There are two terms used in Islamic laws. Had and tazeer. In field of tazeer legislature has authority to make laws under umbrella of basic religious injunctions. But in field of had punishments have been told through revealed text...
I salute your contributions in v log. Indians are more here with great knowledge but language is a problem.I learnt the concept of marxism from you.I am a scholar in sialkot.
Islam ka maaashi or siyasi nizaam khaskar hazrat umar(R.A) kai zamanai sai aik behtareen nizaam hai,agar apko kisi cheez kai barai mai ilam nahi hai is ka yeh matlab nahi kai woh cheez wajood he nai rakhte
Salam Sir, much agreed. The revival of practice of Ijtihad is necessary, but the question remains that who is deemed worthy of interpreting the religion in accordance with modern needs. Moreover, Muslims are bound by faith yet divided by sect and geographical barriers. Keeping this in mind, what is the geographical jurisdiction of Ijtihad conducted in Saudia or any other country? Insight and opinion is appreciated. Thanks...
This is the main problem that one cannot be open totally and Express freely his ideas related to religion. I can guess that you are trying to defend too much rather than criticize openly.
Taimur sahib. Can I see u. I am kalid Farooq basra living in dha. I was anti capitalism I was convicted one year jail as student leader I have written a book علماء کے سرمایہ داری رویے
AsSalamu Alaykum Prof Taimur Rahman, I have mostly enjoyed many of your videos dealing with the economic and political situation in Pakistan. You break it down pretty well even though I disagree partly with your analysis of applying socialism as a model for success. Personally, I think that we need a small central government and make the provinces independent for them to make their own financial decisions, manage their own affairs. This was the method of government that was adopted the Muslim caliphs as well where the governors were responsible for managing their state independently. Curiously, in the US as well, the original model has been small central gov and power to the states, even though the center keeps taking more and more. I disagree with your analysis with respect to the shariah being related only to worship and family matters. The Prophet Muhammad (saw) taught his followers [sahaba] all aspects of life not just related to worship, family law, inheritance but also about the task of governing, state craft, and financial transactions (Which is extensive actually). Obviously, not every sahabi had the same skillset. Some excelled over the others. This can be seen clearly in the caliphate of Omar Ibn Khattab [ra]. One small example is the pension system that he setup for the retired soldiers. From the time of the Prophet's death to the 17th century (roughly) the Muslim world was way ahead of the rest of the world in sciences, architecture, law, financial banking system (non riba based of course). I AGREE with you that at some point, the Muslim scholars stopped doing ijtihad which started a downward spiral and not to mention the constant in-fighting amongst the dynastic Muslim rulers as can be seen clearly in the Muslim Spain. I would also add that Muslims by this time had come decadent with their easy life styles. This aspect is also mentioned the Muqaddimah of Ibn Khaldun where he says the sunnah of the world is that nations rise and fall. "Ibn Khaldun argues that each dynasty has within itself the seeds of its own downfall. He explains that ruling houses tend to emerge on the peripheries of great empires and use the unity presented by those areas to their advantage in order to bring about a change in leadership. As the new rulers establish themselves at the center of their empire, they become increasingly lax and more concerned with maintaining their lifestyles. Thus, a new dynasty can emerge at the periphery of their control and effect a change in leadership, beginning the cycle anew." Anyways, these were just some random thoughts on my part. Looking forward to listening to more of your vlogs.
I,m sorry sir..i totally disagree with u ..islamic system her lehaaz se mukamal guide krta ha..aur ethics ka economy k sath bht gehraa taaluq ha..ap islamic economic aur political system ko mazed prhen..ye captilism aur socialism se bht behter ha..aur insani nature k mutabik ha.
Fiqah aur Shariah mai bunyadi farq hi galat kia hai apnay! Shariah poori Quran mai mojood hai aur uski interpretation Sunnah mai mojood hai. Shariah ko samajhnay ke liye Fiqah mai jannay ki zarorat hi nahi.
Evaluate Islam based on science. A lot of errors in Hadiths and Quran, so scientifically Islam is not based on actual facts. But for Muslims who wants to make sure there is still Islam in the world, the door to ijtihad must be open, to “reinterpret” laws of Islam into something more modern......
u should read Maulana Modudi books, islam guides in detail about politics, these 04 fiqh were not developed to govern khilafat system, expand ur vision.
The whole summarization of the video is, Shariah means rules manifest by God through various revelations and jurisprudence means interpretation of Shariah rules by Human through self-conscience and varied level of apprehensions. There are five major school of jurisprudence in Islam including Hanfi, Malaki, shafi hanbali and shia school of jurisprudence. Until 13th century jurisprudence and interpretation of Quran and Sunnah had almost halted and Ijtihad was no more considered requisite which is the interpretation of sharia rules according to any specific time interval or needs
محترم ! آپ کو ایک غلط فہمی ہوئی ہے۔ وہ یہ ہے کہ قوانین دور رسالت میں نافذ نہیں ہوئے۔ حقیقت یہ ہے کہ قوانین دور نبوت اور خلافت میں نافذ ہو چکے تھے۔ اسلام کا اپنا پینل کوڈ نافذ ہو چکا تھا۔ شریعہ نے اپنے مقاصد بتا دیے ہیں۔
تیمور رحمان یار آپ کا طریقہ کار بہت خوبصورت ہے کہ بڑی ہمدردی سے کسی کو برا لگے بغیر اس کی جہالت کا اعتراف کرایا جائے اور پھر اس جہالت سے نکلنے پر آمادہ کیا جائے۔
in true islam" namaz means system ensuring equality in providing security and safety of honour, wealth and life of all is equal; roza means, every man and woman are bound to have war training to fight in the days of wars. zakat means share happiness and sorrows with each other; hajj means stage a jihad against who attack a muslim state. a muslim is who believe on equality with aiman on Hazrat Muhammad PBUH as messenger of God and God is alone.
Great explanation, it will help Muslim society to be clear about sharia and life economics. Help the society to differentiate the economics and dharma. Respect your clarity and scholarship Madhukar Jadhav
I disagree on certain points.Not every kind of Ijtihad is prohibited and shariah deals with eco,IR as much as it deals with society. Muhazirat e Fiqh a must read book
یار تیمور ! جب سماج سے خطاب ہوگا تو حکومتی عدالتی۔معاشی۔معاشرتی۔خارجی تمام معاملات آئیں گے اور انہیں چیزوں پر ریاست استوار ہوتی ھے جس کو اسلام نے مخاطب کیا ھے۔ تو آپ اگر کہیں کہ اسلام نے عبادات و اخلاقیات کو مخاطب کیا تو آپ حق بجانب نہ ہوں گے۔
سر جی آپ نے کہا کہ ائمہ اربعہ نے اکانومی پہ نہیں لکھا براے کرم فقہ کی کوئی بھی کتاب دیکھ لیں اس میں کتاب البیوع موجود ہے جوکہ معاشی نظام پہ روشنی ڈالتی ہے اگر چہ اس میں جدید مسائل کی زیادتی کی اہمیت کے مدنظر اہل علم کام کر رہے ہیں
Dr. Plz pay attention to changing economic structure. Jagirdari is nothing. Pay attention to millions having interest in internet economy which is globalized. Stop thinking and interpreting history in terms of 18th or 19th century. Give prospective view. These 'workers' will become redundant too in coming years. . Come out of the box.😮
Partially correct Please take some comments from Mufti Taqi Usmani sb. Your understanding is weak and sometimes misleading. Fiqh was developed before compilation of Hadith shareef. Imam Abu Hanifa Was born in 70 hijri. So he died in 150 hijri I.e. around 770 A.D. So your preface of the topic is incorrect.
And sir you discussed only fiqh but you didn't speak about the four great leaders of Islam (successor of Prophet saww) their rule is the best example of Islamic political, social, economic system, and of course the 10 years of Prophet saww in madina where he ruled as a ruler are the example of governing and when he conquered makkah in 8th hijri he rules the whole of present saudi Arbia. sir i think your opinion is pre defined to deny the islamic system because you are communist (i know the meaning "communist" so stay calm i know you are Muslim) sir if Islam is not a complete system it means it is un complete den, and as soon as someone start to believe it is un complete i think he should re-think about his belief. hope you will get it positive its my point of view you have right to accept or deny.
I am interested to hearing your thoughts on the book of Ahmet Kuru titled “Islam , Authoritarianism and underdevelopment , can you share that ? Besides, when I was an undergraduate student of business administration , I realise that we are stuck in past in such a way that , we have forgotten, islam is not stagnant religion ,but modern Muslim needs modern solution . And sir , our students will require a bit of time to understand this simple fact , so what you are doing will be take time to get internalise . But I really enjoy your arguments .
With due respect,I want to say that you should use the word ALLAH instead of the word KHUDA as we have firm belief that there is no god but ALLAH.Thanks
when short minded people get educated they consider themselves better humans in terms of living, eating, wearing and knowledge but actually their mental progress is not more than unknown people
Until n unless people will be prepared for islamic system...but da problem is majority of people is afraid of islamic system.frst people must b prepared for it...u can never...implement islamic system...or even any system.
Aslaam u lekum Aapki puri guftgu ka jawaab sirf yeh hai Islam mein musalman honeka matlab hanfi, Maliki, shafai & hambli hona nhi hai balke sirf Muslim han yeh muaziz shaksiyat zarur hain hum se bohat behtar hain magar inki koi bi baat islaam ka kanoon nhi keh layi gi aur na hi islaami sharyat, sharyat ka matlab sirf quran aur sahih hadees hain unse ijhtihad kya jasakta hai Aur dusri baat yeh hai k islaam aik mukamal zabta e hayaat hai is mein har daur K liye rehnumai hai aur hukum hai na K yeh sirf 1400 pehle K liye kyun yeh khuda ka kanoon hai kisi bande ka nhi hai 200 saal chale aur phir naya nizaam ajae Islam aik mukamal nizaam hai
Shariyat ka Matlab Quran h fiqh iska interpretation h jisme thodi tabdeeli ke baad har duar me istemaal Kiya ja sakta h... You confused among tahzeeb economy and politics be clear of your objection..
Islami nizam ki baat ho tu is me ye khami he k is me islam ka name shamil he aur islam ka name atay hi loog is pr kisi bhi qisam ka criticism bardasht nhi krte aut wo chahtay hen k islam k name pr baghair choon o churan kia baghair isay haq aur sach man lia jaye
Sir Plz once must read the ideology and the concept of Imam shah waliullah regarding Islam. Imam shah walliullah gave a complete system of islam. And the edge is that the Birth of Imam shah walliullah is on the " junction Badshahat & and start of industrial revolution" And must must go through the academia of moulana ubaidullh Sindhi Bcz the late sindhi is very rational Islamic scholar . Hazrat sindhi solved out all these complexities of traditionalism and modernism or liberalism. Sir if U once go through hazrat sindhi's school of thought your concept regarding islam ( old concept) will be clear. I must appreciate your effort sir.. May Allah Almighty Bless u 🌹🌹🌹🥰🥰
HUM KISSISE KAM NEHI India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh, ye teeno mulk ka awam faith k bare me, soch aur behavior se ekhi tarah hai. Inke paas apna dharm mannahi kafi nehi, Muslim ho to Hinduoko galia dena, aur Hindu ho to Muslims ko galia denehi suchcha Musalman aur khati Hindu hone ka manme format bana liya. Alag-alag nampe teeno mulkmehi moujud kattarone, prem-muhabbat ko chodkar, hamesha hinsa, nafrat, baatneka, daraneka ek khatarnak package me dharm ko andar kar diya. Logoko dilse demagtak, lohu-piyas ka khushise iss tarah biswaska palan-posankohi ab dharm bata ja raha hai. Lekin ye v to such hai, samajme jab issi tarah khal-soch ka badwa hote, tab vo samaj kavi sudharte nehi. Ye samajhne k liye koi vishal bidwan ya fir scientist hone ka zarurat nehi hote; Seref ek sawal k bagar. Keya hai vo sawal? Vo hai, sarkarka kaam keya? Sarkar ka kaam keya Jantako Sowarg/nark,Jannat/duzakh, Heaven/hell dena? Jantako Ye saab deneka shamta authority sarkar pass hai keya? Such baat to yehi hai, ye sab dene ka power Sarkarka pas na hai, na kavi tha, na rahenga. Jantaone v keya kavi sarkarka pass Sowarg/Jannat/ Heaven mangte? Nehi mangte. Q k maang tabhi jaej aur sahi hote, jo dene k liye sarkarka pass moujud hote. To jo cheez sarkar ka tarafse dene k liye, aur janta ka tarafse lene k liye hotehi nehi; oossko q hum politics me daalte? Iss ka matlab ye nehi, samajme dharm ka koi zarurat nehi hai. Albat hai. Lekin kiss hat tak, aur kaise? Iss ka jabab milne k liye firse vohi purana sawal karna jarrurat hote - Sarkar ka kaam keya?Sarkar kaam, deshka jantaone haar wakt jo vastovik pereshaniya mushkilatme deen guzarte vo sab hatana. Jaise roti, rozi, nokri, shiksha, health, karobaar ...; ye saab kaam sahi tarikase karne k liye achcha policies banana, aur vo saab lagu karna. Ek achcha adhunik mulkme ekhi dharm k log nehi rahte. Sarkar sare dharm milkar jo aam janta baante oosko liye policies mutabek kaam karenge. Aur janta jo-jo dharm maante shanti k saath dusro ko nafrat karneke bagair apna dharm paalan karenge. Tabhi shanti ka samaj milte. Ab aiyeji dusre sawalpe. Sarkar vo sare policies kaise karenge? Maine, karenge to kiss adharpe? Jaise agriculture, industry k liye policies karna padenge to vo koun dharm k adhar pe (Hindu dharm ka Ved Purana, Islam ka Quran, Isaiyoka Bible ..) karenge? Karnese keya koi faida milenge? Vo sare granthme keya iss bareme kuch likhkha hai? Nehi hai to, upko practical adharpehito karna padega? Ab uphi sochiyeji chaul, daal, gehu... ; aur industrial productions zada karne k liye upko koun dharm-granth ka sahara lena hoga? Aur ek example dete; upka betika zada bukhar chad gaiyee. Iss paristhitime keya up Pharmacy me jaakar bolenge, bhai mera betiki bahut bukhar, jaldi ek page Hindu Paracitamol dijiye? Ya fir bhai please jaldi kadke ek page Muslim Dispirin dijiye! Aisa kuch kahenge to tab keya bolenge dukandar? Jab koi bolenge, ye Hindu makan ka kirai kitna, tab keya sochenge vo log? Haa ye such, Hindustanka karigarone ghar/makan/dalan sundar karne k liye apna karukaj jarur karenge; lekin ghar banane k liye jo naap lenge, vo foot ho aur meter, jo v ho, vo sare duniyame ekhi hote. Hindu Foot, Muslim meter, Jain-Boudh inch kavi hotehi nehi. Jab Angrezone nehi aiya tab v jo naap lete vo haar dharm ka logoko makan banane k liye ekhi tha. To assalme upka parivarme harroz jo saman ka zarurat hote, vo dharm ka baat nehi, baat bazarka. Zara thande demagse sochiyeji, upka saath mera koi dushmani hai keya? Na maine upko pehchanta, na up hamko. Tab v jab upne mera naam padenge, turant upko maanme yehhi khelenge, ye saale Musalmaan ek number ka harami, Hinduko janm dushman, issme shak karenge, to humko khatam hone se koi rook nehi paenge. Lekin upka Hinduttiya keya aise hinsa ka talim dete? Aise laagta nehi humko. Q k hamara bhashame hum mainly Hinduttiya ko pehchante do kavi k madhdhamse. Rabindranath Tegore aur Kavi Kazi Nazrul Islam. Tegore Hindu Musalmonoko beech santi kaem rakhne k liye Hindu culturese dono me “Rakhi Bandhan/Bhai” kiya. Aur Nazrul Islam, Hindu Mitholigy ka adharpe, Radha-Krishan ka prem ko glorify karne k liya itna ooche starpe kirtan, Shama sangeet (Shama ma liye) aur nazm likhkha, jo kisi v naapse aam baat nehi. Mashur gaiyek Anup Jalotajine Nazrulji ka kuch gane gayia. Fursatme thoda dhiyan dekar sunenge, to up ko v zarur pata chalega vo sab kiss level ka geet hai. Netaji Shuvash Chandra Bosh jaise vishal hastiya keya khamokhai Nazrul ka “Durgama giri kaantaar moroo …” ko Hindustanka azadika gane mana? Abtak hum jo bola vo koyee nayee baat nehi. Aur agese jo bolna chahta hai, vo up kahi vabishma k liye, upka pita-mata-beta-beti parivar samaj kehi heet k liye. Ye mai 105% dawi k saath bolneka himmat rakhte. To aiye thoda jaankari lete keya hai vo baat? Keya up jaante India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh ye teeno mulk pratirakhsa/defense k liye haar saal kitney paisa kharch karte? Billion dollars. Iss haalme ek prosatav kalpana kijiyeji, ek reunion hua aur teen deshka sare borders mit giya, koi borders nehi rahega, tab keya honge? Jo mera logic kahte, very fast Ek defense kharch kam-se-kam adha ho jaenge. Q K tab padosan desh ka vitar ek Chinahi rahe jaenge hoomki k hisab se. Ek khatsehi zada paisa bachenge jo janhit k liye haat khul k kharch karneka ek bade mouka denge. Sarkar gaon me kaam karenge logo ko paisa milenge. Jab paisa milenge tab Gehu, Chaul k saath apna beti bohu k liye do leepstick v kharid karenge. Jaha leepstick Banate ooha do char labour ka jarurat hotehi honge. Aisehi to samaj k liye economy kaam karte. Khair, ek baat up khudhi sochoyeji, India + Pakistan + Bangladesh = Ye Akhand Hindustanme koun cheez ka kami hai? Sochkar upka dilkohi puchieji. Aur v baat hai, up jab ek honge tab Chinako himmat nehi honge Hindustan ko saath jabardasti karneka. Ek kahawat hai dushmanka dushman mitro ban jate. Jab up ek honge tab America, Europe aur sare advanced desh v oonko interest k liyehi upko saath khada honge. Baat yehi khatam nehi, jab India + Pakistan + Bangladesh = Indopakbengal = Adi Hindustan jo v kahiye honge, tab Adi Hindustan kudhhi mukhtar banneka laek ho jaenge. Hindustan ko suchchai aur imandarise call deneka takat honge. Bol payenge ao bhai sare saark desh ek jot hokar tarikhme pahlebar ek naiyee chapter khole, maine, Bhutan + Maldives + Nepal + Srilanka + Pakistan +India + Afghanistan + Bangladesh = Akhand Hindustan = Duniyaka tamaam deshse behtarin ek bhukhand, jaha haar cheez assanise milte. Lekin ye sare baat ek kalpana hai. Vaastavik me ye ek assmbhab prostavana se bagar aur kuch nehi. Lekin ye baat v to sahi hai, iss issuese har log kohi ek sawal karneka haq bante. Aur vo hai, ekathha nehi ho payenge ye to samajh liya, lekin q nehi ho paenge isska karan to zara bataiye sriman/janab? Issko do bade karan 1) Dharm, aur 2) Ati-Rasrtovad (Rashtrobaadka saath jab dharm aur dusrose nafrat jodte tab vo Ati-Rashtrovad baan jate. Nafrate jab logone khatreme padte tab, sahanubhuti nehi ooltaa dusre mulk ka logko maza milte. Iss tarah hinsa Ati-Rashtrovad k liye achcha hote lekin insaniyat k liye nehi ) Itihaas/ Tarikhko sahi dhangse dekhna hoga. Jo Europen countries sou-sou saal ek dusre ke saath yuoodh kiya kar te the, ab vo upka ankhoke saamne European union bana liya. Oonko pass demag hai to humko andar kuch nehi? Up keya upko boodhdhihin ooloo mante? Nehi maante to up v boliyeji - HUM KISSISE KAAM NEHI. **Ye aajkaalka baat nehi zarur wakt lagega. Democracy aur Secular sangbidhan rakkhiye air boliyeji, wakat lagenge? Lagne do. Hamara oonnoto jivan k liye Yehi hona chahiye, aur yehi honge.
Allah k nizam m kisi chez ke kami nahin h. Ap k kehny ka matlb ibadat rhy musalmano ke or syasi nizaam rhy angrezo ke. Ye tou munafqat h sir. Hazrat Muhmmad ny apni sari zindgi syast ke or zalmana nizam tor kar islami nizaam qayim kya. Adal insaf or equality ka lecture aaj angrez log dety hain pr ye islam ke dain hain
شکریہ آپ نے ہم جیسے لوگوں کے لئے آسان اور قابل فہم انداز میں ان موضوعات کا انتخاب کیا جن ہر محض ایک طبقے کا اجارہ دارانہ نقطہ نظر مسلط کیا جاتا رہا ہے۔
Kindly see the silent reign of terror ISLAM casts in the society which everyone feels , sees but fears to spell out. Taimur just watch your lecture at around 9.00. The terror is writ large in your whole body language and persona. How can modern thinking people of Pakistan bear and suffer such suffocating a system. So fearful, almost prostrating for anticipatory forgiveness from the wrath of the Mulla establishment. ISLAM ki kaid it seems. ( THE PRISON OF DEEN) Please critically analyse the Holy Quran. 1) Wether it qualifies as hate speech. More than 50% of its verses teach hate for the non believers. 2) It teaches discrimination on basis of faith as Hinduism discriminates on basis of birth. *Does it "mainstream" & "normalise" hate and discrimination*
India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh ka awam ek simple se baat samajhtehi nehi, vertually BJP walaka sabse karib jigri dost hai Pakistan ka Military aur Mullah. Pakistan ka nafrat nehi karega to usko politics kaise rahenge Election me Pulwama hona chahiye BJP k liye. Aur BJP nehi rahenge to Pakistani Military + Politians + Mullahs kaise mulk ko lootenge?
@@meetshah1892 Bhai, salam. Hum Bangladesh ka rahnewala hoon aur Hindi Urdu achche tarah nehi jaanta. Allah ko maante. Lekin beukuf ka tarah nehi. Bhagwan aur Allah jo v kahiye ghum k fir k baat ekhi pointme jode, jo ye baatpe tark jodte vo abhitak jangalvasi hai. Lekin jangalvasi ka tarah achcha ho k bagar. God kavi beukuf ko help nehi karte. Khair, hum jo bol raha hai vo koi naiyee baat nehi. Ek baat bataiyeji, sarkarka kaam keya? Janta ko Sowarg/Nark, Jannat/Duzakh, Heaven/Hell dena? Ye sab dene ka shamta authority sarkar ka pasa hai keya? Janta ko v keya ye sab mangne ka adhikar hai, ye fir kavi bolte Sowarg do nehi to gaddi choron? Janta keya political parties ko jinda rahker vote dete marne k baat sarkarse kuch pane k liye. Are bhai jo cheez dene ka aur lene k v nehi, ussko q baar-baar politics me daalte? Tumko Mandirme, Masjidsme, Gurusuara, Templesme jana achcha lagta jao, koun rookhte? To bhai sarkar ka kaam keya? Sarkar ka kaam hai, jantaone haar roz lo pereshaniya mushkilatme din guzarte, jaise karovar, nokri, education, health, road, bridges, law and ordar maintain etc. ye saab kar ne k liye achcha dhangse policies banana aur lagu karna. Bhaijee upko ek baat bol raha hoon, jo admi aasli kaam chodkar nakli kaampe lagte aur lagate usska natija haar wakt bhaiyonkar hota. Yehi God ka system hai. Jo nehi manenge vohi vaar me jaenge koiyee nehi rookh payenge. God kissika na baap ka jagirdari hai, na jijaji hai. Firse mera maan ka aur kuch baat kahenge. Uska baad disturb nehi karenge. Ghar k andar rahkar, Corona virus aur communal polititians se door rahiyeji. Thank u.
@@quamrulhassan8205 Afsos ki baat he ki aap jaise logon ki kami he yeh teenon mulkon me. Bohot hi accha likha he aapne. Insaan, chahe woh kisi bhi dharm ka ho, chahe woh Bhagwan me maane ya na mane, uska sabse bada kaam he ki woh Nek (kind) ho. yehi ummeed he ki log communal politics Ko chodkar acche se rahe. Waise aap ki hindi kaafi acche he. Kya Bangladesh mein Hindi sikhayi jaati he?
@@meetshah1892 Meet Shah Bhai, salam. Nehi, Bangladeshme Hindi ya fir Urdu ka koi charcha nehi hote. Lekin bahut log Hindi samajhte, vo Hindi film, TV channels aur Internet k zariye. Hindi ka saath Bengali ka bahuthi similarity hai. Lekin Urdu ka saath waise nehi, Urdu means chost Urdu. Achcha bhasha lekin zarrurat nehi padte.yl Khair, hum ek mamuli middle class admi hoon, pahlehi kaha koi khass nehi. Iss liye hum jo bolte ussko koi asar nehi padte. Yehi such aur vastivik hai. Bahar ka logo baat chodiye ji, mera family ka andar aisa log hai jinko beukuffi se bhara baat sunkar hum hairan ho jate. Baat yehi khatam nehi, logically, manvikta saath unka baat nakar karte to turant guss sa v ho jaate!! Keya karoon? To maine samajh liya ye sref gharka baat nehi, pure samaj k. Aur samai beet n k baat aab clear ho giya, ye keval Bangladesh ka nehi, India aur Pakistan ka v aisehi halat hai.Thank u.
Bhai, salam. Kaise hai up log? Mera dua Allah upko sahi salamat rakkhe. Ab ek purana commet copy kar k de raha hoon. Iss liye upko kuch common narrations aur thoda zada v lagenge. Lekin mera request padhiye kuch asahamat hai to please notice kariyeji. HUM KISSISE KAM NEHI India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh, ye teeno mulk ka awam faith k bare me, soch aur behavior se ekhi tarah hai. Inke paas apna dharm mannahi kafi nehi, Muslim ho to Hinduoko galia dena, aur Hindu ho to Muslims ko galia denehi suchcha Musalman aur khati Hindu hone ka ye log ek ajeeb-o-garib format manme bana liya. Alag-alag nampe teeno mulkmehi moujud kattarone, prem-muhabbat ko chodkar, hamesha hinsa, nafrat, baatneka, daraneka ek khatarnak package me dharm ko andar kar diya. Logoko dilse demagtak, lohu-piyas ka khushise iss tarah biswaska palan-posankohi ab dharm bata ja raha hai. Lekin ye v to such hai, samajme jab issi tarah khal-soch ka badwa hote, tab vo samaj kavi nehi sudharte. Ye samajhne k liye koi vishal bidwan ya fir scientist hone ka zarurat nehi hote; Seref ek sawal k bagar. Keya hai vo sawal? Vo hai, sarkarka kaam keya? Sarkar ka kaam keya Jantako Sowarg/nark,Jannat/duzakh, Heaven/hell dena? Jantako Ye saab deneka shamta/ authority sarkar pass hai keya? Such baat to yehi hai, ye sab dene ka power Sarkarka pas na kavi tha, na hai aur na kavi honge. Jantaone v keya kavi sarkarka passp. Sowarg/Jannat/ Heaven mangte? Nehi mangte. Q k maang tabhi jaej aur sahi hote, jo dene k liye sarkarka pass moujud hote. To jo cheez sarkar ka tarafse dene k liye, aur janta ka tarafse lene k liye hotehi nehi; oossko q hum politics me daalte? Iss ka matlab ye nehi, samajme dharm ka koi zarurat nehi hai. Albat hai. Lekin kiss hat tak, aur kaise? Iss ka jabab milne k liye firse vohi purana sawal karne ka jarrurat hote - Sarkar ka kaam keya?Sarkarka kaam, deshka jantaone haar wakt jo vastovik pereshaniya mushkilatme deen guzarte vo sab hatana. Jaise karovar, roti- rozi, nokri, shiksha, health ...; ye saab kaam sahi tarikase karne k liye achcha policies banana, aur vo saab lagu karna. Ab souwal aate Sarkar vo sare policies kaise karenge? Maine, tamam cheez k liye policies karna padenge to vo koun dharm k adhar pe (Hindu dharm ka Ved Purana, Islam ka Quran, Isaiyoka Bible ..) karenge? Karnese keya koi faida milega? Vo sare granthme keya iss bareme kuch likhkha hai? Nehi hai to, keya karna hoga? Keya ye sab tab practical adharpe karna padta hai ki nehi? Uphi sochiyeji chaul, daal, gehu... ; aur industrial productions zada karne k liye upko koun dharm-granth ka sahara lena hoga? Ek example de raha hoon; upka betika zada bukhar chad gaiyee. Iss paristhitime keya up Pharmacy me jaakar bolenge, bhai mera betiki bahut bukhar, jaldi ek page Hindu Paracitamol dijiye? Ya fir bhai please jaldi kadke ek page Muslim Dispirin dijiye! Aisa kuch kahenge to tab keya bolenge dukandar? Jab koi bolenge, ye Hindu makan ka kirai kitna, tab keya sochenge vo log? Haa ye such, Hindustanka karigarone ghar/makan/dalan sundar karne k liye apna karukaj zarur karenge; lekin ghar banane k liye jo naap lenge, vo foot ho aur meter, jo v ho, vo sare duniyame ekhi hote. Hindu Foot, Muslim meter, Sikh-Jain-Boudh inch kavi hotehi nehi. Jab Angrezone nehi aiya tab v jo naap lete vo haar dharm ka logoko makan banane k liye ekhi tha. To assalme upka parivarme harroz jo saman ka zarurat hote, vo dharm ka baat nehi, baat bazarka. Zara thande demagse sochiyeji, upka saath mera koi dushmani hai keya? Na maine upko pehchanta, na up hamko. Tab v jab upne mera naam padenge, turant upko maanme yehhi khelenge, ye saale Musalmaan ek number ka harami, Hinduko janm dushman, issme shak karenge, to humko khatam hone se koi rook nehi paenge. Lekin upka Hinduttiya keya aise hinsa ka talim dete? Aise laagta nehi humko. Q k hamara bhashame hum mainly Hinduttiya ko pehchante do kavi k madhdhamse. Rabindranath Tegore aur Kavi Kazi Nazrul Islam. Tegore Hindu Musalmonoko beech santi kaem rakhne k liye Hindu culturese dono me “Rakhi Bandhan/Bhai” kiya. Aur Nazrul Islam, Hindu Mitholigy ka adharpe, Radha-Krishan ka prem ko glorify karne k liya itna ooche starpe kirtan, Shama sangeet (Shama ma k liye) aur nazm likhkha, jo kisi v naapse aam baat nehi. Mashur gaiyek Anup Jalotajine Nazrulji ka kuch gane gayia. Fursatme thoda dhiyan dekar sunenge, to up ko v zarur pata chalega vo sab kiss level ka geet hai. Netaji Shuvash Chandra Bosh jaise vishal hastiya keya khamokhai Nazrul ka “Durgama giri kaantaar moroo …” ko Hindustanka azadika gane mana? Abtak hum jo bola vo koyee nayee baat nehi. Aur agese jo bolna chahta hai, vo up kahi vabishma k liye, upka pita-mata-beta-beti parivar samaj kehi heet k liye. Ye mai 105% dawi k saath bolneka himmat rakhte. To aiye thoda jaankari lete keya hai vo baat? Keya up jaante India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh ye teeno mulk pratirakhsa/defense k liye haar saal kitney paisa kharch karte? Billion dollars. Iss haalme ek prosatav kalpana kijiyeji, ek reunion hua aur teen deshka sare borders mit giya, koi borders nehi rahega, tab keya honge? Jo mera logic kahte, very fast Ek defense kharch kam-se-kam adha ho jaenge. Q K tab padosan desh ka vitar ek Chinahi rahe jaenge hoomki k hisab se. Ek khatsehi zada paisa bachenge jo janhit k liye haat khul k kharch karneka ek bade mouka denge. Sarkar gaon me kaam karenge logo ko paisa milenge. Jab paisa milenge tab Gehu, Chaul k saath apna beti bohu k liye do leepstick v kharid karenge. Jaha leepstick Banate ooha do char labour ka jarurat hotehi honge. Aisehi to samaj k liye economy kaam karte. Khair, ek baat up khudhi sochoyeji, India + Pakistan + Bangladesh = Ye Akhand Hindustanme koun cheez ka kami hai? Sochkar upka dilkohi puchieji. Aur v baat hai, up jab ek honge tab Chinako himmat nehi honge Hindustan ko saath jabardasti karneka. Ek kahawat hai dushmanka dushman mitro ban jate. Jab up ek honge tab America, Europe aur sare advanced desh v oonko interest k liyehi upko saath khada honge. Baat yehi khatam nehi, jab India + Pakistan + Bangladesh = Indopakbengal = Adi Hindustan jo v kahiye honge, tab Adi Hindustan kudhhi mukhtar banneka laek ho jaenge. Hindustan ko suchchai aur imandarise call deneka takat honge. Bol payenge ao bhai sare saark desh ek jot hokar tarikhme pahlebar ek naiyee chapter khole, maine, Bhutan + Maldives + Nepal + Srilanka + Pakistan + India + Afghanistan + Bangladesh = Akhand Hindustan = Duniyaka tamaam deshse behtarin ek bhukhand, jaha haar cheez assanise milte. Lekin ye sare baat ek kalpana hai. Vaastavik me ye ek assmbhab prostavana se bagar aur kuch nehi. Lekin ye baat v to sahi hai, iss issuese har log kohi ek sawal karneka haq bante. Aur vo hai, ekathha nehi ho payenge ye to samajh liya, lekin q nehi ho paenge isska karan to zara bataiye sriman/janab? Issko do bade karan 1) Dharm, aur 2) Ati-Rasrtovad (Rashtrobaadka saath jab dharm aur dusrose nafrat jodte tab vo Ati-Rashtrovad baan jate. Nafrate jab logone khatreme padte tab, sahanubhuti nehi ooltaa dusre mulk ka logko maza milte. Iss tarah hinsa Ati-Rashtrovad k liye achcha hote lekin insaniyat k liye nehi ) Itihaas/ Tarikhko sahi dhangse dekhna hoga. Jo Europen countries sou-sou saal ek dusre ke saath yuoodh kiya kar te the, ab vo upka ankhoke saamne European union bana liya. Oonko pass demag hai to humko andar kuch nehi? Up keya upko boodhdhihin ooloo mante? Nehi maante to up v boliyeji - HUM KISSISE KAAM NEHI. **Ye aajkaalka baat nehi zarur wakt lagega. Democracy aur Secular sangbidhan rakkhiye air boliyeji, wakat lagenge? Lagne do. Hamara oonnoto jivan k liye Yehi hona chahiye, aur yehi honge. THANK YOU.
Love you Dr sb I learnt many things from your lectures Islamic shari'a
There are two terms used in Islamic laws. Had and tazeer. In field of tazeer legislature has authority to make laws under umbrella of basic religious injunctions. But in field of had punishments have been told through revealed text...
بہت خوب سر آپ کے لیکچر نہایت آسانی سے سمجھ میں آتے ہیں اور یہ کہ چھوٹی چھوٹی کلپس ہیں دیکھنے میں وقت نہیں لگتا
I salute your contributions in v log. Indians are more here with great knowledge but language is a problem.I learnt the concept of marxism from you.I am a scholar in sialkot.
I love your videos because you mentioned the reference from book 😁
Islam ka maaashi or siyasi nizaam khaskar hazrat umar(R.A) kai zamanai sai aik behtareen nizaam hai,agar apko kisi cheez kai barai mai ilam nahi hai is ka yeh matlab nahi kai woh cheez wajood he nai rakhte
Love from India 🇮🇳❤️
thanks sir . your valueable lectures are as guide for us . Salute to you from Gilgit Baltistan
Hello sir I like your lectures spatially on philosophy. I am an Urdu poet .i want to know about modern philosophy
Brilliantly explained. Thank you sir
nice explanation hotta hai sir aap ka , aabhi pura nahi suna
Watching it after 5 years of uploading,
I just opened the video because the fonts used in thumbnail are in trend nowadays
Sir kindly one lecture on your journey about your struggles
Could you record lectures on establishments judiciary ? If you don’t afraid ?
Salam Sir, much agreed. The revival of practice of Ijtihad is necessary, but the question remains that who is deemed worthy of interpreting the religion in accordance with modern needs. Moreover, Muslims are bound by faith yet divided by sect and geographical barriers. Keeping this in mind, what is the geographical jurisdiction of Ijtihad conducted in Saudia or any other country? Insight and opinion is appreciated. Thanks...
Like ever healthy analysis...
This is the main problem that one cannot be open totally and Express freely his ideas related to religion. I can guess that you are trying to defend too much rather than criticize openly.
Sir ur method ..MashAllah ❤👌
Plz give me a heart
Sir plz plz plz publish lectures on political science for css
Is there an English version of this series?
gorgeous sir
PLz share a translation in english, thanks.
سر بین الاقوامی قوانین، کاروبار، معاشی اور اقتصادی نظام اسلام نے بھی متعارف کروایا تھا۔
Please include videos in English
Taimur sahib. Can I see u. I am kalid Farooq basra living in dha. I was anti capitalism I was convicted one year jail as student leader I have written a book علماء کے سرمایہ داری رویے
Hi sir i am baloch from balochistan .....sir app plz balochistan kay histtey and north koriya kay baray bathain
AsSalamu Alaykum Prof Taimur Rahman,
I have mostly enjoyed many of your videos dealing with the economic and political situation in Pakistan. You break it down pretty well even though I disagree partly with your analysis of applying socialism as a model for success. Personally, I think that we need a small central government and make the provinces independent for them to make their own financial decisions, manage their own affairs. This was the method of government that was adopted the Muslim caliphs as well where the governors were responsible for managing their state independently. Curiously, in the US as well, the original model has been small central gov and power to the states, even though the center keeps taking more and more.
I disagree with your analysis with respect to the shariah being related only to worship and family matters. The Prophet Muhammad (saw) taught his followers [sahaba] all aspects of life not just related to worship, family law, inheritance but also about the task of governing, state craft, and financial transactions (Which is extensive actually). Obviously, not every sahabi had the same skillset. Some excelled over the others. This can be seen clearly in the caliphate of Omar Ibn Khattab [ra]. One small example is the pension system that he setup for the retired soldiers.
From the time of the Prophet's death to the 17th century (roughly) the Muslim world was way ahead of the rest of the world in sciences, architecture, law, financial banking system (non riba based of course).
I AGREE with you that at some point, the Muslim scholars stopped doing ijtihad which started a downward spiral and not to mention the constant in-fighting amongst the dynastic Muslim rulers as can be seen clearly in the Muslim Spain. I would also add that Muslims by this time had come decadent with their easy life styles.
This aspect is also mentioned the Muqaddimah of Ibn Khaldun where he says the sunnah of the world is that nations rise and fall.
"Ibn Khaldun argues that each dynasty has within itself the seeds of its own downfall. He explains that ruling houses tend to emerge on the peripheries of great empires and use the unity presented by those areas to their advantage in order to bring about a change in leadership. As the new rulers establish themselves at the center of their empire, they become increasingly lax and more concerned with maintaining their lifestyles. Thus, a new dynasty can emerge at the periphery of their control and effect a change in leadership, beginning the cycle anew."
Anyways, these were just some random thoughts on my part. Looking forward to listening to more of your vlogs.
I,m sorry sir..i totally disagree with u ..islamic system her lehaaz se mukamal guide krta ha..aur ethics ka economy k sath bht gehraa taaluq ha..ap islamic economic aur political system ko mazed prhen..ye captilism aur socialism se bht behter ha..aur insani nature k mutabik ha.
How we elect president in Islamic voting
Quran k ehkamat fard SE related Hain
Agar koi hukamran hai toh us ko Kaha Gaya hai Allah k kanoon ka
Jurisprudence!
Islam is a system for the way of life. A country GDP is not connected to Shariah! It's Economics!
Fiqah aur Shariah mai bunyadi farq hi galat kia hai apnay! Shariah poori Quran mai mojood hai aur uski interpretation Sunnah mai mojood hai. Shariah ko samajhnay ke liye Fiqah mai jannay ki zarorat hi nahi.
Kesi civilization arab wali ya hindu wali brother
Evaluate Islam based on science. A lot of errors in Hadiths and Quran, so scientifically Islam is not based on actual facts. But for Muslims who wants to make sure there is still Islam in the world, the door to ijtihad must be open, to “reinterpret” laws of Islam into something more modern......
Padha Likha Desh
👀👀👀👀👀👀
Hehehehehehe 😂😂😂😂😂🎂👀😍🇺🇸
Sir ap Athiest hn ya Secular??
Secular.
𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘰𝘯𝘭𝘺 𝘰𝘯𝘦 𝘰𝘣𝘫𝘦𝘤𝘵𝘪𝘷𝘦 𝘵𝘰 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘮𝘶𝘭𝘨𝘢𝘵𝘦 𝘐𝘴𝘭𝘢𝘮 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘮𝘰𝘣𝘪𝘭𝘪𝘻𝘦 𝘪𝘵𝘴 𝘱𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘤𝘪𝘱𝘭𝘦 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴 𝘪𝘴 𝘵𝘰 𝘥𝘦𝘤𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘪𝘯𝘵𝘦𝘳𝘦𝘴𝘵.
u should read Maulana Modudi books, islam guides in detail about politics, these 04 fiqh were not developed to govern khilafat system, expand ur vision.
The whole summarization of the video is, Shariah means rules manifest by God through various revelations and jurisprudence means interpretation of Shariah rules by Human through self-conscience and varied level of apprehensions. There are five major school of jurisprudence in Islam including Hanfi, Malaki, shafi hanbali and shia school of jurisprudence. Until 13th century jurisprudence and interpretation of Quran and Sunnah had almost halted and Ijtihad was no more considered requisite which is the interpretation of sharia rules according to any specific time interval or needs
محترم !
آپ کو ایک غلط فہمی ہوئی ہے۔ وہ یہ ہے کہ قوانین دور رسالت میں نافذ نہیں ہوئے۔ حقیقت یہ ہے کہ قوانین دور نبوت اور خلافت میں نافذ ہو چکے تھے۔ اسلام کا اپنا پینل کوڈ نافذ ہو چکا تھا۔
شریعہ نے اپنے مقاصد بتا دیے ہیں۔
تیمور رحمان یار آپ کا طریقہ کار بہت خوبصورت ہے کہ بڑی ہمدردی سے کسی کو برا لگے بغیر اس کی جہالت کا اعتراف کرایا جائے اور پھر اس جہالت سے نکلنے پر آمادہ کیا جائے۔
in true islam" namaz means system ensuring equality in providing security and safety of honour, wealth and life of all is equal; roza means, every man and woman are bound to have war training to fight in the days of wars. zakat means share happiness and sorrows with each other; hajj means stage a jihad against who attack a muslim state. a muslim is who believe on equality with aiman on Hazrat Muhammad PBUH as messenger of God and God is alone.
بلکل غلط islamic system کو interpret کر رہے ھو جناب ۔۔۔۔اگر سمجھ نہی تو اہل علم سے پوچھو
سر بس صاف کہ دے کہ اس کی کوئی خارجہ پالیسی نہیں ہے بس اخلاقیات پر زور دیتے ہیں
well sir i respect you and learning from your videos but i will say that if we read Quran there clearly mentioned free economic system
Great explanation,
it will help Muslim society to be clear about sharia and life economics. Help the society to differentiate the economics and dharma.
Respect your clarity and scholarship
Madhukar Jadhav
I disagree on certain points.Not every kind of Ijtihad is prohibited and shariah deals with eco,IR as much as it deals with society.
Muhazirat e Fiqh a must read book
یار تیمور !
جب سماج سے خطاب ہوگا تو حکومتی
عدالتی۔معاشی۔معاشرتی۔خارجی تمام معاملات آئیں گے اور انہیں چیزوں پر ریاست استوار ہوتی ھے جس کو اسلام نے مخاطب کیا ھے۔
تو آپ اگر کہیں کہ اسلام نے عبادات و اخلاقیات کو مخاطب کیا تو آپ حق بجانب نہ ہوں گے۔
U need read syed madudi for system
سر جی آپ نے کہا کہ ائمہ اربعہ نے اکانومی پہ نہیں لکھا براے کرم فقہ کی کوئی بھی کتاب دیکھ لیں اس میں کتاب البیوع موجود ہے جوکہ معاشی نظام پہ روشنی ڈالتی ہے اگر چہ اس میں جدید مسائل کی زیادتی کی اہمیت کے مدنظر اہل علم کام کر رہے ہیں
Islamic system ne Riasat madinah k ilawa konsi riasat ko taraqi dilayi hai. Except that era 1400yrs ago..
Dr.Shb Ap jaisy logo ko dkh or sun kr khushi hoti or umeed paida hoti ha Slamat rahin ❤ ❤ ❤
Dr. Plz pay attention to changing economic structure. Jagirdari is nothing. Pay attention to millions having interest in internet economy which is globalized. Stop thinking and interpreting history in terms of 18th or 19th century. Give prospective view. These 'workers' will become redundant too in coming years. . Come out of the box.😮
Partially correct
Please take some comments from Mufti Taqi Usmani sb. Your understanding is weak and sometimes misleading. Fiqh was developed before compilation of Hadith shareef. Imam Abu Hanifa
Was born in 70 hijri. So he died in 150 hijri I.e. around 770 A.D.
So your preface of the topic is incorrect.
And sir you discussed only fiqh but you didn't speak about the four great leaders of Islam (successor of Prophet saww) their rule is the best example of Islamic political, social, economic system, and of course the 10 years of Prophet saww in madina where he ruled as a ruler are the example of governing and when he conquered makkah in 8th hijri he rules the whole of present saudi Arbia. sir i think your opinion is pre defined to deny the islamic system because you are communist (i know the meaning "communist" so stay calm i know you are Muslim) sir if Islam is not a complete system it means it is un complete den, and as soon as someone start to believe it is un complete i think he should re-think about his belief.
hope you will get it positive its my point of view you have right to accept or deny.
میں آپ کا مداح ہوں، مگر اختلاف میرا حق ہے
مذہب اور تہذیب دو الگ چیزیں ہیں،
تہذیب جدت کے اپنانے کو کہتے ہیں
مذہب جدت کو رد کرنے کو کہتے ہیں
I am interested to hearing your thoughts on the book of Ahmet Kuru titled “Islam , Authoritarianism and underdevelopment , can you share that ?
Besides, when I was an undergraduate student of business administration , I realise that we are stuck in past in such a way that , we have forgotten, islam is not stagnant religion ,but modern Muslim needs modern solution .
And sir , our students will require a bit of time to understand this simple fact , so what you are doing will be take time to get internalise . But I really enjoy your arguments .
Pagal ho Gaya ha Science Ki Dunia ???
With due respect,I want to say that you should use the word ALLAH instead of the word KHUDA as we have firm belief that there is no god but ALLAH.Thanks
The concept of sharia and fiqh which u explain is not upto the mark
Well Sir, What I Can Say is People in Pakistan just don't get Facts. You're singing to the cats. Stay safe.
U r totally wrong every lines r not equal to one another and sir know what's wrong and what's right
Òimijjj888you 788ppto
when short minded people get educated they consider themselves better humans in terms of living, eating, wearing and knowledge but actually their mental progress is not more than unknown people
@@wajjadsahito3264 But brother, aren't we all lesser humans in eyes of ruling elites??
Until n unless people will be prepared for islamic system...but da problem is majority of people is afraid of islamic system.frst people must b prepared for it...u can never...implement islamic system...or even any system.
What if we open ijtibah and start working
More on exploring Islamic political system? Would it sound better to a socialist person?
Aslaam u lekum
Aapki puri guftgu ka jawaab sirf yeh hai Islam mein musalman honeka matlab hanfi, Maliki, shafai & hambli hona nhi hai balke sirf Muslim han yeh muaziz shaksiyat zarur hain hum se bohat behtar hain magar inki koi bi baat islaam ka kanoon nhi keh layi gi aur na hi islaami sharyat, sharyat ka matlab sirf quran aur sahih hadees hain unse ijhtihad kya jasakta hai
Aur dusri baat yeh hai k islaam aik mukamal zabta e hayaat hai is mein har daur K liye rehnumai hai aur hukum hai na K yeh sirf 1400 pehle K liye kyun yeh khuda ka kanoon hai kisi bande ka nhi hai 200 saal chale aur phir naya nizaam ajae
Islam aik mukamal nizaam hai
اسلام میں جاگیرداری کی کوئی گنجائش نہیں ہے
Shariyat ka Matlab Quran h fiqh iska interpretation h jisme thodi tabdeeli ke baad har duar me istemaal Kiya ja sakta h... You confused among tahzeeb economy and politics be clear of your objection..
Allama Iqbal ny wo os point KY liyen Nahi farmaya , isko thorda bataiye mere Pas details Hain
Islami nizam ki baat ho tu is me ye khami he k is me islam ka name shamil he aur islam ka name atay hi loog is pr kisi bhi qisam ka criticism bardasht nhi krte aut wo chahtay hen k islam k name pr baghair choon o churan kia baghair isay haq aur sach man lia jaye
Islam aik mukamal zaptai hayat hai . That's it , liken main apky dil or dimag se nikli in tamam bataon pr apki izzat karta hn Sath ilmi ikhtilaf BHI .
Sir Plz once must read the ideology and the concept of Imam shah waliullah regarding Islam. Imam shah walliullah gave a complete system of islam. And the edge is that the Birth of Imam shah walliullah is on the " junction Badshahat & and start of industrial revolution"
And must must go through the academia of moulana ubaidullh Sindhi Bcz the late sindhi is very rational Islamic scholar . Hazrat sindhi solved out all these complexities of traditionalism and modernism or liberalism. Sir if U once go through hazrat sindhi's school of thought your concept regarding islam ( old concept) will be clear.
I must appreciate your effort sir..
May Allah Almighty Bless u 🌹🌹🌹🥰🥰
Did u study the basic of Islam the "Adl" and did u study the Umar r.a? If u do then u ll feel shame on urself.
HUM KISSISE KAM NEHI
India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh, ye teeno mulk ka awam faith k bare me, soch aur behavior se ekhi tarah hai. Inke paas apna dharm mannahi kafi nehi, Muslim ho to Hinduoko galia dena, aur Hindu ho to Muslims ko galia denehi suchcha Musalman aur khati Hindu hone ka manme format bana liya. Alag-alag nampe teeno mulkmehi moujud kattarone, prem-muhabbat ko chodkar, hamesha hinsa, nafrat, baatneka, daraneka ek khatarnak package me dharm ko andar kar diya. Logoko dilse demagtak, lohu-piyas ka khushise iss tarah biswaska palan-posankohi ab dharm bata ja raha hai. Lekin ye v to such hai, samajme jab issi tarah khal-soch ka badwa hote, tab vo samaj kavi sudharte nehi. Ye samajhne k liye koi vishal bidwan ya fir scientist hone ka zarurat nehi hote; Seref ek sawal k bagar. Keya hai vo sawal? Vo hai, sarkarka kaam keya? Sarkar ka kaam keya Jantako Sowarg/nark,Jannat/duzakh, Heaven/hell dena? Jantako Ye saab deneka shamta authority sarkar pass hai keya? Such baat to yehi hai, ye sab dene ka power Sarkarka pas na hai, na kavi tha, na rahenga. Jantaone v keya kavi sarkarka pass Sowarg/Jannat/ Heaven mangte? Nehi mangte. Q k maang tabhi jaej aur sahi hote, jo dene k liye sarkarka pass moujud hote. To jo cheez sarkar ka tarafse dene k liye, aur janta ka tarafse lene k liye hotehi nehi; oossko q hum politics me daalte? Iss ka matlab ye nehi, samajme dharm ka koi zarurat nehi hai. Albat hai. Lekin kiss hat tak, aur kaise? Iss ka jabab milne k liye firse vohi purana sawal karna jarrurat hote - Sarkar ka kaam keya?Sarkar kaam, deshka jantaone haar wakt jo vastovik pereshaniya mushkilatme deen guzarte vo sab hatana. Jaise roti, rozi, nokri, shiksha, health, karobaar ...; ye saab kaam sahi tarikase karne k liye achcha policies banana, aur vo saab lagu karna. Ek achcha adhunik mulkme ekhi dharm k log nehi rahte. Sarkar sare dharm milkar jo aam janta baante oosko liye policies mutabek kaam karenge. Aur janta jo-jo dharm maante shanti k saath dusro ko nafrat karneke bagair apna dharm paalan karenge. Tabhi shanti ka samaj milte.
Ab aiyeji dusre sawalpe. Sarkar vo sare policies kaise karenge? Maine, karenge to kiss adharpe? Jaise agriculture, industry k liye policies karna padenge to vo koun dharm k adhar pe (Hindu dharm ka Ved Purana, Islam ka Quran, Isaiyoka Bible ..) karenge? Karnese keya koi faida milenge? Vo sare granthme keya iss bareme kuch likhkha hai? Nehi hai to, upko practical adharpehito karna padega? Ab uphi sochiyeji chaul, daal, gehu... ; aur industrial productions zada karne k liye upko koun dharm-granth ka sahara lena hoga? Aur ek example dete; upka betika zada bukhar chad gaiyee. Iss paristhitime keya up Pharmacy me jaakar bolenge, bhai mera betiki bahut bukhar, jaldi ek page Hindu Paracitamol dijiye? Ya fir bhai please jaldi kadke ek page Muslim Dispirin dijiye! Aisa kuch kahenge to tab keya bolenge dukandar? Jab koi bolenge, ye Hindu makan ka kirai kitna, tab keya sochenge vo log? Haa ye such, Hindustanka karigarone ghar/makan/dalan sundar karne k liye apna karukaj jarur karenge; lekin ghar banane k liye jo naap lenge, vo foot ho aur meter, jo v ho, vo sare duniyame ekhi hote. Hindu Foot, Muslim meter, Jain-Boudh inch kavi hotehi nehi. Jab Angrezone nehi aiya tab v jo naap lete vo haar dharm ka logoko makan banane k liye ekhi tha. To assalme upka parivarme harroz jo saman ka zarurat hote, vo dharm ka baat nehi, baat bazarka.
Zara thande demagse sochiyeji, upka saath mera koi dushmani hai keya? Na maine upko pehchanta, na up hamko. Tab v jab upne mera naam padenge, turant upko maanme yehhi khelenge, ye saale Musalmaan ek number ka harami, Hinduko janm dushman, issme shak karenge, to humko khatam hone se koi rook nehi paenge. Lekin upka Hinduttiya keya aise hinsa ka talim dete? Aise laagta nehi humko. Q k hamara bhashame hum mainly Hinduttiya ko pehchante do kavi k madhdhamse. Rabindranath Tegore aur Kavi Kazi Nazrul Islam. Tegore Hindu Musalmonoko beech santi kaem rakhne k liye Hindu culturese dono me “Rakhi Bandhan/Bhai” kiya. Aur Nazrul Islam, Hindu Mitholigy ka adharpe, Radha-Krishan ka prem ko glorify karne k liya itna ooche starpe kirtan, Shama sangeet (Shama ma liye) aur nazm likhkha, jo kisi v naapse aam baat nehi. Mashur gaiyek Anup Jalotajine Nazrulji ka kuch gane gayia. Fursatme thoda dhiyan dekar sunenge, to up ko v zarur pata chalega vo sab kiss level ka geet hai. Netaji Shuvash Chandra Bosh jaise vishal hastiya keya khamokhai Nazrul ka “Durgama giri kaantaar moroo …” ko Hindustanka azadika gane mana?
Abtak hum jo bola vo koyee nayee baat nehi. Aur agese jo bolna chahta hai, vo up kahi vabishma k liye, upka pita-mata-beta-beti parivar samaj kehi heet k liye. Ye mai 105% dawi k saath bolneka himmat rakhte. To aiye thoda jaankari lete keya hai vo baat?
Keya up jaante India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh ye teeno mulk pratirakhsa/defense k liye haar saal kitney paisa kharch karte? Billion dollars. Iss haalme ek prosatav kalpana kijiyeji, ek reunion hua aur teen deshka sare borders mit giya, koi borders nehi rahega, tab keya honge? Jo mera logic kahte, very fast Ek defense kharch kam-se-kam adha ho jaenge. Q K tab padosan desh ka vitar ek Chinahi rahe jaenge hoomki k hisab se. Ek khatsehi zada paisa bachenge jo janhit k liye haat khul k kharch karneka ek bade mouka denge. Sarkar gaon me kaam karenge logo ko paisa milenge. Jab paisa milenge tab Gehu, Chaul k saath apna beti bohu k liye do leepstick v kharid karenge. Jaha leepstick Banate ooha do char labour ka jarurat hotehi honge. Aisehi to samaj k liye economy kaam karte. Khair, ek baat up khudhi sochoyeji, India + Pakistan + Bangladesh = Ye Akhand Hindustanme koun cheez ka kami hai? Sochkar upka dilkohi puchieji. Aur v baat hai, up jab ek honge tab Chinako himmat nehi honge Hindustan ko saath jabardasti karneka. Ek kahawat hai dushmanka dushman mitro ban jate. Jab up ek honge tab America, Europe aur sare advanced desh v oonko interest k liyehi upko saath khada honge. Baat yehi khatam nehi, jab India + Pakistan + Bangladesh = Indopakbengal = Adi Hindustan jo v kahiye honge, tab Adi Hindustan kudhhi mukhtar banneka laek ho jaenge. Hindustan ko suchchai aur imandarise call deneka takat honge. Bol payenge ao bhai sare saark desh ek jot hokar tarikhme pahlebar ek naiyee chapter khole, maine, Bhutan + Maldives + Nepal + Srilanka + Pakistan +India + Afghanistan + Bangladesh = Akhand Hindustan = Duniyaka tamaam deshse behtarin ek bhukhand, jaha haar cheez assanise milte. Lekin ye sare baat ek kalpana hai. Vaastavik me ye ek assmbhab prostavana se bagar aur kuch nehi. Lekin ye baat v to sahi hai, iss issuese har log kohi ek sawal karneka haq bante. Aur vo hai, ekathha nehi ho payenge ye to samajh liya, lekin q nehi ho paenge isska karan to zara bataiye sriman/janab? Issko do bade karan 1) Dharm, aur 2) Ati-Rasrtovad (Rashtrobaadka saath jab dharm aur dusrose nafrat jodte tab vo Ati-Rashtrovad baan jate. Nafrate jab logone khatreme padte tab, sahanubhuti nehi ooltaa dusre mulk ka logko maza milte. Iss tarah hinsa Ati-Rashtrovad k liye achcha hote lekin insaniyat k liye nehi ) Itihaas/ Tarikhko sahi dhangse dekhna hoga. Jo Europen countries sou-sou saal ek dusre ke saath yuoodh kiya kar te the, ab vo upka ankhoke saamne European union bana liya. Oonko pass demag hai to humko andar kuch nehi? Up keya upko boodhdhihin ooloo mante? Nehi maante to up v boliyeji - HUM KISSISE KAAM NEHI.
**Ye aajkaalka baat nehi zarur wakt lagega. Democracy aur Secular sangbidhan rakkhiye air boliyeji, wakat lagenge? Lagne do. Hamara oonnoto jivan k liye Yehi hona chahiye, aur yehi honge.
Holly Quran is higher rewards thanks forgiveness upon each other
Allah k nizam m kisi chez ke kami nahin h. Ap k kehny ka matlb ibadat rhy musalmano ke or syasi nizaam rhy angrezo ke. Ye tou munafqat h sir. Hazrat Muhmmad ny apni sari zindgi syast ke or zalmana nizam tor kar islami nizaam qayim kya. Adal insaf or equality ka lecture aaj angrez log dety hain pr ye islam ke dain hain
I learn from your lecture. India
Can somebody add english subtitles? Plox
Piotr Dołomisiewicz I will soon
@@falsifiablerussell854 where?
There are already in english language as well.
Yes there is ghap
ماشاءللہ،آپ کی گفتگو بڑی علمی ہوتی ہے
آپ کے طریقہِ بیان پر نزاکت قربان جاۓ...
Islamic system kuch hy hi nai..esy e 2-3 batoon sy derive k3rd k kuch molvi bta ty rehty hn
Sir, I saw your lecturers on the history of philosophy on-media and elements, but they were not complete. How can I reach those complete videos.
Its a good desire. Thank you.
Plz make a public debate with Qaiser Ahmad Raja
شکریہ آپ نے ہم جیسے لوگوں کے لئے آسان اور قابل فہم انداز میں ان موضوعات کا انتخاب کیا جن ہر محض ایک طبقے کا اجارہ دارانہ نقطہ نظر مسلط کیا جاتا رہا ہے۔
Sir ap ki Falsafa per 114 lecturers kamal hain....good Weldon
No islam is not in the majority of Worship
Sir u are matchless person
overacting karte ho sir ye Q afsoos k sath dosro ke ye zahir karte ho k wo kuch nahi aur saara elam maire sath hai
i have learned a lot from you sir
Sir please make video on two nations theory.
nice sir mASha ALLAh
ایک انتہائی بہترین جدلیاتی تجزیہ۔ بہت عمدہ۔
Kindly see the silent reign of terror ISLAM casts in the society which everyone feels , sees but fears to spell out. Taimur just watch your lecture at around 9.00. The terror is writ large in your whole body language and persona. How can modern thinking people of Pakistan bear and suffer such suffocating a system. So fearful, almost prostrating for anticipatory forgiveness from the wrath of the Mulla establishment.
ISLAM ki kaid it seems.
( THE PRISON OF DEEN)
Please critically analyse the Holy Quran.
1) Wether it qualifies as hate speech. More than 50% of its verses teach hate for the non believers.
2) It teaches discrimination on basis of faith as Hinduism discriminates on basis of birth.
*Does it "mainstream" & "normalise" hate and discrimination*
Thank you Sir. I am a new follower of your videos
3:14 what we call white Men's
Burden.
In Panjab is more divide by firka
Sir political science k lye koe youtope suggest kro?
India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh ka awam ek simple se baat samajhtehi nehi, vertually BJP walaka sabse karib jigri dost hai Pakistan ka Military aur Mullah. Pakistan ka nafrat nehi karega to usko politics kaise rahenge Election me Pulwama hona chahiye BJP k liye. Aur BJP nehi rahenge to Pakistani Military + Politians + Mullahs kaise mulk ko lootenge?
Bahut hi sahi baat ki aapne :)
@@meetshah1892 Bhai, salam. Hum Bangladesh ka rahnewala hoon aur Hindi Urdu achche tarah nehi jaanta. Allah ko maante. Lekin beukuf ka tarah nehi. Bhagwan aur Allah jo v kahiye ghum k fir k baat ekhi pointme jode, jo ye baatpe tark jodte vo abhitak jangalvasi hai. Lekin jangalvasi ka tarah achcha ho k bagar. God kavi beukuf ko help nehi karte. Khair, hum jo bol raha hai vo koi naiyee baat nehi. Ek baat bataiyeji, sarkarka kaam keya? Janta ko Sowarg/Nark, Jannat/Duzakh, Heaven/Hell dena? Ye sab dene ka shamta authority sarkar ka pasa hai keya? Janta ko v keya ye sab mangne ka adhikar hai, ye fir kavi bolte Sowarg do nehi to gaddi choron? Janta keya political parties ko jinda rahker vote dete marne k baat sarkarse kuch pane k liye. Are bhai jo cheez dene ka aur lene k v nehi, ussko q baar-baar politics me daalte? Tumko Mandirme, Masjidsme, Gurusuara, Templesme jana achcha lagta jao, koun rookhte? To bhai sarkar ka kaam keya? Sarkar ka kaam hai, jantaone haar roz lo pereshaniya mushkilatme din guzarte, jaise karovar, nokri, education, health, road, bridges, law and ordar maintain etc. ye saab kar ne k liye achcha dhangse policies banana aur lagu karna. Bhaijee upko ek baat bol raha hoon, jo admi aasli kaam chodkar nakli kaampe lagte aur lagate usska natija haar wakt bhaiyonkar hota. Yehi God ka system hai. Jo nehi manenge vohi vaar me jaenge koiyee nehi rookh payenge. God kissika na baap ka jagirdari hai, na jijaji hai. Firse mera maan ka aur kuch baat kahenge. Uska baad disturb nehi karenge. Ghar k andar rahkar, Corona virus aur communal polititians se door rahiyeji. Thank u.
@@quamrulhassan8205 Afsos ki baat he ki aap jaise logon ki kami he yeh teenon mulkon me. Bohot hi accha likha he aapne. Insaan, chahe woh kisi bhi dharm ka ho, chahe woh Bhagwan me maane ya na mane, uska sabse bada kaam he ki woh Nek (kind) ho. yehi ummeed he ki log communal politics Ko chodkar acche se rahe. Waise aap ki hindi kaafi acche he. Kya Bangladesh mein Hindi sikhayi jaati he?
@@meetshah1892 Meet Shah Bhai, salam. Nehi, Bangladeshme Hindi ya fir Urdu ka koi charcha nehi hote. Lekin bahut log Hindi samajhte, vo Hindi film, TV channels aur Internet k zariye. Hindi ka saath Bengali ka bahuthi similarity hai. Lekin Urdu ka saath waise nehi, Urdu means chost Urdu. Achcha bhasha lekin zarrurat nehi padte.yl Khair, hum ek mamuli middle class admi hoon, pahlehi kaha koi khass nehi. Iss liye hum jo bolte ussko koi asar nehi padte. Yehi such aur vastivik hai. Bahar ka logo baat chodiye ji, mera family ka andar aisa log hai jinko beukuffi se bhara baat sunkar hum hairan ho jate. Baat yehi khatam nehi, logically, manvikta saath unka baat nakar karte to turant guss sa v ho jaate!! Keya karoon? To maine samajh liya ye sref gharka baat nehi, pure samaj k. Aur samai beet n k baat aab clear ho giya, ye keval Bangladesh ka nehi, India aur Pakistan ka v aisehi halat hai.Thank u.
Bhai, salam. Kaise hai up log? Mera dua Allah upko sahi salamat rakkhe. Ab ek purana commet copy kar k de raha hoon. Iss liye upko kuch common narrations aur thoda zada v lagenge. Lekin mera request padhiye kuch asahamat hai to please notice kariyeji.
HUM KISSISE KAM NEHI
India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh, ye teeno mulk ka awam faith k bare me, soch aur behavior se ekhi tarah hai. Inke paas apna dharm mannahi kafi nehi, Muslim ho to Hinduoko galia dena, aur Hindu ho to Muslims ko galia denehi suchcha Musalman aur khati Hindu hone ka ye log ek ajeeb-o-garib format manme bana liya. Alag-alag nampe teeno mulkmehi moujud kattarone, prem-muhabbat ko chodkar, hamesha hinsa, nafrat, baatneka, daraneka ek khatarnak package me dharm ko andar kar diya. Logoko dilse demagtak, lohu-piyas ka khushise iss tarah biswaska palan-posankohi ab dharm bata ja raha hai. Lekin ye v to such hai, samajme jab issi tarah khal-soch ka badwa hote, tab vo samaj kavi nehi sudharte. Ye samajhne k liye koi vishal bidwan ya fir scientist hone ka zarurat nehi hote; Seref ek sawal k bagar. Keya hai vo sawal? Vo hai, sarkarka kaam keya? Sarkar ka kaam keya Jantako Sowarg/nark,Jannat/duzakh, Heaven/hell dena? Jantako Ye saab deneka shamta/ authority sarkar pass hai keya? Such baat to yehi hai, ye sab dene ka power Sarkarka pas na kavi tha, na hai aur na kavi honge. Jantaone v keya kavi sarkarka passp. Sowarg/Jannat/ Heaven mangte? Nehi mangte. Q k maang tabhi jaej aur sahi hote, jo dene k liye sarkarka pass moujud hote. To jo cheez sarkar ka tarafse dene k liye, aur janta ka tarafse lene k liye hotehi nehi; oossko q hum politics me daalte? Iss ka matlab ye nehi, samajme dharm ka koi zarurat nehi hai. Albat hai. Lekin kiss hat tak, aur kaise? Iss ka jabab milne k liye firse vohi purana sawal karne ka jarrurat hote - Sarkar ka kaam keya?Sarkarka kaam, deshka jantaone haar wakt jo vastovik pereshaniya mushkilatme deen guzarte vo sab hatana. Jaise karovar, roti- rozi, nokri, shiksha, health ...; ye saab kaam sahi tarikase karne k liye achcha policies banana, aur vo saab lagu karna. Ab souwal aate Sarkar vo sare policies kaise karenge? Maine, tamam cheez k liye policies karna padenge to vo koun dharm k adhar pe (Hindu dharm ka Ved Purana, Islam ka Quran, Isaiyoka Bible ..) karenge? Karnese keya koi faida milega? Vo sare granthme keya iss bareme kuch likhkha hai? Nehi hai to, keya karna hoga? Keya ye sab tab practical adharpe karna padta hai ki nehi? Uphi sochiyeji chaul, daal, gehu... ; aur industrial productions zada karne k liye upko koun dharm-granth ka sahara lena hoga? Ek example de raha hoon; upka betika zada bukhar chad gaiyee. Iss paristhitime keya up Pharmacy me jaakar bolenge, bhai mera betiki bahut bukhar, jaldi ek page Hindu Paracitamol dijiye? Ya fir bhai please jaldi kadke ek page Muslim Dispirin dijiye! Aisa kuch kahenge to tab keya bolenge dukandar? Jab koi bolenge, ye Hindu makan ka kirai kitna, tab keya sochenge vo log? Haa ye such, Hindustanka karigarone ghar/makan/dalan sundar karne k liye apna karukaj zarur karenge; lekin ghar banane k liye jo naap lenge, vo foot ho aur meter, jo v ho, vo sare duniyame ekhi hote. Hindu Foot, Muslim meter, Sikh-Jain-Boudh inch kavi hotehi nehi. Jab Angrezone nehi aiya tab v jo naap lete vo haar dharm ka logoko makan banane k liye ekhi tha. To assalme upka parivarme harroz jo saman ka zarurat hote, vo dharm ka baat nehi, baat bazarka.
Zara thande demagse sochiyeji, upka saath mera koi dushmani hai keya? Na maine upko pehchanta, na up hamko. Tab v jab upne mera naam padenge, turant upko maanme yehhi khelenge, ye saale Musalmaan ek number ka harami, Hinduko janm dushman, issme shak karenge, to humko khatam hone se koi rook nehi paenge. Lekin upka Hinduttiya keya aise hinsa ka talim dete? Aise laagta nehi humko. Q k hamara bhashame hum mainly Hinduttiya ko pehchante do kavi k madhdhamse. Rabindranath Tegore aur Kavi Kazi Nazrul Islam. Tegore Hindu Musalmonoko beech santi kaem rakhne k liye Hindu culturese dono me “Rakhi Bandhan/Bhai” kiya. Aur Nazrul Islam, Hindu Mitholigy ka adharpe, Radha-Krishan ka prem ko glorify karne k liya itna ooche starpe kirtan, Shama sangeet (Shama ma k liye) aur nazm likhkha, jo kisi v naapse aam baat nehi. Mashur gaiyek Anup Jalotajine Nazrulji ka kuch gane gayia. Fursatme thoda dhiyan dekar sunenge, to up ko v zarur pata chalega vo sab kiss level ka geet hai. Netaji Shuvash Chandra Bosh jaise vishal hastiya keya khamokhai Nazrul ka “Durgama giri kaantaar moroo …” ko Hindustanka azadika gane mana?
Abtak hum jo bola vo koyee nayee baat nehi. Aur agese jo bolna chahta hai, vo up kahi vabishma k liye, upka pita-mata-beta-beti parivar samaj kehi heet k liye. Ye mai 105% dawi k saath bolneka himmat rakhte. To aiye thoda jaankari lete keya hai vo baat?
Keya up jaante India, Pakistan aur Bangladesh ye teeno mulk pratirakhsa/defense k liye haar saal kitney paisa kharch karte? Billion dollars. Iss haalme ek prosatav kalpana kijiyeji, ek reunion hua aur teen deshka sare borders mit giya, koi borders nehi rahega, tab keya honge? Jo mera logic kahte, very fast Ek defense kharch kam-se-kam adha ho jaenge. Q K tab padosan desh ka vitar ek Chinahi rahe jaenge hoomki k hisab se. Ek khatsehi zada paisa bachenge jo janhit k liye haat khul k kharch karneka ek bade mouka denge. Sarkar gaon me kaam karenge logo ko paisa milenge. Jab paisa milenge tab Gehu, Chaul k saath apna beti bohu k liye do leepstick v kharid karenge. Jaha leepstick Banate ooha do char labour ka jarurat hotehi honge. Aisehi to samaj k liye economy kaam karte. Khair, ek baat up khudhi sochoyeji, India + Pakistan + Bangladesh = Ye Akhand Hindustanme koun cheez ka kami hai? Sochkar upka dilkohi puchieji. Aur v baat hai, up jab ek honge tab Chinako himmat nehi honge Hindustan ko saath jabardasti karneka. Ek kahawat hai dushmanka dushman mitro ban jate. Jab up ek honge tab America, Europe aur sare advanced desh v oonko interest k liyehi upko saath khada honge. Baat yehi khatam nehi, jab India + Pakistan + Bangladesh = Indopakbengal = Adi Hindustan jo v kahiye honge, tab Adi Hindustan kudhhi mukhtar banneka laek ho jaenge. Hindustan ko suchchai aur imandarise call deneka takat honge. Bol payenge ao bhai sare saark desh ek jot hokar tarikhme pahlebar ek naiyee chapter khole, maine, Bhutan + Maldives + Nepal + Srilanka + Pakistan + India + Afghanistan + Bangladesh = Akhand Hindustan = Duniyaka tamaam deshse behtarin ek bhukhand, jaha haar cheez assanise milte. Lekin ye sare baat ek kalpana hai. Vaastavik me ye ek assmbhab prostavana se bagar aur kuch nehi. Lekin ye baat v to sahi hai, iss issuese har log kohi ek sawal karneka haq bante. Aur vo hai, ekathha nehi ho payenge ye to samajh liya, lekin q nehi ho paenge isska karan to zara bataiye sriman/janab? Issko do bade karan 1) Dharm, aur 2) Ati-Rasrtovad (Rashtrobaadka saath jab dharm aur dusrose nafrat jodte tab vo Ati-Rashtrovad baan jate. Nafrate jab logone khatreme padte tab, sahanubhuti nehi ooltaa dusre mulk ka logko maza milte. Iss tarah hinsa Ati-Rashtrovad k liye achcha hote lekin insaniyat k liye nehi ) Itihaas/ Tarikhko sahi dhangse dekhna hoga. Jo Europen countries sou-sou saal ek dusre ke saath yuoodh kiya kar te the, ab vo upka ankhoke saamne European union bana liya. Oonko pass demag hai to humko andar kuch nehi? Up keya upko boodhdhihin ooloo mante? Nehi maante to up v boliyeji - HUM KISSISE KAAM NEHI.
**Ye aajkaalka baat nehi zarur wakt lagega. Democracy aur Secular sangbidhan rakkhiye air boliyeji, wakat lagenge? Lagne do. Hamara oonnoto jivan k liye Yehi hona chahiye, aur yehi honge.
THANK YOU.