Silhouette Cameo 4 or Cricut Maker!? Which machine is better!?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ต.ค. 2024
- Machines:
Cricut Maker:
Cricut: cricut.pxf.io/...
Amazon: amzn.to/2Roq3Dx
143Vinyl: www.143vinyl.c...
Silhouette Cameo Bundles: shrsl.com/2ersn
Silhouette Cameo 4 on Amazon: amzn.to/32OldoH
Silhouette Cameo 4 on Expressions Vinyl: shrsl.com/2efkg
Software:
Cricut Design Space Free: cricut.pxf.io/...
Silhouette Studio Free: www.silhouette...
Silhouette Studio Business Edition Upgrade: shrsl.com/2ersr
Comparison Chart: www.silhouette...
Extras:
Rotary blade for Cameo 4: amzn.to/2WNJcjS
Glowforge Laser Cutter: glowforge.us/r...
Written Comparison: karleyhall.com...
Skip Ahead:
Price Comparison: 3:10
Product Features Silhouette Cameo: 7:49
Product Features Cricut Maker: 11:18
Software Silhouette: 13:59
Software Cricut: 21:03
Cutting on the Silhouette Cameo: 29:17
Cutting on the Cricut Maker: 33:24
Have questions or want to connect?
Website: www.karleyhall...
TH-cam: www.youtube.co...
Instagram: / karley.hall
Facebook: / karleyhallcreative
Facebook Group: / cricutcraftswithkarley
*Disclaimer: Some links above are affiliate links. By clicking on these links I may earn a small commission at no cost to you. Some products may have been provided to me by vendors, however, all opinions and reviews are strictly my own.:
If you already have a machine, don't forget to comment and tell me what sold you on your machine! Or if you plan to buy a machine, what machine are you going with?!
Will you gift me one to do my projects 😭😭
@@cathrynlainez6033 I have given away several machines! Follow along and you just may be a winner one day!
I have a Cameo 4! Just got it this week. It was a gift from my brother so that is what I love about it. Currently trying to figure out the design and separating layers part! But so far love it!
Hey Great video! We have cameo 3 and 4 and were thinking about getting the cricut but what sold us on the Cameo was the print and cut capability the area we can print and cut is about 12 x 18 inches and the cricut is les than a letter page do that was it. When cricut expands its print and cut area we will buy one for sure!!
I wanted to buy The C. Maker until I seen the S. Maker holds sheets (12x24) and cut it has a slide cutter on it😳 so that’s why I changed my mind
TLDR; If you're thinking about making stickers, get a Cameo.
I have both the Cricut Air (own first) and the Cameo. My sole purpose of the machine was to make stickers and cut out vinyls. I had no problems cutting vinyls on either machine, but printing out stickers then getting the machine to cut the stickers was the deal breaker that made me purchase the Cameo. The Cricut was a nightmare when using the print then cut feature. I wasted so many sticker papers and the printing quality is very very low. There are tricks around the Cricut but I bothered wasting my time and at the end, it wasn't worth the effort. Also, I felt like I wasted so many sticker paper because the print and cut feature is limited to the size the registration mark and what fits inside the box. Registering the marks was a pain in the ass for the Cricut. The software is very basic and I find that you can't do much on it.
The Cameo relieved all my stress that I accumulated from the Cricut. Again, I purchased a cutting machine to cut stickers. I love the Cameo because it can cut my stickers accurately and precisely. The software is easy to learn, and I like how much control you have over it. I used to go on Pixlr for script stickers (so the machine doesn't cut each individual letter on Cricut, I didn't know how to) and with the Cameo I don't have to because the feature is within the software. The cameo has registration marks where the machine reads it, and cuts accordingly (if applicable). And if your machine doesn't read the marks, you have the manual option to point the machine in the direction. I do not have problem with the machine other than the fact that it cuts loud. But despite this con, it beats the Cricut in every way because of it's capabilities.
Cricut is advertise everywhere and it got the best of me. Don't let this happen to you. I absolutely despise this machine and wished I purchased the Cameo from the start. Also a bonus that I got the Cameo 3 for ~$90 bucks @ Michaels just about a month ago.
If you're in the market for a cutting machine, I hope this reviews helps you from making a choice. I don't want any potential sticker maker to go through this mess.
Think about why you're buying the machine for, and if you're gonna cut 200+ material, then the Cricut may be for you.
Excuse my poor grammar, but you understood what I said so it's all cool.
Thank you so much! I’m wanting to do my own stickers and have been going back and fourth of what machine would be best and this helped so much!
Thanks for taking the time to give us your experience. I feel like Cricut and its updates are over the top with little to no change. I really want a Silhouette how did you score the Silhouette for so inexpensive? You sold me on the Silhouette. Tfs, Christine
Thank you so much. Studio vlogs really glorify cricuts but the amount of problems they have is hella scary
Vickie X THANK YOU for posting. I have drove my self crazy researching and was already leaning towards silhouette.... now that I’ve read your comment I have made my decision and ordering now. Thank you.
You just described my experience. I agree other than the loudness, the Cameo beats the Cricut.
You're worrying about being too long on your videos... That's the reason I was here in the first place. To get first hand experience on both platforms. Thank you so very much for comparing these two in such a way. You have done a great job!
Creators worry about video length because of algorithms, analytics, data and demographics. It's all about how to make the most money. Their analytics show that most people stop watching after so many minutes, or dont bother watching if it shows it's more then a few minutes long.
Then you lose advertisers if it shows your viewers are clicking off the video instead of watching till the end. Advertisers want pre-roll, mid-roll and/or end of video..and they want viewers to stick around to see their ads.
It's all about money....always...
People get distracted if it's not quite the video they were hoping for or if someone is talking to long. Creators know this so they put the important information in and make follow up videos (usually) to expand on certain aspects that seem to be of interest to the viewers. I read a comment that this woman has made a video going a bit more in depth in the comparison of the software for these two machines. I don't doubt she has other videos that continue the comparison she went through here. I think she did marvelous and it was exactly the video I was looking for. The comments also are super helpful for me personally in my decision making process. I agree that she was very thorough and concise. That's difficult to find in most cases.
-JC
Not even 10 minutes in the video and it already seems like the cameo is the best
Basically Cricut is like Apple, nice marketing but tells you what to like, simple, user friendly, more expensive( most likely to make up for the r&d). Silhouette is like android, more customization, a bit more options, less expensive, less well known but a very good product all the same.
I think your comparison illustrates pretty much my feeling. As I hate apple, i will go for sillouette! Thanks
if cricut is like apple and silhouette is like android then you must be saying cricut is more reliable and stable because whilst android is more customisable ios is far more stable and reliable. fact
@@beckicoplin4008 i didnt say it was. i was referring to the comment about cricut being like apple and silhouette being like android as a way to put cricut down by pointing out ios is far more reliable and stable than android.
Also Cricut has dropped support for quite a few machines and they cannot be used anymore so you end up with a great big paper weight. I’ve got the first silhouette cameo which I hadn’t used for over 6 years. I signed into my account again recently and it remembered all I had bought and is still supported. It also cuts beautifully.
@@daveferris5465 We have both apple phones and iPads as well as android phones and tablets. I personally would pick android all day long. The apple zombies baffle the hell out of me. As far as reliability....I haven't had either be unreliable...however....you forget your apple password and omg the nightmare. No thanks lol
This video has changed my life. I love my maker but I am not crazy about design space. The fact that I can use the silhouette software with the maker is amazing! Thank you!!!
Do you need both machines in order use silhouette software on the cricut?
You cannot upload designs on the free version of silhouette software.
I love my silhouette cameo. I had a Cricut but sold it because the designing for what I do is limited. I have done so much stuff with my Silhouette.
More ppl like cameos software. But perfer cricuts cutting
Silhouette all the way! I want the control and freedom. Thanks for the comparison I was curious about the maker, but I'll stick with my Cameo.
I have owned both Cricut and Silhouette. I literally gave my Cricut away. It was useless to me. Way too limiting on what I could design and the software felt like a trial version that only let me do a few things. I have the 1st gen Cameo and Cameo 4 Pro and absolutely love them both. The one thing that no one has mentioned is blade life. The Silhouette blades last FOREVER. I bought my first Cameo in 2013 and I have an Etsy business. I have yet to dull a Silhouette blade. The Cricut, in the few short months I used it before rehoming it , blew through blades in a matter of days. I would never go back to Cricut.
@@mwp4205 hi! The cutting force is much stronger, you have two tool holders, and there are a lot more tool options with the Cameo 4 like a rotary blade for example. One really nice thing they give you with the Cameo 4 is a bag of adapters to use your existing legacy tools and pens! I’m very happy with it.
What kind of printer do you use with your cameo? From my understanding, Cameo doesn’t print and cut? I’m leaning towards cameo but don’t think my Brother worksmart series printer will print my detailed art very well. I also have a canon inkjet which I put up in the closet bc ink for it was so expensive and at the time I just needed a printer for basic paper printing/copying.
@@amandamartin2767 This comment isn't relevant anymore since there is the Maker 3. All the things she mentioned that she missed is on the maker 3 commercial grade one.. I love my maker 3. I see a lot of fangirlism on the Cameo like if they are getting payed to say things like that. The Maker 3 has a lot of options. The sky is the limit. The Only thing you need is being creative.
Hi i am wondering if having to change out the blade can be the reason why i have a solid red light on the power button?
@@CheesyMcBeard thanks I’ll have to look into the maker 3.
I have the original Cameo. I got it because it was the only one on the market at the time. I had initially purchased a circuit but the thought of spending money for each cartridge made me break out in hives, so I returned the circuit and paid a it more for the Silhouette. I’m still happy with my machine and have the Designer Edition.
Same here! Recently upgraded to the Cameo 3 and kept my old machine because it is still a great machine.
I’ve been a Silhouette user since 2008. I had the Wishblade version and bought the Cameo when it first debuted. I have many friends who use the Cricut and love it and I wondered if maybe I should buy one. But after your comparison I know for sure Silhoutte is still my choice. I want the 4! Thank you for going into more detail to compare these two machines!
Silhouette all the way! I have a Cameo 3, considering a Cameo 4. I use it to create and cut custom packaging for my jewelry, as well as make every craft I can find the time to do... Foil Quill, vinyl, HTV, paper flowers, cards, and more. I know so many people who got a Cricut and couldn't figure out the software due to such a high learning curve, and the machine ended up collecting dust... had them look at what I could do on my Silhouette (even with the basic level free software) and they were blown away. If you're debating between the two brands, don't give in to the Cricut hype... Silhouette is where it's at.
I want it basically for tshirts and home decor things. Would the silhouette 3 be sufficient?
@@njkel924 Absolutely! That's what I started using mine for, then realized how much *more* I could use it for. 😊
@@EmmyBeanJewelry ok is it really difficult to figure out the computer system. I'm not a techy but I usually can catch on
@@njkel924 The free basic software is quite easy to use. Now, with the basic software you can't use SVG files, its primarily DXF files, but you can use a tracing tool to turn JPGs and PNGs into cut files. There are lots of great (free!) resources out there to show you how. I only recently upgraded to the Design software so I could use SVGs (specifically for using the Foil Quill). With the free basic software I cut HTV for shirts and tote bags, cut vinyl for home decor, cut a zillion paper flowers for a giant arch for my neighbor's daughter's surprise sweet 16 last fall, cut luminaries, boxes, sketched and cut stickers, and designed and cut my own packaging. Just don't rush and try to do things too fast... have fun with it! Practice with spare supplies before using anything pricey. If you're going to be using it for personal projects, or even gifts, there are lots of free fonts, DXF files and more to use. The Silhouette design store has free "how to" resources, too, and free files to use that change frequently.
@@EmmyBeanJewelry hi there! What sort of press did you have in the beginning? Most people use the cricut easy press. I'm wondering what you started out with? Im hoping to do the same later. Thanks! :)
With Silhouette you can cut, sketch, score as many colours as you like without moving the images on and off the mat. you can also do all these with a single send command, you only need to cut by lines. This means that, you choose a line colour for diffent action.So if you have 10 images on the mat and tou wish to cut 3, score 3 and sketch 4. You choose a line colour for each action. The fill colour does not matter. When you send to cut after designing, the default setting is simple, change that to line then check the box on the left side of each colour. then in front of these colours, choose action you want it to carry out.You can also choose which side of the cutting tool you want the machine to use - Red or blue.
Railu Tiamiyu may I ask if you silhouette is beginner friendly
@@carabullock8043 there is a learning curve, but I think they both can have a learning curve ( I own both machines) however there are tons of TH-cam channels that can help you learn tips and tricks with both machines! I think most the problems come when people think they are going to get it out of the box today and make a business out of it tomorrow without doing homework and tons of practice first
I had the old Cricut when still using cartridges. Bought the Imagine back in the day and returned it. Couldn't get it to work and there was NO technical support. They suggested I find someone who could work on the program for me! Bought the Silhouette after seeing a friend using hers. Have never regretted my purchase. Love how I own my designs and how easy it is to use.
Thank you so much for the comparison. I have been wanting to buy a machine but couldn't decide between the silhouette and cricut. Think I'll get the Silhouette 4.
My first machine was a silhouette years ago. I upgraded to a newer silhouette and bought a Cricut as well. I only use my silhouette. I love the design ability.
I love my Silhouette as well. If you have business edition of Silhouette Studio, you can save files as SVG-format, thus using the files also for the Cricut.
The first ever machine I owned was the Cricut Maker, I bought it not long after it was launched. At the time I thought it was awesome, though I used to get frustrated with the online software, odd occasions when I couldn't use my machine because cricut were running maintenance etc. I then purchased a Brother SDX1200 because I wanted to be able to do bigger print and cuts, and eventually found myself using the brother machine all the time with the cricut just sat there idle. The brother machine did cost considerably more but it was a far more versatile machine. I sold the cricut to help finance another brother machine because of an increased workload, however I discovered quite a serious flaw with the brother machines, their build quality wasn't great, the feed roller system was poorly designed and eventually failed due to wear, brother didn't seem to want to admit that they had not put enough effort into development. I think they were just eager to get to market before cricut could made too much of an impact. Anyway, I then purchased a Cameo 4, and I can honestly say, that out of all 3 of the machines, it is the one that suits me the most. It's definitely the most capable, has the most advanced software and is the cheapest. It is the noisiest, with the brother machine being the quietest, but I can live with that. I've worked it hard and it's more than paid for itself, I just wish I had bought one sooner.
I have a Silhouette Portrait (1st edition) and Cameo (1st edition). I always wanted a cutting machine. When I finally had the budget, I did some research and chose Silhouette. It offered what I wanted, freedom and control over the designs without being tied to the internet or cartridges, at a price I could afford. I started using the software before I got the machine, so when it got here I was ready.
Silhouette hands down, and I have had both Cricut and Silhouette. The software is so far superior there’s no comparison and like someone else mentioned my blades last so much longer on my silhouette. Plus I love print and cut and the Cricut is so wasteful of sticker paper.
I just sold off my Air2 for a Silhouette 4 - the software alone is SO much better and targeted to people who design (I bought the Business level software). The machine is much faster too.
I'm torn between which to purchase i make my own designs but i also use some images from google to add to my designs for instance if i need a character ill search it up on google and add it to my design what would you recommend also have u made stickers with the machine i craft by hand for myself and my family but would love to branch out into a business
@@celym6884 You can buy licenced designs on Sillouette that allows commercial use. You can download anything to use from Google but be aware of copyright law if you want to sell product with someone else's design.
Or just use real design software on whatever machine you choose lol
This was a really great video. I grew up with the precursor silhouette machine and I am also still using my Cameo 1. I too find that the Silhouette software is extremely flexible and I only have the Designer Edition compared to your Business Edition. When I get a new idea about something I want to do, I can usually accomplish it with Silhouette. I bought the Maker when it first came out and I have regretted it. I find Design space to be very confining and frustrating. It's too simple for me and also because I'm so used to Silhouette, I don't think Design Space is very intuitive. I have a lot of difficulty figuring out how to do the same things I can do in Silhouette. One of the things you mentioned you like the Cricut machine better is the sorting colors by mat. I find the Silhouette software does have features which can do this. One way, is you don't have to move shapes off the mat if you don't want them cut at the same time as other shapes on your mat. You can simply select those shapes you want the machine to ignore and select "no cut". You can have several shapes on your mat selected as no cut and only one as "cut" and the machine will cut only the shape that has been marked as cut. Also, a feature that I love is that you can select by color. If you have various shapes on your mat in various colors, you can select say all of the red shapes, mark them as cut and the machine will cut only the red shapes. So you don't have to move any shapes off the mat at all. The biggest difference between the two machines that you did not mention and really it is a software difference, is that Cricut Design Space is compatible only with Windows 8 and above, while Silhouette Studio will work with Windows 7. I wish I had known that before I purchased my Maker, because I have Windows 7 and I am perfectly happy with it. Even though support for 7 has ended, I don't plan on an upgrade anytime soon. So, the only way I can use my Maker now is to upgrade to the Silhouette Business Edition so that I can send projects from Silhouette to the Maker. Not sure I want to do that either, so I might end up selling my Maker.
Thanks for your detailed insight! I know people will appreciate it! While you can change the different colors to “no cut,” I still find that I move them around my mat to position them to take advantage of my material. So that’s why I started just moving them off the mat. I feel like it would make sense for silhouette to add the option to sort to different mats if you’d like. Thanks again for your comment!
You can send commands to the Maker with silhouette studio?
Thank you so much for this video! Everyone talks about Cricut but I don’t hear much about the Cameo, this deff helped me with my decision on what to save up for! 😊
I started with the Cricut Maker and love it but I also wanted to be able to do larger print then cut designs so I have added the Silhouette Cameo 4 Plus. I love the ease of the Maker but I plan to get in there and learn Silhouette Studio (Business Edition). Right now, I sometimes get frustrated with all the features of Silhouette Studio and use the Maker simply out of ease. But I also refuse to give up, I will learn Silhouette Studio, even if if takes forever! :)
Silhouette Studio....Business Edition🤔 What is that exactly? Im new here...trying to figure out what is what lolzz...
I'm a beginner and this video helped me decide on which machine fits my needs more. I'm going with the Cameo 4. Thanks a bunch.
I am brand new to the cutting machine world. I bought a Cricut Maker in March and it's my first machine. I love how easy it is to use. I did a ton of research before purchasing, and honestly had no idea about the Silhouette 4 machine! I went with the Maker over the EA2 because of the ability to do the engraving (which I adore). I felt like if I was going to spend that much, I might as well go all out and get the newest one. It is loud, so I can't imagine how loud the Silhouette is! My 4 year old comes running whenever he hears the Cricut running. Even when he heard it in the video, he had to come watch 😂 I really feel like the Maker was the best choice for me.
I got my Maker around the same time and I knew nothing about a Silhouette until recently.
I have the Maker and the silhouette 3. Initially I only used the silhouette for rhinestone cuts.... now I use my maker almost exclusively... easy to use.
The sound that Silhouette is off-putting enough. I thought my Explore Air 2 was loud! I've had my eye on these machines for awhile and am definitely set on the Maker. I'm already someone who creates my own designs on Procreate, Illustrator, and Photoshop on the IPad pro and uploads them to design space for full control so that's not a big deal for me. But I love how sturdy and beautiful the Maker is, it's the same reason I own a Kitchenaid stand mixer, they're beautiful, powerful, and unmatched in quality.
You convinced me to go with the cricut using other software. I to am a kitchenaid Addict
I totally agree with you
I'm set on getting the Cricut Maker too. But I think, Cricut Design Space might have more features in the near future.
I have used Cricut since it first hit the market. Infact, I love it so much that I volunteer teach people how to use it. That being said, I've always had an interest in the Silhouette because I've heard awesome things from other users- but hadn't slowed down to really research it. So so glad your video came in my feed....I'm doing a Watching you was like unwrapping a late Christmas 🎁. I am going to purchase one. You emphasized the versatility it offers. Cricut allows you to import several file types, but not export the designs you make. The fact that with Silhouette I
can export my creations from Silhouette into other programs ie Adobe, of Sawgrass' Program Management software as examples is a game changer as I do sublimation. Lastly the ability to create my own Rhinestone designs in Silhouette is another reason I'm sold. Definitely still love my Cricut for many other reasons...but the Silhouette will be a welcomed addition to my studio! Thank you for your awesome review 😀
Most informative and detailed video I've found, you've helped me decide on the Cameo 4. I want to make and sell decals and the feed tray is what sold me on it. Thank You.
I’m so happy to help!! Thanks for your comment- I really appreciate it!
I switched from Cameo 2 to Cricut Maker two years ago. It was the biggest jump in quality and features ever back then. It appears Cameo is trying to catch up. I agree the quality of the machine itself is better on the Cricut Maker and it’s a more intuitive and quiet system. I couldn’t go back now that I have the ease and beauty of Cricut. I love the rotary blade and all the attachments for the quick switch system. The preforation blade and scoring blades are awesome. But honestly the ready to make projects are my favorite. Easy and fast for crafters who want to make something beautiful but don’t have a ton of time or experience at design!
QuickSwap for sure is a selling point!!! So good! Thanks for your insight! I feel like this will be so helpful to other crafters! You’re the best, Brandi!
Personally I love the freedom of designing my own projects. Once you learn the program it is so easy. Love my silhouette 4
S A it is awesome for designers! I keep both softwares but I don’t have a ton of time to craft anymore so I grab the quick ready to make projects from Cricut. It fits best for my busy lifestyle now.
I agree whole heartedly- I don’t want to get a graphics arts degree to make my things for my home. I am still debating returning the cameo.
This was super helpful. I almost got a Cricut and after watching this I am convinced the Cameo is the machine for me. All that customization. I'm in love. And I am content with spending a little extra for the better software instead of what I've heard Cricut bleeds you of money. THANK YOU
I'm so happy you found this helpful!! Thanks for your feedback!!
I just found this video as I’m trying to decide which crafting cutter is best for me to get started with and I have NEVER seen anyone with their name spelled the exact same as mine!! It was meant to be that I found your video!
Yay!! So glad you found my channel! 🥰 I love meeting other Karleys!
All I knew and trusted was Cricut, but thanks to this video I ordered a cameo. The cameo alleviates all the problems you run into with Cricut.
Can’t wait to hear what you think! Keep me updated!
which problems does it fix specifically? Super curious as I'm still divid on which one to buy !!
Team Silhouette here. More software features, larger print and cut area, cutting without a mat, ability to sell files for use with other machines, and until recently Cricut did not have the ability to work offline like Silhouette
What are the max dimensions for the print and cut area on the Silhouette? Could I do a design as big as 11"×17"?
Thank you Karley! This ia fantastic comparison. I love how you obviously planned and edited this comparison. You do not ramble! All of the information you shared is helpful and your delivery is top notch. I am checking out the laser printer link before I buy. Thank you. Best, Kitty
I have a Cameo 3 but want a Cameo 4 and a Cricut maker! I do prefer silhouette studio design. The point editing helps clean up rough edges. I like the tools and options I have when designing.
What is the difference between the Cameo 3 and Cameo 4?
#silhouette
I love having all the control.
I have a maker and I love it. Still learning and love your videos.
silhouette software with a cricut machine sounds like something that would work for me. Freedom in designing (silhouette) with the ease of use (cricut) like you said in the end of your review. Thanks for the review!
This ability to use the Silhouette software for designing with the Cricut sounds exactly what i am looking for...Cricut Maker for me. Thanks so much for this comparision. Great video!
So are you saying you can get the Silhouette designing software and then transfer those files to Cricut? How much is the software for Silhouette?
The Cameo 4 with the 3mm Kraft blade can cut right through thinner styrene sheet (plasticard) and can score the 1/8" thick stuff deep enough that it will snap on the score line like it should. It makes making wargaming terrain that has a lot of repetitive details much quicker and easier. The 2mm Kraft blade will also get through the thinner styrene. I got the base size Cameo 4 (the 12") because that's really all I need. Most often I'm buying the 7" x 12" sheets sold by Plastruct but I also use the 12" x 24" sheets when I am building an entire new set of terrain because it's more cost effective. with the 12" x 24" cutting mat I can get a lot of styrene parts cut out very quickly and safely. I had tried a laser cutter before that could cut through the material but it often leaves blackened and melted edges, gives off a lot of fumes that will either cause cancer eventually or could possibly create hydrochloric acid in your lungs and there was always the possibility of an errant piece of material reflecting the laser and blinding me. The Cameo 4 cuts the plastic neatly, quickly and safely. I couldn't be happier with it. I had demoed the Cricut at an in-store demo at a JoAnns near me but it just doesn't have the power to even score it well or cleanly.
I have the cam 4 and Cricut 2, love them both not selling neither one
I never even realized the Maker had that front tray storage and had to go check mine out. Don’t know how I missed it. Handy.
Thanks for the comparisons of the machines. I recently bought a cricut maker and I'm looking forward to using it, but now I'm thinking of getting a silhoutte cameo to use along with my cricut.
This was amazing and clear. I have the cameo 2 and was gifted the cricut maker by my husband. I'm glad to know I can transfer my files since I love the control features in silhouette!
So would you recommend the silhouette 2 camo?
@@angelagalan930 I love my cameo2. It is really reliable. I mostly use it for my stickers and vinyl decals since I make most of those files in silhouette's design space as it has more creative freedom. It is more manual since I have to line things up myself, manually adjust my blade settings and less attachment options, but I dont mind that.
This is a great comparison video! Thank you! I have the original Cameo and recently got a Cameo 4. I won my first Cameo in a contest. There is definitely a learning curve to the software, but like you said there is so much you can do with it. Have been contemplating getting the Maker to add to my collection, but just don't know if I really need it. Thanks for the video!
I literally just ordered the Maker and I’m so happy after watching this! Very informative!
Thanks for this video! I love my Cricut Maker, but also love the Silhouette designs. That's all I want to be able to do. I do not want the learning curve that comes with the Silhouette. Cricut Maker is perfect for me and I am so glad that I saw this video as I was close to getting the Silhouette Cameo, not any more after this video. Good for if you are into making your own designs. I am not that advanced. Again, thanks for sharing and I need to find out how to get Silhouette designs to use with my Cricut Maker and I will be a happy camper! xoxo
You can do it-here is a video to show you how! th-cam.com/video/tCr3aHaKAsg/w-d-xo.html
Same here - I love that the Cricut software is simple to use. I just use my cutting machine to make die cuts for scrapbooking projects and the occasional card. But like you I love the Silhouette designs - but now that I know you can buy them and save as an SVG - total game changer
This is the best comparison video that I have found so far. Great job! I am leaning towards the Cameo 4 because of the roll feed capability but I'm still undecided.
The new Cricut Maker 3 also has an optional roll feeder. I just purchased it to do a review!
I really appreciate this comparison! Thank you! I have a Silhouette Portrait I have almost used to death and was considering getting a Cricket Maker, but your video confirms I’m using the right machine for what I do. Thank you!!!
Excellent comparison! I still can't decide though because I don't know if I will use it as much.
Wow, it took until now that I found out it was pronounced "cricket", all this time I thought it was "cry-cut" 🤦🏼♀️
omg same!
Hahaha me too !
That’s weird 😒🙄 because you all should have seen/heard commercials, tutorials, TH-cam videos and all kinds of communications that this product was pronounced properly, for you -Not- mispronounce it’s name! 🤣🤪 Just weird!
@@shawnd4363 I guess I have just been living under a rock so only saw the name written and never heard it pronounced. This is the first video I have watched regarding the machine. After all, I don't own one.
Oh, and you should know that the people at the big box art supplies shop doesn't know how to pronounce it either!
Have a nice day.
So I wasn't the only one 😬
I’ve always had Cricut and currently own a Cricut maker but throughout the years have wandered if I’m missing out on anything with the Cameo. I totally love the idea of being able to use a roll of vinyl for large projects without a mat. You’re comparison is great and answers so many questions. The only thing that I would have liked to see them both cut a much more detailed and intricate design. I’ve heard on more than one occasion complaints about Cameo not cutting intricate designs well. I honestly don’t know if there was/is any truth to that or if it was nothing more than user error... but, I would never purchase a Cameo based on that alone so that would have been nice to see. Thanks for the great video.
Thanks for the review! I need a machine to cut fabric pieces 2 1/2 yrds in length so the Cameo 4 is definitely gonna be the purchase for me!
I'm curious as to how this would work. Does your fabric have a backer? Sorry I am still new to the matt less cutting and the idea still sounds foreign to me.
This is an awesome comparison. I am completely clueless but looking for options as gift for my wife and your video is extremely helpful. Thank you!
I have had my Maker for a few months and I still only do basic things on it. I am so intimidated by it lol. I want to learn how to use it and be a well seasoned Maker user.
Excellent comparison! Thank you for that. I have not have any machine yet but am looking into buying one for my cutting stickers, doll’s clothes and balsa wood (or thick cardboard) for miniature dollhouse furniture. Those are the 3 main things I will use it for, however hearing you said both this machine is not recommended on cutting wood, I’m now back to square one, 😂😂😂 at lease now I know I won’t be getting either of this machine, I have more research to be done. Thank you again for such wonderful comparison, just awesome! 💐💕🙏🏻
You can cut thin balsa wood just fine- but if your wanting something rigid- I’d get something in addition to a cutting machine. For stickers and doll clothes- both will work great :)
@@KarleyHall wow, you actually respond, thank you so much. Good to know it can cut balsa wood, now I just saw this review, it said Cricut fabric mat only can cut 40 rimes before you need to tape it down and the blade are frequently need to replace? You might not have time but I’m just hoping you can help me out. Thank you in advance.
th-cam.com/video/rZqtb8J5bTQ/w-d-xo.html
You can cut two different colors without having to move one shape off. You just choose fill color in the cut screen. That is available in the basic edition.
Right, or just click 'no cut' on one of the shapes when you're on the send panel. I don't think the basic level has cut by color. Not sure though.
This is the best informational video I have seen. Thank you so much for doing this and actually comparing the Pro's and Con's. II am currently a Cricut owner and although it is user friendly for beginners you do it a wall with being able to expand on you're projects.
Thank you for such a detailed video. This actually has convinced me to purchase a cameo 4.
Awesome! I’d so appreciate if you purchase your machine through one of my affiliate links! That directly supports this channel!
This was fun to watch. I now own a Brother Scan N Cut SDX125E. I'd love to see a comparison between it and these two models, a Roland Sticka tabletop digital cutter, and the larger version of the Cameo digital cutter as well. Throwing in the Roland cutter and the larger one from Cameo is a good way to get a feel for the Prosumer market space and the trends that the craft or home markets appear to be headed in.
Thank you for mentioning other options. As a newb I am doing my due diligence as I have to work very hard to save for my first machine. I want to make sure it's reliable as I hope to use it to start a small business with sales from my projects to get me into a better situation. So reliability really is crucial. Going through the comments is helpful and I appreciate you mentioning similar machines that I can add to my list and compare. Stay blessed
- Jessica
Thank you so much for going into the differences with the software! I'm a newbie and need hand-holding for the software aspect. The software definitely sold it for me to get a Cricut. It was also very insightful into knowing the cutting surface area for both machines. For me, I'm looking to create smaller projects and don't require a large space. Very insightful video! :)
Thank you so much for this very thorough comparison. I am definitely going to purchase the Cameo now, especially in light of recent events. I am particularly thankful that you showed the god-awful noise that the Cameo makes. I absolutely would have thought that I purchased a malfunctioning machine! Still going with Cameo, though. 😏
🤣😂 you’ll get used to the noise!
Cricut just released a statement that if you purchase a machine and register it before 12/31/2021-- you will get unlimited uploads for life :)
Geese! My Cameo 4 is waaay quieter than the SD! I can still here TH-cam while cutting!
Thank you Karley! Awesome video! I'm obsessed with Cricut but lately Design Space has been very frustrating and I love using the Silhouette Software. So really really been thinking of just purchasing the Cameo 4 just so I can start and finish my projects without having to switch back and forth between softwares.
Very informative video. Love it!
Susan Ontiveros Design Space has definitely been a headache. I surely hate that because I do find it to be user friendly.
@@TR-lk2ts yes and its the worst when it acts up and you need to get an order done. 🤦♀️. Its been sooo slow lately too.
Super helpful video! I have owned a Cricut Expression (with the Gypsy and old Cricut Craft Room format), a Silhouette Cameo and now I am back to using a Cricut and have a Cricut Explore. I love Cricut Explore because I can use all of the cartridges I amassed from 2006 to 2012 and I think it is so user friendly, but I think the Silhouette Design store has some really great designs. Now that I see that you can buy a Silhouette file as an SVG - that is really a game changer. I am on the fence about whether to buy a Cricut Maker - but I suspect I will need to at some point since I suspect Cricut is going to move to only supporting the blade adapter system which does seem cool
Very informative review. I loved that you weren’t leaning towards just one or the other and actually compared them both. I’m a newbie and just purchased the baby Joy Xtra 😂 hey, I’m just starting out ok! I’ve seen horrible reviews for the Maker 3, so I’m staying away from that one. My sister has a Cricut Explore Air 2 since it came out and she loves it! She says she will use it until it dies before buying another. I think I will go with another Cricut only because DS is much more simpler. I cannot retain information like I used to, so the Silhouette may not be good for me, which is a shame because I was leaning towards that until you said it’s not as easy to learn. I love the features though
I agree very informative review.
I didn't even know I needed to watch until it was over.
I 1st heard of Cricut about 5-7yrs ago but have not used one. I've been training on a Silhouette thru my local library.
Really cool tool.
I picked up a Cricut bundle today but after watching this will likely switch gears & lean towards the Cameo instead, specifically bc it can cut thru thicker material.
I also like that the Silhouette Studio is free, and last year Cricut tried to start charging its customer base with monthly subscription fees.
This is so incredibly helpful! I want to make shirts and decals and such and I feel the Cricut would be easier for me to get started. Thanks!
My Cameo 4 is just stupid good.
I used to use a Cricut at my old job doing temp tatoos and the ease, options, software, and spare parts is just amazing.
Even though it feels *cheap* it's so rubust and as long as you don't drop it (a few times) it will serve you well!
Haha I agree! 🤣 I don’t think many people have trouble not dropping their machines haha
I used to be silhoutte then hopped over to a Maker, which as a stand alone machine is great, but Cricut lets all of its customers down with its software. It is so lacking in design capability and is so glitchy that it makes me dread turning on the machine. Cricut’s business model means they won’t be addressing the design and usability capabilities as they want you to lock into their own designs. I’ve stuck with the Cricut for three years (first with explore then a maker) and I cannot wait for the cameo 4 pro to come out. As soon as it is released, I’ll be selling my maker.
I use my Silhouette software, you are correct, it is better, and cut mostly on my Maker.
I totally agree with you! It bugs me that I will have to leave Cricut behind. Their software is horrendous and they don't seem to care in providing good customer service. I mean I would think this crisis we're all in would teach them that NOTHING IS GUARANTEED! If they can't take care of their client base, what makes them think they'll continue to be a flourishing business.
I've got HUNDREDS of projects so starting over won't be easy but I'm thinking the Silhouette may very well be a much better option.
Allen & Emily Stewart how do you get it if you have cricut?
CJ 4EVA I had Silhouette machines before the Cricut... so I just kept the software, upgraded to business and save as SVG, open the svg in cricut design space and cut. I love Sure cuts a lot 5 too. Dreaming tree has it for $50
@@cj4eva I had a Silhouette first and still had the software on my laptop.. So I upgraded to Business Edition, save as svg and open/cut on the cricut. I know it’s a free download (Silhouette software) but I’m not sure if you have to link it to a Silhouette machine since you won’t actually be cutting. I’m sorry for just now replying, I just saw this!
What sold me on the Silhouette SD way back before Cameo came on market was no cartridges. I also liked the flexibility that Sil offered to alter designs & that I don’t need an internet connection to use all my designs I’ve bought or created. I just bought a Cameo 4 as my SD is restricted to 8.5” wide paper & I’d like to make larger items without piecing together.
I love designing with Silhouette and then save as a SVG and cut with my Maker (specifically when I am cutting felt or fabric). It’s a process, but you just can’t design with the Cricut the same as Silhouette. And my Cameo 3 doesn’t cut fabric like the Maker, but the process I follow works. I do wish Cricut let you have the option to NOT auto sort. Drives me batty!
Omgosh! I enjoyed your video so much! I've been in the market for a cutting machine but couldn't decide which one would best suit my needs. By breaking it down for me, you've helped me significantly in my decision.🥰 Thank you!
I think the one thing that is left out of EVERY side by side comparison IS : That the Silhouette is NOT propitiatory like the Cricut which I think is a HUGE to making a decision on which one you buy in my opinion also lets not forget about the PNC feature is much better than Cricut in my opinion ...Thanks
I’m not sure I know what you mean! Would you mind explaining? I briefly mention the print the cut feature- but yes! Silhouette has print then cut capabilities up to 12x12 which is super handy!
@@KarleyHall probably talking about the stones they throw in peoples way, even go so far to write frivolous lawsuits and "bully" people when they make alternative software for lesser known operating systems for example
I agree with Cricut users complaing about alignment issues. I have a maker and cut my printed designs FACE DOWN. I do this because the edges are a lot nicer on this thick card stock when cut from the back. The trouble that creates is I cannot rely on the registration marks used with print and cut. I recently found out that Design Space places a ridiculous size restriction on print and cut anyways. So I have a few lines in my files that serve as registration marks. I first cut a piece of copy paper with these and cancel before it starts cutting my design. Then I have a guide made of the copy paper to align my print to. This usually works OK. But then sometimes the Cricut will randomly start the cut a few mm too high or low. That used to ruin my design but because those registration lines are cut first, I have time to bail on the cut. If the Cricut is not starting where it should I've found that repeated attempts don't work. I need to cancel the cut, position the design again and do another cut of the copy paper and hope the machine will print in the right place. I should add that I move my cuts around the map frequently since I am cutting with a lot of force. I go right through the mat if I don't move things around so trying to position my art at 0,0 and always placing it in the same spot on the mat is also not something I can do. This process is too tedious and I am disappointed with the Cricut's repeatability. I think once a cut starts in the right spot, it's accurate however most of the time for the two passes my cuts require.
I don't know how I've ever, or will ever again, be able to make a decision unless I hear you lay it out like this SO THOROUGH! I'd love to know your thoughts comparing them now that the maker 3 has come out. Thanks again !
I'm 71 and try to stay techy. I'm only a year ago into the cutting machines, i.e. except I'm a seamstress/designer/inventor. I needed precision cut fabric for my invention and a time saver and thought the Cricut could help - it was great. Well I purchased several including the old machines no longer online but they had this classic look for decorating in the sewing room. Foolish me! I have the Explore 2, Maker, Maker 3 and Joy. I did many tutorials and did not know anything about a rotary tool so I just used another bland, bonded the fabric which is an outdoor type with a heavy nap. I was able to design interesting looks that I could not do by hand, played with the settings on the "Explore 2" and the cuts were great and saved me hours of time. I kept trying to make the design space more computer savvy but I could not maneuver it like I wanted nor did I like losing paper in print and cut. I heard about the Silhouette. It’s tool capability is so scary but what a grand machine for manipulation and power, as I got into it. I purchased a Cameo 2 just to be safe for less than $100 at a thrift store and it works beautiful and the matless was weird although I've paid for smart vinyl from Cricut - I will not buy anymore. I'd rather use the mat especially since Cricut’s print and cut waste so much paper/vinyl. I know that I'll probably us Studio for design and cut many things in Design Space. Great Tutorial and on Point.
I really enjoyed your video. I have Silhouette Cameo 1 - Designer Edition and a Cricut Joy. I love the Joy because I can use my IPad (quicker to open than my laptop). I don’t really like design space for designs - Silhouette Design Store is better laid out and easier to purchase with download cards and the free designs can be added to my library. The thing I don’t like about the Cameo, is the noise. I was disappointed that Cameo 4 is the same. I think Cricut Maker cuts fabric better than the Cameo. Also, the cutting tools of Cricut are of a better quality than Cameo. The Joy’s mat lost it’s stick quickly but rectified with 505. I’m happy using both machines and software, depending on the project - enjoying the challenge. I’m thinking of buying a Maker and keeping my Silhouette Cameo 1. The Joy is so much fun.
I do not use the drawing functions on my Silhouette since I am a graphic designer and use Illustrator exclusively. The reason I watched this video is I know nothing about the capabilities and functions of a Cricut machine. My take away from this... I made the right decision going the Silhouette route, but your right about the noise hahaha
Aesthetically, I love the look of the Silhouette... imho, it looks more sleek and professional.
Thank you for this wonderful video. I have a Cricut Air 2 but I am having so many issues with Design Space and my Mac not playing nice together. It is making me want the Cameo 4. The software looks amazing and I'm very familiar with Illustration and Inkscape. I've loved my Cricut but I think its time for a change
Thanks for an excellent explanation of both machines. I am looking for fabric cutting, and light fashion vinyl. I really am truly undecided as this is for a small business. Again thank you.
I saw a tutorial on Cameo 3 by Silhouette, and she waas able to cut by color, or layer, and she did not have to move designs on and off if she wanted to cut multicolor designs.
You would have to move them to conserve material space. Silhouette needs to get a sort to mat function! That’s the only thing they are missing 😅
Thank you, very good information. I have the cricut air and it continues to loose connection, the small space for my print and cut waste so much product. I'm glad I found your channel. I will likely purchase a silhouette.
Thank You for taking your time to make this video. I highly appreciate it.
I am a beginner and the biggest sell for me is the cricut actually as you say "holding your hand" and showing what to do next. So it is the Cricut that I will be investing in for my bookbinding hobby. Thanks for this video.
Thanks for the detailed comparison, have been wanting to see a video like this 👍
I have the Cricut Maker and based on your video I just bought the cameo 4. I plan to use it with the Janome Artistic Digitizer software
I have had the cameo since 2013 first gen.
Works like a charm but i always wanted to cut deep balsa wood and bass wood.
I got a new cameo for Christmas 2020. Now to make gifts.
Does it cut foam board? The kind you find at Walmart: 20" x 30" x 3/16", 2pk
It can cut up to 3mm thick with the deep cut crsft blade
@@srghot18 Ugh! Thank you so much-
Good question - does Cameo cut the Bass Wood like Cricut? They came out with Cricut 3 must faster and the tray you pay $50 extra for it. Never heard of Cameo so I just learning about it.
@@SK-cm5mt sorry this took me so long to reply. It actually cuts deeper so yes it would cut bass wood
Thank you to the many comments added. Learned a lot reading your experiences.
Really good comparison... I still don't know which will be better for me. I like the idea of the cameo and the cutting feature on the back. Software usually comes easier to me but the ease of use for cameo is also nice.... time to play with the software.
Speaking as someone who’s new to this hobby and bought a second hand cricut maker I’m glad to learn there is software that’s better than what cricut offers. Cheers! :)
My first machine was the Sihlouette portrait 2, I’ve used the free version of the studio, I think it works perfectly. I don’t know why but the business edition seems too complicated than necessary. I love the customisations on the Sihlouette. Will be getting the cameo 4 soon for the big projects. The cricut like you said it’s too forced haha. I don’t like how circuit blades look 😂 too basic for aesthetic, cameo looks much more professional
I picked up the Designer Studio years ago on 3rd party site on sale. It’s worth the cost ($50ish) for the stuff it gives.
Thank you for your time and your thoughts. I plan on getting silhouette cameo 4. It shouldn't be too bad seeing im used to 3d printers and laser cutters.
Thanks for this, I started off way back with a craft robo, then upgraded to a cameo 2, I thought I wanted a cricut maker, but this video has told me nah I’m gonna stick with my cameo and upgrade to the 4!! Thanks 😊
this is also my feeling after this video ( I have also a cameo 2)
I have a maker and definitely want to upgrade to the cameo 4
I have the maker and expressions I also have the cameo 2 and just purchased the cameo plus 15 inch. I love the cameo business software so much better than design space.
Thank you so much for this video. I’ll be buying a Cricut for my wedding!
I have owned both Cameo 3 and Cricut Explore Air 2. I loved them both but for me personally I love the Cameo 3 over the Cricut. For what I create the Cameo gives me more freedom in designing. I’m currently awaiting restock of the Cameo 4 Pro and will order after the Christmas frenzy. Very excited to get a large format cutter.
Hows your cricut explore air 2?
You conveyed the info so concise!! The best video. I know I will by the Cameo for the feeding capabilities. I am a little nervous about the software but there is always TH-cam university to help :) Thank you!
I bought the cameo many years ago over the Cricut because you had to be online. I love the cameo software because I can design and not have to buy designs all the time. I think the Cricut is for people who would rather purchase most of their designs or are not comfortable with designing in the software. I think your comparison was great.
Hello Karley I would like to thank you so much For sharing this tutorial. I learned a lot . My decision is to buy circuit can’t wait until it come.
I know I’m two years late seeing your video, but I’m new to the Silhouette Cameo 4.
I have the CRICUT Explorer Air 2, and recently (the Saturday before Mother’s Day, 2023) I acquired the Silhouette Cameo 4 from someone sold to me off Facebook Marketplace as a “New” cutter. It has a big long scratch on the cover, which is about 6 inches long, the autoblade was not properly installed, and it was shaking and rattling very loudly in the left corner when I turned it on. Although, she told me that she sold it because she already was comfortable using the CRICUT Explorer Air 2, and decided not to learn the new machine and its software. She said she turned it on and back off because it was louder than the CRICUT. So she placed it in her closet.
She shipped the machine to me loosely in a liquor box with about 4 small ziplock bags in the box.
Needless to say, I was shocked when I received it. The noise it made was not normal. Although, the Cameo is louder than the CRICUT, but the shaking, rattling noise was not the normal sound.
The machine did not cut anything at first.
I went to TH-cam to ask about the noise, and quickly found the answer. The carriage needed to be reset by turning the machine off, and manually sliding the carriage from left to right about 6 times. Then, turn the machine back on with the carriage still in the right hand corner. When I turned it back on, it automatically aligned itself properly to the left position. The loud noise was now gone.
The autoblade: I thought the blade was dull or defective, so around 3:00 A.M.,I woke up with that blade on my mind. I went to Amazon to order a couple of replacement blades only to see the product video, which demonstrated how to properly install the autoblade. OH MY GOODNESS!!!! The blade only needed to be pushed down into the carriage to close the gap between the carriage and the blade, and then push in the locking mechanism to hold the autoblade securely in place. Now, this machine cuts really good. It quietly aligns itself every time.
However, I do need to learn the correct settings for the various materials that I desire to cut. The liquor box didn’t include nothing else; just the machine and the one autoblade. Nothing else.
I have concluded that the lady thought she had unloaded a defective machine for $200. I thought the same thing, but, so far, the machine is working fine now. I did cut a couple of designs, and it left the last character off the design on both pieces of HTV. So far, that has only happened twice. I wonder what could be causing this problem of leaving off the last letter in a design. I had to cut the letters separately and piece the design together to press them with my heat press. I also have figure out why the mirror option doesn’t work unless I flip the design before clicking SEND. when it asks to mirror the design, the image doesn’t actually cut mirrored. I have ruined two pieces of 3D PUFF HTV. I HAVE to figure this out. Meanwhile. I will be flipping my designs before clicking SEND.
I have ordered two replacement autoblades, two deep cut blades, two 12x24 long mats, two 12x12 mats, and the stand for stacking the two cutters. The CRICUT is one the top with the bottom screwed onto the top of the white stand, and the Silhouette Cameo 4 is on the bottom.
What do you think about this situation? I would greatly appreciate your feedback.
Thank you,
Donna Watson
This is the perfect video! Thank you so much! I think I will go with the silhouette!
I’ve watched a lot of videos to get help trying to decide which machine was best for me. This was the best video I’ve run across. I was able to make my final decision from your suggestions and demonstrations. Thank you.