spirit that floats above the 'dead waters' a spiritual guy that revives the dragon as living Earth. The material guy (man is made from stuff/dust/ashes) is considered to be the father of all flesh/mankind ; we are his children/offspring, all nations far-off or nearby. If the readoption of this fallen angel happens, now what else will that mean then the forgiving of sins for his offspring as well. It comes close to a potential all-conciliation. Does it include jews ? (pointing this question is basical antisemitic). Honestly saying 'Paul' doesn't explicit say so to make it clear. He keeps it hanging almost as if he is not interested.
Gnosticism is not biblical. Listen to Dr. Heiser's lecture on Gnosticism. Not anything that saves you. Period.
With all due respect to Dr. Heiser, though it seems like he is correct in how Paul is using the term "all Israel" I think his logic is flawed in saying that it has no bearing on the modern state of Israel or some future period of largescale conversion of the Jews as an ethnic group. The passage in its context, based on a plain reading, shows that Paul is making comparisons between natural Israel (just the Jews) and spiritual Israel (Jew and Gentile) and he suggests that the inclusion of the gentiles was designed to make Israel "jealous" (hinting at a time of them being grafted back in). He also refers to a time of the Jews "full inclusion" and a time of their "acceptance" as compared to their current rejection. And he suggests that God has the power to "graft them back in again."
Taken as a whole, it would seem to strongly suggest there will come a time of large scale Jewish acceptance of the gospel, even if the term "all Israel" does not refer exclusively to natrual Israel.
With all due respect, "All Israel" does not include the church which is Christ's body. We are 'partakers' of God's promise in Christ by the gospel...Eph. 3:6.
Would it not be better to interpret the verse in context?...
Rom.11:26,27 , is from Is. 59:20,21 . This is definitely covenant people in view.
B Wendelin "the church" is not even found in the original languages. The term used is the Greek "ekklessia," which means "assembly", and is equivalent to the Hebrew "qahal." The whole assembly of people at Sinai, Israelite and gentile alike, were included in the covenant. The northern house of Israel was later divorced and put out of covenant. It is through the death of Messiah/God, the husband, that Israel, who having been dispersed to the Gentiles is able to be brought back into covenant. Therefore, "all Israel" can now be part of the "new" covenant. The books of Hebrews and Romans speak to these things, but you really need to understand the Old Testament context, especially Jeremiah, Isaiah, and Ezekiel, to understand the New Testament commentary on these theological subjects.
There is no seperation of Gods people if you look at the Greek.
Church and Jew are not two different people of God. Such ideas are artifacts derived from the translating into English. Ironically, a false concept invented from the anti-semetic feelings of the monarchy which funded our English bible.
I second that which is said in the first response to tour comment. Study the Greek word 'ekklessia' and how it is used and where.
So Heiser can't do eschatology. Sad.
If we're going to use the Old Testament, let's use the passage Paul quotes from. Isaiah 59, like many other prophetic passages, is of the national people of Israel rejecting God, being punished/exiled/judged by Him, and then being restored to Him eternally in fulfillment of Exodus 6:7.
Isaiah 59:19 describes the salvation of the Gentiles:
"From the west, people will fear the name of the Lord,
and from the rising of the sun, they will revere his glory.
For he will come like a pent-up flood
that the breath of the Lord drives along"
The very next verse describes Jacob repenting when the Redeemer comes to Zion. If this is not a clear indication of the future salvation of (ethnic) Israel, then nothing is.
There is no difference between Jew and Gentile when it comes to the means of their salvation. The same Lord saves them both through his atoning death. They are saved on the basis of faith, not adherence to the law or works. But the order of their salvation does differ. Israel is temporarily hardened so that the nations can receive salvation. But once that time is up, all Israel will be saved. National Israel. Ethnic Israel. God has not rejected His people forever; only temporarily as both judgment against them and as grace for the nations.
For context, let's finish what God says in Hosea so that we don't have erroneous eschatology. God will restore (ethnic) Israel because He is faithful and has promised He will.
Hosea 2:29
I will plant her for myself in the land;
I will show my love to the one I called ‘Not my loved one.’
I will say to those called ‘Not my people,’ ‘You are my people’;
and they will say, ‘You are my God.’
Not saying you're wrong...but the ending there isn't all that strong, given that Paul also quotes that verse applying it to gentiles.
You are an "idea log", my friend.
Dont be so stiff necked.
I think he said that
YAH never made any Covenant with Jews. He made a Covenant with the Children of Israel. All Israelites were not Jews. A Jew is one who adheres or live up to the precepts of the Lawa Statutes and Commandments which is Jewry i.e The Fullness. So a Jew is noevwho Lived in The Fullness. The Way of Life was not limited to biological Israelites. There were many proselytes....strangers who had adopted the religeon.
Paul defined for us who is " a Jew ". Roms.2:28-29
All Israelites shall be saved . Christ came to save His people from their sins... and He did just that. Regardless of whether an Israelite accepts Christ or not he still shall be saved.
How about this unpopular but true view.? Being saved means that you will not go into the lake of fire. It is sin that would cause you to be thrown into the lake of fire. Sin does not only send you to Hell. Sin will also cause you to be cast into the lake of fire 🔥
And the blood of Jesus atoned for Israel's sins.
Regardless of whether you believe it or not. There shall no Israelites in the lake of fire.
However, all those who rejected the Gospel and and are not waiting on His return shall reap what they sow. They are cultivating rejection and they shall reap rejection. Only to those who check for Him shall He appear to.
" So Christ was once offered to bear the sins of many; and UNTO THEM THAT LOOK FOR HIM SHALL HE APPEAR the second time without sin unto salvation.- Heb 9:28
Nevertheless,
The prophecy of Ezekiel 37:10-14 has to be fulfilled
literally. All deceased Israelites shall be taken out of their graves and shall be placed into their own land. That shall be the first Resurrection . All Israelites shall make the 1st resurrection Also, whether you believe it or not , the 1st resurrection shall occur sometime after Satan is casted into the lake of fire.
Christ's Second Coming to this earth shall not be His last. However I must say that His 2nd Advent has nothing to do with the 1st resurrection. Resurrection is for the dead and those that died in Christ are ASLEEP and not dead. They all shall rise when the loud Trumpet blows They and only they shall rise ..[.not the dead dead.] That shall not be counted for a resurrection.
Which translation is that?
In the KJV Rom.9 reads like this : "Not as though the word of God hath taken none effect. For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel"
How about this view of that verse. Paul is explaining that it not everyone in the Nation of Israel is a biological Israelites and in the same breathe he was making it clear to his audience that it is the biological Israelites that are the seed. Though he pointed out that it was in Issac that the seed be called, he had to deal with Esau who also came from Issac.
Basically he was reaffirming what he said in Roms.9:4-5.
I don't see how you arive at that. But wait... it is the translation that says that.
Well I disagreed with that breakdown.
1 JOHN 4:1 “Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world.”
BEFORE I BEGIN DONT BE OFFENDED BY THE CAPS MY EYES HURT TODAY
NOTHING IS REPLACING ANYTHING
JESUS IS STILL CARRYING OUT HIS COVENANT WITH ABRAHAMS CLAN A PEOPLE WHO WILL OBEY BY FAITH IN HIM
NOTHING HAS CHANGED JUST THE PLAYERS AND EVEN THAT HASNT CHANGED MUCH
ITS NOT LIKE GOD DIDNT TRY WORKING WITH THEM 😳
“But I ask, have they not heard? Indeed they have, for “Their voice has gone out to all the earth, and their words to the ends of the world.” But I ask, did Israel not understand? First Moses says, “I will make you jealous of those who are not a nation; with a foolish nation I will make you angry.” Then Isaiah is so bold as to say, “I have been found by those who did not seek me; I have shown myself to those who did not ask for me.” But of Israel he says, “All day long I have held out my hands to a disobedient and contrary people.””
Romans 10:18-21 ESV
ISRAEL IS NOT THE VINE
ISRAEL IS NOT THE STUMP
NOR IS IT THE ROOT
ITS A BRANCH-JUST LIKE US
““I am the true vine, and my Father is the vinedresser.”
“For if their rejection means the reconciliation of the world, what will their acceptance mean but life from the dead? But if some of the branches were broken off, and you, although a wild olive shoot, were grafted in among the others and now share in the nourishing root of the olive tree, For if God did not spare the NATURAL BRANCHES neither will he spare you. Note then the kindness and the severity of God: severity toward those who have fallen, but God’s kindness to you, provided you continue in his kindness. Otherwise you too will be cut off.”
THE ISRAELITES WERE GIVEN THE MESSAGE AND REJECTED IT REJECTED HIM …SOOOOO
CUT OFF BUNDLED AND TOSSED
SO NOW THE VINE WILL OPEN THE DOOR TO ALL WHO WILL RESPOND LISTEN TRUST AND OBEY
PAUL WARNS US NOT YO BE ARROGANT/STIFF NECKED LIKE THEM OR LIKE THEM WE CAN BE CUT OFF BUNDLED AND TOSSED
PLEASE KEEP IN MIND GOD THE FATHER ALWAYS HAD SOME SOLDOUT CHILDREN AMONGST THE REBELS …THE ELECT
SOOO JUST LIKE THIS DUTCH/ JEW GAL YOU MUST RESPOND AND TURN
NOT TWO TIERS JUST ONE WAY
THOSE WHO BY FAITH
OBEY THESE ARE HIS ISRAEL
I STARTED WITH 1 JOHN 4:1 THAT MEANS YOUR FAVOURITE TEACHERS ESPECIALLY
SHALOM
I disagree with his analysis.
Paul was from the tribe of Benjamin. The bulk of the 12 tribes of Israel had left the middle east and migrated up into Europe more than 700 years before Paul was even born. If you do not have a clear understanding of that then your whole idea is flawed. BTW...the USA is the tribe of Manasseh, which holds the remnant of Jacob.
Exactly right, but the judaizers have brainwashed the masses.
Right you are. There are 20 or 3 million Jews worldwide but the Children of Israel (10 other tribes) number in the many hundreds of millions today.
LMAO, STOP IT ALREADY!!!
@@curtismartin8455
Begone Black Hebro' demon.
Marilyn , if you are going to make such statements, do the scholarly thing and provide proof for your statements. You can't just say "the USA is the tribe of Manasseh" because it's just not a credible statement. It's rather absurd to claim that everyone in the US is descended from Manasseh, seeing as how the USA is literally made up of people from all over the world.