PS4 vs Xbox One vs Xbox One S - How Hot Do They Get???
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ต.ค. 2024
- www.tronicsfix....
TronicsFix is a national mail in repair center for game consoles.
This video shows how hot the PS4, Xbox One & Xbox One S get at various times. It also shows how loud they are.
We first take a look at all three consoles to see how hot and how loud they are when they are just turned on but not playing any games or anything.
After that we test each one, one at a time to see how they are at idle as well as how loud they are. We then play a game on each console for a couple of minutes and recheck the heat and volume of them. When we're done we make a chart showing the PS4, Xbox One and Xbox One S and both the temperature and sound measurement that we took.
While our method is not a scientific method to determine which console runs hotter and which runs cooler, it does give us a general idea.
Web: www.tronicsfix....
Facebook: / tronicsfix
Instagram: / tronicsfix
Twitter: / tronicsfix
Tools I use:
-Protech Toolkit: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/90il5y
-Torx Security T8: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/AEcBvZL
-PH00 Phillips: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/YGVSSv
-Tweezer Set: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/t0VrlcX
-Electric Screwdriver: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/2wbHzJ
-Thermal Paste: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/q2Prd
-Canned Air: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/CPYy
Equipment Used:
-Hakko Hot Air Station: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/y2JDR
-Nozzle for hot air station: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/zpEWlT
-Hakko Soldering Station: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/MTL0qb
-Hakko Air Filter: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/Gqznh
-Microscope: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/WBO3b
-Kester Solder: Amazon (paid link) geni.us/ETXUh
TronicsFix assumes no liability for property damage or injury incurred as a result of any of the information contained in this video. All material provided within this TH-cam channel is for informational, educational, & entertainment purposes only. Some of these projects, materials, and techniques may not be appropriate for all ages or skill levels. No information contained in this video shall create any express or implied warranty or guarantee of any particular result.
TronicsFix does not make any claims of the safety of the projects, techniques, or resources listed on this channel and will not take responsibility of what you do with the information provided by this channel. Any injury, damage or loss that may result from improper use of these tools, equipment, or the information contained in this video is the sole responsibility of the user and not TronicsFix. Please do not attempt anything contained in this video unless you accept personal responsibility for the results, whether they are good or bad.
(*We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.)
Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Sony Airlines
My PS4 sounds like a 747 and is hotter than Pamela Anderson in her prime!
Me too XD
The 2015 revision is markedly more silent than the first version from 2013. A better cooling solution and slighly lower power usage due to better memory modules makes it surprisingly "quiet" compared the older one. So happy I bought mine recently :P
did you people get a broken ps4 then
Alexander Anders many people complain about their PS4'S being loud and hot. Nothing is new about that, lol
+Marius Alsén I got mine almost the first day it came out....
Skip gameplay
Xbox One: 19:25
Xbox One S: 26:08
PS4: 32:29
Kitten thanks
He looks and reminds me of Sheldon Cooper from the big bang theory.
*Fun with Flags*
Sheldon used color dry erase markers. :)
Hahahhahahahahhahahahahhaha
Lol good one
Nice
i think that the ,xbox one s, is better than the others
True that xbox one s rules.
Ps4 pro or ps4 slim
debar_ afan same
Xbox One s team
Yess
Leaf blower station 4.
It's the cpu thermal paste on most ps4's that needs re-applying. I took mine apart reapplied the thermal paste with some arctic silver paste, and it's went from full speed fan constantly even at idle, to quiet as a mouse with some good thermal paste. I guarantee if I do this once a year my ps4 could go forever, well, until something else gives. :P
Mikee Remastered
Yeah funny thing is i replaced the thermal paste & applied better thermal pads & still NO difference.
***** Damn.........re-re-apply it? :P
There is a ps4 cooler you can buy that is supposed to be fantastic. Not the shitty one that sticks into the back that's worse than having nothing. But the one that sits underneath a standing up ps4. There is also a controller docking station on it too. Amazon do them very cheap.
Mikee Remastered
Too late i already sold it since it bored me anyway, i played my PC more. I owned an xbox one longer than i did the ps4 & i NEVER had to buy a 3rd party cooler & yet the thing ran silent.
***** Yes, that's because the ps4 has over-heating issues and the xbox doesn't. I thought we already knew th...anyway enjoy pc. My pc is my main gaming platform. Recently upgraded my older rig with a nice new 970 and an i7-6700k. :)
Ya never know though, you might grab a ps4 pro eventually. Some incredible games coming out on ps4 this year still, and next year. Sadly since xbox decided to put 95% of their exclusives on pc as well now. My xbox one hasn't been plugged in for nearly 6 months now. I don't like Halo and so have no reason to play it for anything yet. :(
My PS4 heat a lot worse than Xbox one, I let my mom use it as comal to warm the tortillas.
Good one
project cars on ps4 sounds like a jet engine.
MarcsLab 😂😂😂😂😂
Jet black colour :D
This was actually a very entertaining test. Nice video :) Subbed
Thanks!
#youknowdeway
Xbox One S & PS4 look badass ;-)
yes lol
The xbox is just a heccin box........lol
@@austincrs stfu kid put the war aside.
@@ulysses4989 war is the only solution
@@austincrs if it is then you already lost
then the Xbox one s is a gaming beast
no
+Vlad TMS why
pokemaster 123 its still weaker than the OJ PS4, maybe Scorpio
+Vlad TMS no sir you are wrong I think you do not have watched full video
run cooler yes, perform better HELL NO
Your videos are a great help in deciding whether to upgrade my 360 or not. Money is an issue and I don't want to go through red ring of death type issues again. I'm one of those cheap dads that doesn't buy just because my son behaves at school or my daughter bats her eyes. Thank you for helping parents who want to avoid extra costs.
You're welcome! The Xbox One S seems to be a good console and I would not hesitate to upgrade to that if I were you. The Xbox One X is good too but obviously very expensive.
Trust me Xbox one s is the right move
Yes ima bye one xbox one s
when i turn on my ps4 it sounds like a plane taking off and when i put in far cry primal it sounds like the screams of pc users reacting to console trailers
is it still alive
Don't know
I must say every video I see you've made I'm astonished at the the time and effort you put in for all your viewers.I keep saying they're very descriptive and worth knowing for anyone......thanks a million!!!👍
Thanks so much! Glad you like them!
FYI: The analog stick of the Xbox Elite controller is a little softer.
I just discovered your channel. I don't know why but there is something appealing about your videos. I'm just 10 minutes into it and I already loved your channel!
Glad you like them!
I have same temperature reader. My Xbox1 s after 12 hours of being on and played is 84.5 Fahrenheit at the Fan and about 74 Fahrenheit abound console. Does not get hot at all. just cool air all around. Fan is quiet. Console has stand attached so is standing vertical. Xbox 1s so far is living up yo its expectations. I love it. Anyone thinking of buying one at least get yourself either the 2tb model or get an external HD. You'll need the space eventually and will appreciate it
My Xbox One S gets way more hot than my PS4 when playing. It's also louder when idle, but at times the PS4 can be a jet engine when playing.
You sir don't have a Xbox one S if it loud lol
blasphemy!
I have always thought that the original xbox one runs cooler because the power supply is outside guess i was wrong
I thought the S would run much warmer than it does. Keep in mind though I didn't play them very long in this video. I plan to do a video in the future where I play it much longer.
TronicsFix i have the original Xbox One but its the 2015 model. It runs very cool i put my hand on the fan vent and its almost cold at idle and while playing its slightly warmer. in the summer i noticed that my xbox one's Cooling fan went to full power for a minute and then it went back to operating speed but its never turned itself off due to overheating, the cooling fan just speeds up.
@@turnipgaming9747 i Have the S model, sometimes it also happens to me when closing a game and starting a heavy one
Xbox one best forever
What is your best now?
Yeah! First video with temp and noise measurement that's is cool! Thank you for hearing my suggestion
Thanks for the great suggestion!
thz very much for the heat test , it was my main concern on buying a new xbox .
amazing all the crap the orig xbox one gets for its size yet it is clearly the quietest console which when sitting on a shelf i could care less about the size yet the noise could for some be of annoyance as the ps4 is no doubt louder device. I'll take bigger size and superior cooling any day over smaller form but hotter and louder.
on my pc i use turtle beach, my consoles sit in my living room where i use my 5.1 surround.
Cody Hackl it was actually hotter than the 1s
*****
yes it does, i was more or less talking about the orig ps4 and orig x1.. the x1 s was able to be small and cool because it has a much more efficient chip in it vs the xbox one orig. I have the ps4 PRO and though i like it, it is very noisy when gaming.
Cody Hackl the original Xbox One has vents on the side
And on the back!
PS4 will be hot and noisy when playing a game
Hope ypu answer me.. i always wanted to know if there is a difference how hot thr Xbox one will get if you stand it vertical vs horizontal
Or making the plastic hotter which was probably picked up
with your heat detector.
The color of the plastic does not make it hotter.
@@Tronicsfix Actually it does! Black consoles are typically the hottest since they absorb more light and convert that to heat energy and white objects are typically colder since they reflect light. Little physics lesson.
@@oswald0_ He ist inside without any sunlight, this is not relevant here.
xbox one 👌
lixo ! xbosta nao tem jogo
S
best consle!!
Hell yeah guys
PS4 pro can use 4K sooo its better
This is a GREAT video this is EXACTLY what I wanted to know. Thanks for the video man!!!! I honestly expected the XBO Slim's stats to be more near the PS4 when it came to how loud and hot it got but this is even better. I'm gonna be picking one up soon now thanks to this video. Keep up the good work!!!
Yes, I expected that it would run hotter than it does. We may have to play a game on it longer to see what the temps are.
+TronicsFix Yeah I'm guessing once you reach the hour mark or so of gaming you'll really be able to see the heat differentials and even the loudness of the consoles. The test you ran are great though gives me a general idea of what to expect. Thanks again for the video. Hope to see more
The PS4 is cooled by a General Electric CF6 turbofan. Very popular engine option on a Boeing 747.
120 f ohh... i love my xbox one, 2 years without any problems, i'm brazilian and here is very very hot, so many ps4 that had overheat in my state , sorry for my bad english
Quente é apelido kkk tambem tenho o one e nada de esquentar demais em 1 ano e meio
add lá, minha gt é brcaixista
Ohhh guys we have a fanboy over here
where ?
Your profile pic is Xbox one logo so obviously you are an Xbox fanboy.
this guy deserves more subscribers
thanks
Good job with the vids man, very useful I'm actually starting my own tech channel as well and hope people find it as useful as yours. Keep up the good work
Glad you like it!
good video.¿ which it is better ps4 or xbox one S?
hey man, just subbed and I think your content is great, keep up the fantastic work! Do you think you could do some Xbox one S controller giveaways as they are still quite new and look amazing. P.S, you really deserve more subscribers for all the effort and quality in your videos, peace!
Thanks man! We may be able to give away some controllers in the future.
Steve thank you for being concerned about the bodly noises in the video, as for me you don't have to worry about that. The video was very interesting. Epic video Steve.
Glad you like it!
Channel is coming up pretty well,very educative too.keep it up.
Yep...glad you like it!
34:15 'it's just 4 decibels.' If sound is 3 decibels louder, it's twice the volume.............
Great Video Brother. Im Subscribed
Thanks man!
Hi Tronicfix, I'm really keen to see temperature videos on the new ps4 slim and ps4 Neo. As I want to know which model will be the best to purchase. I would also be interested in a tear down video of each. As for the giveaways any and all would be cool. Thanks for reading my comment. I really enjoy your videos/channel :D
good idea for a video... I watched all the way, but too long...could've used more post editing too only show highlights of the console tests and the results
Send me that Xbox One S or Xbox One haha I still don't have a next gen console 😂😂😂😂 Good vid, good to know which is evil haha
My original xbox one is from 2014 and still works great. Just some issues with optical/disc drive. And CPU fan but nothing too hard to fix
I have the day one edition I changed the optical/disc drive like 2 years ago I have left it 3 months on to see what’s what and it’s been on now for a week with farming simulator on what a unit dude
I appreciate your hard working bro!💪👏👏👏
I miss videos like this
Just been introduced to your channel and had a flick through your content, looks quite good. Thumbs up from me
Thanks! Glad you like it!
Great video, really enjoying your channel guys, congratulations. Look im already bought a xbox one s, and mine does some buzzing noise in the fan, its always the same level of noise, never higher and never lower, but the fan doestn heat up by any means, even when i pay for long sessions, my xbox one s is from madden 17 bundle, and i just want to know if its normal, because i´ve seen some people complaining about it and sendind it back to microsoft. I cant do this because i live in brazil and i imported this xbox one s. So i want a little help if wont interrupt your great job by any means. Bless you all and thanks again.
I measured my own original Xbox One... The highest temperature in Fahrenheit that my IR reader caught while playing for about 2-3 hours was 112.5°F or so. This was today (May 20, 2019). I didn't find operating temperature specs for the original Xbox One from a trustworthy source (like Microsoft or the Xbox website), so I hope this information will help someone else out there.
Tbh all aging consoles need annual thermal paste replacements. Its unwanted, but prolongs the life, performance, and quiet ness (thats not a word xd)
Should I get a Xbox one s or a PS4 pro
Only you can decide. It all depends on what you like and what you're going for.
Michael Bob, depends on your quality and money.
Michael Bob No doubt, Xbox One S.
Michael Bob Xbox One S
Michael Bob depends on wht country you are in, if you are in America, then go for the xbox, since I live in Malaysia, I bought the Ps4 slim.
Weird to see an old video from you haha, nice anyway!!
the channel is growing fast !!!
Yep...almost 3k in the last 3 weeks or so.
It's hard to test the sound of the Xbox's accurately when there's a ps4 that sounds like a jet engine beside it. You can hear it in the vid
Awesome review Tronics and keep it up
Thanks!
love your videos for how technical are they about the consoles. i am very much concern about the heat the consoles generate. i have a very big concern if you can solve it. i want to know that how much hotter the ps4 1200 series is compared to 1100 & also the heat sink material they have used in both of them coz i think the 1200's is made of steel while 1100's in of aluminium. can you please check yourself by opening both of them & let me what material the 1200's heatsink is made of?? because the 1200 feels so much more hotter 1100 by touching the top part of the ps4.
hi.tronix.nice work keep going i hope you make test pushing both models to limit 1100 and 1200.to know accurate numbers.thank you
great video
Hey thanks!
love how it runs quieter while playing...good vid
Thanks!
My suggestion for a vid is to put new paste in the black XB1 in this vid and test it again to see if there's any difference and anther vid would be of the PS4 slim original paste and new paste with a teardown and so on.
Great idea!
A real test would be the same game for all consoles. Some games run harder than others. But I do believe the ps4 runs harder and hotter due to being a more powerful system.
This video reminds me when studying English in "English Course". Also, reminds me when studying at science classroom in My Senior High School.
I really Miss School. I hope after this pandemic, I can go to school again...
you just earned yourself a sub and a like 👍
Thanks for both!
+TronicsFix can you say HELLO to me and then i will subscribe and like
+Elias Ihalainen :)
great video keep it up. Would be interesting to see power consumption tests
Yes...I'll try to do those soon.
Prediction:
In order from hottest to coolest while idle:
1. PS4
2. Xbox One S
3. Xbox One
In order from hottest to coolest while playing:
1. PS4
2. Xbox One
3. Xbox One S
In order from loudest to quietest while idle:
1. Xbox One
2. Xbox One S
3. PS4
In order from loudest to quietest while playing:
1. Xbox One S
2. PS4
3. Xbox One
Ember THANK YOU MAN. The only reason I went to the comments was to see the scores
Ember ps4 loud while playing for me at least
Ember I don't understand questions 1 and 2
mrlabear crouse lol this was his prediction dummy
Number 3 is incorrect ps4 get very loud
I think you miss the room temperature just to check the delta! cool video!
I love the Xbox one s it’s so quiet I also like the way Microsoft made it smaller
Great video ; very informative! I do have a question though. isn't Need For Speed more demanding of a game than Need For Speed Rivals? that would have a huge impact on heat production, wouldn't it?
That's always possible.
YOU ARE THE BEST CHANNEL IN TH-cam MAN🖒🖒🖒🖒
Hey thanks!
TronicsFix no problem you deserve it ♡
Great Job you guys and digital foundry are the bomb!
Hey thanks!
Great video man . I'm subscribed
Thanks for the sub!
good video bro ....it would have been nicer if your marker was darker , it was slightly hard to read the text in the background...
The consoles while playing are cooler than it is outside
Hello, this is Sony Airlines how may I help you? Me:🤨
PS4 burns
+Neiva you're saying that like its a good thing...
remember this guy is measuring the exhaust air temperature not the actual core temps so you can't really compare to core temps on a pc
Yes, this is not a temp near the APU.
How much does a ps4 power supply cost mine don't work anymore and I don't know which one to get
Also is it possible for me to send in mine ps4 so u could fix it
And roughly how much would it cost
This all just depends on which model you have.
+TronicsFix Ps4 CUH -1116A
If that's what u mean
OK...what's the problem you're having with it?
+TronicsFix I turn it on and it's normal for like 2secs then it turns off
I read into this problem a bit and I think it's the power supply
Also I think it's just some components on the mother board just out of place because initially my ps4 broke because of falling damage
Very, very unlikely that it's the power supply. Most likely it has bad solder joints under the APU. With drops though, it could be other stuff as well.
The best soft soft tutorial ever!
always wanted to see this!
Haven't seen the rest of the video yet (only watched the idle temp test so far), but i think this test is already flawed. When measuring the ps4 and XB1s temp, the reader was around the same distance away. When measuring the XB1 the reader was practically right on top of the console. Would have been a fairer test if you measured the temp form the exact same distance from the exhaust for all 3 consoles.
Doesn't matter where the reader is. It's an infrared temp reader.
Ahhh. I did wonder that after i noticed the red dot, but then just thought that maybe the dot was just there to show where it was aiming, lol.
Xbox one is so quiet due to it being a big console with a decent cooling system and it’s power block really helps it keep quiet, your notice both the Xbox one s and ps4 are louder, but both have the straight lead no power block. So big factor it does help cooling and noise massively, is also good for the health of the console in long term how long it will last power block will help it being officiant and consistent. Being officiant and consistent is what will keep noise and heat down!
Good video! :) Congrats to the winner! :)
Glad you like the vid!
White ps4 looks damn😍
Should I buy an Xbox one 1 tb?
Oliver Hilario do not buy an Xbox box one,buy a ps4.But if you wanna buy an Xbox one,yeah,buy the 1 TB model
Oliver Hilario buy the xbox one s
Want to see more!Very good videos. Please show some three party made controllers.
Any suggestions?
I would like to see yo guys fixing the consoles that you guys receive for repair
I've thought about that but just wasn't sure if many people would want to see those videos.
Should I get an Xbox one or a Xbox one S which one would be better for gaming purposes
BTW which game r u playing on the XBOX ONE ?
Excellent video. Exactly what I needed to cool my av stand.
Glad this helped!
personally i found assassins creed unity the best for stress test meaning more heat and noise from xbox one original and ps4 as played on both. great vid btw
Yes, at some point we may do a vid where I play each for like an hour or so and see what the readings are then.
I just subscribed your channel is great
Thanks for the sub! Let me know if you have video ideas!
this was a really good video me decide what to get and decides to get xbox one s love this video nice video👍👌
Great video!
Which is worth for money?
Xbox one or Xbox 360 or ps4 or ps3 or Xbox one s
Totally depends on the deal you get and what you're looking for.
varun kumar xb1 s
I've always wondered if the temps are wrong due to the air flow design. For example the PS4 is pushing all of it's heat out of the console whereas the xbox one is pulling the heat up and away but I'm wondering if it's pulling up as much heat as it can. Plus as we see in this video the fan dB doesn't really change or go faster so the APU could easily be 120° and the fan can only pull some of that heat away from it hence why we see about 100° coming out. Of course I could be wrong but I've always wondered if that was the case.
Hey great video!! Does xbox one s still have coil whine? mine is making a slight whirring noise while playing digital games from hard drive. it is very low but i can hear it goes off when i shut down the game.
Haven't noticed anything yet, but also haven't played it much.
Beautiful video. Im subscribed
Thanks!
This is a great vid! Keep it up
Glad you like it!
good comparison for these consols.
Always knew Xbox One S and Xbox One was better.😊
subbed and when drifting in need for speed you must stay with the group to earn any points the video was also fun not boring thanks and I will be getting my Xbox one s soon thanks for the info
Fahrenheit readings FeelsGoodMan
I wonder what type of microphone comes with that sound meter? When you got quiet, I heard a lot of background noise. Wonder if that factors in at all?
I always thought that some mics just amplify quiet noises and automatically lower their sensitivity whenever something loud like sum1 talking comes in so it doesn’t clip the audio but idk 🤷♂️
Excelente vídeo, parabéns.....