This is a snippet from the full documentary - The Dark Side of Brahmin. I want people to explore, understand, question & learn the truth themselves, hence to maximize its reach , I uploaded snippet of that doc, here. Link to full video : th-cam.com/video/UoNJf2KPQis/w-d-xo.htmlsi=9Bnj5X-Ysz_DCRE3
project shivoham , i want to comment on your earlier video , you mentioned how the rishis made a theory on the creation of the universe as brahman turning from manifest to unmanifest( i even referred swami tadatmanandas video on vedanta vs big bang ) , while the theory leads to a lot of insights about self inquiry within and magnificent self knowledge and wisdom , it cannot be called scientific since it lacks evidence since we have zero knowledge about the state of the universe before the big bang, rest i highly respect your documentaries , you gave me the interest to delve deeper into our philosophy , i never know in my life that all of this is there like algorithms and cryptography , all i was told about spirituality is "water has memory"
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda one who realised Brahman is called a brahmin , you can know what is the meaning of brahmin more in chanakyas chanakya niti , but i dont quite agree to chanakyas definition , so yeah , "one who realised Brahman is a brahmin"
Everyone must study "Visuddh Manusmriti" edition by Dr. Surendra Kumar. It's a revision work on ancient Manusmriti where he after every chapters end of shlokas cited the reasons which shlokas & why are they later interpolations. Everyone is free to correct & add arguments. "Close the Bible & Open the Manusmriti" - Friedrich Nietzche It teaches the greatest aspect of the art of living and organising society in harmony with aspects of the Vedas. Jai AryaVart
As Dalit 💙 i tell hindus to follow their religion irrespective of what other people say to them they should not listen to non hindus Like dalits , muslims , Christians or any other groups . 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
@@varsha9546then what did the vehement opposer of caste system Ambedkar achieve by converting to Buddhism and dalits blindly imitating him and becoming neo baudhh..?!
@@meenu999 baba saheb is hero for sc/st community How ram was for hindus We have him . Ram= hindu ❤ Babashaheb= Dalits 💙 Jai shree Ram= hindu ❤️ Jai bhim = Dalits 💙
After much deliberation, I'm suggesting that your videos are qualified to teach people about Sanatana Sanskriti. This resource that you have nurtured and built over several years needs much more recognition and many more audience. For me, I refer to your channel to any friend or family who I think is in need for enlightenment regarding their culture and heritage without any hesitation and with confidence that they will learn what they must, including my Son. I watch with him.
Beautiful, as usual. Sir, there are only two Itihasas as i have heard and read- Ramayana and Mahabharatha but you included Baghavat Gita also in your lecture, although it forms part of the Mahabharatha.
Sir you should make a video on how contrary to mainstream narrative Lord Buddha from Hinduism(also known as Sugata Buddha and Adi Buddha)and Gautam Buddha from Buddheism are completely different characters from each other,it's extremely sad that 99%of Hindus still belive that they are the same only!,and explain did the original Buddheists intentionally copied our Lord Buddha and created a duplicate Buddha just to create a new religion out of him only?!🙏🕉️
I am not really concerned about what any particular person BELIEVES. You may believe that there is an old man with a white beard perched in the clouds, that the Ultimate Reality is a young blackish-blue Indian guy, that the universe is eternal, that Mother Mary was a certifiable virgin, or that gross physical matter is the foundation of existence. The ONLY thing that really matters is your meta-ethics, not your meta-physics. Do you consider any form of non-monarchical government (such as democracy or socialism) to be beneficial? Do you unnecessarily destroy the lives of poor, innocent animals and gorge on their bloody carcasses? Do you believe homosexuality and transvestism are moral? Do you consider feminist ideology to be righteous? If so, then you are objectively immoral, and your so-called "enlightened/awakened" state is immaterial, since it does not benefit society in any way.
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda Ara bhi Buddh toh originally ek Hindu Bhagwan hi tha badma tum Baudhisto na hamara Bhagwan Buddha ko copy karka ek duplicate Buddh bana diya aur uska naam sa ek dusra religion suru kar diya!,kyuki Buddheism ki buniyad ji ek bohat bara jhuth par tiki hui hai!
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda true , any philosophy should not be taken for its metaphysics , rather for the ethical value it brings in our lives , and that is what change vedanta brought in my life( i watched the serial upanishad ganga)
Dear Project Shivoham, can you please inform us on the most authentic publishers for our Itihasas, Puranas, Vedas & Upanishads, Agamas, Bhagavad Gita, Siddhantas and so on? Like, which publisher(s) give out the most accurate sanskrit text and most accurate translations. Many publishers tend to not be so accurate in either sanskrit verses nor their translations. I've been searching for the most authentic and accurate versions of our ancient knowledge for a very long time. So far no luck. Can you please help me out? 🙏🏻
Gita press gorakhpur. (The government of India recently awarded the prestigious Gandhi Peace Prize of 2021 to Gorakhpur-based Gita Press) - Please read reviews before buy
@@ChandraSekhar-er4ji IDK. Some are saying even gitapress isn't so accurate. The whole 'Karna is a suta putra' & 'Ekalavia is a dalit' are the kinds of things really make you question "are there any accurate versions left anymore?" I wish. But thanks anyway 👍
@@shanmukh747 Yes I Agree. Project Shivoham has already discussed Ekalavya. The main problem is we don't get all the information in one book. ISKCON English Bhagavadgeeta says SIVA is a Demi God.
@@ChandraSekhar-er4ji Yes I do agree that not everything can we get in one book. And argh! I hate ISKCON. Tried to read their Geeta revised version. So difficult and frustrating to read. Always about elevating Krishna. They're trying to make Krishna into another Christ figure. Claims like Krishna created Vishnu 🙄. Even Vaishnavites would be mad at them. Makes me think "are they even hindus?" I mean, it's not a Hindu way to proselytize to convert and only believe in one particular idol/god. That's an abrahamic way of doing. Not a Dharmic way. Never thought we Hindus would have missionaries of our own such as them. It's embarrassing.
Dear Project Shivoham (sorry for calling you that, I do not know your actual name), Now that you're going to make a video on the brief history of Parashuram very soon, can you also please talk about what makes someone an avatar of Lord Vishnu. I heard that there has to be around 16 to 64 qualities to be one. That they're called 'Kalās' or something. Can you please make an elaborative video on that?
Yes, Manu Smriti is the first law book codified by Manu Maharaj for Krita yug but only Parashar Smriti is applicable in Kali Yug. It was the foolishness of British occupiers who upheld the importance of the wrong Smriti for this yug!!
Sir can you please make a Hindi channel if possible. I want to send your videos to my parents and relatives. If any support is needed from our end then we will support you for it.
Bro you said uttara ramayanam is true but what happened to vedavati curse to ravana that she would become the reason for his death. Even in yuddha kanda ravana talks about vedavati. You also said that skandha purana is authentic it mentioned that agni deva replaced vedavati in form of sita and ravana abducted her. is it true. please give me the answer bro please
I NEED HELP. I want to read our entire knowledge base but can't find the literature and have little to no idea where to start...I don't just want to pick a book and start..I want to imbibe it.
I’m enjoying your videos. I think they are very informative and thoughtful. However, I would like to understand why the dharma sutras are labeled as shruti? Not sure if this is correct. The vedas are shruti and some actually believe that the samhitas are shruti rather than brahmanas, arankyas, and vedanta. But most would agree that vedangas, upavedas and beyond are smritis.
Sir thanks for this video. A small.request. Please give the right source of reading the vedas and other original texts...or suggest the best derived versions... pls help
People who dislike Manusmriti are ignorant. They never properly tried to read it. People behave like Brahmin is "high caste" but Brahmin are supposed to live like renounciants with extremely strict discipline. If a Shudra wants to be a Brahmin then simply adhere to the laws. I assure you a real Brahmin would recognise a "Shudra following laws of Manusmriti". We have changed Yughas and we must return to Manusmriti. Zoroastrian hedonists are misleading us.
The indegenious hater expansionists abrahmic (Massiah cult and Jihadi cult) and communist colonialistic cults need something to hate the natives to divide, rule, engineer poverty, make them dependent, convert and loot them and give some of it to their native brainwashed slaves which they call dalits or "lower caste". if they don't play victimcard of oppression by majority or by Brahmanas then they won't get reservations (free begged schemes from others tax money) who work blood and sweet and feed their families but these victimcard beherupiya imposters "Dalits" are sucking most of our blood of our families in the name of victimhood reservations beggings who can't stand on their feet and then these act as if they are religion of justice, equality and so on. so far western democracy, constitution, seclarism, western systems have failed us to provide security of existence against expansionist conversionist cults, failed to restore our gurukul eduction system, failed us to provide eqquaality, failed us to provide us what we deserve as our indigenous human rights which we call HinduRashra (recognition that this land belongs to Hindus), others invaders behave as if this country belongs to them just because of our level of tolerance. there are 157christian states, 67 Islamic states, 10 buddhists states, 1 isralie state, etc. but there is not a single Hindu state which is not even religious state just indegenious state. everybody in this world is racist towards, is enemy of our existence and against our basic human right which is our HinduRashtra. this world is evil and discriminatory and hypocrite.
▪️Acharya Medhatithi Writes On Manu Smriti 2.241,⬇️ “Though the term ‘non Brahmana’ denoting all the three castes, except the Brahmana, stands for all men, yet the Shudra could not be meant here; for the Shudra is not entitled to learn the Veda; and it is only when one has learn something that he can teach it. ‘But by transgressing the scriptural ordinance, the Shudra also might learn the Veda, just as the Ksattriya and the Vaishya do the work of teaching (which is not permitted).’ This also cannot be; because it has been laid down that is the Shudra happens to learn the Veda, his body should be cut up. And since the penalty is so severe, it follows that the act if a grievous sin.”
Sir please make a video on Satvik, Rajasik and Tamasik puranas. Should we only read the puranas that glorifies lord Vishnu. Why Vedvyasa maharshi wrote the other puranas if they leads to hell
Having attained the highest knowledge, whence every other knowledge is begotten, one is eternally elevated and no longer falls incessantly to lower realms! Keep up the good work!
😇अहिंसा परमो धर्म 😇 ahiṃsā paramo dharma (“non-harm is the HIGHEST religious principle” or “non-violence is the GREATEST law”). Therefore, only a strict VEGAN can claim to be an adherent of the eternal religion (sanātana dharma).🌱
no shastra makes it mandatory to be "vegan" , vegan is a modern term and has no bearing in our dharma . Vegetarianism does but this is mainly in shaiva and vaishnava sampradayas and in the initial stages of shakta too. But there are sampradayas which offer pancha makara to the deities , so it is wrong to say that "only a true vegan be a sanatani" . So please dont pread misinformation
I mean veganism clearly didn't exist back then while as long as u are not following a tamsic diet u should already be rest assured about it if and only if u actually care about your diet or u are from any such sampradaya which require such restrictions but u being a vegan is clearly your own personal restriction, no one is telling u to do it.
Vegan then Krishna himself will not be a Samatani, as he loved butter so much? Please don't make yourself fool oir Dharma allows us to eat anything that is for healthy results. Yes it prohibits meat eating but not Veganism.
i respect you and your work alot , no doubt but i noticed something you give citations and refrence of from where the shloka is taken but in the part of adi shankaracharya you didn't gave exact reference, my question is why ? you made them yourself ! PEACE
Viveka Chudamani is the book. And why are jumping to conclusions that I made it? I don’t care if you blame or praise me. But why are you blindly jumping to conclusions?!
@@ProjectShivoham thank you so much for this reference viveka chudamani, this book has been written by adi Shankaracharya and i checked verses in this theu don't support birth based varna system for example verse 43 of this book doesn't support birth!!!
*Completely agree with you. But unfortunately all the Trad Hindus including the Puri Shankaracharya, Jyotish Math Shankaracharya, Vallabhacharya followers, Madhavacharya and Ramanujacharya followers, etc. believe in rigid caste system.* *The goverment of India has brought a good initiative of providing financial assistance in inter caste marriages. We need more and more inter caste marriages for Hindu unity.* *Jai Shiva Shambhu.*
This is what Savarkar says- Breaking the prohibition of intermarriage does not imply forcibly marrying off girls of one caste into another caste. What it means is that if a hindu with desirable qualities such as love, character, and capacity to beget healthy offspring chooses a spouse from another caste, then such an alliance should not be condemned simply because their castes are different. Such a couple should not be considered as unworthy of cohabitation. Permission for such mixed marriages is extremely desirable not only for the removal of birth-based caste distinction but also for the success of the re-conversion movement. It is both beneficial and essential for the consolidation of the hindu nation. (1935, Hindutvache panchapran or The Spirit of Hindutva, Samagra Savarkar vangmaya, Vol.3, p. 85)
@@bodiminds6571 the trads justify it since the so called chandala was Shiv himself and Adi Shankaracharya realised it. It was not that anything of a caste unity and dismantling the caste discrimination
@@Hacktivist12 *It is not just Adi Shankaracharya. If you go to the traditional Mathas of Ramanujacharya, Madhvacharya, Vallabhacharya, Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, etc., then all of them believe in birth based rigid jati varna system.*
Everything is fine... But what to do to those who calls themselves bhramins... According to what you said here people should not call themselves bhramin right... According to what you said the one who born to a bhramin family is not bhramin... So the people who are sitting inside temple and calling themselves as bhramins are the culprits right... Without being bhramin they call themselves bhramin... So according to what you said it's high time we we find people from all the classes including Dalits who has all the qualities you said and put them inside temples and remove the people who are non devotional but just by birth calling themselves as bhramins... I agree to what you are saying first we have to stop the culprits from the temple then everything will be good in our bharath
In temples only 2-3 pundits or pujari we don't say them bhramins, in small temples only 1 pujari. And if you don't know then reached on it bcz I am know many of pujari from different caste.
@@vamsidaranwith all the proofs he is showing in this channel anybody can ask any questions ...but he's not here to answer he xplained wat he has to in those vdeos
Theoretically Vedas Upanishads teach great things. In today’s world there are a few people who can be called Brahmins Why there are differences Why Acharyas and Muttadhipathis not able to address the issue
Please make a separate video explaining Vedic knowledge system and all its components (as you explained the source of manusmriti). It will help our understanding and you need not to explain every time (atleast to your regular views and subscriber). ❤
guys, do not believe in propaganda and marketed stories. please type and search the below in youtube, and see the pm modi speech. "Surprise ! Narendra Modi on Tamil | Oldest Language| Older than Sanskrit"
You have great content onnyour channel and I am a big fan of you. But, I think there is a problem in the way you present the content. Not so clear to someone who is not familiar with the subject. I am sorry to say this.
Manu smriti is simly the memory of svayambhuva Manu. If we don't remember it and don't follow it, we are just digging our own graves. A person who doesn't even know the Sanskrit language was allowed to tear the manusmriti book (ambedkar). That act of him has made the studying of it prohibited, leave alone following it.
@@pradeephbmcribangwill that had made any changes regarding the contents and doctrines of manusmriti? Nevertheless, the fact that casteist discrimination, misogyny and untouchability were highly encouraged by this lawbook that is manusmriti which is a dharmasastra and many other shastras cannot be denied.
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155just as you say the word 'uppercaste' I can understand your knowledge of sanatana dharma. Caste is human made. Varnas are divine made. Chturvarnyam Maya srushtyam Guna karma vibhagashah - bhagavadgita chapter 4, verse 13
@@pradeephbmcribang lol it's like both jal and water are different as caste and varna are different 😂 ▪️Acharya Medhatithi writes on Manu smriti 2.241,⬇️ “Though the term ‘non brahmana’ denoting all the three castes, except the brahmana, stands for all men, yet the shudra could not be meant here; for the shudra is not entitled to learn the veda; and it is only when one has learn something that he can teach it. ‘But by transgressing the scriptural ordinance, the shudra also might learn the veda, just as the kshatriya and the vaishya do the work of teaching (which is not permitted).’ This also cannot be; because it has been laid down that is the shudra happens to learn the veda, his body should be cut up. And since the penalty is so severe, it follows that the act if a grievous sin.”
But my professor at our university said there are many citations where Vedas are discriminatory One of the examples our prof quoted was Vedas and said it also go to an extent to order to kill shudras and can be used by Brahmin, kshatriya as they wish Please clarify this. I want to know the answer from a practitioner.
One of the observing things was, while teaching about the kingdoms and history of it, they focus more on society, especially caste system. When there was discussion about architecture of Cholas, I asked how such a magnificent structure can be built without using Maths/Architecture( which is agamas). The reply was in just a few words saying something.( It was like, it was dropped from the sky). Idk why PPL do phds from renowned institutions and distort such a beautiful history
तथाकथित संस्कार, वर्ण और आश्रम व्यवस्था :- भारत मे दाहसंस्कार और विवाह संस्कार पाखंड से भर गया है, और अतिखर्चीला हो गया है, पंडित-पुरोहित और बनिया का फ़ायदा होता है और दाहसंस्कार और विवाहसंस्कार करने वाला आम आदमी आर्थिक हानि का शिकार होता चला जाता है, गरीब होता चला जाता है।
Sir we all know that the hero of Ramayana was non other then Lord Ram,then who was really the real hero of Mahabharat?!,I have seen so many people giving their theories on that so I really like to hear your thoughts on that topic as well,that video is needed!🚩🕉️
😇अहिंसा परमो धर्म 😇 ahiṃsā paramo dharma (“non-harm is the HIGHEST religious principle” or “non-violence is the GREATEST law”). Therefore, only a strict VEGAN can claim to be an adherent of the eternal religion (sanātana dharma).🌱
Yudhishthir Maharaj was the hero of Mahābhārata. Governance has been widely discussed in Mahābhārata and Rāmāyaṇa. A Dharmic government brings prosperity and wealth for all. Dharma can be applied in any field of administration. Anything that is logical and benefits a large group of people in a positive way is considered dharmic. When the head of Government follows dharma, then everyone in that land benefits. Why Yudhishthir was trusted to be a king by Bhagavan Krishna? Because he had a balanced dharmic personality and was the best administrator known in the world at that time. Let’s analyze some checks that ensured good governance for Yudhishthir. Economy: Yudhishthir was the best economist of his time. The rule of Yudhishthir made the entire land profitable and ensured growth of mankind in all areas of development. Security: There are three aspects of security - Internal, External, Spiritual. Internal: The best spycraft and policing is needed to ensure that people are secure. It is recommended to use a large number of spies to obtain information beforehand and act upon that. This ensures social justice to all. External: Govt needs to keep all enemies of state in fear. The enemies must know that any misadventure may have heavy penalties Spiritual: The State needs to maintain spiritual ideology to ensure justice based on a common ideology. Spiritual health and spiritual advancement is considered the highest objective of a state. While most countries of the world have a state ideology to protect, India is the only country in the world without a state ideology. Without ideology a state cannot differentiate and defeat its enemies Food: Usually food was never taxed. Only certain Alcohols and intoxicants were taxed after a minimum quota. Immigration: People’s movements across regions was recorded. Because that’s the way to understand demographics. Justice: Swift justice delivered quickly is the hallmark of a successful state. When the court takes months or even years to decide on important matters then it is the failure of the state. Slowly people lose faith in such court system and take decisions independently. In Yudhishthir’s courts and all other local courts, justice was delivered instantaneously. Education: State never interfered in Vedic education system which in turn was a teacher and pupil driven. Teachers received remuneration as per the pupil’s ability to pay. Teachers who were not able to maintain themselves were paid by the state. Graduates were easily absorbed by Administration and private businesses as per popularity and school recommendations. Healthcare: Healthcare was free for all just like education. Healthcare facilities were maintained by the state. Given the wealth and success of Pandavas, it is common sense to believe that Dharma brought them wealth. The credit goes to Maharaja Yudhishthir because he was the strongest leader.
Veda Vyasa has mentioned clearly who is the actual villain and actual hero of Mahabharatham Villain - Dhrutharashtra Hero - Lord Krishna Rest are characters
@@UjwalRam But I will always say that the real hero of Mahabharat was non other then Suryaputra Karn because- 1- He forgives hero mother for for abandoning him in the river to die. 2- he have given boon to her mother that he will kill her four sons only. 3- the best and most trustworthy friend of Duryodhan. 4- the greatest Philanthropist. There are many more examples for that but I have just given you just a few points!
Yudhishthir Maharaj was the hero of Mahābhārata. Governance has been widely discussed in Mahābhārata and Rāmāyaṇa. A dharmic government brings prosperity and wealth for all. Dharma can be applied in any field of administration. Anything that is logical and benefits a large group of people in a positive way is considered dharmic. When the head of Government follows dharma, then everyone in that land benefits. Why Yudhishthir was trusted to be a king by Bhagavan Krishna? Because he had a balanced dharmic personality and was the best administrator known in the world at that time. Let’s analyze some checks that ensured good governance for Yudhishthir. Economy: Yudhishthir was the best economist of his time. The rule of Yudhishthir made the entire land profitable and ensured growth of mankind in all areas of development. Security: There are three aspects of security - internal, external, spiritual. Internal: The best spycraft and policing is needed to ensure that people are secure. It is recommended to use a large number of spies to obtain information beforehand and act upon that. This ensures social justice to all. External: Govt needs to keep all enemies of state in fear. The enemies must know that any misadventure may have heavy penalties Spiritual: The state needs to maintain spiritual ideology to ensure justice based on a common ideology. Spiritual health and spiritual advancement is considered the highest objective of a state. While most countries of the world have a state ideology to protect, India is the only country in the world without a state ideology. Without ideology a state cannot differentiate and defeat its enemies Food: Usually food was never taxed. Only certain alcohols and intoxicants were taxed after a minimum quota. Immigration: People’s movements across regions was recorded. Because that’s the way to understand demographics. Justice: Swift justice delivered quickly is the hallmark of a successful state. When the court takes months or even years to decide on important matters then it is the failure of the state. Slowly people lose faith in such court system and take decisions independently. In Yudhishthir’s courts and all other local courts, justice was delivered instantaneously. Education: State never interfered in vedic education system which in turn was a teacher and pupil driven. Teachers received remuneration as per the pupil’s ability to pay. Teachers who were not able to maintain themselves were paid by the state. Graduates were easily absorbed by Administration and private businesses as per popularity and school recommendations. Healthcare: Healthcare was free for all just like education. Healthcare facilities were maintained by the state. Given the wealth and success of Pandavas, it is common sense to believe that dharma brought them wealth. The credit goes to Maharaja Yudhishthir because he was the strongest leader.
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda I do my best to live by Manusmriti. It has made a better man. It is backbone of law in the ancient world. Beyond that i believe Manu and our dharma. I know it to be true while still stuck in this illlusion. Manusmriti teaches me the amazing traits of a real brahmin. I aspire to be a Brahmin but still suffer sinful ways. I will do my best to live according to Manusmriti in this harshest of Yugas.
In a garden all types and colours of flowers r needed then only beauty of garden increases, Christianity and Islam(Semetic religions) ,tried to remove all other colors and they want only white flowers of their species, and then they fight among them that only my flower is right and not urs. Hindutva is colourful garden with freedom for everyone to believe anything and practice any practice, u may become Atheist, agnostic, one god believer, believing one god express himself in different forms, worshipping our ideal character in our heart,or multiple gods and one supreme god, Adhwaita, Dwaita, vishistadwaita , believing model saints, u may practice Bhakti yoga, karma yoga, Raja yoga/ yoga marga,Gnanayoga , practice them with combination of different paths/ practice any other paths of ur choice, still u r Hindu. Hindu is one who practice as per his individual belief, but must respect others paths, Swamy Vivekananda is the best explainer of Hindutva
In ancient times, personal occupation was chosen according to Guna (ability, eligibility) and Karma, but today that Varna system has been made birth based by the cunning Pandits, religious leaders and people in power, and many people have been forcibly kept away from education by saying that they do not have the right to study scriptures. प्राचीनकाल मे गुण (योग्यता, पात्रता) और कर्म के अनुसार व्यक्तिगत व्यवसाय का चयन होता था ,किंतु परंतु आज उस वर्ण व्यवस्था को धूर्त पंडित, धर्मगुरुओ, सत्ता के लोगों ने जन्मआधारित बना दिया, और बहुत से लोगों को बलात् शिक्षा से दूर कर दिया कि इन्हे शास्त्र-अध्ययन का अधिकार नही है।
Manu smriti was written and translated by English people in 18th century! Book talking about cow's meat! Or telling us if you don't eat meat from aahuti you will go to hell!
@@jhanvitharad3149 That’s what Geeta press Gorakhpur published in the translation. All passages which talk about what kind of meat is allowed and banned especially beef are the passages added by British Sanskrit schollars in early 18”0 s! That makes sense Manu the Bhagwan will never talk about sacrificing and eating even goat! Vedic people were pure vegetarian! Many English translator changed words ! Rigveda talked about coconut which western scholars changed to animals ! Same about soma rasa which was actually Gangajal! Same is belief of Iskon! Hare Rama Hare Krishna!
@@kumar9967 Manu of Manusmriti very likely was a sage or rishi! The Manu who predicted big flood and about Fish is believed to be Avtar. Ancient Indian smritikar etc had tendency to cheat and misguide followers assuming identity of Rigvedic Maharishis like Vashshta, via shwamitra, Ygnavkya, Manu. Ved Vyasa! Just to misguided uneducated Hindu masses! If they were born in this age they will be jail impersonating!
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
This is a snippet from the full documentary - The Dark Side of Brahmin. I want people to explore, understand, question & learn the truth themselves, hence to maximize its reach , I uploaded snippet of that doc, here.
Link to full video : th-cam.com/video/UoNJf2KPQis/w-d-xo.htmlsi=9Bnj5X-Ysz_DCRE3
Brahmin? What on earth is THAT? 😬
project shivoham , i want to comment on your earlier video , you mentioned how the rishis made a theory on the creation of the universe as brahman turning from manifest to unmanifest( i even referred swami tadatmanandas video on vedanta vs big bang ) , while the theory leads to a lot of insights about self inquiry within and magnificent self knowledge and wisdom , it cannot be called scientific since it lacks evidence since we have zero knowledge about the state of the universe before the big bang, rest i highly respect your documentaries , you gave me the interest to delve deeper into our philosophy , i never know in my life that all of this is there like algorithms and cryptography , all i was told about spirituality is "water has memory"
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda one who realised Brahman is called a brahmin , you can know what is the meaning of brahmin more in chanakyas chanakya niti , but i dont quite agree to chanakyas definition , so yeah , "one who realised Brahman is a brahmin"
Video is incomplete. Reupload brother
@@bodiminds6571what is the definition according to chanakya himself?
Everyone must study "Visuddh Manusmriti" edition by Dr. Surendra Kumar. It's a revision work on ancient Manusmriti where he after every chapters end of shlokas cited the reasons which shlokas & why are they later interpolations. Everyone is free to correct & add arguments.
"Close the Bible & Open the Manusmriti"
- Friedrich Nietzche
It teaches the greatest aspect of the art of living and organising society in harmony with aspects of the Vedas.
Jai AryaVart
As Dalit 💙 i tell hindus to follow their religion irrespective of what other people say to them they should not listen to non hindus
Like dalits , muslims , Christians or any other groups .
💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Buddhism also has Caste System same as Hinduism
But Dalits are hindus
@@varsha9546then what did the vehement opposer of caste system Ambedkar achieve by converting to Buddhism and dalits blindly imitating him and becoming neo baudhh..?!
@@varsha9546 I'm not Buddhist .
@@meenu999 baba saheb is hero for sc/st community
How ram was for hindus
We have him .
Ram= hindu ❤
Babashaheb= Dalits 💙
Jai shree Ram= hindu ❤️
Jai bhim = Dalits 💙
🕉️🅾️Ⓜ️ Na🌍 Mah🌊 Shi💥 Va☄️ Ya🌌🔱
🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🥥🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺
✨ఆరంభం⚡అనంతం⚡అఖండం⚡అద్భుతం✨
✨✨✨✨✨✨ అమోఘం ✨✨✨✨✨✨
✨ఆదీశ్వర్⚡ఆదిగురు⚡ఆదిశిల్పి⚡ఆదియోగి✨
🙏🧘🔱🔱🔱🕉️ఓంకారేశ్వర్🕉️🔱🔱🔱🧘🙏
🕉️🅾️Ⓜ️ Na🌍 Mah🌊 Shi💥 Va☄️ Ya🌌🔱
⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️⛈️
🔥
🔥 🔥
🔥🔥 🔥🔥
🔥🔥 🔥🔥
🔥🔥 🔥🔥
🔥🔥 🔥🔥
🔥🔥 🔥🔥
🔥🔥 🔥🔥
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
🔥 🔥
🔥 🔥
🔥 🔥
🔥 🕉️ 🔥
🔥 🔥
🔥 🔥
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡⚡
After much deliberation, I'm suggesting that your videos are qualified to teach people about Sanatana Sanskriti. This resource that you have nurtured and built over several years needs much more recognition and many more audience. For me, I refer to your channel to any friend or family who I think is in need for enlightenment regarding their culture and heritage without any hesitation and with confidence that they will learn what they must, including my Son. I watch with him.
Thanks
Hat's off to you sir
Doing excellent job
Beautiful, as usual. Sir, there are only two Itihasas as i have heard and read- Ramayana and Mahabharatha but you included Baghavat Gita also in your lecture, although it forms part of the Mahabharatha.
I have watched the entire documentary. But these parts help refresh and give us all more inspiration. Thank you
If i start learning from the first page what u have showed(library of vedas). How and where do i start....? Pls suggest something
Very Helpful 🙏🏼
Eye opening👃. Respect you a lot sir
The whole video was about manusmriti but you mentioned not a single shlok from it.?????????????why ??
Sir please make a video on the relationship between human physiology and Ramayana.
Each character represents a human organ. It's an amazing topic
Sir you should make a video on how contrary to mainstream narrative Lord Buddha from Hinduism(also known as Sugata Buddha and Adi Buddha)and Gautam Buddha from Buddheism are completely different characters from each other,it's extremely sad that 99%of Hindus still belive that they are the same only!,and explain did the original Buddheists intentionally copied our Lord Buddha and created a duplicate Buddha just to create a new religion out of him only?!🙏🕉️
I am not really concerned about what any particular person BELIEVES. You may believe that there is an old man with a white beard perched in the clouds, that the Ultimate Reality is a young blackish-blue Indian guy, that the universe is eternal, that Mother Mary was a certifiable virgin, or that gross physical matter is the foundation of existence.
The ONLY thing that really matters is your meta-ethics, not your meta-physics.
Do you consider any form of non-monarchical government (such as democracy or socialism) to be beneficial?
Do you unnecessarily destroy the lives of poor, innocent animals and gorge on their bloody carcasses?
Do you believe homosexuality and transvestism are moral?
Do you consider feminist ideology to be righteous?
If so, then you are objectively immoral, and your so-called "enlightened/awakened" state is immaterial, since it does not benefit society in any way.
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda Ara bhi Buddh toh originally ek Hindu Bhagwan hi tha badma tum Baudhisto na hamara Bhagwan Buddha ko copy karka ek duplicate Buddh bana diya aur uska naam sa ek dusra religion suru kar diya!,kyuki Buddheism ki buniyad ji ek bohat bara jhuth par tiki hui hai!
@@Anubhavsengupta1902, kindly repeat that in ENGLISH, Miss.☝️
Incidentally, Slave, are you VEGAN? 🌱
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda true , and in what i believe , women conquer the demons of life even which the so called gods fail to,(metaphorically),
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda true , any philosophy should not be taken for its metaphysics , rather for the ethical value it brings in our lives , and that is what change vedanta brought in my life( i watched the serial upanishad ganga)
Dear Project Shivoham, can you please inform us on the most authentic publishers for our Itihasas, Puranas, Vedas & Upanishads, Agamas, Bhagavad Gita, Siddhantas and so on? Like, which publisher(s) give out the most accurate sanskrit text and most accurate translations. Many publishers tend to not be so accurate in either sanskrit verses nor their translations. I've been searching for the most authentic and accurate versions of our ancient knowledge for a very long time. So far no luck. Can you please help me out? 🙏🏻
Gita press gorakhpur. (The government of India recently awarded the prestigious Gandhi Peace Prize of 2021 to Gorakhpur-based Gita Press) - Please read reviews before buy
@@ChandraSekhar-er4ji IDK. Some are saying even gitapress isn't so accurate. The whole 'Karna is a suta putra' & 'Ekalavia is a dalit' are the kinds of things really make you question "are there any accurate versions left anymore?" I wish. But thanks anyway 👍
@@shanmukh747 Yes I Agree. Project Shivoham has already discussed Ekalavya. The main problem is we don't get all the information in one book. ISKCON English Bhagavadgeeta says SIVA is a Demi God.
@@ChandraSekhar-er4ji Yes I do agree that not everything can we get in one book. And argh! I hate ISKCON. Tried to read their Geeta revised version. So difficult and frustrating to read. Always about elevating Krishna. They're trying to make Krishna into another Christ figure. Claims like Krishna created Vishnu 🙄. Even Vaishnavites would be mad at them. Makes me think "are they even hindus?" I mean, it's not a Hindu way to proselytize to convert and only believe in one particular idol/god. That's an abrahamic way of doing. Not a Dharmic way. Never thought we Hindus would have missionaries of our own such as them. It's embarrassing.
@@shanmukh747 🙏🙏🙏
Sat Nam, do you know who taught Rishis the Shastras and where? There has to be reaching point or the birth of the knowledge ❤🙏
Bhagvan this is like an ocean never ending subject One life is not enough learn I suppose. Jai Hind.
भाई आपका कार्य सराहनीय है
आपसे एक विनती है कि आपका यह ज्ञान हिंदी भाषा में हो तो आपके ज्ञान का लाभ लेने वालों की संख्या में वृद्धि होगी ।
धन्यवाद❤❤❤
Great explanation for common man. Much appreciated sir.
Dear Project Shivoham (sorry for calling you that, I do not know your actual name), Now that you're going to make a video on the brief history of Parashuram very soon, can you also please talk about what makes someone an avatar of Lord Vishnu. I heard that there has to be around 16 to 64 qualities to be one. That they're called 'Kalās' or something. Can you please make an elaborative video on that?
Please note. Satyameva Jayate is in Pali.
The sanskrit version is understood to be
Satyameva jayati.
Sir you are doing a great job 👏👏🙏🙏
Thank you so much for this video as well as for all other videos with so much organised knowledge of our civilisation/ Sanatana Dharma. 🙏🏽
Well done. People like is utmost important for Sanathana Dharma. God bless you always.
Namaskaram Project Shivoham
You also need to clarify the difference between "jaati" and "varna" . Both are mistakenly translated as "caste"
🙏🏼
Chatur varnyan -Bhagavad Gita chapter 4 sloka 13. & chapter-18 sloka-41
Who is a Brahmin?
Bhagavad Gita chapter 18 sloka-42
Manusmriti says ब्रह्म जानाति ब्रह्मणः which means, the one who knows Bramha/Brahma is a Bramhana/Brahmana.
i want video on "Caste System" in "Buddhism". In buddhism also caste system same as in Hindunism.
@@varsha9546
th-cam.com/video/6ATmowQ_KT8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=TpjaurR-gokfhAbp
Satya Sanatan Hindu Dharam ki Jai
Quality content!
Thank you for all your videos. Thank you for enlightening us with this knowledge. 🙏
I think you should have pronounced it as "VajraSoochi" rather than "VajraSuchi".
Right explanation ❤❤❤
Sir, is it true that Parashara smrithi applies to Kaliyug?
all smrits applies to all yugas..
@@bhargav3350 Ok 🙏
All are applicable but paaraashar smriti is recommended for kali yug
@@Kukhyaati thankyou 🙏
Yes, Manu Smriti is the first law book codified by Manu Maharaj for Krita yug but only Parashar Smriti is applicable in Kali Yug. It was the foolishness of British occupiers who upheld the importance of the wrong Smriti for this yug!!
Sir can you please make a Hindi channel if possible. I want to send your videos to my parents and relatives. If any support is needed from our end then we will support you for it.
Hi Anna! I am studying a Samskrit based profession. So, i want to know the importance of vyutpatti. What is the need to study that???
Bro you said uttara ramayanam is true but what happened to vedavati curse to ravana that she would become the reason for his death. Even in yuddha kanda ravana talks about vedavati. You also said that skandha purana is authentic it mentioned that agni deva replaced vedavati in form of sita and ravana abducted her. is it true. please give me the answer bro please
Very well explened sir. Thanks a ton.❤❤❤❤
Hi Sir
Request you to kindly suggest online book to read Manusmriti and Vajrasuchi.
Hari Aum Tat Sat 🙏🏻💮
A kind request :
Pls find resource people to translate in different languages across India and abroad. Pls publish it in all possible languages 🙏
I NEED HELP. I want to read our entire knowledge base but can't find the literature and have little to no idea where to start...I don't just want to pick a book and start..I want to imbibe it.
I’m enjoying your videos. I think they are very informative and thoughtful. However, I would like to understand why the dharma sutras are labeled as shruti? Not sure if this is correct. The vedas are shruti and some actually believe that the samhitas are shruti rather than brahmanas, arankyas, and vedanta. But most would agree that vedangas, upavedas and beyond are smritis.
Why the Shankaracharyas today doing politics and not doing anything for Hindus and Hinduism. Hindus are leaving Dharma but they don't care
Sir thanks for this video.
A small.request.
Please give the right source of reading the vedas and other original texts...or suggest the best derived versions... pls help
Sir,
Heartfulness meditation kanha shanthi vanam Master Daaji Spiritual anatomy
Indepth research 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉....... Thank you sir.........
Om namah shivaya 🌺
good video...please make a new dedicated video on manusmriti debunking the lies of bhimtas.
Bhrata shri please tell me where should I start
i want video on "Caste System" in "Buddhism". In buddhism also caste system same as in Hindunism.
@@varsha9546 I guess they used the system without much corruption so people don't even care about buddhism having such divisions.
Extremely Good,thanks
Fantastic, thank you very much 🙏
People who dislike Manusmriti are ignorant.
They never properly tried to read it.
People behave like Brahmin is "high caste" but Brahmin are supposed to live like renounciants with extremely strict discipline.
If a Shudra wants to be a Brahmin then simply adhere to the laws.
I assure you a real Brahmin would recognise a "Shudra following laws of Manusmriti".
We have changed Yughas and we must return to Manusmriti.
Zoroastrian hedonists are misleading us.
Bullshit at its peak
The indegenious hater expansionists abrahmic (Massiah cult and Jihadi cult) and communist colonialistic cults need something to hate the natives to divide, rule, engineer poverty, make them dependent, convert and loot them and give some of it to their native brainwashed slaves which they call dalits or "lower caste". if they don't play victimcard of oppression by majority or by Brahmanas then they won't get reservations (free begged schemes from others tax money) who work blood and sweet and feed their families but these victimcard beherupiya imposters "Dalits" are sucking most of our blood of our families in the name of victimhood reservations beggings who can't stand on their feet and then these act as if they are religion of justice, equality and so on. so far western democracy, constitution, seclarism, western systems have failed us to provide security of existence against expansionist conversionist cults, failed to restore our gurukul eduction system, failed us to provide eqquaality, failed us to provide us what we deserve as our indigenous human rights which we call HinduRashra (recognition that this land belongs to Hindus), others invaders behave as if this country belongs to them just because of our level of tolerance. there are 157christian states, 67 Islamic states, 10 buddhists states, 1 isralie state, etc. but there is not a single Hindu state which is not even religious state just indegenious state. everybody in this world is racist towards, is enemy of our existence and against our basic human right which is our HinduRashtra. this world is evil and discriminatory and hypocrite.
▪️Acharya Medhatithi Writes On Manu Smriti 2.241,⬇️
“Though the term ‘non Brahmana’ denoting all the three castes, except the Brahmana, stands for all men, yet the Shudra could not be meant here; for the Shudra is not entitled to learn the Veda; and it is only when one has learn something that he can teach it. ‘But by transgressing the scriptural ordinance, the Shudra also might learn the Veda, just as the Ksattriya and the Vaishya do the work of teaching (which is not permitted).’ This also cannot be; because it has been laid down that is the Shudra happens to learn the Veda, his body should be cut up. And since the penalty is so severe, it follows that the act if a grievous sin.”
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 Quote the Manusmriti and not a critique.
Where does Manusmriti say a Shudra must be cut for studying the Vedas?
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 Buddhism also has Caste System same as Hinduism
100th like on this video ! Keep up the good work
Sir please make a video on Satvik, Rajasik and Tamasik puranas. Should we only read the puranas that glorifies lord Vishnu. Why Vedvyasa maharshi wrote the other puranas if they leads to hell
Try Hindi subtitles too to get a wider audience
Kalpa word.. I heard as process. But for what you call as "kalpa" - is called as "prayoga paatha" in teachings I have heard.
Having attained the highest knowledge, whence every other knowledge is begotten, one is eternally elevated and no longer falls incessantly to lower realms!
Keep up the good work!
Aum Sanaatana dharma ki jai
Satyameva jayathe
Aum Aum Aum Aum Aum
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thank। You blessings & love!🙏🌞🙌🌿💚🤗
Varna system is skewed so much the deeper meaning and message is lost somewhere in translation
Great efforts
😇अहिंसा परमो धर्म 😇
ahiṃsā paramo dharma
(“non-harm is the HIGHEST religious principle” or “non-violence is the GREATEST law”).
Therefore, only a strict VEGAN can claim to be an adherent of the eternal religion (sanātana dharma).🌱
agreed
no shastra makes it mandatory to be "vegan" , vegan is a modern term and has no bearing in our dharma . Vegetarianism does but this is mainly in shaiva and vaishnava sampradayas and in the initial stages of shakta too. But there are sampradayas which offer pancha makara to the deities , so it is wrong to say that "only a true vegan be a sanatani" . So please dont pread misinformation
I mean veganism clearly didn't exist back then while as long as u are not following a tamsic diet u should already be rest assured about it if and only if u actually care about your diet or u are from any such sampradaya which require such restrictions but u being a vegan is clearly your own personal restriction, no one is telling u to do it.
Veganism is utterly non-sensical and stupid
Vegan then Krishna himself will not be a Samatani, as he loved butter so much?
Please don't make yourself fool oir Dharma allows us to eat anything that is for healthy results.
Yes it prohibits meat eating but not Veganism.
Hello guru Telugu lo upload cheyandi Guru
i respect you and your work alot , no doubt but i noticed something you give citations and refrence of from where the shloka is taken but in the part of adi shankaracharya you didn't gave exact reference, my question is why ? you made them yourself ! PEACE
Which Sholka you are referring to?
@@ProjectShivoham in the end where adi shankara answers who is a brahmin? you didnt give reference of that bro from the same upnishad.
Viveka Chudamani is the book. And why are jumping to conclusions that I made it? I don’t care if you blame or praise me. But why are you blindly jumping to conclusions?!
@@ProjectShivoham thank you so much for this reference viveka chudamani, this book has been written by adi Shankaracharya and i checked verses in this theu don't support birth based varna system for example verse 43 of this book doesn't support birth!!!
*Completely agree with you. But unfortunately all the Trad Hindus including the Puri Shankaracharya, Jyotish Math Shankaracharya, Vallabhacharya followers, Madhavacharya and Ramanujacharya followers, etc. believe in rigid caste system.*
*The goverment of India has brought a good initiative of providing financial assistance in inter caste marriages. We need more and more inter caste marriages for Hindu unity.*
*Jai Shiva Shambhu.*
This is what Savarkar says-
Breaking the prohibition of intermarriage does not imply forcibly marrying off girls of one caste into another caste. What it means is that if a hindu with desirable qualities such as love, character, and capacity to beget healthy offspring chooses a spouse from another caste, then such an alliance should not be condemned simply because their castes are different. Such a couple should not be considered as unworthy of cohabitation.
Permission for such mixed marriages is extremely desirable not only for the removal of birth-based caste distinction but also for the success of the re-conversion movement. It is both beneficial and essential for the consolidation of the hindu nation. (1935, Hindutvache panchapran or The Spirit of Hindutva, Samagra Savarkar vangmaya, Vol.3, p. 85)
Adi Shankaracharya's commentary is the source of caste discrimination in Hinduism.
@@Hacktivist12 what about adi shankaras encounter with a chandala , have you read that , or are you making baseless claims without evidence
@@bodiminds6571 the trads justify it since the so called chandala was Shiv himself and Adi Shankaracharya realised it. It was not that anything of a caste unity and dismantling the caste discrimination
@@Hacktivist12 *It is not just Adi Shankaracharya. If you go to the traditional Mathas of Ramanujacharya, Madhvacharya, Vallabhacharya, Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, etc., then all of them believe in birth based rigid jati varna system.*
Thanks now I'm more confident about Sanatandharma christian missionary convert people through propagating false manusmriti
Very good
create a Hindi channel and also a Twitter handle.
Keep up the good work 🫡
Sir Please make this vedio in Telugu, so that many view this and understand
Everything is fine... But what to do to those who calls themselves bhramins... According to what you said here people should not call themselves bhramin right... According to what you said the one who born to a bhramin family is not bhramin... So the people who are sitting inside temple and calling themselves as bhramins are the culprits right... Without being bhramin they call themselves bhramin... So according to what you said it's high time we we find people from all the classes including Dalits who has all the qualities you said and put them inside temples and remove the people who are non devotional but just by birth calling themselves as bhramins... I agree to what you are saying first we have to stop the culprits from the temple then everything will be good in our bharath
In temples only 2-3 pundits or pujari we don't say them bhramins, in small temples only 1 pujari. And if you don't know then reached on it bcz I am know many of pujari from different caste.
U can't ask such smart questions.. In this channel
@@vamsidaranwith all the proofs he is showing in this channel anybody can ask any questions ...but he's not here to answer he xplained wat he has to in those vdeos
Theoretically Vedas Upanishads teach great things. In today’s world there are a few people who can be called Brahmins
Why there are differences
Why Acharyas and Muttadhipathis not able to address the issue
Please make a separate video explaining Vedic knowledge system and all its components (as you explained the source of manusmriti). It will help our understanding and you need not to explain every time (atleast to your regular views and subscriber). ❤
Search for Brief History of Vedas by Project Shivoham. It is made few years ago
@@arvynd7627 I have seen that one but it was not that deep. It was just like an overview.
Hari bol 🙏
❤❤❤
Excellent
हर हर महादेव🙏🙏
Swayambu garu manchi programs conduct chestunnaru, panchagavyam tragi kamakya tantra sadhana chesko inko swayambu tho kalsi
Nee peetha burra ki ikkada ym Pani..😂
Nice information
8:59 No Ambedkar has been hurt.
guys, do not believe in propaganda and marketed stories.
please type and search the below in youtube, and see the pm modi speech.
"Surprise ! Narendra Modi on Tamil | Oldest Language| Older than Sanskrit"
You have great content onnyour channel and I am a big fan of you. But, I think there is a problem in the way you present the content. Not so clear to someone who is not familiar with the subject. I am sorry to say this.
💛🔥🙌
Thanks!
Manu smriti is simly the memory of svayambhuva Manu. If we don't remember it and don't follow it, we are just digging our own graves.
A person who doesn't even know the Sanskrit language was allowed to tear the manusmriti book (ambedkar).
That act of him has made the studying of it prohibited, leave alone following it.
@@pradeephbmcribang lol Dr Ambedkar knew Sanskrit, he had learnt it with many hardships despite the backlash and oppressions from the upper castes
Oh is it? Then why did he tear the English translated version of manusmriti on the day of Christmas? Why not on deepavali or Dusshera?
@@pradeephbmcribangwill that had made any changes regarding the contents and doctrines of manusmriti?
Nevertheless, the fact that casteist discrimination, misogyny and untouchability were highly encouraged by this lawbook that is manusmriti which is a dharmasastra and many other shastras cannot be denied.
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155just as you say the word 'uppercaste' I can understand your knowledge of sanatana dharma. Caste is human made. Varnas are divine made. Chturvarnyam Maya srushtyam Guna karma vibhagashah - bhagavadgita chapter 4, verse 13
@@pradeephbmcribang lol it's like both jal and water are different as caste and varna are different 😂
▪️Acharya Medhatithi writes on Manu smriti 2.241,⬇️
“Though the term ‘non brahmana’ denoting all the three castes, except the brahmana, stands for all men, yet the shudra could not be meant here; for the shudra is not entitled to learn the veda; and it is only when one has learn something that he can teach it. ‘But by transgressing the scriptural ordinance, the shudra also might learn the veda, just as the kshatriya and the vaishya do the work of teaching (which is not permitted).’ This also cannot be; because it has been laid down that is the shudra happens to learn the veda, his body should be cut up. And since the penalty is so severe, it follows that the act if a grievous sin.”
Thanks sir🙏
But my professor at our university said there are many citations where Vedas are discriminatory
One of the examples our prof quoted was Vedas and said it also go to an extent to order to kill shudras and can be used by Brahmin, kshatriya as they wish
Please clarify this. I want to know the answer from a practitioner.
Citations or Reference? Ask your professor to quote verses, context and Bhashya by renowned Bhashyakaras.
lmao it is easy to quote out of context. Please share the quote that Mleccha professor of yours said. let's see what it says
One of the observing things was, while teaching about the kingdoms and history of it, they focus more on society, especially caste system. When there was discussion about architecture of Cholas, I asked how such a magnificent structure can be built without using Maths/Architecture( which is agamas). The reply was in just a few words saying something.( It was like, it was dropped from the sky). Idk why PPL do phds from renowned institutions and distort such a beautiful history
In Buddhism also has Caste System same as in Hinduism
तथाकथित संस्कार, वर्ण और आश्रम व्यवस्था :- भारत मे दाहसंस्कार और विवाह संस्कार
पाखंड से भर गया है, और अतिखर्चीला हो गया है, पंडित-पुरोहित और बनिया का फ़ायदा होता है और दाहसंस्कार और विवाहसंस्कार करने वाला आम आदमी आर्थिक हानि का शिकार होता चला जाता है, गरीब होता चला जाता है।
Sir we all know that the hero of Ramayana was non other then Lord Ram,then who was really the real hero of Mahabharat?!,I have seen so many people giving their theories on that so I really like to hear your thoughts on that topic as well,that video is needed!🚩🕉️
😇अहिंसा परमो धर्म 😇
ahiṃsā paramo dharma
(“non-harm is the HIGHEST religious principle” or “non-violence is the GREATEST law”).
Therefore, only a strict VEGAN can claim to be an adherent of the eternal religion (sanātana dharma).🌱
Yudhishthir Maharaj was the hero of Mahābhārata.
Governance has been widely discussed in Mahābhārata and Rāmāyaṇa. A Dharmic government brings prosperity and wealth for all. Dharma can be applied in any field of administration. Anything that is logical and benefits a large group of people in a positive way is considered dharmic. When the head of Government follows dharma, then everyone in that land benefits. Why Yudhishthir was trusted to be a king by Bhagavan Krishna? Because he had a balanced dharmic personality and was the best administrator known in the world at that time. Let’s analyze some checks that ensured good governance for Yudhishthir.
Economy: Yudhishthir was the best economist of his time. The rule of Yudhishthir made the entire land profitable and ensured growth of mankind in all areas of development.
Security: There are three aspects of security - Internal, External, Spiritual.
Internal: The best spycraft and policing is needed to ensure that people are secure. It is recommended to use a large number of spies to obtain information beforehand and act upon that. This ensures social justice to all.
External: Govt needs to keep all enemies of state in fear. The enemies must know that any misadventure may have heavy penalties
Spiritual: The State needs to maintain spiritual ideology to ensure justice based on a common ideology. Spiritual health and spiritual advancement is considered the highest objective of a state. While most countries of the world have a state ideology to protect, India is the only country in the world without a state ideology. Without ideology a state cannot differentiate and defeat its enemies
Food: Usually food was never taxed. Only certain Alcohols and intoxicants were taxed after a minimum quota.
Immigration: People’s movements across regions was recorded. Because that’s the way to understand demographics.
Justice: Swift justice delivered quickly is the hallmark of a successful state. When the court takes months or even years to decide on important matters then it is the failure of the state. Slowly people lose faith in such court system and take decisions independently. In Yudhishthir’s courts and all other local courts, justice was delivered instantaneously.
Education: State never interfered in Vedic education system which in turn was a teacher and pupil driven. Teachers received remuneration as per the pupil’s ability to pay. Teachers who were not able to maintain themselves were paid by the state. Graduates were easily absorbed by Administration and private businesses as per popularity and school recommendations.
Healthcare: Healthcare was free for all just like education. Healthcare facilities were maintained by the state.
Given the wealth and success of Pandavas, it is common sense to believe that Dharma brought them wealth. The credit goes to Maharaja Yudhishthir because he was the strongest leader.
Veda Vyasa has mentioned clearly who is the actual villain and actual hero of Mahabharatham
Villain - Dhrutharashtra
Hero - Lord Krishna
Rest are characters
@@UjwalRam But I will always say that the real hero of Mahabharat was non other then Suryaputra Karn because-
1- He forgives hero mother for for abandoning him in the river to die.
2- he have given boon to her mother that he will kill her four sons only.
3- the best and most trustworthy friend of Duryodhan.
4- the greatest Philanthropist.
There are many more examples for that but I have just given you just a few points!
Yudhishthir Maharaj was the hero of Mahābhārata.
Governance has been widely discussed in Mahābhārata and Rāmāyaṇa. A dharmic government brings prosperity and wealth for all. Dharma can be applied in any field of administration. Anything that is logical and benefits a large group of people in a positive way is considered dharmic. When the head of Government follows dharma, then everyone in that land benefits. Why Yudhishthir was trusted to be a king by Bhagavan Krishna? Because he had a balanced dharmic personality and was the best administrator known in the world at that time. Let’s analyze some checks that ensured good governance for Yudhishthir.
Economy: Yudhishthir was the best economist of his time. The rule of Yudhishthir made the entire land profitable and ensured growth of mankind in all areas of development.
Security: There are three aspects of security - internal, external, spiritual.
Internal: The best spycraft and policing is needed to ensure that people are secure. It is recommended to use a large number of spies to obtain information beforehand and act upon that. This ensures social justice to all.
External: Govt needs to keep all enemies of state in fear. The enemies must know that any misadventure may have heavy penalties
Spiritual: The state needs to maintain spiritual ideology to ensure justice based on a common ideology. Spiritual health and spiritual advancement is considered the highest objective of a state. While most countries of the world have a state ideology to protect, India is the only country in the world without a state ideology. Without ideology a state cannot differentiate and defeat its enemies
Food: Usually food was never taxed. Only certain alcohols and intoxicants were taxed after a minimum quota.
Immigration: People’s movements across regions was recorded. Because that’s the way to understand demographics.
Justice: Swift justice delivered quickly is the hallmark of a successful state. When the court takes months or even years to decide on important matters then it is the failure of the state. Slowly people lose faith in such court system and take decisions independently. In Yudhishthir’s courts and all other local courts, justice was delivered instantaneously.
Education: State never interfered in vedic education system which in turn was a teacher and pupil driven. Teachers received remuneration as per the pupil’s ability to pay. Teachers who were not able to maintain themselves were paid by the state. Graduates were easily absorbed by Administration and private businesses as per popularity and school recommendations.
Healthcare: Healthcare was free for all just like education. Healthcare facilities were maintained by the state.
Given the wealth and success of Pandavas, it is common sense to believe that dharma brought them wealth. The credit goes to Maharaja Yudhishthir because he was the strongest leader.
I never knew about anything else besides Manusmiriti
I love Manusmriti
Because?
@@JagadguruSvamiVegananda I do my best to live by Manusmriti. It has made a better man. It is backbone of law in the ancient world.
Beyond that i believe Manu and our dharma. I know it to be true while still stuck in this illlusion.
Manusmriti teaches me the amazing traits of a real brahmin.
I aspire to be a Brahmin but still suffer sinful ways. I will do my best to live according to Manusmriti in this harshest of Yugas.
@@IXXILordFibonacciIXXI i want video on "Caste System" in "Buddhism". In buddhism also caste system same as in Hindunism.
In a garden all types and colours of flowers r needed then only beauty of garden increases, Christianity and Islam(Semetic religions) ,tried to remove all other colors and they want only white flowers of their species, and then they fight among them that only my flower is right and not urs.
Hindutva is colourful garden with freedom for everyone to believe anything and practice any practice, u may become Atheist, agnostic, one god believer, believing one god express himself in different forms, worshipping our ideal character in our heart,or multiple gods and one supreme god, Adhwaita, Dwaita, vishistadwaita , believing model saints, u may practice Bhakti yoga, karma yoga, Raja yoga/ yoga marga,Gnanayoga , practice them with combination of different paths/ practice any other paths of ur choice, still u r Hindu.
Hindu is one who practice as per his individual belief, but must respect others paths,
Swamy Vivekananda is the best explainer of Hindutva
Thelugulo cheyyandi please🙏
Sir Kindly dub videos instead of making separate Telugu videos
In ancient times, personal occupation was chosen according to Guna (ability, eligibility) and Karma, but today that Varna system has been made birth based by the cunning Pandits, religious leaders and people in power, and many people have been forcibly kept away from education by saying that they do not have the right to study scriptures.
प्राचीनकाल मे गुण (योग्यता, पात्रता) और कर्म के अनुसार व्यक्तिगत व्यवसाय का चयन होता था ,किंतु परंतु आज उस
वर्ण व्यवस्था को धूर्त पंडित, धर्मगुरुओ, सत्ता के लोगों ने जन्मआधारित बना दिया, और बहुत से लोगों को बलात् शिक्षा से दूर कर दिया कि इन्हे शास्त्र-अध्ययन का अधिकार नही है।
Manu smriti was written and translated by English people in 18th century! Book talking about cow's meat! Or telling us if you don't eat meat from aahuti you will go to hell!
😂😂 kuch bhi
Source ?
@@jhanvitharad3149 That’s what Geeta press Gorakhpur published in the translation. All passages which talk about what kind of meat is allowed and banned especially beef are the passages added by British Sanskrit schollars in early 18”0 s! That makes sense Manu the Bhagwan will never talk about sacrificing and eating even goat! Vedic people were pure vegetarian! Many English translator changed words ! Rigveda talked about coconut which western scholars changed to animals ! Same about soma rasa which was actually Gangajal! Same is belief of Iskon! Hare Rama Hare Krishna!
@@mikesheth5370 manu was not bhagawan, he was just some king, dont read too much into him
@@kumar9967 Manu of Manusmriti very likely was a sage or rishi! The Manu who predicted big flood and about Fish is believed to be Avtar. Ancient Indian smritikar etc had tendency to cheat and misguide followers assuming identity of Rigvedic Maharishis like Vashshta, via shwamitra, Ygnavkya, Manu. Ved Vyasa! Just to misguided uneducated Hindu masses! If they were born in this age they will be jail impersonating!
जो भी तुमको शारीरिक, मानसिक, बौद्धिक, भावात्मक, आर्थिक और आध्यात्मिक दृष्टि से दुर्बल बनाये उसे विष की भाँति त्याग दो।
Jai Hind
Then why the spelling Brahmin instead of Brahaman.
Guru is The Brahmana