Liza Minnelli & Judy Garland - Hello Dolly (live)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ส.ค. 2024
- The novelty of Judy Garland: Live at the London Palladium is the spectacle of the great entertainer sharing the stage with her up-and-coming daughter. In November 1964 Liza Minnelli was not yet 20 and not yet a Broadway success. She looks it: the coltish, appealingly gawky girl is still pretty raw (at one point after a costume change she yanks off her earrings just before launching into a song), and Garland seems alternately proud of and bemused by her. The video is pretty raw, too, a rough black-and-white affair that can best be described as serviceable in quality. However, fans of this brand of showbiz razzmatazz will be satisfied with the duets between the women (especially trading verses on a medley of "Happy Days Are Here Again" and "Get Happy"). Judy opens the show with the reliable chest sweller "Once in a Lifetime" (no relation to the Talking Heads tune) and delivers a tutorial in song dynamics with "The Man That Got Away." She appears rather shrunken and tired but still comes on like a trouper, fending off the audience's constant heckling for "Over the Rainbow" (as though she might forget it?) before finally handing the song back to them as a touching sing-along. This was Garland's last appearance at the Palladium. It's also a passing of the torch to Liza, who would later become the kind of polished dynamo embodied by her mother, more than capable of holding down her own one-woman shows.
![ถามตรงๆ กับ อาจตุพร ทำไม ประเทศไทย ใครเป็นนายก ก็โดนด่า พอออกเเล้วคนคิดถึง!!?? l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3YFLMXxBGAs/mqdefault.jpg)
God, the hair stands up on the back of my neck when Judy starts singing off stage. Just amazing!
Aww judy signaling liza at the end to take a bow is soooo nice. Shes a proud mama u can tell
listened to this hundreds of times and yet I always get chills when Judy comes out... she was magnificent
Can you imagine being in the audience that night? Two of the greatest performers to ever grace the stage, singing together!
You can tell, both women love one another dearly
The most fantastic thing about this performance is the incredible energy that comes from both Judy and Liza's love for each other and the energy of competition.
Liza has spoken in detail about this night. How she sang 3 or 4 songs before this duet and the crowd was just going wild. She could see her mother in the wings becoming less and less enthusiastic because Judy realized they weren't just her fans anymore and Liza (Whose voice was now stronger) was stealing the show.
Judy stalled on purpose to come out (this is when you hear Liza call "Mama? Mama?")
Liza would later recall "When she walked out on that stage she was not Mama. She was Judy Garland!"
The chemistry that night created a show no one will ever forget!
Liza has an ego as big as all out doors. Liza has always hated it because she wasn't as good as her mom, and was always denying that she made it because of her mom. Her acceptance speech at the Oscars "I know you gave this to me", or in the movie That's Entertainment they had Fred Astaire introduce Liza who was going to talk about Judys films, and Fred said "she made in on her own, yes she did". Well no she didn't. Being Judy's daughter opened tons of doors for Liza. I can't see what others see in Liza, singing wise, she's ok at best. She does seem to hit some notes that are real clunkers. She's loud but not melodic. Even Judy said it herself during a radio interview on April 23, 1962, "Lorna is my singer, and Liza is my dancer". Liza could never steal a show from her mom, especially in England.
We will never see anything like again in our lifetime. Well trained talent
Do you remember that interview's name?
@@terrygrant3467 I totally agree with everything you say. Liza will never acknowledge she learned anything from her mum, thats bull, her every move and voice she has tried to outshine her mother but she knows she can't. There is only 1 once in a life time Judy Garland. Sorry Liza thats not you. Its your mother. RIP Judy you sweet soul 🙏
Saw the entire concert, Judy is at her game!! Liz's is very good too. Peace
I loved how JUDY GARLAND showed up on the stage...this is a powerful moment in history.
It takes a legend, to make a star.
Great singers come and go. But in our lifetime we are lucky enough to get two of them, one generation after the other. It's an amazing thing.
Please people, have some respect. They were both great singers. Thanks for posting a good memory .
Unreal.
One of my all time favorites.
I miss this kind of talent, showmanship, and JOY!
Me too.That is why we turn to You Tube. Videos to watch them perform.RIP Judy and Thanks .
Judy Garland was the greatest talent that ever lived, why would anyone think she could be jealous of one person, let alone her own daughter, AND for me, EVERYONE fades totally away the second Judy steps on stage. It's just exciting waiting for her to step into that spotlight. Judy is thrilling to watch.!!!
The most accurate statement so far. Well said.
Wow,,,,,,, i didn't even born yet . but judy WAS an AMAIZING PERFORMANCER . Rip
i visit her show last year in Belgium, and believe me it was awsome!!!
AWESOME!!!! I love when history is found on tape!
This gave me major chills!!! Can you imagine how incredible it must have been to be in that audience!?!?!
They didn't call Judy "The World's Greatest Entertainer" during her own lifetime for nothing!
Two of the greatest!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You can't hear me, but I'm applauding you. Very well stated and it's true.
Two of the most valuable voices in the world!
Aww, tears are coming to my eyes. My own mother died of breast cancer two weeks ago, and I frequently had to leave her bedside to drive to school to rehearse for Hello Dolly. The night before she was taken to hospice, I sang "Hello, mama" like Liza did and it made her smile. =)
They both got the outstanding & powerful voice!!
thank you!
The stage presence and voice of each of these two women is utterly gobsmacking. Love it love it love it!
Meravigliosa e dolce Judy... no one like her
No, genes like that never come together twice,
So sad I am that it was waster in such a tragic way.
She is still rememberedd and remorsed by her fans many years later.
Nothing compares to these two!
Marvelous!
I'm in tears, I have no words
it is very, very, very rare that the child of an unique star has the same talent. They all try, but it's one in a million. But here it comes true. Liza has the voice, the stage pressence. the charisma of her mother and the both of them - pure magic.
when judy started singing off stage, I started crying and I didn't stop throughout the performance. I wish she was still around, and I wish she had been happier when she was here. Thank god she had Liza, one part of her life that she enjoyed!
@DancerSam01 These two ladies just oozed talent from every pore in their bodies. The were entertainers par exellence. Sadly it is unlikely that we will ever see their likes again.
Two such amazing a talented women in their glory together
Sensational! There are very few strong voices like that left in the world. Damn, they were good.
thanks keep posting judy
Fantastic mother and daughter!!! Thanks!!!
absolutley wonderful
this is BEYOND marvelous!!!
Awesome upload, wonderful clip!
si.... great Judy with great Liza
A mother and her Daugther singing together,
how lovely it is
I finally got tickets to see you Liza.I am so looking forward to seeing you!!! I know you put on one hell of a show! I can't believe I am going to see the legendary LIZA MINNELLI I can't wait! Welcome back to America Liza I have followed your tour and it is back in the U.S.A.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ya! Love Barb...
Two absulete stunning superstars.Highest qualitu and talent.
***"La rencontre inoubliables de deux "MONSTRES SACRÉS" more than a LEGEND !
beautiful !!!! two great singers .....
¡que hermoso! como dijo alguien esto si que es una joya
WOW was that iconic
Wow! I never realized how much alike they sounded!!!
It's a show! But Isn't it lovely?
No, I meant that, at this moment, there are not that many people who can still sing like that and have as strong a voice as these 2 ladies had.
I know that Liza is still amongst the living, but I am not sure she could still sing as good as she did in 1964.
they may be gay icons, but they are also much more than that...this upload is a treat, thanks so much for this.
@Odette321 From Judy's earliest childhood on stage, the spotlight rarely off her, she HAD to center on the image she projected. And once the film studios hired and "wired" her (8 days a week on uppers to stay awake, lively and productive; then downers to crash land in dreamless, unrefreshing, unrecreative sleeps), and mercilessly criticized her appearance / tore her ego to shreds and made her lose her natural feminine youthful plumpness, amazing she survived at all.
Extraordinary !
wow! this video it's a treasure! very epic
Wow, that was amazing!
Judy was the best
love juds!
I never knew such a delight existed. Thank you!!!
@lovelessAndros simply amazing:-) What I wouldn`t give to have been there. I wish times like this would never end. Wish I had a time machine.
thank you for sharing with us this talented ladies performance!
Sweet mother and daughter duet. Love them both.
Thanks for posting! If they only knew the future of videos. THIS should have been preserved with better sound and color like the crap we save today. Jonas Brothers in 3D?! Technology came too late for Judy, but whatever format you listen/see her in FAR surpasses in quality most entertainment today. Good talent shines through. And she DID her share of technicolor classics! When you think how the studio chopped up A STAR IS BORN////
Beautiful
nAW!! so beautiful!!!
They have had so much energy!!!
wow like mother like daughter very same actions rest in peace Judy
Jeeze...These are Greats...what are we going to do when there's no more artists like this left.. it's now 2010 and there's only a handful of that can actually sing and being able to sing these days is saying alot!
***"La rencontre inoubliables de deux "MONSTRES SACRÉS"
Liza is giving you major KAY THOMPSON in her opening notes! OMG...love this!
great footage of two legends
thx 4 notifying, i corrected te info, x
Garland Forever !
love love love love love love etc etc etc etc etc etc
wonderful
Judy & Liza ++++++
just .....no words
Goosebumps!!
Beautiful!!
So wonderful
I love this!
This is freakin' priceless.
WOW WOW no puedo creer lo increible que es esto
i love this so much it is wonderful they are my favoritre singers
Beatiful both!
LOVE IT!!
este documento es impresionante
If there ever was to be a movie about them I'd say....
Anne Hathaway-Liza Minnelli
Sally Field-Judy Garland
Anyone agree?
@laurelfan1 Are you serious. Everytime Liza sings you can clearly her Judy!!!
That really would have been something if they were to have done that musical together.
this gives me chiLLLLLLs
They are just wonderful. I am as straight as they come and they are amazing. Not beautiful, not sexy (Liza in Caberet manages to be alluring without being sexy), just great vocal talent and great charisma.
Hello Liza! ;)
lo veo lo veo y lo se guire viendo y me seguira gustando entre mas lo veo mas me gusta ,,,,,no lo puedo creer que mujeres en el escenario a de ver sido todo un show y un super gusto escucharlas vivas felicidades a las dos .........................
Qué maravilla...
Duas divas!!!!❤❤❤❤
@Dirkdebruyne Thank You so Much!!! I've always known who they were. But I'm just now Searching for Music, be it Cd, DvD or old records :D Just bought the Cabaret Record for like $2.00. So glad to know this is all on some sort of entertainment form. Thanks Again :D
Happy Tears. That's all I got.
fenomenal , madre e hija son maravillosas, wonderful womans, great
Nice. :)
It was briefly considered. IMDB says that in pre-production (when Warners producers were still casting) they considered Judy for Rose and either Liza, Jane Fonda, or Ann-Margret (!) for Louise, but conflicts with Judy's recurring television specials on CBS (as well as her now well-publicized unpredictability) persuaded them to drop the idea. I would've loved to see it; I always thought it was, to quote a song, the role that got away.
Judy was very genrous to all her guests and especially to her Children. Some have said Judy was jealous of her daughter Liza. Not true Judy wasn't catty and always talked with great proud of Liza . Check Judy on the old tv show "whats my line" and with Barbara walters interview. Judy also made sure she woudl never be like her own mother who was jealous of Judy" because she had absolutely no talent." Judy said that to Barbara Walters in a 1967 interview on the TODAY Show. :-)
Very true statement it was Liza that was jealous of Judy but she will never be a match for her mother. Takes a true legend to make a star. RIP Judy you beautiful soul
@grtbow Liza is on tour! You can go to her website and see the dates and times. She cancelled a few due to illness but is back. She also has a special coming on in December (the 11th or 12th I think) on TCM about her parents. :)