ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2022
- Senior fellow at the Independent Women’s Network, Asra Nomani, breaks down her findings on the Depp-Heard defamation trial verdict, and how the media has framed this trial in relation to #MeToo.
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive
Johnny Depp winning is also a Me Too moment. So glad for him speaking out about his abuse.
Yeah...he will no longer be, Captain Sparrow..more like Captain Crybaby!
@@Caged63Man and why is that Amber fan? Have you followed the hearings? Listen to the audio recordings?
Ryan is incorrect here. It wasn't like there was a huge support for Depp initially so it's not like there were all these people looking for his innocence. The number of people that supported him grew as the case got presented. In the beginning Amber had most of the public support and Depp was cancelled without being able to tell his story while Amber got to film Aquaman 2. With the victory he will most likely be able to get movie roles again now that he is more popular than ever.
Women domestic abuse against men doesn’t get reported like men to women.. women casually hit men in frustration and think it’s okay and some men just allow it.
So glad Depp had his Me Too moment to talk about his abuse. More men should come out about it.
Yes!
female violence is more common, just less consequential
That’s totally true
Believe all women has got to be one of the craziest ideas ever
A better refrain would be "don't ever DISMISS women." Always take this stuff seriously and investigate like lives are on the line. It's really not hard.
@@anthonytwohill9726 Yes. Definitely.
Yup , believe nobody blindly..
@@anthonytwohill9726 reasonable prudence seems to always get hijacked - shameful the harm it ends up doing
@@anthonytwohill9726 how about don't dismiss allegations and take gender out of it.
Ryan, the reason this strikes a chord with so many women is that we're sensitive to being abused and then gaslit about it.
Well put!
Just stop making false accusations and then you'll have nothing to worry about
Ryan is gaslighter in chief. For details, see Jimmy Dore 's expose.
How sexist to assume that man is always the aggressor.
statistically the majority Times They Are
@@play030 no. A man is more often reported by women for physical violence. Women more often instigate (as reported by women themselves) and overwhelmingly women apply emotional, mental, and social abuse.
@@play030 check your stats.... compare initiator of aggression vs legal charges and gender discrepancies in reporting.
Asra Nomani has such a positive energy; it was a delight to listen to her speak.
Oh thank you Sebastiano - I try very hard to speak and act with good intention as a happy warrior now in life. It helps to have such joyful folks like Emily with whom to talk and be understood.
Great guest. She seemed very fair and balance.
Thank you, sir! We can be fair and further women’s and girl’s right without fomenting injustice.
@@AsraNomani Thanks for your input on this issue Asra. I want to say that I disagree with Ryan's take that the "mob" was in search of a case. Depp's support grew among people including media personalities as more facts were revealed and people deemed it safe to support him. Amber had all the public support initially and used it in an attempt to springboard her career. I think if go further back people were upset that in a case of he said she said, Depp ended up losing everything and cancelled from Hollywood while Amber was able to continue her career. I think that upset a lot of people.
@@AsraNomani Exactly......and if anybody is this court case was bad for women's right's it was Ambers lies and what ever women's movement, they should quickly make space to her, as we are all humans and we should fight together against all abuse, no matter who is the victim.
Clearly not a lawyer, or particularly well-versed in justice.
Anyone who counts on a mob to rectify the injustice of a mob is worse than a fool.
I was made a monster in Finland about 35 years ago, when in fact my Ex was the real monster.....in the court nobody wanted to give me a voice at all....she lie, made stories and try to set me up and she told my Mother, that she is going to do all she can to destroy my life and only because I took a divorce. Also what Ryan is saying, that 90% of abuse done is from men is completely wrong, and even about 2 years ago the Finnish official report from the police department told, that they had come to the conclusion, that in these days over 50% of abusers are women, but that men are shy to report it to the police because then they are kept in the society as looser and made fun of. Finland is a country with very strong Feminist movement, that has take over most of the politics and Media, so I'm sure that in USA the abuse is higher by men, but never and ever any 90% of cases. We are all humans and there are always going to be bad individuals no matter they are men or women.
I am amazed at this interpretation. To me this was a trial about Johnny Depp and Amber Heard. I am a female and I believed the evidence fell on Johnny's side. And I sure don't believe that a man winning once takes justice away from women. Every case should be treated independently.
I wish someone would've fact checked Ryan's +90%
seriously
Ryan gets it wrong so dam much. He is a liberal dinosaur that cites facts from the 90s
Yes Im sorry I didn’t know
Thanks to your guest, Asra Nomani for being fair and honest.
Thank you so much for your kind words. Fairness is what most of us want.
@@AsraNomani , absolutely !
I’m glad he won. These women need to be more accountable with their lies.
This lying chick just couldn’t stand losing.😃
Bad thing is many men are supports of those lies. Often men hearing about this will jump to white knighting for the woman out of some blind act of chivalry, when they don’t have a clue what’s going on.
@@losthighway5967 this is what happens when the left rejects due process.
I love her, thank you for having her on today.
Back at you ❤️
she did a good job!
Asra spitting nothing but facts
🖍
Totally failed to check Ryan on his 90% nonsense comment he just made up
@@R-vw3uz I didn’t have the data but will find it and write and record something!
@@R-vw3uz She rebutted in a much more profound, polite, and meaningful way. What she said in this interview, myself and many have been waiting to hear on a broadcast for 5 years. I thank her from the bottom of my heart and only wish she makes it on to other media outlets!!! Please, Asra, I don't say this with an ounce of hyperbole: THE COUNTRY NEEDS YOU!
The thing that sticks with me the most: what has happened to the ACLU???!!! What an incredible downfall, and so fast too!
Not fast. They've been corrupt for decades.
@@kcstewart671 maybe I wasn’t paying enough attention. I still saw them sticking up for the 1st amendment in some “controversial” cases up until around the middle of trumps term. Maybe I need to look into more of it before then.
Maybe having a reflex action that doesn’t involve considering facts but simply taking the other side to the crowd is not the way things are supposed to be since the age of reason since the 1700
Maybe that's especially bad when you're a journalist with a following
He simply said it was his initial reaction to be contrarian. I'm a contrarian too. Some people believe the mob mentality first (the normies we can call them). Either way that one is by nature one should always keep looking into things before deciding. I think Ryan does that.
Ryan you missed the point. And proving people point on Men being abuse isn't taking serious. And people getting falsely accused.
To add to your point, Men have a stigma on reporting abuse. It's difficult for any victim to verbalize abuse but Men also grapple with shaming and feeling as though it's emasculating by admitting it.
I would guess that Abuse on Men is wildly underreported.
@@Eujoung Thank you
“Ryan, you missed the point.”
Is anyone ever surprised by him missing the point?
Meanwhile, hundreds of people, everyday are denied due process in The United States. Unless your well off, you don't get your day in court
Yes we must fix this injustice
Yeah, I know two people who've been in jail 7 years without a trial. We recently learned that, if they'd had a good lawyer that was on their side instead of the court appointed ones that were friendly with the judges and DAs, they would have been out the first day. That's why I was so happy about this case getting so much attention; it's opened people's eyes about how hard it can be to get justice.
Ask men you know if they've been hit by a female partner, then ask women you know the same question about male partners.
Actually studies have shown that women are MORE likely to be the ones who throw the first physical punch when verbal abuse turns to physical violence - it's just that men are stronger on the whole and more deadly.
Women also tend to use slander and gossip as their form of 'violence' - so I'm glad he won because it was very damaging to his career and in reality that damage to his career, was victim-blaming.
He should now sue the producers of the movies which dropped him over her unfounded 'allegations'.
Can you share studies you find?
@@AsraNomani Here's a quote from an article in Feminist publication "BUST".
"Analyzing data gathered from 11,370 respondents, researchers found that “half of [violent relationships] were reciprocally violent. In non-reciprocally violent relationships, women were the perpetrators in more that 70% of the cases."
In addition, an analytic view of 552 domestic violence studies published in the Psychological Bulletin found that 38% of the physical injuries suffered in domestic violence disputes were suffered by men."
In one study of 1,100 lesbian or bisexual women in abusive lesbian relationships, researchers found that the women were more likely to have experienced domestic violence in past relationships with women than in their relationships with men."
However, what researchers also note is that domestic violence research is often problematic. This is because the data is often extracted from crime reports or crime victims surveys where, as Dr. Dutton explains, “men under-report more than women, and have been publicized as indicating domestic violence is a gender issue…In fact, when larger surveys with representative samples are examined, perpetration of domestic violence is slightly more common for females.”
In my opinion, if it was 50/50 that would be normal because we're all human.
Wow, they actually had on a guest contributor who WASN'T completely insane!
I’ll take the compliment!
@Jacob they have quite a few who arent, Asra was a great one but only one of many great guests
@@AsraNomani you should, you definitely earned n deserve it
I mean she was lying.
Johnny's over here showing men can be abuse victims here too. I see that as a win.
Thanks to Asra Normani for her take! What I think: I'm not sure Depp's massive support has necessarily a lot to do with the MeToo movement. I mean, certainly in some cases, because I've seen people happy it's exposing the problem with MeToo's "believe all women" motto. But I've also seen a lot of supporters who say they're still behind MeToo. It wasn't all Depp fans or "stans" (as many in the media keep insisting) because I've seen many who say they didn't like him before. Also, I saw a great many domestic violence survivors (both men and women) coming out for him because they identified with him. What it boils down to is that all sorts of different people supported him because his innocence (and her guilt) was so obvious. He had underdog status because of his troubles in getting the truth out, and everyone loves an underdog! For those on Heard's side, a lot don't seem to have even been following the trial, and it's pretty easy to spot them. Such as the "experts" the media's been trotting out to say this puts women back. Those still on her side don't want to give up on the "believe all women" thing and/or are the kind who supported her in the beginning and don't want to admit they were wrong.
Ryan would help his party the most by learning when to be quiet.
People don't mind defending women when they are victims. What we don't care for is going on speaking engagements against someone when you are also an abuser is not acceptable. Due to this is why women can now go to law enforcement and allegations be investigated. Let's be honest the me too spoke women were women that chose to stay silent for fame. The real victims of abuse of power were ignored in the movement. As for the fans showing up is ridiculous. Mobs outside courts is just weird. I get press but random people is weird.
Yep, there are plenty of women who speak up when abused and are dismissed. Yet women who while may be under duress exchanged s* x for favors are the true victims? Go figure.
I'm gonna cry. A voice of reason. It's like finding a unicorn these days ;)
❤️❤️ I know you were waiting for the other shoe to drop but I always ground my thoughts in conversations with my mom, who is truly salt of the earth.
I swear I almost shed some tears. I have been waiting to hear a voice like this for the past 5 years.
Washington post & ACLU should be held responsible also.
If you don't want an overcorrection -- then don't go overboard, in the first place.
there is a reason Federalist guests are always the best,
you can figure out the rest
Love her passion!
I know you want my jacket 🔥
Finally! Someone understands the male side! It's not just the one-sided issue. Things really are multifaceted and the mainstream media likes to take one side these days!
They destroy themselves when every woman against the right should be believed while backing every leftie accuse of the same things.
after suffering 4 days of BJG, it's great to hear Ryan's bumbling, stumbling, stuttering 10-minute questions...
Brianna is even worse
Victims triumphing over their abusers is not a rebuke of MeToo
"Me Too" & "Him too" cross a line when they go beyond supporting victims" right to have their voices heard & get their day in court yet ignore the "innocent until proven guilty" human right. I'm a DA & SV survivor who watched the entire trial, and feel offended by assertions that the internet &/or JD's fame swayed me. Amber does NOT represent me, and the only ill-will I feel about her is based on her continued insistence that she does! Hear all her audio tapes.
Why not bring up MeToo's coverup and protection of Andrew Cuomo? So disappointed all media refuses to talk about this.
Don't forget the Tera Read case
Yes that was the Time’s Up corruption. I wish I’d named it.
Great guest
Paraphrasing what Ryan said “so many women are behind Johnny Depp …. That’s disturbing”…. Why, Ryan? Women can see through BS and appreciate delivering justice regardless of the gender. Do you doubt that?
I normally respect Ryan’s opinions, but surely not in this case. He didn’t make any valid points. Women like Amber Heard hurt actual victims of abuse.
This get to the heart of the matter! hank you for covering this so thoughtfully and thoroughly. Great job!
Dude we've watched all of the evidence. It isn't a sign of meetoo going wrong.
It was that she was caught lying, that's it.
It's that simple.
👍
A win for all men. Finally!!!!
I ❤ ASRA, So very well said! 🇺🇸❤👏
Thank you and let’s show grace to Amber ❤️. She’s not well, the psychologists confirm.
@@AsraNomani 🙏 for Amber
Overall: 90+% the men are abusers in these cass?
I’d really like to see you look up the statistics instead of just guessing.
Last I saw it was much closer to a 50/50 split. Women are much more likely to be killed by an abusive man than the other way around, but when talking about abuse in general men are not overwhelmingly more likely to be the abuser.
Can you share any data sources?
@@AsraNomani there was a study in the UK that found 40% of men have experienced IPV. It was on the internet, will try to find it.
female abuse is more common, just less consequential
I like how the Women, who are on the correct side of this issue, basically ignored Ryan’s Wokeness. Great guest, very personable.
I agree with both sides. I want both men and women to get the justice they deserve; that means not automatically believing the woman's claims because her demeanor fits that of a victim, but also not dismissing her claims or refusing to take them seriously because the man in question is more powerful or likable. I hope everyone can agree to this.
And just one note, this DV in our own city was actually closer to 50/50, as per a police detective expressed at a meeting.
In which city?
What a fair take on this whole thing ! Nice 😊
Thank you, Fahad!
I expected to be annoyed by Ryan and he didn’t disappoint.
Thank-you Arsa great reporting.
Honestly to me, the Me too, was for survivors of DV, not just for women and this shows men are supposed to be a part of this too. As a survivor myself, this was a breath of fresh air for men too.
This was profound from Asra, and mirrors what many of us have been yelling at the top of our lungs for the past 5 years. Many of us were behind the idea of the metoo movement originally but came to absolutely HATE IT! It was the worst thing for the very civility of America and beyond. The movement spat in the face of 200+ years of many ppl who fought and died to give us "a more perfect union." It absolutely demolished and was antithetical to the fundamental principles for which we stand. It encouraged a "believe her" and don't require her to have proof, ALSO, don't question her or investigate at all. The ladder is why it was dangerous and despised by so many, black, white, Hispanic, Indian, and all.
I love this woman! Please bring her back!!!
This guy's hair-do is disturbing
the Paulie Walnuts wings
Could it be the he beside toxic masculinity there is also a bit of toxic feminity. Perish the thought.
Doesn't work that way. There is no culture of femininity that makes women "toxic" as in being unemotional or aggressive people. Men on the other hand have always been pressured by society to be tough, can't show any weakness, cant cry, you gotta fight if someone steps up to you, etc....
The final four minutes are the best reasoned take on this. I hope the big ideas discussed hear just doesn’t disappear
Thank you so much for telling the truth and doing real journalism...You guys are PERFECT :D
Yes I want to "Believe All Victims" but I need it to be established that they are victims first. Sorry, I am not an omniscient being.
The trial WASN'T news, it was a free mini series. It was ENTERTAINMENT! No nobody actors as judge, lawyers, experts and stand-in audience. A few Guest appearances, zoom video on YT? lol I don't see ads but I bet more money was made in advertising than either actor won, combined. LOL It WAS A SHOW!!
Great Segment! Lower state courts are flooded with domestic abuse cases of which the majority fall apart because people have discovered (mostly women, not always) that because of new laws, calling the police and claiming abuse gives them leverage in their pursuit of gaining complete custody control, gaining sole use of the domicile, or whatever their goals are. Of course there are impactful abuse cases, but they are very few among ALL claims. High levels of resources are utilized to filter through these cases and lives are disrupted for months and sometimes years.
It was the poop in the bed that tipped the scale, that's just deranged,,,
I don't see how this represents either side. They're both spoiled brats!
Wow. Incredible woman.
Thank you, dear Jean! What point resonated with you?
I was always waiting for Ashley Judd, Alyssa Milano, etc to comment on this and support Amber no matter what. I missed it if they did.
Of course Ryan is on team Amber 🤨
Well, . . . We are clearly not listening to a lawyer.
All of these numbers and statistics that I hear people say don’t make sense to me when I personally know and everyone I have talked to personally knows a woman that has used the threat of calling the police and domestic abuse to control the behavior of whatever man is in the relationship.
yep👍, the toxic underbelly of feminism is slowly being exposed. What you are stating is very real, and people don't report on it or study it because it does not fit the feminist narrative. But the truth always comes out; just takes time.
This woman is absolutely lovely. Such great energy
WOMEN have SONS who may have been falsely accused! But they are supposed to believe guilty until proven innocent? I don’t think so.
Any normal human knows today how evil women can be. We all have a neighbor, a friend, a sister, SOMEONE who is an absolute conniving b*tch. We all know these women. They're the first to be an 'Amber'. We are sick of it.
Great guest!
Men are the abusers more often then not…
Expect if the abuser is a teacher
Based on media… we have a national problem of female teachers being gRapey
Libs can’t stand losing a culture war.
This trial hit a nerve because many people know women who use the bias towards women in the courts to control their husbands and make sure they never leave them. Its a pernicious form of bullying and needs to stop. In sum, women weaponizing the courts against their husbands is a serious issue that needs to be addressed.
Ryan does not sound like a journalist at all.
Fact check: DV is nearly 50/50 across genders. Men tend to be violent slightly more often overall and more damaging when they are. Women tend to initiate one-sided aggression more that can (sometimes) lead to retaliation. By floating ideas that propaganda put in his head, Ryan became part of the complicit media in an ironic twist. Will we get a correction on his 90% statement?
Watched everyday back and forth between LegalBytes and Rakets.
She's awesome
Dave Chappelle predicted a back lash against MeToo
She was great!
Thank you!
I hope they have you on lots!
Anyone who counts on a mob to rectify the injustice of a mob is worse than a fool.
Many people stay in the constant cycle of abuse is because they cannot "leave". Most of the times the reason boils down to finances and whether they can make it out on their own. If one is financially independent, it is easy to leave and not look back. There may be other reasons, but finances seem to be most probable one. All the more reason to stay in school and build up a career.
There is real abuse. Then there are people who will use that fact to find an advantage for themselves. Human nature.
Fortunately, we have a court system where fact can be separated from fiction. (As opposed to the media where fact and fiction are often indistinguishable.)
Thank you for this video. It’s been on my mind for far too long, and I’ve been too terrified to talk about it. Verbal Abuse is a serious thing, and it comes from all genders & ethnicity- it is a human problem.
The justice for Johnny has been around years with very little following as it wasn’t fashionable to support him. Still her narrative was accepted by the mainstream media. Once they truth came out with the trial and people realized the extent of her liver he started having so much support. What Ryan experienced that if so many people support it something is wrong I felt it with the movement against him.
This lady 💯
90 % ??? Are you a real reporter ? In Europe you were fired NOW
So if you win the case it's truth if you lose its murky?
Exactly? Like how is it disturbing that women are supporting depp?? Should they support a women even if she’s wrong just cuz she’s a woman
Not always
@@stephenstrange4239 just when politically convenient.
What is goin on with Ryan's hair tho 😂👨
If women are perfect then why there so many Karen? Lol
Well Ryan!, the 'actual statistics' is roughly 50/50, the form of that abuse may vary widely but who is, or who isn't the abuser does not
Reality check and ethical input by a man of integrity-Ryan
They should have made it pay per view . Would have made a killing haha
This lady was awesome and very impartial. I hope they have her back on here again soon.
Beautifully fair & balanced take from Asra Nomani!
I hope everyone chills on the Amber trash talk because the world got a little too invested & crazy about this case!
Just hope to see Jack Sparrow in another movie in the future! 🏴☠️
Yes Amber Heard is unhealthy and we have to deny her the attention that feeds her pathology, as detailed by the psychological report, not to shame her but to urge her to get the help she needs so she can be a healthy mother and human being.
Absolutely! I’m neither team Heard or team Depp. I’m team justice. I hope Amber gets the help she needs for her child.
I’m not really a fan of the pirates movie but if he wants to do it…good…if not…let him live his best life. I don’t think Johnny wants to destroy her life to the point where she commits suicide. Hopefully, Amber gets help then maybe she could build her career again in the future.
Women accountability = Kryptonite
Another lack of trust thing.
Amber placed her bet on the fact that she's a women and that she automatically would be believed no matter what & now the truth is out that she is the true abuser. The 'Me Too' movement should be ashamed of themselves for siding with a lying sociopath & that aside, they should also include men who are victims of DV not just woman. If it's just a woman's club then that's sexist & proves how biased & hypocritical it is, sounds like it might just be a little Woke to me and a group that sides with the Cancel Culture Mob!!!
Absolutely, AH became the scape goat. Lucky for JD
I’ve watched some woman accuse boyfriends or husbands of abuse when they want out of the verbally abusive manipulation relationship
Some woman change once they have the guy
I’ve also seen men do the same
It’s scary how people hide their crazy until the relationship is locked in