Just upgraded to the Silhouette 4, still have my Cameo 3. Downloaded the Design space to see how it works and was lost. I'm good with computers, your video just confirmed for me that I made the right choice. Thanks for taken the time to compare them.
I have been looking into buying one of the machines for about a year now, i’ve watched many many videos. Your video is by far the best at everything, you explained everything a beginner without any idea about either machine needs to know. You just gained a supporter and a subscriber. I’m gonna go look into more of your videos to finalise my decision. But i’m leaning into the cricut more as a beginner and maybe i’ll treat myself to the cameo later on when I get the hang of them. Thank you so much ❤ I didn’t even feel like it was an hour. No time wasted!
Deal breaker #1 for me is that you MUST be on-line for Cricut. There are times I have limited or spotty internet or I just want to design without getting on-line and you can do that with the Silhouette Design Studio. Deal breaker #2 is that you do need a subscription to effective use the cutter. You can access Silhouette's on-line designs and can also save your own designs to your own hard drive but also to your on-line library. You do NOT need to pay a monthly subscription for this. And you can purchase single designs whenever you want. And Silhouette always has free files that they are giving away. The machines offer similar cutting, print and cut etc. now (both companies have improved over the years) so the extras are what makes a difference for me. I am not trying to convince others about which machine to buy but to encourage them to do their homework on the restrictions and advantages of each machine before purchase. Silhouette does have lower cost options for beginners, the 8.5 x 11 Portrait is often available (on sale) for about $120. I find the Silhouette software intuitive but I have been working with it since maybe 2008? I started with the Silhouette Portrait when it was first released after I had less than optimal results with the original 12" cartridge-based Cricut. Their background as commercial plotters made their machine superior at the time and they offered Print-n-cut long before Cricut did. Of course Cricut has improved since then but Silhouette still shines in their accuracy and print-n-cut.
You have no idea how many times I've been inconvenienced by this! I live in a shared house with WIFI and sometimes the WIFI goes down and the machine becomes a brick! However, the worse part is that there is no way to turn off automatic updates for Cricut Design Space. I work on high performance kites and often, a software update would release and my measurements would be off for some reason. Cricut's software is absolutely trash and very inaccurate and unreliable. One time our WIFI was down for 2 weeks until we had the internet provider come in and fix it and I was unable to cut for 1 week oh but what happened with the last week? Surprise, I got a Cameo 5 and my Cricut Maker 3 has been on the floor collecting dust.
Do you want to sell your Cricut Maker 3? I want to start crafting and am low on cash and would want to patronize your maker 3 if you will sell to me@supernova4760
I was today years old when I learned you could add a print bleed in silhouette 🤣 I've been using silhouette for 8+ years, like daily for my Etsy shop. So, thank you, it's been a life saver!!
You are by far the most professional person I have seen, making videos for judgments based on facts!!!! I have already purchased a Cricut three. I don’t think I would have been able to learn the Silhouette out of the box. Now that I know more about how to design, I wish I had purchased both machines! I will be recommending this video to several friends who are thinking about purchasing a cutting machine. Bravo!
Thank you for this comment!!! It made my day! After posting this video I was really insecure about how long it was. I appreciate you taking the time to build me back up with your comment 🥰
First video I watched that wasn’t sort of sponsored with honest opinion. Thank you so much! I love the fact that you compared the two in different situations and needs with factional information. Again, thanks!
I opened this video thinking to purchase Cameo 5 then ended up choosing Cricut Maker 3 instead! 😄❤️ I am so happy that I didn't rush and get across this incredibly explained video! When I saw the length is almost 1 hour I said "Yess!! This is exactly what I want!" Thank you so much for helping me and other people to make up our minds ❤️
I loved my maker... until it had a software glitch just a couple months out of warranty and it is now a brick. Customer service offered sympathy and a $25 coupon toward a new machine. Never dealing with them again. (I also don't want to deal with design space ever again)
I just got the Cameo 5 off Amazon and they are selling a bundle for $399.99 that comes with the Cameo 5 whole bunch of vinyls, extra autoblade, pen, and some tools. I found this to be a pretty good deal because they're selling the Cameo 5 base for $379.99.
I have both the Cricut Maker and Silhouette Cameo 4. I love my Silhouette Studio software I have been a user since cameo 1 and it is my cutter of choice but I would recommend the Cricut Maker for those who just want to cut without designing.
👍🏼 That’s actually a brilliant way of looking at it-Arno I really enjoy working with my Cricut and design my own files to cut with it (using vector software like Adobe Illustrator and Linearity Curve for iPad).
hi there what about if i want do stickers and trading cards what is better for me i will need both Debossing and embossing and Engraving on trading card covers and make tiny boxes and stickers
Silhouette Cameo Designer Edition Software does have an auto arrange option it is called "Nesting" . Nesting does not arrange by color, it does auto arranges the designs to fit on the material, designs can be all the same or a variety of designs. The free Silhouette Standard Edition Software and above has an option in the settings to cut to the edge of the material. Silhouette studio not only allows you to save your designs to your computer or cloud drive it also has a library back-up option. If you edit a Silhouette design or create your own you can save your edited and created design to your computer or cloud drive. Save your design in a variety of file formats depending on which edition of Silhouette software you are using. Additional shapes available in the Designer Edition Plus and more in the Business addition. You can also use the Silhouette Software and connect to your Cameo offline. Thank you Karley for your excellent review.
hi bro i just want to know if i want do stickers and trading cards what is better for me i will need both Debossing and embossing and Engraving on trading card covers and make tiny boxes and stickers
You can repeat a job on Cricut very easily. I had to cut 64 roses out of cardstock for a project. One rose per sheet. It was the same cut but I needed it done on different colors of paper. To redo a job, simply cut your first piece and when the mat comes out, remove that paper, put a new sheet on the mat and hit the load button then the go (start) button. It will then cut the same exact job. Do this as many times as you need to without going back to the computer. That’s why the load button continues to flash after you’re done. It’s waiting to see if you are going to repeat the cut. When you click done in design space, it knows you’re done with that cut. Also, any time you have two conflicting devices on Bluetooth, just turn off the device you don’t want connected. No need to find a cable. Thanks for the video! 👍🏼
Yes! I love the repeat job on Cricut! Sorry if I made that unclear- I knew cricut had a repeat job and I’m happy to see silhouette catching up! I actually did turn off every conflicting Bluetooth device with no luck. Silhouette’s Bluetooth has always been a little finicky on the first connection for me so I love having the usb cable as a back up :)
I never used my Cricut Maker without USB cable and consequently never had connection issues. I'm very active on a Redditt sub and users report Bluetooth connection problems all the time. In few ocasion they aslo reported USB connection issues but such instances are few and far between. In six years of use I can't recall a situation when I was not able to connect using USB. While my Maker is still running strong I am about to add a new machine and I have my eyes on Cameo 5 Plus. I need a bit wider format machine. I'm waiting for that model to become available. I came here to get more acquainted with Cameo 5 models and their capabilities. I very much appreciate your overal work in this field and your expertise. Keep doing great job!
I've really been struggling with the decision, but I finally decided to start with Cricut Maker 3, and when I feel more confident, I can always buy a different make/model - I appreciate this video and the work you put into your presentations.
After a year of frustration, and multiple hours talking with support, I finally made a change and went to Silhouette Cameo 5. It is far superior to the Cricut. The machine, software, and mats are all better.
I have had a Silhouette since it was an 8 1/2 x 11 manual fed machine and a Cricut that used Cricut cartridges. I think you did a good job with the video however, I get frustrated when it is suggested that if someone isn't tech savvy to get a Cricut. I think the Cricut software is VERY clunky. Silhouette's software functionality is very similar to the MS office suite bit even if you're not "tech" savvy, it's very logical to a certain degree for all types of end users. I think there are ALOT of extra steps in the Cricut software and most of them I have to find a video because they're not very logical so I have to look it up. I like how the Crciut machine is made. I still have one and use it for.Disney exclusives and I like the tshirt, onesies, etc templates to do iron on. Cricuts trace feature is not anywhere near as robust as the Silhouette and you have to have pay for monthly access if you want it to be just a little better. There are alot.of card makers out there and if they new they could stamp an image and use the picscan to.cut it out on the Silhouette, they would be sold. Again, I don't dislike the Cricut but there are SO many things that are better on the Cameo/Silhouette ❤
Going for a Cameo 5. I will mainly use it for HTV designs for custom hardcover books. I read the Cameo 5 will also have an embossing tool so might try that as well.
You sold me on a Cricut, cut and print looks so much easier with the Cricut vs the Silhouette. I put the cart in front of the horse, way out in front of the horse. I picked up a Geo Knight 20sp, and then did a bunch of video research on cutting vinyl. It doesn't take much to snowball this crafting hobby. It's going to be a nice addition to my Multi needle Happy embroidery machine. Thank you for the video.
Cameo has a big advantage with Print then Cut, the optical sensor. You have more options within Silhouette Studio, but it isn't really any more difficult to use. After the first couple times using it, you'll be a master. Once you realize how restricted Cricut Design Space is, you'll possibly regret spending more money for less capability.
Nice video. Thank you. I just thinking about buying this machine. And do my research. Very understandable information. So many videos and it’s first one where explained everything
While I am an experienced maker who does 3D printing, electronics, and woodworking, I have decided on the Cricut Maker. I will probably be using Adobe Illustrator for my designs and just importing them into the Cricut software instead of using it to design. While the Cameo 5 Plus's 24-inch capacity is enticing, I doubt that it will limit what I make, and the lovely design and UX on the Cricut over the plasticky look of the Cameo are absolutely a factor for me. Thanks for a good video 🥰
Cricut is going downhill fast, I bought the Maker 3 and returned it. It is no better than the Explore Air 3. I have a Cameo too, it is so loud, so glad I watched this video to help me decide if I want the 5 or not. I just know I won't ever buy another Cricut machine. You can't even save and share designs in Design space, which is ridiculous. I pay monthly for their stuff that is amature at best. The Maker 3 is loud too, not much difference to me than the 5.
Thank you for your honest opinion about both. What would have been nice is a comparison to intricate cuts. While I feel Cameo does a great job, I saw a demonstration where Cricut did a better job. Could had been the type of paper, dull blade...I don't know. I have had all the Cameos and then I realized it had been 7 years since buying the Cameo 3. (It is no longer supported.) I can still buy a Cameo 5 and take my Business Edition with me. I was thinking strongly about Cricut but I know the Cameo well and I haven't been disappointed. I like the freedom of not having to be online and saving anywhere and sending to friends as to something I designed. You were very clear, slow, methodical in your video...thank you so very much.
brother scan N cut is another option. .Trying to buy one for my elemetary school teachers to use for bulletin boards and class projects. Most teachers are pretty busy so I was leaning towards the scan and cut, but I do like the electrostatic mat on the cameo 5.
Very informative, I wish I had seen this video before I bought a Cricut Explore 3 as a first vinyl cutter on Black Friday, almost wanted to run the machine over due to it failing to connect. Windows, Macbook, tablet, phones, nothing connected reliably. When I used the USB cable, it takes 3~4 tries and software will keep nagging me to use bluetooth After reading about how Cricut often bricks their machines remotely to prevent reselling the devices, which is a reason why they require you to be online to use Design Space, I've just purchased a Cameo 5 and will be returning the Cricut. I instantly love how configurable it is. I spend hours configuring my 3d printer and this is honestly how I expected the cutter should be.
Cricut does not brick machines to prevent reselling. It bricks machines reported faulty or stolen and send replacement machine to the owner. The issue is that sometimes owners of the bricked machines try to sell them to unsuspecting buyers. Working second hand machines can be used by the new owners without problem. All they have to do is to create their own account and register the machine. The original owner doesn't even have to deregister the machine, since they can be registered to multiple accounts.
The electrostatic mat sounds interesting. I think the cameo 5 is a better value and more flexible. I don’t like the closed system of cricut and exclusive materials needed for meatless cutting I like the card mat on cricut. Silhouette can be overwhelming
Great video, very helpful. I’m seriously thinking of changing from a Cricut Maker 3 to the Cameo 5 +. I’ve worked with Illustrator as a designer for over 30 years, so I prefer to have more software control over what and how I create. Also, we have a very good internet connection in the city, but we will be moving to the countryside next year, and it won’t be as reliable. I would still like to create if I lose the internet connection.
I have never owned either machines, but I have bought one of each for different businesses that I was employed at so that I could do the signage around the properties. In 2008 I needed to create a nonslip surface in the middle of the mall (on the tile) because at the top of every hour the automatic snowmachine would kick on and snow in center Court. At that time I bought the heavy duty blade and the peel and stick sandpaper that you use in industrial sites and I fed that through the Silouhette machine and it cut like a gem. I cut snowflakes and words out of the sandpaper and they kept everybody safe while sharing a message. Wish I had a picture to share. Then a few years later at a new company I bought a cricket so that the manager could run it as well since it was a little more straightforward and in that position I didn’t need to do as many creative things. Now, it has been five years without access to a machine and I’m going crazy. Thank you for taking the time to deep dive. I know which machine I’m asking for Christmas! This time it will be… mine😊
i am a beginner and been wanting to make vinyl stickers labels etc for home use.. so everyone says i can just buy the most basic one.. but the thing is cricut joy here costs 199€ and i found a great deal with cameo 4 at only 249€.. 😅 i am so tempted to buy the cameo but im scared i might get overwhelmed when it actually arrives 😅
Thanks Karley. I have an old Silhouette Cameo which is a great machine but I couldn’t stand the noise. I had intended to upgrade to 4 but they were still very noisy, so I bought a Cricut Joy, then the Maker and they solid machines. I think the Silhouette Design store is by far superior to Cricut - Silhouette also has free files that you can use forever whereas Cricut’s free files are for a limited time and Cricut expects you to subscribe to be able to use certain design tools. I don’t mind paying for files (as I’m not a regular user, but, for my budget, a subscription is money wasted) I also like the setup of the Design Store where you can search by designer. Cricut has certainly improved their design tools over the last few years and is slowly catching up to Silhouette. I like the idea of the electrostatic mat - awesome for intricate designs. I live in another country, so when I was having a technical difficulty, I emailed for support and the team from Silhouette responded promptly and sorted out my issue.
Very informative and detailed. Thank you. Think I'm going to buy the Silouhette. Mainly for price and tools added. Who knows, later down the road, I might purchase the Cricut but for a starter who's tech savvy, I think I can handle the Silouhette 🤣. gave you a thumbs up and subscribed. again, thank you.
Awesome comparison!! I already bought the Cameo 5 ... HOT off Da PRESS!! lol.. I had the Cameo 2; and wanted an updated version. Also the Free usage of Silhouette Studio, is more than valuable than the limitations of Cricut... but to each his own! also, I think it's more about what you've grown to use, and feel comfortable using the program. also the Design Studio, had dropped their prices from $99 to $50 for Business Edition, which allows you all the controls and options!
Design Space doesn't have a Bezier tool (necessary for designing within the software rather than importing from another program). Auto-arrange? Cricut creates a sort of box around each element it cuts, and moves anything that has been rotated into the zero-degree orientation. I find I need to rearrange almost every item on a Cricut mat in order to get the most efficient use of my materials.
You can actually arrange everything on canvas and attach to keep the arrangement but what you said about designing capabilities is true. I create my stuff in another (vector) program and upload to the Design Space.
I started with the Cricut that had cartridges many years ago, I sadly wasn’t impressed with customer service, as after only 15months it gave up and they were no help at all. Eventually went to Silhouette Cameo and loved it, I have since owned the original Cameo, 3,4, and now the 5, I’ve purchased the 5 for the Electrostatic mat, was thinking of the Curio but that would take up too much space. I also purchased the Cricut Maker 3 so that I could do some engraving and also cut out some balsa wood, not impressed with either the Design Space or the cutting of several materials 😢 I find the DS Is clunky and confusing I’ve now sold it as the software was driving me insane. Another downside to the Design Space is you cannot use it without the Internet which I find insane, wheee as you can do everything with the Silhouette provided you have power and a computer iPad or Laptop that’s another big PLUS for me.
I am getting to be an old man, closer to 80YO than to 70YO. I just got back from the VA hospital in Biloxi, Ms. I was there for a bi-annual vision tuneup. I was at the Blind Rehab Center. BTW: Anyone low vision or blind with an honorable discharge from any branch of the military can go to this program. Some things at the VA are truly UNIQUE, but this is a GREAT program. Does NOT have to be service connected (not combat related). So, I guess you now know that I have limited sight. I am looking for somewhat of a hobby. While I was in Biloxi they had a CNC router and it was cutting out some signs with military emblems for each of hte5 major branches. It was fascinating and very beautiful. I thought about getting into the CNC business but I have decided against it, too messy and too expensive for what I want to do. My question is: "Can you do some things with the die cutters, making stencils, than might kinda look like the engravings? I know that is a mouth full, but you seem very experienced. I have pretty good computer skills That I learned at the Blind Rehab. Did I mention that they give you an iPhone, a Mac desktop, an IPad and some other items. But what is most important is that they teach you to use them as a blind person. Enough of that. If anyone has an interest or a need. Contact the VA and ask about the Visor program or simply call the VA hospital in Biloxi, Ms and ask for Blind Rehab Center. I would like to say that I just watched your video on Maker 3 vs Cameo 5. Great job. Very good research. That is one of the best reviews I think I have seen. Good Job. I think I'm leaning for the Cameo on price and technology. I think i mostly want to make stencils. Thanks again. Might you have a video on the foil embossing, I think that is what it is called. Or might you be able to lead me in the right direction. Thank you again. Please take care and be safe in all of your travels and all of your activities. Sincerely...
Thank you for this video, I am new to world of print and cut but I like designing and experimenting. I am also quite tech savvy, so I would be launching my craft hobby with the Silhouette Cameo 5 🎉 I will try the Cricut sometime in the future too as it was my first choice before I found this video.
Please can anyone advise the best silhouette software edition to purchase because I can see different options like business edition, designer edition plus, etc?
Since I bought the Cameo 4 one of my few issues is the crop marks when doing printed graphics to sublimate and then cut. I haven't had a single job that I couldn't finish without a single issue with crop marks. I believe it was my trigger to decide to change to DTF and White toner print which I have decided to fully change my prints to that technique and use vinyl only for accesories and hard surfaces when doing single or a few colors. Great video and information, thank you!
My only gripe with cricut is the rubber rollers break down too quickly with no local repair shops available in almost all states. You have to be ready to buy a new machine if your DIY repair job fails. Hence why I’m looking at the silhouette.
Thank you for making this video. I purchased the original Silhouette Cameo years ago, and I still use it. But I have heard so much about Cricuit, that now that I’m ready for an upgrade, I thought I’d get a Cricuit instead of a Silhouette this time. I literally had the Cricuit Maker 3 in the online checkout when it occurred to me that I should see what TH-cam had to say. I watched your entire video and as a result, I think I would have been disappointed with the Cricuit Maker 3. I have decided to stick with Silhouette Cameo and will purchase the 5. Thanks again!
I think that youTube has more videos on the use of the cricut than the Cameo. I do not get what all the hype is about, I have had silhouettes for many years. What sold me was design capabilities. Sure there is a learning curve, but that's with everything. Then the fact that you have to be connected at all times to even use the cricut, doesn't make sense to me. I have the 4, but really hope to upgrade soon!
Thank you so much for making this video! I am so happy that I found it since these are the 2 that I have been comparing back and forth. I am an absolute complete beginner. I think I am going to buy the Maker 3.......if i find down the road that my skills have improved and I need more, then I will look at buying a Cameo 5
Which machine is best for cutting leather, faux leather, cotton vinyl with a stabilizer fused on back, clear vinyl, and all fabrics? Should I be looking at the Brother Scan N Cut? Great presentation here, thank you so much.
Just found your channel and love it thanks for so much information I am still on the edge of which machine I want. I want to make punch cards for my knitting machine which is my first priority in Canada the machines are about the same price as the ones I seen but still need to check other places. I would sure appreciate your thoughts. Thanks again. Pat
I wish there was a machine that combined the best of both! It’s so hard to choose when they both have their good qualities. Thanks for sharing the info. By the way, where did you get your craft storage cabinets?
Thank you, it is deep information and no doubt it is going to help anyone to choose between them. in my case is still prefer brother scanncut sdx1200 over them
This video was so much more helpful than every other video!! Thank you! I am now however stuck between the curio 2 and the cameo 5. The big down fall for me with the cameo is it can’t engrave at all. Could you compare the two?
Cricut isn't exactly great at engraving, as she mentioned. You'd be better off investing in a dedicated engraving machine, like the X Tool, as she mentioned.
I know this is late but my explore 3 just went up and I’m looking for a new one. I’ve never seen your vids I just kinda wing it. I’m into everything but I’ve decided in my later years I’m a lousy multitasker so I’m going to stick to one or 2 things and that can be done with one of these. I think the circuit maker since I’m used to design space. Thank you Karly. I will see you around.😊
Hi Karley! Fantastic video! I'm leaning more towards the Cameo 5, however, I am having trouble comparing the two machines in terms of embossing. Have any thoughts?
Hello Karley. I stumbled across your page last night and I am so glad that I did. I am new to this stuff and my head was spinning on what machine to get. After watching this wonderful video, I am going with Silhouette. That is also what my daughter has and she likes it. She cuts out and uses the lettering on stuff and does shirts. I plan to do paint parties and want to be able to make my own stencils. What blade do you use and what material do you use for the stencils? I read somewhere about 4 mil. There is so many different things and I'm not sure which is the best to use. Thanks so much!
New sub. I really enjoyed you providing a non-biased review of both machines. I started on my phone in bed with the earlier video and then moved to the computer and found this video. I am a model railroader and will be looking to use the machine in model making instead of crafting. I have seen in forums where some modelers have had success in using the machines in a few applications. An instance I can provide where a fellow modified the tool to scribe styrene plastic to create a brick wall. In scale this is extremely tiny and it did work but was not perfect. I will be trying to make mask in vinyl to be transfered to metal and use it in electro etching and chemical etching. Although I havent yet purchased a machine. I would hands down go with the Cameo 5 as to not have the limitations of the cricut and a few features that I liked better as well. the lower price was not really a factor but for sure a bonus. In the next year I hope to get set up to move forward with this and you have really gave me a positive direction in which to start this adventure. Cheers, Rob
I own both a cricut maker and silhouette cameo4 . I use my cricut for cutting alot of my felt projects and love it. I feel like the machines are build more substancial but that being said I use my cameo the most. Because of the design limitation in cricut I design alot of things in silhouette. So therefore I will be buying the cameo 5 because I still feel limited in print and cut area as many things with cricut but I completely plan to keep using both for various reasons. You did a great job and I am exceited to get the ES mat! That is a game changer to me i hate mats!
Hi Karley. I happened upon your video when searching info for embossing and engraving. I thought you were so informative and clear in explaining the method to using the engraving tool and how to fill in the lines etc in Silhouette. I own an Explore Air 2 and a cameo 4. I have owned the Cricut since 2021 and the Cameo just recently. I am having a lot of trouble understanding what the options that we would click on mean in order to make almost any project, move letters around, get the sizes of shapes to use as part of a design or template. I did see what you did for your circle, so I will be excited to give that a try. I was wondering if you have made a video explaining the basics for using the Cameo to make a some great things. I know and also have heard that Cricut is very user friendly but not as comprehensive as the Silhouette machine, etc. I am hoping you can help get me up and running. You have a great helpful manner and I am already enjoying your videos! Hope all is well, and that I will hear from you. Much appreciated. Dee.
Well that was the best comparison video ever thanks ! I am still not sure though ; cricut seems easier to use for beginners and silhouette maybe better for advance users .. I want to mainly do stickers and maybe cards stuff . I do like the new cameo5 advert for the electrostatic mat - and pixy might make it easier to do stickers …. But I may be wrong ? 😊
Karley, I in middle between Silhouette and Cricut. I’m familiar with Cricut I had the Explore Air 2 then Marker 2. Year 2021 I decided to move to Costa Rica. Between Marker 2 weight and customs a left a behind with a friend who Wedding planner. I preferred Cricut easy for me, Cricut has distributor but are Virtual Store. Silhouette America has distributor here but has Art, Craft and Classes. With Silhouette I not designer do not customizing, that where I like Cricut products. And the calibration for print and cut, I’m not likely manually adjusting, I like Cricut better.
Thank you very much for your review! I am very tech-savy, mostly using cardstock, stickers and print-then-cut. So, I am pretty sure the Silhouette is the better choice for me. However, I do wonder about other things, like: the cut quality, durability (of machine and the blades), faults, it the standard auto blade the only tool I need?, when to go for premium/other blades?, how well can the Silhouette do scoring (important for fold lines) compared to the Cricut?, material/pens availability (and fitment)?
I don't have any experience with the Cricut, but can maybe answer some of your questions, based on my experience so far with the Cameo 5, it's my first digital cutter and I've had it for about a month... If you're tech-savvy, then you shouldn't have any issues with using the Cameo or it's associated software. There are a lot of online tutorials/blogs too. With regards to a 'lack of support' that people mention, I had issues trying to get the Silhouette Connect plugin working with my version of Illustrator, I sent an email and they were very helpful and set up a remote support session, to try and diagnose the fault and came up with a solution. So far, I've been very pleased with the cut quality, just using the autoblade that came with the machine. I've cut 200-240gsm card, with no issues and also vinyl. The machine seems very durable to me, certainly more so than your average inkjet printer, so I've got no concerns with anything breaking. I'd recommend using the autoblade first, having a play with the machine and seeing what you can do. Then, if there are specific materials that you want to cut, you can buy a more specialised blade, e.g. if cutting fabric, then you would need the rotary blade, 2-3mm craft foam, a kraft blade etc. I've not scored material yet, but I don't see it being an issue, as the autoblade adjusts anywhere between 0.1mm and 1mm, in 0.1mm increments. So, if using 220gsm cardstock requires e.g. 0.7mm blade depth to cut, then try 0.3mm to score? A lot of the designs I've downloaded use a dashed line for folds, which also seems to work well. I've got a feeling that trying to score thin materials, e.g. paper may be somewhat more tricky, and an embossing tool may be more suited, but you would need an embossing mat too.
I have the cameo 4 pro. I have never been able to cut over 14 inches vinyl without it overlapping.. I'm considering the 5, getting reimbursed thru warranty..
I'm a digital artist and do my designs in photoshop. I want to import my designs for cutting. My work is also quite intricate and detailed so it will involve delicate cutting on fine art paper, 200 to 300gsm. I am also interested in using embossing tools. I would really appreciate your advice on which machine you think would be better suited for my needs. Thanks so much.
It looks like the DreamBox from Create Room. I just ordered the DreamBox 2 today because they are having an amazing Mother's Day Sale right now! It's on the higher side of cost, but it's a huge piece of furniture that will hold all of my crafting needs. ☺
What a great review! I have a cricut, I found print and cut via cricut is painful and waste a lot of papers...😢 I am planning to change to silhouette cameo 5 for print and cut🥰😍 Do you think curio2 is also good for this? This is so fun
I bought the Silhouette Cameo 5 - the roller broke in the first week, amazon replaced it no problem - That was in January of 2024, it is now December 2024 and guess what - it broke again. They do not sale replacement parts for this problem and I have learned to research that this is an on going problem. I have also had issues with the software and updates. I use this machine and software for my business. I don't have the money or time to keep replacing this machine. I am seriously thinking about getting a Cricut Maker 3.
I am a professional mixed media artist. I would like to cut fabric , heavy cardstock and stencil mylar. Would be designing intimate stencils. Would only be interested in fonts but not commercial designs.Which machine do you recommend? Thank you for your time. Great video. Jennie
Thank you for making this video. I'm wanting to start a stencil business and I ordered the cricut air 2 but it won't cut the stencil material I need to use. I'm leaning towards cameo sihloette .. pls advise
The most important function I am looking at is to cut fabric for appliqué for my embroidery. Which would you recommend? I watched another comparison of all cutters and the Cricut was the only one that cut intricate designs well.
Hi there, I'm thinking I will go with the cricut maker. I want to use it to make tshirts, luggage tags, passport holders and more. My 2nd business is a Travel agent and I feel based on this video that the cricut maker is the better options. What do you recomend?
Hello, and thank you for all your info on the cricut or silhouette machines. I want to make my own T-shirt designs and logos on different types of fabric with permanent vynyl paper and iron on paper. So was wondering what machine would be better for that? This is my main reason for wanting to buy one. Tired of just plain ole T shirts. lol
Which machine cut fabric better? I have a maker that is no longer recognizing the quick swap tools. Therefore, I’m looking into buying a new machine. I don’t live in the warranty zone so I’m not worrying about customer service so much. Both software is difficult to understand especially silhouette. I want my machine mainly to cut faux leather for bags. Which one would you recommend?
Totally amazes me to this day that either company has not gone WiFi as it is far more stable and has a greater range and bandwidth. Bluetooth is so unstable I cannot use it...I must cable the device to have reliable printing and jobs that finish and dont waste my stuff. The problem of both being bluetooth would NOT be a problem with WiFi as they would have individual IP addresses and thus no conflict. I have both the Cameo 4 and Cricut Maker 3 (my new machine).
Hi Karely! Great video, thanks so much! 😊 I'm so torn, and can't decide which machine to purchase. I'll be using it primarily to cut craft felt and also some heat transfer vinyl. Softwares not a major concern as I can use Adobe to design. If you were me, which would you go for? I just need someone to decide for me 😂
I also still have to decide on the cameo, I like it best for the electrostatic mat and the hot foil but I don't know if I can cut the same materials that the maker 3 cuts, can you give me more information?
@@annunziatasessa8352 it’s does- you need the Kraft knife. But neither machine cuts it well so I don’t recommend it. It can cut super basic/ big shapes- nothing intricate.
Hi! I looove your video but still I'm not sure which one should I get. I'm really new at this, I'm starting a new proyect with felt and I want to know which one would be the best and easy to cut felt fabric and also to stamp images on the fabric using a press machine. I know that the circuit comes with a mini press but don't know if the silhouette does. Please if you can help me out. Thank you so much !
Very informative, but I am a beginner and I want to print stickers,make t- shirt prints and being able to print on vinyl, foils etc and just have fun doing lots of crafting that should I get a cricut maker 3 or cameo 5? I know with cameo I can do bigger prints if I need letters for signs, boards, posters etc…… Also from what I been hearing cameo does more than cricut and can do what cricut does but better
really amazing video i'm about to buy today so i would love if you give me final answer . i want use the machine to do small custom boxs for trading cards . and also trading cards and stickers i see both offer same but it will cost extra tools
Thank you for all the info. I would like to make stickers that I can peel off a backing sheet, without having to cut the backing sheet, but where I can make a different cut for the backing sheet (so I can give star stickers to students that they can add to a journal or take home for their refrigerator door:). Also, do you have a video on scoring fold lines using the Silhouette? What would you recommend for a sticker for a car rear window or bumper that won't easily fall off?
Just upgraded to the Silhouette 4, still have my Cameo 3. Downloaded the Design space to see how it works and was lost. I'm good with computers, your video just confirmed for me that I made the right choice. Thanks for taken the time to compare them.
I have been looking into buying one of the machines for about a year now, i’ve watched many many videos. Your video is by far the best at everything, you explained everything a beginner without any idea about either machine needs to know. You just gained a supporter and a subscriber. I’m gonna go look into more of your videos to finalise my decision. But i’m leaning into the cricut more as a beginner and maybe i’ll treat myself to the cameo later on when I get the hang of them. Thank you so much ❤ I didn’t even feel like it was an hour. No time wasted!
Deal breaker #1 for me is that you MUST be on-line for Cricut. There are times I have limited or spotty internet or I just want to design without getting on-line and you can do that with the Silhouette Design Studio.
Deal breaker #2 is that you do need a subscription to effective use the cutter. You can access Silhouette's on-line designs and can also save your own designs to your own hard drive but also to your on-line library. You do NOT need to pay a monthly subscription for this. And you can purchase single designs whenever you want. And Silhouette always has free files that they are giving away.
The machines offer similar cutting, print and cut etc. now (both companies have improved over the years) so the extras are what makes a difference for me. I am not trying to convince others about which machine to buy but to encourage them to do their homework on the restrictions and advantages of each machine before purchase.
Silhouette does have lower cost options for beginners, the 8.5 x 11 Portrait is often available (on sale) for about $120. I find the Silhouette software intuitive but I have been working with it since maybe 2008? I started with the Silhouette Portrait when it was first released after I had less than optimal results with the original 12" cartridge-based Cricut. Their background as commercial plotters made their machine superior at the time and they offered Print-n-cut long before Cricut did. Of course Cricut has improved since then but Silhouette still shines in their accuracy and print-n-cut.
This is why I went with Cameo 5.
You have no idea how many times I've been inconvenienced by this! I live in a shared house with WIFI and sometimes the WIFI goes down and the machine becomes a brick! However, the worse part is that there is no way to turn off automatic updates for Cricut Design Space. I work on high performance kites and often, a software update would release and my measurements would be off for some reason. Cricut's software is absolutely trash and very inaccurate and unreliable. One time our WIFI was down for 2 weeks until we had the internet provider come in and fix it and I was unable to cut for 1 week oh but what happened with the last week? Surprise, I got a Cameo 5 and my Cricut Maker 3 has been on the floor collecting dust.
If you need the internet to use something you paid for, then you've become their pet. They can take away what they've made you believe is yours.
@@executorprime Like the designs you get in the Design Space... They don't belong to you.
Do you want to sell your Cricut Maker 3? I want to start crafting and am low on cash and would want to patronize your maker 3 if you will sell to me@supernova4760
I was today years old when I learned you could add a print bleed in silhouette 🤣 I've been using silhouette for 8+ years, like daily for my Etsy shop. So, thank you, it's been a life saver!!
You are by far the most professional person I have seen, making videos for judgments based on facts!!!! I have already purchased a Cricut three. I don’t think I would have been able to learn the Silhouette out of the box. Now that I know more about how to design, I wish I had purchased both machines! I will be recommending this video to several friends who are thinking about purchasing a cutting machine. Bravo!
Thank you for this comment!!! It made my day! After posting this video I was really insecure about how long it was. I appreciate you taking the time to build me back up with your comment 🥰
this is the only video on youtube that compares cameo 5 vs maker 3. the rest still at cameo 4😊
I love how you actually describe everything, meanwhile I had to search up in multiple videos and still be confused thank you
First video I watched that wasn’t sort of sponsored with honest opinion. Thank you so much! I love the fact that you compared the two in different situations and needs with factional information. Again, thanks!
The best comparison video! About to buy Cameo 5 ❤
I opened this video thinking to purchase Cameo 5 then ended up choosing Cricut Maker 3 instead! 😄❤️ I am so happy that I didn't rush and get across this incredibly explained video! When I saw the length is almost 1 hour I said "Yess!! This is exactly what I want!"
Thank you so much for helping me and other people to make up our minds ❤️
nooooooooo
bad choice
why?@@NJVArtimations
Did you buy Maker 3? do you love it? any issues?
I loved my maker... until it had a software glitch just a couple months out of warranty and it is now a brick. Customer service offered sympathy and a $25 coupon toward a new machine. Never dealing with them again. (I also don't want to deal with design space ever again)
I just got the Cameo 5 off Amazon and they are selling a bundle for $399.99 that comes with the Cameo 5 whole bunch of vinyls, extra autoblade, pen, and some tools. I found this to be a pretty good deal because they're selling the Cameo 5 base for $379.99.
I have both the Cricut Maker and Silhouette Cameo 4. I love my Silhouette Studio software I have been a user since cameo 1 and it is my cutter of choice but I would recommend the Cricut Maker for those who just want to cut without designing.
I have the same ones. The Silhouette is way better for Print then Cut. I never viewed it that way. I do a lot of projects so I needed 2 machines.
👍🏼 That’s actually a brilliant way of looking at it-Arno I really enjoy working with my Cricut and design my own files to cut with it (using vector software like Adobe Illustrator and Linearity Curve for iPad).
Thank you, I like to think of myself as a designer but I’m not. So than you
Interested in selling one of your machines
hi there what about if i want do stickers and trading cards what is better for me i will need both Debossing and embossing and Engraving on trading card covers and make tiny boxes and stickers
Silhouette Cameo Designer Edition Software does have an auto arrange option it is called "Nesting" . Nesting does not arrange by color, it does auto arranges the designs to fit on the material, designs can be all the same or a variety of designs. The free Silhouette Standard Edition Software and above has an option in the settings to cut to the edge of the material. Silhouette studio not only allows you to save your designs to your computer or cloud drive it also has a library back-up option. If you edit a Silhouette design or create your own you can save your edited and created design to your computer or cloud drive. Save your design in a variety of file formats depending on which edition of Silhouette software you are using. Additional shapes available in the Designer Edition Plus and more in the Business addition. You can also use the Silhouette Software and connect to your Cameo offline. Thank you Karley for your excellent review.
hi bro i just want to know if i want do stickers and trading cards what is better for me i will need both Debossing and embossing and Engraving on trading card covers and make tiny boxes and stickers
I am going to get the Cameo and really appreciate all of your comments!
You can repeat a job on Cricut very easily. I had to cut 64 roses out of cardstock for a project. One rose per sheet. It was the same cut but I needed it done on different colors of paper. To redo a job, simply cut your first piece and when the mat comes out, remove that paper, put a new sheet on the mat and hit the load button then the go (start) button. It will then cut the same exact job. Do this as many times as you need to without going back to the computer. That’s why the load button continues to flash after you’re done. It’s waiting to see if you are going to repeat the cut. When you click done in design space, it knows you’re done with that cut. Also, any time you have two conflicting devices on Bluetooth, just turn off the device you don’t want connected. No need to find a cable. Thanks for the video! 👍🏼
Yes! I love the repeat job on Cricut! Sorry if I made that unclear- I knew cricut had a repeat job and I’m happy to see silhouette catching up!
I actually did turn off every conflicting Bluetooth device with no luck. Silhouette’s Bluetooth has always been a little finicky on the first connection for me so I love having the usb cable as a back up :)
@@KarleyHall gotcha! Definitely good to have one if needed. 😊
I never used my Cricut Maker without USB cable and consequently never had connection issues. I'm very active on a Redditt sub and users report Bluetooth connection problems all the time. In few ocasion they aslo reported USB connection issues but such instances are few and far between. In six years of use I can't recall a situation when I was not able to connect using USB.
While my Maker is still running strong I am about to add a new machine and I have my eyes on Cameo 5 Plus. I need a bit wider format machine. I'm waiting for that model to become available. I came here to get more acquainted with Cameo 5 models and their capabilities. I very much appreciate your overal work in this field and your expertise. Keep doing great job!
I've really been struggling with the decision, but I finally decided to start with Cricut Maker 3, and when I feel more confident, I can always buy a different make/model - I appreciate this video and the work you put into your presentations.
After a year of frustration, and multiple hours talking with support, I finally made a change and went to Silhouette Cameo 5. It is far superior to the Cricut. The machine, software, and mats are all better.
I have had a Silhouette since it was an 8 1/2 x 11 manual fed machine and a Cricut that used Cricut cartridges. I think you did a good job with the video however, I get frustrated when it is suggested that if someone isn't tech savvy to get a Cricut. I think the Cricut software is VERY clunky. Silhouette's software functionality is very similar to the MS office suite bit even if you're not "tech" savvy, it's very logical to a certain degree for all types of end users. I think there are ALOT of extra steps in the Cricut software and most of them I have to find a video because they're not very logical so I have to look it up. I like how the Crciut machine is made. I still have one and use it for.Disney exclusives and I like the tshirt, onesies, etc templates to do iron on. Cricuts trace feature is not anywhere near as robust as the Silhouette and you have to have pay for monthly access if you want it to be just a little better. There are alot.of card makers out there and if they new they could stamp an image and use the picscan to.cut it out on the Silhouette, they would be sold. Again, I don't dislike the Cricut but there are SO many things that are better on the Cameo/Silhouette ❤
Going for a Cameo 5. I will mainly use it for HTV designs for custom hardcover books. I read the Cameo 5 will also have an embossing tool so might try that as well.
You sold me on a Cricut, cut and print looks so much easier with the Cricut vs the Silhouette.
I put the cart in front of the horse, way out in front of the horse. I picked up a Geo Knight 20sp, and then did a bunch of video research on cutting vinyl. It doesn't take much to snowball this crafting hobby. It's going to be a nice addition to my Multi needle Happy embroidery machine.
Thank you for the video.
Cameo has a big advantage with Print then Cut, the optical sensor. You have more options within Silhouette Studio, but it isn't really any more difficult to use. After the first couple times using it, you'll be a master. Once you realize how restricted Cricut Design Space is, you'll possibly regret spending more money for less capability.
Nice video. Thank you. I just thinking about buying this machine. And do my research. Very understandable information. So many videos and it’s first one where explained everything
While I am an experienced maker who does 3D printing, electronics, and woodworking, I have decided on the Cricut Maker. I will probably be using Adobe Illustrator for my designs and just importing them into the Cricut software instead of using it to design.
While the Cameo 5 Plus's 24-inch capacity is enticing, I doubt that it will limit what I make, and the lovely design and UX on the Cricut over the plasticky look of the Cameo are absolutely a factor for me.
Thanks for a good video 🥰
Cricut is going downhill fast, I bought the Maker 3 and returned it. It is no better than the Explore Air 3. I have a Cameo too, it is so loud, so glad I watched this video to help me decide if I want the 5 or not. I just know I won't ever buy another Cricut machine. You can't even save and share designs in Design space, which is ridiculous. I pay monthly for their stuff that is amature at best. The Maker 3 is loud too, not much difference to me than the 5.
Thank you for your honest opinion about both. What would have been nice is a comparison to intricate cuts. While I feel Cameo does a great job, I saw a demonstration where Cricut did a better job. Could had been the type of paper, dull blade...I don't know. I have had all the Cameos and then I realized it had been 7 years since buying the Cameo 3. (It is no longer supported.) I can still buy a Cameo 5 and take my Business Edition with me. I was thinking strongly about Cricut but I know the Cameo well and I haven't been disappointed. I like the freedom of not having to be online and saving anywhere and sending to friends as to something I designed. You were very clear, slow, methodical in your video...thank you so very much.
brother scan N cut is another option. .Trying to buy one for my elemetary school teachers to use for bulletin boards and class projects. Most teachers are pretty busy so I was leaning towards the scan and cut, but I do like the electrostatic mat on the cameo 5.
Very informative, I wish I had seen this video before I bought a Cricut Explore 3 as a first vinyl cutter on Black Friday, almost wanted to run the machine over due to it failing to connect. Windows, Macbook, tablet, phones, nothing connected reliably. When I used the USB cable, it takes 3~4 tries and software will keep nagging me to use bluetooth After reading about how Cricut often bricks their machines remotely to prevent reselling the devices, which is a reason why they require you to be online to use Design Space, I've just purchased a Cameo 5 and will be returning the Cricut. I instantly love how configurable it is. I spend hours configuring my 3d printer and this is honestly how I expected the cutter should be.
Cricut does not brick machines to prevent reselling. It bricks machines reported faulty or stolen and send replacement machine to the owner. The issue is that sometimes owners of the bricked machines try to sell them to unsuspecting buyers. Working second hand machines can be used by the new owners without problem. All they have to do is to create their own account and register the machine. The original owner doesn't even have to deregister the machine, since they can be registered to multiple accounts.
The electrostatic mat sounds interesting. I think the cameo 5 is a better value and more flexible. I don’t like the closed system of cricut and exclusive materials needed for meatless cutting I like the card mat on cricut. Silhouette can be overwhelming
Great video, very helpful. I’m seriously thinking of changing from a Cricut Maker 3 to the Cameo 5 +. I’ve worked with Illustrator as a designer for over 30 years, so I prefer to have more software control over what and how I create. Also, we have a very good internet connection in the city, but we will be moving to the countryside next year, and it won’t be as reliable. I would still like to create if I lose the internet connection.
I have never owned either machines, but I have bought one of each for different businesses that I was employed at so that I could do the signage around the properties. In 2008 I needed to create a nonslip surface in the middle of the mall (on the tile) because at the top of every hour the automatic snowmachine would kick on and snow in center Court. At that time I bought the heavy duty blade and the peel and stick sandpaper that you use in industrial sites and I fed that through the Silouhette machine and it cut like a gem. I cut snowflakes and words out of the sandpaper and they kept everybody safe while sharing a message. Wish I had a picture to share. Then a few years later at a new company I bought a cricket so that the manager could run it as well since it was a little more straightforward and in that position I didn’t need to do as many creative things. Now, it has been five years without access to a machine and I’m going crazy. Thank you for taking the time to deep dive. I know which machine I’m asking for Christmas! This time it will be… mine😊
Thanks!!! I will buy the cameo 5 ❤
Thanks!
i am a beginner and been wanting to make vinyl stickers labels etc for home use.. so everyone says i can just buy the most basic one.. but the thing is cricut joy here costs 199€ and i found a great deal with cameo 4 at only 249€.. 😅 i am so tempted to buy the cameo but im scared i might get overwhelmed when it actually arrives 😅
Thanks Karley. I have an old Silhouette Cameo which is a great machine but I couldn’t stand the noise. I had intended to upgrade to 4 but they were still very noisy, so I bought a Cricut Joy, then the Maker and they solid machines. I think the Silhouette Design store is by far superior to Cricut - Silhouette also has free files that you can use forever whereas Cricut’s free files are for a limited time and Cricut expects you to subscribe to be able to use certain design tools. I don’t mind paying for files (as I’m not a regular user, but, for my budget, a subscription is money wasted) I also like the setup of the Design Store where you can search by designer. Cricut has certainly improved their design tools over the last few years and is slowly catching up to Silhouette. I like the idea of the electrostatic mat - awesome for intricate designs. I live in another country, so when I was having a technical difficulty, I emailed for support and the team from Silhouette responded promptly and sorted out my issue.
Hat mir sehr geholfen eine Entscheidung zu treffen, Cameo 5 👍 danke für dieses Video
I just purchased the Silhouette Cameo 5 today. I want to cut heat transfer vinyl for making screen prints
Congratulations!!!
Cameo 4 user 4 yrs strong seeking 5 Boss machines. Cameo made me
Very informative and detailed. Thank you. Think I'm going to buy the Silouhette. Mainly for price and tools added. Who knows, later down the road, I might purchase the Cricut but for a starter who's tech savvy, I think I can handle the Silouhette 🤣. gave you a thumbs up and subscribed. again, thank you.
Awesome comparison!! I already bought the Cameo 5 ... HOT off Da PRESS!! lol.. I had the Cameo 2; and wanted an updated version. Also the Free usage of Silhouette Studio, is more than valuable than the limitations of Cricut... but to each his own! also, I think it's more about what you've grown to use, and feel comfortable using the program. also the Design Studio, had dropped their prices from $99 to $50 for Business Edition, which allows you all the controls and options!
Detailed explaination , i really appreciate
Design Space doesn't have a Bezier tool (necessary for designing within the software rather than importing from another program). Auto-arrange? Cricut creates a sort of box around each element it cuts, and moves anything that has been rotated into the zero-degree orientation. I find I need to rearrange almost every item on a Cricut mat in order to get the most efficient use of my materials.
You can actually arrange everything on canvas and attach to keep the arrangement but what you said about designing capabilities is true. I create my stuff in another (vector) program and upload to the Design Space.
I started with the Cricut that had cartridges many years ago, I sadly wasn’t impressed with customer service, as after only 15months it gave up and they were no help at all. Eventually went to Silhouette Cameo and loved it, I have since owned the original Cameo, 3,4, and now the 5, I’ve purchased the 5 for the Electrostatic mat, was thinking of the Curio but that would take up too much space. I also purchased the Cricut Maker 3 so that I could do some engraving and also cut out some balsa wood, not impressed with either the Design Space or the cutting of several materials 😢 I find the DS Is clunky and confusing I’ve now sold it as the software was driving me insane. Another downside to the Design Space is you cannot use it without the Internet which I find insane, wheee as you can do everything with the Silhouette provided you have power and a computer iPad or Laptop that’s another big PLUS for me.
Thanks for making a very informative video. I hacve been tossing between a the two and have decided to get a Silhouette.
I am getting to be an old man, closer to 80YO than to 70YO. I just got back from the VA
hospital in Biloxi, Ms. I was there for a bi-annual vision tuneup. I was at the Blind
Rehab Center. BTW: Anyone low vision or blind with an honorable discharge from any branch of the military can go to this program. Some things at the VA are truly UNIQUE, but this is a GREAT program. Does NOT have to be service connected (not combat related). So, I guess you now know that I have limited sight. I am looking for somewhat of a hobby.
While I was in Biloxi they had a CNC router and it was cutting out some signs with military emblems for each of hte5 major branches. It was fascinating and very beautiful. I thought about getting into the CNC business but I have decided against it, too messy and too expensive for what I want to do. My question is: "Can you do some things with the die cutters, making stencils, than might kinda look like the engravings? I know that is a mouth full, but you seem very experienced. I have pretty good computer skills That I learned at the Blind Rehab. Did I mention that they give you an iPhone, a Mac desktop, an IPad and some other items. But what is most important is that they teach you to use them as a blind person. Enough of that. If anyone has an interest or a need. Contact the VA and ask about the Visor program or simply call the VA hospital in Biloxi, Ms and ask for Blind Rehab Center.
I would like to say that I just watched your video on Maker 3 vs Cameo 5. Great job. Very good research. That is one of the best reviews I think I have seen. Good Job. I think I'm leaning for the Cameo on price and technology. I think i mostly want to make stencils. Thanks again.
Might you have a video on the foil embossing, I think that is what it is called. Or might you be able to lead me in the right direction. Thank you again. Please take care and be safe in all of your travels and all of your activities.
Sincerely...
Wow your knowledge is incredible. Subbed! And you really helped me pick a machine.
Thank you for this video, I am new to world of print and cut but I like designing and experimenting. I am also quite tech savvy, so I would be launching my craft hobby with the Silhouette Cameo 5 🎉 I will try the Cricut sometime in the future too as it was my first choice before I found this video.
Please can anyone advise the best silhouette software edition to purchase because I can see different options like business edition, designer edition plus, etc?
Since I bought the Cameo 4 one of my few issues is the crop marks when doing printed graphics to sublimate and then cut. I haven't had a single job that I couldn't finish without a single issue with crop marks. I believe it was my trigger to decide to change to DTF and White toner print which I have decided to fully change my prints to that technique and use vinyl only for accesories and hard surfaces when doing single or a few colors. Great video and information, thank you!
My only gripe with cricut is the rubber rollers break down too quickly with no local repair shops available in almost all states. You have to be ready to buy a new machine if your DIY repair job fails. Hence why I’m looking at the silhouette.
That’s my problem right now.
literally why I'm here.. my rubber rollers have broken.. and the DIY seems to be a bit much.
Thank you for making this video. I purchased the original Silhouette Cameo years ago, and I still use it. But I have heard so much about Cricuit, that now that I’m ready for an upgrade, I thought I’d get a Cricuit instead of a Silhouette this time. I literally had the Cricuit Maker 3 in the online checkout when it occurred to me that I should see what TH-cam had to say. I watched your entire video and as a result, I think I would have been disappointed with the Cricuit Maker 3. I have decided to stick with Silhouette Cameo and will purchase the 5. Thanks again!
Have you got Cameo 5 yet? Please share if you love it and if any issues :)
I think that youTube has more videos on the use of the cricut than the Cameo. I do not get what all the hype is about, I have had silhouettes for many years. What sold me was design capabilities. Sure there is a learning curve, but that's with everything. Then the fact that you have to be connected at all times to even use the cricut, doesn't make sense to me. I have the 4, but really hope to upgrade soon!
@@janstetler9888How is the software/program to use ? Are there a lot of glitches, issues with it?
Thank you so much for making this video! I am so happy that I found it since these are the 2 that I have been comparing back and forth.
I am an absolute complete beginner.
I think I am going to buy the Maker 3.......if i find down the road that my skills have improved and I need more, then I will look at buying a Cameo 5
Which machine is best for cutting leather, faux leather, cotton vinyl with a stabilizer fused on back, clear vinyl, and all fabrics? Should I be looking at the Brother Scan N Cut? Great presentation here, thank you so much.
I have the same questions! I’m a bag maker looking to use materials as you mentioned above ❤
Cricut can’t read Unicode fonts but Silhouette can. Clear winner for me because I use Unicode fonts a lot!
Just found your channel and love it thanks for so much information I am still on the edge of which machine I want. I want to make punch cards for my knitting machine which is my first priority in Canada the machines are about the same price as the ones I seen but still need to check other places. I would sure appreciate your thoughts. Thanks again. Pat
Thanks so much, I will buy maker 3 because feel like noise less than cameo 5 when cutting.
I wish there was a machine that combined the best of both! It’s so hard to choose when they both have their good qualities. Thanks for sharing the info. By the way, where did you get your craft storage cabinets?
I would like to know about the cabinets too!
Thank you, it is deep information and no doubt it is going to help anyone to choose between them.
in my case is still prefer brother scanncut sdx1200 over them
I love the scan and cut minus the issues with their Mats
This video was so much more helpful than every other video!! Thank you!
I am now however stuck between the curio 2 and the cameo 5. The big down fall for me with the cameo is it can’t engrave at all. Could you compare the two?
Cricut isn't exactly great at engraving, as she mentioned. You'd be better off investing in a dedicated engraving machine, like the X Tool, as she mentioned.
I know this is late but my explore 3 just went up and I’m looking for a new one. I’ve never seen your vids I just kinda wing it. I’m into everything but I’ve decided in my later years I’m a lousy multitasker so I’m going to stick to one or 2 things and that can be done with one of these. I think the circuit maker since I’m used to design space. Thank you Karly. I will see you around.😊
Can you use cricut mats in the cameo 5?
By far, the best reference video on the subject 👌
Hi Karley! Fantastic video! I'm leaning more towards the Cameo 5, however, I am having trouble comparing the two machines in terms of embossing. Have any thoughts?
I’m going to use my machine (when i purchase one) I’ll be making decals ,names on cups
Hello Karley. I stumbled across your page last night and I am so glad that I did. I am new to this stuff and my head was spinning on what machine to get. After watching this wonderful video, I am going with Silhouette. That is also what my daughter has and she likes it. She cuts out and uses the lettering on stuff and does shirts. I plan to do paint parties and want to be able to make my own stencils. What blade do you use and what material do you use for the stencils? I read somewhere about 4 mil. There is so many different things and I'm not sure which is the best to use. Thanks so much!
Really informative video; thank you!!
New sub. I really enjoyed you providing a non-biased review of both machines. I started on my phone in bed with the earlier video and then moved to the computer and found this video. I am a model railroader and will be looking to use the machine in model making instead of crafting. I have seen in forums where some modelers have had success in using the machines in a few applications. An instance I can provide where a fellow modified the tool to scribe styrene plastic to create a brick wall. In scale this is extremely tiny and it did work but was not perfect. I will be trying to make mask in vinyl to be transfered to metal and use it in electro etching and chemical etching. Although I havent yet purchased a machine. I would hands down go with the Cameo 5 as to not have the limitations of the cricut and a few features that I liked better as well. the lower price was not really a factor but for sure a bonus. In the next year I hope to get set up to move forward with this and you have really gave me a positive direction in which to start this adventure. Cheers, Rob
I own both a cricut maker and silhouette cameo4 . I use my cricut for cutting alot of my felt projects and love it. I feel like the machines are build more substancial but that being said I use my cameo the most. Because of the design limitation in cricut I design alot of things in silhouette. So therefore I will be buying the cameo 5 because I still feel limited in print and cut area as many things with cricut but I completely plan to keep using both for various reasons. You did a great job and I am exceited to get the ES mat! That is a game changer to me i hate mats!
Is cricut really easier to learn?
Well done. Impressive.
I have cameo 4 and i am happy with that. The only problem i face is blades are expensive
If it's out of warranty you can purchase generic blades but they are manual adjustments not Auto Blades.
Hi Karley. I happened upon your video when searching info for embossing and engraving. I thought you were so informative and clear in explaining the method to using the engraving tool and how to fill in the lines etc in Silhouette. I own an Explore Air 2 and a cameo 4. I have owned the Cricut since 2021 and the Cameo just recently. I am having a lot of trouble understanding what the options that we would click on mean in order to make almost any project, move letters around, get the sizes of shapes to use as part of a design or template. I did see what you did for your circle, so I will be excited to give that a try. I was wondering if you have made a video explaining the basics for using the Cameo to make a some great things. I know and also have heard that Cricut is very user friendly but not as comprehensive as the Silhouette machine, etc. I am hoping you can help get me up and running. You have a great helpful manner and I am already enjoying your videos! Hope all is well, and that I will hear from you. Much appreciated. Dee.
Well that was the best comparison video ever thanks ! I am still not sure though ; cricut seems easier to use for beginners and silhouette maybe better for advance users .. I want to mainly do stickers and maybe cards stuff . I do like the new cameo5 advert for the electrostatic mat - and pixy might make it easier to do stickers …. But I may be wrong ? 😊
Karley, I in middle between Silhouette and Cricut. I’m familiar with Cricut I had the Explore Air 2 then Marker 2. Year 2021 I decided to move to Costa Rica. Between Marker 2 weight and customs a left a behind with a friend who Wedding planner. I preferred Cricut easy for me, Cricut has distributor but are Virtual Store. Silhouette America has distributor here but has Art, Craft and Classes. With Silhouette I not designer do
not customizing, that where I like Cricut products. And the calibration for print and cut, I’m not likely manually adjusting, I like Cricut better.
For the cricut, is the machine mat the same as the cutting mat?
Thank you very much for your review! I am very tech-savy, mostly using cardstock, stickers and print-then-cut. So, I am pretty sure the Silhouette is the better choice for me. However, I do wonder about other things, like: the cut quality, durability (of machine and the blades), faults, it the standard auto blade the only tool I need?, when to go for premium/other blades?, how well can the Silhouette do scoring (important for fold lines) compared to the Cricut?, material/pens availability (and fitment)?
I don't have any experience with the Cricut, but can maybe answer some of your questions, based on my experience so far with the Cameo 5, it's my first digital cutter and I've had it for about a month... If you're tech-savvy, then you shouldn't have any issues with using the Cameo or it's associated software. There are a lot of online tutorials/blogs too. With regards to a 'lack of support' that people mention, I had issues trying to get the Silhouette Connect plugin working with my version of Illustrator, I sent an email and they were very helpful and set up a remote support session, to try and diagnose the fault and came up with a solution. So far, I've been very pleased with the cut quality, just using the autoblade that came with the machine. I've cut 200-240gsm card, with no issues and also vinyl. The machine seems very durable to me, certainly more so than your average inkjet printer, so I've got no concerns with anything breaking. I'd recommend using the autoblade first, having a play with the machine and seeing what you can do. Then, if there are specific materials that you want to cut, you can buy a more specialised blade, e.g. if cutting fabric, then you would need the rotary blade, 2-3mm craft foam, a kraft blade etc. I've not scored material yet, but I don't see it being an issue, as the autoblade adjusts anywhere between 0.1mm and 1mm, in 0.1mm increments. So, if using 220gsm cardstock requires e.g. 0.7mm blade depth to cut, then try 0.3mm to score? A lot of the designs I've downloaded use a dashed line for folds, which also seems to work well. I've got a feeling that trying to score thin materials, e.g. paper may be somewhat more tricky, and an embossing tool may be more suited, but you would need an embossing mat too.
Wonderful review, thank you!
I have the cameo 4 pro. I have never been able to cut over 14 inches vinyl without it overlapping..
I'm considering the 5, getting reimbursed thru warranty..
I'm a digital artist and do my designs in photoshop. I want to import my designs for cutting. My work is also quite intricate and detailed so it will involve delicate cutting on fine art paper, 200 to 300gsm. I am also interested in using embossing tools. I would really appreciate your advice on which machine you think would be better suited for my needs. Thanks so much.
mix feeling for both machines which makes me undecisive which to get
Hello. What is the brand of storage system behind you? Looks fantastic. Thank you
It looks like the DreamBox from Create Room. I just ordered the DreamBox 2 today because they are having an amazing Mother's Day Sale right now! It's on the higher side of cost, but it's a huge piece of furniture that will hold all of my crafting needs. ☺
What a great review! I have a cricut, I found print and cut via cricut is painful and waste a lot of papers...😢 I am planning to change to silhouette cameo 5 for print and cut🥰😍
Do you think curio2 is also good for this? This is so fun
I bought the Silhouette Cameo 5 - the roller broke in the first week, amazon replaced it no problem - That was in January of 2024, it is now December 2024 and guess what - it broke again. They do not sale replacement parts for this problem and I have learned to research that this is an on going problem. I have also had issues with the software and updates. I use this machine and software for my business. I don't have the money or time to keep replacing this machine. I am seriously thinking about getting a Cricut Maker 3.
Thank you.
You have a lovely smile.
I’m waiting for the cameo 5 xl 😊
I might have missed this in your video but... I'm an Adobe illustrator user. Can I use illustrator and have these machines import my files?
Yes! Both machine can import svgs. You’d need an upgraded software (one time fee) for silhouette. It’s free on Cricut.
I am a professional mixed media artist. I would like to cut fabric , heavy cardstock and stencil mylar. Would be designing intimate stencils. Would only be interested in fonts but not commercial designs.Which machine do you recommend? Thank you for your time. Great video. Jennie
Thank you for making this video. I'm wanting to start a stencil business and I ordered the cricut air 2 but it won't cut the stencil material I need to use. I'm leaning towards cameo sihloette .. pls advise
The most important function I am looking at is to cut fabric for appliqué for my embroidery. Which would you recommend? I watched another comparison of all cutters and the Cricut was the only one that cut intricate designs well.
Cricut Maker is hands down my pick for fabric cutting!
Hi there, I'm thinking I will go with the cricut maker. I want to use it to make tshirts, luggage tags, passport holders and more. My 2nd business is a Travel agent and I feel based on this video that the cricut maker is the better options. What do you recomend?
Hello, and thank you for all your info on the cricut or silhouette machines. I want to make my own T-shirt designs and logos on different types of fabric with permanent vynyl paper and iron on paper. So was wondering what machine would be better for that? This is my main reason for wanting to buy one. Tired of just plain ole T shirts. lol
Which machine cut fabric better? I have a maker that is no longer recognizing the quick swap tools. Therefore, I’m looking into buying a new machine. I don’t live in the warranty zone so I’m not worrying about customer service so much. Both software is difficult to understand especially silhouette. I want my machine mainly to cut faux leather for bags. Which one would you recommend?
Totally amazes me to this day that either company has not gone WiFi as it is far more stable and has a greater range and bandwidth. Bluetooth is so unstable I cannot use it...I must cable the device to have reliable printing and jobs that finish and dont waste my stuff. The problem of both being bluetooth would NOT be a problem with WiFi as they would have individual IP addresses and thus no conflict. I have both the Cameo 4 and Cricut Maker 3 (my new machine).
Hi mme how are you ? Wich machine does half cut please ?
Hi Karely! Great video, thanks so much! 😊 I'm so torn, and can't decide which machine to purchase. I'll be using it primarily to cut craft felt and also some heat transfer vinyl. Softwares not a major concern as I can use Adobe to design.
If you were me, which would you go for? I just need someone to decide for me 😂
Cricut maker! The rotary blade on the cricut makers is better in my opinion! I use that to cut felt and I love it!!
This was super informative but I’m still torn between which machine to purchase.
Did you make a decision?! What do you want to make!?
I also still have to decide on the cameo, I like it best for the electrostatic mat and the hot foil but I don't know if I can cut the same materials that the maker 3 cuts, can you give me more information?
@@annunziatasessa8352 yes- both machines can cut the same materials :)
@@KarleyHall ok thank you very much...but the cameo also cuts balsa wood like the maker3 does
@@annunziatasessa8352 it’s does- you need the Kraft knife. But neither machine cuts it well so I don’t recommend it. It can cut super basic/ big shapes- nothing intricate.
Hi! I looove your video but still I'm not sure which one should I get. I'm really new at this, I'm starting a new proyect with felt and I want to know which one would be the best and easy to cut felt fabric and also to stamp images on the fabric using a press machine. I know that the circuit comes with a mini press but don't know if the silhouette does. Please if you can help me out. Thank you so much !
I love the cricut maker + rotary blade for cutting felt! So fast and such great, clean cuts!
Cricut press is sold separately.
Hello what kind of material/paper ? To put it in the printer.
Very informative, but I am a beginner and I want to print stickers,make t- shirt prints and being able to print on vinyl, foils etc and just have fun doing lots of crafting that should I get a cricut maker 3 or cameo 5? I know with cameo I can do bigger prints if I need letters for signs, boards, posters etc……
Also from what I been hearing cameo does more than cricut and can do what cricut does but better
This is a very useful video I still don’t know what machine lol
really amazing video i'm about to buy today so i would love if you give me final answer . i want use the machine to do small custom boxs for trading cards . and also trading cards and stickers i see both offer same but it will cost extra tools
Have you tried cutting fabric with either? Like a basic non-stretch cotton
Yes! They both can cut unbacked fabric with the rotary blade (sold separately)
I have used my cameo 1 for more than 10 years this month I broke down and upgraded to cameo 5, I am unaware how to use the 2nd blade holder
Thank you for all the info. I would like to make stickers that I can peel off a backing sheet, without having to cut the backing sheet, but where I can make a different cut for the backing sheet (so I can give star stickers to students that they can add to a journal or take home for their refrigerator door:). Also, do you have a video on scoring fold lines using the Silhouette? What would you recommend for a sticker for a car rear window or bumper that won't easily fall off?