Ejection 160 - Andy Green Ejected on Day 1 as Cubs Acting Manager After Tom Hallion's Slide No-Call
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ก.ย. 2021
- 2B Umpire and Crew Chief Tom Hallion ejected Cubs bench coach/interim manager Andy Green after a bona fide slide rule interference no-call on Pirates runner Kevin Newman's slide. Report: www.closecallsports.com/2021/...
Unlike college (NCAA), which uses a force play slide rule (FPSR) standard that would declare this runner out for failing to slide in a direct line between the bases, professional baseball (OBR) uses a bona fide slide standard.
According to slide rule OBR 6.01(j), a runner meets the criteria for a bona fide slide by:
1) beginning the slide prior to reaching the base;
2) being able and attempting to reach the base with a hand or foot;
3) being able and attemping to remain on the base after completing the slide;
4) sliding within reach of the base without changing pathway for the purpose of initiating contact with a fielder to break up a double play.
Although this is a reviewable play, Chicago was out of challenges due to an unsuccessful challenge earlier in the game on a play at home plate. The Crew Chief is unable to initiate a Crew Chief Review on non-HR boundary calls prior to the 8th inning. - กีฬา
Tom Hallion is a man who knows when his ass is in the jackpot. His calls should never again be disputed lol.
“Jomboy is gonna love this “ lmaoo that’s golden
"Jomboy is gonna love this" Love it lol.
can we stop with this nonsense already? go to his videos when its posted leave him off this page already he doesn't know the rules and doesn't care to be educated in teaching himself the rules
@@critter2 Jeez man, lighting up a little and have some fun. No matter how much you love baseball it's still just a game. We watch this channel for the rules and Jomboy for the lip reading and lighter side of things. They pair well together. If you don't like it thats fine but don't be a party pooper!
@@chrismess135 well said
@@critter2 people here know CCS is for knowledge, Jomboy is just entertainment. There's room for both.
Yea I got a good chuckle when they said it! Also subbed to both, go figure!
Keep it up CCS
Gotta love Tom Hallion. He's one of the best.
Yes, I believe Tom will be the most senior umpire next year if he doesn't retire along with Joe West and Gerry Davis. I'll miss him!!!
He's the kind of ump that thinks he's part of the show when behind the plate. If I was a manager, I'd let him know he's a horse's ass when I give him the lineup card. I hate umps trying to get airtime.
@@bartsimpsonsimpson3367 You're a David Price fan, obviously. Lol
Lol Andy isn’t the head manager. Covid or not. He’s had too many embarrassing ejections in SD. Doesn’t know the rules and it shows here. Not a great look.
@Mike Heathman based on fact on TH-cam? Take words out of context much? Geeze what’s your deal tonight? Had a field day on this comment section. Good grief.
I love Hallion saying ‘you don’t know what you’re talking about that’s why you aren’t the manager’ kind of true too
Andy green has lots of baseball experience and was a valedictorian in high school I highly doubt he doesn’t study the rules and have some of the best understanding of the rules. He was a manager for 3 years in San Diego he will be a manager again in the future.
@@joshgarza1527 and Hallion attended University of Buffalo and has been an umpire for 35 years and has extensive knowledge of the MLB rules. See anyone can google facts about an umpire or player or manager.
That being said I would trust Hallions knowledge of the MLB rules better than Andy Greens seeing as he has been an umpire for a very long time. And one has training and two experience in the MLB.
@@borisjohnson7799 I’m sure he does but it was a clear slide into the fielder and not the base he just missed the call it’s not really even a deep down rule that any coach or ump would have a hard time understanding. Second off I didn’t google that I knew that because I follow Kentucky baseball…
Josh Garza What you said doesn’t matter...You have to use the criteria set out, not your opinion...
No wonder you are defending Green
@@rickhaavisto9023 that rule is an interpretation call it depends on how you see the rule.
If I can read lips I think Tom added the F word when he said you don't know what you're talking about
The way he put his hat back on tho! 😂😂😂 3:34
2:54 Tom hallion said ah bullshit😂
Thanks for the analysis, Beaker!
Hey guys love the videos you guys put out, always look forward to learning new things about the game.
@@davej3781 thought it was some kind of joke or something
@@davej3781 ah shit my bad, thanks for that.
Gil/Lindsay is trans. That’s her new voice.
This is the first time you mentioned Jomboy Media. I agree 100%. He is definitely gonna have a good time with this.
@Mike Heathman - Dude, this ISN'T your channel. Gil brought up Jomboy, so Jomboy fans ARE welcome here. So, fuck off.
What a champ Hallion. Still has my favourite strike 3 called in baseball
Looks like a close play at the plate, bang-bang play. Foot and ball at the same time. Call was right at 2nd.
Where is this last second direction change that the announcers keep talking about? He was always aiming at the outside of the bag, he never deviated
Green tried to go up against the Cosa Nostra of MLB Umpires - Hallion and then Cuzzi comes to his defence. Lol.
I missed seeing Andy Green get tossed. I remember he got tossed on my birthday back on April 2nd. I live on the east coast so it was already the 3rd.(my birthday). It was a great birthday present!!
April 3rd is my B-Day, too! 1967
birthday twins!
@@terryrose4804 97
I've said it before. There are simply some managers umps don't like. Trust me: Green is one of those; that's why Hallion's not taking his sh!t.
How does replay miss the call at home though???
I've missed watching Andy get worked up and ejected
he got ejected earlier in the year too
@@aydanpatrick9182 yeah, but this was an especially reminiscent example of his temper he displayed in SD
@@UnhungHero yeah
Andy got owned by Hallion here. That umps got balls.
@@aydanpatrick9182 This is Green's first ejection of the year.
Tom Hallion rules
Thats a high blood pressure moment huh...
The guy was sae sliding into home so they have a right to be pissed... You hate to see the rare instance of review not getting it right
I agree. I think Andy Green wasn’t necessarily as mad about Hallion’s call, but instead more about the missed call at home that caused them to not have a challenge for Hallion’s call. The replay system is good, but it feels so flawed with the “indisputable evidence” aspect. A lot of calls get missed because it’s so difficult to overturn calls. It’s really just up to the officials making the replay call
@@troywilson9885 Having a limit on challenges hampers all sports and many missed calls could have been corrected.
Unless they have the absolute perfect camera angle, they're not going to overrule.
I agree he was safe. However, with the first base side camera, they can say the catcher blocks the view so you can't, with 100 % certainty see when the tag is applied.
Same with the 3rd base camera. Because of the angle, you can't see if the glove brushed the runner's leg.
Since the call on the field was out and they don't have 100% confirmation the runner was safe (despite what our eyes tell us) they have to uphold the call
Rare.
I’ve said it before, but you and Jomboy need to do a collaboration video!
Miss watching this as a padres fan
Mentioning Jomboy by name!! Loving it!!!
As a Cubs fan, even I think it was stupid to get mad over. He had released the ball before he was slid into.
It was a legal slide too.
Love those uniforms
This is very sad to say, but Tom Hallion is no longer a major league umpire. He had a marvelous career.
I was just thinking that....Jomboy will love it.
Can't wait to see Jomboy's video
Best ump in baseball.
wait a second, why was David Ross fired from the Cubs??
David Ross got covid so Andy green is acting as manager
Call at home looked wrong.... correct at second
I agree. There are a couple of frames where it's obvious that the runner has his foot on the plate and there's air between the catcher's mitt and the runner. Also, it looks like the catcher may have been blocking the plate with his left foot before he had the ball.
This is why Andy Green will never see an actual managerial job again in MLB, he doesn't know the rules and definitely can't stand being told your wrong. Let's ignore the fact that he looks like the stunt double for Sean Astin
These no contact plays at the plate are killing me thanks posey
Tom Hallion aka the tornado ump
Have you ever been a second basemen when a runner slides into you? I don't think so.....
Andy's ass was in the jackpot.
Who’s the 3rd manager?
Tommy Hottovy
When are you getting your normal voice back? Lol!
Funny how he will criticize any announcer but hides the elephant in the room when it relates to HIS commentary
@@daniellaughlin2754
@@davej3781 There's a huge difference between bein unable to address an issue an unwilling, this is the latter.
@@davej3781 Yes because fixing his ailment is the only solution to this issue...
@@davej3781 he could quit taking the hormone shots and be a man.
think thiis was more about the home plate call happ was clearly safe but oh well we got the w
is your voice ok? I dont know whats happening and im kinda concerened.
Not trying to be crass or presumptuous, but he does now have the trans flag on his personal twitter bio and has a bunch of trans covid masks on in some photos during Pride month so maybe he has transitioned to a "trans woman"?
his voice is fine
@@shakedownFTW ohh yeah that makes sense. I don’t really social media anything so I wouldn’t know. Sorry
@@shakedownFTW Maybe. IDK. Love Gil's content! I thought it was an 'add subscribers' gimmick or an 'inside joke' I missed 🤷♀️
@@Jamesott86 no reason to be sorry, I made the same comment you made on his last couple videos saying something was wrong with his voice and everyone said he might be sick, so i checked his personal twitter to see if he had clarified that he was sick or anything and that's when I saw everything I mentioned in my last comment, so its just an educated guess, I'm not certain.
I love how Gil and Jomboy seem to have a mutual respect for each other as TH-cam baseball creators, but all the umpire stans on the channel hate Jomboy because he criticized an umpire once before.
No one hates him cause he criticized umpires, people just wish he'd know the rules. He criticized this correct call below.
And here's a video of the play in question.
th-cam.com/video/MMNcN89QwD8/w-d-xo.html
It's that JomTool doesn't know the rules, makes things up, and bashes umpires strictly for content. If he was fair in his commentary, sure, but he has no clue on how officiating works, game management, rules, etc..
Hes great at what he does, but he just adds to all the misperceptions
Such a tired narrative
Jomboy was in the past terrible... but he has recently reformed his ways and is far better now. Thankfully.
we hate him cause he doesn't get the rules doesn't educate himself for the rules. Gil speaks nothing on his videos Gil shares the rules does facts and educate people here
@@MH-Tesla yea i doubt that i already blocked his channel
He just had to take the opportunity to pad his resume with a convincing temper tantrum if he wants to be a manager in the future.
The only thing Green is good at is getting ejected
Please don’t talk during the videos. We just want to see the ejection and what ensues
Its seems every day these stupid broadcasts go to replay too early and miss all the action
Will they ever learn
My favorite part when he chucks that useless mask.
Real good job of de-escalating there. Lol
Once a manager is ejected like that, the purpose of de-escalating is drastically reduced.
Umpires try to de-escalate to keep people in the game (and preventing brawls) When a manager throws his hat on the ground and starts screaming at you, attempting to de-escalate is a meaningless effort
Wtf does the voice keep going higher?
Awful uniforms
Hallion was wrong he should have looked a a replay. The rule states you can't change your path to make contact with the 2nd baseman. He clearly changed his path and aimed for Alcantra. So, your answer to #4 is wrong.
It was a good call. Green is just one of those "managers" umps don't like. Got nothing coming! (Yes, an unwritten rule. Fight me.)
But it doesn't at all. They just can't do it with elevated feet or legs. He's well within reach of the bag, legal slide.
@@KWally it cannot be a legal slide if the path taken is illegal. He leaves his running lane to make contact with the 2nd Baseman and dose not come back to the base in the last steps. So he is already out by rule. That means his slide is also illegal as he dose not make any attempt to not obstruct the play. But that's why rules are just a suggestion in baseball. That's what makes it baseball. It's all opinions.
Adam Larue That is completely untrue...he leaves his running lane is obviously a stupid statement in multiple regards, but you make it seem like he had to move to the base after he finished sliding. He slid into the base and the fielder, and it was completely legal...
@@rickhaavisto9023 draw a straight line from the direction the baserunner is running to second he may not deviate from that line EXCEPT to reach the base. The runner must go Straight to the base and may not take any deviation that would result in him making contact with a fielder unless the above are followed. Watch the video he changes half way to second to intentionally make contact and would have slid past the base had the baseman not been there.
that should be a legal slide from little league to the bigs....
you have to avoid contact in youth sports you can purposely slide into someone
@@critter2 The contact is irrelevant since it happened on the first base side of second base.
What happened to the phoney 😷🎭🎭🎭🎭🎭🎭
It’s hilarious how quickly Green lost that stupid mask. I hope he doesn’t get COVID now lol
Just another staged act for the fans people.......this is LAUGHABLE. Bush league tactics...give it up Green.