her first note was sharp but she slowly adjusted. And the sound quality of the mics was clearly poor. She's clear and strong. This was not a bad performance at all.
It was flat. And I don't know how that's the mic's fault lmao, probably more about her not being able to hear herself properly, or lack of training in that department.
@@absolutelynotarobotif you look at the other videos of the exact same performance you will see that their mics are very low, they also messed up the instrumentals. She basically has to scream to be heard
It’s no one’s fault. It’s just a small human error. The other girls were singing at the same volume as the back track so they probably adjusted the volume of the mics more louder so they can be heard more, but sophia’s singing is belted that’s why it overpowered the track. Filipino’s are know to naturally belt when singing.
Anybody who has watched Sophia sing while sitting still would know she is an amazing singer. She's doing extreme choreography in the video and isn't toning down the energy yet still sounds good 🔥 in Katseye we trust
THIS is how a fully on mic sounds like… I’m fed up with blind (and deaf) kpop fans blindly argue a backed or lipsynced vocal to be 100% live to “support” their idols. NO ONE can dance like this and still sing perfectly like CD. And I LIKE a live vocal sounds with full energy and intensity. ❤
@ what I’m saying is there js a difference between playing a pre-recorded track and singing live vocal no matter how stable and well-skilled the vocal is (yes, there are many many well-trained and professional K-pop artists who can do that, to name but a few, Hyolin from SISTAR… and many more, but a GOOD live vocal performance doesn’t equate singing exactly like CD, and even though some sang live the ultimate clip could be still highly edited or auto tuned)
she’s not bad at all, honestly pretty stable vocals. but (just my opinion sorry) if someone really is a bad vocalist, using “new idol” as an excuse is absolutely horrid bc shouldn’t new idols be good too??
@@cocoyuya4419 I think they just mean shes inexperienced in singing and dancing at the same time, even if u are good at singing, getting used to doing both at the same time requires experience, skill and stamina, something new idols don't have a lot during the sstart of their careers
She is really great despite the error on the start and the choreo being quite hard to sing with. Phenomenal since most artist I see literally just lipsyncs and focused more on the image and aesthetic more than the musicality itself.
this is what sound checks are for. the fact that Sophia's gain is up so high, you can't hear Megan at all, AND the whole start of the song being fucked... my little sound tech heart is breaking
We arent saying that she sucks at singing we are saying that their mics were not good… whoever programmed them mics gotta be fired! But the girls? They slayed real hard! Just not the mics…❤
They all sing live, the problem is that the soundtrack is very loud and you can't hear their voices, instead Sofia's microphone is much louder than the backing music, but they are all very talented and sing live.
Sophia's mic was actually so loud in person, They also messed up twice in the Intro with Playing the song Late and then Playing a Different song😭, in the Chorus, Sophia and Megan were supposed to Harmonize but bc of Soph's mic, You can barely hear Megan.
I respect her a lot for this, even if she didn't sound "amazing" I respect her for singing live which many idols kinda seem to be afraid of doing, doesn't want to do or aren't allowed to..
She’s such a good dancer. I’m like obsessed with them all doing the super high fan kick perfectly in sync. It’s soooooo satisfying to watch. I really enjoy Katseye so far! I think it’s a cute group name too
I was there to watch them live and it was amazing. I keep noticing that the mics are sounding different. Sophia can sing good, but whoever was in charge of doing the music and microphone needs to do better. Still love the band Katseye.
this is so crazy because i met katseye backstage while performing at the mama awards (we were the middle school who performed with tws) and i had no idea how famous they actually are. i was talking to them and everything unknowingly that they are extremely famous!
Anyone hating on her needs to understand that THIS IS LIVE not everyone is beyonce or Ariana grande and sounds like the damn cd, respect to the flaws and all man ❤️
guys its not her fault of being loud or not lip syncing, nobody was actually lip syncing just really quietly, sophia still sang when her mic was wayyy up which caused the huge sound, the microphone people did not realize her mic was up, but a mistake is now famous!!
Bro Sophia's vocals is so stable when shee sing so powerful girl plus bro why did mic is so loud too,megan sing too but lower just to harmonize with sophia❤ (Its hard to sing her part) Im all rounder no hate.
They all can sing live. Newjeans (while they were in hybe) could and can sing very well if you watch their Livestreams, recording behind the scenes etc Fromis 9 r good singers in general (watch encores) Le Sserafim can sing well, Except Sakura, Kazuha and eunchae's voices fit a more soft and cute concept. For example crazier is a slow song which suits their voices if you watch their recording behind the scenes in illit, minju and yunah carry the group, iroha improved but they all suit. A girl crush concept especially moka since a cute concept doesn't suit their voices
@GLLIT_ForLife listen the operating system messed up.They increased the volume of Sophia's mic that's why her voice was louder than others. Check the liability of your comment before posting it.
@GLLIT_ForLife ???? its not that deep.. original commenter isnt even saying sophia has, for example, "horrible vocals". it literally is just loud and its not even an opinion, its a fact. you can hear at the start of the chorus, that the "oh," is quite louder compared to when the pre-chorus ends. plus, eternity is just mentioning what happened personally for them during the clip, it isnt for clout or attention..
Desde el comienzo de la presentación habían problemas técnicos, y cuando sophia cantó le subieron el volumen de la música en su audífono, entonces ella se veía obligada en cantar así de alto
On tiktok someone said that they were behind the guys doing the sound and they were old and PANICKING trying to do something for the sound of her mic 😂
![[#2024MAMA] KATSEYE - Debut + Touch | Mnet 241122](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I8erREJ08p8/mqdefault.jpg)
her first note was sharp but she slowly adjusted. And the sound quality of the mics was clearly poor. She's clear and strong. This was not a bad performance at all.
It was flat not sharp lol
Hahahaha. You even blamed the mic. Ahahahaha. She's not that good. Mid
It was flat. And I don't know how that's the mic's fault lmao, probably more about her not being able to hear herself properly, or lack of training in that department.
@PidrisCruxy you wanna cookie? No one asked for you
@@absolutelynotarobotif you look at the other videos of the exact same performance you will see that their mics are very low, they also messed up the instrumentals. She basically has to scream to be heard
daniela's pants are brighter than my future WHICH LOOKS SO GOOD ON HER. and i literally fell in love with sophia's vocals
did you mean daniela lol
danielle???
I WAS LOOKING AT SOMEWHERE ELSE……
Daniela*
Danielle is from NewJeans 😭
No there is someone with that name in katseye
whoever was managing the mics was so foul for blasting sophia like this 😂😢
This is the answer. It’s not any of the girls fault. They have no idea until the show is done lol
It’s no one’s fault. It’s just a small human error. The other girls were singing at the same volume as the back track so they probably adjusted the volume of the mics more louder so they can be heard more, but sophia’s singing is belted that’s why it overpowered the track. Filipino’s are know to naturally belt when singing.
i think this was the show where the sound engineers messed up a lot
@@MrChibblez they never said that it was the girls fault 😭
@@AngelDust-l4d I responded to someone and they deleted their comment I think
For those wondering why Megan is also singing but we cant hear her, she is harmonizing with Sophia but lower.
Naur there was just a mic issue. Sophia’s mic was louder then the rest lol
@ameenamohamed3865 Naur, in the debut performance video, it confirms Megan is harmonizing with Sophia but she was doing it in lower voice
You can hear her a bit at the “we can run it, run it, run it”
I can’t believe anyone couldn’t hear Megan
I can hear her perfectly ??
@@mochijuice8074you lyin lmao
Anybody who has watched Sophia sing while sitting still would know she is an amazing singer. She's doing extreme choreography in the video and isn't toning down the energy yet still sounds good 🔥 in Katseye we trust
THIS is how a fully on mic sounds like… I’m fed up with blind (and deaf) kpop fans blindly argue a backed or lipsynced vocal to be 100% live to “support” their idols. NO ONE can dance like this and still sing perfectly like CD. And I LIKE a live vocal sounds with full energy and intensity. ❤
Pink does it while hanging from the ceiling and spinning, but I definitely couldn't
Actually, there are artists who can..
@ what I’m saying is there js a difference between playing a pre-recorded track and singing live vocal no matter how stable and well-skilled the vocal is (yes, there are many many well-trained and professional K-pop artists who can do that, to name but a few, Hyolin from SISTAR… and many more, but a GOOD live vocal performance doesn’t equate singing exactly like CD, and even though some sang live the ultimate clip could be still highly edited or auto tuned)
EVERYONE SAYING SHE'S BAD WDYM SHE SO GOOD FOR A NEW IDOL LIKE. Edit: YALL WTH I DIDINT EXPECT THIS TO BLOW UP TO 1K LIKES TYSMMMM
She’s a good singer it was the stupid mic 😭
REAL
she’s not bad at all, honestly pretty stable vocals. but (just my opinion sorry) if someone really is a bad vocalist, using “new idol” as an excuse is absolutely horrid bc shouldn’t new idols be good too??
@@cocoyuya4419 I think they just mean shes inexperienced in singing and dancing at the same time, even if u are good at singing, getting used to doing both at the same time requires experience, skill and stamina, something new idols don't have a lot during the sstart of their careers
@@oofgottarunn yea exactly plus everyone is saying that hybe doesn't train idols in vocals so katseye is doing great for a rookie group
the vibrato when she sang “debut” was so GOOD 😭
MY fAV PART IM SO GLAD SOMEONE ELSE NOTICED!!!!!!! Lol 👏🏼👏🏼
She is really great despite the error on the start and the choreo being quite hard to sing with. Phenomenal since most artist I see literally just lipsyncs and focused more on the image and aesthetic more than the musicality itself.
the sound engineering on this show was horrible. PEOPLE NEED TO GET FIRED 🗣️
I second, third, fourth...etc....THIS!
I FIFTH THIS!
I SIXTH THIS ‼️
It's the vocals that aren't stable when dancing. Something basic for an idol...it's her fault :)
@@ahienyFl that’s not it tho in the beginning they messed up even js playing it multiple times
this is what sound checks are for. the fact that Sophia's gain is up so high, you can't hear Megan at all, AND the whole start of the song being fucked... my little sound tech heart is breaking
The "debuuuut" scrathes my brain so hard i love it
Edit: OMG TYSM FOR 100 LIKES
girl literally ATE the mic 😭😭
"they keep coming back."
"OHH- 😩"
😂😂😂😂😂
SHE ATE THO!!💗
Her vocals are GREAt😮😮!!!!!🎉
I was there and it was amazing! I literally DIED bc of their vocals!!!
The fact there singing and dancing is amazing
The vibrato towards the endd 🤭😜😍😍
We arent saying that she sucks at singing we are saying that their mics were not good… whoever programmed them mics gotta be fired! But the girls? They slayed real hard! Just not the mics…❤
She ate the whole earth ❤
They all sing live, the problem is that the soundtrack is very loud and you can't hear their voices, instead Sofia's microphone is much louder than the backing music, but they are all very talented and sing live.
Definitely proves that their mics are ON!!!! 👍
woah (almost) same pfp 😮
There was a problem with her mic you can literally tell💀
For real
No there wasn’t be real
No you are just deaf 😂
@@PiggiesInTheRainthere literally was😭😭 that whole show was filled with mic issues
"DeEeEeEbut" is the reason I keep repeating this
Can't stop repeating 🙏
Sophia's mic was actually so loud in person, They also messed up twice in the Intro with Playing the song Late and then Playing a Different song😭, in the Chorus, Sophia and Megan were supposed to Harmonize but bc of Soph's mic, You can barely hear Megan.
I respect her a lot for this, even if she didn't sound "amazing" I respect her for singing live which many idols kinda seem to be afraid of doing, doesn't want to do or aren't allowed to..
Yes she is my bias❤
So talent ❤❤❤
her voice is so stable omg
She really just said my momma ain’t raise no lip singer
Ofc we already know she was from Philippines, born to be a singer
And she still nailed it! ❤
She nailed it 🎉
The bad mic+loud ass backtrack= sound tech fired
Laras voice sounds heavenly
OOHH WEEEEE🔊🔊🔊🔊🔊🔊
i miss ot12 sm i could cry
DANIELA WE KNOW YOUR SPARKLING-
She’s such a good dancer. I’m like obsessed with them all doing the super high fan kick perfectly in sync. It’s soooooo satisfying to watch. I really enjoy Katseye so far! I think it’s a cute group name too
@@laurenstephens4192 so true gurl!
She did so good 😭
The best way to turn down lip sync rumours as a rookie group😊
Can we just appreciate Lara's voice
They literally looks like the WINX CLUB girlies
OOo WE E e e 🗣🗣🔥🔥
i mean like, if i danced like that, i wouldn't be able to sing anymore lmao 💀 I'd be so out of breath, I'd actually die out of asthma. xD
Some of y’all bashing on her but dancing while singing is HARD😭 she did great
Con vibrato y todo yasss❤
THE DEBUT?!!!!! HELLO IM HOOKED BY ONE WORD
I was there to watch them live and it was amazing. I keep noticing that the mics are sounding different. Sophia can sing good, but whoever was in charge of doing the music and microphone needs to do better. Still love the band Katseye.
I think she sounded good!
SHE SLAAAAAAYED!
this is so crazy because i met katseye backstage while performing at the mama awards (we were the middle school who performed with tws) and i had no idea how famous they actually are. i was talking to them and everything unknowingly that they are extremely famous!
Daniela’s sparkly paaaaants✨🩷
OH 🗣️🗣️
It's Sophia on her karaoke mode guys😂
SOPHIA ATE
It was good but the voice crack but she slayed everything:]
Sophia: 'HEAR ME OUT'
The OoOOOOHHH GOT ME ROLLING ON THD FLOOR😂😂😂😂
Anyone hating on her needs to understand that THIS IS LIVE not everyone is beyonce or Ariana grande and sounds like the damn cd, respect to the flaws and all man ❤️
You can't blame them since its a pretty dance and its hard to sing while dancing yet she ate
guys its not her fault of being loud or not lip syncing, nobody was actually lip syncing just really quietly, sophia still sang when her mic was wayyy up which caused the huge sound, the microphone people did not realize her mic was up, but a mistake is now famous!!
OH🗣🔊
“Mic check, Mic check”
She still sound good
besides that first note she ate
They ate.
I love how Sophia realized and put on a show
Yah,sophia no need to lipsynced.especially she is pilipina🇵🇭👍💞 proud of katseye thier are all talented artist.🌹🌹🌹🥰🥰🥰
It's almost like they've done this a thousand times.
I just cant imagine my ribcage being moved around so much yet staying so steady like well done
I really hope the sound guy got a stern talking to by the producer of the show. They cannot be letting these types of things slide.
Her vocals was pretty on point. it's the sound system that mess up the audio
This is the same stage where they started playing my way instead of debut, something was clearly wrong with the sound guys backstage that day 💀
Them and babymonster are the most talented 5th gen girl groups❤
Katseye is not kpop :)
@@ItsRenPlays0 They said 5th gen groups not 5th gen kpop groups 😭 But yh they aren't kpop
but Who asked you
What about Kiss Of Life?
@@GoQuokka1235th gen = kpop. western artists don’t use generations
Bro Sophia's vocals is so stable when shee sing so powerful girl plus bro why did mic is so loud too,megan sing too but lower just to harmonize with sophia❤
(Its hard to sing her part)
Im all rounder no hate.
Proof that she really sings not lipsynch😊
She slayed it hard 💖🤭💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻💖💖💖💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻🥰🥰
the only girl group in hybe that can sing live
They all can sing live. Newjeans (while they were in hybe) could and can sing very well if you watch their Livestreams, recording behind the scenes etc
Fromis 9 r good singers in general (watch encores)
Le Sserafim can sing well, Except Sakura, Kazuha and eunchae's voices fit a more soft and cute concept. For example crazier is a slow song which suits their voices if you watch their recording behind the scenes
in illit, minju and yunah carry the group, iroha improved but they all suit. A girl crush concept especially moka since a cute concept doesn't suit their voices
I was there and it was so loud in person my ears were bleeding
How were they up close? Besides the loudness 😭
Yeah cuz... she's singing in a mic...?
@GLLIT_ForLife listen the operating system messed up.They increased the volume of Sophia's mic that's why her voice was louder than others.
Check the liability of your comment before posting it.
Stop getting confused! I was talking about @ETERNITY_ENT wanting attention-
@GLLIT_ForLife ???? its not that deep.. original commenter isnt even saying sophia has, for example, "horrible vocals". it literally is just loud and its not even an opinion, its a fact. you can hear at the start of the chorus, that the "oh," is quite louder compared to when the pre-chorus ends. plus, eternity is just mentioning what happened personally for them during the clip, it isnt for clout or attention..
daniela is actually body goals like
The DeBuuUt was muahh 🤌
Ang totoong singer lalo na pag sa Philippines ay di gumagamit ng lyp sync. They said don't call yourself a singer if you use lip sync
i like how she just went "whoops" and then to "slay again"
AT LEAST SHE SLAYED AND DOESN'T LIPS SYNC
BRO ALL OF THEIR SONGS ARE SO CATCHIE AND LOL SHOPHIAS MIC WAS SO HIGH I LATER REALISED THT MEGAN WAS SINGING ASWELL ..😂😂❤
Idk what people r talking about I think she slayed the day away
"S"lay in Sophia is really showing
Me tryna find the “DOGSEYE”😭
yall its an energetic dance what r yall expecting 😭
Was this at jingle ball?Because I was there
Desde el comienzo de la presentación habían problemas técnicos, y cuando sophia cantó le subieron el volumen de la música en su audífono, entonces ella se veía obligada en cantar así de alto
On tiktok someone said that they were behind the guys doing the sound and they were old and PANICKING trying to do something for the sound of her mic 😂
Manon's is finally here ☺️
Idk why people is talking shhht i mean it was quite good, for a rookie and for a dancing based group
this pissed me off so bad, jingle ball fucked up their mics so badly
Shes literally philipino loud✋️😭
I love Sophia because is my name!!!
They keep coming back....
Sophia: OOOOOOOOO
OMG Lana slayed