An effective and courageous film...and it did not even touch upon the violence of the Christian Brothers, the industrial schools, the Magdalen laundries, nor the endemic sexual abuse of children by the catholic clergy.
Listening to this, around 27:30, trust in 'Telefis Eireann'. Awfully apt today, PAC appearance by R Turbridy. (I love the Trinity guy's huge white polo-neck) "Father" Michael Cleary, 55 mins, he's "not against sex..." we know now.
I once showed this to my parents, who grew up in the 1960s. It obviously rang true because they were so angry. They leapt to the defence of the church and FF and FG. The hypocrisy runs deep.
I had an inarticulte anger as a child, the casual entitled brutality of "Christian "brothers, the apathy of the gangsters in Leinster house, the abandoned sisters and brothers in the north. Yet you live in hope for some kind of justice.
1. This is a fascinating film. 2. Non-Smokers must have been viewed as right weirdos, 54 years ago. 3. Who's the guy singing "Rocky Road to Dublin" from about 15 minutes in? 4. The GAA mentality actually shocked me. 5. That girl at 39:58 was not a born dancer but she was definitely out to get a man! 6. The wedding reception seemed pretty normal by any standards and the older priest came across as a decent guy but Harry and Bríd seemed to be at their own wedding under protest!
The guy singing from 14 minutes in is Ted McKenna. He is hard to find on TH-cam because of a much better known Ted McKenna but if you search for Ted McKenna Paddy Brennan you will find most of the only album they made: The McKenna Brothers live in O'Donoghue's. Ted was my best man and I am happy to say he is still playing at age 80+.
What’s the sparsely attended hurling match, does anyone know? They have the guys in white coats behind the goals so I assume it’s a game of some standing but it’s a very paltry crowd.
I'm not sure If I still have the original ISO/DVD rip file I gleamed it from. The quality you see in this TH-cam video is about as good as it ever looked though from the original DVD release so I would suggest using the following site to simply download this video: downloaderto.com/en/ downloaderto.com/en/.
Interesting, but very male dominated, the mother got her fed up view's across, the only femail in the newspaper discussion had no voice at all, no nun's view,or any professional ,nurse or artist,writer singer,musician, Dr ,even at the end a load of running school boys, how sad is that,also no actress to be heard 😮
We must remember Ireland is a work in progress. Terrible things happened to Ireland for centuries. We had a series of revolutions, gre We must remember, Ireland is a work in progress. Terrible things happened to us for centuries. We had many revolutions, a great famine. This famine did untold 35:2135:22
An effective and courageous film...and it did not even touch upon the violence of the Christian Brothers, the industrial schools, the Magdalen laundries, nor the endemic sexual abuse of children by the catholic clergy.
Special thanks Cian for upload. Seán Ó Faoláin - one of our greats. People might check out Vive Moi if some interest Ireland early decades 20thC.
Good to see this film is on TH-cam again!
thank you, thank you for making this available
No worries bud, now that the copyright holder can monetise this documentary it hasnt been removed again at least.
Listening to this, around 27:30, trust in 'Telefis Eireann'. Awfully apt today, PAC appearance by R Turbridy. (I love the Trinity guy's huge white polo-neck) "Father" Michael Cleary, 55 mins, he's "not against sex..." we know now.
Great social documentary of Ireland in the 60s.
,
Fr Michael Cleary, "celibacy is a personal sacrifice for me," yet he had his own partner, and they had a son together! Do as I say and not as I do..
That was Peter Lennon genius - the depth of hypocracy is nowhere better revealed.
The film is like a time bomb... with a thirty year fuse.
Who's the Fella singing at 15.20?
I once showed this to my parents, who grew up in the 1960s. It obviously rang true because they were so angry. They leapt to the defence of the church and FF and FG. The hypocrisy runs deep.
Stockholm Syndrome.
Modern Ireland is deeply flawed too - you'll probably attack me for saying that. Same energy as with your parents.
@@christopherconnolly5340 I am no apologist for modern Ireland, so no need to assume I would attack you. It is just flawed in different ways.
this was good and sad
If only we knew then what we know now.
"Father" Cleary....what an absolute gangster of a priest.....shameful, an absolute manipulator
I had an inarticulte anger as a child, the casual entitled brutality of "Christian "brothers, the apathy of the gangsters in Leinster house, the abandoned sisters and brothers in the north. Yet you live in hope for some kind of justice.
1. This is a fascinating film.
2. Non-Smokers must have been viewed as right weirdos, 54 years ago.
3. Who's the guy singing "Rocky Road to Dublin" from about 15 minutes in?
4. The GAA mentality actually shocked me.
5. That girl at 39:58 was not a born dancer but she was definitely out to get a man!
6. The wedding reception seemed pretty normal by any standards and the older priest came across as a decent guy but Harry and Bríd seemed to be at their own wedding under protest!
The guy singing from 14 minutes in is Ted McKenna. He is hard to find on TH-cam because of a much better known Ted McKenna but if you search for Ted McKenna Paddy Brennan you will find most of the only album they made: The McKenna Brothers live in O'Donoghue's. Ted was my best man and I am happy to say he is still playing at age 80+.
Is the much better known Ted McKenna from the Sensational Alex Harvey Band?@@niallmac44
@@niallmac44Nice...Thank you! ✌🏼
Made by the wonderful Peter Lennon Guardian Paris corr and all round decent man
This is sick!
Hypocrisy, fear, brutality and corruption. Thank God times have changed.
Government corruption and brutal austerity are still alive and well though.
yes but there still isn't enough jobs for everyone
What’s the sparsely attended hurling match, does anyone know? They have the guys in white coats behind the goals so I assume it’s a game of some standing but it’s a very paltry crowd.
It has the feel of The Railway Cup - inter provincial comp.
Let's see how long this stays up
Still here! 😄
@@CianODonnell Still here😎
Still here!
@CianODonell Is it possible for you to send me this film? I would like to use some of its audio and footage for a project! 😀
I'm not sure If I still have the original ISO/DVD rip file I gleamed it from. The quality you see in this TH-cam video is about as good as it ever looked though from the original DVD release so I would suggest using the following site to simply download this video: downloaderto.com/en/ downloaderto.com/en/.
The ICA in London showed this documentary about 15 years or so ago. Maybe they can point you in the direction of a sharper version.
I'd imagine they projected an original print, Im not aware of a blu-ray release even@@rosebyrne8471
The Roman Catholic Church, doing the babysitting...
Cruise o brien,Irelands quisling.
Interesting, but very male dominated, the mother got her fed up view's across, the only femail in the newspaper discussion had no voice at all, no nun's view,or any professional ,nurse or artist,writer singer,musician, Dr ,even at the end a load of running school boys, how sad is that,also no actress to be heard 😮
This is a reflection of the realities of the time. I wouldn't see it as a flaw of the film.
We must remember Ireland is a work in progress. Terrible things happened to Ireland for centuries. We had a series of revolutions, gre
We must remember, Ireland is a work in progress. Terrible things happened to us for centuries. We had many revolutions, a great famine. This famine did untold
35:21 35:22
P