You weren't wrong when you referred to the 22lr silvertip as a rebranded round, even thought it's not a typical hp. They were originally sold as a varmint round and called the Varmint HE. And personally I think it's kind of irresponsible of them to market a purposely frangible varmint load for SD. I've tested these also and while the base does penetrate adequately, what's left after the fragments peel off in the first couple inches is only 23.5 grains.
I looked it up. You are right. Winchester Varmint HE 37 gr Segmenting. Same bullet when it's zoomed in. The Silvertip is coated in some silver colored wash, so I guess one could argue it's different, but silver colored copper wash and the 1,400 FPS rating expressed through a handgun and "1,060 FPS" slapped on the box is pretty far from innovation.
I would have to agree both of these rimfire options are highly questionable regarding their viability for the intended use as suggested by Winchester's marketing.
My two grown daughters are not gun people & are recoil sensitive. I gifted each of them a small .22 revolver they keep in the house that they can easily handle. If I had the $$ I’d upgrade both to .22 mag. Thx for another informative video!
The closeups of the gel block and initial penetration depth measurements/analysis of the performance, that camera was very shaky from the wrong settings being on. Any attempt to fix it post production failed. There's also some secondary camera shake with the steel target but it's not as noticeable. Most people won't notice, but if you have had vertigo be careful!
Thanks. I don't think I am lol, I see a lot of cool content. However for someone that just goes out with one or two boxes of ammo, some gel and two GoPro's, I milk all I can out of what little I have to work with.
Really nice comparison. The .22 LR ST seemed to work somewhat reliably out of my 1980s vintage Beretta Bobcats. The .38 Special seemed to perform about the same as it always has since gurus started testing them in gel in the late 80s. My favorite ST is still the 145 grain .357 Mag version. Elegant round.
Winchester should get a new name. WhateverWorks lol. Out of all the companies, they seem to have the most random designs, and they market them to death. Like Defender/PDX1, Ranger, Ranger T, Silvertip, USA, Super X, Big Bore, USA Ready, Ranger One, Black Talon, SXT and the list goes on and on. Compare that to like Speer - Gold Dot, G2, Lawman...
You should do a review on silvertip and the super x power point with the herritage rough rider vs a semi auto. I got a herritage rough rider an use both but trust the silvertip a little more for defense. (An the silvertip i bought say 1080fps)
Personally, I think Winchester makes the lowest quality defensive ammo out of the big american ammo brands. I tried a couple boxes of 22lr Silvertips and the shitty stuff had at least one dud and at least 2 low powered charges in every magazine, on top of that, the stuff stank like Aquila made ammo. Federal's Punch (22lr and 22 mag) never had that issue, Hornady's Critical Defense (22 mag) never had that issue, and Speer's Gold Dot (22 mag) never had that issue. I would like the 22LR silvertip if it was made by someone else.
I'd say Federal is the best, then Speer. I have seen some pretty bad stuff from Remington though, albeit they don't fancy up the box and hike the price like Winchester does.
22LR definitely benefits from staying in one piece. The 38 Special didn't do too badly. I wish those projectiles were available as reloading components. All I can seem to find these days is XTPs.
I'd say the .22 is one of those things that can be looked at in different ways. In one piece, the penetration would be less, shedding those pieces basically turns it into the 29 gr Federal Punch. But it seems misleading a bit, as i'm not sure going an inch or two more in gel justifies lowering the projectile mass, and that mass might have tumbled or done something more nasty.
Just purchased today a Taurus 865 38 special.The firing pin fell out on the first dry fire jamming up the gun.I removed the side plate and discovered there was no retaining pin installed for the firing, also number on side plate did not match gun serial number one digit off. So off to Taurus we go. 😡🤬
That is really messed up. I always tell people, a gamble on Taurus has a 50% chance of having something useable, but never make it your first gun because you need at least one more for when the Taurus has to go back.
This and a few other 22Mag tests revise my opinion about it as a defensive round. Only data from real life shootings would finalize my thoughts about it versus 380ACP for my wife carry.
I only buy ammo sold in a 50 round boxes even in defensive ammo can't beat Federal train and protect not the absolute best defensive ammo it performs well and are very reliable dependable same can be said with Gold Dots if needing center fired handgun ammo 9mm 45acp 40sw 10mm 357 SIG and CCI mini mags if needing 22lr ammo because it has been the most reliable in all my 22lr rim fired handguns and rifles remember a FMJ that fires cycles and ejects and chambers the next round without any hang ups is better than a JHP that doesn't if your life is depending on it so my ammo pick for quality defensive ammo that is somewhat cost effective would be Federal protect and train - Speer Gold Dots - CCI mini mags only ones sold in 50 round boxes no outrageous priced 20 round boxes I'm sure its great ammo just can"t afford it
I like to buy Gold Dot and HST on the websites that sell LE ammo to the general public. Many sites sell 9mm+P, .40 S&W and .45 ACP in Gold Dot or HST in 50 round boxes for $30 to $40.
@@hoffmiermp l think the Federal train and protect 10mm 180 grain should go 1140-1160fps out of your Glock 20 Federal rates it at 1175fps best 10mm ammo available no but at 38-42 dollars for 50 rounds l think it's hard to beat muzzle energy is 550 pounds you'd be paying for some high dollar 40sw to beat these numbers
Not a brand I buy. Those .38's are too light. .22's are a lot of fun. I just plink with those. Thanks for the test. Hopefully your tube stopped deleting my posts.
Again, i don't see how barrel travel is a relevant metric to determine fairness of a test. Not that the miniscule difference matters much here, but it means giving the already longer cartridge a longer overall system length breech to muzzle when - correct me if i'm wrong - the ideal comparison would be between same sized guns? If one cartridge requires 3 inches of casing to do its thing, do you give it a 6" barrel for fairness reasons?
One, EXACTLY. A 3" revolver and 4" semi auto is the SAME size gun. I am not measuring from breech to muzzle, I am measuring from bullet nose to muzzle. Except for short semi auto cases in a semi auto caliber revolver, a .38 Special/.357 Mag is about the same nose to muzzle in a 3" revolver as a 4" semi auto, same goes for 4" revolver and 5" semi auto and so on. SAME size gun, same bullet travel nose to muzzle.
@@GunSam Yeah, but that's a coincidence when comparing semis and wheel guns in this case. You don't cut down half an inch of barrel length in a moon-clipped 9mm revolver because it would have an unfair advantage in the length of its acceleration path. No, you take the same gun ideally with the same dimensions and see which caliber does better with what is offered. That usually means breach to muzzle.
@@GunSam I just found that video and watched it, I’m just a little disappointed in the fpe, are buffalo bore and underwood the only brands that make 38spl with decent power?
I never did anything. I think TH-cam is pulling some stuff. Like I commented on Wilson Combat's last video, and it was really detailed and a good comment with nothing in it to not post, but it was gone a minute later. I have indeed after the fact, went into my comments where there are 'held for review" and "inappropriate/spam" comments, and most of the time they are comments like "good video!" or random stuff like whatever you would have said. The only time I ever delete comments is when someone leaves one that is disrespectful like "come on idiot, I don't agree, and you are dumb and here is why" etc etc, because of the tone. If anyone posts a comment here that is completely normal without hating on people, it always stays. I will check my spam comments.
@GunSam TH-cam is so fickle. Almost every channel, covering numerous subjects that I follow, has been subjected to tampering. The summary of my comment was that the 22 Mag is far superior to the. 22 LR. That's it !
@@MrJdebest.. TH-cam is not fickle; they are Mercenary. Every decision is based on what creates the greatest revenue. They will demonetize or outright ban a channel that makes advertisers cancel contracts. They will tolerate a “gun channel” because they are very popular and draw a lot of views. They will use software ‘bots to look for ‘objectionable comments (or content)” because those are cheaper than paying human beings. (I’ve seen MANY creators complain that ‘you cannot call a live person at TH-cam! It’s all AI!) TH-cam (Google Alphabet Inc.) cares LEAST about pissing off a single viewer (like you or me) because we - as individuals - add the least value to any channel’s revenue stream. Every single decision or action you experience here is formatted by what makes them the most money.
You weren't wrong when you referred to the 22lr silvertip as a rebranded round, even thought it's not a typical hp. They were originally sold as a varmint round and called the Varmint HE. And personally I think it's kind of irresponsible of them to market a purposely frangible varmint load for SD. I've tested these also and while the base does penetrate adequately, what's left after the fragments peel off in the first couple inches is only 23.5 grains.
I knew CCI had something like that, but thanks for the info. This one guy on another video was SCREAMING about how wrong I was lol.
I looked it up. You are right. Winchester Varmint HE 37 gr Segmenting. Same bullet when it's zoomed in. The Silvertip is coated in some silver colored wash, so I guess one could argue it's different, but silver colored copper wash and the 1,400 FPS rating expressed through a handgun and "1,060 FPS" slapped on the box is pretty far from innovation.
@@GunSam u should a video on cans with those calibers 40gr cci mini mag I didn’t expect for them to do sum crazy damage to the cans
I would have to agree both of these rimfire options are highly questionable regarding their viability for the intended use as suggested by Winchester's marketing.
Nice testing as always. Enjoyed the video.
Thanks Buffalo
My two grown daughters are not gun people & are recoil sensitive. I gifted each of them a small .22 revolver they keep in the house that they can easily handle. If I had the $$ I’d upgrade both to .22 mag. Thx for another informative video!
The lcr, I’m assuming.
I have recommended .22 Magnum to numerous friends who are recoil averse. I'm always impressed by .22 magnum penetration tests. Thanks Sam!
The closeups of the gel block and initial penetration depth measurements/analysis of the performance, that camera was very shaky from the wrong settings being on. Any attempt to fix it post production failed. There's also some secondary camera shake with the steel target but it's not as noticeable. Most people won't notice, but if you have had vertigo be careful!
GS. Good video. Always interesting comparisons. Plus, great shooing. Thanks for sharing and take care.
Thank you. Take care.
Interesting test. I recently found for the first time Winchester Silvertips in 357 mag, 145gr projectile. They seem shootable in my 3 inch M60.
Thanks for all the testing !!!
Love all your Content Sam
Thank you
Sam you are the best and most professional gun guy on U Tube!
Thanks. I don't think I am lol, I see a lot of cool content. However for someone that just goes out with one or two boxes of ammo, some gel and two GoPro's, I milk all I can out of what little I have to work with.
Really nice comparison. The .22 LR ST seemed to work somewhat reliably out of my 1980s vintage Beretta Bobcats. The .38 Special seemed to perform about the same as it always has since gurus started testing them in gel in the late 80s. My favorite ST is still the 145 grain .357 Mag version. Elegant round.
I appreciate the info Sir. 👍
Thanks for watching!
Thanks for the video always wondered how the Winchester 38SPL silver tip Performs
Thanks for watching. I filmed another video from my 2" Taurus 605 with the newer .38 Special+P 125 gr JHP also.
@@GunSam I have the Taurus 856 Snub nose it's My EDC
Very informative test.
Thanks much!
I tried to buy hyper 22 Lr Winchester at wally world , they only had the 1,280 copper plated 40 gr stuff .
Really dig your tests man. Like the way you think outside the box.
Thank you. Could also be a pun lol. I used to use a ballistic box on the side of my gel shelf, now I shoot gel on the outside of it...
Thanks, that was helpful. The .22LR Silvertip did better than I expected. .38 Special still does the job.
Thanks again !!!
Good test , good ammo too .
Thanks
Good info. The 38 Special looks good.
Not all types of Silvertips are great , many are very good . On av I have had good luck with all kinds of Winchester , Wt Box , Ranger T , others .
Winchester should get a new name. WhateverWorks lol. Out of all the companies, they seem to have the most random designs, and they market them to death. Like Defender/PDX1, Ranger, Ranger T, Silvertip, USA, Super X, Big Bore, USA Ready, Ranger One, Black Talon, SXT and the list goes on and on. Compare that to like Speer - Gold Dot, G2, Lawman...
You should do a review on silvertip and the super x power point with the herritage rough rider vs a semi auto. I got a herritage rough rider an use both but trust the silvertip a little more for defense. (An the silvertip i bought say 1080fps)
Personally, I think Winchester makes the lowest quality defensive ammo out of the big american ammo brands. I tried a couple boxes of 22lr Silvertips and the shitty stuff had at least one dud and at least 2 low powered charges in every magazine, on top of that, the stuff stank like Aquila made ammo. Federal's Punch (22lr and 22 mag) never had that issue, Hornady's Critical Defense (22 mag) never had that issue, and Speer's Gold Dot (22 mag) never had that issue. I would like the 22LR silvertip if it was made by someone else.
I'd say Federal is the best, then Speer. I have seen some pretty bad stuff from Remington though, albeit they don't fancy up the box and hike the price like Winchester does.
That's why I don't carry a automatic because they will all jam one day good video
22LR definitely benefits from staying in one piece. The 38 Special didn't do too badly. I wish those projectiles were available as reloading components. All I can seem to find these days is XTPs.
I'd say the .22 is one of those things that can be looked at in different ways. In one piece, the penetration would be less, shedding those pieces basically turns it into the 29 gr Federal Punch. But it seems misleading a bit, as i'm not sure going an inch or two more in gel justifies lowering the projectile mass, and that mass might have tumbled or done something more nasty.
Regards!
38 worked pretty well, 22 Mag has better rounds, 22LR for hunting small game would be great but not for a defensive round. Thanks for the test.
Just purchased today a Taurus 865 38 special.The firing pin fell out on the first dry fire jamming up the gun.I removed the side plate and discovered there was no retaining pin installed for the firing, also number on side plate did not match gun serial number one digit off. So off to Taurus we go. 😡🤬
That is really messed up. I always tell people, a gamble on Taurus has a 50% chance of having something useable, but never make it your first gun because you need at least one more for when the Taurus has to go back.
👍😊
This and a few other 22Mag tests revise my opinion about it as a defensive round. Only data from real life shootings would finalize my thoughts about it versus 380ACP for my wife carry.
I only buy ammo sold in a 50 round boxes even in defensive ammo can't beat Federal train and protect not the absolute best defensive ammo it performs well and are very reliable dependable same can be said with Gold Dots if needing center fired handgun ammo 9mm 45acp 40sw 10mm 357 SIG and CCI mini mags if needing 22lr ammo because it has been the most reliable in all my 22lr rim fired handguns and rifles remember a FMJ that fires cycles and ejects and chambers the next round without any hang ups is better than a JHP that doesn't if your life is depending on it so my ammo pick for quality defensive ammo that is somewhat cost effective would be Federal protect and train - Speer Gold Dots - CCI mini mags only ones sold in 50 round boxes no outrageous priced 20 round boxes I'm sure its great ammo just can"t afford it
I like to buy Gold Dot and HST on the websites that sell LE ammo to the general public. Many sites sell 9mm+P, .40 S&W and .45 ACP in Gold Dot or HST in 50 round boxes for $30 to $40.
The HST is so so imo. I wasn't impressed with the 10mm stuff when I was getting .40SW velocities out of my G20.
@@hoffmiermp l think the Federal train and protect 10mm 180 grain should go 1140-1160fps out of your Glock 20 Federal rates it at 1175fps best 10mm ammo available no but at 38-42 dollars for 50 rounds l think it's hard to beat muzzle energy is 550 pounds you'd be paying for some high dollar 40sw to beat these numbers
Aren't you wondering how a 40 grain 22WMR out of your 3 inch would compare to a 40 grain 22Lr out of a 16 to 20 inch barrel?
1300 fps probably wouldn't happen from a rifle barrel on a 40gr .22LR unless it was one of the "hyper velocity" types.
You seem to have missed the whole point ---- to see how they (40 grain rounds) compare in the real world!@@exothermal.sprocket
@@Hutzjohn You seem to have missed my whole point.
OK smartass tell us all exactly what the 2 round did to the gel!@@exothermal.sprocket
Not a brand I buy. Those .38's are too light. .22's are a lot of fun. I just plink with those.
Thanks for the test. Hopefully your tube stopped deleting my posts.
I tried the 125+P version of Silvertip. I haven't released the video yet, but they were not impressive.
👍🙂
What's your favorite 22wmr for the 3-inch LCR at this point?
I would prefer out of the three 22WMR
No contest.that from a 9mm. or better guy.😊
Again, i don't see how barrel travel is a relevant metric to determine fairness of a test.
Not that the miniscule difference matters much here, but it means giving the already longer cartridge a longer overall system length breech to muzzle when - correct me if i'm wrong - the ideal comparison would be between same sized guns?
If one cartridge requires 3 inches of casing to do its thing, do you give it a 6" barrel for fairness reasons?
I honestly have no idea what you are talking about.
One, EXACTLY. A 3" revolver and 4" semi auto is the SAME size gun. I am not measuring from breech to muzzle, I am measuring from bullet nose to muzzle. Except for short semi auto cases in a semi auto caliber revolver, a .38 Special/.357 Mag is about the same nose to muzzle in a 3" revolver as a 4" semi auto, same goes for 4" revolver and 5" semi auto and so on. SAME size gun, same bullet travel nose to muzzle.
@@GunSam Yeah, but that's a coincidence when comparing semis and wheel guns in this case.
You don't cut down half an inch of barrel length in a moon-clipped 9mm revolver because it would have an unfair advantage in the length of its acceleration path.
No, you take the same gun ideally with the same dimensions and see which caliber does better with what is offered.
That usually means breach to muzzle.
I'll stick with my 22 mag Gold Dots
38 Special Olympics is kinda a Fudd round but its cheap and good for target practice in plus p its ok for women and wimps for defence I guess...
22lr is the best
38 spc wins convincingly. 22LR better than 22 WRM
I’ve been searching, is the there a 38spl Silvertip +p?
Yes in the 125 gr+P. I have tested it, it's 'new', however it used to exist as Super X Silvertip years ago.
@@GunSam I just found that video and watched it, I’m just a little disappointed in the fpe, are buffalo bore and underwood the only brands that make 38spl with decent power?
My comment about gophers has disappeared 😕
I never did anything. I think TH-cam is pulling some stuff. Like I commented on Wilson Combat's last video, and it was really detailed and a good comment with nothing in it to not post, but it was gone a minute later. I have indeed after the fact, went into my comments where there are 'held for review" and "inappropriate/spam" comments, and most of the time they are comments like "good video!" or random stuff like whatever you would have said. The only time I ever delete comments is when someone leaves one that is disrespectful like "come on idiot, I don't agree, and you are dumb and here is why" etc etc, because of the tone. If anyone posts a comment here that is completely normal without hating on people, it always stays. I will check my spam comments.
@GunSam TH-cam is so fickle. Almost every channel, covering numerous subjects that I follow, has been subjected to tampering. The summary of my comment was that the 22 Mag is far superior to the. 22 LR. That's it !
@@GunSam More and more censorship from TH-cam and the rest of the controlled media, even frivolous censorship for no known reason.
@@MrJdebest.. TH-cam is not fickle; they are Mercenary. Every decision is based on what creates the greatest revenue. They will demonetize or outright ban a channel that makes advertisers cancel contracts. They will tolerate a “gun channel” because they are very popular and draw a lot of views. They will use software ‘bots to look for ‘objectionable comments (or content)” because those are cheaper than paying human beings. (I’ve seen MANY creators complain that ‘you cannot call a live person at TH-cam! It’s all AI!) TH-cam (Google Alphabet Inc.) cares LEAST about pissing off a single viewer (like you or me) because we - as individuals - add the least value to any channel’s revenue stream. Every single decision or action you experience here is formatted by what makes them the most money.
PizzA
22 mag is ok.