Jagan Vs Chandrababu Over Tirupati I Should Temples Have Govt Control? New Poll Shows.. I Barkha

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 101

  • @prrasadrao7802
    @prrasadrao7802 หลายเดือนก่อน +8

    Jagan Reddy's humanistic approach is well to the people of AP - in the barbaric killing of his uncle Vivekanada Reddy

    • @CultReddy
      @CultReddy หลายเดือนก่อน

      Fact 💯

  • @nrusimha11
    @nrusimha11 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

    The question of whether the beef-pork-ghee was used for making laddu is merely a question of titillation and schadenfreude for secular journalists. The religious consequences are for the Hindu who might have eaten them, and even any Muslim who might have. The bigger question is, how did the beef and pork get there? Was there premeditation?

    • @arpanapalle5556
      @arpanapalle5556 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Pure greed for money was the reason for adulteration of ghee. Hunger for profit was the reason for adulteration ghee on the part of manufacturers and the trustees' greed for the profits/kickbacks led them to procure ghee from these manufacturers.

    • @Liberty55555
      @Liberty55555 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ghee was normal . dont worry . i ate the laddu and i am feeling normal

    • @nrusimha11
      @nrusimha11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@Liberty55555 Sri Venkateswara is watching. It is such arrogance that crushed Jagan to 9 seats.

  • @pateldg
    @pateldg หลายเดือนก่อน +8

    No duffer on this panel raise the point that how can suppliers can supply cow ghee at the rate 350 rs when market value is arround 1100 rs per kg.

    • @Ramarao0125
      @Ramarao0125 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Yes sir still issue going new tender ( 5 days back)given to nandhi and alpha for 460 rs kg . In the market it is around 1100 rs per kg.. how CBN gives for this cost I can't understand

    • @SudhaReddy-z1o
      @SudhaReddy-z1o หลายเดือนก่อน

      In the market it is 500 only brother

    • @prabhakarnz
      @prabhakarnz หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@SudhaReddy-z1o: Rs.500/- where at A1 Jail Reddy’s fake binami company

    • @Ramarao0125
      @Ramarao0125 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@prabhakarnz 5 days back CBN also given Nandhini and alpha for 460 rs per kg why don't you talk about skill full BABU

    • @MdAlamin-3rd
      @MdAlamin-3rd หลายเดือนก่อน

      Its around 500rs

  • @WhoWhatWhy_123
    @WhoWhatWhy_123 หลายเดือนก่อน +10

    Most informed and data backed discussion on this topic. We Hindus are hurt because standing up for our faith is in some strange convoluted way seen as Communal. Born as a Hindu, converted to Christianity at age 2 along with my whole family, and subsequently brainwashed into believing Hindu gods are demons (in the most loving flowery language), I personally lived through the trauma of Christian conversions. The conversions are targeting the very core of Hinduism - the most beautiful pluralistic belief system that all paths lead to the god. For years, I was told not to visit Hindu temples, not to pray to Hindu gods, not to eat Hindu prashad, not to celebrate Hindu festivals, not to keep Hindu god pictures in home, and for God's sake they didn't even let us participate in the death rituals of our close relatives and family members.
    It's such a vile and exclusivist ideology under the garb of love of compassion. 40 years old, I'm still suffering from this childhood trauma induced by christianity. I know demeaning Hindu gods is wrong, but I was petrified even to think otherwise because they brainwashed to me believe that even a mere thought of accepting other forms of beliefs is a sure shot ticket to eternal hell. Irrespective of you are a good person or not. The only way to eternal heaven is through Jesus. So it's your job to stay in the box, and also bring other lost sheep into your box of Christianity.

    • @bulususrisatishkrishnachai402
      @bulususrisatishkrishnachai402 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Sorry to hear about your ordeal sister. Hope you and your family came out of that cult.

    • @WhoWhatWhy_123
      @WhoWhatWhy_123 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@bulususrisatishkrishnachai402 I don't think I can never come out of it. Most horrifying thing is that many Hindus hate Hindus more than Christians and Muslims. The anguish of suppressed feelings is going to stay with me till death.

    • @sumarianprince
      @sumarianprince หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Hope you managed to get over your indoctrination.

    • @WhoWhatWhy_123
      @WhoWhatWhy_123 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@sumarianprince I did. But with a lot of damage

    • @sumarianprince
      @sumarianprince หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@WhoWhatWhy_123 It doesn't what you believe in as long as you are following something that gives you mental peace ✌️.
      My problem with Abrahamic faiths is that they demonize Sanata Dharma without understanding.
      The fact of the matter is we start pointing out the flaws in their scripture they will be forced to accept that own faith is mired in controversial edicts.

  • @nrusimha11
    @nrusimha11 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    "Most informed and data backed discussion on this topic. We Hindus are hurt because standing up for our faith is in some strange convoluted way seen as Communal. Born as a Hindu, converted to Christianity at age 2 along with my whole family, and subsequently brainwashed into believing Hindu gods are demons (in the most loving flowery language), I personally lived through the trauma of Christian conversions. The conversions are targeting the very core of Hinduism - the most beautiful pluralistic belief system that all paths lead to the god. For years, I was told not to visit Hindu temples, not to pray to Hindu gods, not to eat Hindu prashad, not to celebrate Hindu festivals, not to keep Hindu god pictures in home, and for God's sake they didn't even let us participate in the death rituals of our close relatives and family members.
    It's such a vile and exclusivist ideology under the garb of love of compassion. 40 years old, I'm still suffering from this childhood trauma induced by christianity. I know demeaning Hindu gods is wrong, but I was petrified even to think otherwise because they brainwashed to me believe that even a mere thought of accepting other forms of beliefs is a sure shot ticket to eternal hell. Irrespective of you are a good person or not. The only way to eternal heaven is through Jesus. So it's your job to stay in the box, and also bring other lost sheep into your box of Christianity."

    • @CultReddy
      @CultReddy หลายเดือนก่อน

      Dengey ra converted lk 😅😢

  • @venkateswarluk5133
    @venkateswarluk5133 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    After some tanks of ghee from the company in question were used, the devotees complained about the quality of Laddoo. So, the remaining tanks of ghee were sent for testing. The testing indicated adulteration of ghee with vegetable oil, animal fat, pork tallow etc. So, it is very difficult to say the ghee used in Laddoos was not contaminated since all the tanks of ghee arrived at the same time. Also, Tirupathi doesn't have a proper facility to test for adulteration of Ghee so they wouldn't have known whether the ghee was adulterated or not. Then how is it possible to say the adulterated ghee was not used in the Laddoos preparation?

    • @rosarosa6715
      @rosarosa6715 หลายเดือนก่อน

      😂

    • @Ramarao0125
      @Ramarao0125 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@venkateswarluk5133 in TDP regime 14 tanks sent back on record..
      Suppose 'x' supplier supplies 2 ghee tanks to TTD in 2016 april ,one passed and one failed ( that was returned back) as per policy . But another one used which is from same supplier but is it is passed .that means laddu contaminated in 2016 ..?
      Here the answer is NO ,there is 3 levers checking by TTD lab accredited by NABL . If they give pass then only tankers enter into TTD ..
      Here also same NABL lab gives pass confirmation then also it pass and used for laddu.. ( who failed not used for laddu ,this reqular procedure by TTD)
      TTD Don't passed tankers based on trust and once laddu is prepared now it may or may not be contaminated. These are all CBN political games.

  • @nrusimha11
    @nrusimha11 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    4 tankers of beef-pork-ghee were used, 4 were caught before being used.

    • @nrusimha11
      @nrusimha11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @Mbr-one are you intimately familiar with the procedures at Tirupati or are you speculating?

  • @sadhanasuresha587
    @sadhanasuresha587 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    How can politics not come into the issue when the contamination supposedly happened during Jagan's rule in AP and people nominated by Jagan in the Tirupathi Board during his govt reign, were the people who either deliberately conspired to adulterate or allowed the adulteration of laddus to happen because of obvious corruption and also that people of another religion appointed by Jagan on the Tirupathi Board could not care less if the ghee is impure or not. Hence, this issue has everything to do with politics.

  • @Balakrishna28M
    @Balakrishna28M หลายเดือนก่อน

    Chandrababu is a worst CM in the history of AP ..CheeBN💦

  • @mohanrajjmesipam442
    @mohanrajjmesipam442 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Even though the tender was accepted during Jagan's time, but the first consignment came in during current regime and they rejected the contaminated consignment.

  • @akhilyella7411
    @akhilyella7411 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    If jagan says i respect their religion then what stops him signing the declaration and visiting the Tirumala temple.
    Humanity is my religion note down in declaration says jagan ok, your declaration got rejected Please step aside.. Follow tradition and rules of the Temple period..

    • @abhiram13579
      @abhiram13579 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I don’t understand why this declaration came into picture now? Why didn’t they stop in previous tdp government during 2014 - 2019? Why didn’t that modi or amit shah didn’t ask when the visited to Tirumala with Jagan? Suddenly it came in to picture now because he lost in elections. I myself visited tirumala with my friends in 2018 one of my friend is a christian we all submitted our aadhar cards there but no one asked for declaration. So the rule is only for Jagan mohan reddy or all others? And i heard that he declared in 2009 itself when he visited first time itself.

    • @babupandirla1421
      @babupandirla1421 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@abhiram13579because your fucking christian friend is not genuine about his faith. He can come but with the respect not by deceiving

    • @venkateswarluk5133
      @venkateswarluk5133 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      @@abhiram13579 Visiting Tirumala as a person is different from visiting as the CM, who represents the govt. and offer clothes to God on behalf of the govt. So, the govt. representative should obey the rules of TTD that existed at the time.

    • @swathi123vm
      @swathi123vm หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@abhiram13579 WHAT an ahole argument. "You were okay before then. Why not now" is a classic victim-shaming technique. If you were sexually assaulted for a very long period and suddenly decided enough was enough and reported it, would you ask the same question? It was okay before, but it doesn't make it okay now. The rule was broken before, and the rule is broken again now. Since TDP has more power noiw, they used it to their advantage, but that doesn't make what Jagan did right. HOW HARD IS FUCKING STAYING TRUE TO YOUR OWN LANE?

    • @abhiram13579
      @abhiram13579 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@venkateswarluk5133 but he even visited when he was in opposition during 2014-2019 several times and he has signed when he visited first time on 2009. He doesn’t have any issues to sign 1000 times but the issue here is TDP wanna show their egoistic power on him.

  • @HariPrasad-wj7lz
    @HariPrasad-wj7lz หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    First things first. Jagan is no politician you people know. And YSRCP is no political party that you can compare. Closest would be Pablo Escobar.

    • @arunavalli1659
      @arunavalli1659 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Succinct and accurate.

  • @coffeeguru1970
    @coffeeguru1970 หลายเดือนก่อน

    If the TTD Board is not giving clear answers as to their procedures for testing every single drop of ghee being used in the temple, it is they who are deliberately creating confusions in the minds of all pilgrims, when all they need to do is emphatically state the procedures they follow for every single container of ghee being received for the last 100 years. By being ambiguous they have allowed doubt and suspicion to creep in and create this controversy which was completely unnecessary.

  • @ganesankrishnamurthy8658
    @ganesankrishnamurthy8658 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Corrupt people can be anybody either in government or in private organizations. How do you decide.

  • @RamaKrishna-mp7md
    @RamaKrishna-mp7md หลายเดือนก่อน

    Barkha is twisting the facts. The declaration for entering Tirumala temple doesn't ask to which faith the person belongs. The person should only sign the declaration that he believes in Lord Venkateshwara.

  • @stanchill6174
    @stanchill6174 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Everyone in the discussion has missed the truth.

  • @nss74
    @nss74 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Pawan Kakyan seems a big fool. He is totally brain washed. Such fall from grace

    • @smgs4170
      @smgs4170 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Unlike your atanki culy, no one read atanki manual 5 times a day unlike yours.

  • @Bambabu2023
    @Bambabu2023 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Jagan is a notorious criminal

  • @ianpadiyar7314
    @ianpadiyar7314 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    See Ms Barka Dutt she thinks she very smart in her discussion brings some clowns and for her her panalist are the brillient pepoles. And will choose laddu subjects. In our country we millions of issues but she will choose and make big drama since she speaks good English !! If she is good reporter she will have picked up "Prime Mister fund, Election Fund, Adani , Ambai. Unfortuntly she will never speak above issues. Recently Ms Madhavi Bouch conterverse. No one speaks. And they call themselves a honest reporters which is wrong....

  • @DSRao-wu5vp
    @DSRao-wu5vp หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Funny someone who has humanity as religion dons different religions in different places instead of just being human !! I would accept if he said his religion was politics - pure and unadulterable.

    • @abhiram13579
      @abhiram13579 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      If that’s the case all our politicians religion is politics

  • @sadhanasuresha587
    @sadhanasuresha587 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Waqf board controls land supposedly donated by Muslims but it is, not a body that controls mosques and how islamic rituals are practised. So, there is no similarity with control of temples. Waqf Board powers are in dispute in the Bill brought by govt because the waqf board had indiscriminate & illogical powers when it came to calling any land in India as that belonging to the Waqf board.

  • @muralimohanreddykasireddy5359
    @muralimohanreddykasireddy5359 หลายเดือนก่อน

    This debate is lost credibility because mixing things instead of answering straight forward whether or not adulterated ghee was used taking into the information available in public domain. For any one to believe that adulterated ghee was supplied not in Jagan government. It was happened now in present government. Therefore how Jagan is responsible.
    Second one is that whether Jagan needs to sign declaration or not? Jagan's party says declaration was given in 2009 itself. Does he require each time?

    • @smgs4170
      @smgs4170 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Yes its required each time. That's what TTD process says. Its far more than adulterated ghee, for years you can't keep a religion hostage in the name of secularism. Jagan has played around to dilute the sanctity of Tirupati. He should have stayed out during his tenure.

  • @nss74
    @nss74 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Its a shame that in 21st century India such trivial issue being discussed. What if ghee was adultrated and laddus were made. Catch the culprit and punish in accordance with law of the land.
    Each human on this land eat adultrated food and consume chemically poisioned food, water and air. That should be point of discussion.
    Shit journalism

    • @smgs4170
      @smgs4170 หลายเดือนก่อน

      What happens to these big talks when sar tan se juda blows around for all trivial reasons?

  • @Monickamp
    @Monickamp หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    Ex chief minister Jegan Mohan is an honest and great leader. Question his religion and put him in trouble is cheap political vendetta . BJP government always going in line with religion.

    • @karthikkumar2972
      @karthikkumar2972 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

      Temples are not public parks. It has it's rules, just follow them. Most temples don't have such rules go there.
      If same thing is about mosque or churches and if someone tries to break the rule you same people react differently.

    • @pavel009
      @pavel009 หลายเดือนก่อน

      He's a clown

    • @madhuparuchuri7068
      @madhuparuchuri7068 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Ohh then why did he started pink dimond politics?

    • @prabhakarnz
      @prabhakarnz หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      What Jagan is a honest and great leader?, don’t tell anyone they will laugh at you from rear end. This A1 Jail Reddy is the most corrupted politician in India to that matter Sourh Asia. People of AP figured that during his disastrous 5 years rule hence they gave him 11 seats in the recently concluded assembly elections.

    • @sumarianprince
      @sumarianprince หลายเดือนก่อน

      He is an evangelist asshole, that's all.

  • @pintubackaga
    @pintubackaga หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Jagan is always honest about his faith.

    • @sumarianprince
      @sumarianprince หลายเดือนก่อน

      No, he is not. Jagan is a crypto Christian like others of his ilk.

  • @venkateswarluk5133
    @venkateswarluk5133 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Rich temples should be controlled by govt. to bring accountability. If the richest Tirupathi and Ranganatha temples had gone out of control, who was going to protect those temples wealth?

    • @bulususrisatishkrishnachai402
      @bulususrisatishkrishnachai402 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Can the same logic apply to rich mosques and churches?

    • @it5617
      @it5617 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      If so then the same rule should be applied to every church and mosque. Temples will go out of control from whom? Why should government interfere in religious matters first of all? If it's interfering then why other religions are exempted? What kind of secularism is this?

    • @venkateswarluk5133
      @venkateswarluk5133 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@it5617 Yes, it should apply to mosques and churches that are as rich as those I mentioned. We don't want our temples controlled by some Swamijis or religious organisations, who have no responsibility. As I said before, who will take responsibility if the wealth in temples is stolen?

    • @karthikkumar2972
      @karthikkumar2972 หลายเดือนก่อน

      We all saw from 75 years how badly temples are maintained. Bad maintenance, breaking the samapradaya of temples, mistreating devotees in temples, looting money in the name of tax and other wellfare uses of government, selling or occupying temple lands, missing of temples asserts like gold etc.

    • @it5617
      @it5617 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@venkateswarluk5133u can't cheerypick the criteria as per ur wishes. All temples are under government . Similarly all churches etc should come under government. Only then it's true equality. If government only wants to control the temples then it's better to remove government involvement. Also, the donations given to temple are by private citizens, so infact government should not have any control over these institutions. Devotees should manage it themselves.

  • @ianpadiyar7314
    @ianpadiyar7314 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Hello Ladies and Gentlemen what's happning in our country it's very sad! Look at your team one Deshmuk who lives in Dubai and talk about India. The media lady see she has got no other subject..... can this pepole tell us do we get food original ? Company like Baba ramdav is his foods are puree! How can you forget few countries have complained about Few masala adeltration did government took any action that too also few madicines .....

  • @samin096
    @samin096 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I can not believe I am listening to this arguments in 2024. This are out of date even in Ramayan times

  • @deetyareddy8546
    @deetyareddy8546 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I am a Hindu, but I sometimes go to church in USA and when I visited Italy recently, I went and visited church. Nobody asked what is my religion

    • @sumarianprince
      @sumarianprince หลายเดือนก่อน

      That's because you don't understand Abrahamism. They consider you a devil worshipper if you are a Hindu.

    • @smgs4170
      @smgs4170 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Why are you comparing Christians in west and the converted ones in India. Westerners follow atheism, scientology even if they go to church. They don't bother playing any festivals any religion. Indian ones are told to hate the origin from where they come from.

  • @nss74
    @nss74 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Rahul Ishwar is a big fool. Someone visiting a tample already means he believes and if someone visiting the temple for picnic it would not make that person faithful by writing something in a register.
    Its unfortunate we have such fools who are followed by many.

    • @smgs4170
      @smgs4170 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Temples are for specific religion/cult, not a picnic place. If rule are there, follow it...or don't go.

  • @rosarosa6715
    @rosarosa6715 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    no hindu believes in all deities equally. so even hindus should start signing that they believe in the deity they want to have darshan of.😂

    • @ATANKINAMAZI
      @ATANKINAMAZI หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Because they believe god come in different forms. Eventually it leads to spirituality, god are all one. Unlike you have been told to sell bible in bicycle which may give you a high paying job in US companies. Sadly its not working, brains don't grow by conversion.

  • @pcs.1961
    @pcs.1961 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Jagan Mohan Reddy is true Gentlemen.

  • @pslamba51
    @pslamba51 หลายเดือนก่อน

    People are angry bec naidu told that beef fat was found in the testing report.
    As evident from the report, it is a blatant lie.
    The presence of chemical pointing to Beef fat was only one of the 14 contaminants possible, and all others were veg oil/fat based.
    The crime of Naidu is that he emphasized on beef, but the test report didn't say that specifically.
    As Naidu is now aligned with BJP he is trying to communalise the issue because Reddy is a Christian.

    • @sumarianprince
      @sumarianprince หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      As if YSR & his father didn't try to evangelize in Tirumala hills, so just fuck off.

    • @smgs4170
      @smgs4170 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Nice words, the report does talk about beef tallow. Suddenly you are to spin this as communal as perhaps you are not bothered about other's emotions. Or else there would have been killing in the name sacrilege. Sounds familiar? Hindus beliefs are not BJP or Congress. If you can't support, don't step into places not of your concern.