@@tadhggoreyoneill13666 well in canon (before disney) Lucas sort of loosely entertained the idea of Mace being alive. Never confirmed it. But he also never hated the idea when fans speculated it. But in disney canon (not my canon) hes dead. But Starwars theory is doing a fanfilm about it which ill definitely consider as my headcanon.
@@tadhggoreyoneill13666 thats fair. I just like to imagine how things would be different if Mace survived. In some ways, deep deep down i kinda like to imagine he survived in some way. This video is a great take on Maces survival. Probably my favorite "what if mace survived" fanfic yet.
This has to be the first time I have heard a "anakin came back from the dark side...." and he actually faced justice and wasn't given a free pass and a "water under the bridge" outcome. Also having Mace NOT survive to the end even though this was about him, was another first. Over all this is one of the better What if alternate realities Ive seen.
I know right? Everyone is so forgiving of Anakin and Vader because "there is still good in him". Bitch, he murdered children and then countless others, he deserves to die even if he turns back.
@@aaronquinn2449uh what? Most of the Jedi looked up to Anakin and respected him. The younglings that Anakin murdered probably looked up to and admired him. And then Anakin the crybaby goes into the temple killing priests, children, and teenagers. Most of the Jedi order didn’t do anything wrong to Anakin. Anakins actions were unacceptable
This, Anakin's problems are because of his own personal issues. Obi-Wan might of needed to at least(Well before the purge started) tried to push Anakin to speak up more but that doesn't mean the Jedi deserve to be slaughtered enmasse. Anakin's an adult and he should of at least thought "What would mother think of me doing this." What would Obi-Wan think of me doing this. He fucked up and thats the tragedy.
@@ChrisBear1989 bro, the whole jedi code is "fuck emotions. you're supposed to serve the galaxy as an unfeeling warrior." hell, he went to get help about nightmares of his loved ones dying and was basically told "shut up you whiny baby, death is a good thing" rather than being given actual help processing it. anakin isn't the only one to blame when the people who were failing their own code were making him worse.
Well I could imagine Luke and Leia wanting to become jedi... but I understand why they wouldn't be permitted to... they would have to deal with the animosity of the other jedi both in training and not. Great story!
they should reconsider. This is why Anakin was turned to the dark side. Too much caution and mistrust of Anakin was the reason why Anakin could not fully devote hinself to the order. If the order fully handled properly Anakin in the beginning, Palpatine would not have that much influence on Anakin.
As you pointed out this was a rather dark story, but it was presented very well and tastefully all things considered. As dark as the ending was, I understand why you ended it the way you did and I like all of the twists the story took. Well done with this story.
The Star Wars franchise really needs to consider giving the beloved Samuel & fictional Mace another chance since the best characters don’t really die so easily. He’d be the perfect Jedi to’ve survived the purge. Mace grows on me the longer he’s been gone & ignored unlike the others, even as Force Ghosts. And Samuel contributed by insisting to have a purple blade in Episode II. He’s been pivotal. Have to honor him properly.
There's an old saying, "The enemy of my enemy is my friend." That would make sense to Dooku if he knew Sidious will betray him in the end, and he'd have just one chance to do the right thing after all he did before and during the Clone Wars.
@@michaelsmith622 no excuses for the youngling massacre but I understand the Jedi Order wasn't blameless in how he turned out. They tried to snuff emotions out of him despite seeing it fail time after time. Told him they didn't trust him for year all while using him. They had it coming
Dammit Anakin you just had to break Mace Windu's trust just after you gained it. What if ideas: 1. What if Count Dooku survived and took control of the Galactic Empire 2. What if Captain Phasma became the Supreme leader of the First Order 3. What if Abeloth broke free from her prison during the Clone Wars 4. What if General Grievous joined the Republic 5. What if the Yuuzhan Vong won
What if the Jedi had successfully defended the temple? I remember hearing that several Jedi sensed that there was something wrong but didn't seal the temple because they believed Anakin to still be on their side.
The temple can be defended better, especially the Jedi are prepared, the Grand Inquisitor is taken down quickly, and Cin Drallig & Shaak Ti manage to stay alive and coordinate on. They also need to somehow take Anakin out of the fight. But unless someone manages to take down Sidious & rescind Order 66, they won't hold out longer than in canon - maybe until the sunrise, but that's it. There are just too many clones, in comparison to the Jedi, and they can just start bombing the temple from the star destroyers & call for more clones if the resistance is too stiff. In Legends there were non-Jedi security force on the temple as well, but I don't know if that's canon anymore. It's why similar scenarios from this channel end with the successful evacuation. The victory conditions here are escape and survival, not holding the temple.
I love these so much dude. Well done. It reminds me of what me and my friends used to do, making our own Star Wars stories as kids. The shame and credit to you is your stories are better than Revenge of the Sith.
I actually really liked this story. I don't like how so many of these what ifs having Anakin just be forgiven by everyone after murdering so many people in cold blood. I think that it makes sense that he would have to face the consequences of his terrible actions.
WOW! Excellent storytelling. This was so emotional, especially how you worked in Reva from the Obi Wan series! Thank you for this🙏🏽. I love Star Wars and reimagined stories such as this makes me fall in love with Star Wars all over again 💚. May the force be with you 🙏🏽
Trying to ne a Rock, for someone who just lost a Mountain. Damn. Absolutely beautiful, and it truly shows the weight of the situation. Worth the thumbs up I'm about to give this video, on top of the scene between Oni Wan and Reva. Tears Kid, and I ain't ashamed to say it. Well done. Well done indeed.
27:25 wouldn’t be easy to move on, wouldn’t be easy to forget what happened.. but what could be changed is the present & that could affect the future ❤ Keep it real man, this is the kind of theme I love Star Wars stories for, you capture the heart & tone of it perfectly each time! ☺️
If I were Plageius or Palpatine, I'd rather just end the Rule of 2. And restore multiple Sith Lords at a time. Infighting may be inevitable, but atleast if one Sith Lord Dies. The Other Sith will live to avenge their fallen Sith Comrades.
Can Disney please make either an animated series or individual movies/series around Star Wars alternate history? This story was incredible and I would love to see it play out on screen. I can see it being hugely popular amongst the wider Star Wars community seeing as how we would get to see how differently changing just a small event effects the entire timeline of the galaxy.
I still love the grand inquisitor as your opening😂. You've taken one simple phrase from the TV show, and now it feels like some big inside joke between you and all of us😂
i’m so excited for this one. it also makes me wonder what if what if anakin and mace grew up together. . or also what if anakin went with obi wan to utapau
Oh man, you're writing skills are stellar. I'm crying again. Keep it up man. I still have one story I found that holds my interest rn. Hopefully I'm not gonna be crying a third time, but if I am then so be it. You're stories are worth it.
A tragic story indeed but a surprisingly realistic outcome in the end, Anakin was too far gone after order 66 and at least Windu saved some younglings. Honestly I loved every second of it ! Here an idea, what if Padme was force sensitive ? Since we know that a certain Sith Lord was a senator on Naboo at this time, what would have happened to the young Naberrie/Amidala if she was found by Palpatine ?
Mace has to realize that Luke is not his father. Obi-Wan and Yoda knew it. Holding Luke back is just asking for trouble. Have Mace take Luke under his wing. They both are not your typical Jedi. It would fit.
this should be a movie it's good to look at different outcome events exploring alternatives is fun . may the videos continue and be wirh us always . 👍👍
Bastilla Shan did have an holocron but I think a what if video about Anakin falling in love with Aayla Secura was already done (I might confuse her with another Jedi master however).
What if the sack of the jedi temple on curasaunt from the old republic wars was launched into the future, and the battle took place during rots? As in the battle had just begun in the temple but the fighters (jedi/sith) all went through time. I feel like these kinds of scenarios would be cool because it would be an interesting way to get characters that never met to interact.
Opposite of the original timeline anakin would likely defend the younglings from the sith onslaught it is unknown if he survived the attack his body disappeared all that remained was his lightsaber 😉🤔
@@shaquantucker7463 yes, but it did not have the battle in the jedi temple itself transport through time. As in, the entire main hallway is quiet one second then a second later there is a battle going on as if it sounded like it was going on for hours now, and the jedi of this time have to quickly decide if they want to act and help or not. Then they can discuss with the old jedi should they choose to help them win and maybe the beliefs dont allign anymore so then they fight. He focused on the sith army and palpatine. I want all aspects of this sort of event to be talked about.
There's only one issue with the story that I saw. Obi-Wan Kenobi wouldn't kill a defenseless Anakin even after all that happened, as that is not the way of the Jedi. At best Anakin would be imprisoned for the rest of his life in a republic solitary cell and never see the outside world ever again, at worst he would be put on trial for treason against the republic and be executed for it.
What if idea! I actually have a couple different ideas to share, the premise is essentially the same for both ideas. What if Palpatine failed to kill the Jedi that went to confront him with Mace? The other is not much different, but what if Yoda had been present when Mace confronted Palpatine? I can't remember where Yoda was when Mace confronted Palpatine, but both of these ideas are essentially asking what would have changed if another Jedi had been present when Anakin showed up to stop Mace from ending Palpatine? This also begs the question, what if Padme had been present when Mace was battling Palpatine and when Anakin showed up to save Palpatine? If any of these things had happened it could have greatly changed the outcome of those events.
What if idea. What if everyone was literally on Deathsticks. Keep the whole story the same but everyone is on deathsticks and see how that plays out. Maybe like at first everything is fine but the water supply gets poisoned by deathstix smugglers because they got pulled over by cops and happened to have the largest supply of it so they tried to get rid of it by dumping it into a pipe that just so happens to cover the planets water supply and in the middle of the uninterrupted timeline everyone slowly gets the onset of an extremely high dose of it lol (it might not even get this far but imagine “Execute order uhh.. execute order.. how many orders did I make…? What was I talking about? Lol)
Your not wrong I mean anakin would really be depressed and would be broken and ik for a fact it took all of obi wan to do it obi wan couldn’t kill anakin but the brokenness that order 66 left could not be ignored but you should do what if palpation never became emperor like everything works out expect him being emperor
Hey, I'd just like to point out that Mace would never have been able to see the temple burning from where he was when he came to. The Jedi Temple, like all the visible structures seen across Coruscant in the films, is located FAR above the surface of the planet. Don't forget that what you see in the films is merely the topmost level of a planet covered by cities built atop older cities built atop even older cities, over millennia. The actual surface of Coruscant lies many miles below the visible "surface" of the cityscape, and is thus cast in permanent darkness as no sunlight can reach it due to the miles deep canyons of durasteel and other building materials. It is also notorious for it's horrific living conditions, being rife with poverty and crime; also, the fact that the jedi, despite being headquartered on the same planet, rarely ever venture into the Coruscant undercity would surely make it unlikely that the area's inhabitants would be so kind as to help a complete stranger, especially one dressed like a jedi knight, due to a combination of 'every man for himself' survival instinct and resentment. Resentment towards the hypocrites of the Jedi Order who claim to be keepers of the peace, yet can't be bothered to help the people who need it the most on the very planet in which they hole themselves up in their great temple, basking in the glorious sunlight, miles above the planet's surface, while the vast majority of the populace suffers, starves and dies in the pitch darkness of the Coruscant underworld. That is the harsh reality of life on Coruscant. The gleaming spires of the Coruscant cityscape are primarily inhabited by the wealthy and the priveleged of galactic society; the vast majority of Coruscantis live far below that, in horrible conditions full of rampant poverty and violent crime, and with nightmarish creatures prowling the darkness preying upon the weak and vulnerable, with the conditions only getting worse and worse as you venture ever lower. Hell truly is the only way to describe the reality of Coruscant's undercity. And even that description is almost being too generous.
Tragic to the core this story was. I enjoyed the darkness of Order 66 and what happened to the Jedi. I was sadden in the end that Obi-Wan was the one to kill Anakin. Not surprised the kids would not join the order
Okay I like this one I do wish you a lot longer I like to plot twist the story hope you will make a part 2 to this one keep up the good work and May the force be with you
>Reva isn't a fan favorite character its less that people dislike her, and more they really dislike how she was written. As you've demonstrated, you can easily make this character work with a bit of competent writing. As tragic and depressing as this story is, you've done it in a way meeting with your usual quality, which is to say stellar and enjoyable. Please keep up the good work.
The ending is very dark and tragic with Obi wan killing Anakin the way he did, but the ending explanation that Anakin could not live with himself and the detail of Anakin accepting the death and even mouthing “thank you” to Kenobi as his last words makes it a very artistically tasteful. I personally prefer darker or bittersweet endings. A happy ending would not have made sense following order 66
-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies?(In the same vain of the Darth JarJar fic you did.) -What if The Rule of Two was abolished after the Clone Wars? -What if the Sith Empire returned during the Galactic Civil War instead of the Clone Wars? -What if Vader lived at the end of RotJ, not redeemed and in charge of the Imperial Remnant? -What if Anakin saved Mace Windu and stayed in the light during Order 66? -What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy? -What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic? -What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious? -What if Vader,Thrawn and Several Imperials started an Imperial Rebellion separate from the Rebels,which really took off around the DS1 destruction? -What if Vader never burned on Mustafar? -What if Grevious was a Republic General but still hated the Jedi? -What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 and later trained the Skywalker Twins? -What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc, basically replacing Vader?
That would be so cool vitiate returning around the prequels I wonder what the Jedi think of him and how would sidious react or maybe return during the originals I wonder what Vader would think of him
Pente Patrol Star Wars. Could you please do a Dark Side version of What If Anakin had a Sister. Where Darth Plagueis went to get the Twins instead of Darth Sidious & got a hold of them. Trained them in secret so Palpatine and Maul didn't know that they were being trained & then faked his death just before Palpatine's Election to Chancellor of the Republic?
This was a dark story, but I do disagree with anakin dueling both masters while being fired upon by clones. Masters Yoda and Windu were very clever and would've done one of two things... they would've forced pushed (knocked out) the clones or would've pulled anakin into the path of blaster fire. The clones were good but in close quarters, not THAT good. That and there's no way in hell anakin would let them join him in a duel... he was too proud and too arrogant to let anyone but him take the glory of defeating both of them.
I have two what if’s for you. If you could use them awesome if not understandable 1. What if Palpatine was not deformed. During the duel with mace (mace blocks it against the wall or something) 2. What if Dooku and Mace swapped roles. Why does this work. Mace taps into the darkside sometimes. Basically Mace is the apprentice of Palpatine after maul. Dooku is the MOTO
Obi-Wan killing Anakin WAS essential . As a reverted Jedi again he would have been unstable , more so than originally , so FAR too much of a risk . Plus he had already ventured deeply into the Path of the Sith way . And was Guilty of , basically ,Theolocide . Couldn't be permitted to Exist .
Mace Windu did survive. Samuel L. Jackson talks about his character's return as Jedi Master Mace Windu in the Mandalorian S3, And book of boba fett S2.
Subscribe and Share
What if anakin fell in love with duchess satine
What if anakin fell in love with ahsoka
What if anakin fell in love with serra keto
What if Satele shan trained anakin
is the next video what if thrawn was a sith
Master Windu's survival would cause many problems for the Empire. He would definitely have been a thorn.
Yeah in canon I don't think he's still alive
@@tadhggoreyoneill13666 well in canon (before disney) Lucas sort of loosely entertained the idea of Mace being alive. Never confirmed it. But he also never hated the idea when fans speculated it. But in disney canon (not my canon) hes dead. But Starwars theory is doing a fanfilm about it which ill definitely consider as my headcanon.
@@coreymckee4844 and besides bringing him back undermines what Anakin did and the weight of his actions
@@tadhggoreyoneill13666 thats fair. I just like to imagine how things would be different if Mace survived. In some ways, deep deep down i kinda like to imagine he survived in some way. This video is a great take on Maces survival. Probably my favorite "what if mace survived" fanfic yet.
@@tadhggoreyoneill13666 I disagree mace could have done what Yoda did an went into hiding so what happened would always have happened
"trying to be a rock for someone who just lost a mountain" is an amazingly written line.
This has to be the first time I have heard a "anakin came back from the dark side...." and he actually faced justice and wasn't given a free pass and a "water under the bridge" outcome. Also having Mace NOT survive to the end even though this was about him, was another first. Over all this is one of the better What if alternate realities Ive seen.
I know right? Everyone is so forgiving of Anakin and Vader because "there is still good in him". Bitch, he murdered children and then countless others, he deserves to die even if he turns back.
That betrayal at the end really hit me in the feels, for a moment there I completely forgot Obi Wan’s main objective was to kill Anakin
if you think about it the Jedi betray Anakin a lot so why not betray him some more, just shows how that in a way they are more of a slow evil.
In my view it's the Jedi who are evil
@@aaronquinn2449uh what? Most of the Jedi looked up to Anakin and respected him. The younglings that Anakin murdered probably looked up to and admired him. And then Anakin the crybaby goes into the temple killing priests, children, and teenagers. Most of the Jedi order didn’t do anything wrong to Anakin. Anakins actions were unacceptable
This, Anakin's problems are because of his own personal issues. Obi-Wan might of needed to at least(Well before the purge started) tried to push Anakin to speak up more but that doesn't mean the Jedi deserve to be slaughtered enmasse. Anakin's an adult and he should of at least thought "What would mother think of me doing this." What would Obi-Wan think of me doing this.
He fucked up and thats the tragedy.
@@ChrisBear1989 bro, the whole jedi code is "fuck emotions. you're supposed to serve the galaxy as an unfeeling warrior." hell, he went to get help about nightmares of his loved ones dying and was basically told "shut up you whiny baby, death is a good thing" rather than being given actual help processing it. anakin isn't the only one to blame when the people who were failing their own code were making him worse.
Well I could imagine Luke and Leia wanting to become jedi... but I understand why they wouldn't be permitted to... they would have to deal with the animosity of the other jedi both in training and not. Great story!
they should reconsider. This is why Anakin was turned to the dark side. Too much caution and mistrust of Anakin was the reason why Anakin could not fully devote hinself to the order. If the order fully handled properly Anakin in the beginning, Palpatine would not have that much influence on Anakin.
As you pointed out this was a rather dark story, but it was presented very well and tastefully all things considered. As dark as the ending was, I understand why you ended it the way you did and I like all of the twists the story took. Well done with this story.
I don’t know why I scrolled the comments before watching, but thanks for not spoiling
What if Anakin stayed with his Troops on Umbara?
What if Rex reminded Anakin of Krells Troop losses?
how would anakin finding out about that even matter
Anakin: I did this to save my wife
Kenobi: She’s fine!
Anakin: Wait, what!?
The Star Wars franchise really needs to consider giving the beloved Samuel & fictional Mace another chance since the best characters don’t really die so easily. He’d be the perfect Jedi to’ve survived the purge. Mace grows on me the longer he’s been gone & ignored unlike the others, even as Force Ghosts. And Samuel contributed by insisting to have a purple blade in Episode II. He’s been pivotal. Have to honor him properly.
Man! That would be amazing if Mace came back. I mean if Maul and Boba Fett can do it, why not Mace??
@@gmann1968 because all they care about is money
But imagine how much money they can get from a mace series
I think they think that shows like book of boba fett will earn more money than mace windu show because boba is more of a fan favourite
Mace is too OP which is why he gets the lamest death 😒
Get him his own series!
32:50
Windu: Round two, mothafucka.
Adding reva was a touch of genius and added to the story, kudos for the wonderful idea, the force is with you
What if Dooku changed Order 66 to spare the Jedi that were not Generals?
Creative I like
Yes
There's an old saying, "The enemy of my enemy is my friend." That would make sense to Dooku if he knew Sidious will betray him in the end, and he'd have just one chance to do the right thing after all he did before and during the Clone Wars.
Mace couldn't believe that Skywalker was capable of it but refused to see that pushing young Skywalker away only put him on this path.
Killing kids tho. (Sigh)Yeah.... Now Anikan has to die.
@@michaelsmith622 no excuses for the youngling massacre but I understand the Jedi Order wasn't blameless in how he turned out. They tried to snuff emotions out of him despite seeing it fail time after time. Told him they didn't trust him for year all while using him. They had it coming
@@avarycepierce6296 Not the kids. Their innocent.
@@michaelsmith622 only until they commit their first war crime
@@avarycepierce6296 The Jedi jade a good deal of fault with them. That's still no excuse whatsoever for Anakin's actions.
Dammit Anakin you just had to break Mace Windu's trust just after you gained it.
What if ideas:
1. What if Count Dooku survived and took control of the Galactic Empire
2. What if Captain Phasma became the Supreme leader of the First Order
3. What if Abeloth broke free from her prison during the Clone Wars
4. What if General Grievous joined the Republic
5. What if the Yuuzhan Vong won
I would watch all of these 💯
30:17 the best line ever 🤣💀
“Cuz she ain’t no snitch” LMAOOO IM DEAAAAD
What if the Jedi had successfully defended the temple?
I remember hearing that several Jedi sensed that there was something wrong but didn't seal the temple because they believed Anakin to still be on their side.
It would be hard to do that considering nobody present could stop anakin or the temple guards
The temple can be defended better, especially the Jedi are prepared, the Grand Inquisitor is taken down quickly, and Cin Drallig & Shaak Ti manage to stay alive and coordinate on. They also need to somehow take Anakin out of the fight. But unless someone manages to take down Sidious & rescind Order 66, they won't hold out longer than in canon - maybe until the sunrise, but that's it.
There are just too many clones, in comparison to the Jedi, and they can just start bombing the temple from the star destroyers & call for more clones if the resistance is too stiff. In Legends there were non-Jedi security force on the temple as well, but I don't know if that's canon anymore.
It's why similar scenarios from this channel end with the successful evacuation. The victory conditions here are escape and survival, not holding the temple.
I love these so much dude. Well done. It reminds me of what me and my friends used to do, making our own Star Wars stories as kids. The shame and credit to you is your stories are better than Revenge of the Sith.
I actually really liked this story. I don't like how so many of these what ifs having Anakin just be forgiven by everyone after murdering so many people in cold blood. I think that it makes sense that he would have to face the consequences of his terrible actions.
WOW! Excellent storytelling. This was so emotional, especially how you worked in Reva from the Obi Wan series! Thank you for this🙏🏽. I love Star Wars and reimagined stories such as this makes me fall in love with Star Wars all over again 💚. May the force be with you 🙏🏽
Trying to ne a Rock, for someone who just lost a Mountain.
Damn. Absolutely beautiful, and it truly shows the weight of the situation.
Worth the thumbs up I'm about to give this video, on top of the scene between Oni Wan and Reva. Tears Kid, and I ain't ashamed to say it.
Well done. Well done indeed.
27:25 wouldn’t be easy to move on, wouldn’t be easy to forget what happened.. but what could be changed is the present & that could affect the future ❤
Keep it real man, this is the kind of theme I love Star Wars stories for, you capture the heart & tone of it perfectly each time! ☺️
As sad as it is, it is kinda poetic that regardless Anakin must make some sort of sacrifice for the rest of the galaxy
She asked why nonone was here.
She asked why no one protected them.
That had to be such a heartbreaking moment.
If I were Plageius or Palpatine, I'd rather just end the Rule of 2. And restore multiple Sith Lords at a time. Infighting may be inevitable, but atleast if one Sith Lord Dies. The Other Sith will live to avenge their fallen Sith Comrades.
Can Disney please make either an animated series or individual movies/series around Star Wars alternate history? This story was incredible and I would love to see it play out on screen. I can see it being hugely popular amongst the wider Star Wars community seeing as how we would get to see how differently changing just a small event effects the entire timeline of the galaxy.
A Star Wars What-If show. Like Disney had Marvel do.
Be funnier if Windu chopped Anakin in half like Obiwan and made sure to inform him he would never sit on the council after the fact
"cause she aint no snitch" got me wheezing 😂30:24
I still love the grand inquisitor as your opening😂. You've taken one simple phrase from the TV show, and now it feels like some big inside joke between you and all of us😂
i’m so excited for this one. it also makes me wonder what if what if anakin and mace grew up together. . or also what if anakin went with obi wan to utapau
Oh man, you're writing skills are stellar. I'm crying again. Keep it up man. I still have one story I found that holds my interest rn. Hopefully I'm not gonna be crying a third time, but if I am then so be it. You're stories are worth it.
Oh and thank you. This has inspired a bit of inspiration for a table top story I've been working on. Thank you.
I love how the first 20 minutes is just rambling about the anaking killing younglings meme hahaha
The real crime disney made was not making a show like what if for marvel but for star wars
Nahh that's why y'all got me and Elseworlds lol
A tragic story indeed but a surprisingly realistic outcome in the end, Anakin was too far gone after order 66 and at least Windu saved some younglings. Honestly I loved every second of it !
Here an idea, what if Padme was force sensitive ? Since we know that a certain Sith Lord was a senator on Naboo at this time, what would have happened to the young Naberrie/Amidala if she was found by Palpatine ?
Palpatine: Release The Murder Hobo!
Mace has to realize that Luke is not his father. Obi-Wan and Yoda knew it. Holding Luke back is just asking for trouble. Have Mace take Luke under his wing. They both are not your typical Jedi. It would fit.
Wanting to kerp the audio so i can repeat listen to this offline. Wow this was tragic.
I’m not crying, there’s just rain in my room. 🌧🌧🌧
I wish yoda would’ve somehow sometime fought anakin while he was evil. Preferably right before his suit
😂😂😂 “ Padme didn’t say anything, ‘cause she ain’t no snitch “ 😂😂😂 that was great!
I've got freaking goosebumps... I think that's enough feedback ;D
this should be a movie it's good to look at different outcome events exploring alternatives is fun .
may the videos continue and
be wirh us always .
👍👍
If Mace survived, Anakin would have gotten his ass KICKED up and down Coruscant. It would have been the end of the Sith
What if Anakin fell in love with Dutchess Satine and what if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Alallua Secura
Bastilla Shan did have an holocron but I think a what if video about Anakin falling in love with Aayla Secura was already done (I might confuse her with another Jedi master however).
@@wargamesmaster they said with duchess satine not Aylah sacura
U just want to see conflict between obi wan and anakin 😂
@@jackdonaldson9224 context fix: they said trained by secura, not dating
No problem
@@ZeKermet no they didn't they said "but I think a what if video about anakin falling in love with aayla secura was already done"
What if the sack of the jedi temple on curasaunt from the old republic wars was launched into the future, and the battle took place during rots? As in the battle had just begun in the temple but the fighters (jedi/sith) all went through time. I feel like these kinds of scenarios would be cool because it would be an interesting way to get characters that never met to interact.
There is a video on what if the ancient sith returned during the clone wars.
Opposite of the original timeline anakin would likely defend the younglings from the sith onslaught it is unknown if he survived the attack his body disappeared all that remained was his lightsaber 😉🤔
@@shaquantucker7463 yes, but it did not have the battle in the jedi temple itself transport through time. As in, the entire main hallway is quiet one second then a second later there is a battle going on as if it sounded like it was going on for hours now, and the jedi of this time have to quickly decide if they want to act and help or not. Then they can discuss with the old jedi should they choose to help them win and maybe the beliefs dont allign anymore so then they fight. He focused on the sith army and palpatine. I want all aspects of this sort of event to be talked about.
There's only one issue with the story that I saw. Obi-Wan Kenobi wouldn't kill a defenseless Anakin even after all that happened, as that is not the way of the Jedi. At best Anakin would be imprisoned for the rest of his life in a republic solitary cell and never see the outside world ever again, at worst he would be put on trial for treason against the republic and be executed for it.
What if idea! I actually have a couple different ideas to share, the premise is essentially the same for both ideas. What if Palpatine failed to kill the Jedi that went to confront him with Mace? The other is not much different, but what if Yoda had been present when Mace confronted Palpatine? I can't remember where Yoda was when Mace confronted Palpatine, but both of these ideas are essentially asking what would have changed if another Jedi had been present when Anakin showed up to stop Mace from ending Palpatine? This also begs the question, what if Padme had been present when Mace was battling Palpatine and when Anakin showed up to save Palpatine? If any of these things had happened it could have greatly changed the outcome of those events.
Good relations with the wookies, I have.
What if idea. What if everyone was literally on Deathsticks. Keep the whole story the same but everyone is on deathsticks and see how that plays out. Maybe like at first everything is fine but the water supply gets poisoned by deathstix smugglers because they got pulled over by cops and happened to have the largest supply of it so they tried to get rid of it by dumping it into a pipe that just so happens to cover the planets water supply and in the middle of the uninterrupted timeline everyone slowly gets the onset of an extremely high dose of it lol (it might not even get this far but imagine “Execute order uhh.. execute order.. how many orders did I make…? What was I talking about? Lol)
Technically this: th-cam.com/video/vC3uWPpjqss/w-d-xo.html
Your not wrong I mean anakin would really be depressed and would be broken and ik for a fact it took all of obi wan to do it obi wan couldn’t kill anakin but the brokenness that order 66 left could not be ignored but you should do what if palpation never became emperor like everything works out expect him being emperor
I really enjoyed this one, and I'm glad Anakin didn't get to walk away free again.
That was brilliant, got heavy near the end, I liked the twists
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars Most welcome Darth Pente 😎
no not best Palawan DeSha sorry I don't know how to spell it
also the way Kenobi took out Anakin was perfectly poetic, I respect that
Feels unrealistic, Obi Wan couldn't even kill the hate filled Anakin on Mustafar. Now Anakin felt guilty and he killed him nonetheless
I’ve watched like 50 of your videos and I think this is my favorite
Hey, I'd just like to point out that Mace would never have been able to see the temple burning from where he was when he came to. The Jedi Temple, like all the visible structures seen across Coruscant in the films, is located FAR above the surface of the planet.
Don't forget that what you see in the films is merely the topmost level of a planet covered by cities built atop older cities built atop even older cities, over millennia.
The actual surface of Coruscant lies many miles below the visible "surface" of the cityscape, and is thus cast in permanent darkness as no sunlight can reach it due to the miles deep canyons of durasteel and other building materials.
It is also notorious for it's horrific living conditions, being rife with poverty and crime; also, the fact that the jedi, despite being headquartered on the same planet, rarely ever venture into the Coruscant undercity would surely make it unlikely that the area's inhabitants would be so kind as to help a complete stranger, especially one dressed like a jedi knight, due to a combination of 'every man for himself' survival instinct and resentment.
Resentment towards the hypocrites of the Jedi Order who claim to be keepers of the peace, yet can't be bothered to help the people who need it the most on the very planet in which they hole themselves up in their great temple, basking in the glorious sunlight, miles above the planet's surface, while the vast majority of the populace suffers, starves and dies in the pitch darkness of the Coruscant underworld.
That is the harsh reality of life on Coruscant. The gleaming spires of the Coruscant cityscape are primarily inhabited by the wealthy and the priveleged of galactic society; the vast majority of Coruscantis live far below that, in horrible conditions full of rampant poverty and violent crime, and with nightmarish creatures prowling the darkness preying upon the weak and vulnerable, with the conditions only getting worse and worse as you venture ever lower.
Hell truly is the only way to describe the reality of Coruscant's undercity. And even that description is almost being too generous.
im helping dad at work and im on free time and man this is more heartbreaking than anything i could imagine in the shower
Tragic to the core this story was. I enjoyed the darkness of Order 66 and what happened to the Jedi. I was sadden in the end that Obi-Wan was the one to kill Anakin. Not surprised the kids would not join the order
This made me cry.... Great job man
Awesome What if as always!
You're the king of SW What If's bro
Also yes this definitely brings out the Feels
Thank you so much!
Okay I like this one I do wish you a lot longer I like to plot twist the story hope you will make a part 2 to this one keep up the good work and May the force be with you
Great story. I kinda guessed what was gonna happen after the nod. Enjoy all of your videos. Keep up the great work. Can't wait for the next one.
Thank you so much!
TH-camr Star Wars Theory said he became the model for Supreme Chancellor Snoke.
Anakin killing Yoda and mace windu, idk it seems unreal 😂
Damm, I guess you could say he went out the windu
36:21 i think Anakin is going to die again
I was right god dammit why can't he stop dying
This so cool thanks for the video
>Reva isn't a fan favorite character
its less that people dislike her, and more they really dislike how she was written.
As you've demonstrated, you can easily make this character work with a bit of competent writing.
As tragic and depressing as this story is, you've done it in a way meeting with your usual quality, which is to say stellar and enjoyable.
Please keep up the good work.
Man just imagine that the star wars franchise do an actual tv series of "what if" story just like marvel
The ending is very dark and tragic with Obi wan killing Anakin the way he did, but the ending explanation that Anakin could not live with himself and the detail of Anakin accepting the death and even mouthing “thank you” to Kenobi as his last words makes it a very artistically tasteful. I personally prefer darker or bittersweet endings. A happy ending would not have made sense following order 66
-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies?(In the same vain of the Darth JarJar fic you did.)
-What if The Rule of Two was abolished after the Clone Wars?
-What if the Sith Empire returned during the Galactic Civil War instead of the Clone Wars?
-What if Vader lived at the end of RotJ, not redeemed and in charge of the Imperial Remnant?
-What if Anakin saved Mace Windu and stayed in the light during Order 66?
-What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy?
-What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic?
-What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious?
-What if Vader,Thrawn and Several Imperials started an Imperial Rebellion separate from the Rebels,which really took off around the DS1 destruction?
-What if Vader never burned on Mustafar?
-What if Grevious was a Republic General but still hated the Jedi?
-What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 and later trained the Skywalker Twins?
-What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc, basically replacing Vader?
That would be so cool vitiate returning around the prequels I wonder what the Jedi think of him and how would sidious react or maybe return during the originals I wonder what Vader would think of him
Pente Patrol Star Wars. Could you please do a Dark Side version of What If Anakin had a Sister. Where Darth Plagueis went to get the Twins instead of Darth Sidious & got a hold of them. Trained them in secret so Palpatine and Maul didn't know that they were being trained & then faked his death just before Palpatine's Election to Chancellor of the Republic?
Dun DUn DUN!!!
Palpatine do it do it do it
At 25:43 ik it’s supposed to be sad but when he called homie kenobi a failure and then quickly moved on I couldn’t stop laughing
This was a dark story, but I do disagree with anakin dueling both masters while being fired upon by clones. Masters Yoda and Windu were very clever and would've done one of two things... they would've forced pushed (knocked out) the clones or would've pulled anakin into the path of blaster fire. The clones were good but in close quarters, not THAT good. That and there's no way in hell anakin would let them join him in a duel... he was too proud and too arrogant to let anyone but him take the glory of defeating both of them.
Windu should have survived and just like Yoda and Kenobi go into hiding awaiting for the return of the Jedi.
At first after I saw episode three I thought Mace Windu did survived. Maybe I was thinking of someone else.
I mean, if Maul survived being chopped in half and Reva a saber to the chest why couldn’t he have survived?
Not nearly as dark as the Canon version, no need for a rebellion and no death star to worry about.
Mace Windu never knew how to choose his battles. He hated Palpatine and failed to end the Sith and picked weak Jedi to arrest him.
It should have been him Yoda and Cin Drawling.
be alive as a ghost as he's talked to Rey in the final battle
This is the saddest what if I ever listened to ...thank you great job
Dude obi go hardcore guess he saw the trilogy
This is really good! You really tell this story with conviction.
Keep doing these, they are all good!
He might’ve actually survived in the canon but just gone onto hiding
You did well explaining Order 66. It was what its supposed to be explained as: genocide is always a tragedy. It brought tears to my eyes. WELL DONE!
I'm so happy Anakin won. He is the chosen one after all I would've been so sad if Yoda and windu beat him
Epic. Wendo is alive and we all know it lol. This one but hard too. Another epic what if. Your work and dedication to star wars is wonderful.
I have two what if’s for you. If you could use them awesome if not understandable
1. What if Palpatine was not deformed.
During the duel with mace (mace blocks it against the wall or something)
2. What if Dooku and Mace swapped roles. Why does this work. Mace taps into the darkside sometimes.
Basically Mace is the apprentice of Palpatine after maul. Dooku is the MOTO
What if Mace Windu survived?
'proceeds to die'
Need one about padme hooking up with Obi-Wan and leaving anakin lol
You did well, thank you. There is balance in your story.
Mace closed her eyes 😂
My reaction is a really emotional "oof"
Pente Patrol has a talent with these videos. Always unexpected things happen and it’s some amazing content.
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars your Ehat If Videos are always great and Continue so 😆👍
@@DrystanNG Will do!
“But she wasn’t, she was dead” he said nonchalantly
What if Mundi never brought up the droid attack on the Wookies?
Obi-Wan killing Anakin WAS essential . As a reverted Jedi again he would have been unstable , more so than originally , so FAR too much of a risk .
Plus he had already ventured deeply into the Path of the Sith way . And was Guilty of , basically ,Theolocide . Couldn't be permitted to Exist .
By not training the twins, he's giving in to fear. The kind of fear that will seep into the order and cause a violent split in a few generations.
The end was heartbreaking. Great story.
Mace Windu did survive. Samuel L. Jackson talks about his character's return as Jedi Master Mace Windu in the Mandalorian S3, And book of boba fett S2.
Yeah I did