Which character should I cover next? Are you still waiting for NOTR to cover your favorite?? Save 20% off your order with the code: NERDOFTHERINGS at SlideBelts.com !
Gotta love a guy who sets his daughter's bridal price as "Save the world by defeating the last great evil on Earth in war, reclaim your long vacant throne, and restore honor of my brother's household" before giving his blessing. But Aragorn pulls through.
Yes, that is badass from Estel, but I think King Thingol's demand for Tinúviel was even harsher: go a steal the most precious possession from Morgoth himself. And to Beren's credit, he pulled that off.
Jacob, A great improvement from his ancestor who sets the bride price to just steal a jewel from the devil, but otherwise does not requires anything else. Also an improvement from his other ancestor who basically arrange the marriage with the father of the groom because he thought the father of the groom is his son.
Elrond exemplifies everything it is to be an elf - he lost his father, mother, brother and daughter. Never to see them again and yet he endured. After Finrod, he has been the greatest Elven teacher to men. He fought, and he healed. He submitted to Gil-Galad's reign despite being a descendant of a Maiar. And when he created his own 'realm', it was not one of strength and fortitude but of peace and hospitality.
His parents are at least in Valinor, most likely. If not, then they'd be in the Halls of Mandos, where he could still potentially see them again. They're not completely beyond possibility for him to see again. Arwen and Elros, however, are truly beyond the possibility of him ever seeing again, at least before the end of the world. And aside from Luthien (and *maybe* Elladan and Elrohir, who Tolkien never specified their choices), they're the only two Elf/Half-Elf souls to depart Arda. Even the end of the world (where the world is made anew and Men take part of the second Song with Eru and the Valar) isnt a guarantee, since (iirc) Tolkien never actually settled on whether Elves are part of the Second Song/new Arda or not
@Broadway JR His parents are flying in the skies actually. Also, won't Feanor "reincarnated" break the Silmarils and restore the light of the two trees? Though I'm not sure if that's before, during or after the Dagor Dagorlath.
@@aminiqbal4907Only Eärendil is sailing in Vingilótë across Ilmen while Elwing waits for him in Elwing’s tower northward upon the borders of the Sundering Seas. She only flies like a bird to meet her husband whenever he returns from his voyages.
I love Elrond. He's that rare Elf who understood and lived with the weight of love and sacrifice. Every choice he made honored his family and his kin. I've always imagined that like his father, he eventually meets Manwe. And that Manwe would embrace him and say, "My son, you have done well. You make us proud!"
Detach from this world and the distractions/pleasures in it.This world and the things in it are temporary, spend your time doing something that will matter in the long run. Do as much as you can to help other people while you are here so that you are ready to face Jesus on judgement day. The last 3000+ years of human history have been a testimony in favor of God's word. Contemplate how the Roman Empire fulfilled the role of the beast from the sea in Revelation 13. Revelation 17 confirms that it is in fact Rome. From this we can conclude that A) Jesus is the son of God and can tell the future or make it happen B) The world leaders/governments/nations etc have been conspiring together to accomplish this roadmap set in place by the Israelites or C) History as we know it is fake despite the archaeological evidence. You don't really need to speculate though because you can start a relationship with God and have proof. Call on the name of Jesus and pray for Him to intervene in your life - Revelation 3:20. The world is rapidly passing away and eventually you will have to stand before God on judgement day and explain to Him what you have done with your life. Make sure you are making every effort to help others while you can
I can imagine situation, when Elrond teachs his sons history of Middle-Earth: "Do you see that bright star near horizon? That's my father." *Deadly serious*
@@Olivia-W and another commited suicide. As one unknown tolkienist poet said(about Fëanor and his sons): 'this family is flawed and their bite is as bad as their bark.'
7:40 one important detail here was Isildur was going to ask Elrond for council about what to do with the ring on his way back north. After possessing it for awhile and not being able to bend it to his will he knew he had to do something. He could tell the ring was more like to slowly have an effect on him than the other way around. So unlike the movies he came to the right conclusion eventually but never got to see it through.
"But my memory reaches back even to the Elder Days. Earendil was my sire, who was born in Gondolin before its fall; and my mother was Elwing, daughter of Dior, son of Luthien of Doriath. I have seen three ages in the West of the world, and many defeats, and many fruitless victories." -- Elrond in The Fellowship of the Ring, "The Council of Elrond"
Unfortunately, due to his immortality, Elrond would go insane and lead the forces of Hydra in ww2 after a botched super soldier experiment. His whereabouts are unknown, but it's speculated that he was spotted leading people to a treasure he could not possess.
Many years after his spectral days at Vormir, he once again appeared as a powerful programming, an agent of the system and, like other Agents, had the role to police and maintain the Matrix by eliminating potential threats to the stability of the system, which were mostly seen to be Redpills and defunct programs. He was known as Agent Smith and was personified as stern, serious, and nearly invincible, as he was in the days in middle earth
You can't tell me Elrond don't have Abandonment issues. Father often absent cause Earendil was looking for Valinor. Elwing has Sirion to rule. Foster Fathers disappeared, one dead, the other singing until the ends of the world. A brother choosing mortality, Gil Galad burnt inside out, Celebrian tortured and left. Then his daughter chose mortality again. The dude life story is enough to have a series of his own.
I'd say he's a great father to Arwen and a great father figure to Aragorn, though, and I think the abandonment issues make that all the more impressive.
Well at least he remained friends with his parents-in-laws until the end of the Third Age. I wonder if Galadriel and Celeborn were ever able to give him some parental affection
15:03 Liv Tyler was Peter Jackson's best casting decision. Her Elvish pronunciation was breathtaking, sincere & flawless, her manner noble, and Arwen's face is now deservedly hers. A good example of a minor character that becomes unforgettable. You don't have to be the greatest actor ever to inhabit a role so as to own it.
might be the only time i wasn't mad at nepotism. she was the only one that could play that role and probably the one who will ever do that character justice. she was literally perfect for the role.
not saying this as an attempt to be a dick, more for the sake of discussion...but i honestly didn't like Arwen in the movies. she felt over dramatic and like she existed solely to slobber over Aragorn in every scene. it wasn't until the extended editions that she actually gained any modicum of character. (i say this as someone who hasn't read the books)
I find it so beautiful how Elrond was raised by someone who wasn't biologically related to him and later on raised someone who wasn't biologically related to him.
Yes, let us ignore that Elrond and Elros' twin uncles were abandoned to die alone after their foster father betrayed and murdered their grandfather, Díor. Let's also forget that Elrond and Elros were taken from their homes after they were destroyed by the greed and pride of the House of Fëanor, and that it was because of them that Elrond and Elros never saw their mother again. None of this is wholesome
Yes it was beautiful how ‘Middle Earth adoption’ worked in these stories… Things could have been much worse. It started with greed and murder and could have very well ended with more greed and murder. Elrond and his brother could have been killed off, Aragorn could have been thrown into the wilderness to die. As children, they wouldn’t have survived without protection. It’s nice that there were characters like the merciful uncle and Elrond to add some good into the tragic storyline. We choose what we want to focus on. Only the negative stuff or the positive redeeming things. It would have been nice to have seen a Dwarf get taken in by the Elves but that would have been asking for too much, lol.
@@moscanaveia But Maeglor was always a reluctant follower of his father and brothers. That doesn't excuse him, but nothing can change the fact that he did take the twins to raise, whereas Maedhros would either have abandoned or killed them.
3:34 I always feel a wave of sadness when I see that drawing of the two brothers. One now mortal and soon to die, while the other immortal now to lose his twin forever. Another pain for Elrond to endure as with the passing of his own daughter.
Another noteable thing about Elrond and his family; If you include his fosterage by Maglor and Maedhros as some form of parentage, it makes Arwen (by Elrond's marriage to Celebrian) the first being in Middle Earth to descend from the houses of Beor the old and Hador, and the people of Haleth, as well as all three Noldor houses AND the house of Thingol.
yep I always thought it this way! I am obsessed and in awe with their lineage so much. The bloodlines of Elladan, Elrohir and Arwen are pretty fascinating. Oh also wouldn't Arwen and her brothers have Teleri blood as well through their grandmother Galadriel. She's the daughter of Earwen who's the princess of the Teleri ( Earwen daughter of Olwe, king of the Teleri)
This was a beautiful and touching review of one of the most important characters in Tolkien’s legendarium. Well done! I particularly liked the way you treated Elrond’s fostering of Aragorn and his influence in his life. It is fascinating to think about the parallels between the union of Aragorn and Arwen and that of their mutual distant (for Aragorn) ancestors, Beren and Luthien. I love how in both stories the father sets an enormous bride price on his daughters hand that involves challenging the Dark Lord on his own throne. The obvious difference was that Luthien’s father was driven by jealousy and greed in his challenge of Beren to bring him one of the Silmarils from Morgoth’s crown. Elrond, on the other hand, is genuinely motivated by love of his brothers people and his heir, Aragorn. His sacrifice plays a major role in driving Aragorn to dedicate his life to the fight against Sauron.
I always think of Elrond looking up into the night sky and seeing his parents, Eärendil and Elwing, traverse it. It's truly mythic. But I do sometimes forget the tenderness of Maglor, their foster parent. Maglor was possibly the least obviously accomplished of Fëanor's children, but in this act of kindness he may have saved his father's legacy. Through Elrond and his immediate kin, and the eventual lineage of Elros, would the sins of Ñoldor be redeemed.
What do you mean by least obviously accomplished? I mean, he survived all the wars and battles of the first age. Not even the greatest elves have that accolade.
Least accomplished? Maglor Faenorion, Kanafinwe Makalaure, least accomplished? Oh my... He may have Nerdanel's gentleness but have you forgotten who his father is? Unlike Maedhros, Maglor didn't protest the burning of the ships. He was High King himself for thirty years throughout Maedhros torture. You got to have nerves of steel and diplomatic prowess to give up your brother for dead, rein in the Noldor, one group being Fingolfin's house who crossed the Grinding Ice and basically preventing a civil war to occur. He supported Maedhros and held Maglor's Gap for decades ensuring East Beleriand is safe. When they were betrayed in the Nirnaeth, Maglor personally took care of one of the main betrayers hunting him down throughout the chaos. He participated in all three kinslayings. And not to mention he is a freaking Bard. Songs are basically power in Tolkienverse and he's the greatest bard of all the Noldor. Maglor is loyal to his family and driven to a fault.
Elrond's story is legendary. He was born during the late years of the First Age when Morgoth plagued Middle-Earth. He fought in the War of the Last Alliance and the War of the Ring. His father was Earendil, but he was raised by Maglor from the House of Feanor.
Yeah Elrond’s dad is about the closest Jesus parallel you’ll find in Middle Earth, his brother was a God King for Middle Earth’s Roman Empire equivalent, he’s either related to or held in high regard by every other super important elf. The man is crazy.
@@delphinazizumbo8674Maglor was a prince and was once King Regent. Fought three battles against Morgoth, committed three kinslayings not to mention a powerful bard and we know singing is basically power. The twins being raised by Maglor would give them an edge though not good on their reputation.
The comments section of these videos demonstrates the scope and power of Tolkien's creation. We talk about these characters and stories as if they were authentic historical facts. It's both funny and endearing.
So true. But it’s real in the sense that fake characters represent real emotions, archetypes, experiences, and aspects of humanity. I read somewhere that Tolkien expressed the view that myth represents truth about humanity and its environment far better than the crude factuality of science is able to. It allows people to see in a new light what has become commonplace and drab. Although Elves, for instance, do not "exist" in a scientific sense, they embody the creative skill and immortality of the human spirit, and therefore do exist. As Tolkien put it, the storyteller "makes a Secondary World in which your mind can enter. Inside it, what he relates is "true": it accords with the laws of that world. You therefore believe it, while you are, as it were, inside". He called this process sub-creation: by creating a parallel world, the myth-maker emulates God, the supreme creator.
@@keyboarddancers7751 In what way embedded? I thought schools all over world are teaching the Hellenic Cultures. My high school is teaching the hellenic culture, specially the Trojan War. Though Tolkien based his legendarium in Norse Mythology. Bec in his youth, he wondered why Great Bretain has no mythology on its own. So he made his own.
Love the video! Elrond is such a timeless and classic character, he definitely led a hard life and lost so many people that he loved dearly. His lineage is just incredibly insane being 56% Elf, 37% Man and 6% Maia was always cool to me. Also just my head cannon which I mentioned in discord about his sons. I think that Elladan and Elrohir stayed behind at least until after Arwen passes and sailed or they wait and sail when Celeborn leaves in F.o.A 171.
Detach from this world and the distractions/pleasures in it.This world and the things in it are temporary, spend your time doing something that will matter in the long run. Do as much as you can to help other people while you are here so that you are ready to face Jesus on judgement day. The last 3000+ years of human history have been a testimony in favor of God's word. Contemplate how the Roman Empire fulfilled the role of the beast from the sea in Revelation 13. Revelation 17 confirms that it is in fact Rome. From this we can conclude that A) Jesus is the son of God and can tell the future or make it happen B) The world leaders/governments/nations etc have been conspiring together to accomplish this roadmap set in place by the Israelites or C) History as we know it is fake despite the archaeological evidence. You don't really need to speculate though because you can start a relationship with God and have proof. Call on the name of Jesus and pray for Him to intervene in your life - Revelation 3:20. The world is rapidly passing away and eventually you will have to stand before God on judgement day and explain to Him what you have done with your life. Make sure you are making every effort to help others while you can
Elrond has become my favorite character and you did a great job presenting his story. Look at everything that transpired throughout his life and got to give it up to him for remaining strong through it all.
It's not just a father putting a near impossible price on his daughters hand which is the most badass point. But deliberately placing it knowing full well that aragorn had the means to deliver them. He showed her immense value to him even when using her to encourage the man who will save the world into doing so. And what's even more badass is he gave up his own personal feelings against losing her to mortality and never sailing west with him, in order to save the world. He didn't even set it as a price for her hand, but for losing her companionship and life, and knew she was the drive and price he'd have to pay to save the world. So in depth it's unreal. Like real people with real dilemmas
I love how every time the elves look like they're going to be destroyed -- Unnumbered Tears, Elrond at Eregion, etc -- the dwarves show up, save them, and then just go home lol.
If memory doesn't the God that created elfs and the one who created the Dwarfs are really close, he is the one that sends Radagast the earth mage to middle earth to take care of the animals and plants of Middle earth which is why we don't see him along Saruman and Gandalf.
@@glcsander actually nope, but it's close in some ways. Eru Illúvatar created the elves and men, but the dwarves were created by Aule, Smith of the Valar (while him also being a creation of Illúvatar). Aule created the dwarves because he wanted someone to teach so bad but he couldn't give them independent lives and souls since he was not Eru. Later on, Eru Illúvatar confronts him about his creatures and Aule is ready to destroy the dwarves but Illúvatar has mercy on them and gives them souls. The Vala who sent Radagast/Aiwendil to Middle Earth is not Aule, but actually his wife, Yavanna.
@@bencebuda4599 not correcting, but adding that Aule eru mainly gave the dwarves true life because Aule made them out of a genuine love and desire for creation unlike melkor who would corrupt and twist things for his own rule.
@@NerdoftheRings thanks for the content, re -reading the books (silmarillion - to lord of the rings trilogy) lately and seeing how many things I just don't remember is awesome, but it's so much better when you add so much more to a world I love!
I love these summaries, and using Elrond as the focus of such a story almost sums up the ages Tolkien wrote down. It was wonderful to listen to. Thank you. From Alv, Norway.
Even though Elrond was an incredibly powerful leader, what I've always appreciated about him was how down to earth and accepting he was. His willingness to nurture others helped many of Middle Earth's greatest heroes succeed. His title as a healer extended far beyond just physical injuries.
One of my biggest complaints about the LoTR movies is how they handled Elrond. He comes off as cold and untrusting until almost the very end, which is so different from how he came off in the books
feel bad for elrond when you realized he never meet his twin brother again after 58 2nd Age and see his descendants fall twice in a very major way. still even after that he willingly fostered and support their heirs until Sauron Fall. truly an amazing character in the legendarium
Elros and Elrond both chose their fate aged 90. Only after that Elros took the throne as the First King of Numenor. Obviously they would have met until Elros' death in SA 442.
@@goodputin4324 Maybe true, despite i would love to see Elrond meet Elros in his final moment, this paragraph really bother me a lot. to quote : "There idea description in a late philological essay of the first meeting if the Nunenoreans with the Men of Eriador at that time: "it was six hundred years after the departure of the survivors of the Atani [Edain] over the sea to Numenor that a ship first came again out of the West to Middle-earth and passed up the Gulf of Lhun. Its captain and mariners were welcomed by Gil-galad; and thus was begun the friendship and alliance of Numenor with the Eldar of Lindon." Unfinished Tales, Aldarion and Erendis, Note 3 however there still a small chance that Elrond did sail to numenor thanks to ya boi Cirdan but it still a theory
@@goodputin4324 So they were 6 years old when they were taken in Sirion. And how many years were they fostered by the Feanorians? I always believed the twins were in their 30s or 40s and mayhaps joined with their foster fathers towards the end of the War of Wrath. And it was after the War of Wrath when they were given the choice by Eonwe. The timeline confuses me a little so I could be wrong. (I think I'm wrong. Can't seem to find a proper timeline)
Damn, the guy who plays Elrond in the Amazon series really looks nothing like the mighty and wise half elf you described in your video. They didn't even bother to give him the right hair colour, which they could have done easily. I just really hope that they don't butcher the character and story of one of the greatest beings that have ever lived in Middle Earth. They can do what they want to Galadriel and the rest but at least do justice to Elrond.
So much for that hope. They took an epic story and turned it into a soap opera, starring Guyladriel the Magnificent, who should've have very little to do with the story.
Loved this deep dive on Lord Elrond, thanks for making it! I have been a LOTR's and Hobbit fan for over 20 years, and I never knew about all the other stories of the 1st and 2nd Age or anything else until recently haha! Now I'm seriously addicted to all the lore, and I've watched almost all your video's already. I just ordered 'The Silmarillion' book and I'm excited to read it, but I've heard that it's a challenging read :)
This is such an awesome story to be told. Just imagine what Amazon COULD HAVE DONE with show about the histories of Middle Earth. Each season could have been a story arc that covers the lives of characters like Elrond and Galadriel and covered what happened over the courses of their long 1000s of years spent alive. I for one would love to see the tales of Fingolfin so that his battle against Morgoth could be brought to life. That would be one of THE MOST EPIC battles to be portrayed on screen ever if they would just damn do it right. Theres enough material in the tales of the Silmarillion to make episodic shows and even movies based on all the stuff in it for years and years and years.
Trully a character that you must love! For me one of the wisest and greatest warriors in all of legendarium! Im just hoping that Rings of Power show will cover him in a satisfying way... Nerd, once again great video!
Elrond's ancestry is the craziest thing ever. Descended from a Maiar, all three major groups of elves (noldor, Sindar, and Teleri) and 2 great houses of men.
Always loved his story and character so much ever since reading Tolkien and watching the movies & I'm such a fan of Robert Aramayo's portrayal of him in the series ❤️
In ancient Greek myth gods often mated with humans and twins were the result. One twin was usually mortal and the other divine. Castor and Pollux (Helen of Troy's brothers) decided to share fates and so are either mortal or divine on alternate days.
I'm not familiar with most Greek Myth twins but at least for Heracles and his twin it was a form of superfecundation. Twins with two different fathers. A mortal and a divine one. It's insanely rare but does happen in real life(minus the divine father).
The case of Tuor is a mistery. In The Silmarillion is stated that "in after days it was sung that Tuor alone of mortal Men was numbered among the elder race, and was joined with the Noldor, whom he loved; and his fate is sundered from the fate of Men". In Letter 153 Tolkien wrote: "Tuor weds Idril the daughter of Turgon King of Gondolin; and 'it is supposed' (not stated) that he as an unique exception receives the Elvish limited 'immortality': an exception either way". Not even the Professor confirmed Tuor was accounted among the Firstborns. Sure, it is something nice to consider, specially after everything he's been through and fought for. But in the end of the day, it's just another legend with no clear answer (or Elvish gossip, as I like to say, 🤭🤭🤭).
My fellow nerds! How often do you think Elrond thought of Elros? I’ve known a few pairs of twins very well and they did EVERYTHING together. Imagine that pain and love, especially after Elros’ passing. Do you think Elronds decisions were influenced by his love of his twin, even deep into the third age?
I would have to imagine they were. Identical twins are often two halves of a single whole. I find it curious that Tolkien never really went into detail on WHY the two of them chose separate races, instead of both making the same choice. My guess is that Elros took it to heart that Illuvatar himself referred to mortality not as the doom of men, but as "the gift of men", and trusted that there must be a reason for that. Given everything that Elrond experienced in his life, it may well be that Elros actually chose the easier path.
Thereupon Elrond paused a while and sighed. 'I remember well the splendour of their banners," he said. 'It recalled to me the glory of the Elder Days and the hosts of Beleriand, so many great princes and captains were assembled. And yet not so many, nor so fair, as when Thangorodrim was broken, and the Elves deemed that evil was ended forever, and it was not so.'
I have just subscribed to your channel. I congratulate you on your research, the pictures and portraits, and also your pronunciation of Tolkien's Elvish names. Back in the early 1990s, I was a member of the Oxford Tolkien Society. I have lost much knowledge, and intend to acquire again The Silmarillion, The Book of Lost Tales, Unfinished Tales, and the other publications by Christopher Tolkien, from whence The Hobbit came. I recommend these books, for the depth and breadth that the Internet cannot provide. The best ways of learning do not have an on/off switch. I salute you.
Yeah it is nice to know that when Elrond left his daughter and sons on Middle-Earth from the Grey Havens, it's good to now know that his wife was waiting for him on the other side in Valinor! This reminds me of Maximus from Gladiator. Although he dies and must leave Lucius and Lucilla, he is then able to rejoin with his wife and son in the afterlife!
I swear everyone’s story in lord of the rings is so beautiful. A book or movie or series could be written about every individual and have a beautiful story.
Man, to think that an elf as young as Elrond could have gone through so much. (Yes, kinda young, at least in comparison to those who'd seen the light of the Trees. Folks like Galadriel and especially Cirdan are practically eldritch in comparison to his 6k plus years, especially if you use the longer length for the Years of the Trees in Valinor. I think Glorfindel is significantly older.)
Imagine your father in law being the legendary brother of the guy who literally founded your civilization, people, and bloodline thousands of years ago. Aragorn is just that guy
Thingol to Beren: Bring me a Silmaril from the hands of dark lord to marry my daughter. Elrond to Aragorn: Defeat the dark lord, reunite the great kingdom and become the high king to marry my daughter. And incredibly so, they both did it. This elven maids must be worth it.
Next to Galadriel he's one of the most important elves in Tolkien's universe. To bad that fact isn't good enough for Amazons LOTRTROP show. Its clear in their quest to highlight how great she really was they're actually dragging her down to the level of a mere warrior when she was something much greater. While at the same time dragging Elrond down even hard to an ignorant politician who owns a nice variety of hair brushes made from mithril.
17:19 based on this description, they absolutely nailed the look with Hugo Weaving in the PJ films. I wish they could have shown his love for Aragorn more but the scene where he bestows Anduril is even more amazing with the quote from Aragorn’s mother and the fact that Elrond loves Aragorn as his son.
would be cool if you made a ”travels of shadowfax” or maybe a video about mainly shadowfax and also about horses in general. So for example about the horse of Oromë too.
I really appreciate your knowledge. I'm jumping around just to know more. I've read the Trilogy and the Hobbit fully yet not even ready to tackle the Silmarillion. Just thanks and keep being amazing. You still are the best.
I kinda wish that they would make a show that showed us what it looked like with Aragorn bringing peace to the realm, watching him fight the Corsairs and Easterlings, and dealing with Sauron's lingering influence over them
Fantastic as always. I'm very curious what Elrond's life looked like in the large unaccounted for gaps in his history, particularly the first thousand or so years in both the 2nd and 3rd age. Hopefully the Rings of Power show will deliver and do Elrond's character justice
It truly did, in my opinion! It showed him as this wise, charismatic and gentle being, although a much younger Elrond - a way less bitter one than the PJ movies Elrond. In the series, he's truly "kind as summer"
![SAFEPLANET - ดาวเคราะห์ [ THE PLANET ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4X1XL3I_k3c/mqdefault.jpg)
Which character should I cover next? Are you still waiting for NOTR to cover your favorite??
Save 20% off your order with the code: NERDOFTHERINGS at SlideBelts.com !
(If youre not done this) Imrahil
A few possibilities if you’ve not already done. Ulmo, Dain Ironfoot, also possibly the story of the Ring of Barahir?
Have you done saramaun and balin
One of the Feanorians, possibly Maglor Feanorian
the necromancer
Gotta love a guy who sets his daughter's bridal price as "Save the world by defeating the last great evil on Earth in war, reclaim your long vacant throne, and restore honor of my brother's household" before giving his blessing. But Aragorn pulls through.
I love it so much!! ✨
Yes, that is badass from Estel, but I think King Thingol's demand for Tinúviel was even harsher: go a steal the most precious possession from Morgoth himself. And to Beren's credit, he pulled that off.
Jacob,
A great improvement from his ancestor who sets the bride price to just steal a jewel from the devil, but otherwise does not requires anything else. Also an improvement from his other ancestor who basically arrange the marriage with the father of the groom because he thought the father of the groom is his son.
"Come over, my ancestors aren't home"
It’s like when Thingol told Beren to get a Silmaril off Morgoth’s crown in exchange for Luthien’s hand. That’s one hell of a dowry.
Elrond exemplifies everything it is to be an elf - he lost his father, mother, brother and daughter. Never to see them again and yet he endured. After Finrod, he has been the greatest Elven teacher to men. He fought, and he healed.
He submitted to Gil-Galad's reign despite being a descendant of a Maiar. And when he created his own 'realm', it was not one of strength and fortitude but of peace and hospitality.
His parents are at least in Valinor, most likely. If not, then they'd be in the Halls of Mandos, where he could still potentially see them again. They're not completely beyond possibility for him to see again.
Arwen and Elros, however, are truly beyond the possibility of him ever seeing again, at least before the end of the world. And aside from Luthien (and *maybe* Elladan and Elrohir, who Tolkien never specified their choices), they're the only two Elf/Half-Elf souls to depart Arda. Even the end of the world (where the world is made anew and Men take part of the second Song with Eru and the Valar) isnt a guarantee, since (iirc) Tolkien never actually settled on whether Elves are part of the Second Song/new Arda or not
@Broadway JR His parents are flying in the skies actually. Also, won't Feanor "reincarnated" break the Silmarils and restore the light of the two trees? Though I'm not sure if that's before, during or after the Dagor Dagorlath.
That is so poetic!
Though he ironically is very different from the elves as he has a far more easy going nature and is far more open minded.
@@aminiqbal4907Only Eärendil is sailing in Vingilótë across Ilmen while Elwing waits for him in Elwing’s tower northward upon the borders of the Sundering Seas. She only flies like a bird to meet her husband whenever he returns from his voyages.
I love Elrond. He's that rare Elf who understood and lived with the weight of love and sacrifice. Every choice he made honored his family and his kin. I've always imagined that like his father, he eventually meets Manwe. And that Manwe would embrace him and say, "My son, you have done well. You make us proud!"
Alongside Cirdan
Detach from this world and the distractions/pleasures in it.This world and the things in it are temporary, spend your time doing something that will matter in the long run. Do as much as you can to help other people while you are here so that you are ready to face Jesus on judgement day. The last 3000+ years of human history have been a testimony in favor of God's word. Contemplate how the Roman Empire fulfilled the role of the beast from the sea in Revelation 13. Revelation 17 confirms that it is in fact Rome. From this we can conclude that A) Jesus is the son of God and can tell the future or make it happen B) The world leaders/governments/nations etc have been conspiring together to accomplish this roadmap set in place by the Israelites or C) History as we know it is fake despite the archaeological evidence. You don't really need to speculate though because you can start a relationship with God and have proof.
Call on the name of Jesus and pray for Him to intervene in your life - Revelation 3:20. The world is rapidly passing away and eventually you will have to stand before God on judgement day and explain to Him what you have done with your life. Make sure you are making every effort to help others while you can
Hopefully more than one plaudits, but gets invited to Manwe's potluck luncheon on his birthday every year.
I love Elrond too. I'm actually going as him for Halloween this year.
Legolas also has those qualities. Goes into many dangers for aragorn when he could have turned away.
I can imagine situation, when Elrond teachs his sons history of Middle-Earth: "Do you see that bright star near horizon? That's my father." *Deadly serious*
Also one of my foster fathers may or may not be endlessly wandering the shore right now.
@@Olivia-W and another commited suicide. As one unknown tolkienist poet said(about Fëanor and his sons): 'this family is flawed and their bite is as bad as their bark.'
7:40 one important detail here was Isildur was going to ask Elrond for council about what to do with the ring on his way back north. After possessing it for awhile and not being able to bend it to his will he knew he had to do something. He could tell the ring was more like to slowly have an effect on him than the other way around. So unlike the movies he came to the right conclusion eventually but never got to see it through.
"But my memory reaches back even to the Elder Days. Earendil was my sire, who was born in Gondolin before its fall; and my mother was Elwing, daughter of Dior, son of Luthien of Doriath. I have seen three ages in the West of the world, and many defeats, and many fruitless victories." -- Elrond in The Fellowship of the Ring, "The Council of Elrond"
Unfortunately, due to his immortality, Elrond would go insane and lead the forces of Hydra in ww2 after a botched super soldier experiment. His whereabouts are unknown, but it's speculated that he was spotted leading people to a treasure he could not possess.
Many years after his spectral days at Vormir, he once again appeared as a powerful programming, an agent of the system and, like other Agents, had the role to police and maintain the Matrix by eliminating potential threats to the stability of the system, which were mostly seen to be Redpills and defunct programs. He was known as Agent Smith and was personified as stern, serious, and nearly invincible, as he was in the days in middle earth
😂 good one 😂
Oh, brother... 🙄 That's almost like mixing metaphors.
So it was true, the purpose of elrond has finally been found its faith has tide into the stone that he once possessed
This is my world, MY WORLD!
You can't tell me Elrond don't have Abandonment issues. Father often absent cause Earendil was looking for Valinor. Elwing has Sirion to rule. Foster Fathers disappeared, one dead, the other singing until the ends of the world. A brother choosing mortality, Gil Galad burnt inside out, Celebrian tortured and left. Then his daughter chose mortality again. The dude life story is enough to have a series of his own.
It was his curse for breaking unbreakable oath
He may have met his grandfather Tuor when he sailed to Valinor
I'd say he's a great father to Arwen and a great father figure to Aragorn, though, and I think the abandonment issues make that all the more impressive.
@@kerankerai7872 What oath was that?
Well at least he remained friends with his parents-in-laws until the end of the Third Age. I wonder if Galadriel and Celeborn were ever able to give him some parental affection
15:03 Liv Tyler was Peter Jackson's best casting decision. Her Elvish pronunciation was breathtaking, sincere & flawless, her manner noble, and Arwen's face is now deservedly hers. A good example of a minor character that becomes unforgettable. You don't have to be the greatest actor ever to inhabit a role so as to own it.
Not only the cast, but the decision to give her a greater role than she had in the books turned out to be spot on as well.
Agreed, she was phenomenal. Man, that whole cast was fantastic. You really just don’t see casts that good/fitting anymore
might be the only time i wasn't mad at nepotism. she was the only one that could play that role and probably the one who will ever do that character justice. she was literally perfect for the role.
I mean, all that applies to Cate Blanchett, too, apart from the minor character thing
not saying this as an attempt to be a dick, more for the sake of discussion...but i honestly didn't like Arwen in the movies. she felt over dramatic and like she existed solely to slobber over Aragorn in every scene. it wasn't until the extended editions that she actually gained any modicum of character.
(i say this as someone who hasn't read the books)
I find it so beautiful how Elrond was raised by someone who wasn't biologically related to him and later on raised someone who wasn't biologically related to him.
Yes, let us ignore that Elrond and Elros' twin uncles were abandoned to die alone after their foster father betrayed and murdered their grandfather, Díor. Let's also forget that Elrond and Elros were taken from their homes after they were destroyed by the greed and pride of the House of Fëanor, and that it was because of them that Elrond and Elros never saw their mother again. None of this is wholesome
@@moscanaveia Dang, man, I was just saying how I saw it. Thanks for putting it into perspective, though. You make a fine point.
Yes it was beautiful how ‘Middle Earth adoption’ worked in these stories…
Things could have been much worse. It started with greed and murder and could have very well ended with more greed and murder. Elrond and his brother could have been killed off, Aragorn could have been thrown into the wilderness to die. As children, they wouldn’t have survived without protection. It’s nice that there were characters like the merciful uncle and Elrond to add some good into the tragic storyline.
We choose what we want to focus on. Only the negative stuff or the positive redeeming things.
It would have been nice to have seen a Dwarf get taken in by the Elves but that would have been asking for too much, lol.
@@moscanaveia But Maeglor was always a reluctant follower of his father and brothers. That doesn't excuse him, but nothing can change the fact that he did take the twins to raise, whereas Maedhros would either have abandoned or killed them.
Aragorn and Arwen step-siblings, so beautiful
3:34 I always feel a wave of sadness when I see that drawing of the two brothers. One now mortal and soon to die, while the other immortal now to lose his twin forever. Another pain for Elrond to endure as with the passing of his own daughter.
Another noteable thing about Elrond and his family; If you include his fosterage by Maglor and Maedhros as some form of parentage, it makes Arwen (by Elrond's marriage to Celebrian) the first being in Middle Earth to descend from the houses of Beor the old and Hador, and the people of Haleth, as well as all three Noldor houses AND the house of Thingol.
yep I always thought it this way! I am obsessed and in awe with their lineage so much. The bloodlines of Elladan, Elrohir and Arwen are pretty fascinating.
Oh also wouldn't Arwen and her brothers have Teleri blood as well through their grandmother Galadriel. She's the daughter of Earwen who's the princess of the Teleri ( Earwen daughter of Olwe, king of the Teleri)
That is an awesome point of view
@Legal Inuman Sessions also a very fair point. She’d be the first second I suppose
@Legal Inuman Sessions I don’t think it’s an implication, just an accident, which is very common in this world we call middle earth
@@TheCradM doesn’t she also have two older brothers?
This was a beautiful and touching review of one of the most important characters in Tolkien’s legendarium. Well done! I particularly liked the way you treated Elrond’s fostering of Aragorn and his influence in his life. It is fascinating to think about the parallels between the union of Aragorn and Arwen and that of their mutual distant (for Aragorn) ancestors, Beren and Luthien. I love how in both stories the father sets an enormous bride price on his daughters hand that involves challenging the Dark Lord on his own throne. The obvious difference was that Luthien’s father was driven by jealousy and greed in his challenge of Beren to bring him one of the Silmarils from Morgoth’s crown. Elrond, on the other hand, is genuinely motivated by love of his brothers people and his heir, Aragorn. His sacrifice plays a major role in driving Aragorn to dedicate his life to the fight against Sauron.
I always think of Elrond looking up into the night sky and seeing his parents, Eärendil and Elwing, traverse it. It's truly mythic. But I do sometimes forget the tenderness of Maglor, their foster parent. Maglor was possibly the least obviously accomplished of Fëanor's children, but in this act of kindness he may have saved his father's legacy. Through Elrond and his immediate kin, and the eventual lineage of Elros, would the sins of Ñoldor be redeemed.
What do you mean by least obviously accomplished? I mean, he survived all the wars and battles of the first age. Not even the greatest elves have that accolade.
Least accomplished? Maglor Faenorion, Kanafinwe Makalaure, least accomplished? Oh my... He may have Nerdanel's gentleness but have you forgotten who his father is? Unlike Maedhros, Maglor didn't protest the burning of the ships. He was High King himself for thirty years throughout Maedhros torture. You got to have nerves of steel and diplomatic prowess to give up your brother for dead, rein in the Noldor, one group being Fingolfin's house who crossed the Grinding Ice and basically preventing a civil war to occur. He supported Maedhros and held Maglor's Gap for decades ensuring East Beleriand is safe. When they were betrayed in the Nirnaeth, Maglor personally took care of one of the main betrayers hunting him down throughout the chaos. He participated in all three kinslayings. And not to mention he is a freaking Bard. Songs are basically power in Tolkienverse and he's the greatest bard of all the Noldor. Maglor is loyal to his family and driven to a fault.
OK, Maglor fans. :) I deeply apologize for calling him the "least obviously accomplished".
@@EmblemParadethe Least accomplished of Faenor's line are the Ambarussa. I agree with the Itachi comment above.
The "could heal the body, not the mind" thing really hits home with PTSD
Tolkien fought in WW1 and lived through WW2. He understood this stuff on a personal level.
@@jacobnisley6581 I know, that's kinda why I said that...
Elrond's story is legendary. He was born during the late years of the First Age when Morgoth plagued Middle-Earth. He fought in the War of the Last Alliance and the War of the Ring. His father was Earendil, but he was raised by Maglor from the House of Feanor.
Yeah Elrond’s dad is about the closest Jesus parallel you’ll find in Middle Earth, his brother was a God King for Middle Earth’s Roman Empire equivalent, he’s either related to or held in high regard by every other super important elf. The man is crazy.
He also fought in the war of elves and sauron in the second age and against angmar in the third age
maglor was a psychopath
@@delphinazizumbo8674Maglor was a prince and was once King Regent. Fought three battles against Morgoth, committed three kinslayings not to mention a powerful bard and we know singing is basically power. The twins being raised by Maglor would give them an edge though not good on their reputation.
Really cool to think when Thorin’s company goes to Rivendell, 10 year old Aragorn is there.
The comments section of these videos demonstrates the scope and power of Tolkien's creation. We talk about these characters and stories as if they were authentic historical facts. It's both funny and endearing.
In history class when the teacher asks you to write a piece about a key event in history:
"It began with the forging of the great rings"
@@Mattkayina lolol
Tolkien himself called his body of works as Legendarium. As a parallel to the Helenic Culture of the Gods of Olympus.
So true. But it’s real in the sense that fake characters represent real emotions, archetypes, experiences, and aspects of humanity. I read somewhere that Tolkien expressed the view that myth represents truth about humanity and its environment far better than the crude factuality of science is able to. It allows people to see in a new light what has become commonplace and drab. Although Elves, for instance, do not "exist" in a scientific sense, they embody the creative skill and immortality of the human spirit, and therefore do exist. As Tolkien put it, the storyteller "makes a Secondary World in which your mind can enter. Inside it, what he relates is "true": it accords with the laws of that world. You therefore believe it, while you are, as it were, inside". He called this process sub-creation: by creating a parallel world, the myth-maker emulates God, the supreme creator.
@@keyboarddancers7751 In what way embedded? I thought schools all over world are teaching the Hellenic Cultures. My high school is teaching the hellenic culture, specially the Trojan War. Though Tolkien based his legendarium in Norse Mythology. Bec in his youth, he wondered why Great Bretain has no mythology on its own. So he made his own.
Love the video! Elrond is such a timeless and classic character, he definitely led a hard life and lost so many people that he loved dearly. His lineage is just incredibly insane being 56% Elf, 37% Man and 6% Maia was always cool to me. Also just my head cannon which I mentioned in discord about his sons. I think that Elladan and Elrohir stayed behind at least until after Arwen passes and sailed or they wait and sail when Celeborn leaves in F.o.A 171.
That's 99%
@@themechanictangerine1% badass 😂😂
@@vatanasevda 100% badass
Elrond the one who is part Maiar, Elf, and man! That is one hell of a lineage!
It warms my heart to learn that Shadowfax went to the Undying Lands. 😌
Gonna need some meat during the journey on the ship ...
@@obikenobi8855 😳 Stop horsing around.
@@obikenobi8855atleast his legs..he dont need those😀
@@hydraliskin ohh they look so tasty 😋
Bill was the real one
The story of Elrond's wife is so sad, hopefully they had had a great reunion in Valinor.
Detach from this world and the distractions/pleasures in it.This world and the things in it are temporary, spend your time doing something that will matter in the long run. Do as much as you can to help other people while you are here so that you are ready to face Jesus on judgement day. The last 3000+ years of human history have been a testimony in favor of God's word. Contemplate how the Roman Empire fulfilled the role of the beast from the sea in Revelation 13. Revelation 17 confirms that it is in fact Rome. From this we can conclude that A) Jesus is the son of God and can tell the future or make it happen B) The world leaders/governments/nations etc have been conspiring together to accomplish this roadmap set in place by the Israelites or C) History as we know it is fake despite the archaeological evidence. You don't really need to speculate though because you can start a relationship with God and have proof.
Call on the name of Jesus and pray for Him to intervene in your life - Revelation 3:20. The world is rapidly passing away and eventually you will have to stand before God on judgement day and explain to Him what you have done with your life. Make sure you are making every effort to help others while you can
Very common for elves to have a life of sorrow and growing wisdom.
"Hey honey, where's our daughter?"
Elrond has become my favorite character and you did a great job presenting his story. Look at everything that transpired throughout his life and got to give it up to him for remaining strong through it all.
It's not just a father putting a near impossible price on his daughters hand which is the most badass point. But deliberately placing it knowing full well that aragorn had the means to deliver them. He showed her immense value to him even when using her to encourage the man who will save the world into doing so. And what's even more badass is he gave up his own personal feelings against losing her to mortality and never sailing west with him, in order to save the world. He didn't even set it as a price for her hand, but for losing her companionship and life, and knew she was the drive and price he'd have to pay to save the world.
So in depth it's unreal. Like real people with real dilemmas
I love how every time the elves look like they're going to be destroyed -- Unnumbered Tears, Elrond at Eregion, etc -- the dwarves show up, save them, and then just go home lol.
The best kind of ally.
If memory doesn't the God that created elfs and the one who created the Dwarfs are really close, he is the one that sends Radagast the earth mage to middle earth to take care of the animals and plants of Middle earth which is why we don't see him along Saruman and Gandalf.
@@glcsander actually nope, but it's close in some ways.
Eru Illúvatar created the elves and men, but the dwarves were created by Aule, Smith of the Valar (while him also being a creation of Illúvatar). Aule created the dwarves because he wanted someone to teach so bad but he couldn't give them independent lives and souls since he was not Eru. Later on, Eru Illúvatar confronts him about his creatures and Aule is ready to destroy the dwarves but Illúvatar has mercy on them and gives them souls.
The Vala who sent Radagast/Aiwendil to Middle Earth is not Aule, but actually his wife, Yavanna.
@@bencebuda4599 thanks
@@bencebuda4599 not correcting, but adding that Aule eru mainly gave the dwarves true life because Aule made them out of a genuine love and desire for creation unlike melkor who would corrupt and twist things for his own rule.
Elrond was pretty much part of almost everything, from the War of Wrath and Melkor to the end of the Third Age. Stories he could tell...
That picture of old Elros and forever-young Elrond saying goodbye at 3:40 tears my heart out of my chest every time I see it.
Unfortunately Numenoreans started travelling to Middle Earth only around 150 years after Elros died, so that scene never actually happened 😢
@@giorgiograffino3724 it’s not a stretch to assume Elrond visited his brother in Númenor when he could.
The artistry in this is so incredibly amazing!!!
*When Elrond arrives in Valinor
Celebrían: Honey, where are the kids?
Elrond: 👁️👄👁️
Elrond: uh... They're on their way.
@@TheMightyCrucibleKnight184 They're on their way, just give them a little more time. Let's say another thousand years.
I've been looking forward to this for so long!!!!! Easily one of my favorite elves!!!
Mine too! Elrond is such a great character!
@@NerdoftheRings thanks for the content, re -reading the books (silmarillion - to lord of the rings trilogy) lately and seeing how many things I just don't remember is awesome, but it's so much better when you add so much more to a world I love!
Love the change in music. It was beautiful and quite appropriate.
I love these summaries, and using Elrond as the focus of such a story almost sums up the ages Tolkien wrote down. It was wonderful to listen to. Thank you. From Alv, Norway.
Even though Elrond was an incredibly powerful leader, what I've always appreciated about him was how down to earth and accepting he was. His willingness to nurture others helped many of Middle Earth's greatest heroes succeed. His title as a healer extended far beyond just physical injuries.
Elrond is one of my favorite characters he cares about people and he is very hospitable !
One of my biggest complaints about the LoTR movies is how they handled Elrond. He comes off as cold and untrusting until almost the very end, which is so different from how he came off in the books
If Jackson had made a word for word movie series it would be three ages long 😂. And if I was immortal I would watch them over and over.
feel bad for elrond when you realized he never meet his twin brother again after 58 2nd Age and see his descendants fall twice in a very major way. still even after that he willingly fostered and support their heirs until Sauron Fall. truly an amazing character in the legendarium
Elros and Elrond both chose their fate aged 90. Only after that Elros took the throne as the First King of Numenor. Obviously they would have met until Elros' death in SA 442.
@@goodputin4324 Maybe true, despite i would love to see Elrond meet Elros in his final moment, this paragraph really bother me a lot. to quote :
"There idea description in a late philological essay of the first meeting if the Nunenoreans with the Men of Eriador at that time: "it was six hundred years after the departure of the survivors of the Atani [Edain] over the sea to Numenor that a ship first came again out of the West to Middle-earth and passed up the Gulf of Lhun. Its captain and mariners were welcomed by Gil-galad; and thus was begun the friendship and alliance of Numenor with the Eldar of Lindon."
Unfinished Tales, Aldarion and Erendis, Note 3
however there still a small chance that Elrond did sail to numenor thanks to ya boi Cirdan but it still a theory
@@goodputin4324 So they were 6 years old when they were taken in Sirion. And how many years were they fostered by the Feanorians? I always believed the twins were in their 30s or 40s and mayhaps joined with their foster fathers towards the end of the War of Wrath. And it was after the War of Wrath when they were given the choice by Eonwe. The timeline confuses me a little so I could be wrong. (I think I'm wrong. Can't seem to find a proper timeline)
Awesome job!!!! Would you consider doing a what if Faramir went to Rivendell instead of his brother?
Damn, the guy who plays Elrond in the Amazon series really looks nothing like the mighty and wise half elf you described in your video. They didn't even bother to give him the right hair colour, which they could have done easily. I just really hope that they don't butcher the character and story of one of the greatest beings that have ever lived in Middle Earth. They can do what they want to Galadriel and the rest but at least do justice to Elrond.
So much for that hope. They took an epic story and turned it into a soap opera, starring Guyladriel the Magnificent, who should've have very little to do with the story.
Loved this deep dive on Lord Elrond, thanks for making it! I have been a LOTR's and Hobbit fan for over 20 years, and I never knew about all the other stories of the 1st and 2nd Age or anything else until recently haha! Now I'm seriously addicted to all the lore, and I've watched almost all your video's already. I just ordered 'The Silmarillion' book and I'm excited to read it, but I've heard that it's a challenging read :)
Oooh yess. You can't read it just once. Prepare a notebook too just in case. It gets better every reread and more and more tragic.
I always smile when I think about Elrond (and Galadriel, for that matter) being reunited with Celebrían. In my mind, they lived happily ever after 😤
This is such an awesome story to be told. Just imagine what Amazon COULD HAVE DONE with show about the histories of Middle Earth. Each season could have been a story arc that covers the lives of characters like Elrond and Galadriel and covered what happened over the courses of their long 1000s of years spent alive. I for one would love to see the tales of Fingolfin so that his battle against Morgoth could be brought to life. That would be one of THE MOST EPIC battles to be portrayed on screen ever if they would just damn do it right. Theres enough material in the tales of the Silmarillion to make episodic shows and even movies based on all the stuff in it for years and years and years.
Amazon cannot make anything in the Silmarillion. They own nothing but the rights to the trilogy and it's appendices
@@SilentSolvent I know that, thats why this is going to suck balrog balls.
@sara-stinabergstedt3019 They ruined everything. RoP is an abomination.
Damn bro every one of these has me misty-eyed, fantastic work.
Trully a character that you must love! For me one of the wisest and greatest warriors in all of legendarium! Im just hoping that Rings of Power show will cover him in a satisfying way...
Nerd, once again great video!
Elrond's ancestry is the craziest thing ever. Descended from a Maiar, all three major groups of elves (noldor, Sindar, and Teleri) and 2 great houses of men.
Always loved his story and character so much ever since reading Tolkien and watching the movies & I'm such a fan of Robert Aramayo's portrayal of him in the series ❤️
Thank you for that last little ending on a good note! His story was so sad, it's nice to be reminded of him returning to his great love.
The Second Age. And this was the Age in which Elrond would truly make a name for himself as one of the key players in the fate of Middle Earth.
Yes! I love when you cover Elrond!
Imagine looking up almost every night for thousands of years, seeing Eärendil/Venus, and being like "Yep, that's my dad up there."
it canonically sucks, and that's putting it lightly. But man is it romantic in a way.
Wait, what? Eärendil's Earth equivalent is Venus? So Elrond's dad is basically Lucifer or smth, then.........
i don‘t get how that works. Is Earendil like literally up there alone? How does his days look?
In ancient Greek myth gods often mated with humans and twins were the result. One twin was usually mortal and the other divine. Castor and Pollux (Helen of Troy's brothers) decided to share fates and so are either mortal or divine on alternate days.
I'm not familiar with most Greek Myth twins but at least for Heracles and his twin it was a form of superfecundation. Twins with two different fathers. A mortal and a divine one. It's insanely rare but does happen in real life(minus the divine father).
0:43 today's video is sponsored by the thing I feared the most as a delinquent child
Lol you right
Not just his wife Elronds mother, father, Tuor and his wife a great family reunion in the undying lands
The case of Tuor is a mistery. In The Silmarillion is stated that "in after days it was sung that Tuor alone of mortal Men was numbered among the elder race, and was joined with the Noldor, whom he loved; and his fate is sundered from the fate of Men".
In Letter 153 Tolkien wrote: "Tuor weds Idril the daughter of Turgon King of Gondolin; and 'it is supposed' (not stated) that he as an unique exception receives the Elvish limited 'immortality': an exception either way".
Not even the Professor confirmed Tuor was accounted among the Firstborns. Sure, it is something nice to consider, specially after everything he's been through and fought for. But in the end of the day, it's just another legend with no clear answer (or Elvish gossip, as I like to say, 🤭🤭🤭).
I cannot imagine living thousands of years and literally seeing a family line go extinct and caring for so many of the heirs.
My fellow nerds! How often do you think Elrond thought of Elros? I’ve known a few pairs of twins very well and they did EVERYTHING together. Imagine that pain and love, especially after Elros’ passing. Do you think Elronds decisions were influenced by his love of his twin, even deep into the third age?
I would have to imagine they were. Identical twins are often two halves of a single whole. I find it curious that Tolkien never really went into detail on WHY the two of them chose separate races, instead of both making the same choice. My guess is that Elros took it to heart that Illuvatar himself referred to mortality not as the doom of men, but as "the gift of men", and trusted that there must be a reason for that. Given everything that Elrond experienced in his life, it may well be that Elros actually chose the easier path.
Truly Lord Elrond is immortal, you can find him up to this day in Australia . He just recently celebrated his 6,200 birthdays🥰.
Amazingly told story here dude, the visuals are so clean n crisp and well timed explanation also
Thereupon Elrond paused a while and sighed. 'I remember well the splendour of their banners," he said. 'It recalled to me the glory of the Elder Days and the hosts of Beleriand, so many great princes and captains were assembled. And yet not so many, nor so fair, as when Thangorodrim was broken, and the Elves deemed that evil was ended forever, and it was not so.'
Favourite series on TH-cam
Well met sir! Excellent analysis and info as ALWAYS! Keep up the great work Mellon! Ecthelion!!!
I have just subscribed to your channel. I congratulate you on your research, the pictures and portraits, and also your pronunciation of Tolkien's Elvish names. Back in the early 1990s, I was a member of the Oxford Tolkien Society. I have lost much knowledge, and intend to acquire again The Silmarillion, The Book of Lost Tales, Unfinished Tales, and the other publications by Christopher Tolkien, from whence The Hobbit came. I recommend these books, for the depth and breadth that the Internet cannot provide. The best ways of learning do not have an on/off switch. I salute you.
The life of Elrond alone would make a good TV series
Great video 👏 by far the best Tolkien page on TH-cam love it 🤌🤌 would love a video on maglor son of feanor
The fact that people in the comments talk about this as though it was historical makes me proud to be among the Tolkien fandom.
No different from being a Mormon or Christian. Except Tolkien's fiction is better thought out .
Yeah it is nice to know that when Elrond left his daughter and sons on Middle-Earth from the Grey Havens, it's good to now know that his wife was waiting for him on the other side in Valinor!
This reminds me of Maximus from Gladiator. Although he dies and must leave Lucius and Lucilla, he is then able to rejoin with his wife and son in the afterlife!
"Mr. Anderson" - Elrond says calmly... 🙈
For many years I have suppressed my inner nerd. Now I feel it awaken anew.
I love all your videos! They have given me so much more knowledge of the world of tolkien, which has also given me alot of joy! Thank you
I'm from Portugal and i love your channel. Continue with the very good work! :)
I swear everyone’s story in lord of the rings is so beautiful. A book or movie or series could be written about every individual and have a beautiful story.
Man, to think that an elf as young as Elrond could have gone through so much. (Yes, kinda young, at least in comparison to those who'd seen the light of the Trees. Folks like Galadriel and especially Cirdan are practically eldritch in comparison to his 6k plus years, especially if you use the longer length for the Years of the Trees in Valinor. I think Glorfindel is significantly older.)
Darn the commericals! I guess they are necessary, but I miss the pre-commerical days - it soils the message, there is no way around it.
Imagine your father in law being the legendary brother of the guy who literally founded your civilization, people, and bloodline thousands of years ago. Aragorn is just that guy
I've waited for this!! Aahhh!! Great great video, as always!
Thingol to Beren: Bring me a Silmaril from the hands of dark lord to marry my daughter.
Elrond to Aragorn: Defeat the dark lord, reunite the great kingdom and become the high king to marry my daughter.
And incredibly so, they both did it.
This elven maids must be worth it.
Next to Galadriel he's one of the most important elves in Tolkien's universe. To bad that fact isn't good enough for Amazons LOTRTROP show. Its clear in their quest to highlight how great she really was they're actually dragging her down to the level of a mere warrior when she was something much greater. While at the same time dragging Elrond down even hard to an ignorant politician who owns a nice variety of hair brushes made from mithril.
Is she older than him ?
@@ashoush85 yeah, by quite a lot. Galadriel was around when the Two Trees still lived (born during Years of the Trees), Elrond was born in First Age
Elrond is not in Rings of Power, just some gay, dorky elf with a ridiculous haircut that happens to share his name and be bff's with Guyladriel.
Elrond is one of the badass Elves of all time, I wish in the new TV series they won't suck at reflecting his true characteristics
What a great character Elrond is...😌 Great video)❤
17:19 based on this description, they absolutely nailed the look with Hugo Weaving in the PJ films. I wish they could have shown his love for Aragorn more but the scene where he bestows Anduril is even more amazing with the quote from Aragorn’s mother and the fact that Elrond loves Aragorn as his son.
Man it’s gonna be so cool watching Elrond NOT lead the Elves to war in Rings of Power since Galadriel is doing that now.
11:19 Probably the most book-accurate depiction of Orcs I've ever seen
would be cool if you made a ”travels of shadowfax” or maybe a video about mainly shadowfax and also about horses in general. So for example about the horse of Oromë too.
So Elrond is Aragon's multi generational uncle.
Man, even in the fan art he looks like Hugo Weaving.
One of the reasons people watch live actions despite some of it 'sucking' is to have a reference for their beloved characters.
I really appreciate your knowledge. I'm jumping around just to know more. I've read the Trilogy and the Hobbit fully yet not even ready to tackle the Silmarillion. Just thanks and keep being amazing. You still are the best.
One of the best videos of yours, man. Well done
great video as always
Elrond, "my father turned into a star."
"That's rough buddy."
One of your best!! Thank you!!!
Really wish they would make a series or a film on Aragorn and his time as a ranger, it’d be super interesting and filled with lore.
Someone did a kow budget film about that a long time ago. It was quite good
The one dear to him waiting.
That was sweet.
I didnt think about it before but dwarves sending members to elrond means alot
I kinda wish that they would make a show that showed us what it looked like with Aragorn bringing peace to the realm, watching him fight the Corsairs and Easterlings, and dealing with Sauron's lingering influence over them
Omg i dont have the time to watch this right now but YEY i'm so happy I'll watch it as SOON AS I CAN
One of my favorite characters. So cool.
I didn't know what a belt buckle could all do. Impressive!
Great video!
That's a lot of pressure on Aragorn.
"I gave up immortality for you!"
"FIne! We'll get ANOTHER cat"
Fantastic as always. I'm very curious what Elrond's life looked like in the large unaccounted for gaps in his history, particularly the first thousand or so years in both the 2nd and 3rd age. Hopefully the Rings of Power show will deliver and do Elrond's character justice
It truly did, in my opinion! It showed him as this wise, charismatic and gentle being, although a much younger Elrond - a way less bitter one than the PJ movies Elrond. In the series, he's truly "kind as summer"
I was waiting for this video of Elrond. Thank you very much. I really enjoy your vids.
Could you please add the music in the description?
A man of great wisdom and heroism