Being from the Rail industry myself it was a pleasure to listen to Mr. Mani and his ideas, Very informative and he clearly highlights various issues in our sector! Please keep inviting such technocrats! And Mr. Arvind, your questions were detailed. Thank you
@@ManiSudhanshu Sir what do you about this comment?? 'I get brainwashed leftist vibe from this Man. Sad, ☹️such intelligent people are susceptible to leftist lies!!'
@kalam needs straight pillar height approx 15-25meter and land acquisition say 500kms..... So first let mumbai ahmedabad b built as most if the gujratis r workers who travel to Mumbai hahahaha actually it needs to build for that section which needs to travel.... Not for politicians who use travel on govt cost Nd the ones w beurocrats class ie getting paid wo working class nd banya class who just increase the cost of materials 5 times that's the present situation so let's c what comes of it.. If ur dokala fan u can take bullet train by 2026 hopefully 🌹🌹🌹🙊 it would have been better to connect nagpur to Mumbai first as it wd have reduced 17 hrs travel to under 4hrs with 2hrs each runs and connected east-west of India or Delhi-Mumbai or Patna-Delhi first as max population wd have been catered to
Mani sir, has the in-depth insight on the Indian railways system and it’s policies. Wish him to be in policy making team for prosperous Indian railways future. Hope govt. is aware of all the challenges point out by mani sir in the podcast..
What I like most about Shudhanshu Ji is his critisising nature and pointing government directly. Sure Govt is doing GOOD but only GOOD is not worthy , BEST needed. I believe that Mr. Ashvini Vaishnav sir will work on it. Yes India is speeding !!! हम गति पकड़ने दौड़े है , गति मिलेगी ही । 🔥
🙏 Thanks. Many do not understand, or rather do not want to understand, unable to digest the truth. Speaking the truth is then dismissed as the voice of a disgruntled person. To each his own 🙏
@@ManiSudhanshu Sir just one request to you is please be in touch with ministry or the Personnels working in ministry then you can do more better for the Railways. System के बाहर रहकर System बदलना बहुत कठिन है । What I want is that good talks between you and ministry continues. क्यूं सोचे की T18 का क्या होगा , कुछ नही होगा तो तजुर्बा होगा 🙏🏻
@@ManiSudhanshu Aap ko bahut shubh kaamnaaye Sudhanshu ji. I can tell you are a patriot of the first order and want India to gain true design knowledge as well as manufacturing capacity. Criticism and questioning of the current administrators from someone like you with vast experience is always welcome. You raise so many valid questions about why certain tenders for certain quantities have been raised or why certain parts are still imported etc. I wish there were decision makers or our railway minister answering these questions. At the very least one is curious to know why fencing and track upgradation is going at a slow pace given the projected number of vande bharat trains. I hope you come on this channel often to give us an update of what is going well and not so well with the Railways from time to time.
@@ManiSudhanshuNow❤ atleast if v can, as 180kmph webtac brakes have been tested on new vande nd if found useful, can they b put on every train along with anti collision if it works to stop trains at least possible time nd if double brakes or automatic brakes w laser guided track obstruction is detected if trains can braked to min possible speed it has advantages.. So automatically braking signal braking with kavach Nd Ai enabled or control room enabled in case of emergencies it is a must to implement
Hey Buddy, can you bring Retrired IAS officer Sanjay Dixit Ji to your podcast. He is 1 of the few Indians who does a Perfect analysis of current Events related to the India. And surprisingly, he also has Answer to every Question related to India and its History. His Expertise lies in Indian History, Partition of India, National Integrity and islamic invasions. Thanks!
What a realist. Mr. Sudhanshu Mani is someone who should have been given an extension with a new challenge to develop an indigenous High Speed Train. The man seems to be brimming with ideas and execution. Thanks for bringing him to the show.
मणी सर जो कहे रहे है उसपर चर्चा हो और पुणॅत: भारत मे ही ट्रेन बने और कीसी भी तरह की राजनीति न हो.हमारी क्षमता विश्वस्तरीय है ही. हम सिर्फ विदेशो के लिए मार्केट नही है.
0) Sections of WDFC/EDFC are running freight trains as of now. Land acquisition is almost done. Other than one critical stretch in EDFC with extensive tunneling there should be not be much delay. So contract mgmt might be major issue as suggested. 1) JVs with MSME supply-chain seems to be the future both for growing manufacturing ecosystem with incoming tech, investment and scaling. As capacity increases the kind of projects that can be executed will definitely grow multiple times over 5-10 years. 2) About track renewal there's a question mark as it can't be done with a magic wand. Unless there's some other method to get it done parallely without disrupting traffic to reduce time frame. Update : 3) IR going to take help of NHAI crash barrier/barrier tech for stopping cattle accidents by enclosing the tracks.
There are some updates, i'm sure guest would know that Vande Bharat wheels were coming from Ukraine, but due to war, it was delayed and then Modi government decided that all forged wheels will be made in India. Regarding automatic door, i remember there was 1 company which installed indigeneous door system in one of the metro stations, I'm sure in next 2-3 years we will be creating them Kavach is a good system indigeneously made. I agree there are lot of things which needs to be done but i think lots have changed in last 8 years regarding broad guage, double lining and electrification, cleanliness, station redevelopment.
Brother do u think we import all parts of train from abroad..... If no can u tell which have been imported (i asked this becuz wat u have said is contrary to mani Sir's comment)
A forged wheel pant by RINL is ready for commissioning for more than a year with an investment of Rs 2000 crores. Yes, some good work has sure been done but let us not talk of half truths please. 🙏
Loved this podcast. His experience and knowledge reflects through his conversation. Salute you sir. I love Vande Bharat train. Gov needs to work on their weak areas and improve the railway.
Salute to Sudhanshu Mani sir and his team. There are some elements in our society,Those who are unable to create history, they will always blame. History is created by Mani sir and Modi sir. Jai hind.
Aaj ki tarikh me itna to kaam kia.. 70 saal me kya ukhad kia jo aaj sarkar ki intension ko sawal Kaer rahe he.. sir humne bhi India dekha he aj tak.. aage kya hoga ye pata nahi he
I was eagerly awaiting for mr.sudhanshu mani...for his heroic efforts in taking big bulls ( cows ) and going ahead with amazing works and his colleagues at ICF... Chennai... 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Sudanshu mani ji addressed all the valid points this video .he is exact to the point .if average speed is under 80 train is a waste we just do not want to enjoy luxury but we want journey time cut down .first upgrade tracks and fence the tracks .
Track up gradation is happening very fast since last 10 years prev there was not even railway crossings and electrification and even proper cleanliness all railway crossing got upgraded and electrification of treks done and now all trains have bio toilet before few years it was just a dream now we r talking about speed . speed can't be achieved in day. And vande bharat is not only about speed..
It is important for experts to talk to the govt nd convince them nd show them the mirror . Speaking on Podcasts doesnt help in improvement but only makes the viewers more anxious . Just my thought sirji 🙏🏼
Inspiring talk for new energetic engineers and it's seem that how tough to do in India🇮🇳 during talk I observed that if our PM don't show intrest it can not be happened Salute yor dedication sir jai Hind
Great interview kept me interested till end ,watching it on the day when kerela vande bharat started . Always good to hear knowledgeable persons like you ,should keep contributing to railways in some way or other .Thanks
Every IAS Officer during service: I'll sleep and pass my time and never let my control go. After retirement: I've many unique ideas and pvt sector is good.
IAS bureaucracy is like an immovable object, no single person however skilled or enthusiastic, cannot change the system. The sole objective of that mafia is to hold control of everything, earn millions in corruption and do minimal work all while maintaining "elite" stature in the society. So no point blaming Mr Mani. He did everything he could with little support.
He is IRAS not IAS, you are right but we should welcome criticism especially when we don't know how people worked during their administration. It's very tough to be a successful administration being in govt. One interview not in line with our political inclination doesn't mean we should criticise his working
@Mani Sudhanshu ❤❤❤ Sudhanshu mani u shd use ur influence to advocate for the need for 4 coach Memu that can run 130kmph or 160kmph doable absolutely.... ICF makes 220 coaches which can b scaled up to 240 or 280 a month and mint 70-75 memus that runs 160kmph in a month and distribute 12 each to run 50 kms both sides or 360 degrees of a cities ie every 10min frequency solves all the problems ie if 12 memus r distributed to run 6 runs every hr to n fo 50 to 60 kms in 1 hr solves all the present probs in cities esp w feeder bus service 2stns covering a radius of 10-20kms frm the stn nd major stops curtailed to 50kms making trains faster and easier for longer routes nd memus for under 50 kms travel as available every 10min.. Railways adopts 6 cities each mth providing 12x6 72 Memus ie in a yr 60 cities have risen to new levels of travel.. Or railways ensures 60 new metro city creation... So start creating with the power u have ❤❤❤ if v had the power I wd do it Tom.... Make a new Tom today... Railways 2Adopt 6 cities nd create 6new metro cities acroos the nation each month, 😂❤with rcf, mcf taking care of the rest of the products
This was lots of fun listening to candid talk between you and Mr.Mani. Belonging to Railway Engineering I really enjoyed this talk. I personally feel Logistics policy implemented well will revolutionize all moods of Transport including railway. Railway just needs to work fast n hard to be ready when the benifits of the logictics policy starts coming after the policy becomes set on ground. Let's hope it works well 🙂 cheers to you bhrata ✌🏻☺️
@@ManiSudhanshu Thank you for the candid talk Sir and for your services to the nation 🙏🏻 Along with loving your voice I really loved your idea of Porters using trolleys to carry load ❤️ that can help porters have dignity, better health and platforms look more civilised 🙂 I wish Current DRMs take note from your ideas 🙏🏻
@@ManiSudhanshu I understand your frustration sir. All of us staff who work hard to bring change is nullified time to time by rigid ministry, Board, Officer mentality and lack of coordination, constantly changing direction and not valueing the valuable staff. It's depressing. I see change of mindset in myself too before joining and now after 10yrs of service. It happens sadly. But then those who only know to work hard and serve the nation will keep doing so no matter the shortcomings of the system 🙏🏻 I really appreciate relentless work of all those service staff with managers like you overlooking and trying my best to immitate the same 🙏🏻😌
From the time conversation started, first thing to appreciate is the vocal quality of Shree Sudhanshu Mani which compelled to listen entire video. Inspite of such a great achievement nowhere does he mentions it with to much pride. He probably has certain reservations on planning and has right to express as a experience super top boss. However he doesn't criticise in a indecent manner. These qualities only make such high profile individuals. Salute to Mani .Sir
46:57 Vaise bhi Solar power aur wind power, donho hii kaafi inefficient aur unreliable hain. Nuclear power hii sahi raasta hain. Par ek nuclear plant banaane ke liye bhi bahut samay lagta hain aur uska initial cost bahut jyaada hoata hain.
India needs Master plan for local public transport n population needs fully general coach trains for industrial labours.First start centralised route map from Nagpur a 0 mile n priority to 1 tourist 2 long journey sleeper coaches n 3 trains for ports 4 Military depots routes near border areas 5 centralised food distribution FCI godowns 6 Railway passenger n goods trains centralised maintenance workshops 7 Centralised Railway staff training Institutions 8 Railway track Monitoring system like France 9 Solar electric manufacturing system 10 Centralised petrolium train depots .🙏🇮🇳
Very encouraging shift in the government machinery and drivers. Hope to see more ministers like Ashwini and leaders like Modi emerging in Indian horizon. It's time everyone converges with the India growth story and every effort should be made to accelerate the journey
Hey Buddy can you explain about the following Indian Legends, Kingdoms and Philosophies: Indian Legeneds: 1. Adi Shankaracharya 2. Gautam Buddha 3. Mahavir Jain 4. Ashoka the Great 5. Guru Gobind Singh 6. Swami Vivekananda 7. Bodhi Dharma: He spread Martial Arts to China 8. Rani Rudramma Devi: How she is the Best women Warrior of India 9. Bodisena: Spread Buddhism to Japan and it is still followed highly there Indian Kingdoms: 1. Vijayanagara Empire 2. Sathavahana Dynasty 3. Chola Dynasty 4. Sikh Empire 5. Gupta Empire 6. Mauryan Empire 7. Ahoms 8. Rajputs Indian Philosophies: 1. Questions in Prashna Upanishad 2. Bhagavad Gita and Uddava Gita 3. Charvaka Philosophy 4. Why Yoga and Meditation is so Efficient 5. Debates in Ancient India 6. Why Indians worshiped idols, nature and everything. There are a lot of controversies around this. Many invaders and current day Indians criticize this. But Gita gives an excellent answer
Humre idhar hon chahiye USA type - department of transportation, aise karke USDOT dekh kr lagta hai ek dum boss hai wo poore US ke. Integral study karni padegi bahut saari. Poore desh me Transit Orient development sochna padega with integrated study
Considering how trains were 30 years ago we can justifiably be proud of the achievements in 10 years. Thinking small will not get you far. Our engineers can learn fast and can not be dismissive about the possibility. Underestimating the skill is pessimistic. We do not have to reinvent the wheel.
Great Man.... In India there is long history of anti national elements always dominates Really True Nationalism because powerful cartel of corrupt politician, corrupt bureaucracy and foreign forces. Famous example Late Shree Dr. APG Abdul Kalam in Hovercraft case in defense. Isro Dr. Nambi Narayanan, and many more along with Sudhanshu Mani. But it is unfortunate in present Nationalist Govt. I found a Extremely Good Technical and Practical Knowledge , courage to put right thing an balanced way...
ANY TRANSITION TAKES TIME ELECTRIFICATION IS GOOD OPTION. IN ANY CASE 100% IS NOT THERE N WE WILL NEED SOME BACKUP. WE MAY CONVERT THEM TO MIXED OR DUAL MODE
Train 18 was made by the experts of ICF, not the government, so all the credit should go to them. Firstly they criticized the project_ now they are claiming credit for it . Don't be brainwashed by political messages, see the truth within.
@@sanjoybhattacharya7476 both the Givg and Rly board were peeved ICF made almost on their. They could not claim any thing. They stopped it for two years. When Train 18 went viral modi the publicity hAwk swooped for neat. Any thing and every thing for election stunt.
@@maitri74 Absolutely right, Sir. This Govt has no contribution, except in helping some Railway Board members in derailing the project & now Claiming credit for an achievement in which they don't have an iota of contribution .
Every man has his own perspective. If I say VB is providing features and comfort still ok, when tracks gets better VB is capable of delivering speed. You can't say you make VBs on that time. If one part is on and second is slow to deliver means we are on track and one day we'll pick up. No blame game, on every point blaming govt means you need all the powers in your own hands, you can't, there is a system and organisation in place.
Jo last mey baat kahi hai ki Main station key baad fast train ho usmey risk bhi hai China key case mey fast railway to hai but loss making hai. To uska bhi panga hai kahi na kahi railway line banana koi badi baat nhi hai, profit mey railway line banana important hai. Hala ki jo Delhi wali baat kahi wo kafi sahi hai but prices matter karengey, China ney bhi aisi hi strategy use ki thi start mey but fir over use Kari or loss making line bana di.
Any Upgradation costs money, which needs to have a return, thus raising train fares. It's okay to upgrade tracks on major routes, where there is sufficient demand & traffic to support the huge expenditure, but not for all routes.
Mani sir is delightfully informative while listening . On electrification, I would like to give my two cents opinion...Electrified Railway is relatively cleaner than Diesel driven railways due to efficiency of electric engine being more than Diesel engine. So, his opinion is not correct per se
aisa kar do vaisa kar do , are Bhai you coming from system know how difficult its to change things , Mani looks bit Frustrated his earlier interview was Good but this one is more about nit picking, BTW one suggestion pls try to include Pictures & Statistics also of things like when talking about accident picture of train , audio / visual Qs . Helps understanding the context better . Cheers Good work
@@ManiSudhanshu more essential to have audit for sectional speeds... A section can determined 2b 400kms and inusive of stops b upgraded 2 avg 4hrs runs irrespective of no of stops... What trains or trainsets used r irrelevant... First to 80kmph avg ie 5hrs then towards 100kmph reach in eaxh state... Before anything else is attempted... Trainsets r available locos r available... 2...capacity augmentation ie more passengers per day runs / long loops wn passenger availability is below capacity, 3....rake utilization shd b optimised to 18-20hrs in 24hr runs.. Ie 4 hrs max allocated to maintenance nothing more per rake 4.....communication devices installed w control room, track, maintenance,Sm, forward Loco n one behind in real time operating Navi n real time area n track knowledge via navi software 4lp
Hi Mani Sir , I'm Ajit Singh , I'm the same guy who wrote that famous fb post which is Viral these days . If you remember , we've met earlier. I came to your place in Lko. सिर्फ एक बात कहूंगा ...... सरकार आपको बेशक पद्मश्री न दे , पर भारत की जनता ने आपको भारत रत्न मान लिया है । May God bless you .
Lekin jo badlav huva hai usko najar andaj nahi kar sakte hai....jaise pahle train me jo sahuliyat milti thi unse behtar sahuliyat milti hai vande bhart me....or choro chapati jyada tar bandh huyi....vande bharat banane wale engineers ko Salam....
Being from the Rail industry myself it was a pleasure to listen to Mr. Mani and his ideas, Very informative and he clearly highlights various issues in our sector! Please keep inviting such technocrats! And Mr. Arvind, your questions were detailed. Thank you
🙏
@@ManiSudhanshu Sir what do you about this comment??
'I get brainwashed leftist vibe from this Man. Sad, ☹️such intelligent people are susceptible to leftist lies!!'
Which section of railway do u work or as
@kalam needs straight pillar height approx 15-25meter and land acquisition say 500kms..... So first let mumbai ahmedabad b built as most if the gujratis r workers who travel to Mumbai hahahaha actually it needs to build for that section which needs to travel.... Not for politicians who use travel on govt cost Nd the ones w beurocrats class ie getting paid wo working class nd banya class who just increase the cost of materials 5 times that's the present situation so let's c what comes of it.. If ur dokala fan u can take bullet train by 2026 hopefully 🌹🌹🌹🙊 it would have been better to connect nagpur to Mumbai first as it wd have reduced 17 hrs travel to under 4hrs with 2hrs each runs and connected east-west of India or Delhi-Mumbai or Patna-Delhi first as max population wd have been catered to
Mani sir, has the in-depth insight on the Indian railways system and it’s policies. Wish him to be in policy making team for prosperous Indian railways future. Hope govt. is aware of all the challenges point out by mani sir in the podcast..
🙏
What I like most about Shudhanshu Ji is his critisising nature and pointing government directly.
Sure Govt is doing GOOD but only GOOD is not worthy , BEST needed.
I believe that Mr. Ashvini Vaishnav sir will work on it.
Yes India is speeding !!!
हम गति पकड़ने दौड़े है , गति मिलेगी ही । 🔥
70 saal se best dekha he humne. Railway walo ka jitna bolo utna Kum he
70 saal se best dekha he
🙏 Thanks. Many do not understand, or rather do not want to understand, unable to digest the truth. Speaking the truth is then dismissed as the voice of a disgruntled person. To each his own 🙏
@@ManiSudhanshu Sir just one request to you is please be in touch with ministry or the Personnels working in ministry then you can do more better for the Railways.
System के बाहर रहकर System बदलना बहुत कठिन है ।
What I want is that good talks between you and ministry continues.
क्यूं सोचे की T18 का क्या होगा ,
कुछ नही होगा तो तजुर्बा होगा 🙏🏻
@@ManiSudhanshu Aap ko bahut shubh kaamnaaye Sudhanshu ji. I can tell you are a patriot of the first order and want India to gain true design knowledge as well as manufacturing capacity. Criticism and questioning of the current administrators from someone like you with vast experience is always welcome. You raise so many valid questions about why certain tenders for certain quantities have been raised or why certain parts are still imported etc. I wish there were decision makers or our railway minister answering these questions. At the very least one is curious to know why fencing and track upgradation is going at a slow pace given the projected number of vande bharat trains. I hope you come on this channel often to give us an update of what is going well and not so well with the Railways from time to time.
Sudhanshu sir is a fan favourite as he brings realistic perspective to infra projects, he is like CTO of Vaad, if can say so .
🙏
These podcasts are so unique, would be really interested in the hearing other prominent government officials in various parts of the industry.
🙏
@@ManiSudhanshuNow❤ atleast if v can, as 180kmph webtac brakes have been tested on new vande nd if found useful, can they b put on every train along with anti collision if it works to stop trains at least possible time nd if double brakes or automatic brakes w laser guided track obstruction is detected if trains can braked to min possible speed it has advantages.. So automatically braking signal braking with kavach Nd Ai enabled or control room enabled in case of emergencies it is a must to implement
@@roshanmathew9443 Long subject, cannot debate here please. Thanks
Hey Buddy, can you bring Retrired IAS officer Sanjay Dixit Ji to your podcast. He is 1 of the few Indians who does a Perfect analysis of current Events related to the India. And surprisingly, he also has Answer to every Question related to India and its History. His Expertise lies in Indian History, Partition of India, National Integrity and islamic invasions. Thanks!
We also agree plz plz
+1
+1
-1
Sanjay Dixit is con man
🙏💐सुधांशु जी भारत के रत्न हैं, उनको सादर नमन है!🙏💐
🙏
What a realist. Mr. Sudhanshu Mani is someone who should have been given an extension with a new challenge to develop an indigenous High Speed Train.
The man seems to be brimming with ideas and execution.
Thanks for bringing him to the show.
Best Podcast, long clear and open conversations. Thanks for bringing Sudhanshu Mani Ji a 3rd time, it is so sad how this project progressed.
🙏
मणी सर जो कहे रहे है उसपर चर्चा हो और पुणॅत: भारत मे ही ट्रेन बने और कीसी भी तरह की राजनीति न हो.हमारी क्षमता विश्वस्तरीय है ही. हम सिर्फ विदेशो के लिए मार्केट नही है.
0) Sections of WDFC/EDFC are running freight trains as of now. Land acquisition is almost done. Other than one critical stretch in EDFC with extensive tunneling there should be not be much delay. So contract mgmt might be major issue as suggested.
1) JVs with MSME supply-chain seems to be the future both for growing manufacturing ecosystem with incoming tech, investment and scaling. As capacity increases the kind of projects that can be executed will definitely grow multiple times over 5-10 years.
2) About track renewal there's a question mark as it can't be done with a magic wand. Unless there's some other method to get it done parallely without disrupting traffic to reduce time frame.
Update :
3) IR going to take help of NHAI crash barrier/barrier tech for stopping cattle accidents by enclosing the tracks.
Noted
There are some updates, i'm sure guest would know that Vande Bharat wheels were coming from Ukraine, but due to war, it was delayed and then Modi government decided that all forged wheels will be made in India. Regarding automatic door, i remember there was 1 company which installed indigeneous door system in one of the metro stations, I'm sure in next 2-3 years we will be creating them
Kavach is a good system indigeneously made. I agree there are lot of things which needs to be done but i think lots have changed in last 8 years regarding broad guage, double lining and electrification, cleanliness, station redevelopment.
Brother do u think we import all parts of train from abroad..... If no can u tell which have been imported (i asked this becuz wat u have said is contrary to mani Sir's comment)
A forged wheel pant by RINL is ready for commissioning for more than a year with an investment of Rs 2000 crores. Yes, some good work has sure been done but let us not talk of half truths please. 🙏
Train upgradation is the most important of all
Track*
Loved this podcast. His experience and knowledge reflects through his conversation. Salute you sir. I love Vande Bharat train. Gov needs to work on their weak areas and improve the railway.
🙏
Wish Come True.
Watching Mani Sir, Very Happy.
Speaking Just Like Sudhanshu Trivedi.
Best Thing,Mani Sir Speaking Hindi.Simply ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
सुधांशु मणि जी को शत शत नमन 🙏
Salute to Sudhanshu Mani sir and his team. There are some elements in our society,Those who are unable to create history, they will always blame. History is created by Mani sir and Modi sir. Jai hind.
Sudhansu ji aapko koti-koti Namaskar
He is a genuine person, very rare to find nowadays..
Aaj ki tarikh me itna to kaam kia.. 70 saal me kya ukhad kia jo aaj sarkar ki intension ko sawal Kaer rahe he.. sir humne bhi India dekha he aj tak.. aage kya hoga ye pata nahi he
Yahi soch kar toh Modi ko vote Kiya tha.. abb pata chala ki 80 saal me bhi kuchh nahi ukhaad paa rahe..😂😂😂
I was eagerly awaiting for mr.sudhanshu mani...for his heroic efforts in taking big bulls ( cows ) and going ahead with amazing works and his colleagues at ICF... Chennai... 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
That's why we love vaad yha pr achhai ke sath sath policy ko improvements ya mudde wali baat hoti hai
😀
Sudanshu mani ji addressed all the valid points this video .he is exact to the point .if average speed is under 80 train is a waste we just do not want to enjoy luxury but we want journey time cut down .first upgrade tracks and fence the tracks .
Track up gradation is happening very fast since last 10 years prev there was not even railway crossings and electrification and even proper cleanliness all railway crossing got upgraded and electrification of treks done and now all trains have bio toilet before few years it was just a dream now we r talking about speed . speed can't be achieved in day. And vande bharat is not only about speed..
Hats off Mani Sir for your simple & technically clear talk.
🙏
Mechanical division of railways opposed electrification for years to protect their jobs
Govt. jobs are secure 😊
Shatabdi is running at 130 km per hour since 1988
My salute again and again to the entire team who dared to dream! ❤️❤️❤️❤️
🙏
You are doing a very great job. I've been waiting for this second episode podcast.
😀
Very knowledgeable person. Love his critical analysis - factual and to the point
Excellent video with factual comments from Mr. Mani however few sarcastic comments from anchor and Mr. Manii are adding negatives vibes.
Totally!
It is important for experts to talk to the govt nd convince them nd show them the mirror .
Speaking on Podcasts doesnt help in improvement but only makes the viewers more anxious .
Just my thought sirji 🙏🏼
What makes you think they would listen? 😂
@@ManiSudhanshu Sir, the bureaucrats with vested interests may not but honest ministers , the PM may…..
Just my hope .🙏🏼
@@ambassador3365 No reach to PM, others, well, how honest are they? Not sure
This episode was really informative
Please do more episodes with him in future
Loved it
🙏🙏
Request to have latest discussion with sudhanshu mani.very important in national interest.
🙏
Being an Indian, we feel proud that India now think about fast train. Also want to congratulate and salute Mr. Mani for making it successful.❤❤❤
🙏
Good to bring Sir Again ...Keep it up Vaad Team
🙏
Inspiring talk for new energetic engineers and it's seem that how tough to do in India🇮🇳 during talk I observed that if our PM don't show intrest it can not be happened
Salute yor dedication sir jai Hind
Big fan of mani sir..nam suna tha aaj dekha bhi .he is gem as a person.bhut acha lga sun k ..jitni tarif krein kamm
🙏
This is the most genuine podcast .
❤️
God bless you sir for taking the initiative and completing it on time.
😊
Sudhansu sir a true inspiration …. karmayogi😊
Great interview kept me interested till end ,watching it on the day when kerela vande bharat started . Always good to hear knowledgeable persons like you ,should keep contributing to railways in some way or other .Thanks
Nice 👍 analytical information with wise as well as wide personality mr s.mani🙏 many many thanks to both 🙏🇮🇳
Hope Railway ministry will understand all these issues regarding Vande Bharat & Railways .
🙏
देश के दुश्मनों से आज़ादी पहले चाहिए, फेंसिंग से भी पहले हा हा हा हा, उम्र दराज को सोचना चाहिए,।
जय श्री राम सभी देश भक्ति को
काफी अच्छी वार्ता थी
🙏🙏
Every IAS Officer during service: I'll sleep and pass my time and never let my control go.
After retirement: I've many unique ideas and pvt sector is good.
IAS bureaucracy is like an immovable object, no single person however skilled or enthusiastic, cannot change the system. The sole objective of that mafia is to hold control of everything, earn millions in corruption and do minimal work all while maintaining "elite" stature in the society.
So no point blaming Mr Mani. He did everything he could with little support.
Context? 🤔
He is IRAS not IAS, you are right but we should welcome criticism especially when we don't know how people worked during their administration. It's very tough to be a successful administration being in govt. One interview not in line with our political inclination doesn't mean we should criticise his working
keep up with the amazing guests you are bringing to the podcasts
😀
Lot Of Thanks Resp. Sir. .
🙏
Next focus will be on fencing and track . Lot bigger country , takes time. 180KM speed train is not a joke. Main is engineering / technology.
@Mani Sudhanshu ❤❤❤ Sudhanshu mani u shd use ur influence to advocate for the need for 4 coach Memu that can run 130kmph or 160kmph doable absolutely.... ICF makes 220 coaches which can b scaled up to 240 or 280 a month and mint 70-75 memus that runs 160kmph in a month and distribute 12 each to run 50 kms both sides or 360 degrees of a cities ie every 10min frequency solves all the problems ie if 12 memus r distributed to run 6 runs every hr to n fo 50 to 60 kms in 1 hr solves all the present probs in cities esp w feeder bus service 2stns covering a radius of 10-20kms frm the stn nd major stops curtailed to 50kms making trains faster and easier for longer routes nd memus for under 50 kms travel as available every 10min.. Railways adopts 6 cities each mth providing 12x6 72 Memus ie in a yr 60 cities have risen to new levels of travel.. Or railways ensures 60 new metro city creation... So start creating with the power u have ❤❤❤ if v had the power I wd do it Tom.... Make a new Tom today... Railways 2Adopt 6 cities nd create 6new metro cities acroos the nation each month, 😂❤with rcf, mcf taking care of the rest of the products
This was lots of fun listening to candid talk between you and Mr.Mani. Belonging to Railway Engineering I really enjoyed this talk.
I personally feel Logistics policy implemented well will revolutionize all moods of Transport including railway. Railway just needs to work fast n hard to be ready when the benifits of the logictics policy starts coming after the policy becomes set on ground. Let's hope it works well 🙂 cheers to you bhrata ✌🏻☺️
🙏🙏
@@ManiSudhanshu Thank you for the candid talk Sir and for your services to the nation 🙏🏻
Along with loving your voice I really loved your idea of Porters using trolleys to carry load ❤️ that can help porters have dignity, better health and platforms look more civilised 🙂 I wish Current DRMs take note from your ideas 🙏🏻
@@debdulalsenapati1391 They won't unfortunately, but there is hope as long as people like you appreciate it 🙏
@@ManiSudhanshu I understand your frustration sir. All of us staff who work hard to bring change is nullified time to time by rigid ministry, Board, Officer mentality and lack of coordination, constantly changing direction and not valueing the valuable staff. It's depressing. I see change of mindset in myself too before joining and now after 10yrs of service. It happens sadly. But then those who only know to work hard and serve the nation will keep doing so no matter the shortcomings of the system 🙏🏻
I really appreciate relentless work of all those service staff with managers like you overlooking and trying my best to immitate the same 🙏🏻😌
@@debdulalsenapati1391 Not frustrated, just trying to put the record stright. Happy in whatever I am doing today 🙏
Meaningful discussion
🙏
Vande Bharat is future hai jalne wale jlte rho or burai krte rho ❤ burai krne wale bhi indian railways me hi travel krte hai fun fact😂
From the time conversation started, first thing to appreciate is the vocal quality of Shree Sudhanshu Mani which compelled to listen entire video. Inspite of such a great achievement nowhere does he mentions it with to much pride. He probably has certain reservations on planning and has right to express as a experience super top boss. However he doesn't criticise in a indecent manner. These qualities only make such high profile individuals. Salute to Mani .Sir
46:57
Vaise bhi Solar power aur wind power, donho hii kaafi inefficient aur unreliable hain. Nuclear power hii sahi raasta hain. Par ek nuclear plant banaane ke liye bhi bahut samay lagta hain aur uska initial cost bahut jyaada hoata hain.
Reality hit hard now but this will help us grow .. this man is real
India needs Master plan for local public transport n population needs fully general coach trains for industrial labours.First start centralised route map from Nagpur a 0 mile n priority to 1 tourist 2 long journey sleeper coaches n 3 trains for ports 4 Military depots routes near border areas 5 centralised food distribution FCI godowns 6 Railway passenger n goods trains centralised maintenance workshops 7 Centralised Railway staff training Institutions 8 Railway track Monitoring system like France 9 Solar electric manufacturing system 10 Centralised petrolium train depots .🙏🇮🇳
Very encouraging shift in the government machinery and drivers. Hope to see more ministers like Ashwini and leaders like Modi emerging in Indian horizon. It's time everyone converges with the India growth story and every effort should be made to accelerate the journey
Hey Buddy can you explain about the following Indian Legends, Kingdoms and Philosophies:
Indian Legeneds:
1. Adi Shankaracharya
2. Gautam Buddha
3. Mahavir Jain
4. Ashoka the Great
5. Guru Gobind Singh
6. Swami Vivekananda
7. Bodhi Dharma: He spread Martial Arts to China
8. Rani Rudramma Devi: How she is the Best women Warrior of India
9. Bodisena: Spread Buddhism to Japan and it is still followed highly there
Indian Kingdoms:
1. Vijayanagara Empire
2. Sathavahana Dynasty
3. Chola Dynasty
4. Sikh Empire
5. Gupta Empire
6. Mauryan Empire
7. Ahoms
8. Rajputs
Indian Philosophies:
1. Questions in Prashna Upanishad
2. Bhagavad Gita and Uddava Gita
3. Charvaka Philosophy
4. Why Yoga and Meditation is so Efficient
5. Debates in Ancient India
6. Why Indians worshiped idols, nature and everything. There are a lot of controversies around this. Many invaders and current day Indians criticize this. But Gita gives an excellent answer
amazing comment
Sudhanshu ji always give new perspective to things. Very informative.
🙏
Great to see and listen a great personality
Son of Varanasi, blessed by Mahadev himself.
😊
Very good information
Thank you for this talk, Sir. I thoroughly loved the manner in which you articulate each point so very well.
🙏🙏
Very nice train. Wonderful experience 👍👍👍👍
Brilliant podcast as always🙏🏼👍
🙏
Humre idhar hon chahiye USA type - department of transportation, aise karke USDOT dekh kr lagta hai ek dum boss hai wo poore US ke.
Integral study karni padegi bahut saari. Poore desh me Transit Orient development sochna padega with integrated study
Salute him Sir
Man said "Pvt. worker ka efficiency kam ho, output uska zyada hota he"..bruh.
Very good explanation geart work sir.
🙏
Thanks!
Congratulations for 1L subscribers.
Very informative podcast
🙏
Really deserve great appreciation.
🙏
मैं उस दिन के इंतज़ार में हूँ। जिस दिन मनी जी बधाई देंगें सरकार को अच्छा काम करने की।
I also wait for the day when you shed your gullibility 😊🙏
Considering how trains were 30 years ago we can justifiably be proud of the achievements in 10 years. Thinking small will not get you far. Our engineers can learn fast and can not be dismissive about the possibility. Underestimating the skill is pessimistic. We do not have to reinvent the wheel.
Mani sir ko Railway secretary appoint krna chahiye
Great Man.... In India there is long history of anti national elements always dominates Really True Nationalism because powerful cartel of corrupt politician, corrupt bureaucracy and foreign forces. Famous example Late Shree Dr. APG Abdul Kalam in Hovercraft case in defense. Isro Dr. Nambi Narayanan, and many more along with Sudhanshu Mani. But it is unfortunate in present Nationalist Govt. I found a Extremely Good Technical and Practical Knowledge , courage to put right thing an balanced way...
ANY TRANSITION TAKES TIME ELECTRIFICATION IS GOOD OPTION. IN ANY CASE 100% IS NOT THERE N WE WILL NEED SOME BACKUP. WE MAY CONVERT THEM TO MIXED OR DUAL MODE
Interesting Conversation 👍
🙏
He is pessimist. Modiji ne DFC bana diya...as announced by lalu, when I was 7 years old. Today i am 27 years old. 20 years ka paap Modiji dho rahe hai
Agreed
Bahut sahi, isi pessimism ne hi to 18 months men train bana di thi 🙏
Train 18 was made by the experts of ICF, not the government, so all the credit should go to them.
Firstly they criticized the project_ now they are claiming credit for it .
Don't be brainwashed by political messages, see the truth within.
@@sanjoybhattacharya7476 both the Givg and Rly board were peeved ICF made almost on their. They could not claim any thing. They stopped it for two years. When Train 18 went viral modi the publicity hAwk swooped for neat. Any thing and every thing for election stunt.
@@maitri74 Absolutely right, Sir.
This Govt has no contribution, except in helping some Railway Board members in derailing the project & now Claiming credit for an achievement in which they don't have an iota of contribution .
Very refreshing to see nana patekar on vaad...☺️
😁
keep the good work up arihant bhratashri
Hydrogen powerplants hum bana sakte hain for electricity? 🤔
India needs more than one Sudhanshu.
His next project will be to produceand train
more Sudhashus
👍
Again a good podcast
🙏
Lets see in 2 years time frame, there would be improvements
Sudhanshu ji can suggest used Diesel locomotives for export to countries . Sudhanshu ji must suggest and give solution
Yes, that is an option to be followed strongly
Love you sir ❤️❤️❤️❤️
🙏
Every man has his own perspective.
If I say VB is providing features and comfort still ok, when tracks gets better VB is capable of delivering speed. You can't say you make VBs on that time. If one part is on and second is slow to deliver means we are on track and one day we'll pick up.
No blame game, on every point blaming govt means you need all the powers in your own hands, you can't, there is a system and organisation in place.
Jo last mey baat kahi hai ki Main station key baad fast train ho usmey risk bhi hai China key case mey fast railway to hai but loss making hai. To uska bhi panga hai kahi na kahi railway line banana koi badi baat nhi hai, profit mey railway line banana important hai.
Hala ki jo Delhi wali baat kahi wo kafi sahi hai but prices matter karengey, China ney bhi aisi hi strategy use ki thi start mey but fir over use Kari or loss making line bana di.
20 sal se make in India? Kya bol rahe sir??
seats kuch time tak spain se aa rhi thi, abhi tata bna rhi hai . Naye orders me bhi tata ne clarify kiya ki wo seats ka kaam continue rakhengi.
do google search -- tata clarifies vande bharat seats
High regards to Moni sir from ASSAM RAIL PASSENGERS ASSOCIATION
🙏
To change the complete tracks in India for higher speed upgradation will take more than Rs.1 lakh crore.
Yes…even more
& such Upgradation is pointless
@@sanjoybhattacharya7476 why?
Way more. Indian tracks are huge.
Any Upgradation costs money, which needs to have a return, thus raising train fares.
It's okay to upgrade tracks on major routes, where there is sufficient demand & traffic to support the huge expenditure, but not for all routes.
Mani sir is delightfully informative while listening . On electrification, I would like to give my two cents opinion...Electrified Railway is relatively cleaner than Diesel driven railways due to efficiency of electric engine being more than Diesel engine. So, his opinion is not correct per se
TRIPPLING AND DUARDUPPLING IS ALSO GOING ON . SO ALTOGETHER NEW ALIGNMENT MAY NOT BE NECESSARY FOR ACHIEVING DIMOND RAILWAY FOR GOODS TRAFFIC.
aisa kar do vaisa kar do , are Bhai you coming from system know how difficult its to change things , Mani looks bit Frustrated his earlier interview was Good but this one is more about nit picking, BTW one suggestion pls try to include Pictures & Statistics also of things like when talking about accident picture of train , audio / visual Qs . Helps understanding the context better . Cheers Good work
Sach bhi sun sakne ki aadat daaliye bhai 😊
@@ManiSudhanshu more essential to have audit for sectional speeds... A section can determined 2b 400kms and inusive of stops b upgraded 2 avg 4hrs runs irrespective of no of stops... What trains or trainsets used r irrelevant... First to 80kmph avg ie 5hrs then towards 100kmph reach in eaxh state... Before anything else is attempted... Trainsets r available locos r available... 2...capacity augmentation ie more passengers per day runs / long loops wn passenger availability is below capacity, 3....rake utilization shd b optimised to 18-20hrs in 24hr runs.. Ie 4 hrs max allocated to maintenance nothing more per rake 4.....communication devices installed w control room, track, maintenance,Sm, forward Loco n one behind in real time operating Navi n real time area n track knowledge via navi software 4lp
अंत्या, उपांत्य, उपोपांत्य -> Final, Semifinal, Quarterfinal
Any Future Railway Projects?
Hi Mani Sir , I'm Ajit Singh , I'm the same guy who wrote that famous fb post which is Viral these days .
If you remember , we've met earlier.
I came to your place in Lko.
सिर्फ एक बात कहूंगा ...... सरकार आपको बेशक पद्मश्री न दे , पर भारत की जनता ने आपको भारत रत्न मान लिया है ।
May God bless you .
Ajit Singh ji, aap ne shuru kiya tha wo post? Haan, bahuton ne mujhe bheja, idhar udhar se! Bahut bahut dhanyavaad 😊
Lekin jo badlav huva hai usko najar andaj nahi kar sakte hai....jaise pahle train me jo sahuliyat milti thi unse behtar sahuliyat milti hai vande bhart me....or choro chapati jyada tar bandh huyi....vande bharat banane wale engineers ko Salam....