also Su sister has a podcast and she said that the members still talk to Yui and Yui knows Momo. She said yui still watches their lives shows online and communicates w them about them. Momo is an amazing addition
Wait what? Source? SOURCE!? I mean I'm aware that Himeka has a podcast and all, but had no idea she mentioned Yui at one point. Are you sure? And when did she mention her? 🤔
she mentioned that she had watched one night of a stream vs another, but i can't remember which ep is was. and the link was on weibo. ive ever been able to find it again if ANYone here is able to find a link please share it because ive been trying to find it again thats why i keep mentioning it i keep hoping someone finds the episode @@Vault-14_Kingdom
re answering because i can't see the first response. basically it was mentioned that yui watched one live stream of a show vs another (like when they do black night clear night) i cannot remember which show it was she watched. the link i found was on weibo but ive not been able to find it again so i post about it under multiple BM vid to see if someone can find it! @@Vault-14_Kingdom
Seems legit. Yui having back issues was already one of the theories. Some people claimed that they thought she was wearing a back support brace under her stage costume at multiple shows. I donno. But it really does seem legit. Makes sense.
The most logical explanation which fits all the facts is this: 1) Yui falls off the stage at The Budokan Red Night in 2014 due to inadequate safety precautions. 2) Although she appeared to be ok and was back onstage for the next song there must have been some spinal/muscle damage. 3) Due to BABYMETAL's constant hectic schedule inadequate treatment was given. Therefore the problem gradually got worse. 4) By 2017 Yui was on steroids/painkillers in order to be able to perform, finally in her last show having to wear a back brace. 5) All of the above was clearly down to negligence by Amuse: so when Yui left BABYMETAL she signed an NDA in return for Amuse agreeing to cover all her medical costs whilst keeping her on as a signed Amuse artist, and possibly a basic fixed income. 6) Similarly Su and Moa are contractually forbidden to discuss or reveal any details about the whole situation.
While totally plausible, I don't know that I believe that to be the case. I always had suspicions, and again, no proof, just suspicions, that what afflicted her family member when she was very young wad beginning to take hold of her as well and as a result the doctors told her she had to stop and start treatments to prevent it from becoming as serious as what happened to her family member, thus she left Babymetal but said she hoped to return some day as Yui. Just speculation, but that is what I always thought. Not e en sure WHY that popped into my head, but it was the first thing I thought of when I heard she was leaving.
Yui's relative was apparently suffering from a "life threatening" illness. Yui's condition was clearly related to her back. Back injuries/problems are rarely life threatening. Therefore imo the balance of probabilities points to this originating with the Budokan fall. If it was some sort of family inherited genetic condition then surely it would have affected her mother as well?@@jeremyboynowski3784
It’s not just that she left, she DISAPPEARED. We all know how intrusive Japanese media can be. Between that and the fandom, NOBODY has seen this girl since she left. There’s no pictures of her. Nobody talks to her. She’s a ghost now.
I’m happy Yui and the band members are cool. They are basically family. She’s prolly somewhat involved behind the scenes. Wouldn’t surprise me if Yui is helping Momo. My wish: Few years from now. In their 30s. Yui comes back for a one off in Tokyo. Su. Moa. Momo. Yui. All at once. One time. That performance would stand the test of time and I’ll throw my life savings for it.
@@alexperez3367 I hurrrrd the producer got her pregnant & she had to be a teen mom, that's why she's been completely erased from existence without even a social media account because the record company wants to hide the scandal. I don't know if it's true though.
If she physically couldn't do it, that would explain why. Babymetal is very demanding physically. Might also explain why she hadnt resurfaced. It must really burn if your body stops you doing what you want. Plus the mental impact of that. Plus Yui was also very shy it seemed to me
@@HOXHOXHOX Nah that is Total B.S.! At some point she most likely got injured & that injury became chronic. I saw a video of their concert in Germany, pretty sure it was before the Budokan Red Night concert. MoiMoi were on their riser platforms. Moa was doing those full on bend over dips as usual, but Yui could only nod her head. So at some point she either got hurt at that show or prior to that. Most of us have seen pics of Yui with that big back brace, & her swollen face. I hate saying that but it's true. Why is it my Fave Musicians/Dancers end up passing away or having to quit due to physical illness or injuries! \🙄/
Hi Mate, you really belive in authentication of Yui statement? Every statement is made by Amuse,every question in intervievs ia Amuse allowed. Also ,i believe, girls have instructions how to answer on each question. After 7yrs. She is still under contract to Amuse. Amuse feels some responsibility for her having to retire? Something happend and with the contract Amuse keeps her silent? Yui have wishes and dreams and i ,hope so, still have them. Wish to become an actress and singer too. Singer in usual chlotes,not only in costumes. "I will work hard with great effort to be able to meet with everyone again someday as Mizuno Yui." As Yui fan i have only one wish: -to see her in some video clip/interview. With that Yuimetal mystery ... case closed. And support for Yui Mizuno actress/singer/citizen/whatever ... is open. To se her healthy and alive...that is my wish. (Google translated) Have a nice day 🙂 🦊 & 🍅
Yui is still under contract with Amuse , they will never let her perform without their permission . I bet they give her royalty checks but only if she stays quiet and no social media , Most Japanese idols don't get treated very well . Baby Metal seems to be doing even better now and with the acceptance of Momoko , it's for certain that they keep Yui in the dark .
Damn, people still arguing about that? Lol. Miss Yui in Babymetal, but it sure is time to move on. As long as she’s happy and pursuing her life, it’s all good! 🍅🤘🦊
Right. It's like she's gone and enough is enough. She's out of the band, she's not coming back. People need to be happy that she was what helped build Babymetal. As much as it would be awesome for a comeback we can be happy that she's enjoying her life.
Thank you for standing up for Yui and truth. A few fans claim to be fans of Babymetal yet they will call Yui a liar. Real class. Back issues make sense as to the physical health. Her fall from the stage looked bad and is much worse than we thought. My concern for Yui is that she can recover from the back issues. Been fighting mine for 35+ years. No matter what, we will always miss her and root for her success. If Yui cannot go back to performing, maybe she could go into music and stage production. She was Production Chair her senior year at Sakura Gakuin, after all.
Back issues are no joke. Nor any injury. I stopped footballing probably 10 years earlier than I would because of them. Yui had dreams to be a solo performer, cool. We haven't seen that so why not? Possibly because she physically cannot? Being stopped like that because of ill health must be brutally devastating, why wouldn't you hide away. Must be gut wrenching to see others doing what you simply cannot anymore. Does anyone want to see Yui like another Phil Collins? Wheeled out on a wheelchair? That BTW is devastatingly sad to see. Maybe Su told Yui to look after her health first and foremost, she had Himeka's example to draw on. Seeing how Himeka suffered must have been hard and she wouldn't want Yui to face the same. Whatever she's doing I hope she's happy and healthy as she can be. Yui always seemed the most sensible but shyest member. Maybe she pursued her astronomy dreams, and deliberately keeps a low profile? Until she tells us, we won't know.
@@ChuckJansenII How's it a rant? I agreed back issues and any physical injuries are no joke. They aren't. Yui said she wasn't up to it, end of story. What's more telling is her saying she still isn't 100%
@@paulelainebarks8644 This line is an example. "Does anyone want to see Yui like another Phil Collins? Wheeled out on a wheelchair? That BTW is devastatingly sad to see.? Rant.
@ChuckJansenII It's a fact not a rant. Do you even know what a rant is? So tell me, DO you want to see Yui end up like Phil Collins? It's a pertinent question. How much for your entertainment must she sacrifice?
I believe a lot of the issues is AMUSE were virtually silent about Yui's absence. It was not until Yui's statement was released that it was known, that she would not return to BabyMetal. AMUSE obfuscated the question and would not say if Yui, would return for the USA tour after Su's twentieth birthday concert show. People were shocked, angered and extremely disappointed she was not on stage at that time. This for me, is where all this continued speculation was incubated. I believe and people may think I am being cynical but AMUSE are ruthless business people. Letting it be known Yui, would not be attending that USA tour, could have led to reduce ticket sales and merchandise sales. A statement from AMUSE, clearly stating that Yui will not be appearing for that tour and then a second one after the tour reporting that Yui, is still not ready to return to BabyMetal, would have stopped, probably 99% of all these wild speculations. The statement from Yui herself, would have ended all this nonsense completely. Sadly The One, did not get that and the result, still rears it's head.
"The statement from Yui herself, would have ended all this nonsense completely." Considering that people are still arguing about this years later makes me think you've got a lot of misplaced optimism about a certain sub group of BABYMETAL fans. She issued a statement when she decided to leave the group. And yet, we still get posts and speculation like this one.
"Edit: I realise my claim is unsubstantiated but I don’t want to say here why I know it’s trustworthy for privacy reasons." LOL. Sounds legit to me. : ). ( Sarcasm alert, in case that wasn't clear. )
I think the group held out hope she would return, that is my logic for it taking around 5 years to name a new permanent member. Also I do believe the choreography took its toll. People have noticed that it has been toned down a bit the last few years.
I'm sure Su said loads as far as she and Moa were concerned, Yui was still a member right up to Yuis statement. Here's a few facts. People say amuse are ruthless and babymetal fabricated. If this was true, Yui would have been replaced pronto! Mustn't halt the money machine, right? The fact that spot was left open so long says to me that Su and Moa, always hoped that Yui would return no matter what. And despite her statement, and got their way with amuse. Then maybe it became clear that wasn't going to happen, maybe from Yui herself so Momo got her reward. I think Su would have followed and backed Yui 100% in her choices, after what happened to her sister. And probably told Yui in the end her health was the most important thing. I remember all the wild speculation about Himeka too, even now when we know the facts.
Everything anybody comes up with about Yui is pure speculation no one knows what her specific injury was it could have been her knee it could have been her ankle it could have been her hip it could have been anything no one knows because it was never disclosed she has not been to several Babymetal shows there's only ever been reports that some members of Sakura gakuin seen at shows and even talked about from those members nothing about seeing Yui or her even attending any shows from any of them everything about or what Yui has done or has been doing Babymetal shows or anything else has been purely speculation The only two people who have publicly talked about how Yui is doing are Su and Moa when they have been asked about her from the press and the only thing they say she is like family and she is doing well That's it That's the only thing that is absolutely true anything beyond that is speculation other than that there was a note from her in the last Sakura gakuin book
Been a Yui fan since BM havent even born and im not gonna argue why She left BM, since its a normal thing to left a group due to health, etc. BUT, the only one thing that still pissed me off till this day is the silence to public of her disappearance, like why? is there any contract that forcing her to not show herself to public? like wtf man. the worst thing i can think is she is already dead and the staff and close people trying to fake a script for public that she is doing fine and yadayadayada, even the writing for SG book are easily to be faked. but yea we dont know. The only probability that make sense for me is she became a Vtuber or something, lol. Wish her all the best.
Yes, exactly this is onevof thevreason why in many cases there is extremevsilent. Thevlawyers of both sides don't have any interestvto inform thebpublic, they have responsibilities to protect their clients.
It was obvious the year leading up to Yui's departure that she was off. You could see her severe weight loss and pain in her face. I just want what's best for her and not for her to be my personal kawaii entertainer, no matter what she's going through. These are real people behind the image and performance. They have their own real struggles and issues. Spamming "I miss Yui! Where's Yui?! It's not the same without Yui!" in every internet comment section isn't going to change that fact. At least be happy that the band is still going forward, still killing it, and that Momometal is a fitting replacement.
I must say this, after Yui Mizuno took a nasty spill at the Budokan a few years ago, she had not been the same since. I believe that fall did more damage than a lot of people realizes, and yes, I'm only guessing at this myself. I don't doubt Yui saying her reasons for leaving Babymetal, I don't believe there is bad blood between them, even after she left, Su-Metal and Moametal knew they needed to move forward after Yui left, but they still expressed love for her. At least I got the feeling of that. And one other thing here, and it just dawned on me. Who is to say that Yui is or isn't attending Babymetal shows? I believe she might still attend shows, if she is able, I believe in my heart she still has deep love for her former band mates. This is also just a guess as well. Thank you for allowing me to state my feelings and opinions about this. You are doing an excellent job, thank you for being here..👍👍👍
Hey, thank you for the thoughtful comment. I read it all and think you brought up some really good points. Special the part of who is to say Yui is or is not attending shows? Some just want there to be drama where there is none.
@@rantandchill9503 I think she is attending them. I think she may even be HELPING Babymetal in some capacity. Keep in mind Su and Moa DID say Yui will ALWAYS be a part of the Babymetal family. While that is very vague, it could be vague on purpose. That could also be why she is still on the Amuse books too. Just speculation. But it would not surprise me in the least if it were found to be true.
This post was just some dude going "trust me bro" without giving any evidence at all. Literally zero value post. People weren't dogpiling on this post because they think there were badblood between the members. This was pretty much like me going "my uncle works at nintendo and I know that the next console will be trust me bro". Also the title REAL REASON YUI LEFT BABYMETAL is annoying as heck since you really need to give some concrete evidence to make statements like that but this guy literally gave us nothing to support his claims. Really don't know what videos of her collapsing are you talking about? Only time I have seen or heard of her "collapsing" were the famous incident where she fell of the stage during the budokan shows. And when she had a heatstroke during some concert in 2015 (or around that time)
I believe in the farewell letter from the first moment. but the problem is that she is completely missing for too much time even though Yui is still enrolled in amuse and said she had another dream to fulfill
I hurrrrd the producer got her pregnant & she had to be a teen mom, that's why she's been completely erased from existence without even a social media account because the record company wants to hide the scandal. I don't know if it's true though.
@@HOXHOXHOXHardly a scandal this day and age. Yui seemed the most sensible but shy of the girls. Hell, plenty of stars vanish from sight. I remember Tiffany and Debbie Gibson practically vanishing from fame overnight. Same with Jo O'Meara of S club despite her saying about a solo career. Maybe her physical condition is so crap she walked away? Maybe Su told her to look after her health first and foremost. Shy people are the worst at hiding away. And in Japan, privacy is a hell of a lot more respected than here.
Knowing how influential she was in helping to shape the direction of the band during her time with BM, I would find it hard to believe that she would completely disassociate herself from them permanently. I wouldn't be surprised if she still plays a role quietly behind the scenes advising them to this day
I guess it just weirds people out that she is nowhere to be seen or found. After that comment nobody knows what happened to her. Also the comment was made by the company in a post without a face. People are very skeptical about large companies. I get the impression people won't be satisfied until they see you eat say it herself
I saw in an interview Moa was asked if she could talk to a younger version of herself what advice would she give herself. She said the she would definitely advice herself to take stretching seriously and do it before every performance. I don’t know if she was referring to yui’s back problems
I surely believe it. Many hard working jobs can pull ever peoples back out! Of a serious injury the person would have to retire from he or her very great job work performance skills.👏
Мужик, после ухода Юи ни одной фотографии, видео, ни одной статьи о ней она как сквозь землю провалилась хочешь не хочешь люди будут обсуждать такое исчезновение, надеюсь у неё все хорошо❤
Учитывая её последнее обращение к своим фанатам и обещание общаться у меня есть только одно объяснение зная чуть социум японцев и отношение к иностранцем , к сожалению это расизм (они не особо за людей считают других ( могу и хотелось бы ошибаться)) . Я всё понимаю возможно ей не нравится как она выглядит из-за каких-то проблем с здоровьем но извините за столько времени хотя-бы из вежливости не поздороваться с своими фанатами через какой-то коментарийй наталкивает на мысль ... увы , мы для неё никто и абсолютно плевать на нас ....
The deadest of dead horses is continuing to be beaten. We will never know what the real reason was, and that is fine. Neither Yui nor anyone else involved owes us an explanation; she's entitled to privacy in medical matters. Babymetal has moved on, Momoko has become the new member and is doing a fine job, and hopefully Yui is doing well in whatever she is doing now. That said, I think it's the mystery around what Yui is up to now that keeps this issue bubbling along. Yui is still listed as an Amuse talent, and her statement made it sound like she would be a performer in the future, yet nothing has happened. I think if she had reappeared as part of another project that would give people a definitive answer and there would be closure. It's the uncertainty that keeps people speculating.
Yes, your last paragraph is the question of the Yui fans that we still have left. but some fans lie saying that we want bm to get back with her. and they say let it go, move on. To those people I say: do not slander, we still have a question to answer and it is about yui solo project. not to anchor her to babymetal
and why would someone completely disappear due to a back health problem? ok, maybe Yui had many others reasons to leave the band, that's normal... but the issue is Yui's total disappearance... sorry, this isn't a private life, it's a hidden life... living in hiding like that would be very difficult even for us anonymous people, so imagine for a beloved public person like Yui... she could put an end to all the speculation by recording a video explaining the reason... that's it...
and taking into account that Yui in her letter said that she still has personal dreams and is still enrolled in amuse. It is logical to believe that she still has something to contribute in ART. But a total disappearance does not mean respecting her private life, but rather it seems like a punishment
No, Amuse was not ruthless, they are and were a company withva pretty good reputation. My big problem is, you simply can't calculate back health reasons to a single event. There is always an amountnof speculation involved esspecialy for dancers. This is one of thevreasons why they are often insured. And if they activate an insurance, it goes in and protect their client. They often demand a freeze of the account of the insured person. The business paetner has extremly restrictive permissionsvwhatvthey can say. In many cases the company is not allowed to say anything and the insurrance might want to meet the employer in court. So the lawyers of the company are pretty careful.
sorry for resurrect, but, for everyone out there that want to understand what actually happened to Yui and also just maybe, the other things like some accidents around the same time, just take a look at the anime named Perfect Blue. And sorry for collapsing your brain with that story that inspired some greater future movies. #PerfectBlue
Congratulations. You've discovered the one subject favored by Trigger Engineers and Trollaphiles across online "fan pages". There's a sub-culture of "fans" that put in effort to keep the disinformation and comment section battles active in regards to Yuimetal's departure. It's usually copy/paste text from YEARS of the same bs being posted across the interwebs. And I wouldn't be surprised if dudes are utilizing AI to generate word vomit to trigger fans for reactions. It's a stupid habit of creeps and jerks of the online culture. Same bs & disinformation as seen/read when I discovered BABYMETAL in 2019. Didn't get any better in 2020 when everyone was home & online for several months. (SMH x 2). And that sucks for New fans who are out there trying to learn more of the history of BABYMETAL. They out here just wanting to learn about this group from Japan and find these stupid online content of comment battles about a former member. I've personally blocked out anything about Yuimetal subject online. Especially if it's in English. That's the red flag for me. The BABYMETAL fans of Japan I follow on X don't ever launch into comment battles about it. In conclusion: Thank You for reading out loud the Official Statement! 🤘 That right there is what's going to assist New fans to better understand the Legit reason about the Yuimetal subject. Let's hope the New fans can respect and honor the legit reason, and continue to support BABYMETAL. 🤘🦊
It seems like the back and health issues may have been the reason why she left. The choreography and stages are now designed for the members to stay in one place, whereas they used to be on a moving platform. In the "IDZ" choreography, some people noticed that the running part is slower and longer, header they don't do the jumping anymore. In the K-pop industry, choreography isn't usually changed unless there's a serious injury preventing them from doing the move, for safety reasons. I understand that the phenomenon of sudden disappearances is quite unusual, but it's actually a common occurrence in Japan. There's even a specific term for it, and it applies to Japanese idols who withdraw from the public eye to lead normal lives. In Japan and Korea, there are strict privacy laws for celebrities, which is why rumors can be particularly surprising to American audiences. This is likely because we are accustomed to constant media coverage of celebrities, including paparazzi following their every move.
It's more likely to have changed the choreography and the stages and so forth probably put in safety measures due to the fact that Yui is suing amuse for damages. That is also a large part of why they are forbidden to speak about her. it is a legal gag order
@@rantandchill9503 Babymetal was created it's ran like a business.. the music the songs the dances are organized by someone else ... the girls are just used as a tool like most J-pop or K-pop bands.. Something odd happen with Yui ... like I'm going to really believe that she had a back issue and just disappeared , come on dude use your head .
@@aurozappa305 If something scandalous happened then surely it would have been leaked, there's literally hundreds of people involved with BM someone would have blabbed. Remember we are dealing with a totally different culture. We can't even be 100% Yui Mizuno is a real name. The other thing to consider, depression and mental health issues are still taboo in Japan, where sufferers are often hidden away.
For all I care, if Yui 's health is well, it's all that matters. Everything else is secondary. Also, the group gained so much with Momoko, and MM Legend of 03's show was evidence of that. They're all gonna be fine.
Besides that, there were rumors about YUI being * "pregnant" * and the father was their late lead guitarist *Mikio Fujioka* which was linked to him * "jumping" * from an observation deck. No proof but who knows? Members having been silenced by Amuse is giving out dark vibes for the fans.
Besides anything else, it's HUGELY disrespectful to Momo. She's doing the best job and , think about, had probably the biggest shoes to fill. And has done it superbly. I'd go as far as to say Momo plugged the hole in the slightly sinking ship. In Japanese culture if you quit, you quit. Had Yui's health improved to the point she was able to perform again, it would NEVER have been with BABYMETAL. Yuimetal is akin to your first boyfriend/girlfriend that you fondly reminisce about. Gone but never forgotten. Bad blood? After everything they went through together, it's laughable there could be. Su's obvious affection and Moa's close friendship with Yui was there to see.
Further proof of the close bond the original members had for one another is everywhere, from Su declaring that Yui will forever be a part of Babymetal, to the little Easter Egg you get when Babymetal performed Babymetal - The One Stairway to Living Legend where at the end of the song you see 3 comets flying off even though it's just Su and Moa. The third comet is an obvious reference to Yui. You can't even make the argument is Momo as Momo was not declared an official Babymetal member yet at that time, nor did she perform that song with Moa and Su. If she HAD performed that song with them, then you would have a bit of a stronger case, but she didn't. It was very obviously a very intimate and private performance meant for the fans and Babymetal, yet it STILL had the 3 comets. So in my eyes it has to be a nod to Yui. If Amuse, Su, and Moa didn't care anything about Yui, there wouldn't have been anything of the sort. I loved Yui as a member of Babymetal and she was my favorite of the 3 while she was in the group. Out of the 3 of the girls, I felt she was the most ... unusual. There was so many little things about her, from her timidness, to her Yuibot'ness, to her ability to ALWAYS detect when a camera was focused on her. Her ability to stare into your soul, to fall asleep during interviews. To me she was/is a girl who is very introverted, but was pushing past that boundary to become an idol, so she worked on to push her boundary and comfort level and pursue her dream of becoming an idol. So I had a lot of respect for her for doing that and actually succeeding in that pursuit! I love the other girls as well, but Yui will always have a bit more respect in my eyes for those reasons. Not to mention I recently learned it was YUI who would decide the set lists and stuff like that, so even at her young age she was a mastermind at things like that. Makes me curious what other tricks these girls have up their sleeves that us fans don't know about yet!
@@jeremyboynowski3784 "Not to mention I recently learned it was YUI who would decide the set lists and stuff like that" Yui was in charge of that during her senior year in Sakura Gakuin, in her role as Production Chairman. Moa was class President that year. I've never seen any credible source that says she had the same job with BABYMETAL. We do know from interviews with the members, that she insisted that 'Road of Resistance' have its worldwide debut at O2 Academy Brixton. That would be an odd thing to remark upon if she was the person in charge of deciding setlists.
@@rickwagner- At Su's graduation from SG, Su thanked Yui for always creating the set lists for SG. So it seems Yui was performing that role earlier than just her senior year.
@@rickwagner- True true. The girls may have had some suggestive input, but Babymetal is very much Koba's brain trust and he always got the final say. Especially when they were still children.
Yui left for her own reasons. She hasn’t explained those reasons. Amuse hasn’t either. Nor has Su or Moa. No one related to BabyMetal has explained the reasons. Yui has moved on. No one has heard or seen anything from her since the SG book quote. If Yui has moved on. Su & Moa has moved on too. Momo has officially joined the group. Brand new album & world tour is currently going on. Years have passed. People need to let go. You can reminisce about all those years of Yui being part of BabyMetal. Founding member. Never will be replaced. If people can’t move on then enjoy the early albums of BabyMetal. Because it doesn’t look like the group is slowing down anytime soon. So, make a choice.. linger in the past or remember the past fondly but enjoy the ongoing journey.
Considering her last message to fans and her promise to communicate, I only have one explanation, knowing a little about Japanese society and attitudes towards foreigners, unfortunately it is racism (they don't really consider others as human beings (I could and would like to be wrong)). I understand everything, perhaps she doesn’t like the way she looks due to some health problems but at least once in eight years, through some comment on some social network on the Internet, you could at least say hello to your fans ... alas, we are nothing to her and she doesn’t care about us...
What? Talk about reaching. Yui thanked the fans in her last message, but she does not owe us any further communication. Why do you feel that you're owed further communication when she clearly does not have interest to do so? The racism thing is bullshit.
@@rantandchill9503 It's not an obligation, it's mutual respect.Dude, calm down as you wish, it's everyone's business, I miss her too. I can read and I read her last address several times, everything is very clear there. I made unpleasant conclusions for myself. We are absolute zero for her (maybe even a negative value)
@@rantandchill9503 She doesn’t owe anyone anything, but if she wanted to sing solo (or as part of a group) as Yui Mizuno and nothing happens, us fans are going to at least wonder.
Whatever happened, since Yui is no longer with Babymetal, I'm no longer a fan of the "new" Babymetal. I really dislike the latest CD. I'm glad I can still listen to the older tracks.
I liked the last album, slowly accepts MG. But the thing I don't like anymore is how they still socialize with the teen caricature and the darkest outfits
Only the Newbs and new to the fandom keep talking about her leaving oh yeah those who say they LOVE Babymetal yet "inadvertently" disrespect them trying to get clicks
So far all we know is the official statements. Idk why fans need to drag this on. I miss yui too but like they need to stop making statements that arent true. Endless she comes out and say theres bad blood i ain't believing it. All i hope is that yui is alive and well
Blame su just look at the interviews how she always giving yui the side eye look it up Dr Phil before u make a video bro!!she broke yui and moa up as friends because su has some fruity feelings for moa just look at the interviews and explain why she's doing that to yui but not moa?
First off Yui Mizuno has no official social media account here in Japan and basically became a ghost. She hasn't made a appearance since she left Babymetal and because she comes from a rich family plus having made lots of money during her time in babymetal she was able to use all of the money to disappear. Two things that will plague Yui story-wise is the death of Takayoshi Ohmura then her leaving Banymeatl abruptly starting the rumors she was pregnant with his child. The rumors hold weight to this day because Yui remains missing to this day. For all we know she could not even be in Japan and be living abroad in Europe somewhere where it would be easy for her to remain anonymous. Bottom line is nobody will ever know until she comes out of hiding which is highly unlikely and the longer she remains gone and anonymous with the rumors continuing I honestly believe she will remain anonymous.
Reddit is the worst place tbh and haters are gonna hate. Idk why people are still speculating and arguing about Yui tbh. She left Babymetal, she made an official statement as to why and that’s it. End of story. There is probably Amuse politics and influence behind but why would you waste your time arguing about that? Yui was an core member of the band for many years and will always hold a special place in my heart but she is gone now and I wish her only the best in whatever she is doing now and hope that she is doing great. Su and Moa have said in the past that she is doing well and that they are still in contact with her and that they still are friends (which makes sense, given that they spend so many years with her and grow up together). Momoko worked so hard to become the new third member as is doing a fantastic job so far and hopefully she continues for many years to come. 🤘🦊🔥
Amuse wrote a made up story about why Yui left. When Yui was absent from Babymatal concerts Yui wrote, or should I say Amuse wrote, I`ll be back don`t worry there is no Babymetal without me - this statement was taken off later when it was confirmed that Yui would not be back. Also, Yui said (once again Amuse) that she will be pursuing a solo career...will Amuse where is her solo career? NO BODY KNOW WHY YUI LEFT!!!
Bc we miss her. Reddit is disgusting, that's true. Also, We want to help Yui in case Amuse didn't help her. Only in case she left the band for health problem releated overwork. They're Idol group, yeah. The moment they leave japan to be a metal group, they should not be treat as an idol group anymore.
also Su sister has a podcast and she said that the members still talk to Yui and Yui knows Momo. She said yui still watches their lives shows online and communicates w them about them. Momo is an amazing addition
Wait what? Source? SOURCE!? I mean I'm aware that Himeka has a podcast and all, but had no idea she mentioned Yui at one point. Are you sure? And when did she mention her? 🤔
she mentioned that she had watched one night of a stream vs another, but i can't remember which ep is was. and the link was on weibo. ive ever been able to find it again if ANYone here is able to find a link please share it because ive been trying to find it again thats why i keep mentioning it i keep hoping someone finds the episode
@@Vault-14_Kingdom
(and before anyone gives me a hard time about weibo, sorry, it was a chinese fan, if i had another link i would link it)
i keep posting about it because i want SOMEone to find the link to the ep! @@pawziimetal_yt
re answering because i can't see the first response. basically it was mentioned that yui watched one live stream of a show vs another (like when they do black night clear night) i cannot remember which show it was she watched. the link i found was on weibo but ive not been able to find it again so i post about it under multiple BM vid to see if someone can find it! @@Vault-14_Kingdom
Seems legit. Yui having back issues was already one of the theories. Some people claimed that they thought she was wearing a back support brace under her stage costume at multiple shows. I donno. But it really does seem legit. Makes sense.
The most logical explanation which fits all the facts is this:
1) Yui falls off the stage at The Budokan Red Night in 2014 due to inadequate safety precautions.
2) Although she appeared to be ok and was back onstage for the next song there must have been some spinal/muscle damage.
3) Due to BABYMETAL's constant hectic schedule inadequate treatment was given. Therefore the problem gradually got worse.
4) By 2017 Yui was on steroids/painkillers in order to be able to perform, finally in her last show having to wear a back brace.
5) All of the above was clearly down to negligence by Amuse: so when Yui left BABYMETAL she signed an NDA in return for Amuse
agreeing to cover all her medical costs whilst keeping her on as a signed Amuse artist, and possibly a basic fixed income.
6) Similarly Su and Moa are contractually forbidden to discuss or reveal any details about the whole situation.
While totally plausible, I don't know that I believe that to be the case. I always had suspicions, and again, no proof, just suspicions, that what afflicted her family member when she was very young wad beginning to take hold of her as well and as a result the doctors told her she had to stop and start treatments to prevent it from becoming as serious as what happened to her family member, thus she left Babymetal but said she hoped to return some day as Yui. Just speculation, but that is what I always thought. Not e en sure WHY that popped into my head, but it was the first thing I thought of when I heard she was leaving.
Yui's relative was apparently suffering from a "life threatening" illness. Yui's condition was clearly related to her back. Back injuries/problems are rarely life threatening. Therefore imo the balance of probabilities points to this originating with the Budokan fall. If it was some sort of family inherited genetic condition then surely it would have affected her mother as well?@@jeremyboynowski3784
I think we don't know anything about 1 being involved, I'm sticking with just that she had a back problem. Lots of people have a weak back.
@@autohmae totally agree. There is no evidence for anything. I'm just going off of a feeling I got and that's all.
I read comments that Moa (I think it was her?) was also injured during that same show. She hurt her leg and did her best to hide it.
It’s not just that she left, she DISAPPEARED. We all know how intrusive Japanese media can be. Between that and the fandom, NOBODY has seen this girl since she left. There’s no pictures of her. Nobody talks to her. She’s a ghost now.
I’m happy Yui and the band members are cool. They are basically family. She’s prolly somewhat involved behind the scenes. Wouldn’t surprise me if Yui is helping Momo.
My wish: Few years from now. In their 30s. Yui comes back for a one off in Tokyo. Su. Moa. Momo. Yui. All at once. One time.
That performance would stand the test of time and I’ll throw my life savings for it.
I'm still wondering why Yui left
It is understandable why yui left, why she has not yet reappeared is what I will never understand
@@alexperez3367 I hurrrrd the producer got her pregnant & she had to be a teen mom, that's why she's been completely erased from existence without even a social media account because the record company wants to hide the scandal. I don't know if it's true though.
If she physically couldn't do it, that would explain why. Babymetal is very demanding physically. Might also explain why she hadnt resurfaced. It must really burn if your body stops you doing what you want. Plus the mental impact of that. Plus Yui was also very shy it seemed to me
@@HOXHOXHOX Nah that is Total B.S.! At some point she most likely got injured & that injury became chronic. I saw a video of their concert in Germany, pretty sure it was before the Budokan Red Night concert. MoiMoi were on their riser platforms. Moa was doing those full on bend over dips as usual, but Yui could only nod her head. So at some point she either got hurt at that show or prior to that. Most of us have seen pics of Yui with that big back brace, & her swollen face. I hate saying that but it's true. Why is it my Fave Musicians/Dancers end up passing away or having to quit due to physical illness or injuries!
\🙄/
@@HOXHOXHOX oshi no ko theory
Hi Mate,
you really belive in authentication of Yui statement?
Every statement is made by Amuse,every question in intervievs ia Amuse allowed.
Also ,i believe, girls have instructions how to answer on each question.
After 7yrs.
She is still under contract to Amuse.
Amuse feels some responsibility for her having to retire?
Something happend and with the contract Amuse keeps her silent?
Yui have wishes and dreams and i ,hope so, still have them.
Wish to become an actress and singer too.
Singer in usual chlotes,not only in costumes.
"I will work hard with great effort to be able to meet with everyone again someday as Mizuno Yui."
As Yui fan i have only one wish:
-to see her in some video clip/interview.
With that Yuimetal mystery ... case closed.
And support for Yui Mizuno actress/singer/citizen/whatever ... is open.
To se her healthy and alive...that is my wish.
(Google translated)
Have a nice day 🙂
🦊 & 🍅
Yui is still under contract with Amuse , they will never let her perform without their permission .
I bet they give her royalty checks but only if she stays quiet and no social media ,
Most Japanese idols don't get treated very well .
Baby Metal seems to be doing even better now and with the acceptance of Momoko ,
it's for certain that they keep Yui in the dark .
Sadly even small back injuries can change your life and ruin your mobility.
Damn, people still arguing about that? Lol. Miss Yui in Babymetal, but it sure is time to move on. As long as she’s happy and pursuing her life, it’s all good!
🍅🤘🦊
Right. It's like she's gone and enough is enough. She's out of the band, she's not coming back. People need to be happy that she was what helped build Babymetal. As much as it would be awesome for a comeback we can be happy that she's enjoying her life.
And the Yui own dream, when?
We will never move on until we know the truth. Its better to be specticle then to believe everything
Yui got pregnant by a God and is a mommy now.
Thank you for standing up for Yui and truth.
A few fans claim to be fans of Babymetal yet they will call Yui a liar. Real class.
Back issues make sense as to the physical health. Her fall from the stage looked bad and is much worse than we thought. My concern for Yui is that she can recover from the back issues. Been fighting mine for 35+ years.
No matter what, we will always miss her and root for her success.
If Yui cannot go back to performing, maybe she could go into music and stage production. She was Production Chair her senior year at Sakura Gakuin, after all.
Back issues are no joke. Nor any injury. I stopped footballing probably 10 years earlier than I would because of them.
Yui had dreams to be a solo performer, cool. We haven't seen that so why not?
Possibly because she physically cannot? Being stopped like that because of ill health must be brutally devastating, why wouldn't you hide away. Must be gut wrenching to see others doing what you simply cannot anymore. Does anyone want to see Yui like another Phil Collins? Wheeled out on a wheelchair? That BTW is devastatingly sad to see.
Maybe Su told Yui to look after her health first and foremost, she had Himeka's example to draw on. Seeing how Himeka suffered must have been hard and she wouldn't want Yui to face the same.
Whatever she's doing I hope she's happy and healthy as she can be. Yui always seemed the most sensible but shyest member. Maybe she pursued her astronomy dreams, and deliberately keeps a low profile? Until she tells us, we won't know.
@@paulelainebarks8644 Quite the rant.
@@ChuckJansenII How's it a rant? I agreed back issues and any physical injuries are no joke. They aren't. Yui said she wasn't up to it, end of story. What's more telling is her saying she still isn't 100%
@@paulelainebarks8644 This line is an example. "Does anyone want to see Yui like another Phil Collins? Wheeled out on a wheelchair? That BTW is devastatingly sad to see.?
Rant.
@ChuckJansenII It's a fact not a rant. Do you even know what a rant is? So tell me, DO you want to see Yui end up like Phil Collins? It's a pertinent question. How much for your entertainment must she sacrifice?
I have no idea what happened, but may she get back all the happiness she gave the world. May your star shine bright, little senshi.
I just hope one day she'll reunite with her fellow members on stage one day.
I believe a lot of the issues is AMUSE were virtually silent about Yui's absence.
It was not until Yui's statement was released that it was known, that she would not return to BabyMetal. AMUSE obfuscated the question and would not say if Yui, would return for the USA tour after Su's twentieth birthday concert show. People were shocked, angered and extremely disappointed she was not on stage at that time.
This for me, is where all this continued speculation was incubated.
I believe and people may think I am being cynical but AMUSE are ruthless business people. Letting it be known Yui, would not be attending that USA tour, could have led to reduce ticket sales and merchandise sales.
A statement from AMUSE, clearly stating that Yui will not be appearing for that tour and then a second one after the tour reporting that Yui, is still not ready to return to BabyMetal, would have stopped, probably 99% of all these wild speculations.
The statement from Yui herself, would have ended all this nonsense completely. Sadly The One, did not get that and the result, still rears it's head.
"The statement from Yui herself, would have ended all this nonsense completely."
Considering that people are still arguing about this years later makes me think you've got a lot of misplaced optimism about a certain sub group of BABYMETAL fans.
She issued a statement when she decided to leave the group.
And yet, we still get posts and speculation like this one.
"Edit: I realise my claim is unsubstantiated but I don’t want to say here why I know it’s trustworthy for privacy reasons."
LOL. Sounds legit to me. : ).
( Sarcasm alert, in case that wasn't clear. )
I think the group held out hope she would return, that is my logic for it taking around 5 years to name a new permanent member. Also I do believe the choreography took its toll. People have noticed that it has been toned down a bit the last few years.
You could see in headbangers, There are not more high jumps. They only did this again was for momobanger.
Their live shows would drain a Decathelete. I suppose it had to end sometime as they got older. We don't want the Ladies ending up like Phil Collins.
I'm sure Su said loads as far as she and Moa were concerned, Yui was still a member right up to Yuis statement.
Here's a few facts. People say amuse are ruthless and babymetal fabricated. If this was true, Yui would have been replaced pronto! Mustn't halt the money machine, right?
The fact that spot was left open so long says to me that Su and Moa, always hoped that Yui would return no matter what. And despite her statement, and got their way with amuse.
Then maybe it became clear that wasn't going to happen, maybe from Yui herself so Momo got her reward.
I think Su would have followed and backed Yui 100% in her choices, after what happened to her sister. And probably told Yui in the end her health was the most important thing. I remember all the wild speculation about Himeka too, even now when we know the facts.
Everything anybody comes up with about Yui is pure speculation no one knows what her specific injury was it could have been her knee it could have been her ankle it could have been her hip it could have been anything no one knows because it was never disclosed she has not been to several Babymetal shows there's only ever been reports that some members of Sakura gakuin seen at shows and even talked about from those members nothing about seeing Yui or her even attending any shows from any of them everything about or what Yui has done or has been doing Babymetal shows or anything else has been purely speculation The only two people who have publicly talked about how Yui is doing are Su and Moa when they have been asked about her from the press and the only thing they say she is like family and she is doing well That's it That's the only thing that is absolutely true anything beyond that is speculation other than that there was a note from her in the last Sakura gakuin book
in the SG Final book put out many have commented that even after they disbanded that any member of SG can contact her
Been a Yui fan since BM havent even born and im not gonna argue why She left BM, since its a normal thing to left a group due to health, etc.
BUT, the only one thing that still pissed me off till this day is the silence to public of her disappearance, like why? is there any contract that forcing her to not show herself to public? like wtf man. the worst thing i can think is she is already dead and the staff and close people trying to fake a script for public that she is doing fine and yadayadayada, even the writing for SG book are easily to be faked. but yea we dont know.
The only probability that make sense for me is she became a Vtuber or something, lol. Wish her all the best.
Yes, exactly this is onevof thevreason why in many cases there is extremevsilent. Thevlawyers of both sides don't have any interestvto inform thebpublic, they have responsibilities to protect their clients.
‘Illness’ and ‘injury’ are two different things.
It was obvious the year leading up to Yui's departure that she was off. You could see her severe weight loss and pain in her face. I just want what's best for her and not for her to be my personal kawaii entertainer, no matter what she's going through. These are real people behind the image and performance. They have their own real struggles and issues. Spamming "I miss Yui! Where's Yui?! It's not the same without Yui!" in every internet comment section isn't going to change that fact.
At least be happy that the band is still going forward, still killing it, and that Momometal is a fitting replacement.
Only the foxgod knows...
No, concerning this matter, also the Foxgod has no idea . . .
I must say this, after Yui Mizuno took a nasty spill at the Budokan a few years ago, she had not been the same since. I believe that fall did more damage than a lot of people realizes, and yes, I'm only guessing at this myself.
I don't doubt Yui saying her reasons for leaving Babymetal, I don't believe there is bad blood between them, even after she left, Su-Metal and Moametal knew they needed to move forward after Yui left, but they still expressed love for her. At least I got the feeling of that.
And one other thing here, and it just dawned on me. Who is to say that Yui is or isn't attending Babymetal shows? I believe she might still attend shows, if she is able, I believe in my heart she still has deep love for her former band mates. This is also just a guess as well.
Thank you for allowing me to state my feelings and opinions about this. You are doing an excellent job, thank you for being here..👍👍👍
Hey, thank you for the thoughtful comment. I read it all and think you brought up some really good points. Special the part of who is to say Yui is or is not attending shows?
Some just want there to be drama where there is none.
@@rantandchill9503 I think she is attending them. I think she may even be HELPING Babymetal in some capacity. Keep in mind Su and Moa DID say Yui will ALWAYS be a part of the Babymetal family. While that is very vague, it could be vague on purpose. That could also be why she is still on the Amuse books too. Just speculation. But it would not surprise me in the least if it were found to be true.
This post was just some dude going "trust me bro" without giving any evidence at all. Literally zero value post. People weren't dogpiling on this post because they think there were badblood between the members. This was pretty much like me going "my uncle works at nintendo and I know that the next console will be trust me bro". Also the title REAL REASON YUI LEFT BABYMETAL is annoying as heck since you really need to give some concrete evidence to make statements like that but this guy literally gave us nothing to support his claims. Really don't know what videos of her collapsing are you talking about? Only time I have seen or heard of her "collapsing" were the famous incident where she fell of the stage during the budokan shows. And when she had a heatstroke during some concert in 2015 (or around that time)
@@Tyyppl Yui got pregnant by a God and is a mommy now
@@To-Ro1🎯 then the little God committed suicide out of Shame
I believe in the farewell letter from the first moment. but the problem is that she is completely missing for too much time even though Yui is still enrolled in amuse and said she had another dream to fulfill
I hurrrrd the producer got her pregnant & she had to be a teen mom, that's why she's been completely erased from existence without even a social media account because the record company wants to hide the scandal. I don't know if it's true though.
@@HOXHOXHOXHardly a scandal this day and age. Yui seemed the most sensible but shy of the girls. Hell, plenty of stars vanish from sight.
I remember Tiffany and Debbie Gibson practically vanishing from fame overnight. Same with Jo O'Meara of S club despite her saying about a solo career.
Maybe her physical condition is so crap she walked away? Maybe Su told her to look after her health first and foremost.
Shy people are the worst at hiding away. And in Japan, privacy is a hell of a lot more respected than here.
Knowing how influential she was in helping to shape the direction of the band during her time with BM, I would find it hard to believe that she would completely disassociate herself from them permanently. I wouldn't be surprised if she still plays a role quietly behind the scenes advising them to this day
THIS. ^ :)
Haters are going to hate. They would rather believe the garbage then something that makes sense.
I guess it just weirds people out that she is nowhere to be seen or found. After that comment nobody knows what happened to her. Also the comment was made by the company in a post without a face. People are very skeptical about large companies. I get the impression people won't be satisfied until they see you eat say it herself
I saw in an interview Moa was asked if she could talk to a younger version of herself what advice would she give herself. She said the she would definitely advice herself to take stretching seriously and do it before every performance. I don’t know if she was referring to yui’s back problems
I surely believe it. Many hard working jobs can pull ever peoples back out! Of a serious injury the person would have to retire from he or her very great job work performance skills.👏
Мужик, после ухода Юи ни одной фотографии, видео, ни одной статьи о ней она как сквозь землю провалилась хочешь не хочешь люди будут обсуждать такое исчезновение, надеюсь у неё все хорошо❤
Учитывая её последнее обращение к своим фанатам и обещание общаться у меня есть только одно объяснение зная чуть социум японцев и отношение к иностранцем , к сожалению это расизм (они не особо за людей считают других ( могу и хотелось бы ошибаться)) . Я всё понимаю возможно ей не нравится как она выглядит из-за каких-то проблем с здоровьем но извините за столько времени хотя-бы из вежливости не поздороваться с своими фанатами через какой-то коментарийй наталкивает на мысль ... увы , мы для неё никто и абсолютно плевать на нас ....
The deadest of dead horses is continuing to be beaten. We will never know what the real reason was, and that is fine. Neither Yui nor anyone else involved owes us an explanation; she's entitled to privacy in medical matters. Babymetal has moved on, Momoko has become the new member and is doing a fine job, and hopefully Yui is doing well in whatever she is doing now.
That said, I think it's the mystery around what Yui is up to now that keeps this issue bubbling along. Yui is still listed as an Amuse talent, and her statement made it sound like she would be a performer in the future, yet nothing has happened. I think if she had reappeared as part of another project that would give people a definitive answer and there would be closure. It's the uncertainty that keeps people speculating.
Yes, your last paragraph is the question of the Yui fans that we still have left.
but some fans lie saying that we want bm to get back with her. and they say let it go, move on.
To those people I say: do not slander, we still have a question to answer and it is about yui solo project. not to anchor her to babymetal
and why would someone completely disappear due to a back health problem? ok, maybe Yui had many others reasons to leave the band, that's normal... but the issue is Yui's total disappearance... sorry, this isn't a private life, it's a hidden life... living in hiding like that would be very difficult even for us anonymous people, so imagine for a beloved public person like Yui... she could put an end to all the speculation by recording a video explaining the reason... that's it...
and taking into account that Yui in her letter said that she still has personal dreams and is still enrolled in amuse. It is logical to believe that she still has something to contribute in ART.
But a total disappearance does not mean respecting her private life, but rather it seems like a punishment
@@alexperez3367Ironclad non-compete contract and Legal gag orders in place for ongoing legislation
No, Amuse was not ruthless, they are and were a company withva pretty good reputation.
My big problem is, you simply can't calculate back health reasons to a single event. There is always an amountnof speculation involved esspecialy for dancers. This is one of thevreasons why they are often insured. And if they activate an insurance, it goes in and protect their client. They often demand a freeze of the account of the insured person. The business paetner has extremly restrictive permissionsvwhatvthey can say. In many cases the company is not allowed to say anything and the insurrance might want to meet the employer in court. So the lawyers of the company are pretty careful.
sorry for resurrect, but, for everyone out there that want to understand what actually happened to Yui and also just maybe, the other things like some accidents around the same time, just take a look at the anime named Perfect Blue. And sorry for collapsing your brain with that story that inspired some greater future movies. #PerfectBlue
What's the truth about Metal-Cat missing from this reaction???🤔 🦊 🖖❤
Congratulations. You've discovered the one subject favored by Trigger Engineers and Trollaphiles across online "fan pages". There's a sub-culture of "fans" that put in effort to keep the disinformation and comment section battles active in regards to Yuimetal's departure. It's usually copy/paste text from YEARS of the same bs being posted across the interwebs. And I wouldn't be surprised if dudes are utilizing AI to generate word vomit to trigger fans for reactions. It's a stupid habit of creeps and jerks of the online culture. Same bs & disinformation as seen/read when I discovered BABYMETAL in 2019. Didn't get any better in 2020 when everyone was home & online for several months. (SMH x 2). And that sucks for New fans who are out there trying to learn more of the history of BABYMETAL. They out here just wanting to learn about this group from Japan and find these stupid online content of comment battles about a former member. I've personally blocked out anything about Yuimetal subject online. Especially if it's in English. That's the red flag for me. The BABYMETAL fans of Japan I follow on X don't ever launch into comment battles about it.
In conclusion: Thank You for reading out loud the Official Statement! 🤘 That right there is what's going to assist New fans to better understand the Legit reason about the Yuimetal subject. Let's hope the New fans can respect and honor the legit reason, and continue to support BABYMETAL. 🤘🦊
"Any chain is always as strong as its weakest limb . . . ""
It seems like the back and health issues may have been the reason why she left. The choreography and stages are now designed for the members to stay in one place, whereas they used to be on a moving platform. In the "IDZ" choreography, some people noticed that the running part is slower and longer, header they don't do the jumping anymore. In the K-pop industry, choreography isn't usually changed unless there's a serious injury preventing them from doing the move, for safety reasons. I understand that the phenomenon of sudden disappearances is quite unusual, but it's actually a common occurrence in Japan. There's even a specific term for it, and it applies to Japanese idols who withdraw from the public eye to lead normal lives. In Japan and Korea, there are strict privacy laws for celebrities, which is why rumors can be particularly surprising to American audiences. This is likely because we are accustomed to constant media coverage of celebrities, including paparazzi following their every move.
It's more likely to have changed the choreography and the stages and so forth probably put in safety measures due to the fact that Yui is suing amuse for damages. That is also a large part of why they are forbidden to speak about her. it is a legal gag order
i miss yui so much.. i will learn to make Yui Video clip with AI generated as a tribute to her..
Wow Moa and Su have both stated that they visit Yui when they can.
Until she doesn't herself tell the reason why she left , I'm not buying any of it !!!
Bullshit. She gave a statement a long time ago about this.
At this point the people demanding answers are just insufferable.
Get over it
@@rantandchill9503 Babymetal was created it's ran like a business.. the music the songs the dances are organized by someone else ... the girls are just used as a tool like most J-pop or K-pop bands.. Something odd happen with Yui ... like I'm going to really believe that she had a back issue and just disappeared , come on dude use your head .
@@aurozappa305 If something scandalous happened then surely it would have been leaked, there's literally hundreds of people involved with BM someone would have blabbed. Remember we are dealing with a totally different culture. We can't even be 100% Yui Mizuno is a real name. The other thing to consider, depression and mental health issues are still taboo in Japan, where sufferers are often hidden away.
@@benuk2409 Very true😞
For all I care, if Yui 's health is well, it's all that matters. Everything else is secondary.
Also, the group gained so much with Momoko, and MM Legend of 03's show was evidence of that. They're all gonna be fine.
Besides that, there were rumors about YUI being * "pregnant" * and the father was their late lead guitarist *Mikio Fujioka* which was linked to him * "jumping" * from an observation deck. No proof but who knows? Members having been silenced by Amuse is giving out dark vibes for the fans.
That rumor is just flat-out dumb.
Besides anything else, it's HUGELY disrespectful to Momo. She's doing the best job and , think about, had probably the biggest shoes to fill. And has done it superbly.
I'd go as far as to say Momo plugged the hole in the slightly sinking ship.
In Japanese culture if you quit, you quit. Had Yui's health improved to the point she was able to perform again, it would NEVER have been with BABYMETAL.
Yuimetal is akin to your first boyfriend/girlfriend that you fondly reminisce about. Gone but never forgotten.
Bad blood? After everything they went through together, it's laughable there could be. Su's obvious affection and Moa's close friendship with Yui was there to see.
Further proof of the close bond the original members had for one another is everywhere, from Su declaring that Yui will forever be a part of Babymetal, to the little Easter Egg you get when Babymetal performed Babymetal - The One Stairway to Living Legend where at the end of the song you see 3 comets flying off even though it's just Su and Moa. The third comet is an obvious reference to Yui. You can't even make the argument is Momo as Momo was not declared an official Babymetal member yet at that time, nor did she perform that song with Moa and Su. If she HAD performed that song with them, then you would have a bit of a stronger case, but she didn't. It was very obviously a very intimate and private performance meant for the fans and Babymetal, yet it STILL had the 3 comets. So in my eyes it has to be a nod to Yui. If Amuse, Su, and Moa didn't care anything about Yui, there wouldn't have been anything of the sort.
I loved Yui as a member of Babymetal and she was my favorite of the 3 while she was in the group. Out of the 3 of the girls, I felt she was the most ... unusual. There was so many little things about her, from her timidness, to her Yuibot'ness, to her ability to ALWAYS detect when a camera was focused on her. Her ability to stare into your soul, to fall asleep during interviews. To me she was/is a girl who is very introverted, but was pushing past that boundary to become an idol, so she worked on to push her boundary and comfort level and pursue her dream of becoming an idol. So I had a lot of respect for her for doing that and actually succeeding in that pursuit! I love the other girls as well, but Yui will always have a bit more respect in my eyes for those reasons. Not to mention I recently learned it was YUI who would decide the set lists and stuff like that, so even at her young age she was a mastermind at things like that. Makes me curious what other tricks these girls have up their sleeves that us fans don't know about yet!
@@jeremyboynowski3784 "Not to mention I recently learned it was YUI who would decide the set lists and stuff like that"
Yui was in charge of that during her senior year in Sakura Gakuin, in her role as Production Chairman. Moa was class President that year.
I've never seen any credible source that says she had the same job with BABYMETAL.
We do know from interviews with the members, that she insisted that 'Road of Resistance' have its worldwide debut at O2 Academy Brixton.
That would be an odd thing to remark upon if she was the person in charge of deciding setlists.
@@rickwagner- At Su's graduation from SG, Su thanked Yui for always creating the set lists for SG. So it seems Yui was performing that role earlier than just her senior year.
@@AxeSwipe2011 Good point.
I've still never seen any indication she had the same role with BABYMETAL.
@@rickwagner- True true. The girls may have had some suggestive input, but Babymetal is very much Koba's brain trust and he always got the final say. Especially when they were still children.
Yui left for her own reasons. She hasn’t explained those reasons. Amuse hasn’t either. Nor has Su or Moa. No one related to BabyMetal has explained the reasons.
Yui has moved on. No one has heard or seen anything from her since the SG book quote. If Yui has moved on. Su & Moa has moved on too. Momo has officially joined the group. Brand new album & world tour is currently going on. Years have passed.
People need to let go. You can reminisce about all those years of Yui being part of BabyMetal. Founding member. Never will be replaced. If people can’t move on then enjoy the early albums of BabyMetal. Because it doesn’t look like the group is slowing down anytime soon. So, make a choice.. linger in the past or remember the past fondly but enjoy the ongoing journey.
Bisa jadi Yui skrng sdh menjadi istri dr kobametal
Teori apa ini😂
Considering her last message to fans and her promise to communicate, I only have one explanation, knowing a little about Japanese society and attitudes towards foreigners, unfortunately it is racism (they don't really consider others as human beings (I could and would like to be wrong)). I understand everything, perhaps she doesn’t like the way she looks due to some health problems but at least once in eight years, through some comment on some social network on the Internet, you could at least say hello to your fans ... alas, we are nothing to her and she doesn’t care about us...
What? Talk about reaching. Yui thanked the fans in her last message, but she does not owe us any further communication. Why do you feel that you're owed further communication when she clearly does not have interest to do so?
The racism thing is bullshit.
@@rantandchill9503 It's not an obligation, it's mutual respect.Dude, calm down as you wish, it's everyone's business, I miss her too. I can read and I read her last address several times, everything is very clear there. I made unpleasant conclusions for myself. We are absolute zero for her (maybe even a negative value)
@@laniakeacluster4499 You're still not owed anything. None of us are
@@MelancholyJoker19 у тебя забыл спросить
@@rantandchill9503 She doesn’t owe anyone anything, but if she wanted to sing solo (or as part of a group) as Yui Mizuno and nothing happens, us fans are going to at least wonder.
there are many crazies coping what happen to Yui they really need to make up things just to fit their own narrative ,
She fell off those giant stages twice. Lucky she survived. A back injury is very believable.
Twice? She did fell of during Budokan. Care to tell me what was the other time?
Once.
1 fall, 1 law suit
Whatever happened, since Yui is no longer with Babymetal, I'm no longer a fan of the "new" Babymetal. I really dislike the latest CD. I'm glad I can still listen to the older tracks.
I liked the last album, slowly accepts MG. But the thing I don't like anymore is how they still socialize with the teen caricature and the darkest outfits
Yes, people can really get hurt when they fall, especially off a stage. Sheesh, BM guitarist Mikio Fujioka died after a bad fall.
Are you comparing Mikio falling from a high observation deck on a freaking tower to Yui falling off a 1,20m high stage?
Yeah, he fell, riigghhtt
Yui developed a heart issue and could no longer keep up with the dancing routine as well as the touring life. It's really just that simple
Thanks for sharing! There are some that deny this, which can be frustrating at times.
Regis Tadeu do exterior?
😮😮😮😮😮
Only the Newbs and new to the fandom keep talking about her leaving oh yeah those who say they LOVE Babymetal yet "inadvertently" disrespect them trying to get clicks
So far all we know is the official statements. Idk why fans need to drag this on. I miss yui too but like they need to stop making statements that arent true. Endless she comes out and say theres bad blood i ain't believing it. All i hope is that yui is alive and well
Blame su just look at the interviews how she always giving yui the side eye look it up Dr Phil before u make a video bro!!she broke yui and moa up as friends because su has some fruity feelings for moa just look at the interviews and explain why she's doing that to yui but not moa?
I dont wanna think like that 😭 the girls always said no to bullying so i hope they never left each other out
That's false, Suzuka always have that cold but in reality is an attentive look to anyone in the interviews
I also agree that Su and Moa likely ✂️✂️
🎯
Wtf 🤢@@syruup-5555
First off Yui Mizuno has no official social media account here in Japan and basically became a ghost. She hasn't made a appearance since she left Babymetal and because she comes from a rich family plus having made lots of money during her time in babymetal she was able to use all of the money to disappear.
Two things that will plague Yui story-wise is the death of Takayoshi Ohmura then her leaving Banymeatl abruptly starting the rumors she was pregnant with his child. The rumors hold weight to this day because Yui remains missing to this day. For all we know she could not even be in Japan and be living abroad in Europe somewhere where it would be easy for her to remain anonymous.
Bottom line is nobody will ever know until she comes out of hiding which is highly unlikely and the longer she remains gone and anonymous with the rumors continuing I honestly believe she will remain anonymous.
Takayoshi Ohmura didn't die. Mikio Fujioka was the guitarist that died. RIP
Nskxnwfkd oops you meant mikio def not ohmura He is active on insta and twitter
That is fd up
The problem is that the disappearance was the cause of the bad rumors, and not the other way around
Source that Yui comes from a rich family, because Mizuno trademark of shoes?
Reddit is the worst place tbh and haters are gonna hate. Idk why people are still speculating and arguing about Yui tbh. She left Babymetal, she made an official statement as to why and that’s it. End of story. There is probably Amuse politics and influence behind but why would you waste your time arguing about that?
Yui was an core member of the band for many years and will always hold a special place in my heart but she is gone now and I wish her only the best in whatever she is doing now and hope that she is doing great. Su and Moa have said in the past that she is doing well and that they are still in contact with her and that they still are friends (which makes sense, given that they spend so many years with her and grow up together).
Momoko worked so hard to become the new third member as is doing a fantastic job so far and hopefully she continues for many years to come. 🤘🦊🔥
Amuse wrote a made up story about why Yui left. When Yui was absent from Babymatal concerts Yui wrote, or should I say Amuse wrote, I`ll be back don`t worry there is no Babymetal without me - this statement was taken off later when it was confirmed that Yui would not be back. Also, Yui said (once again Amuse) that she will be pursuing a solo career...will Amuse where is her solo career? NO BODY KNOW WHY YUI LEFT!!!
Bc we miss her. Reddit is disgusting, that's true.
Also, We want to help Yui in case Amuse didn't help her. Only in case she left the band for health problem releated overwork.
They're Idol group, yeah. The moment they leave japan to be a metal group, they should not be treat as an idol group anymore.