I'm a Baloch who spent half of my life in Lahore and the other half in Islamabad.For me, all the Bangalis are my brothers and sisters just like Pathan , Sindhi , Baloch , Punjabi and all others.
Bhai jiska soba hota hai usey masla hai ham mulk nahi bheer hai Kashmir GB ko province right nahi de raha! Sindh Karachi ko soba nahi bnnay de raha! Punjab sraikistan nahi bnnay de raha! Balochistan me aye din Punjabi maray jatay hain.bas ye Pakistan bheer hai nation nahi we must develop ourselves to make a strong nation
@@3b7pa Bengali is also muslim.many group of hindu live together why not Bengali. We made Pakistan. We love Pakistan very much.india is our common enemy.rss and Hindutva ideology very dangerous of us.Pakistan should take care Bengali.
I had never imagined that our Bengali brothers were going through such oppression. After such tyranny how could one think that Pakistan is ever going to prosper. This is inhumane, unlawful and most importantly UN-ISLAMIC!
🤣🤣🤣 👏👏👏 🤣🤣🤣 U have no clue about Islaam 📗 biggest Maulwis & Hafiz & Ulemaas call these bengalis as Munaafiq... do u know more islaam than the Ulemaas? 📗 just like Arabs call Pakistani, Indian, Bangladeshi as munaafiqs
@@persaud1 Those so called ulemas are themselves munafiqs, racism, pan Nationalism is blatantly haram in Islam, so dont teach us Islam, i know you are a poojet and i can smell it
This video should be sent to the international human rights commission and other international media. Pakistan talks about the rights of Kashmiris and Palestinians, but, totally ignores its own people who sacrificed for Pakistan.
Yes , you are right but realistically to give them their right we have to run big and effective campaigns for them and very honestly I really do not trust the intention of state because past 3 years open my eyes.
I am a karachiite, I know how painful the whole things is!! and snow ball effects goes bigger and bigger!! a big issue for a metropol city and for the country and humanity!! kuddus to team raftar!! hats off
Sirf brother consider Karne s kujh nhi hota bengaliyon or muhajiron ko pure Pakistan m haq milna chahiye ap bhi kujh muhajir or bengaliyon ko Punjab ka domicile dilwaye or unko Punjab m nokriyan dilwaye settle kare Punjab m kpk or Balochistan m gilgit m or Kashmir m bhi
@@KashafaliBhutto Charon subon mai inko divide kia jai to phir bhi kuch hosakta hai lekin agar sirf sindh mai hi inko citizenship di gai to Hum sindhi minority ban sakte hai apni hi Sindh mai
@afsssd-cz9lk m wahi bat kar Raha hun muhajir bhi Pakistan aaye the Sindh m to nhi aaye the Bengali bhi Pakistan aaye the Sindh to nhi aaye the na to isliye inko equally sare provinces m divide Kiya jaye
@@अब्दुससमदअनाम i am from gujrat. My neighbour is bengoli and they are jewelers. Amazing people. Muslim. We never discriminate them. As a muslim why always muslims discriminate other muslims? I was visited turkiye on my holidays with my wife Turks came and tell me Indians go home and I tell them i am muslim so they tell me whatever you are south Asians go home. I swear I'll never visit turkiye, same heppends with me in malesia, Oman and ect. If there's no concept of racism in islam then why muslims are the most resist?
This is so depressing 😢 and as this is the case, we can't even talk about the stranded Pakistanis in Bangladesh. Bravo, Raftar. Keep on opening the eyes of this country.
Hatsoff to Raftar for raising voice. As a Bengali I have faced alot of racism, even to this day Nadra don’t want to help us and openly refer us as Bengali case.
We apologise as Pakistani from you but we are ourselves disappointed from our government and army who have the all control but they’re unable to deliver cz they are compromised themselves as a overall team.Islam is the basic and only bond which can join and unite us with honesty and justice.I hope we will be happy one day will come soon انشاءالله 😭
Laikin ap log achanak NARA kay shikanjay main kaisay phansay, yani ap ko 'alien' kion samjha jany laga, jab kay ap log yahan dahayon say reh rahay hain, shayed bohet say 71' say bhi qabl say yahan abad hain?
Basically everybody in Pakistan is crying because they or their Ancestors chose Pakistan. Pakistan has always disappointed it's people. May Allah help common people of Pakistan.
@@_plastikman it's establishment that form state, people form nation. Pakistan has become a failed state, as even basic institutions like for water, police, education, court are not working.
Even we are Muslims but we don't care other Muslims this is bitter truth of Pakistani Muslims... We are divided... Every religion every sector is running after supremacy... And I really appreciate the way you are working and giving awareness thumbs up for you👍
Not Bangladeshi, Not Pakistani but They are Muslim. I always wanted that as muslim Pakistani are good but inside I had this feeling the politician really hate our brown color. They were always had this racism and yes I know not everyone is same, thanks to all those people who are really brave enough to make this video. love from Bangladesh!
اللہ کی قسم حب سے یہ ویڈیو دیکھی دل خون کے آنسو رورھا ھے یہ کیسا سلوک ھے جو ان بے گناہ بنگالیوں کے ساتھ مسلسل کیا جارھا ھے میں بھی لاہور سے ہوں پنجابی ہوں
As a Bangladeshi, I appeal to Pakistan government to make relation with Bangladesh. Now Bangladeshi government is independent from Indian hegemony. And both countries need to give rights Bengali in Pakistan and biharis in Bangladesh. 🇧🇩❤️🇵🇰
بھائی میرا کلیجہ منہ کو آرھا ھے یہ ظلم ھے قسم سے ظلم ھے ہم سبکو رفتار چینل کا ساتھ دینا چاہئے تاکہ بنگالیوں کے لئے زیادہ سے زیادہ آواز اٹھائیں یہ ظلم ھے انسانیت کی تذلیل ھے
as a Bangladeshi I thanks our ancestor and freedom fighters who fight for the Bengali peoples freedom and right free from the Pakistan Joy Bangla long live Bangladesh 🇧🇩✊
I am from 🇧🇩 And we should do batter relationship with Pakistan..... Bangladesh is currently under threat from India, we need to have a good relationship with Pakistan to save🇧🇩 from Indian Every aspect of thread Like economic,, Security threaten in Chittagong,,
After listening and watching this my heart is broken💔 سینہ چاکان مشرق بھی اپنے ہی تھے جن کا خوں منہ پہ ملنے کو تم آئے تھے مامتاؤں کی تقدیس کو لوٹنے یا بغاوت کچلنے کو تم آئے تھے ان کی تقدیر تم کیا بدلتے مگر ان کی نسلیں بدلنے کو تم آئے تھے اس کا انجام جو کچھ ہوا سو ہوا شب گئی خواب تم سے پریشاں گئے کس جلال و رعونت سے وارد ہوئے کس خجالت سے تم سوئے زنداں گئے احمد فراز
Thank you Raftar team for making this video and raising awareness about the depressed Bengali community of Karachi 🫡 they must get Pakistani nationality
Pakistnai people can't source their basic necessities, why would they or their government care for a group of people who themselves don't do any protests to claim their rights. There has been zero outcry, zero protest, zero interest or awareness. Even I came to know about the 3 million strong community today through this window. Its baffling to see such a big community with no united voice. 3 million is huge!
@@brazensmusings2738 same,I had no idea about this either and I live in Karachi.we can't expect everything to go right by itself, Pakistan needs a revolution
ماشاءاللہ آپ نے بہت اہم موضوع پر ویڈیو بنائی ہے اللہ رب العالمین آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے اور ہمارے بنگلہ زبان والے مسلمان بھائیوں کے تمام مسائل حل فرمائے آمین
Thank you for this video. My grandparents were from East Pakistan, Alhamdulillah we are legal citizens of Pakistan, however there are many relatives of mine that have to undergo harassment, intimidation by police, law enforcement authorities for not having their NIC and even face legal obstacles when they want to acquire an NIC.
Yea kon log hain, jin ka NIC nahin ben raha, jab kay wo decades say yahan reh rahay hain, aur bohet say yahan peda bhi huway hain, yani pedaishi taur per yahan kay shehri hain? Ap kay aur in logon kay documents main kia ferq hay?
@hs6736 please visit orangi town yehi tu issue hai k unko bolte hai prove do k yehi ki paidaish hai ,you can also watch some bihari camp in Bangladesh.... Both Bengali and Bihari communities in certain areas of Pakistan, especially Karachi, have faced issues related to their National Identity Cards (NICs) due to historical, political, and bureaucratic challenges. For Biharis, many of whom migrated to Pakistan after 1971, the NIC issue has often been linked to questions about citizenship and verification processes. Despite having settled in Pakistan for decades, some Biharis have faced difficulties in proving their nationality, often due to limited documentation from earlier years or the complex bureaucratic processes involved. Similarly, certain Bengali-origin residents in Pakistan have faced hurdles in obtaining or renewing NICs, often due to similar challenges around documentation and verification. These issues are compounded by socioeconomic factors, access to resources, and sometimes unclear policies, leading to both communities facing similar struggles. However, reports indicate that Biharis might face a slightly higher rate of NIC issues due to the unique challenges of their migration history and political context.
@@justtrue-mb2er yehi tu masla hai hamare system mai sb k pas knowledge hai pr agar koi practical se guzre tb pata chale na ap shayed nh guzre ho to ap ko nh pata .
25.44 کی نہ صرف یہ وڈیو ہے ۔ بلکہ 1973 کے بعد جتنے بھی مسائل ابھی تک ہم سب برداشت کر رہے ہیں ان سب کا بہترین طور پر احاطہ ،منظر کشی اور روزمرہ زندگی میں انے والے مسائل کو اجاگر کیا گیا ہے ۔ جنہوں نے یہ ڈاکومنٹری بنائی ہے ان کے جذبے ،سوچ اور کاوشوں کو دل کی گہرائیوں سے سلام
Lots of love for bengali in pakistan❤ i hope someone will think about them and accept them as pakistan and give them nationality… Mujhe bhaut dhuk hua yeh video dekh kar…
afsos ki bat to ye hai ke hum Pakistanio ko apny bengalio bhaio ke is maslay ka pta nahe hai. Main stream media pe kabhi is maslay ko highlight nahe kia gaya. Thanks to raftar jis ne is ghmabir maslay ko highlight kia. Allah hamary bengali bhaio aur behno ki madad karay.
Salute to the team for bringing up such an important issue, rather should be called a situation of human crises in Pakistan. Being a Karachiite I have witnessed myself the general treatment and behavioral issues towards the community, They are citizens of Pakistan but unfortunately deprived for all their basic rights in the country. Apart from Govt.'s conduct to solve their issues, I think it is a high time for all of us to stop doing what we have been doing with them, and accept them as our own and provide our support with all available means.
Thanks a lot Raftar for highlighting such issues. This is disheartening to see that we always raise voice for whole Muslim world and protests for them but unfortunately we are not raising our voice for our own brothers who are a part of this country and living here for decades.
Raftar is the best channel in the world, Sahi Awaz Uthai hai apnay, Ya Bangali hamaray Bhai hai, or Pakistani Hai, hamaray Pakistan py Inka utna he haqq hai jitna Hindu, parsi, or essaiyon ka hai, Allah Pak inhay qamiyabi atta karya Ameen Sumameen
@@faisalhocane170 Sindh didn't join Pakistan to open an Orphanage for all muslims of world. Sindhi Muslims had also some aspirations for themselves to grow in their own land & protect their indigenous culture. We have given more than enough by donating our capital Karachi itself to lots of Indian Muslim migrants in 1947. No more please, if this continues Sindhis will soon become minority in their own province. Now I think it's time for Punjab, Pakhtunkhwa, Kashmir , Balochistan & especially Islamabad to accommodate some of our Bengali brothers with open arms !!
@saifsamo9750 Ooo puttar Sindh Didn't accommodate BLA BLA BLA. Do You Know a thing called HISTORY. Ni pata to main prha dun??? Donating karachi??? Karachi was the best place to have chosen as a capital. Kabhi legislative assembly main kya hua tha wo prha???
Salute to you for raising a voice for bangali people they are our brother kindly accept them and give them respect they have given a huge sacrifice for pakistan🙏🏻
This is an eye opening doc for all of us & wake up call of what r we still doing with these poor Bangali people. Such a shame on our Politicians & laws which r failed to recognise such important people within our so called respectable society.. No hopes left for Pakistan...😢
Thank you And Salutation to you about raising and highlighting such issues which hardly any Pakistani is aware of… It was so touchy and emotional May Allah SWT help them Amern
@alhabtoormotors4221 dear Bro m ny kb kahan..... K koe problem hn Bangaliyon sy.... Laikin muhajiron ny kb in klia awaz uthaee h....Or utha bhi lain to kon suntan h... Leadership to apnay mafadat k Kia Har maqam pr yes boos kehti h...
@@alhabtoormotors4221muhajiro ke sheher nahi hua karte agar muhajiro ke sheher hote to wo muhajir nahi kehlayenge. By the way ye Sindhio ka sheher tha jo muhajiro ne aakar historical Sindhi aksariyat Raat o Raat akhliyat ho gayi !!
Love your content. Just one request for future videos: can you guys add subtitles? Some words spoken are difficult to understand and Google doesn't translate that well. Would love to improve my Urdu, too.
Exceptional work❤ literally sorry to Bengalis living in Pakistan and we are responsible for their plight.....we have to help them raise their voice as they have lost their confidence that too cause of us.....I am devastated to the fact they don't have I'd card cause from childhood to adulthood this is my basic necessity to move ahead in life how they are managing things literallyyyyy? This is the way to marginalize them and to hinder their progress ahead as they can't attain education uffffff all the governments had been and are have to be answerable to Allah for this inhumane injustices
Pakistani har sector main India ka muqabla karte hain,par haar jaate hain keoki india main aaj b core level par sab community ek sath rehte hain, lekin pakistan aaj tak apne logo mai. Unity nhi la ska, feeling bad for bangali of pakistan.😢
Pakistan without a doubt has issues and serious ones but India isn't a barometer for anything. Whole world knows what Indian Muslims are going though since 2014, what is happening in Manipur, etc. we don't compare ourselves with you guys nor are you guys any examples of unity. I have relatives in India and have been to India as well.
@msr7373 Issue of Manipur & Indian muslim is temporary it's resolved as time is pass,but suffering of Pakistani bangali muslim still continues from since 1947 or 1971, I agreed our muslims brothers & my community Sikhs suffer from since 2014 , but my point of view says a muslim suffer in muslim majority nation not bad as minority suffer in hindu majority nation.
As a bangladeshi This video make me sad but most importantly everyone should remember we are human we are Muslim. And you raise your voice.Lots of Thanks brother for these Valuable information
پہلی بار مظلوم بنگالیوں کے لئے آواز اٹھانے پر آپ کی ٹیم کو سلام❤
We should raise voice for their rights. These people should be given nationality without any delay......
SHAME on us.
Jaka Bangladesh ma raho
MQM shuro say Bangli or Bihario Kay lay awaz utha the Rahai hay jab Afghanio KO Dy saktay to Bangli or Bihario nay to Pakistan banaya hay
@@babarkhan4363 kash julfikar aur mujeeb na behis bante to aaj sab kuchh achcha hota
I'm a Baloch who spent half of my life in Lahore and the other half in Islamabad.For me, all the Bangalis are my brothers and sisters just like Pathan , Sindhi , Baloch , Punjabi and all others.
Don't include Sindhi, no one has a problem with Bengalis getting citizenship only Sindhsi
Bhai jiska soba hota hai usey masla hai ham mulk nahi bheer hai Kashmir GB ko province right nahi de raha! Sindh Karachi ko soba nahi bnnay de raha! Punjab sraikistan nahi bnnay de raha! Balochistan me aye din Punjabi maray jatay hain.bas ye Pakistan bheer hai nation nahi we must develop ourselves to make a strong nation
@@3b7payes right that is why we also want to divorce from this failed Pakistan Project just like the Bengalis. Jeay SINDHUDESH ❤
@@WhenWhere-h2c But ask any Punjabi, and you will get a different reply.
@@3b7pa Bengali is also muslim.many group of hindu live together why not Bengali. We made Pakistan. We love Pakistan very much.india is our common enemy.rss and Hindutva ideology very dangerous of us.Pakistan should take care Bengali.
I had never imagined that our Bengali brothers were going through such oppression. After such tyranny how could one think that Pakistan is ever going to prosper. This is inhumane, unlawful and most importantly UN-ISLAMIC!
🤣🤣🤣 👏👏👏 🤣🤣🤣
U have no clue about Islaam
📗 biggest Maulwis & Hafiz & Ulemaas call these bengalis as Munaafiq... do u know more islaam than the Ulemaas?
📗 just like Arabs call Pakistani, Indian, Bangladeshi as munaafiqs
our Bengali brothers? really. Pakistan is just doing their job, becoming ISLAMIC, Bangladesh is on the same ISLAMIC path.
Agree😢
@@persaud1
Those so called ulemas are themselves munafiqs, racism, pan Nationalism is blatantly haram in Islam, so dont teach us Islam, i know you are a poojet and i can smell it
@@anil4015 Least attacking indian comment
This video should be sent to the international human rights commission and other international media. Pakistan talks about the rights of Kashmiris and Palestinians, but, totally ignores its own people who sacrificed for Pakistan.
Lumber 1 hypocrite country sir
Pakistan is only acting on Kashmir and Phalastin issues
until bangladesh dont give citezenship to biharis bengalis wont get citezesnhip
same with Endia
Exactly!
Really I feel sorry about the condition of our Bengali brother ..
Love for our beloved Bengali Pakistanis ..
May Allah give them their rights .
Bengali pakistani ak ni ho skte he
Khud Jo kar sakte ho uske liye Allah ko kyu pareshaan karte ho
Maybe we can fight for their rights by raising awareness about their issues
Yes , you are right but realistically to give them their right we have to run big and effective campaigns for them and very honestly I really do not trust the intention of state because past 3 years open my eyes.
Bhai Kyu nahi.. woh loog iss mitti kae bachae hain .. Woh Pakistani hi hain aur jab tak yaha rahay gae Pakistani hi rahae gae..
Lots of love and respect for bengali brothers
Nice joke😂
Hum inki nasle badal denge😅
Bhule ni he
Bhai aap k is love ka unho ne achaar daalna hai? Love hai to in k liye kuch kr k dikhao in k liye awaaz uthao
☪️ANCER claims themselves Bengali 😂😂
I am a karachiite, I know how painful the whole things is!! and snow ball effects goes bigger and bigger!! a big issue for a metropol city and for the country and humanity!! kuddus to team raftar!! hats off
As a Punjabi, I consider Bengalis as our brothers and sisters nationally and religiously also. They're us.
Heart breaking documentary.
So if a Bengali would be Hindu, Christian or Atheist, it's open season to oppress them since they're not your religious brothers?
Sirf brother consider Karne s kujh nhi hota bengaliyon or muhajiron ko pure Pakistan m haq milna chahiye ap bhi kujh muhajir or bengaliyon ko Punjab ka domicile dilwaye or unko Punjab m nokriyan dilwaye settle kare Punjab m kpk or Balochistan m gilgit m or Kashmir m bhi
@@KashafaliBhutto Charon subon mai inko divide kia jai to phir bhi kuch hosakta hai lekin agar sirf sindh mai hi inko citizenship di gai to Hum sindhi minority ban sakte hai apni hi Sindh mai
@@afsssd-cz9lk Yehi hypocrisy ha Pakistaniyun ki, rights dene hain Lekin bus Apne jotay ke neechay rahen
@afsssd-cz9lk m wahi bat kar Raha hun muhajir bhi Pakistan aaye the Sindh m to nhi aaye the Bengali bhi Pakistan aaye the Sindh to nhi aaye the na to isliye inko equally sare provinces m divide Kiya jaye
We Bangladeshi gave shelter 10 lakhs Pakistani bihari in Bangladesh. But our Bengali people lead a miserable life in Pakistan. 😢
@@akibgo pakistan Bihari whatt??
gale ke bahar bhi duniya hai Jan lo baniya ji
Alhamdulillah
I'm Bangali Muslim
@@अब्दुससमदअनाम i am from gujrat. My neighbour is bengoli and they are jewelers. Amazing people. Muslim.
We never discriminate them.
As a muslim why always muslims discriminate other muslims? I was visited turkiye on my holidays with my wife Turks came and tell me Indians go home and I tell them i am muslim so they tell me whatever you are south Asians go home.
I swear I'll never visit turkiye, same heppends with me in malesia, Oman and ect.
If there's no concept of racism in islam then why muslims are the most resist?
Nijere bangali muslim bolo abar nam hindi, mane ki?
হিন্দি নামের দরকার কি?!
Only bengali,not muslim hindu
@@trug2 আপনি কি ছাগল ওনি তো পশ্চিম বঙ্গের ও হতে পারে
My hats off to you for taking up such a tragic humanitarian issue. Blessings to your channel. Doing brilliant work.
This is so depressing 😢 and as this is the case, we can't even talk about the stranded Pakistanis in Bangladesh. Bravo, Raftar. Keep on opening the eyes of this country.
One of the best doc .I hope our Bengali brothers get justice
Hatsoff to Raftar for raising voice. As a Bengali I have faced alot of racism, even to this day Nadra don’t want to help us and openly refer us as Bengali case.
We apologise as Pakistani from you but we are ourselves disappointed from our government and army who have the all control but they’re unable to deliver cz they are compromised themselves as a overall team.Islam is the basic and only bond which can join and unite us with honesty and justice.I hope we will be happy one day will come soon انشاءالله 😭
Come to Punjab brother
Apnar kono kharap obostha hoile Bangladesh e eshe poren
Laikin ap log achanak NARA kay shikanjay main kaisay phansay, yani ap ko 'alien' kion samjha jany laga, jab kay ap log yahan dahayon say reh rahay hain, shayed bohet say 71' say bhi qabl say yahan abad hain?
Basically everybody in Pakistan is crying because they or their Ancestors chose Pakistan. Pakistan has always disappointed it's people. May Allah help common people of Pakistan.
It is not Pakistan fault. Those who are running Pakistan it's their fault.
@@_plastikmanits the armies fault
but not giving CNIC to them is another type of struggle
@@_plastikman it's establishment that form state, people form nation. Pakistan has become a failed state, as even basic institutions like for water, police, education, court are not working.
Kudos to this channel for showcasing this side of Pakistan!
We are proud of our bangli brother
Bolne se kya hota he tum log ho kon kya okhad he tumhari hur chiz foz decide krti he tumhare yaha
@@SaDaVeLLamunda786 Bhaijaan Sirf comment krne s kuch ni hota
Y baat amal bhi kia kro
Heartbreaking documentary 😢
Thank you for shedding light on the suffering of these innocent people😞
Even we are Muslims but we don't care other Muslims this is bitter truth of Pakistani Muslims... We are divided... Every religion every sector is running after supremacy... And I really appreciate the way you are working and giving awareness thumbs up for you👍
Not Bangladeshi, Not Pakistani but They are Muslim. I always wanted that as muslim Pakistani are good but inside I had this feeling the politician really hate our brown color. They were always had this racism and yes I know not everyone is same, thanks to all those people who are really brave enough to make this video. love from Bangladesh!
As a Punjabi Stand with our Bengali Brothers
Lot of Love from Lahore Punjab
Bus rehn do tum toh ager itna hi saath de sakte ho toh bolo boot 👢 ke khilaf
اللہ کی قسم حب سے یہ ویڈیو دیکھی دل خون کے آنسو رورھا ھے یہ کیسا سلوک ھے جو ان بے گناہ بنگالیوں کے ساتھ مسلسل کیا جارھا ھے میں بھی لاہور سے ہوں پنجابی ہوں
First care developed balochistan.. dirty racist
As a Bangladeshi, I appeal to Pakistan government to make relation with Bangladesh. Now Bangladeshi government is independent from Indian hegemony.
And both countries need to give rights Bengali in Pakistan and biharis in Bangladesh.
🇧🇩❤️🇵🇰
রাজাকারের বাচ্চা
میں زاتی طور پر ان سب چیزوں سے واقف ہوں یہ تو بہت کم داستان ہے انکا درد بہت زیادہ ہے۔
بھائی میرا کلیجہ منہ کو آرھا ھے یہ ظلم ھے قسم سے ظلم ھے ہم سبکو رفتار چینل کا ساتھ دینا چاہئے تاکہ بنگالیوں کے لئے زیادہ سے زیادہ آواز اٹھائیں یہ ظلم ھے انسانیت کی تذلیل ھے
as a Bangladeshi I thanks our ancestor and freedom fighters who fight for the Bengali peoples freedom and right free from the Pakistan
Joy Bangla
long live Bangladesh 🇧🇩✊
Yunus sorkar er uchit,eder ke taratari Bangladesh e nia asha
Pakistanis are racist. That's why their country is going backwards. So called islamic republic.
Long live our great nation🇧🇩
We are developing and we will develop much more insha'Allah
@@Cheems010 এরা সবাই নিজে থেকেই পাকিস্তানে চলে গিয়েছিল। এখন আমরা কেন ওদের আনবো।
I am from 🇧🇩
And we should do batter relationship with Pakistan.....
Bangladesh is currently under threat from India, we need to have a good relationship with Pakistan to save🇧🇩 from Indian
Every aspect of thread
Like economic,, Security threaten in Chittagong,,
After listening and watching this my heart is broken💔
سینہ چاکان مشرق بھی اپنے ہی تھے
جن کا خوں منہ پہ ملنے کو تم آئے تھے
مامتاؤں کی تقدیس کو لوٹنے
یا بغاوت کچلنے کو تم آئے تھے
ان کی تقدیر تم کیا بدلتے مگر
ان کی نسلیں بدلنے کو تم آئے تھے
اس کا انجام جو کچھ ہوا سو ہوا
شب گئی خواب تم سے پریشاں گئے
کس جلال و رعونت سے وارد ہوئے
کس خجالت سے تم سوئے زنداں گئے
احمد فراز
ہم شرمندہ ہیں بھائیوں ۔اب تو افسوس ہوتا ہے پاکستانی ہونے پر😢😢😢
رفتار کا سلام ہے جس نے کم از کم کسی کمیونٹی کے لیے اس پر بات تو کی
Alhamdulillah im pakistani bangali from karachi
Raftar is the Voice Real Pakistan Love From India.
It's not fall of Dhaka, it's rise of Dhaka...
Thanks raftar reality dekhany ky Liye
Thank you Raftar team for making this video and raising awareness about the depressed Bengali community of Karachi 🫡 they must get Pakistani nationality
Such a sad reality of Pakistan, and wrong priorities of Pakistani government and people.
Pakistnai people can't source their basic necessities, why would they or their government care for a group of people who themselves don't do any protests to claim their rights. There has been zero outcry, zero protest, zero interest or awareness. Even I came to know about the 3 million strong community today through this window.
Its baffling to see such a big community with no united voice. 3 million is huge!
We cannot blame one's wrongdoing onto other because they dont protest!! Wrong is wrong whether it happens to any1@@brazensmusings2738
@@brazensmusings2738 same,I had no idea about this either and I live in Karachi.we can't expect everything to go right by itself, Pakistan needs a revolution
ماشاءاللہ
آپ نے بہت اہم موضوع پر ویڈیو بنائی ہے
اللہ رب العالمین آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے اور ہمارے بنگلہ زبان والے مسلمان بھائیوں کے تمام مسائل حل فرمائے آمین
Really appreciate to RAFTAR team for such a great work!
Well done! Keep it up!
Watching this video from Jharkhand, India, thank you for making this informative video.
Tu kaha se hai? Bharat ya Bangladesh se?
Salute u Bengalis....hum maafi chahte hain....🙏🙏🙏 thanks to establishment... Pakistan ko barbaad Karne k lie 😷😷😷😷
Thank you for this video. My grandparents were from East Pakistan, Alhamdulillah we are legal citizens of Pakistan, however there are many relatives of mine that have to undergo harassment, intimidation by police, law enforcement authorities for not having their NIC and even face legal obstacles when they want to acquire an NIC.
Yea kon log hain, jin ka NIC nahin ben raha, jab kay wo decades say yahan reh rahay hain, aur bohet say yahan peda bhi huway hain, yani pedaishi taur per yahan kay shehri hain? Ap kay aur in logon kay documents main kia ferq hay?
Same situation of bihari... 😢😢😢
@@infokarachiaseel why ? Bihari ki kya problem h ? Unke saath to bass Mahavir vaala issue hi h.
I genuinely want to know.
@hs6736 please visit orangi town yehi tu issue hai k unko bolte hai prove do k yehi ki paidaish hai ,you can also watch some bihari camp in Bangladesh....
Both Bengali and Bihari communities in certain areas of Pakistan, especially Karachi, have faced issues related to their National Identity Cards (NICs) due to historical, political, and bureaucratic challenges.
For Biharis, many of whom migrated to Pakistan after 1971, the NIC issue has often been linked to questions about citizenship and verification processes. Despite having settled in Pakistan for decades, some Biharis have faced difficulties in proving their nationality, often due to limited documentation from earlier years or the complex bureaucratic processes involved.
Similarly, certain Bengali-origin residents in Pakistan have faced hurdles in obtaining or renewing NICs, often due to similar challenges around documentation and verification. These issues are compounded by socioeconomic factors, access to resources, and sometimes unclear policies, leading to both communities facing similar struggles. However, reports indicate that Biharis might face a slightly higher rate of NIC issues due to the unique challenges of their migration history and political context.
Aap ko jab proper knowledge nahi to please...."Don't Comments"....😡
@@justtrue-mb2er yehi tu masla hai hamare system mai sb k pas knowledge hai pr agar koi practical se guzre tb pata chale na ap shayed nh guzre ho to ap ko nh pata .
One of the best documentary of RAFTAR
Thanks
@@raftartvMake a documentry about force conversation
Can u make part 2.... Solutions of it???? @@raftartv
@@raftartvjanab bihari community k Saath bhi yhi Kuch masail he, unhein bhi shanakht se mehroom rakha jata he
ap general pervaiz musharraf era par video bnao @@raftartv
must awaited documentary. you are literally doing a great job.
Ap ka BHT BHT shukria hm mazloom bangalio k liye awaz uthany k liye
25.44
کی نہ صرف یہ وڈیو ہے ۔
بلکہ 1973 کے بعد جتنے بھی مسائل ابھی تک ہم سب برداشت کر رہے ہیں ان سب کا بہترین طور پر احاطہ ،منظر کشی اور روزمرہ زندگی میں انے والے مسائل کو اجاگر کیا گیا ہے ۔
جنہوں نے یہ ڈاکومنٹری بنائی ہے ان کے جذبے ،سوچ اور کاوشوں کو دل کی گہرائیوں سے سلام
😢 mere Bangali bhai bechaary hum pakistanion ne agr apne Bangali bhaion ke Liye awaz uthhayi to Hum missing kr diye jaain ge 😢😢😢
Well done Raftar, you guys are on top to raise real issues.
May Allah protect you all
Dillo mai aag laganay ka kam , Raftar sai bethar koi nhi krsakta 🔥🔥💔
Firestarters
Lots of love for bengali in pakistan❤ i hope someone will think about them and accept them as pakistan and give them nationality…
Mujhe bhaut dhuk hua yeh video dekh kar…
Hats off to Team Raftar ❤
afsos ki bat to ye hai ke hum Pakistanio ko apny bengalio bhaio ke is maslay ka pta nahe hai. Main stream media pe kabhi is maslay ko highlight nahe kia gaya. Thanks to raftar jis ne is ghmabir maslay ko highlight kia. Allah hamary bengali bhaio aur behno ki madad karay.
Tum jaan kr bhi kya kr loge boot 👢 ki chalti he napak me
Rafter doing very well ALLAH ap logo ko khush rakhy success du
JazakAllah
Very poor attitude of Pakistanis towards Bengalis 😢😢😢😢
This video should be sent to the international human rights commission and other international media.😥
And we cry about Israel, when will we realize?
Lets raise our voices for our bengali brothers, sister. promise here everyone one will do, what they can for brothers
Salute to the team for bringing up such an important issue, rather should be called a situation of human crises in Pakistan. Being a Karachiite I have witnessed myself the general treatment and behavioral issues towards the community, They are citizens of Pakistan but unfortunately deprived for all their basic rights in the country. Apart from Govt.'s conduct to solve their issues, I think it is a high time for all of us to stop doing what we have been doing with them, and accept them as our own and provide our support with all available means.
finally someone spoke about it, I hope a leader will be born from their community and fight for their rights InshAllah 💪🏾🙏🏾
بنگلہ دیش کے بہاریوں پر بھی ایک ویڈیو بنائیں ۔
Plz make a video on stranded Bihari's in Bangladesh
@@FarhanAli-nu7wy vai Pakistani bihari ko Bangladesh ne nid card diya
Raftar is hats off the best media channel in Pakistan now
بنگالی بھائیوں کے لئے یکجا ہو کر اواز اٹھائیں۔حکومت سے ان کو حقوق دلائیں جزاک اللہ
One of the best comment
بلکل درست فرمایا آپ نے یہ آواز رکنی نہیں چاہئے یہ کیسا ظلم ھے جو مسلسل جاری ھے😢😢😥
Bangladeshi are great people. ❤
Love and Respect from Bangladesh for Making this documentary. Raftar Jindabad
Why they don't deserve that 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢.... so cld Muslim brotherhood
Now raftar the asset of Pakistani nation ❤
Love you
I really appreciate your channel. And it's very thoughtful matter
I appreciate that!
Same situation of Biharis in Bangladesh
Aap ki team ko salam, ayse ayse issues per bat ki ap logo ne jiska yakeen karen humee ilm hy thek trhan se nahi tha..
Really I feel sorry for the condition of our Bengali brother
Another piece of art by @teamraftar. Salute to team raftar
Thanks a lot Raftar for highlighting such issues. This is disheartening to see that we always raise voice for whole Muslim world and protests for them but unfortunately we are not raising our voice for our own brothers who are a part of this country and living here for decades.
You're doing great work raftar
Very good I appreciate raftars effort for raising voice for the rights of Bengalis
Raftar is the best channel in the world, Sahi Awaz Uthai hai apnay, Ya Bangali hamaray Bhai hai, or Pakistani Hai, hamaray Pakistan py Inka utna he haqq hai jitna Hindu, parsi, or essaiyon ka hai, Allah Pak inhay qamiyabi atta karya Ameen Sumameen
Hats off to you guys for creating this awareness content for our Bengali brothers and sisters.
Keep it up! always support to you
Respect young man! Keep fighting the good fight and speaking for the voiceless!!!👏👏
"We Lost Have Of Pakistan, Now We Do Not Want To Lose The Rest Of It."
Anwar Maqsood
If all the burden will be forced upon Sindh alone then very soon this will happen. Jeay SINDHUDESH
@saifsamo9750 What kind of burden will you please mention???
@saifsamo9750 people like you live in dreams, Build castles And in the end you end up like a crackhead in a pagal khaana 🤣
@@faisalhocane170 Sindh didn't join Pakistan to open an Orphanage for all muslims of world. Sindhi Muslims had also some aspirations for themselves to grow in their own land & protect their indigenous culture.
We have given more than enough by donating our capital Karachi itself to lots of Indian Muslim migrants in 1947. No more please, if this continues Sindhis will soon become minority in their own province.
Now I think it's time for Punjab, Pakhtunkhwa, Kashmir , Balochistan & especially Islamabad to accommodate some of our Bengali brothers with open arms !!
@saifsamo9750 Ooo puttar
Sindh Didn't accommodate BLA BLA BLA.
Do You Know a thing called HISTORY.
Ni pata to main prha dun???
Donating karachi???
Karachi was the best place to have chosen as a capital.
Kabhi legislative assembly main kya hua tha wo prha???
Salute to you for raising a voice for bangali people they are our brother kindly accept them and give them respect they have given a huge sacrifice for pakistan🙏🏻
سلام ہے أپ کی پوری ٹیم کو دل جیت لیا❤❤❤
Great work Raftar this is called real journalism
I do not even know about that
thanks, Rftar
Aankhon main aansu AA gye video dekh kr
Agar main politics main aya... toh maqsad sirf yahi ho ga... k Apne bhayoo aur bachoo ko Identity dilwa doo... 🥺🥺🥺
Govt must take action. This is serious issue. Thank u raftar.... i hope govt action ly go koi
This is an eye opening doc for all of us & wake up call of what r we still doing with these poor Bangali people. Such a shame on our Politicians & laws which r failed to recognise such important people within our so called respectable society..
No hopes left for Pakistan...😢
Thank you And Salutation to you about raising and highlighting such issues which hardly any Pakistani is aware of… It was so touchy and emotional May Allah SWT help them Amern
Muhajiron k sheher m bangali Muhajir..... 😢
O Bhai muhajir don't have problem with them, only sindhis
@alhabtoormotors4221 dear Bro m ny kb kahan..... K koe problem hn Bangaliyon sy....
Laikin muhajiron ny kb in klia awaz uthaee h....Or utha bhi lain to kon suntan h... Leadership to apnay mafadat k Kia Har maqam pr yes boos kehti h...
@@alhabtoormotors4221muhajiro ke sheher nahi hua karte agar muhajiro ke sheher hote to wo muhajir nahi kehlayenge. By the way ye Sindhio ka sheher tha jo muhajiro ne aakar historical Sindhi aksariyat Raat o Raat akhliyat ho gayi !!
Khanabadoshon k bhi shehar hua kartay hain mujhe aj pata laga🤣🤣🤣
I am sorry yr as a pakistani i m crying during watching this zulm
Love your content. Just one request for future videos: can you guys add subtitles? Some words spoken are difficult to understand and Google doesn't translate that well. Would love to improve my Urdu, too.
Please give them rights they are real assit of pakistan. They are very brave and loyal people i found ever.
Pakistani lovers in India often talk about Human Rights of Intruders but they never ever mentioned These unfortunate Bengali son of soil
Great Video i usually don't like to comment but this one really made me do it ... Keep up this good work ❤
But we always try respond to every comment - thanks for your love
@raftartv you deserve it ❤️
insha'Allah jald haq milay ga
Exceptional work❤ literally sorry to Bengalis living in Pakistan and we are responsible for their plight.....we have to help them raise their voice as they have lost their confidence that too cause of us.....I am devastated to the fact they don't have I'd card cause from childhood to adulthood this is my basic necessity to move ahead in life how they are managing things literallyyyyy? This is the way to marginalize them and to hinder their progress ahead as they can't attain education uffffff all the governments had been and are have to be answerable to Allah for this inhumane injustices
Pakistani har sector main India ka muqabla karte hain,par haar jaate hain keoki india main aaj b core level par sab community ek sath rehte hain, lekin pakistan aaj tak apne logo mai. Unity nhi la ska, feeling bad for bangali of pakistan.😢
Pakistan without a doubt has issues and serious ones but India isn't a barometer for anything. Whole world knows what Indian Muslims are going though since 2014, what is happening in Manipur, etc. we don't compare ourselves with you guys nor are you guys any examples of unity. I have relatives in India and have been to India as well.
@msr7373 Issue of Manipur & Indian muslim is temporary it's resolved as time is pass,but suffering of Pakistani bangali muslim still continues from since 1947 or 1971, I agreed our muslims brothers & my community Sikhs suffer from since 2014 , but my point of view says a muslim suffer in muslim majority nation not bad as minority suffer in hindu majority nation.
Pakistan Blames India in Kashmir Issue( Just Propaganda), but didn't criticise their Past Action. Hypocrite Country 😂😂😂
Bangali my bahadur brother❤❤❤love from punjab❤❤
Bangladeshis who loves Pakistan should watch this documentary😂😂😂
Keep it up raftar
As a bangladeshi This video make me sad but most importantly everyone should remember we are human we are Muslim. And you raise your voice.Lots of Thanks brother for these Valuable information
raftar polution in pakistan next video plz