For real. I got to see Rush several times before they called it quits and Neil Peart passed away, I saw Tom Petty 2 months before HE passed away, and this summer I’ll be seeing Roger Waters for probably the last time.
@@MrBrungers les Rolling Stones sont le plus grand groupe de la planète tu ne peux pas lutter contre ça j'adore les Who mais il sont (surtout actuellement) bien en dessous des stones
The scream at the end was a combination of Roger doing it live, and the recorded scream from the Who’s Next album (I could hear the bit of scratchiness from the album). But hey, Rog is 78 - gotta cut him some slack here. The fact that he and Pete are out there doing it at all is a miracle in itself.
@@ralphboyle Either way, you did not hear a record "scratch" because IF they DID they would NOT use a RECORD. I am a musician and familiar with live sound. You just get your kicks being right. Whatever.
Wow! Great video. My wife and I were at the show in St Louis (courtesy of our son) Thanks for taking the time to do this. To sacrifice your "live' experience so that you can share this with others is admirable and very much appreciated.
You bet! The show was great, hope to see em again! Please subscribe and check out my back catalog! Over 2500 live concert videos! www.youtube.com/@DeadMikeConcertVideos/playlists
He hit the scream (7:47), and I think it was actually live! I was expecting either a debacle or something pre-recorded, but that sounded live, and sounded really good!
Roger sounds fine but the scream was not live. If you saw the concert for NYC *live* in 2001, the scream was an absolute train wreck. Trust me. I heard it live. It was subsequently overdubbed for video release. If Roger could not hit the scream *THEN* he sure as hell is not doing it over 20 years later at nearly age 80. Please get a grip on reality.
@@Better_Call_Raul Upon further review... I am willing to concede that it's very likely I was wrong and the scream is probably a mix of (mostly) a recording together with whatever he's still capable of at age 78. I let my enthusiasm for the band and the song get the better of my objective analysis. But I don't see why you need to be mean about it. 🤷♂
A few harsh comments on here.... but I think we just have to appreciate that the golden generation of rock/Pop pioneers are close to retirement or dare I say, the inevitable. I'm glad I've seen most of my musical heroes at least once live, and there's many of them. The Who, Stones, Hollies, Beach Boys all still exist with at least 2 original members and have existed for at least 60 years, (The Who slightly less). It's knowing when to call it a day - flagging performances, physical deficits or a significant band member's death. Only they will know when.
I watched this just to see if Roger could still hit the scream. Damn....he did. I am very impressed. It seems to weird to see him very old and that heavy since he was in such great shape in his heyday. I would not recognize him walking down the street. Looks like someone who would yell at me to get off his lawn....but he hit the scream. Kudos.
Roger sounds fine but the scream was not live. If you saw the concert for NYC live in 2001, the scream was an absolute train wreck. Trust me. I heard it live. It was subsequently overdubbed for video release. If Roger could not hit the scream THEN he sure as hell is not doing it over 20 years later at nearly age 80. Please get a grip on reality.
I don’t understand the harsh and critical comments. You obviously can’t go see The Who today and expect them to look and sound like they did 20, 30, 40 or 50 years ago. I realize it’s a bit of a backhanded compliment, like telling a woman that she looks good for her age. But given Roger and Pete’s age (78 and 77), I think they still look and sound pretty darn good. I’ve seen some embarrassing shows (think B.B. King at the end or Bon Jovi now), and to me, this isn’t embarrassing at all. As long as you have realistic expectations, I think The Who is still worth seeing and a treat for the fans that they’re still out there performing at, although certainly diminished from their prime, but at a still pretty remarkable level nearly 60 years later.
Roger sounds fine for his age but they need to use common sense and drop the key from A to G. Don't know why it is not done. Does Pete prefer playing the song in the original key? But make no mistake, Roger would sound much better and less strained if the key was dropped. And the audience would never know nor care.
I think it has a lot to do with the electric drums and other performers, when they did this back in 2019 the sound was awful too. I saw them in 2017 and blew the roof of the building in Atlantic City. Every video I watch from this tour and 2019 the drums sound awful.
i don't know what tp say other then this is for squares who worked to hard and missed their youth...... cheap seats are over 200$.... that should tell you something..... Deead n Company do the same thing..... no self respecting scenester would be caught dead at this show..... in my opinion.....
@@corbettdc They sure were, the best! If you even look at just 7 years ago live they were worth watching. This tour looks like two old gramps out there with Daltry looming weak and confused at times , totally missing notes . Emabarrising really.
@@lobstermania4025let’s see you do even a quarter of what these guys are doing when you’re approaching 80. The life they’ve lived of 10 men. They sound great.. give em a break. Rather this and have some mistakes than some fella up there with headphones pushing buttons -cd player glorified dj
I don't blame him for losing his place in the song given how hard they are working. This was the first The Who concert I've been to and it was extremely hot just being in the audience. So I can't imagine what they feel like on stage.
![[TH] 2024 PMWC x EWC Group Stage Day 3 | PUBG MOBILE WORLD CUP x ESPORTS WORLD CUP](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VnOqutfqWqU/mqdefault.jpg)
I think we have lost sight in the fact these guys are still preforming at a high level consistently!
It’s sobering witnessing all these greats nearing the end of the road.
And theres nobody to take their place :(
For real. I got to see Rush several times before they called it quits and Neil Peart passed away, I saw Tom Petty 2 months before HE passed away, and this summer I’ll be seeing Roger Waters for probably the last time.
Les Stones sont bien plus énergiques sur scène
@@vincentberthier9583 The Who blew them off the stage many many times
@@MrBrungers les
Rolling Stones sont le plus grand groupe de la planète tu ne peux pas lutter contre ça j'adore les Who mais il sont (surtout actuellement) bien en dessous des stones
Just to hear Daltry nail that trademark scream still today is worth the price of admission. Unbelievable!! 👏👏👏👏
Sorry to inform you that it's tracked. Still entertaining I guess. Late 70s here.
Some crowds expect miracles.
The scream at the end was a combination of Roger doing it live, and the recorded scream from the Who’s Next album (I could hear the bit of scratchiness from the album). But hey, Rog is 78 - gotta cut him some slack here. The fact that he and Pete are out there doing it at all is a miracle in itself.
That was all live...if they used a backing track (which they don't) you wouldn't hear an "album"....they would use a tape. That's still all Roger!.
@JimiC sorry, you're wrong.
@@ralphboyle Either way, you did not hear a record "scratch" because IF they DID they would NOT use a RECORD. I am a musician and familiar with live sound. You just get your kicks being right. Whatever.
@@jimic5960 lol
lol
Geez Roger still sounds great!
I got up on stage with them in OKC and confessed my love for them, and I caught a pick 🤘
Roger looks like he'd be a good wrestling manager? Haha lol
Wow! Great video. My wife and I were at the show in St Louis (courtesy of our son) Thanks for taking the time to do this. To sacrifice your "live' experience so that you can share this with others is admirable and very much appreciated.
You bet! The show was great, hope to see em again! Please subscribe and check out my back catalog! Over 2500 live concert videos!
www.youtube.com/@DeadMikeConcertVideos/playlists
He hit the scream (7:47), and I think it was actually live! I was expecting either a debacle or something pre-recorded, but that sounded live, and sounded really good!
No. That is for sure the scream from the album. He did the same thing in 2017.
Andy be trippin!
Roger sounds fine but the scream was not live. If you saw the concert for NYC *live* in 2001, the scream was an absolute train wreck. Trust me. I heard it live. It was subsequently overdubbed for video release. If Roger could not hit the scream *THEN* he sure as hell is not doing it over 20 years later at nearly age 80. Please get a grip on reality.
@@Better_Call_Raul Upon further review... I am willing to concede that it's very likely I was wrong and the scream is probably a mix of (mostly) a recording together with whatever he's still capable of at age 78. I let my enthusiasm for the band and the song get the better of my objective analysis. But I don't see why you need to be mean about it. 🤷♂
It was very hot that night. I felt for Roger and Pete. Great job guys.
OMG !!! They're still alive !!! Rock on !!!
I love Pete counting in to get back on track after monitor issues with Roger❤️🎸
Saw them couple of nights ago in Portland Oregon. They were awesome 👌
Love the improve, true professionals 🎸
Worth every penny, glad I went even if I was one of the youngest people there
I saw them Pre pandemic. Roger is definitely less animated than he was 3 years ago
Dirty old man!! I love ya💪👏👍👍
A few harsh comments on here.... but I think we just have to appreciate that the golden generation of rock/Pop pioneers are close to retirement or dare I say, the inevitable. I'm glad I've seen most of my musical heroes at least once live, and there's many of them. The Who, Stones, Hollies, Beach Boys all still exist with at least 2 original members and have existed for at least 60 years, (The Who slightly less). It's knowing when to call it a day - flagging performances, physical deficits or a significant band member's death. Only they will know when.
I watched this just to see if Roger could still hit the scream. Damn....he did. I am very impressed. It seems to weird to see him very old and that heavy since he was in such great shape in his heyday. I would not recognize him walking down the street. Looks like someone who would yell at me to get off his lawn....but he hit the scream. Kudos.
Spoilers hahaha
He didn't. He was lip syncing.
Roger sounds fine but the scream was not live. If you saw the concert for NYC live in 2001, the scream was an absolute train wreck. Trust me. I heard it live. It was subsequently overdubbed for video release. If Roger could not hit the scream THEN he sure as hell is not doing it over 20 years later at nearly age 80. Please get a grip on reality.
The whooooo you guys pushing 80 that's what blows my brain swell they can still do it!!!
Увидимся в Берлине 😎💥💪👍
No hiding here. The Who still happy to demonstrate their live chops. Only Queen beats them.
ピート優しいｗ
I don’t understand the harsh and critical comments. You obviously can’t go see The Who today and expect them to look and sound like they did 20, 30, 40 or 50 years ago. I realize it’s a bit of a backhanded compliment, like telling a woman that she looks good for her age. But given Roger and Pete’s age (78 and 77), I think they still look and sound pretty darn good. I’ve seen some embarrassing shows (think B.B. King at the end or Bon Jovi now), and to me, this isn’t embarrassing at all. As long as you have realistic expectations, I think The Who is still worth seeing and a treat for the fans that they’re still out there performing at, although certainly diminished from their prime, but at a still pretty remarkable level nearly 60 years later.
Roger sounds fine for his age but they need to use common sense and drop the key from A to G. Don't know why it is not done. Does Pete prefer playing the song in the original key? But make no mistake, Roger would sound much better and less strained if the key was dropped. And the audience would never know nor care.
It's a mud bath meets a clam bake.
And Roger can still do the scream at least some concerts!
Yeah he can lip sync to the isolated scream from the album.
Oh well they're trying..at that age gotta hand it to'em
Starky rules
Let me spell that correctly for you - sucks
They seem to be having their share of technical problems on this tour.
I think it has a lot to do with the electric drums and other performers, when they did this back in 2019 the sound was awful too. I saw them in 2017 and blew the roof of the building in Atlantic City. Every video I watch from this tour and 2019 the drums sound awful.
After playing this song like 5,000 times, they completely F*cked it up- time to pack it in fellas.
I was there, just awful. Roger Daltrey reminded me of somebody's drunk uncle singing at a party.
Bit of a mess.
i don't know what tp say other then this is for squares who worked to hard and missed their youth...... cheap seats are over 200$.... that should tell you something..... Deead n Company do the same thing..... no self respecting scenester would be caught dead at this show..... in my opinion.....
Depressing compared to what they were once like glad I didnt waste money and go
Idiotic comment. What did you expect??
Damn Roger can still sing at 78. Yet the hairpiece looks ridiculous. It’s ok you are bald.
Are you kidding? What did you pay to see this?
Yeah, its comical.. they should be laying by the pool in an old folks home.
Great artist in their prime! Sad embarrassment in old age.
@@corbettdc They sure were, the best! If you even look at just 7 years ago live they were worth watching. This tour looks like two old gramps out there with Daltry looming weak and confused at times , totally missing notes . Emabarrising really.
@@lobstermania4025let’s see you do even a quarter of what these guys are doing when you’re approaching 80. The life they’ve lived of 10 men. They sound great.. give em a break. Rather this and have some mistakes than some fella up there with headphones pushing buttons -cd player glorified dj
Rogers Voice is great but his brain is gone..
Wtf? Why?
He lost his monitor that's all.
I don't blame him for losing his place in the song given how hard they are working. This was the first The Who concert I've been to and it was extremely hot just being in the audience. So I can't imagine what they feel like on stage.
@@mattcox20109 and Pete had his jacket on.
electric drums? horrible.
Just the cymbals.
@@ledgema7686 no, they look like acoustic drums but they are not.