What? Full walkthrough in order, with time stamps, with on screen POI , and no BS useless trash talking ?? This is the BEST tutorial I’ve seen across all channels and games!!!! Congrats! You got yourself a new subscriber !!! Cheers mate great job
Great video thank you, on my second playthrough going for inferno ending. This game is awesome, from a long time souls fan it has its problems but the positive easily out weighs the negative.
For a lot of the people thinking that the quest is bugged. Just make sure you got each of the items first. The order in which he will accept them is a little odd. He took the rosarys from me making me think I had to move on but I had actually missed the hallowed dentinal scripture.
This is ridiculous. I've given him everything in order. I can't do it any other way and got them all in this order. There's something screwing his quest up and I don't no what. And I'm a pure radiance build. I NEED him.
uhh, you need to mention that going into that well locks you out of the regular ending. And if anyone has purified a beam they will be locked out of all endings at this point.
@@scarvello Your objective in the game is to journey to 5 corrupted beacons and purify them, to prevent the return of the exile Adyr. If you actually go along with this, you'll get locked into the Radiance ending. If you go through the game without purifying any of the beacons, the other two endings become possible. If you just continue to the last level like usual, by default you'll get locked into the Inferno ending, where you help Adyr return instead of stopping him. To get the Umbral ending, you need to not purify any beacons, and also progress a quest in a secret area underground, before continuing to the last level. Adyr's return doesn't matter compared to what you end up doing.
@@UltraStarWarsFanatic ah thank you, it’s just strange to me because I didn’t even know the option to not do anything would also effect the game’s outcome. I pretty much did things out of order as usual during my first blind play throughs smh. I think the only reason I even went a Radiance build initially is because Pieta’s sword was so sick when I first saw it lol,
Very helpful! I took a long break from the game and forgot that I had already given him most of the items. Still need to fight the boss, but should be a straight shot from there.
Just one question. I am going for the radiant (good) ending in my first playthrough. Cleansed all beacons so far, I am in Upper Calrath on my way to Bramis Castle. Entering in the wall does lock out this ending?
On my 5th playthrough and this quest has broken for me every single time. After I give him the Rosary’s I get no further dialog options from him and he stays put near his table in Skyrest. I’ve tried restarting the game reloading save files warping in and out. Nothing works. I’ve tried not giving him and of the items until I have them all and still can’t get the quest to update. This is so BS my one of my only complaints about this game is the ridiculous way your supposed to know how to do NPC quest lines. Impossible without Google
Gave him everything thing even the Book of Sinners, and he is stuck on me getting that book even though I was maticulously following Fighting Cowboys 100% walk through. Went back to see if I missed the book but it was gone. I have radiant build and can't finish the questline.😂😢😂
@@MrBlainev no. Just kept playing and since he gives the one op radiat spell that is a must have for this build when you complete it I'm losing interest. Reloaded Dark Souls 3 and am reminded how the pros do it.
Hello, thank you for the easy guide. But one question, if I just enter mother Lull just to talk to Dunmire, am I locked from the other endings the moment I step in mother lull ?
Thanks for the guide, this quest is constantly bugged for me, both playthroughs, he just stops giving me the option to give him the tombs at some point and I cannot progress
Really? That's a shame. I wonder what caused it. Were you going step by step? If so, I think giving him all of the items at once might be the best strategy
@@NinjaPups Nope you were right, I missed the very first item both times, thanks for the clear video, was going nuts not being able to have lucent beam :)
Guessing mine is bugged, on psn. Gave him everything, he moved to mohu, he mentions he want's to decend & I can then find him in the skein but he's both in skein and in skyrest. he never goes to the mothers lull from the skein
So I was doing the fire ending, at some point he just bugged out, but after clearing the ending and not going into a ng, he finally moved completely from skyrest instead of bring at both locations, his skein talking had the right dialogue and then his stuff at the well was there, so at some point during the fire ending if you get that bug, just keep playing through and go back to him / the 10:30 mark in the video as he should complete still.
I handed him the hallowed scripture, then book of sin, then bloody aspergillum. After I handed him both rosary’s in order, and even though I have all the remaining items, it won’t let me hand them to him. Any way to fix this?
@@chriskociolek1830 I heard that some ppl having trouble with that, but it seems like a bug which probably getting fixed. But not the intentional design like Kukajin or cpt.Stormund
im stuck. i gave 2 items out of order before taking it serious and i had no problems until the dark crusaders call. he just wont accept it. i killed the biss got the rememberance and all but he wont interact
I have all the items, but it wont let me give him anything after the ravager gregorys rosary. Ive rested multiple times, exited out of the game a couple times. Nothing changes, is there something im doing wrong?
Thank you for making this guide! But it pains me when see our scholarly Dunmire is charmed by the Mother's presence and completely lost his mind. And in the end, probably he let himself be devoured by the Mother. His laugh in the end is creepy. A thing i hate in this game is almost shop NPCs run around too much and they disappear after finishing their quests, especially Stomund. He has good radiance spells for sale but he runs around too much and can dissappear forever if finishing his quest.
I don’t get this game. I thought we were supposed to clear the beacons to progress. It all started off good but i don’t know what the heck I’m doing. I’m sure it will all make sense somewhere. I’ve never been more turned around in a souls game. I kind of like that in a way but sometimes like , where the hell am I , I’m never getting back here. Lol thanks for the video much appreciated.
Where can i find him after completing the quest? I progresses the game till last encounter of lightreaper and suddenly decided to change my build stats because of dunmire's casting spells, but now he is available nowhere 😢
Appreciate this, he just kept screaming at me to go to the tower. Once I got that last piece forum he just disappeared. There is nothing that gives you any indication he would have went to the mines. That was literally the last place I want to look. Thankfully yes I found him and I was able to finally end this quest. I wish they gave you some kind of hints like from software does in item descriptions. The npc quest lines in this game are a pain.
Yeah absolutely. I mean even Elden Ring usually NPCS would give you quest items. You read the item descriptions and it generally gives you an idea of what you need to do next with them.@@NinjaPups
After completing this quest. Equip martyr shackles and harrower dervla's sword to unlock the special boss weapon skill for dervla sword. Thank me later!!!
@@NinjaPups no, if you use the scouring thing and enter the well, you are locked into umbral ending, and if you had previously purified a beacon you're fuct. no ending for you.
Do you have a timestamp for which one you're talking about? Throughout the video I use a few, notably dual Lightreaper swords and dual judge cleric's corruppted swords
This quest sucks it failed to let me hand in book of sin even though I did pick it up. Doesn't let you go back and retry what BS. New character now Barros rosary not on body !? F this game
What? Full walkthrough in order, with time stamps, with on screen POI , and no BS useless trash talking ?? This is the BEST tutorial I’ve seen across all channels and games!!!! Congrats! You got yourself a new subscriber !!! Cheers mate great job
Thanks so much! If any new quests or content comes to Lords of the Fallen, I plan to cover it! :)
Absolutely agree. Love the straightforwardness. Thank you sir. Subscribed
This helped me immensely, you sir are a true follower of Orius
After completing this quest. Equip martyr shackles and harrower dervla's sword to unlock the special boss weapon skill for dervla sword.
Damn, I finally found the most helpful and detailed guide for Don's quest!! As expected of u, thanks!!
Thank you very much for this detailed guide, it was very helpful :)
You are very welcome!
Great video thank you, on my second playthrough going for inferno ending. This game is awesome, from a long time souls fan it has its problems but the positive easily out weighs the negative.
For a lot of the people thinking that the quest is bugged. Just make sure you got each of the items first. The order in which he will accept them is a little odd. He took the rosarys from me making me think I had to move on but I had actually missed the hallowed dentinal scripture.
😂😂😂 The Hallowed "Dentinal" scripture, I love it! Not laughing at you but that sounded funny to me lol
This is ridiculous. I've given him everything in order. I can't do it any other way and got them all in this order. There's something screwing his quest up and I don't no what. And I'm a pure radiance build. I NEED him.
Very helpful. Thank you for making this video.
uhh, you need to mention that going into that well locks you out of the regular ending. And if anyone has purified a beam they will be locked out of all endings at this point.
It absolutely does not lock you into the umbral ending. I went to Mother's Lull and completed this quest during my Radiant playthrough.
@UltraStarWarsFanatic I wish, I tried doing the umbral ending but messed up and decided for the inferno ending.
Hey guys, what determines the endings that you get?
@@scarvello Your objective in the game is to journey to 5 corrupted beacons and purify them, to prevent the return of the exile Adyr. If you actually go along with this, you'll get locked into the Radiance ending.
If you go through the game without purifying any of the beacons, the other two endings become possible. If you just continue to the last level like usual, by default you'll get locked into the Inferno ending, where you help Adyr return instead of stopping him.
To get the Umbral ending, you need to not purify any beacons, and also progress a quest in a secret area underground, before continuing to the last level. Adyr's return doesn't matter compared to what you end up doing.
@@UltraStarWarsFanatic ah thank you, it’s just strange to me because I didn’t even know the option to not do anything would also effect the game’s outcome. I pretty much did things out of order as usual during my first blind play throughs smh. I think the only reason I even went a Radiance build initially is because Pieta’s sword was so sick when I first saw it lol,
awesome guide sir many thanks🎉
Video on point, no extra bullshit.Good job
Very helpful! I took a long break from the game and forgot that I had already given him most of the items. Still need to fight the boss, but should be a straight shot from there.
Just one question. I am going for the radiant (good) ending in my first playthrough. Cleansed all beacons so far, I am in Upper Calrath on my way to Bramis Castle. Entering in the wall does lock out this ending?
Awesome guide, thank you. I couldn't figure out where he went after giving him the Wisp.
without a guide, none the less as good as yours, i could not have done this quest :) well done
Thank you so much ☺️
Love all of your videos. Such good tutorials, hope you keeping making them for LOTF!
Thank you :)
Great tutorial. Lucky for me. I had missed only the first item on the list.
Thanks for the helpful video, my man!
Sure thing!
Awesome guide dude. Another trophy down. MVP
You are welcome :)
Wonderful guide, thank you for the time u spent
Thank you so much for the kind words. It was a lot of effort so I'm glad it helped!
Great guide. I was very confused until I realised I never picked up the first item as it was camouflaged in the flames
Yeah big thanks man 💯
Can’t believe I missed that one item in the tower! Thank you!
Went back for ravager rosary, not sure maybe I got it earlier in my play thru, but now he won’t talk to me about the umbral one
Same here :/
Finally, a good vid on this quest line; 🙌 thanks.
Thank u so much! missed the first item.
Great video thank you so much
You are welcome!
Big thank you
Another great video. Thanks
On my 5th playthrough and this quest has broken for me every single time. After I give him the Rosary’s I get no further dialog options from him and he stays put near his table in Skyrest. I’ve tried restarting the game reloading save files warping in and out. Nothing works. I’ve tried not giving him and of the items until I have them all and still can’t get the quest to update. This is so BS my one of my only complaints about this game is the ridiculous way your supposed to know how to do NPC quest lines. Impossible without Google
Gave him everything thing even the Book of Sinners, and he is stuck on me getting that book even though I was maticulously following Fighting Cowboys 100% walk through. Went back to see if I missed the book but it was gone. I have radiant build and can't finish the questline.😂😢😂
Bro I just ran Into this problem..have you figured why it stops?
@@MrBlainev no. Just kept playing and since he gives the one op radiat spell that is a must have for this build when you complete it I'm losing interest. Reloaded Dark Souls 3 and am reminded how the pros do it.
He is in mother's lull for me however he never dropped any of his equipment? Either by the entrance to mother's lull or in the mines. Can anyone help
Oh man just logged back in and my crossbow blows now lmao
So I gave him the wisp, but he’s not in the Umbral area you go to via the clump/well. I wonder if I screwed something up?
Hello, thank you for the easy guide.
But one question, if I just enter mother Lull just to talk to Dunmire, am I locked from the other endings the moment I step in mother lull ?
Thanks for the guide, this quest is constantly bugged for me, both playthroughs, he just stops giving me the option to give him the tombs at some point and I cannot progress
Really? That's a shame. I wonder what caused it. Were you going step by step? If so, I think giving him all of the items at once might be the best strategy
@@NinjaPups Nope you were right, I missed the very first item both times, thanks for the clear video, was going nuts not being able to have lucent beam :)
Same... I'll have to try and give all at once... sucks tho
Edit: all good now.. I actually missed the 1st item... and all back to normal. Thanks
Perfect thank you so much :)
what weapons are those? And great video ty!
Thank you, you absolute legend
I unlocked mothers lull but didn’t get the ring and went I went check corpse nothing either. I gave him items out of order is that a common bug?
I fixed the bug by traveling to skyrest resting exiting game and revisiting deeps where the lull is. Hope this helps someone
@@richalva415 That worked for me, thanks
Dude thank you. He wouldn't accept umbral and apparently i had given him all but the VERY FIRST ONE thanks
Thanks I was wondering why he wasn't moving. Kept saying to the tower. I looked it up & down & it was hidden.
For #5 the vestige is right underneath 😊
Thanks!
Guessing mine is bugged, on psn. Gave him everything, he moved to mohu, he mentions he want's to decend & I can then find him in the skein but he's both in skein and in skyrest. he never goes to the mothers lull from the skein
So I was doing the fire ending, at some point he just bugged out, but after clearing the ending and not going into a ng, he finally moved completely from skyrest instead of bring at both locations, his skein talking had the right dialogue and then his stuff at the well was there, so at some point during the fire ending if you get that bug, just keep playing through and go back to him / the 10:30 mark in the video as he should complete still.
thanks man
Can you tell me which armor is on your character at 8:50 (Umbral Tome) ? Thanks in advance.
That is the Paladin Armor Set, you can obtain that in the quest to unlock Dark Crusader class
thanks man, great help
I missed the Vanguard rosary and gave him the Perception Wisp already. Which means I can't buy anything from him until NG+ nooo
Also his ring and rosary weren't next to the well for me for some odd reason
Exiting to the menu and loading back in fixed it
Good to know!
I handed him the hallowed scripture, then book of sin, then bloody aspergillum. After I handed him both rosary’s in order, and even though I have all the remaining items, it won’t let me hand them to him. Any way to fix this?
Extremely useful.
Thx for the guide
And wow! an actual npc questline which aint breaking from making a single step in wrong direction.
You’re welcome, and yes I totally get you lol
This quest line is broken AF
@@chriskociolek1830 I heard that some ppl having trouble with that, but it seems like a bug which probably getting fixed. But not the intentional design like Kukajin or cpt.Stormund
Yeah I'm stuck after giving the rosary. There's no dialogue to give him the umbrel tome
Thanks for making the video
Sure thing
Thank you very much kind sir
im stuck. i gave 2 items out of order before taking it serious and i had no problems until the dark crusaders call. he just wont accept it. i killed the biss got the rememberance and all but he wont interact
I got the umbral tome and he wont even take it I wanted that radiance spell ? Any ideas?
Good gide only problem is i had to look eldewhere how to get back to the depths
Oh, my bad!
I have all the items, but it wont let me give him anything after the ravager gregorys rosary. Ive rested multiple times, exited out of the game a couple times. Nothing changes, is there something im doing wrong?
I have no idea, I'm sorry :( I hope it works for you soon though
Guess i did mine in a different order and now i cant give him roasary until after dark knight call.
Thank you for making this guide! But it pains me when see our scholarly Dunmire is charmed by the Mother's presence and completely lost his mind. And in the end, probably he let himself be devoured by the Mother. His laugh in the end is creepy.
A thing i hate in this game is almost shop NPCs run around too much and they disappear after finishing their quests, especially Stomund. He has good radiance spells for sale but he runs around too much and can dissappear forever if finishing his quest.
I don’t get this game. I thought we were supposed to clear the beacons to progress. It all started off good but i don’t know what the heck I’m doing. I’m sure it will all make sense somewhere. I’ve never been more turned around in a souls game. I kind of like that in a way but sometimes like , where the hell am I , I’m never getting back here. Lol thanks for the video much appreciated.
Excellent.
Thanks very helpful
I have the Dark crusader call AND umbral tome yet he has no new dialogue. Is it ANOTHER bugged quest ? This is getting fucking tiring.
Is it some bug that i picked up his gear and have no achivment?
Where can i find him after completing the quest? I progresses the game till last encounter of lightreaper and suddenly decided to change my build stats because of dunmire's casting spells, but now he is available nowhere 😢
If you completed his quest, he’s dead I’m afraid
Is this doable with eliyanne as end boss ?
It's been so long, I don't remember if they are compatible, sorry :/ Let me know if you figure it out though
Does anyone know what you do with his rosary? Seems weird you get another "armor" quest item with no one to give it too...cause he...y'know.
I think it's just a collectible reward similar to the banner you get at the end of stomund's quest.
What swords are those??
the side quests in this game are so poorly designed it's crazy. thanks for this video mate, great effort
Glad you found it helpful
It won't let me give dunmire the scripture thing before the rosary.
Thank!
Appreciate this, he just kept screaming at me to go to the tower. Once I got that last piece forum he just disappeared. There is nothing that gives you any indication he would have went to the mines. That was literally the last place I want to look. Thankfully yes I found him and I was able to finally end this quest. I wish they gave you some kind of hints like from software does in item descriptions. The npc quest lines in this game are a pain.
You are welcome. And yeah I agree with that.
Yeah absolutely. I mean even Elden Ring usually NPCS would give you quest items. You read the item descriptions and it generally gives you an idea of what you need to do next with them.@@NinjaPups
Gg bro this quest have no glitch now is work step by step give item
Anyone know why his loot wont spawn in for me in the mines?
Thanks
Sure thing :)
After completing this quest. Equip martyr shackles and harrower dervla's sword to unlock the special boss weapon skill for dervla sword.
Thank me later!!!
He just says see to the book crusader and thats it HELP SOMEONE PLEASE 🙏
If I enter mother's lull does that lock me into the umbral ending?
No it doesn't. You can even go back and light the beacons after visiting mother's lull if you want.
@@NinjaPups ok, thanks
@@NinjaPups no, if you use the scouring thing and enter the well, you are locked into umbral ending, and if you had previously purified a beacon you're fuct. no ending for you.
No , i entered the mother's lull after i cleansed some beacons and still i did the radiant ending . @@nastysoda9212
his gear is not there for me
Where do i get the spells now?
Nowhere. Once he’s dead you’re locked out of his specific spells
Did everything he did but the loot is not at the mines lol
ATTEND TO ME SURGEON
For some reason he won’t take the wisp from me
He wont move to the umbral room for me i dont understand its my second play through and i camt 100% percent the game if dumbmire wont move his ass😢😂
Hes not there after i see him in the mines
Damn dude how tf are you level 578 lol great vid btw
He does not accept my dar crusader item..
WHAT SWORD IS THAT IN YOUR RIGHT HAND????
Do you have a timestamp for which one you're talking about? Throughout the video I use a few, notably dual Lightreaper swords and dual judge cleric's corruppted swords
Dang I messed up and locked myself out of getting his spells and weapons.
All because a book drove him to madness. Sad.
Oof 😥
I’m starting to think the NPCs won’t get happy endings in this game😂
XD yeah…
The lack of quest directions is the major downfall of these type of games.
No actually it isn't. It's a trademark style choice and one of the reasons people love these games
Where is the prescription wisp
In the tower?
Lost me at 50 scourings 😭
I cant give his ass the umbral tome
There's his ring right after you exit mother's lull
It's nuts how long the side quests are in this game wtf
Just a normal quest design for souls likes. In elden ring you have side quests that span through entirety of the game
Dunmire lost his marbles 😮 i kinda felt bad for him at mothers lull
Same. He couldn't handle the Umbral D:
I guess I screwed up? I beat the game then tried the quest?...LOL
6
This quest sucks it failed to let me hand in book of sin even though I did pick it up. Doesn't let you go back and retry what BS. New character now Barros rosary not on body !? F this game
How the fuck were you meant to find this out? 🤦🏻♂️
Man, the NPC quests in this game make no sense