In the 60s & 70s songs were commonly 3 minutes. Band Maid creates great songs in the 4 minute range. This song emphasizes Saiki’s vocals and Miku’s beautiful harmonizing vocals. Kanami’s guitar work is amazing. When she’s not carrying the song with a solid hook and a shredding solo, she’s does subtle meandering chord work and riffing reminiscent of the Edge and Alex Lifeson. This is one of my very favorite Band Maid songs.
I wouldn't say commercial, it's more like they are executing the hard rock genre very well. To me, Band-Maid relates back to the hard rock bands of the 70's with some 70's new wave and a bit of punk thrown in. You don't find this kind of driving rock and roll very much anymore, which is why it appeals to me, being the music I used to listen to as a teenager.
Saiki-san definitely in my top three female fronts worldwide...love her vocals, especially after the surgery... Wanna be blown away by her vocals? Do the acoustic version of this song! Live version...
"Onset" is pure instrumental. Yes. they have a formula but they do like to mix it up. Their new "endless Story" is more poppy but it is intended as an audience sing along. To quote Kanami, an "arena" song. Planning for the future. In fan videos from their recent Europe tour you will see Saiki teaching the audience the lyrics to sing along (the song was not yet released) . It is kind of a Japanese thing to have audience participation. At the same time they have added a guitar solo as a new intro to their song "Moratorium". And if you listen to their live songs and compare them to the album versions you will find they are tweaking the songs. They've done this same song "Puzzle" as an acoustic song with just Saiki and Kanami on acoustic guitar and doing backup vocals. And then there is their April Fool's joke that has taken in a life of its own, Band-Maiko, where they dress up as geishas and mix in some traditional Japanese instruments with their usual instruments. Check out "Gion-cho" th-cam.com/video/umSt7oMUMcs/w-d-xo.html
@@santirodriguez2544 Well yeah, an apprentice geisha, but most non-Japanese don't know the word "maiko" nor would they know what to look for to tell maiko and geisha apart. Besides they are too old to be maiko who are usually in their teens.
This song is a BM masterpiece composed by Kanami and lyrics plus main vocal arrangements by Miku with some input from Saiki. The song is called Puzzle because of its lyrics, but also because of its composition. This song would likely have been even more progressive if the label wouldn't have limited its length.
Huge thanks for turning me on to this band! I am 63 yrs old and still bangn. Have you guys ever hear of Leo Moracchioli ? This guy is a mad genius ,He is from Norway covers songs in his style/plays all the instruments. The song is Zombie cover of Cranberries/ Metal version it has over 30 million views! Went to my play list
I guess everything has a formula, right? The Chevy formula. The NFL formula. The YT Reactor’s formula. How about saying, the Band-Maid “sound” or “style”. Band-Maid’s sound is like none other. Same for each individual player. But if you want different genre-specific music within their sound or style, try: [Hard Rock] - Moratorium, Domination, Clang, Dice, Spirit, Turn Me On, Fate, Play, Hide-And-Seek, Secret My Lips, Puzzle, Glory or Choose Me… or powerful, beautifully written [slower tunes] -- Daydreaming, Anemone and Smile... or more [punky] -- Don’t Let Me Down and Screaming… or [funky] -- Bubble… or [poppy] -- Start Over… or [cultural] -- Band-Maiko! In any case, I highly recommend using headsets set to “Stun” because this group rocks, again... like none other!
Band-Maid's 'super-power' is Miku & Konami's damned GOOD TASTE in lyric/music arrangement. Sure, 'heavier,' more 'technical' bands, play fast & hard w/something to prove, but BM's actually got something to say ;-)
@@gusgrimm7533 100% !! Now if people (like in the USA) would get over some hangups (or at least, try to understand) the "Gap" and why they wear maid outfits... or the fact that girls can rock as good, if not better, than guys... or the way they act... or that they might not understand all the lyrics without translation or learning some Japanese, etc... they could reach the level of a RUSH or a Foo Fighters in a few short years. Oh, yeah... and their promoters need to get more creative with this important, awesome band. Here's one of my ideas I recently wrote to their management: A Two-Man Show - The Warning and Band-Maid - South & North American Tour 2020
@@TomClark-Futoura: Yup. It's up to us to promote this band via 'word-of-mouth' and encourage a 'Rock'n'Roll Renaissance' among every bedroom guitarist & garage band in our neighborhoods. 2020's gonna be a great year ;-)
New sub! If you haven't yet could you please check out Nightwish? I recommend Yours is an Empty Hope live!!! 🤘🤘 Live at Wembley is great, or the cruise one is great too!! 😉
@@hopsmetalshow3413 Oh absolutely!! And if you want a nice heavy song from Nightwish might I suggest Your's is an Empty Hope live!! 🤘🤘 It really does kick!!
this performance is from the Shinkiba Studio Coast performance from end of 2017.. released as a DVD/Bluray, it's got the best audio imo. the other major live DVD/Bluray is from Zepp Tokyo 2018. i agree that BAND-MAID's got a rather commercial sound to em.. but that's totally fine, coz what they put out is so damn good, and it never comes across as feeling contrived. they've got an effortless mish-mash of different sounds.. the catchy hook from pop music being one of their strongest assets imo. even if they rarely deviate from a standard song structure, their songs are filled with so much quality musicianship that it's easy for me to look past that th-cam.com/video/N7BQCkUb4SI/w-d-xo.html Moratorium's another heavy hitter.. it actually comes right before Puzzle at this show
They compose their music and play it themselves. It's good to see young girls who dedicate to what they want to do. Whatever people lable them, they shouldn't care about it. They may not be the best, actually the best band to me so far is Dream State from South Wales, but I want to see their growth as a big fan from their debut.
Band-Maid is currently on their US tour and played at Aftershock this year which was epic!! They are 100% on their game right now as even the fancams are brilliant. Garage shows basically arn't supposed to be this good. This is a A level band deserving of a proper arena tour. Akane is seriously next level as her drum solos are giving me chills. See them live as that is where they shine here. Hope they finally start to get some recognition now to good to pass up here!! Good reaction BTW!! 🤘
Hey guys, for something different you should do Puzzle acoustic live, which includes a song called Anemone. It is only Kanami the guitarist and Saiki the vocalist. Also the instrumental Onset is great as many have suggested.
Miku (rhythm) does most of backup and sometimes lead vocals. Kanami (lead g) does backup vocals sometimes. Misa (bass) and Akane (drums) do not sing. Just a reminder. Saiki (lead vocal) - say like pshychi Miku (rhythm g and backup vocal) Kanami (lead g) Misa (bass) Akane (drums)
I think you have to buy a CD with bounus DVD direct from Japan to get a live concert. The cost is worth it. CDs in Japan are more costly than the UK and, I am guessing the States. Pity you are not going to the September concerts in the States. You will find fans flying from all over. It is one of the great way to meet new friends. Met some Japanese fans who came for the London gig. One reason is the meet and greet, as this might not happen in Japan with Band Maid now (?).
The only real pattern I have been able to detect is that they don't like to do the same thing twice, even within a song. Each verse and chorus has something different about it, and they throw in tempo and mood changes at random.
Coming from a hard-rock/metal inclination, once you get passed the pop and learn to love it, they DO NOT have a bad song. I actually enjoy some of the pop stuff more than the rock type stuff. This band also got me to appreciate pop-punk and other punky type music I always disliked. It's crazy how Band-Maid has destroyed my preconceptions of "good" music. ROCK ON BAND-MAID!!! 🤘
1:20. Cookie cutter, I don't see it. They play great rock and roll. If that is cookie cutter, I am with it. I grew up with rock and roll and this is no more cookie cutter than that music. At the least, Band Maid is putting out really good music. I can't wait for January of 2021.
With 75 songs published since 2013 you are going to find a lot of style and diversity in Band-Maid's music obviously. That's not a bad thing. Would you know Helter Skelter and Yesterday were both done by the Beatles if you did not know both songs were done by the Beatles? l doubt it. See some of you at the Echoplex in LA Sept. 30th.
Hey dudes, I like your reviews, Could I give you a suggestion from Australia, please give a look at “Twelve Foot Ninja” it’ll be right up your alley, their songs are epic to say the least, a few suggestions are “Coming For You “. or “One Hand Killing” or “Mother Sky”
They have produced two blu-ray concert DVDs. Most all of the pro-shot live videos on YT have been ripped from these two-hour shows. The middle guy had to be sure and make the cookie-cutter comment right up front, yes? Tell me, and please go into detail, what aspect of this song has cookie-cutter qualities? The drums, the bass, the guitar work? Perhaps it's the lyrics Miku wrote, or the composition that Kanami and the rest of the band provided. As for being commercial, maybe they should make unmelodious music just to show how edgy they are, right?
i think he's referring to the format a lot of their songs follow.. A verse, chorus, B verse, chorus, solo, bridge, chorus, end. they do play around with it from time to time, and it's always welcome
I would say the only "cookie-cutter" aspect is the frantic and epileptic editing of this live DVD, which is inferior to certain fan recordings. Other than that this song is perfect, going on full gas without a single dull moment. The song has formulaic structure but Kanami changes the riff all the time and Akane never dwells on the same drum pattern.
@@borntraitor289 Well yes, there are similarities in the composition of many of their songs, but what I love is how Band-Maid changes things up in their songs like chord progressions, time signatures and song intros. He deflected the cookie cutter comment by saying someone else made them, but you know he was thinking the same thing just by mentioning it very early on. if it wasn't at the top of his mind, then why mention it. Their songs all sound like Band-Maid and I wouldn't have it any other way.
I have been in bands for 50 years and anybody who complains about commercialization of music either has a lucky hit or is starving and hasn't hit on a formula yet.
Please react to the BAND-MAID Acoustical: *Puzzle (Acoustic)* th-cam.com/video/xdwNmzr-ipk/w-d-xo.html _(What Is This Salty Discharge?)_ *Anemone (Acoustic)* th-cam.com/video/YysS1LX0zk0/w-d-xo.html _(Is Somebody Chopping Onions in Here?)_ Thanks and enjoy your reaction as always.
Not bad musicians, but I'm a snob when it comes to female vocalists and she's not one I would listen to. She does have power in her voice but that's not everything. Sorry not sorry.
Love Band Maid, they rock 🤘🤘
Killer vocals every time I listen to a song I haven't heard much it becomes a favorite/
In the 60s & 70s songs were commonly 3 minutes. Band Maid creates great songs in the 4 minute range. This song emphasizes Saiki’s vocals and Miku’s beautiful harmonizing vocals. Kanami’s guitar work is amazing. When she’s not carrying the song with a solid hook and a shredding solo, she’s does subtle meandering chord work and riffing reminiscent of the Edge and Alex Lifeson. This is one of my very favorite Band Maid songs.
Another BANGER! Band Maid has the BEST rhythm section on the planet.
I wouldn't say commercial, it's more like they are executing the hard rock genre very well. To me, Band-Maid relates back to the hard rock bands of the 70's with some 70's new wave and a bit of punk thrown in. You don't find this kind of driving rock and roll very much anymore, which is why it appeals to me, being the music I used to listen to as a teenager.
Kanami, the lead guitarist, the one who writes the music for the band, says she was especially influenced by Carlos Santana.
This is my favorite song and arrangement of Band Maid --until the next one🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
7:21 i'm like that going back n listening to songs of theirs i've already heard over n over again
sooo good....
Best Japanese Metal all female band. Huge chops with Misa on bass, Akane on lead guitar. How can you not love these ladies?
Dang I meant Akane on drums. Have a brain fart
Saiki-san definitely in my top three female fronts worldwide...love her vocals, especially after the surgery... Wanna be blown away by her vocals? Do the acoustic version of this song! Live version...
"Onset" is pure instrumental. Yes. they have a formula but they do like to mix it up. Their new "endless Story" is more poppy but it is intended as an audience sing along. To quote Kanami, an "arena" song. Planning for the future. In fan videos from their recent Europe tour you will see Saiki teaching the audience the lyrics to sing along (the song was not yet released) . It is kind of a Japanese thing to have audience participation. At the same time they have added a guitar solo as a new intro to their song "Moratorium". And if you listen to their live songs and compare them to the album versions you will find they are tweaking the songs. They've done this same song "Puzzle" as an acoustic song with just Saiki and Kanami on acoustic guitar and doing backup vocals. And then there is their April Fool's joke that has taken in a life of its own, Band-Maiko, where they dress up as geishas and mix in some traditional Japanese instruments with their usual instruments. Check out "Gion-cho" th-cam.com/video/umSt7oMUMcs/w-d-xo.html
They dress up as... maikos
@@santirodriguez2544 Well yeah, an apprentice geisha, but most non-Japanese don't know the word "maiko" nor would they know what to look for to tell maiko and geisha apart. Besides they are too old to be maiko who are usually in their teens.
This song is a BM masterpiece composed by Kanami and lyrics plus main vocal arrangements by Miku with some input from Saiki. The song is called Puzzle because of its lyrics, but also because of its composition. This song would likely have been even more progressive if the label wouldn't have limited its length.
Huge thanks for turning me on to this band! I am 63 yrs old and still bangn. Have you guys ever hear of Leo Moracchioli ? This guy is a mad genius ,He is from Norway covers songs in his style/plays all the instruments. The song is Zombie cover of Cranberries/ Metal version it has over 30 million views! Went to my play list
I guess everything has a formula, right? The Chevy formula. The NFL formula. The YT Reactor’s formula. How about saying, the Band-Maid “sound” or “style”. Band-Maid’s sound is like none other. Same for each individual player. But if you want different genre-specific music within their sound or style, try: [Hard Rock] - Moratorium, Domination, Clang, Dice, Spirit, Turn Me On, Fate, Play, Hide-And-Seek, Secret My Lips, Puzzle, Glory or Choose Me… or powerful, beautifully written [slower tunes] -- Daydreaming, Anemone and Smile... or more [punky] -- Don’t Let Me Down and Screaming… or [funky] -- Bubble… or [poppy] -- Start Over… or [cultural] -- Band-Maiko! In any case, I highly recommend using headsets set to “Stun” because this group rocks, again... like none other!
Band-Maid's 'super-power' is Miku & Konami's damned GOOD TASTE in lyric/music arrangement. Sure, 'heavier,' more 'technical' bands, play fast & hard w/something to prove, but BM's actually got something to say ;-)
@@gusgrimm7533 100% !! Now if people (like in the USA) would get over some hangups (or at least, try to understand) the "Gap" and why they wear maid outfits... or the fact that girls can rock as good, if not better, than guys... or the way they act... or that they might not understand all the lyrics without translation or learning some Japanese, etc... they could reach the level of a RUSH or a Foo Fighters in a few short years. Oh, yeah... and their promoters need to get more creative with this important, awesome band. Here's one of my ideas I recently wrote to their management: A Two-Man Show - The Warning and Band-Maid - South & North American Tour 2020
@@TomClark-Futoura: Yup. It's up to us to promote this band via 'word-of-mouth' and encourage a 'Rock'n'Roll Renaissance' among every bedroom guitarist & garage band in our neighborhoods. 2020's gonna be a great year ;-)
Way to go is live.Band maid never disapoint.
🤘🤘❤️🤘🤘 Oh yeah!!! These ladies are Fan-freakin-tastic!!! 🤘🤘
New sub! If you haven't yet could you please check out Nightwish? I recommend Yours is an Empty Hope live!!! 🤘🤘 Live at Wembley is great, or the cruise one is great too!! 😉
@@hopsmetalshow3413 I just saw these! Sweet! And I will definitely check out the website!!! 🤘🤘
@@hopsmetalshow3413 Oh absolutely!! And if you want a nice heavy song from Nightwish might I suggest Your's is an Empty Hope live!! 🤘🤘 It really does kick!!
Thanks guys!
this performance is from the Shinkiba Studio Coast performance from end of 2017.. released as a DVD/Bluray, it's got the best audio imo. the other major live DVD/Bluray is from Zepp Tokyo 2018.
i agree that BAND-MAID's got a rather commercial sound to em.. but that's totally fine, coz what they put out is so damn good, and it never comes across as feeling contrived. they've got an effortless mish-mash of different sounds.. the catchy hook from pop music being one of their strongest assets imo. even if they rarely deviate from a standard song structure, their songs are filled with so much quality musicianship that it's easy for me to look past that
th-cam.com/video/N7BQCkUb4SI/w-d-xo.html Moratorium's another heavy hitter.. it actually comes right before Puzzle at this show
They compose their music and play it themselves. It's good to see young girls who dedicate to what they want to do. Whatever people lable them, they shouldn't care about it. They may not be the best, actually the best band to me so far is Dream State from South Wales, but I want to see their growth as a big fan from their debut.
Band-Maid is currently on their US tour and played at Aftershock this year which was epic!! They are 100% on their game right now as even the fancams are brilliant.
Garage shows basically arn't supposed to be this good. This is a A level band deserving of a proper arena tour. Akane is seriously next level as her drum solos are giving me chills.
See them live as that is where they shine here. Hope they finally start to get some recognition now to good to pass up here!! Good reaction BTW!! 🤘
We are suppose to see them live Oct 25
MIKU! MIKU! MIKU!
I wish so much that BAND-MAID would "Freebird" this and extend it to 15 minutes. Give Saiki a break and let the other 4 girls absolutely tear it up.
Hey guys, for something different you should do Puzzle acoustic live, which includes a song
called Anemone. It is only Kanami the guitarist and Saiki the vocalist. Also the instrumental
Onset is great as many have suggested.
Miku (rhythm) does most of backup and sometimes lead vocals. Kanami (lead g) does backup vocals sometimes. Misa (bass) and Akane (drums) do not sing.
Just a reminder.
Saiki (lead vocal) - say like pshychi
Miku (rhythm g and backup vocal)
Kanami (lead g)
Misa (bass)
Akane (drums)
MISA sang before she joined Band-Maid, and there is fancam footage of Akane with a Mic set up on her kit doing backing
@@DavidMISAMISAMISACook You are correct. Akane does sometimes. But, since I never saw Misa singing with B-M, let that slide, huh? Cheers
Sa-ee-kee, there are no silent letters.
I think I've read that Misa used to sing in a band when she was in high school. Wouldn't surprise me if they could all sing.
MISA🤘🤘
you guys should listen to this song again with a headphone
More Band-Maid Doc! Misaiki kuruppo!
I think you have to buy a CD with bounus DVD direct from Japan to get a live concert. The cost is worth it.
CDs in Japan are more costly than the UK and, I am guessing the States.
Pity you are not going to the September concerts in the States. You will find fans flying from all over. It is one of the great way to meet new friends. Met some Japanese fans who came for the London gig. One reason is the meet and greet, as this might not happen in Japan with Band Maid now (?).
The only real pattern I have been able to detect is that they don't like to do the same thing twice, even within a song. Each verse and chorus has something different about it, and they throw in tempo and mood changes at random.
Miku Kobato (small pidgeon) is the backup vocalist, rhythm guitarist and band founder. Don't label these fine ladies. They defy it.
Robert what she does on backup vocals and energy is amazing
She also writes the lyrics.
I still haven't found a single bad song by this band.
everything ive heard so far is good
They have none
Coming from a hard-rock/metal inclination, once you get passed the pop and learn to love it, they DO NOT have a bad song. I actually enjoy some of the pop stuff more than the rock type stuff. This band also got me to appreciate pop-punk and other punky type music I always disliked. It's crazy how Band-Maid has destroyed my preconceptions of "good" music. ROCK ON BAND-MAID!!! 🤘
Why are you guys not reacting to new Bandmaid song ”Different” just came out？
its coming soon
next Bubble Reaction
Misa, the barefoot assassin
5:39 you know, máster.
Great reaction, these girls won't let you down, now listen to "Don't let me down" LOL - there's some English in this song so listen closely
It's all in English, just Sai-chans Accent throws you off
All in English and dirty as hell :)
1:20. Cookie cutter, I don't see it. They play great rock and roll. If that is cookie cutter, I am with it. I grew up with rock and roll and this is no more cookie cutter than that music. At the least, Band Maid is putting out really good music. I can't wait for January of 2021.
Her voice 😌
With 75 songs published since 2013 you are going to find a lot of style and diversity in Band-Maid's music obviously. That's not a bad thing. Would you know Helter Skelter and Yesterday were both done by the Beatles if you did not know both songs were done by the Beatles? l doubt it. See some of you at the Echoplex in LA Sept. 30th.
Hey dudes, I like your reviews,
Could I give you a suggestion from Australia, please give a look at “Twelve Foot Ninja” it’ll be right up your alley, their songs are epic to say the least, a few suggestions are “Coming For You “. or “One Hand Killing” or “Mother Sky”
Rotor Thermotech I’ll add them to the list
You guys should react to Ningen Isu => Heartless sact
Onset, instrumental. th-cam.com/video/ud0pxII3YwM/w-d-xo.html
They have produced two blu-ray concert DVDs. Most all of the pro-shot live videos on YT have been ripped from these two-hour shows. The middle guy had to be sure and make the cookie-cutter comment right up front, yes? Tell me, and please go into detail, what aspect of this song has cookie-cutter qualities? The drums, the bass, the guitar work? Perhaps it's the lyrics Miku wrote, or the composition that Kanami and the rest of the band provided. As for being commercial, maybe they should make unmelodious music just to show how edgy they are, right?
i think he's referring to the format a lot of their songs follow.. A verse, chorus, B verse, chorus, solo, bridge, chorus, end. they do play around with it from time to time, and it's always welcome
I would say the only "cookie-cutter" aspect is the frantic and epileptic editing of this live DVD, which is inferior to certain fan recordings. Other than that this song is perfect, going on full gas without a single dull moment. The song has formulaic structure but Kanami changes the riff all the time and Akane never dwells on the same drum pattern.
i wish the bluray just had all angles available for us to pick from
@@borntraitor289 Well yes, there are similarities in the composition of many of their songs, but what I love is how Band-Maid changes things up in their songs like chord progressions, time signatures and song intros. He deflected the cookie cutter comment by saying someone else made them, but you know he was thinking the same thing just by mentioning it very early on. if it wasn't at the top of his mind, then why mention it. Their songs all sound like Band-Maid and I wouldn't have it any other way.
@@wrcompositi I'm with you on that 100%. Even their studio MV's suffer from rapid fire scene cuts. Dice is one example.
the guy in the middle could not look more unhappy lol ...
I have been in bands for 50 years and anybody who complains about commercialization of music either has a lucky hit or is starving and hasn't hit on a formula yet.
Check out “bloodshedd” title song beast 696 , Thank you guys
Please react to the BAND-MAID Acoustical:
*Puzzle (Acoustic)* th-cam.com/video/xdwNmzr-ipk/w-d-xo.html _(What Is This Salty Discharge?)_
*Anemone (Acoustic)* th-cam.com/video/YysS1LX0zk0/w-d-xo.html _(Is Somebody Chopping Onions in Here?)_
Thanks and enjoy your reaction as always.
Once again the Maid's lay waste to a venue
Two negative votes. Who knew Justin Bieber and Taylor Swift watched TH-cam?
request
drop's 「赤いブルーズ」
th-cam.com/video/lsXOjF20jFc/w-d-xo.html
Great reaction guys.
These girls never disapoint.
Next you should do a official video.
DONT LET ME DOWN.
th-cam.com/video/0YGwUhg2XNk/w-d-xo.html
auto like
Great video guys 👍
Their live shows are damaging
Not bad musicians, but I'm a snob when it comes to female vocalists and she's not one I would listen to. She does have power in her voice but that's not everything. Sorry not sorry.