Jack White's musicianship,passion for the music and collaboration with similarly talented artists is a delight for the soul especially in these troubling international times
I think Jack White is just amazing. The output of music he does, the producing he does, having been in 3 successful bands. This song is just beautiful. Makes you feel things internally that are rare in music........
Jack white is my guitar idol. White stripes are my favorite band. That said I LOVE WHEN JACK WHITE MESSES UP ON GUITAR!!! its cuz I also play guitar and write. I love it it makes the performance more real and alive. No one wants perfection if so go listen to the record at home
It's kind of what I liked about the first, like, 7 Cure records. Robert Smith always wrote a little out of his own range so those higher notes had so much more feel and effort applied to them. Much more interesting to me than someone like Celine Dion singing some perfect BS.
An awesome song and an awesome performance by each of the musicians. I hear this and am reminded of the folk-rock of the mid to late 60s that incorporated sitar and had a light Indian raga flavor (at least to my untrained western ears). The fiddle and mandolin really compliment the guitar well. Probably the best choices of instruments to use for this song.
Children's song at 3:00 is Brother John. Are you sleeping? Are you sleeping, Brother John? Morning bells are ringing, Morning bells are ringing ding, ding, dong.
Before anyone comments on his voice, and how this and recorded version sound different, the recording is from 2005 when he could still sing his high ends, but then he messed up those up and would often get Bronchitis due to the effects of smoking, so you dont have to feel bad because you thought his high ends naturally worse, he did it himself, so be mad at him
I like his voice, roughness and all. I take his voice for what it is. He's never had a clean and beautiful voice to begin with, that was part of his appeal. I just didn't like this rendition due to the fiddle being so loud and drowning him out at some points to the point it became a distraction.
Um, moo, please don't spread misinformation. This recording is not from 2005. It is from October 15, 2016. Last Saturday night. It was a first rate show at A Prairie Home Companion.
Pete Gjerness If you read my comment thoroughly i said: "And how this, and the recorded version sound different" i was comparing the one recorded from the get behind me satan era and this show
Thanks so much for watching clips of Live From Here, if you enjoy this checkout Chris Thile and Punch Brothers new musical variety show, The Energy Curfew Music Hour. Season one is streaming here: bit.ly/ecmh-season1
Hahaha you can tell they're usually a rock band. They're not super used to *playing together*... Just slamming about and a insane racket. Jack should play quieter with his musicians more often so they can learn to blend... It sounds like theyre all trying to be heard over each other.
Nah, I'm a raving atheist. You think a bible thumper'd have Newman as their image? I'm just sarcastically reveling in the fact that Garry K's sanctimonious drivel (see a nice summary on the Pharyngula blog titled "Go back to Lake Wobegone, Garrison Keillor") is dying out.
Your comment sounded like something that was meant as satire/ sarcastic but I wasn't sure. I can see Garrison saying something like what you said, all in good fun of course. I'm looking forward to this new age in PHC, I will definitely go into it with an open mind. :)
This was okay. I like Lilliie Mae but sometimes her fiddle just over powes the song and her voice is not necessary and this is one of those times. I look forward to her solo venture.
Meg Joray He may have but he was doing great on his own. It was more some of the fiddle parts that sounded overpowering for me. I think Jack's voice is still going strong This whole set was amazing, this was the only song that I wasn't 100% on for me.
drtrolish What the hell is this supposed to mean? I'm a fan of Lillie Mae's, I'm looking forward to her solo album and saw her with Jack in concert, where I absolutely fell in love with her. The fact that she's a girl makes her even more badass in my opinion you judgmental ass. Back it up.
What a lame comment!! These guys are very talented and are taking acoustic music to a totally new audience who may not see a tattoo as tacky. If your prejudice blocks your ability to enjoy the performance, just hit the stop button and move on!
Jack White's musicianship,passion for the music and collaboration with similarly talented artists is a delight for the soul especially in these troubling international times
I think Jack White is just amazing. The output of music he does, the producing he does, having been in 3 successful bands. This song is just beautiful. Makes you feel things internally that are rare in music........
this song & its singer win me over
Jack white is my guitar idol. White stripes are my favorite band. That said I LOVE WHEN JACK WHITE MESSES UP ON GUITAR!!! its cuz I also play guitar and write. I love it it makes the performance more real and alive. No one wants perfection if so go listen to the record at home
This brings me the same nostalgia that we are going to be friends does. He's done it again.
Utterly enchanting.
So... Am I the only one who likes Jack's really rough high notes?
nope
Joker no.
Joker also the weird sad face he does sometimes, kinda like an upside down smile, when trying to reach high notes
It's kind of what I liked about the first, like, 7 Cure records. Robert Smith always wrote a little out of his own range so those higher notes had so much more feel and effort applied to them. Much more interesting to me than someone like Celine Dion singing some perfect BS.
You are not. Lol, he's amazing!
This is too beautiful
So impossibly beautiful.
An awesome song and an awesome performance by each of the musicians. I hear this and am reminded of the folk-rock of the mid to late 60s that incorporated sitar and had a light Indian raga flavor (at least to my untrained western ears). The fiddle and mandolin really compliment the guitar well. Probably the best choices of instruments to use for this song.
Amazing. Goose bumps.
Wonderful.
This is so beautiful
I can not wait until I do arrive by my side
Impressive all around!
love the shower video for this!!
Beautiful....lovely
I believe this is the only time he’s played this song live. Correct me if I’m wrong
Well this was an unreleased track from The White Stripes.
Children's song at 3:00 is Brother John. Are you sleeping? Are you sleeping, Brother John? Morning bells are ringing, Morning bells are ringing ding, ding, dong.
yea!
Before anyone comments on his voice, and how this and recorded version sound different, the recording is from 2005 when he could still sing his high ends, but then he messed up those up and would often get Bronchitis due to the effects of smoking, so you dont have to feel bad because you thought his high ends naturally worse, he did it himself, so be mad at him
I like his voice, roughness and all. I take his voice for what it is. He's never had a clean and beautiful voice to begin with, that was part of his appeal. I just didn't like this rendition due to the fiddle being so loud and drowning him out at some points to the point it became a distraction.
Um, moo, please don't spread misinformation. This recording is not from 2005. It is from October 15, 2016. Last Saturday night. It was a first rate show at A Prairie Home Companion.
Pete Gjerness If you read my comment thoroughly i said: "And how this, and the recorded version sound different" i was comparing the one recorded from the get behind me satan era and this show
The recorded version was from the other year.
Just beautiful
Amazing
Thanks so much for watching clips of Live From Here, if you enjoy this checkout Chris Thile and Punch Brothers new musical variety show, The Energy Curfew Music Hour. Season one is streaming here: bit.ly/ecmh-season1
dziękuję
I can hear some Frere Jacqua in that melody, very pretty.
that's not in the original version though
Did anybody else catch the childrens song thrown in at 3:00 ?
I hear it but I can't place it. Somebody help me!
Amber
"Are you sleeping brother John?"
❤❤❤
Inspirational lack of expectations, as a freedom-n-liberty thing, seems to have been created by Jack White. Musically speaking.
I fucking love Jack White but I would like to have her sing the whole song. Love that girl
I will fo.rever love you , you always my favorite buzz n. You & dream of tha
The dude abides
Here I Am Ms Sophia Loks In the flesh babiiii
Hahaha you can tell they're usually a rock band.
They're not super used to *playing together*... Just slamming about and a insane racket.
Jack should play quieter with his musicians more often so they can learn to blend... It sounds like theyre all trying to be heard over each other.
Jacks guitar is almost inaudible the entire time
that wasn't Chris Thile
where's Meg!
Dario P. the band broke up in Feb 22 2011
😭😭😭
Are they all playing meatal instruments?
The style of guitar that Jacks playing, a resonator, is usually made of metal. He probably wanted the rest of them to match though.
You know orever I will answer ... ldudffuddu
Is Garry K. standing in the wings whispering, "These shaven head women and long haired men need to GET RIGHT WITH GOD!"?
No.
No.
Nah, I'm a raving atheist. You think a bible thumper'd have Newman as their image? I'm just sarcastically reveling in the fact that Garry K's sanctimonious drivel (see a nice summary on the Pharyngula blog titled "Go back to Lake Wobegone, Garrison Keillor") is dying out.
Your comment sounded like something that was meant as satire/ sarcastic but I wasn't sure. I can see Garrison saying something like what you said, all in good fun of course. I'm looking forward to this new age in PHC, I will definitely go into it with an open mind. :)
Rudy Angulo It was, I've been busy. :) I get you....
This was okay. I like Lilliie Mae but sometimes her fiddle just over powes the song and her voice is not necessary and this is one of those times. I look forward to her solo venture.
I wonder if he asked her to sing out on those high licks with him so that the notes came through when he couldn't quite hit them.
"That's because you're a girl" - Anguy the archer.
She was amazing in this btw imo.
Meg Joray He may have but he was doing great on his own. It was more some of the fiddle parts that sounded overpowering for me. I think Jack's voice is still going strong This whole set was amazing, this was the only song that I wasn't 100% on for me.
drtrolish What the hell is this supposed to mean? I'm a fan of Lillie Mae's, I'm looking forward to her solo album and saw her with Jack in concert, where I absolutely fell in love with her. The fact that she's a girl makes her even more badass in my opinion you judgmental ass. Back it up.
how the mighty have fallen
What's that suppose to mean??? Jack white does so much music. Raconteurs had a number 1 album
People change, kids become adults.
The fiddler's tacky tattoos distract from the performance. Real musicians and artists don's feel the need to express themselves through a tattoo.
Oh really? Good to know...
That's pure nonsense you muppet.
wtf, this comment is fucking stupid.
What a lame comment!! These guys are very talented and are taking acoustic music to a totally new audience who may not see a tattoo as tacky. If your prejudice blocks your ability to enjoy the performance, just hit the stop button and move on!
You listen to music with your ears, not your eyes.
Impressive all around!