Pakistan has seen 3 military coups. India none. Why?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ย. 2024
- Since 1947, India and Pakistan's politics has treaded along different paths. Pakistan has seen a spate of military rulers and 3 successful military coups. While India has seen an uninterrupted civilian rule barring the emergency in the 70s. What explains this difference?
Sources:
1. www.amazon.com...
2. qz.com/india/4...
3. indianexpress....
4. thediplomat.co...
5. apps.dtic.mil/...
#Pakistan #MilitaryCoup #MohakMangal
Music Credits:
Music from filmmusic.io
"Sincerely" by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Half-Mystrey" by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
"Basic Imposion" by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
License: CC BY (creativecommons...)
Bhai! Amazing Content 🙌🙌
Are bhai aap ...gajab❤️
Aap bhi bahuto ke inspiration ho sir🙏🏿
Bro hi is leftists influence don't believe
@@tusharlohar2520 nomadic is leftist too. Look up his vlog on Hindus and Sikhs in afghanistan. He makes excuses for islam.
O bhae Maro muze Maro❤️😘
@@itr8247 Why Modi Govt is aiding Afghanistan? They are kattar Hindus na? Why did they build Afghanistan Parliament? Why did Modi ji travel to Afghanistan to inaugurate Afghan parliament? Why did India send free doses of COVID vaccines to Afghanistan? Anyone who doesn't wanna take religious sides is leftist according to you? 😂😂
*I'm not a congress supporter but ill say that we really need a strong opposition
as competition will make sure we get better services*
@@Overflowersonly ha par itna bhi Nahi ki coalition govt wali khichdi phail Jaye😂😂😂
Samr
Yes that's why.i alway support oppsition party
I'll vote for congress if they kick out the gandhi family.
@@raghuls5914 omg yes
When a UPSC guy turn into youtuber..😂😂.nailed it.
he went to Yale University
😁😁😁🙏
@@terrorist6928 bachpan me goumutr pia tha dudh ki jagag👈🖕🤭
@@ismeazamredwanahmed693 Sahi kaha ye gobarbhakt ki paidaish hai
@@ujjwaltyagi6484 Well, benefits bataao zara....aur bhai gaumutra nahi peete.....uska ark peete hai wo bhi 1/4 teaspoon in 1L of water....
So, a military coup not happening in India is by design, not by chance.
never our first govt ensured that
Always by design. The only reason military coup doesn't happen in the US, is by design too.
No! It's by chance!
Nehru bad!!
Nehru bad!!
🤬🤬
@Thomas Jose I thinks he/she/they is being sarcastic
Our military power growing and after another war see what will happen next.
INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS at that time was so far sighted, genius and politically experienced. We owe a lot to the late leaders. Now the Congress in such a pitiful position 😒😔
The Congress back then is incomparable with the current INC.
@@abhishekmittal4765 tabhi voh congress tha 😎 aur cow symbol tha that's the real congress after 1978 it is fake 👍
agreed...
Problem yeh hai ki congress apne ko raaja samjhne lagi thi aisa lg rha tha yeh raajtantra hai.ek hi pariwar ke log raaj krte aar rhe hain
Sahi baat hai Genius And Farsighted..... Handling Veto to china, Orchestrating 26/11 with Pakistan, Letting Go Aksai Chin, PoK,etc. , 1984 Sikh Riots , hundred crores worth of scams
We truly need congress. 🤲🏻🤲🏻😎
we must appreciate Congress for today's well structured Indian system, what they did is now forgotten that's sad
Isliya to abhi tak hmre pass NSG membership nhi h....UN permanent seat nhi h.....POK/Akshai chine aur v kuch Chaiya?
@@harinandantanti9b189 The simple fact is that no official offer was ever made to Nehru or the Indian government to become a permanent member of the UNSC. At best, there were ideas, floated by US officials, which suffered premature deaths.
@@harinandantanti9b189 Dude. I know, congress is not very good party. But we must appreciate congress party for well-structured system. And also we must appreciate Dr. Ambedkar for such wonderful constitution.
1. Congress started from Zero to run this country. There was a time before 1990, Indians were considered to be beggars in the international level.
2. There was no Money to run the nation well.
3. There were no big business or private organizations until 1990.
And you think, in such a poor condition, congress wanted India to be permanent nation of UN?? You wanted NSG membership? wow dude.
At least think of a poor man, how could he afford McDonalds daily? When he'll get promotion of salary increase, then he might be capable of that. And Now, India is capable of that because of previous governance of Congress. Current Modi Government of the BJP sucks, they are just utilizing the funds earned by Congress for the nation.
At that time Congress had leaders like nehru, sardar Patel, Gandhi, baba saheb but now there aren't any leaders there are politicians
@@instinct2233 true bro, today’s youth won’t understand the struggle which country did during that time. Starting from zero is not easy. One must consider their parents situation and examine how country progressed.
In conclusion - India's military power lies in hands of elected govt. In Pakistan, general of army is as powerful as prime minister which is why there's a flawed power sharing system
simply not true, pakistani here, military has guns civilans have tongue, there is no power sharing if you are pointed with a gun. according to constitution of paksitan prime minister is the most powerful person in counrty, but we all know who is more powerful.... the one who has gun.
@@abdulalikhilji2083 that is only because civilian institutions are weak in Pakistan
Second, education system in Pakistan isn't very good and top of that only 57% Pakistani are literate
And third, bullet can only kill you once, but your voice(thoughts) will forever be alive
So, boli>>>>goli
@@abdulalikhilji2083 there’s a poem in Bengali language goes by saying this - "A strong leader's voice is more powerful than hundreds of bullets". Pakistan is in need of strong development-mind leader's guidance. But, I fear that majority of Pakistani citizens think that all the time strong anti-Indian stance of a leader is indicator of his great leadership skills. I often search the twitter & facebook threads of Pakistani leaders where they mostly being indulged in anti-Indian rants than thinking of Pakistani citizens.
@@abdulalikhilji2083 Actually, Army heads are below civilian officers in India. This is the real reason. In fact, any uniformed job is below the civilian job in all the parts of the world. For example, we have the policemen and the revenue department who shares certain parts of law and order. Now, the police is only used as a tool for executing the order of the civilian officer. The police, even IPS officers cannot shoot or do a lathi charge without the direction from RDO/ADM or the district Collector.
How do I know it? My family has both police and civilian officers and army officers. The civilian officers gets promotion much faster, has the authority to command to uniformed officers. For example, when the military comes for any mission, whom do they report to? A civilian officer.
@@abdulalikhilji2083 military takes orders from civilian government.. imagine a businessman hiring bodyguards. Even though the bodyguards hold the guns, it's still the businessman who rules
General V.K.Singh left his position of Chief of Army Staff in 2012 and joined the BJP government in 2014. What is your opinion about senior army officers joining politics? Should there be a buffer period?
Yes they should be banned according to me because consequences are very bad if anything goes wrong.
I don't think anyone but you can answer this question, I am really surprised how intricate things can go.
According to me, army ' retire person should be banned to join any political parties completely without any buffer period...
Logic behind my statement is simple,
1)
After all, each and every army person is human being, ultimately they will have certain ideologies, few support left wings few right wing..
But
If these ideologies let them think that , it compulsory to support certain political parties to be it member then for post benefit as well as for income benefit they will retire and join political parties...
2)
Even our constitution has made certain limits for army not to indulge in political activities even because of this they have not given right to vote ( condition applied) so they can't be treated as vote bank for political parties...
Thus morality as well as constitution both indicates they should be far away from poison..
For ex: -
Since 2014 , we can see many retire army person have started appearing on news channel as spoke person, and indirectly they support bjp...
Just because they are ex army person , majority of people in sake of patriotism may guide by their thought to support certain political party...
Thus it's not good.
Professional career is entirely different from personal thoughts and as per our constitution, there shouldn't be any kind of discrimination upon any one (even against their profession).
Example: Lawyers, policemen, businessmen and even bureaucrats will have their own opinions and impressions in their life as per their experiences and how they perceive those experiences which means everyone is potential radical in their own sense (if we think like this in micro political levels, everything will be absurd). Therefore Ex-army personnel have the right to join politics at any course of his/her life (even immediately after retirement/resignation).
Gen.VK singh was not blot free, he created the ruckuss over his age and questioned the army rule book, also he cashed on anna moment. The army persons shall be allowed to be political after they have enough cooling off period.
What's very surprising is that the Indian army was cool with all these reforms and attempts by the government to distance them. Not a word of protest.
Thats also because the CoAS of that time was Sam Maneckshaw, who had a ton of respect for people like Patel and Nehru even if he butt heads with them. He understood the value of those measures and the value of civilian control in any nation.
Because of Sam manekshaw. He was literally the coolest person ever lived in India. He had a personality to be looked at.
army does what it is asked to do they obey orders
@@gravity7208 Not all armies.
@@himelsarkar5892 Sam Manekshaw was the army chief under Indira Gandhi. Kuchh mat likh diya kar bhai
I am from Pakistan. You have cleared my confusion. Yes, Indian political leadership was more proactive and rational in their decisions. As a result, Indian army has become more professional.
More powerful too
Plus in 1857 indian army try to take over country but the British government some how manage to suppress them later on British structure army so diverse that it's become hard for them to do another millitary couple but when they are leaving india nehruji is concern that india can face millitary coup that's why in majority of desicions he first deny the millitary intervention and invasion on anything like integration of Hyderabad and goa to india and also in topics like kashmir or taking revenge against Pakistan by invading them and merge them back to india nehru decline all this offers by his cabinate to make sure millitary never take over india as they want india to be a democracy a people's rule and ideal rule which in india also known as (ram raaj means rule of india similar to when king ram rule over us)
Bro your jounerlism level is very pure and purely based on facts..
You should broadcast videos day to day..if not daily then at least in every 3rd day
journalism*
That may reduce the quality content.
Broadcast is a word meant for radios. And telecast for TVs.
Smartphones.........so smartcast?
Really good info... First time after very long long time.... Iam hearing health info
Being a Pakistani I would salute your analysis..!!
Who the f asked u
@@saulgoodman5663 Does anyone ask for comments idiot?
@@saulgoodman5663 me
❤
@@mirzafawazbaig724 Really India is amazing ❤️
As a Pakistani citizen I'm very thankful to you for such a unbiased and neutral analysis, we have these problems and you correctly presented the whole History of Pak Army interference in Politics. Hats off to you bro 👍
Namaste 🙏❤️
As we Indian permote peace and prosperity
@हर्षित harshit sharma bhai we never have been blind folded by religions. Quiad e azam have said in his last sermon “ you are free to go to your temples, mosques, churches” you would not given any advantage for your religion. We have been running by dictatorships because of chutiyah gen gracy who was joint chief of india and Pakistan. He didn’t accept any orders from quaid e azam, that was the inception point of dictatorships and that’s where army started to rule the country. Fate had kill us
@maddy gamer we have always hated the army when they try to pull dictatorship, it’s obvious.
Awais nazir...Bhai I m indian muslim I want to know have u read about Azad Hind Fauz, revolt of 1857... What I feel about pre 1947 history....JAI HIND 🇮🇳👍🙏
One thing I underestimated about congress[Nehru] was that they were exceptional in making India's foundations strong as f*ck. Our administration is strong AF, educational institutes are amazing, judiciary, although flawed sometimes but still exceptional. I mean, you can clearly see the state of our neighboring countries and about their administration. Hat's off Nehru....
But aaj kl ke logo ko kuchh smjh nhi.. aata... Nehru jaise century me 1 baar paida hote h..
@@prashanttiwari1413 bro are u comeding me
@@maharshidadheech3791 nhi bhaiii sach baat h.. Itna strong foundation bnana Asaan nhi h... Bo bbi uss time communist ideology peak par thi... Aur india me extreme Right wing just like Present time..
@@prashanttiwari1413 leave it bro but do u thing partition hona chaiye tha
ind pak ka and thats the worst thing congress has and or bhi bahut si chize galat ki h bhai
I am from Bangladesh🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩 and I have to say.. your analyses are damn good man. 1971 happened because of Bangali vs Panjabi clash. Before our liberation war Pakistan army, politics and whole government system were dominated by the panjabi people. Even they didn’t let Sekh Mujibur Rohman to form central government after won the 1970 election.
In our liberation war most of the brutal things were done by panjabi regiments.
along with Bihari Muslims aligning with Punjabis.
Just to clarify bhutto was not a punjabi. He won in punjab but was not a punjabi he was a sindhi
@@usamajaved2634 yes a sindhi muslim rajput
But majority soldiers were Punjabi and they dominated the decisions
@@ashutoshanand1573 yeah I recently heard that and even now they are in a problem of not getting citizenship
@@usamajaved2634 bhutto surname came from hindu surname bhatt, am i right?
being a Pakistani i would say its a very neutral and informative video. Although I always see a war mongering and hatred for Pak Army from other side but this one is very neutral and based on facts.
Liberals in Pakistan are rare
I hope stability for Pakistan, only then our shared region would prosper.
Conservative Liberal have u ever been to balochistan?
@Ruturaj Shiralkar And Indian government never provided any evidence.
after WW2 p5 disided to divide world
Lanka, E.Pak was created to keep India, successor of British Raj busy internally
W.Pakistan was supposed to be part of USSR
Burma, Tibet, Nepal was supposed to be part of then Republic Of China even before Mao happened
YOU CAN CROSS CHECK WITH EVENTS LIKE AFGHAN INVASION
Pakistan did not invade Kashmir, military was under British commanders when this conflict began in India as well as Pakistan
THAT DOES NOT MEN WHAT YOU DID IN BANGLADESH & BALUCHISTAN IS RIGHT
that explains i have no intention of playing devils advocate
but we all must know this facts
Bro I am from Pakistan, and this video is so on point, the Ahamdiya incident is the important and overlooked incident in Pakistan, the inicident was a testing point of military rule in Pakistan
Dispassionate unbiased report.
Respect from Pakistan.
What is this panjabi thing ? But you guys are descendents of turks and arbis as per your leaders.
@@mayankmishra1186 hey why are u talking rudely it's better to talk nicely.
In the time of war we are free do any thing.
@@neverfallinlove.5801 rudely ????
mayank mishra not true? My parents are pakistani but I am descended from punjabi Indians
Just keep peace
As a Pakistani, I appreciate this very respectful and neutral method of discourse. It was very effective taking insight from an orthodox source. I hope you continue to make videos in this method so a trend of respectful discourse is promoted among our nations.
Oh boy...
I never ever saw a better explanation even by a pak professor...
Thank you man.
For that you need educated people in Pakistan 😄
Why your 10 minute video make more sense than 18 years of pakistan studies subject :(
What disaster would happened if coup was made by world 4th most powerful military
mohd farhan
Dear your word have Value but we just study 📖 Pakistan-Study in 10th and 2nd year.
In rest we study social sciences.
Muhammad Hashim Khan lol..not in just 10th and 2nd year...Its a compulsory subject from grade 1 to 10th..and in 12th..
Stop being deluded..
Throw that book out in the garbage. There are more important things to worry about than remembering who created a country and who were ghadaars.
Abe bas kr o yr.. 4th powerfull army😆
@@chandshek9903 we r muslims too and ur taking this in shame on u muslims against muslims
Dude i am from Pakistan and i really appreciate on the research that u have done, its amazing. You forgot to mention thay Pakistan also has had its share of corrupt politicians like Nawaz Sharif and Zardari.
Pakistani army have respect among masses but political parties does not.
@mr. Sachin yup exactly!!
No bro he is just stating facts.
May b Nawaz would have done something good for ur country, therefore he cannot judge or criticise Nawaz or anyone
But can judge or criticise his policies and judgements.
@radhenitsri yes exactly what he is saying is exactly the narrative of all the military dictators that all politicians are corrupt so you should choose us
Which should not be an option in any situation
Indian politicians are even more corrupt but still they represent democracy
This channel has made the language of media to a different level. It gives us information, analysis, topics, thoughts and shows us how to be responsible journalists (unlike TV news channels). So impressed over your choice of topics. Awesome video... Keep it up.
Ghanta election ka analysis dekho Pura fail ho Gaya prediction lol 😂 khud ko smart samazata hain
Mere state me to exactly wahi hua... West Bengal me analysis Acha Kiya tha
Aur prediction 100% Kaise hoga... Points Aur facts realistic the
@@arpitsarkar4793 lekin kise ne Socha tha Kya bjp300 paar jaegi muze laga tha Amit shah bhi nahi kar payega lekin us patrakar ne predict kar liya tum prediction ke liye uske video dekho iske nahi ye channel Congress ki taraf zuka hua hain
I'm sorry bro. Lekin Mujhe to lagta hai ye channel sabse neutral channel Hai. Sabse balanced analysis karte hai. Pehele to topic i choose karte hai Aisa jisme biased hone Ka jarurat nehi. Dhruv Rathi Ka channel thoda AAP ki taraf biased Hai... Par ye channel Bilkul nehi.. Ye Mera rai hai... Apko lag sakta Hai ye congress ke prati biased... Wo Apka opinion hai
So, Congress is responsible for preserving democracy in india
Congress did emergency. Biggest reason is that India is a dharmic majority country while Pakistan is an islamic country.
@@itr8247 so Why Pakistan is not developed As inda after 70yrs.
@@adarsh3179 because of coups and using money to fund terrorism in India, Afghanistan and Iran.
@@itr8247 Bhai u really need to read some books tbh.
@@itr8247 what are you saying ? Do you have problem about india's secularism?
Respect from a Pakistani, when someone speaks the truth.
Iam Pakistani but your research is well organzed and sums up history of martial laws in pakistan i appreciate that
👉 95% people who watch this channel are "Young"
main young hoon meri shadi karwade bhai >
I am 12
@@AlexKarston re itna vi young nahi...🤭🤭
Gourab Sarkar I am a Mapper so I like Political Content.It helps me do better mapping.
Im 19
you indians are lucky to have a visionary leader like nehru our first prime misnister made a language that only 3% of the population spoke the only official language.
Yaa nehru
Who refused gwadar
Who refused aksai chin
Who refused khuriya muriya
Who refused nuke in 1959
Who refused col point
I'm very proud of my army... more than any institution in india...
But I never want military coup in INDIA🇮🇳
Then why do you vote bjp?
@@UdayKumar-hg7rx Better than anit national and anti hindu.
@@joshuatheunkownuniverse.2475 who is anti national? Why are they not yet been arrested? Not a single case has been done on any anti national.
Anti Hindu!!! 80% of india’s population is hindu
We are blessed to have such a great leader's past like Nehru, Ambedkar, Indira. Long live India
Oh god!! How do you even get such topics for discussion? Keep doing this wonderful job
You dont get it by watching youtube go through books girl.
@@mayankmishra1186 books are boring boy
@@Banditxam4 thats why fools are increasing while studying in whatsapp university.
@@mayankmishra1186 books may be misleading nowadays, we can't trust anyone nowadays.
DHooka hee DHooka
@@mayankmishra1186 Tujhe kisne kaha smartness dikhane ko
From Pakistan but Not GOnna Lie!!! Loved your work and your research! The main stream Indian TV News channels should learn from nowadays young kids who works way far better than them actually its the most neutral content I've seen on TH-cam from someone who's from India. Y'all should support this guy!!!!! Keep it up BrO! Luv from Pakistan!
mainstream indian chanels are funded by bjp so dont expect unbiased news.
@Ramesh Ranjan I don't watch them
Tu hota kaun hai Indian media ko gali dena wale be ???
Ja jake bache ka balatkar kar
well I agree, but the same applies to Pakistani media
isn't it?
@@aryakrishna6923 i wonder will you say the same for pakistani news channels?
Subscribed with ♥️ from 🇵🇰
Please keep doing good and unbiased work.
Namaste 🙏 from india🇮🇳.
Nehru Govt. Have handled India in a very well manner..many would criticise him but no one can compare handling a newly independent country to a well settled , well developed (Still improving) nd well organised country.
I guess you've seen just one side of coin. I'll give you a lot of examples where newly independent country grew more exponentially
@@heathens2867 not just newly independent , can you show examples which had similar issues like our neighbour Pakistan and China and the internal conditions full of communal riots
agree
Ironic that the most efficient institution of the country has never overstepped its power.
@TheTurramkhan Army is unanimously the most efficient institution of India. But they never tried to enter into politics.
Thank god we got visionaries like Nehru, Patel, ambedkar, abul kalam azad and others unlike Jinnah ❤️
Yes absolutely
Thank God we had leader like Nehru, Patel, ambedkar and kalam
@@sadanandpoojari5811 Nehru 😂😂😂😂 jaath barabar bhi Nahi h Patel ji ki
Nehru ki wajah se Kashmir hua Laddakh Gaya
UNSC Gaya
Please include First, First Person in the List
@Amaan Haider pagal h kya.. General Manekshaw ka interview dekh.. unhone bola tha patel ji ne pressure kiya tbhi Nehru ne order Diya army ko kashmir lene k liye
@Amaan Haider aesa kuch nhi hua. Patel ji bohot upset thae bcz Nehru UN pahuch gya tha. Indian Army ne kha tha ki hume time dijiye hum Islamabad Lahore Karachi sab jeet lenge 1947.
Mera India 🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳❤️
tera nhi Hamara 🇮🇳
@@shivam_nagar69 sometimes people are really stupid . if you say anythings like this with word "mera" it increases the importance for an individual . but when we say hamara its like shared thing which decreases its importance for an individual, although its a very idiosyncratic thing. you should not write words "tera" it represent pomposity and create a gloomy abode
@@prakharvirdi914 chill dude such a long comment why?
Where is the other guy?Haven't seen him awhile.
Exactly
Yes ! Searching for that girl too ...
Probably behind the camera.
@Daniel Smith 😂 lynched by peacefuls
The other guy have joined the BjP😂😂😂 Now they are working only for India/Bharat/Hindustan
I am Bangladeshi and this is Very well researched unbiased and good contents with facts and informative and educational.
None of these fancy videos crap with who has what weapons and tanks and jets.
Sorry to ask but how do u understand what he's saying if you're Bangladeshi
@@aditsud5354 some of them know both Hibdi and Bengali
@@aditsud5354 Bangladeshis understand Hindi because hindi is similar to bangla and Bollywood is very popular
@@conservativewarrior6717 Hindi and Bengali are similar but non-Bengali hindi speakers can't understand Bengali. Why is the vice-versa true ?
Indian army ❤️ Noble army hats off salute to the tributes 🇮🇳Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
Jai Jawan Jai Kisan 🚩🚩 🚩 🚩
Truly based upon the facts,
A logical and rational analysis.
Great Respect from Pakistan
I appreciate your respect brother namaste 🙏 from india 🇮🇳
I have Listen many Videos On Army Operation and Partition but Never heard Such deep Information in TH-cam Amazing Information bro .
Man you are so well versed and educated about these things. And you have a very unbiased and professional way of presenting facts without sugar coating anything and without being abusive either. So professional! Much love from Pakistan 🇵🇰♥️
No military coup reason = Indian army was divided into para-military forces. Great decision.
This is such a well-explained video, really enjoyed the research you put into the historical and political factors that can often get overlooked. Thank you for putting this up.
Congress was an asset after partition that successfully laid a strong foundations. They made democratic system strong enough to stay so for generations. Don't believe what BJP is spreading, research on your own and use your brain.
Right.... Actually Hindu mahasabha had an existential threat from Congress that's why today RSS-BJP is bending history to defame Congress...
The Congress at that time was full of intellectuals and freedom fighters. But now only one family .
@@kurapatichaitanya705 exactly
@gulag master this channel is pakistan and congress funded
Map of india shown in video is ?
@@kurapatichaitanya705 Agree with you
Bohat aage jayega bhai tu. I have seen lot of youtubers but you are different and unique. Keep it same
As a Pakistani I would appreciate you for making neutral content. before this video I never seen any Indian content creater to make neutral content....
Thanks bro 🥰❤️❤️❤️❤️
Are u really Pakistani? If yes then love Pakistan from India
we don't have dearth of quality content creators bro...
@हर्षित harshit sharma No bro,
Word Affairs by Prashant sir Channel is totally Propaganda based news Channel.
He make video very quickly but totally miss guide his audience, if you have doubt then research on his each and every news about Pakistan that he give you will shock to see the reality.
I'm watching your Social media content creators this guy Mohak is only sensible and mature content creator from all of them..
@@krish4134 Yes I'm.
@हर्षित harshit sharma just follow this guy ( Mohak) to get purely research based content.
I am laughing at pakistani's comments, saying indian media should be like this, meanwhile i came here after watching pakistani media comedy🤣🤣 wtf man HYPOCRISY ki bhi seema hoti h at least india mai neutral stance dikh rha h tumhaara kya haal h?
Sahi keh rahe hai woh
Very well done, boy. Appreciate the neutrality you've shown in this video. And it was totally fact-based. Going to subscribe to your channel. Peace everywhere!
Jakar the wide side ka video dekho
Have watched every single video he has uploaded since ever. Chill bro.
@@Dddddddd61
Bhai kyo hatered failate ho?
Most of the people can't think of these topics. How do you get these kinds of ideas and marvellous presentation, Bro...
Am here after Coup in Myanmar
As a pakistani, I feel obligated to say : Bruh.
Aajtak ek bhi pm pura tenure pura nhi kar paya hai pakistan me ye to general knowledge hai🤦
Me too, I have been trying to look into this type of stuff. The things that are happening in Myanmar are horrible. Do you know any way to help?
This is what Congress contributed in India's development, a strong base of the Country
indeed
That is why Congress remain in power for most of the time. Even now also congress is a brand in politics.
@@rh2400 no, the Nehru Gandhi was too much influential and decided the decisions of the nation. Present day Congress is not able to fight. Their too much reliance on RaGa is their biggest problem. The Grand old party is now reduced to a Family owned private limited company
@@ashutoshanand1573 very true
@@ashutoshanand1573 agreed. I hope to see a reforming of inc...where sachin pilot and potential leaders can have the room for showing how the progressive motto of INC can be executed on ground-level.
Who came here after bangladesh coup?
i rarely say this, but i have started to become a huge fan ... keep up the good work
Here after watching today's video ♥️
yessss, I remember now,, a total Mechanised Infantry brigade was called to report the COAS in Delhi ....Now he's a minister in the current Govt..........
You earned my subscription. There is difference between begging and earning. Modern world needs more of objective rationale than biased/manipulative thought process
Because our army is legendary🇮🇳
If anyone from defence forces is reading this we civilians are grateful.
@TheTurramkhan Not necessarily!
An educated and real citizens wants to watch this type of vedio
Keep it up
Love u bro
Amazed at how farsighted our leaders used to be. We are still living off their good work.
Wonderfully researched and beautifully presented. This made me so happy. Keep up the good work.
Pakistani knows 3 words rss , bjp , godi media 😂 they are quite interested in Indian politics 😂
And people say congress did nothing in 70 years
Congress and BJP were same party before independence lol!!
Congress till Rajiv was good that's why we voted Congress for so many years.
But present day congress is more of monarchy and communal bias
@@unitedbeast6614 second that. We hate congress under sonia ffs
Congress buiid the newly independent India.Congress was really good when it was in good hands.From Indira and especially after rajiv gandhi..congress stared sucking India.
@@hinayakohli6437 no the downfall started after mandal commission. That is when they became pseudo secular
Informative. Thank you.
Urdu was imposed to Pakistan where only 3% representation was there, and biggest Language Bangla and Punjabi were banned!!!
dude you are one genuine journalist , keep doing what you do aur kisi press conference ya public meet mein aaye to i will pakka attend do post venue and dates , good luck as always .
Pakistan money diverted to 70% to military is also the main reason for Pakistan still being so unstable and non emerging country and will be always in future. Thanks to their mindset and fear of India taking over Pakistan will never compete with India and now even with Bangladesh. They have to give up their fear, forget Kashmir and stop sponsoring terrorism against neighbours which will benefit for Pakistan and Pakistani and make them stable and sustainable economy.
It was my school *ASSAM RIFLES PUBLIC SCHOOL AGARTALA,Tripura* 😙
Bangladeshi go back, leave our Tripura, there is no place for Bangladeshi like you
@@EastTwipra shut up 🤫
@@EastTwipra he is a bengali hindu
@@ashutoshanand1573 North East people are sick of Immigrants. They don't want any outsider in there area either hindu or muslim.
They became minorities in there own state because of immigration from Bangladesh
I have also studied in this school for 3 years
Hey, wait are you really a forecaster...
You already had a vision about Myanmar's coup ..... 😂😂 Well, really informative video!
This video is a proof that Congress party did well after independence 😀👍
Mashallah hogaya😂
Lots of respect for your facts,research and presentation.. thanks 👍👏👏 Plz guys help this channel to grow,share as much as you can..
Even though Nehru made lots of mistakes,which we could analyze only bcoz we r in future,he was the best P.M...we ever had!!Thats the power of scientific temper!!Now we have someone similar to Patel🙄.Strong..but outdated like a tribal leader!!
Nehru built india from ashes, he should be respected.
Even though indian leaders make mistakes but India is not barbaric like it's neighbours and having no military coup is a proof
We need to keep improving ourselves to have a stable present and future ....jai hind🇮🇳
Imagine if rss bjp and people like modi amit shah yogi savarkar were in power during those times. Our situation would have been just as Pakistan’s situation and most importantly, India wouldn’t have been a democratic country today.
Thanks to diversity in race and religion in congress and the visionary leadership of nehruji who chose to focus in diversity, secularism and scientific temperament for which reason he founded, with a very limited budget (as India just got independence after the looting of $45T), institutions like IIT, IIM, AIIMS, DRDO, BARC, INCOSPAR which later became ISRO, BE and many other successful profitable PSUs, which are still shining the name of India today, which wouldn’t have been the case if he built temples & statues with that limited budget. And because of his diversity & secularism ideology, ISRO was able to successfully launch its first rocket in 1969 from a church(St. Mary Magdalene church) in Thimbu, Kerala and the bishop & other church leaders played a crucial role in acquiring 600acres of land in Thimbu from the locals for ISRO’s use. If it was Savarkar or mudi or yogi, they would’ve used those limited funds in building statues & temples and citizens would’ve become radical as focus would have been made in religion instead of education, just as Pakistan.
Nehruji’s visionary geopolitical diplomacy is still being followed till today which is benefitting India and her interests till today. His non alignment policy and yet siding with USSR was the wisest decision of all. Because he chose to side with USSR instead of USA during Cold War era, India was able to acquire many important defence equipment from USSR even in barter system and their VETO has been so much helpful in UNSC, the defence pact signed between India & USSR under the leadership of Indira Gandhi ji literally saved India in 1971 war from USA’s powerful 7th fleet followed by British royal navy and our military was able to divide paapistan into two parts with the highest military surrender of 93k soldiers in human history (she really was an Iron Lady, something which current Gandhians failed to acquire). And because of the important & all time tested friendship between India and USSR, the friendship continued till today’s Russia as well for which reason we are able to get crude oil(the most essential part of running a country) in heavily discounted price (during the time when crude oil price per barrel are skyrocketing because of Ukraine invasion) that is literally saving us from recession, to be precise we are at 7% gdp growth rate in times when major developed countries are facing recession because pricy crude oil.
Our gdp per capita is still 1200$ in 2014
Even congress rupe over us for 55 year
Ya it true we don't become like pakisatan
But ya we also don't become successful as a country
@@divya9951 congress PMs were DEMOCRATICALLY elected by hardworking Indians to govern the country. Your statement is utterly ridiculous and ignorant. And when India got independence, only Congress was such political party who were strong enough. So, if they wanted, they could have made india One Party System, just like china, with no democracy or election. But they chose democracy and let the Indian citizens choose their leaders in which congress won in every election. If Savarkar or rss or bjp leaders like Modi amit shah yogi were in place of Gandhi Nehru SVP, India would have become autocratic nation instead of democracy. In 2004, India’s gdp was $700M and in 2014 India’s gdp became $2.14T. That means in 10yrs Dr. Manmohan Singh govt tripled(3times) Indian gdp even though there were sanctions upon India for 1998 Pokhran nuclear test and 2008 world recession. And now, Modi is not even able to double the gdp since 2014 to 2023 with all the infrastructures and good diplomatic ties with all major countries.
And Indian Rupee was less than ₹50 against $1 and now it is almost ₹90
@@casualuser2317 broo
With a gdp per capita of 1000$
@@divya9951 it was $1600 in 2014 and in 2023 it is $2600
india me military nhi literally god hai.
coup isn't something we can even accidently think of😌.
jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳
Rakshak ko bhakshak bolne se pehle Army ko sahi tarah se jaan le. Fir bol.. Tum logo jaise army me power aur seat ke liye ladai nahi hoti.
@Moda Foka army me tum logo se toh kam hi corruption hota hai. Chal bhaag yaha se, khud toh select ho nahi pate aur bhok bhok ke unka naam kharab karte ho ek baat dhyaan rakh agar zinda haina toh unhi ki wajah se hai . Unki kabiliyat aur niyat pe shakk mat kar
Your best content on SOCH ever. It's very informative and leadership based knowledge.
@Zack Smith Pakistan is already unofficially under military rule.
@Pappu Rahul Khan no we don't want military rule.
Democracy is good for us.
Kuch log to har jagah hote haii.
Allah aur bhagwan dono ka sukra haii ki wo log bhaut Kam haii.
@@neverfallinlove.5801 Allah aur Bhagwan ek hi hai.
Indian Army never betrayed its people and never will
Pak doesn't have a
Civilian society for democracy
They favour army , which is bit contractions for modernization of society
Islam hates democracy and islamists love monarchy caliphate and sharia law
@Abhi 'Shrupp' Nandan kam se kam jo channel dekh raha hai usi ka lihaaz karte huwe thodaa meaningful krdeta
They have sharia law
@@kashutosh9132 sachai h babu bhaiya
Just imagine if the current ruling party back then had been the government and not the current opposition we would be like what Pakistan is today. This is why civilized, secular, and most importantly educated(not just literate) are needed as leaders else India becoming like Pakistan is not far from reality.
Actually, a strong constitution and its well calculated amendment made india stronger.... Whenever a rule of religious or ethnicity fanatics starred in a country the people would lose believe in their constitution. Signs of this uncomfort are now getting visible in the society. Beware and be true to the preamble of the Indian Constitution.
Please make a video on how to research on a topic by ourselves
Go to google
Like you research Mia khalifa
Ya but how can we know whether the info makes any sense or not
@@shreevathsabhat5846 hello there. Great to see you passionate about researching facts.
Here are some of the basics.
1) Wikipedia is your enemy. Never take any thing you read on the internet for its face value.
2) Try authorised or well known agency data. They are liable for the work they do, hence fudging data/facts is quite impossible. However cross verifying all data is a good idea.
3) You should know how to look for the outcome you seek. Basically have a plan as to what you want to know coz it really help you narrow down the research.
4) Research papers are your best friends and can be freely accessed via the google scholar filter.
You can check out indiaspend they do pretty solid data journalism... You will pick up a few things going through their articles.
I am not affiliated to them . They are really good.
Your journalism level is fabulous👌👌👌well done brother keep on doing and giving informative videos to us
The most basic difference, our Army is never driven by religious inclinations but pure patriotism and discipline. Our army has Hindus, Muslim, Sikh this hetrogenity is our power.
Our army has civilian life as priority , while Musharraf says : war is exciting and fun!
Also Sam and Indira's argument clearly defined how Our army has always been supremely wise than these political monkeys.
You forgot one aspect, the geography. The size of India won't let a coup easy as the army need to cover a large area unlike pakistan or Somalia
Loved the analysis, it's unbiased, fact based, precis and have different perspectives!
Thank you Congress for laying the foundation of building a diverse country.
Which govt made APJ Abdul Kalam president 🤔
@Moda Foka
Vajpayee ji ne kalam sir ko nominate Kiya tha
Lol what the fuck
Thanks to Nehru...Nehru is best pm of india, bcz he is secular, educated... Lastly Nehru 7 saal jail main tha, indian freedom fight ke liye...
9 years, not 7
Still 30 40% decision he made were worst
And he died bcz of HIV😊😊😊✌️
@@shashankrai6070 WhatsApp Ka knowledge Nahi Lena Bhai😂😂😂😂😂fake hai thodi to research Kar lete😂😂
@Bhanu Pratap Singh do you even know the meaning of secularism???
Wrong information 4 coups in Pakistan ,
1 ) Yahyah Khan
2 ) Ayub Khan
3 ) Zia Ul Khan
4 ) Parvez Mushraf
Zia ul haq ha
Who is Zia ul Khan?
and they say what congress had done in 70 years
Pakistani in this comment section are so respectful .how come 😳
superb analysis bro...one of the best video on u tube in terms of logical reasoning
Another informative video by Soch hats off to you mohak
love you
big respect from pakistan
👍🏼
No homo
if India have military rule all the border issues will be resolved within day😂😂😂😂😂 but Indian military respect Indian Constitution,they will never do such think
Thank God army is not in power then.
@@nmo3148 So you want border issues?
@@knowledgedesk1653 We don't want chaos.
Bhai i am watching this video after the recent Mayanmar military coup.. And your really defined the very Sharp edges behind the coup.. and ya I'm following you since you didn't even crossed 50k.. And when i compared this with the recent coup.. it made me to comment for the first time... You really had done a very impressive research.. love u bro..
I have just listened a masterpiece of journalism 👍
Good Analysis not biased , keep it bro love from 🇵🇰
Namaste 🙏❤️🇮🇳 India
You just managed to turn military coup positive. I feel among many emotions, amazed. NO justification should be given for the dismantling and undermining of democratically elected governments and institutions by the army of any state. That is where the line should be drawn. The army should have zero say in the governance of a state period.
And for you to completely ignore the corruption within the pakistan army and ignore the ambitions of the generals involved in the coups is just flat out wrong, personal ambition has always been a huge and the foremost among other reasons for military coups in pakistan, and for you to igonore that fact, seems and I’m sorry that i have to say this, biased.
Dude please make a Patreon page. We want to support people like you. People like you are what this country needs.
Indians are very well educated
This is making india one of the leading country in world ❤️
@@rottenapple6531 Ohhh🤑🤑🤘🎉🌋🌋