Palestinians Film War in Gaza: ‘So They Know We Existed’ | NYT
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ก.ค. 2021
- “I removed the password from my phone so that if we didn’t make it out, and we were killed, people would know what happened to us. So they know we existed.” Palestinians in Gaza used their phones to film the toll of the 11-day war in May between Israel and Hamas. They spoke to us about the trauma of violence under an indefinite blockade.
Subscribe: bit.ly/U8Ys7n
More from The New York Times Video: nytimes.com/video
----------
Whether it's reporting on conflicts abroad and political divisions at home, or covering the latest style trends and scientific developments, New York Times video journalists provide a revealing and unforgettable view of the world. It's all the news that's fit to watch.
I wonder how many of these people are alive today…. Have they survived this current war😢😢😢😢
thinking the same 😢😢😢😢
It's Genocide not war
The same
and they kept only blaming Hamas, when this has been going on for yearsm where Isreal did this, ofcourse people will retaliate, and then Isreal playVictim
most of them did, i don;t know all of them
The sad part is no one cares to do anything about this. It’s repeated for decades. Nothing has changed.
The forever wars
Actually it has escalated and though this has been going on for a long time the IDF is murdering and bombing and stealing land to the point that there will be no more Palestine if nothing is done to stop them
because the Palestinians never wanted peace
@@tytube3001 you can't expect them to "want peace" WHILE you're actively violently removing them from their homes. There is no peace without justice. Even then, the bulk if the violence and killing is committed by Israel, not Palestine.
@@tytube3001 Hamas is not interested in peace, only in the total annihilation of what they call "the Zionist entity".
the Palestinian Government in the West Bank, neither, for economic reasons, money will cease to flow in their bank accounts once there is peace.
Should we wait to be slaughtered, and the world will stay put, as they did during the Holocaust?
"Dreams are destroyed" may Allah fill this country and the world with peace.
How can you be assured that your doctrine is on the truth without looking for it in other schools of thought?.
كيف تطمئن بأن مذهبك على الحق دون البحث عنه في باقي المذاهب؟.
th-cam.com/video/FbU8AaOW4Uk/w-d-xo.html
📀SERCH ADITYA RATHORE, HE ALSO MAKES INFOMATIVE CONTENT LIKE NYT ON U-TUBE📀
Ameen
Ameen 🤲
Looks like Allah doesn't care
@3:24 she is saying to her sister "it's over" so tragic that they have to go through this again.
THIS IS NOT OKAY!
THIS WILL NEVER BE OKAY!
IT'S JUST... TOO MUCH
It’s not okay, but it is a reality. There’s cultural issues at play, and politics
it's never been okay, nothing justifies apartheid. Nothing justifies oppression. Nothing justifies air strikes against civilians. Nothing justifies the forced evictions. Nothing justifies breaking international law.
@@JeroenBIG Unfortunately I have to agree... politics are exacerbating and somewhat encouraging the perpetuation of this conflict and these cultural issues, and has been for literally generations.
@@legally_lisa there was a peace process in the past but Hamas decided to use suicide bombers inside Israel. As result the israeli population voted more for the right wing and those are the consequences. Hamas basically undermined the peace process cos they want no peace. As long as Hamas rules palestine there will never be peace between palestinians and israelis even tho most civilians would like that to happen. It gets even worse now because Iran uses its proxies (Hamas, Hezbollah,...) for its strategic gains against Israel. Have you ever wondered why Hamas started this war knowing they arent strong enough to keep up with the Israeli miliary? The Gaza war was meant to put international pressure on Israel in order to internationally gain moral support for Irans goal to wipe Israel off the map. It was a campaign planned almost half a year before it happened (even one of hamas speaker confirmed it), al aqsa was just a planned pretext.
"Nothing justifies air strikes against civilians": These were airstrikes against military targets. In the rule of war its stated that its allowed to take civilians casualties if the military target cant be neutralized without casualties. It means that even 1 higher ranking Hamas member living near your house could result in you dying aswell because thats allowed, he is a military target and therefore a strike targeting him (even when hitting civilians aswell) is allowed.
"Nothing justifies breaking international law.": As i stated above, Israel acted in the rules of international law. The rules of war allow such things. War is definetly awful, it has always been like that but there was no breaking of int. law just because it was awful for civilians.
@@hanspeter-fs4in peace will only be achieved when Israel is wiped off the map, nothing less will do.
Imagine Going through this and not being able to go anywhere for safety. Imagine the children.
@Mohd 50 & Aisha 6 imagine creating an account on Jul 17, 2021 just to do this
@Mohd 50 & Aisha 6 being desperate *
imagination is not reality in that case bro. but i tried to imagine it, feels horrible
“The kiddie killers”
@Mohd 50 & Aisha 6 🐄 Mooooo Moooo
I’ve had like 500,000 tears fall down my face while I watched this…
You know what's messed up? Is that the whole video NYT did not address that these shells and bombs were sent down by the Israeli army and that Gaza has been under siege for the past 14 years. Instead,they labelled it as a "conflict", as if there is ever a conflict between the occupier and the occupied, or the ones benefitting off of apartheid and the ones suffocating under it. I know it might be too obvious to be addressed to some, but this could also be quite confusing to those still learning about the Israeli occupation of Palestinian lands and their cold blooded genocide of indigenous Palestinians.
what are u talking about man? there isnt any conflicts 4 of ky precious friends died because of them and since tgis start of this month theres 25 israelies who died what are u even saying man?
everyone seems to forget that in 2007 Hamas was Elected by the people of Gaza to lead them to a "better" future.
over the last 15 years Palestine's received billions of $... and did they used this money for schools, hospitals a mall perhaps?
No! all the money was used to build a terrorist's haven on earth, with 5* underground accommodation, multiple weapons to choose from (like a buffet), plenty of children to be both human shields and potential candidates to replenish the "troops".
it's very sad to see the cost of life and destruction in Gaza, but they really gave the Israeli side no choice.
Let's hope Israel will be able to wipe out all of Hamas's infrastructure in the Gaza strip (actually doing the job that they should have done themselves) and this time elect better leadership- one that is not focused on destroying Israel but rebuilding Gaza and giving hope for a better future
Exactly.
TWO YRS AGO you commented this, and here we are today seeing these horrid atrocities happening and now since 2yrs much worse. This should had been stopped yrs ago . No one should live in constant danger of being bombed. Israel is a terrorist state
“I removed the password on my phone... so they know we existed"
@@garrett9945 Or , just as a teen PERIOD. SMDH this is really sad.
@@garrett9945 painful 💔i have no other word
Free Palestine from the river to the sea 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸
@@foreveravatar5874 Thanks for showing your true ideology.
Don't cry when we turn your houses into dust
@@heisenbug3542 ???
"So that people will know we existed......." oh my God!!
@Linda Leonard Golda Meir meant there was no Palestinian identity, pre-1948. There were Jews and Arabs.
Israeli and Palestinian nationalities were both created in the 1950s.
🟣 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE, HE ALSO MAKES INFOMATIVE CONTENT LIKE NYT ON U-TUBE🟣
Well, President Jimmy Carter wrote about Baron Lionel Walter Rothschild who signed The Balfour Declaration of November, 1917 that led to the re-establishment in Israel in 1948. Balfour Declaration = Encyclopedia Britannica. Arthur James Balfour was a British Statesmen. Even Lord Jacob Rothschild gave an interview on TH-cam about his family's involvement in restoring Israel in Palestine due to The Balfour Declaration.
I wonder how many of you ever watched the movie, "The House of Rothschild" from 1934 starring George Arliss from 20th Century Fox. and Actor George Arliss also acted in the movie, "Alexander Hamilton" in 1930. The movie, "The House of Rothschild was based on Mayer Amschel Rothschild's son and his five sons, more specifically on, Nathanial Rothschild and James Rothschild. According to that movie, Mayer Amschel Rothschild's son, Nathaniel Rothschild, connived his way into winning the bid on the loan for "The Reparations" of France" after The Battle of Waterloo in Belgium in 1815. Nathaniel funded The British side of the war while his brother, James, funded Napoleon's side of The Napoleon Wars in France. The Battle of Waterloo was the last battle to ever take place between The British & France. It is also mentioned in The Jewish Encyclopedia, Vol. 10 on page 490 published in 1906 that Mayer Amschel Rothschild was an agent of Prince William Landgrave IX of Hesse Kassel out of Germany who funded British Troops against The American Revolution. It is also mentioned in The Journals of The House of Commons, Vol. 23, that Prince William Landgrave IX of Hesse Kassel's father, Frederick The II, married Princess Mary, the daughter of King George The II. Of course, our U.S. Founding Fathers fought against King George The III.
Oh...my direct ancestor, Reverend Edward Wightman, was one of the reasons why Roger Williams, The Founder of Rhode Island & Founder of The 1st Baptist Church came out with The Separation of Church & State that later transcended down into our U.S. 1st Amendment between The Danbury Baptist Association & Thomas Jefferson in Danbury, CT in 1803. That also took place due to Roman Catholics who, in Virginia, tried to "Fine" an Anglican Protestant Church. Of course, the reasons also stem back to The European Persecutions (*U.S. Library of Congress) as well as The Protestant Reformation Era that included people like Martin Luther, William Tyndale, Anne Boleyn (National Geographic has a good article on Anne Boleyn, but they fail to mention, "The Carthusian Martyrs of London, and Anne Boleyn's brother, George Boleyn). There was also John Rogers, The 1st Protestant Martyr burned at the stake in 1555 after William was burned at the stake in 1536, same year that Anne Boleyn was executed, King Henry The VIII's 2nd wife. Reverend Edward Wightman was The Last Martyr during The Protestant Reformation Era burned at the stake by King James for heresy in 1612, same year that English Minister John Smyth died. Every one I mentioned are in Encyclopedias, but Edward Wightman was mentioned under "Burning At The Stake" as one of the reasons why, "Capital Punishment' came to America, but they fail to mention that it was The British who were behind that. Reverend Edward Wightman's great grandson, Reverend Valentine Wightman married Susannah Holmes, The Great Grand Daughter of Roger Williams who came to America in 1630. Susannah also fell under Obadiah Holmes mentioned through Christianity Websites. As for English Minister John Smyth, who was another Protestant like Anne Boleyn, Martin Luther (Lutheranism), and William Tyndale, as well as John Rogers, John Smyth had a hand in forming The Baptist Church Denomination who died in 1612. However, he also had followers, Puritans, who set out to convince other Puritans and Protestants of forming a Pilgrimage called, "The Great Puritan Migration" which included The Mayflower, Speedwell, and The Fortune.
The Mayflower & Speedwell left late in September of 1620 due to repairs needed to The Mayflower, and they arrived in Plymouth, MA in December of 1620. Most Pilgrims were sick when they arrived ashore until Squanto appeared, one of the 27 Indians captured by Capt. Thomas Hunt, a lieutenant of Capt. John Smith from Jamestown, Virginia who had come to know Pocahontas. (Note: Not the same John Smith as English Minister John Smyth. Pastor John Robison who led The Mayflower was influenced by English Minister John Smyth before they left Scrooby, England.
Squanto, during his capture, lived 9 years in London where he ended up working as an interpreter for British Captains before he was set free and allowed to return home to find his tribe, "The Patuxet Tribe" of 'The Wampanoag Clan' all wiped out by disease. From there, Squanto trekked south to find other clansman from The Wampanoag Clan. That all led to The Pilgrim Wampanoag Peace Treaty signed on April 1st, 1621. Chief Massasoit kept the peace until he died from The Wampanoag Clan. However, Chief Massasoit's 2nd son later attacked in what was known as King Philip's War or The 1st American Indian War. He attacked due to more and more settlers who arrived that encroached upon their land. The British Royals just wanted to enslave all those American Indians that they called, 'Savages," but people like Roger Williams prevented that from happening even after those Indians killed Anne Hutchinson. That is also the reason why Roger Williams was known as "The 1st Abilitionist." The British did manage to enslave some of those Indians, however, but not all. The Wampanoag Clan also tried to drag The Narransett Tribe into that war. Roger Williams bought his land from The Narragansett Tribe who were not part of The Wampanoag Clan or any of its tribes. Roger Williams University, The Massasoit Community College, and Massasoit State Park would not exist for some of those events.
My God.. these people are so resilient, courageous, and strong. How anyone can think that having these barbaric wars and attacks is okay, is beyond me. It's disgusting. I wish they could be truly safe. They don't deserve this. God bless them all ♡♡♡
I am afraid until the Palestinians get rid of Hamas they will never be "truly safe". Do the Palestinians deserve this? Good question , but to my understanding the vast majority of Palestinians elected Hamas and put them in power.
@@davidfrench6521 well so many ways yiu can look at this right? Let’s just rely on the fact for this current conflict.
Fact- long before Hamas started firing the rockets, they were expelling Palestinians from their home, bulldozing, inciting violence by illegal settlers, backed up by IDF!
Fact- 10000 worshippers in the mosque praying on their holiest day of year, in one of the holiest place to them and they get attacked by armed soldiers with stun grenedes and rubber coated bullets! Just imagine if some Muslim army did that to any church or synagogue anywhere in the world.. just imagine the aftermath..
Fact- same week the IDF cracking down ‘violent protester everywhere, still forcing props from east Jerusalem, still building settlements in West Bank, still maintaining the blockade on Gaza, a tiny strip of land inhabited by 2 million people, small numbers of them are Hamas, who can’t even come out in day time l, stay hiding, making crude rockets or whatever they do..
fact- after the mosque attack, nobody in the world doing anything about it or will do anything about it, 1700 people were injured,
So Hamas called isreal, just saying yo stop attacking and forcing civilians to be removed ethnically. Hamas gave them 24 hours to stop the violence, or they will retaliate only way they know how allowed to do how..! But natanyahu just laughed and mobilized the troops coz he knows how to provoke Hamas! I mean the whole population is beyond provocation by now. So IDF didn’t stop their assault, actually increased it a bit because natanyahu could use the sweet distraction from opposition pressure of him stepping down. Anyway nothing changed and Hamas started firing rockets, knowing 94% of it not gonna even cross! Then we see the distraction Gaza went through!
Fact- isreali know every single Palestinian name and birth information and address!
Fact- Israeli also claimed to have most sophisticated laser guided missiles system and the bombing ..
Then why they destroyed 40000 residential housing unit? 70 schools? 11 clinics, 16 ambulance? 4 UN shelters even when UN workers called them18 times and told them not to bomb there coz of kids? So when they say they were targeting the hamas and they got precise guide system missiles and bombs? And they have all the names of the terrorist ? So why the schools, clinics, press office? Ambulance??terrorist?hmmmm.. hmmm.. most moral military in the world???only democracy in the world??and What I stated above is all facts ok? You don’t have to agree with me but you can’t just make up your version of the events or selective amount of accounts for consideration of the whole pictures!!
So tell me now, is it Hamas thst the problem?
Do you know who crated and funded Hamas? Isreal, to counter popularity of the PLO!
Well Hamas wasn’t elected body till 2006, how about the attack before that? Hamas got elected by their own people, they are the government body of Gaza and they were funded on doing social work like schools, clinics, hospitals, university and other governmental duties while hiding from Israeli drones! Fighting back, if you can call it, is just one part of their government functionaries! By the way jimi Carter and other international body was present when Hamas won the popular vote. Do you know what US and Israeli does? And their EU parter of FREDOM and democracy? They declare Hamas who just won democratically, a designated terrorist organization!
@@sajibanas1077 Well said it's just if you want to be blind of the clear light.
Hamas believes they deserve it and actually should be happy/proud to have been a part of it.
@@adam7.633 yes I’m very familiar with the typical can’t see the light response when one can’t deny the facts stated above! It’s actually not the light we should focus on, it’s this huge bubble certain community has been living in for so long that they forget about the it’s sheer existence, meaning thru start to believe their own lie!
I'm 15 years old, I live in Gaza, and you can see the impact of the war on me because I'm still watching these videos until now.
الله يكون في عونكم حبيبتي 🌷و الله كل شي عندو نهاية ، و ربنا راح ينصركم على الصهاينة المجرمين و راح تسترجعوا اراضيكم و تشرق شمس الفرح و السعادة تانية على بلدكم و راح تشوفو كيف العدو ينقهر قدامكم ، في هذي الأعوام او حتى بعد خمسين سنة ، فلسطين راح تكون حرة 🌸🌸 اختكم من تونس 💜💜
May Allah help you my brother! And your family and friends and all of our people.
I'm ashamed that we could do no more than simply pray for you...
Only Allah can provide peace.
الله يحفظكم ويقويكم، نحن نشوف نفسنا فيكم❤️❤️❤️❤️🇵🇸
Hopefully you will grow up and be able to vote for leaders who are more peaceful and less destructive and hateful like Hamas. Once you make peace between yourselves and your neighbors, only then your life will be better! All the best of luck!
@@GPBKM is israel more “peaceful” than hamas? And it’s her choose to vote for hamas or fatah
Absolutely heartbreaking.
They should stop supporting Hamas
Hamas is using them to hide.. It's the normal people who are paying a price
@@fma6571 by that logic, if someone kills Israeli civilians, you can say "they should stop supporting IDF".
That's not a justification. Who said they're all supporting Hamas to begin with? And these Israeli atrocities were there long before Hamas.
@@fma6571 and what about the people in jeuraselem who were pulled out of their homes, shot with rubber cases mettalic bullets, dragged out of their mosques. Also what about shooting down institutions like Al Jazeera and associated press? Are you gonna tell me Hamas was underneath them like all the Zionist trolls repeating IDF talking points?
@@mohit_panjwani if we wanted to destroy Gaza, we would have turned it into a parking lot 20 years ago.
I agree that the issue in Sheh Jarah is very disturbing, even for me as an Israeli.
But if Hamas keeps dropping rockets on, we will turn Gaza into dustland.
If you want a solution, start talking. Shooting rocket will result in 1mg ton on your head
When you realize that power, in this world, unchecked seems to usually disregard the value of life. It gives you an idea of where evil is in this world.
Yup most the truly evil people are in our government positions. They’re your governors, presidents, prime ministers, mayors, bunch of corrupt scum who care for nothing but power and control. Oh and of course money. The root of everything. (Also anyone reading this, no i’m not anti government incase you’re wondering. I’m anti corrupt people in government positions.)
@@AnUnknownPlayer. lol
Blame it to the HAMAS.
⭕ SERCH ADITYA RATHORE, HE ALSO MAKES INFOMATIVE CONTENT LIKE NYT ON U-TUBE⭕
It’s cruel to bomb a prison for civilians and children. They can’t even leave.
Oh right, throwing rockets on everything around you is not cruel. Did you expect us to give them cookies?
Don't let Hamas use you as meat shields, you won't get bomb on your head.
@@heisenbug3542 Wth are u talking about? These are innocent civilians. R u even human?
@@fubytv731 oh right, the Israel side are not innocent civilians, how I didn't understand that.
Don't shoot rockets, don't get bombs.
@@heisenbug3542 An eye for an eye will make the whole world blind. Just, stop, with the violence, and just start respecting other human beings.
@@heisenbug3542 Very convenient of you to leave out the context aka the ILLEGAL 14 year blockade of Gaza as well as the decades long ILLEGAL military occupation of Palestinian land. But I guess facts and context don't really mean much to racists like yourself lacking in human empathy
it's genocide, not conflict
Thank you NYT for covering this, they deserve to share what really happened. It was suffocating just to hear abt all this misery from them, i cant even imagine how a person goes thru that
Now NYT is being accused of knowing about the Gaza attacks and not supporting Israel.
Ironically, you don't see the same thing happening in Israel.. crazy how palestinians go through this daily
No one is talking how they were bombing homes with no call or promession....
you mean how Hamas bombed Israeli homes without a warning? happened to my cousin... Israeli is warning before every attack. Plus , Hamas loves hiding their weapons under those same homes....
@@theendermc4822 hamas has the right to defend itself
@@aniqahaider7152 how is killing civillians defending yourself?
@@aniqahaider7152 hamas stars every war/fighting round.....
@@aniqahaider7152 Israel has the right to defend itself as well.
My heart always hurts for the babies and children like wtf 😢
scripted you been mind fu*ked
The older sister comforting the younger sister hit me on an emotional level. I would walk through fire with gasoline draws on for that girl
They always need more fighters in gaza or you could just donate your paycheck to them.
@@tsukeisawa7786No , we never need that ,, we need peace , we dont want hamas, also we dont want isreal army , we want just peace
This video is hard to watch. My hearts goes out to the Palestinians fighting for their homes and right to exist.
@@antonio7497 palestine is not even by the gulf...
it's ethnic cleansing, not conflict
The western world don’t know how easy we have it, life is precious.
It's so easy here half of the people think we are the good guys sending billions of dollars worth of military technology to foreign terrorist conducting a genocide against partisans armed with rocks and sticks.
@@MoringAfterStar well , Israel is an US allied nation , unless they turn on each other , the aid to Israel won't stop
@@MoringAfterStar foreign aid was never about humanity , but for strengthen relationships between nations and coalitions
@@user-xl1wm6xl9d the USS Liberty GTR5 look it up, the army enforces what the government wants and the government enforces what the corporations want, let me make it just a little easier to understand....
Saudi Arabia has the oil, Palestine has Ports in the Mediterranean sea, both are muslim nations, America has lied about everything after WW2, they became anti socialist, adopted Nazis and started a cold war that almost ended human civilization as we know it by making aggressive attacks at the CCCP. America doesnt even care about it's own people, they only care about the aristocrats who run it.
@@MoringAfterStar If hundreds of missiles are rocks and sticks..... Its incredible how people don't understand the palestinian position is not coexistence, but complete destruction of Isreal, and the removal of all jews from palestine. Also, where is the genocide! There are many peaceful Palistiniens that live in Isreal peacefully and enjoy life there, where are the mass graves of the genocide you claim?
I'm from Israel. I am sorry my state do this to you:( This is not okay in any way
Respect to you
Destroy every enemy of ur country
Otherwise they destroy you
These western and Arab news Portals are baised
You are a liar! Another terrorist online painting a narrative.
So glad technology is being used to show the horrors of war .Amazing people 😔♥️
@@Joe-by8jh 9 Israelis dead. 260 Palestinian Christians and Muslims dead.
@@ahmedarush165 I'm pretty sure all Palestinian christians live in the west bank not gaza
@@TurbanLeDurban Lol no there are like 4 churches in Gaza, Israel bombed two so now remains two churches. And a small community of 1000-2000 Christians live in Gaza
@@Joe-by8jh Hamas has commited 15 war crimes throughout Its existence according to even biased media channels suh as Fox News and Israeli media companies. Israel has violated 28 resolutions of the United Nations Security Council (which are legally binding on member-nations U.N.
Charter, Article 25 (1945); a few sample resolutions - 54, 111, 233, 234, 236, 248, 250, 252, 256, 262, 267, 270, 280, 285, 298, 313, 316, 468, 476,
etc. many of them even before its existence. what is the definition of terrorism? "The unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims." And what is Israel currently doing? The exact definition of terrorism. So what was Israels excuse for the ethnic cleansing and displacement programs before The existence of Hamas.
@@user-ch7hn8dd8j
What the UN Decides or not it's irrelevant.
This organization is anti-jew and anti-israel as you can see by the number of violations it gets while countries who perform genocides in millions get 0.
UN is obssessed with israel.
It isn't objective, so it's irrelevant.
I stand with Gaza. May you all be safe and hope it will end soon. Greetings from Norway
Thank u bro🥺♥️
@@eheaalasm5776 always. Stay safe and be careful😀❤
@@blakemrolfsensanchez547 I WILL. THANK U
@@eheaalasm5776 May Allah Help You Guys 😔
may Allah be wiped from the face of the Earth forever forgotten
im a man i dont remember the last time i cried so much after seeing the 15 years old kid looking his dead father broke my heart.
i feel you, these the sories that have been told there is a thousand more and im trying not to think about it.
GAZA they lie a lot to.get sympathy and support. Isael , tgey are the victims
Shame on Israel
This is NOT a middle Eastern problem it IS a problem in the USA --- the solution is not to found in Israel or Gaza the solution is in the USA. America's financial, military and (im)moral support is where the change has to happen.
I agree mostly and I'm an American. I wouldn't say it's all the US's fault but much of it is. We cater to our little brother "Israel" who does nothing for the world. We send them money and weapons and all they do is misuse it. We fund their terrorism. It makes me sick.
Thats a very big misconception. The US gives a few billions to Israel each year which Israel then has to buy American military equipment. A few billions is nothing compared to the hundreds of billions the IDF gets from the government each year. If the US stopped funding Israel, the situation would stay the same.
@@elishakoch3749 So if the US navy was to embargo all goods coming into and out of Israel until Israel does what the UN has ruled on Israel's "invasion" of the west bank. Do you think things would change . Of course it would. But of course the Zionist lobby has too much influence in the American political for either side of politics to do such a thing. This is the US's immoral support of Israel -- a USA problem.
@@dtm180258 no its not a USA problem
@@theangrykekistani9418 ask the families of those killed on 9/11 -- where does the support come from? the USA needs to make a moral stand not one based on $ support for political parties.
Young ladies - You are courageous. My heart goes out all the Palestine people who are living in these conditions. God bless.
@carter smith Palestine should be wiped off the face of the Earth
So powerful. Everyone should see this! It is horrible that this has been allowed to continue to happen to the Palestinians for over 70 years. Just brings me to tears.
This has been going on for way too long man :(((( like these people and children can hardly live
We’re all humans. #FreePalestine🇵🇸
😭🖖
@@HashknightGaming ❤️🤝❤️
🇮🇱💪🇮🇱💪🇮🇱
Free Palestine
@@lucymerkom9571 ,🤣🤣🤣🤡🤡🤡🤡🤣🤣🤡🥱🥱🥱🥱Free💩💩💩💩
8:23 this is a war crime according to international law !! But Israel always get its way
@@elio3950 yeah, you're right. IDF shouldn't be shooting at schools or medics either good point.
@@elio3950 th-cam.com/video/w0inm3oS71c/w-d-xo.html
I didn't say hospitals
@@elio3950 I say its one of Zionists lie ! Bc you can’t fire a rocket from a building it has to be open area to be able to fire the rocket not appartement nor school !!
Second the international court of justice called for investigation on Israel commeting war crimes not Hamas 😉 so go find a new lie
@@goodboiadvsp3297 or bombeing media officies as they did AP office !! They wanna wipe off Every non jew whether its Hamas or not !! As they forcibly kicked 7 million Palestinians out of their home lands and that was way before Hamas..Zionism is real cancer
@@goodboiadvsp3297 get the facts right. when hamas shoots rockets from schools and hospitals they make these areas legitimate targets and terror sites for israel to retaliate as per the geneva convention. stop playing the victim and deceiving people
Seeing a 10 year old girl talking about how she feels mentaly exhausted and wish she was an adult so she could help rebuild their houses.. It pains my heart.
Its sad she got to grow up that fast. My 9 year old girl just likes to play and being a kid.
God bless the Palestinians and Syrians. And everyone who suffers war and violence .
8:13 "Our whole life is built on emergencies." This is no way to live, I cannot imagine the pain and fear Palestinians have to deal with every single day. I wish for peace for all of you every day. 🙏
kindasorta123
14 hours ago
8:13 "Our whole life is built on emergencies." This is no way to live, I cannot imagine the pain and fear Israelis have to deal with every single day. I wish for peace for all of you every day. 🙏
War crimes perpetrated on civilians are inexcusable.
Israel blowing up missile launch sites isn’t a war crime. Hamas setting a missile site up next to a school is.
@@danlivni2097 oh? we’re bringing war crimes and Israel up are we?
@@danlivni2097 Israel killed many people in those strikes...
@@oliverrevis4190 www.memritv.org/clip/en/4441.htmegards
Arab writer confronts Hamas official on Arab TV on Hamas using Gazan's as human shields. When the Hamas official has no response, he threatens the Arab journalists life for telling the truth on Hamas war crimes.
@@xjsvg8054
Hamas MP Fathi Hammad: We Used Women and Children as Human Shields.
th-cam.com/video/g0wJXf2nt4Y/w-d-xo.html
This is insane. Innocent life taken senselessly. That boy screaming in the street for his dad😭. All govs everywhere deserve to die for the ignorance and division they spread amongst people WORLDWIDE. The trauma they inflict on the innocent. Prayers to all the families and people who lost their lives or lost loved ones. This is no way to live at all.
I guess retaliating to a rocket strike from Hamas is “senseless”. U Palestinian sympathisers are ignorant as well, you don’t poke a lion and not expect it to maul you back. Gaza can consider itself lucky that it isn’t levelled like Baghdad in Operation Iraqi Freedom
.
@@delta-romeo0263 stfu
@@delta-romeo0263 Hamas has commited 15 war crimes throughout Its existence according to even biased media channels suh as Fox News and Israeli media companies. Israel has violated 28 resolutions of the United Nations Security Council (which are legally binding on member-nations U.N.
Charter, Article 25 (1945); a few sample resolutions - 54, 111, 233, 234, 236, 248, 250, 252, 256, 262, 267, 270, 280, 285, 298, 313, 316, 468, 476,
etc. many of them even before its existence. what is the definition of terrorism? "The unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims." And what is Israel currently doing? The exact definition of terrorism. So what was Israels excuse for the ethnic cleansing and displacement programs before The existence of Hamas. Also a little side story, my grandmother had her small apartment complex bombed without warning but most people where watching the maintenance nearby and only 2 families where in the building they did not get a call or a fake shell land on the roof to signal them. A mother and daughter both have sever brain damage and the rest have broken limbs or some damage in their ribs. Israel claimed they thought their was some activity and it turned out they where just reckless.
@@delta-romeo0263 shut up.
@@user-ch7hn8dd8j dude I lived in this conflict my all life , please you just put lies right now , you just blind .. hamas is terror organization that did thousands of horrible things all this years claiming it’s the name of allah .. you can condemn the evil in both side
U don't have to be Palestinian to defend Palestine u just have to be a human
What's "Palestine"?
@@elio3950 watch the video 🙏
Thanks to the New York Times for publishing this, and I'll do something about it, if I can.
How different is it when neighboring countries of Palestine provides weapons to the governing body of Palestine from US providing weapons or funding to Israel to develop weapons and their army? When people look at Palestine negatively when its young people join a militant group from Israel who makes it mandatory for all its citizens to join the army? Why is one okay and the other is called a terrorist?
What war? Agreesion, single sided occupation, not a two sided war!
this is just blindness
Its almost unbearable to think that its 2021 and this kind of thing is still happening.
because ISRAEL's selfishness exist.
Right? HAZA HARVEST HAMAS
Palestinians, we know you exist. Stay strong and may you all be granted jannah. Love and prayers from Malaysia 🇲🇾🇵🇸 #freepalestine
😥🖖
kita sama2 doakan mereka di malaysia
Do Kurds, Balochistan and the Uyghurs exist to you, or they don't fit your agenda.
Did you say the same about Syria (500,000 people dead)?
Or maybe about the Kurds and the extrication Turkey is doing to them?
No? didn't though so.
Arabs. You just don't get along with this world do you
@@danlivni2097 this video is about Palestine, you don’t live inside his brain to know if he supports others or not.
This was just to painful to watch
Share it maybe people would wake up
This is heartbreaking.
War has no winners. Only Sinners.
Israel is a winner , they literally have unconditional supports from the west since it’s the last apartheid and facist and imperialism projects
O
🏀 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE, HE ALSO MAKES INFOMATIVE CONTENT LIKE NYT ON U-TUBE🏀
@@everythingsfine1395 lastly i'll checked ha mas sanction on unhrc = 0 same with Saudi Arabia, chi na, Turkey, Russian?
Well, well, well the fact choose the other sides. 😌😌
@@everythingsfine1395 Firstly, how is it an apartheid? I’d love for some examples.
Secondly, fascist is a form of far-right, authoritarian ultranationalism characterized by dictatorial power. How is Israel far right when it has Arabs in the government? And how is it a dictatorship if it has voting every 4 years?
Choose your words wisely kid.
Most resilient people
Viva Palestine ❤
🇵🇸❤🇮🇪
Americans , especially, American Jewish Community that are still in the dark should watch as all.peoples from all walks and corners of this world . Put ourselves in the people of Palestine in particular G@Z@ . Something to ponder and wonder ? Today its even worse .
Wowww... some of us dont realize hiw blessed we really are... I thank God every day... my life hasnt been easy... however never experienced anything like this... God is merciful!
Help out by fighting against the HOGS that support this. Show them the atrocities, change their mind.
@@MoringAfterStar the only people u need to fight is hamas thats all it is
@@lovinglife995 no, but good try.
@@MoringAfterStar what do u mean good try
@@MoringAfterStar ur giving them so much credit and we israelies are suffering from as well who do u think u are to actually declare its one sided
Nobody is helping them like india occupied Kashmir 😞.
Sad but true…….
This is hard to watch. And UN didn't do anything.
@@joyfuldays596 Good questions posed for you. What would you do if your Hamas neighbor across the street in Gaza sits down on the balcony, puts his little boy on his lap and starts shooting machine gun fire into your nursery in Israel?
Question 2: What would you do if your neighbor across the street digs a tunnel from his nursery to your nursery in order to blow up your home or in order to kidnap your family?
@@danlivni2097 let’s bomb 5x the buildings with families and children nearby with no evacuation plan, blame it all on Hamas, all while we continue expanding our occupation and call it a day! Problem solved
"If I don't steal your home, someone else will" - Jacob, Israeli settler
@Eva Gina Was Israel able to illegally annex and occupy Palestinian territory all by themselves or did they need massive help from the United States?
@Eva Gina joke of the year..without USA Israel can't survive a second. Believe it or not..
@Eva Gina - Israel receives billions of dollars in American financial and military aid ever year. Paid for by the U.S. taxpayers. Denying this is absurd. Israel is one of the worlds largest recipients of foreign aid.
Interesting that you focused on my comment about American aid to Israel, and provided no rebuttal for my comment about the illegal annexation of Palestinian land, and the illegal settlements in the West Bank. There is an article in the 4th Geneva convention that states it is illegal to relocate civillians into occupied territory.
International law applies to every nation on earth. Including Israel.
@@182kramer Hamas and the PLO gets 15 billion dollars per year from the Arab countries while Israel gets only 4 billion p/y but the difference is that Israel put the money in education and high tech and the Palestinians put to pay for rockets and terrorists
@@idokonak451 if the PLO receives 15 billion dollars per year dont you think they would have gotten better weapons by now? I mean, all this talk about Israel being able to support itself like some kind of able-bodied male is because it never had support itself in the first place. Since the early 18th and 19th century, Christian Zionists within the British government and British elites pushed for the creation of Israel in whats known as Palestine. When Israel was within its early existence, Israel had very little reason to worry about its Arab neighbours was because the Zionists knew that the British would have their backs, would guarantee their 'independence'. Furthermore, the USA turned a blind eye towards Palestine and the illegal-land grab by Zionist militias because the Pentagon saw Israel as this fortress against anti-American countries, where the USA could safely project its power from Israel to the Middle East. Israel never had to worry about national security because they were pampered by bigger powers, and possibly because of their complacency caused the Israel-Arab War and the Yom Kippur War. Israels existence was not without the forced relocation of native Palestinians, both native Muslims and Jews who had been living there for generations. It doesnt matter whether you refer to the 1948 maps, the 1968 maps or whatever map Israel has redrawn, the Zionists keep saying that Palestine is a land without a people, and the Jews are a people without a land, but they keep forgetting that Palestine has people in it. And Zionists keep making this claim that when they were given a part of Palestine, its the empty, barren lands that nobody wants to live there, rural areas and farmlands when that is not true. Under the First Nakba(the First Displacement) when the State of Israel was created, seven-hundred thousand Palestinians were displaced. Thats entire houses, neighbourhoods, properties and cities where they lived, their grandparents and ancestors used to live, now taken away by Zionist settlers. Israel had an enormous boost, an enormous headstart for their existence, while the Palestinians already lost half its limbs in the first round. Tbh, Im surprised even after seven decades the Palestinian will for existence remains strong. Thats my thought.
The USA has a very big role in this !! They always block all resolutions that try to improve things !!
USA cant. because USA is sheep of ISRAEL.
We’ll look back at this long era of discrimination against Palestinians by Israel the same way we view Apartheid Era South Africa.
Be on the right side of history.
To the people who dislike this video:
I don't dislike you, but I wish you were allowed more love in your heart in this life, so that you could have more sympathy for others because that is what the world needs most.
❤️
Agreed
The dislikes people will reap what they sow in everything they do.
"Israel and Hamas went to war." "260 Palestinians were killed in Gaza, and 13 people were killed in Israel."
Yes, israel shuold apologize cuz its stronger ? Do you know how many missiles were launched from Gaza into Israel? Missile without directional capability, towards civilian population, the only difference between us is that we only attack places of missile launches or weapons depots (which by the way Hamas hides in places like schools and hospitals) and that Israel has developed the ability to defend itself
@@user-xg8it7dh8k or missiles that mostly landed in desserts whilst Israel fired them into the Densest place in the world
@@ad72644 So what is Israel supposed to do to let Hamas destroy the country? The logic of accepting missiles and silence is simply illogical. I'm sorry. Do you really expect the State of Israel to be attacked by thousands of missiles (for the civilian population without weapons targets) without responding back?
@@user-xg8it7dh8k So killing kids is a right of defence?!
@@Atl0siy No, you distort my words, the solution is to stop attacking Israel as soon as Hamas stops attacking Israel will not attack back, if you attack Israel with thousands of missiles Israel will bounce back, unfortunately civilians will also die. Now I ask you, is it okay for thousands of rockets to be launched into Israel every few years? By the way, there is an area where Hamas until recently launched rockets every few months / weeks. Is that okay?
All my love and support to these brave people from Iceland. Stay strong, were all humans, and we love you all ❤️🇮🇸🇵🇸
❤️❤️❤️
Thank you
Ég hata gyðinga svo mikið, vona að þú sérð einhvern timann hvað þeir eru að og hafa gert við heiminn. Það er enginn annar hópur jafn ógeðslegur og júðarnir.
@@brightblackgrouse6236 Gyðingar eru ekki vandamálið.
@Eva Gina no?
Children shouldn’t be worrying about things like leaving proofs of existence in face of Annihilation on a weekly or daily basis. The Desperation is heart breaking and maddening
I'm surprised that the mainstream media is publishing this.
So scary from just the footage I can’t imagine it in person…
same
@@antonio7497 tf you mean
@@antonio7497 the only good Indians are ones oppose authoritarianism like the Reuters correspondent who was killed in Afghanistan by Taliban but was ridiculed by right wing Indians because he covered the covid crisis in North India and before you come and attack me like all the Indian trolls on government payroll, I'm not Chinese and neither support the CCP
When will the western world governments view Palestinians as human beings who deserve to live a dignified life?
when they stop shooting rockets at Israel
@@tytube3001 when Israel stops illegally removing them from their homes and illegally occupying their lands.
@@tytube3001 silly comment by a silly human. How much does the Mossad pay you to spam Palestinian posts?
@@tytube3001 Great Post
@@haiderzia987
Former Palestinian Knesset Member, Professor Azmi Bishara: There Is No "Palestinian Nation", Never Was!
th-cam.com/video/P3n5-yG-6dU/w-d-xo.html
My heart aches for all the civilians..may Allah protect you all give u victory
Dear God, be with the family who have lost their family members. OM SHANTI!
“If you’ve ever wondered what you would have done during the Holocaust, genocide and the civil rights movement,
you’re doing it now”
No not really. You can’t compare the Holocaust to this. Sure it’s terrible as all wars have been but it’s nothing compared to the Holocaust.
@@mangomaster5820 Oh really! how so? if you mean the fact that the holocaust did not include an apartheid and the world's largest constriction camp then by all means.
@@ramicaormairos1511 what I mean is the Holocaust is massive compared to this. Hamas and Israel are both firing rockets both sides are bad.
⚪ SERCH ADITYA RATHORE, HE ALSO MAKES INFOMATIVE CONTENT LIKE NYT ON U-TUBE⚪
@@mangomaster5820 I understand what point u are coming from but u have to understand that the destruction Hammas has caused cannot be compared to the destruction Israel has caused and in these past few months hammas has only retaliated to Israel’s attacks .
The Holocaust is occurring in China against the Uighurs and Israel is also an apartheid state- these are not my words they are words from renowned Israeli charities. Every year there are injustices against certain groups of people, I just believe we shouldn’t pick and choose when to stand up against them and when to stay silent.
Although I’m Israeli, I want peace 🇵🇸 🙌🏽 🇮🇱
We want our right to return
@@mihmd1238 you'll get it
Thats why tge wars will never end and you suffer from it much more than as
@@PodcastCentral333
I don't think so
That's why Israel is killing us
@@mihmd1238 Israel (the government) is. The Israelis (the people on the street) aren't.
😭😭😭 I think of all these people every single day
I feel for the children
same . they deserve sm better....
Imagine a group of people being bombed with hi tech air crafts and precision guided missiles in broad day light in the 21st century and presence of social media . And still the world silently watches, no one intervenes to put an end to this
@Advait K Which incident? What's your point exactly?
@Advait K You are saying Pakistan should let its soil be used for terror and not conduct any operation?
Because Israel warns when and where it will strike to avoid civilian casualties. At that point if they die it's their fault
@Advait K What is your argument? I see nothing but whatabboutery. Two wrongs don't make one right.
@@spongemanicecone5445 Really ?Signals before attacking ? This is the moral compass that we using now and somehow makes Israel justified and humane ? ? Nothing justifies
the human cost on the military engagement is too much - how can its chilling hearing children sceaming as bombs are shaking their buildings, and the saddest part is the ones we see are the fortunate ones 😰
🟥 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE, HE ALSO MAKES INFOMATIVE CONTENT LIKE NYT ON U-TUBE🟥
This is not military engagement! This is the state of terror Israel 🇮🇱
@@TheHadeelLife explain Hamas please? 4000 rockets on Israeli civilian targets? someone is hiding the truth...
Heartbreaking. Just heartbreaking.
This is worse than war world 2 very tragic. I am sorry for your pain & suffering. If there is God it will help this situation.
My heart is broken.. i can't even do anything to stop these pain people are going through..
So grateful you guys knew whats really happened to them😔
No more war on earth please.
To all the world leaders.
Ok war stopped you saved us all
@@garfieldarbuckle1317 LOL
Owner of war has disconnected
its about money...
@@bpcgos thats why people rebel against countrys like china because they want money?
02:26 - "So they know we existed" this made me cry!
Thank you New York Times for this short documentary, and for publishing the truth!
Rest and peace to those who were murdered. And I hope the Palestinians live a very long, happy and healthy lives in their own homeland- Palestine.
I also think that if you care about Palestinians you should condemn Hamas. Besides the fact they are killing all opposition within Gaza and terrorising thier own population. During the operation they fired thousands of missles at Israel. I live in Tel Aviv we experienced barrages of hounderds of missiles fired at us at as a time - very scary, and some went through the defence system and destroyed buildings, we spent all that time in bomb shelters. No other country would have responded to it in a different manner (I think most countries' response would have been far more aggressive), plus it is pretty clear that without Iron Dome we would have had hounderds of casualties.
I feel bad for innocent people in Gaza and we should avoid hurting them, but Hamas is doing all they can to harm innocent people on both sides, firing from populated areas into populated areas. You should condemn Hamas if you care about Palestinians.
What? Where do you see Palestine on a funking map? There is no such place
the new York times is usually unfair about this topic but I liked this video too
@@maytalsj6888 exactly. Because the Israel government, and state, and its zionist visions blur, and blind the world. The Israeli government has always the upper hand compare to the Palestinians whom land they stole and occupy
Anyone who support Palestine will time waste donot support leave these people's with israel
this happens worse right now
Ok @The New York Times . I watched @3:38 minutes in and this breaks my heart. This world is going nutzo.
This has been happening forever, we just were able to ignore it much easier
Earlier it was easy to ignore.
This has been happening since the 40's literally, and repeatedly covered up even by this very platform. Kudos to them for finally opening up and showing the hidden side.
Whats the artist social media ?
I keep all of you over there in my prayers every night. Sending love from the US.
You're sending nothing. They need homes not your prayers.
@@hardknockscoc So you disregard people who could at least contribute to spreading awareness of the problem? Small-minded.
@@hardknockscoc you're apparently atheist. My right to send prayers even I want to and love. Definitely isn't going to hurt. So back off!
That’s very kind of you❤️❤️
God bless the people of Gaza. Our hearts and minds are with you.
Man. Just imagine all the innocent terrified people not knowing if you guys are next. Living in constant fear is not a way to live 🤦🏿♂️
#freepalestine🇵🇸
Sadness and suffering. Lives of these people are totally destroyed. They will never recover. Who is responisble for this atrocities?
And somehow the ghouls perpetrating this indiscriminate barbarity think it makes them safer? Pure evil.
FREE PALESTINE! Stop Palestinian genocide! 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸💔💔💔💔💔🇵🇸🇵🇸🕊🕊
My heart trembling while watching this
what a beautiful sister to smile and say she's fine now
It's so heartbreaking whenever they said "the war is over" in this video because now we know that the war never ended 2 years ago. My heart breaks for all the innocent lives lost in this senseless bloodbath.
it must take bravery and courage to film all the heartbreaking scenes around you
Every time I happen to come across a Palestinian, I just want to hug them so tight and tell them how much I'm sorry. Nobody is on their side, whatsoever, cause that'll trigger their Israeli/US international relations. In the big picture, it really sounds like Palestinians VS the world (Not Israel).
Thank u so much for ur support❤️
😭😭now i am afraid of wars!
Unbelievably sad. Just horrible. 😫💔
🔺 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE, HE ALSO MAKES INFOMATIVE CONTENT LIKE NYT ON U-TUBE🔺
This world, will one day have peace
But a thought for all of us.
What kind of peace?
For even the greatest country cannot answer it for us and the most sacred books can only be characters in front of reality
@@ordinarydude2237 Not saying humans will be here or any species. Just earth
😭💔
I dont see any CC options, but if it could be done, I'd like to add Hebrew subtitles here.
Are you hebry and pro plastenian
I cried from all my heart...
I can't do anything to stop it, but for the rest of my life I will advocate for Palestine!!!!!!
#FreePalestine
Correction: not a war. not a conflict.
Genocide. Massacre. Are the correct words to use here.
And, war crimes.
How is this not a war?
@@cristianomessi8079 He meant to say it's more than a war, more than a conflict.
@@cristianomessi8079 it's not a war because Palestine is not allowed to maintain a regularized military to defend its borders and sovereignty against ongoing Israeli expansion, leaving no choice but for militias to attempt to defend it. These militias are then much easier to label "terrorists" and bomb Palestine indiscriminately.
It would be a war if Palestine had a military to defend itself.
@@haiderzia987 That isn’t Israel’s fault though, Hamas fought fatah off which led to a fierce battle between the two which cancelled the idea of a military
It's hard not to cry upon watching this. Free Palestine from the river to the sea
Why my comment got removed?
rip