Empowering Truth: Experts and Allies Debunk Danielle Smith's Anti-Trans Policy
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- Let’s talk about the facts.
Not conspiracies, not false myths spread on social media - facts.
Danielle Smith’s policy targeting trans and gender-diverse youth is an attack on a vulnerable group of youth and on thousands of Albertans. It is a massive overstep into private health care decisions. And it is an attack on the fundamental education rights of kids in our province.
But don’t take it from me: listen to the experts and allies in our video. Listen to the people with real, lived experiences.
Share this video and information with your friends and help combat the misinformation being spread by the Alberta government.
Sign our petition and tell Danielle Smith to stop pursuing these proposed changes.
Tell her that Albertans believe all human rights must be protected.
www.albertandp...
#ableg #alberta #albertapolitics #transrights #humanrights #yyc #yeg - บันเทิง
How about copy this link and send it to your MLA ? Mine is Miles McDougall and I am going to do just that once I sign the petition :)
Friday 6:15pm Feb 16th. This is an excellent video! It provides the truth from experts behind the misinformation about trans youth and their needs as presented by Danielle Smith. Albertans need to see this so I hope it will be shared widely. I also hope Albertans will address their views directly to Danielle Smith by telephoning her office and/or emailing her. Well done and thank you to the NDP for this.
Why is this video trying to misinform about female trans athletes all we have to do is observe the Lia Thomas story. Female trans athletes would destroy biological women in many sports
I'm genuinely interested in the chemical or biological data behind gender dysphoria. Basically, why do trans kids feel like they're the wrong sex. I may use the wrong terms here, but I'm trying to learn.
It's a medical condition at the intersection of neurology and sex development.
There is also this, communities where sex shifts spontaneously in significant populations at puberty -- there are good links to the research here: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%BCevedoce#:~:text=The%20first%20scientific%20investigations%20of,at%20the%20onset%20of%20puberty.
No you're not (genuinely interested). Because if you WERE you'd do a google search. There is TONS of info on the science of gender vs sex traits and TONS of info on all the MANY variances of chromosomes.
People say stuff like you are saying but then ignore everything out there.
You legitimately interested? Google 'gender variances in chromosomes'. Google 'chromosome variances and sex traits'. Google "sex vs gender'.
There is a TON of stuff that's been written about this. Check your local library
I don't know much on the biology. But when it comes to how they might feel I've got an idea:
Think of it like you are attending an event and you need to wear certain clothes. You hate those clothes, but because it's a special event you wear them. Now imagine it's like that all the time no matter where you go: school, work, with friends, even with your family. Your still stuck in the clothes that you hate even when you're not wearing any.
I think that's sorta what it's like. But I'm not trans, so take it with a grain of salt.
Thank you Rachel Notley for posting this video. More people need to educate themselves about trans issues; this video is a great first step.
I'm afraid we're likely to see horrible mistreatment of trans kids here in Alberta such as the incident in Oklahoma.
Excellent video. Nice to have a conversation with experts and people that are directly affected by these issues. Wish Danielle Smith would have just left her own opinions at home, instead of forcing her ignorance on the rest of us. This legislation doesn't represent the Alberta I know and love.
DS is doing a Good Job . 470 views in 6 hours ? PATHETIC.
@@jackpontiac52I strongly disagree that Smith is doing a gpod job. She grandstands inn a damaging way. UCP started the destruction with Kenney & Smith is worse!
@@veenamishra8950 TRUMP 2024 ! PP4PM ! Trudope and His Dopes for Jail !
HONK HONK from Cooking Lake , Alberta !
@@jackpontiac52 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@susanquinn8493 Stifle, Edith !
Great video. I thought that years of activism and fighting back for rights for the 2SLGBTIA+ community that these types of abuses of power by governments had passed. That’s why my husband and I have returned to being active again because obviously the fight is not over. We must debunk the misinformation being spouted by the UCP/TBA coalition. Please share this video and support the truth. Support Trans rights and fight for all kids in our province.
This is misinformation about female trans athletes. Lia Thomas would have destroyed female swimmers records until the Olympic organization put a stop to it.
Brilliant. If only because it allows the people affect to speak, rather than be spoken about. Thank you.
This is a discussion and decision that should be between parents and their children. The hypocrisy by libertarian Danielle Smith is shocking. Get your government out of people’s private lives.
Thats right, Decisions made by the parents. Not the school board for each child. Smith's bill does exactly this.
@@noncomplier5385It does not.
@@noncomplier5385 except she is taking away parents’ right to make decisions for their child with their child.
@@noncomplier5385 you have been misinformed. The proposed law would prohibit gender affirming care even when parents support it. It would use the power of the state to prevent a medical decision supported by parents.
@@shiftfocus1 Misinformed? You should check the polls that support this bill. lol
I am saddened that we have to be dealing with this at all. This is important information that everyone needs to know and share. Bless you for doing this.
Rachel Please protect the people the Canadian Convoy call sheep. One of them stated they can't wait to start cracking heads open. This was said on tiktok for all to see.
“Little is known about the long-term side effects of hormone or puberty blockers in children with gender dysphoria.
Although the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) advises this is a physically reversible treatment if stopped, it is not known what the psychological effects may be.
It’s also not known whether hormone blockers affect the development of the teenage brain or children’s bones. Side effects may also include hot flushes, fatigue and mood alterations.”
Psychology is very clear on this: Supporting people to live as they know is right for them and hurts no one else and is no one else's business is always psychologically healthy and beneficial for society.
Being forced to live as you are NOT is damaging.
Do you think puberty blockers are a new drug? Do you have any idea why they developed puberty blockers? Precocious Puberty - Look it up
This is a fantastic video that confronts and debunks the misinformation of this proposed policy. Great work, NDP AB!! Thank you to the community experts who lent their expertise for this.
Richard Dawkins, a world leader in evolutionary biology disproves these trans theory's.
“Richard Dawkins has over the past several years accumulated a history of making statements that use the guise of scientific discourse to demean marginalised groups, an approach antithetical to humanist values.”
Such a good video. Thank you for making it.
Thank you Rachel for the TRUTH!
Video is done well but I question the fact that only one side of the issue is being brought forward. I would like to hear the other
side from people on the street or professionals to make an informed decision.
If it's raining outside and the weather announcer says that it's raining outside, we don't need "the other side" presented.
Pin this on your homepage please. It's currently buried in your video tab.
How do we do that?
Who should choose when a kid must START transitioning?
Should it be the kid him/herself, with their under-developed brain, inability to understand risks and no grasp on long term consequences?...
The parents, who are legally responsible and liable for the kid, and who live the closest to the kid?
The teachers?
The social worker or the therapist?
The doctor?
The political regime?
The whole non-binary trans thing nowadays is a fashion. Kids buy into it because they are confused about being asked the question, because early teenage is uncomfortable and also because it has the side benefit of freaking out their parents (!). This is the equivalent of coloring our hair in the 80's, or wearing a skirt too short in the 50's.
The big issue here is NOT about preventing legit cases where transition is obviously required. The real issue is about the other 95% where, if time was allowed to do its work, the questions and discomforts would sort themselves out.
Down the road, if this social "experiment" fails, then who will care? Who will bare the consequences? Is it the doctor? The psychologist? The politicians? The teacher? Nope. These people are all protected by social laws and do not have to live with the problem they helped creating.
The one who should take the FIRST and FINAL decision about it should be the same people who bear the full and long term consequences of it down the road. The kids, along with the parents should be the one to decide.
And NO, do not ask my 5 year old kid if he prefers to use the boy or the girl's bathroom... That question alone is the first step in this mess. Let my kid grow normally. And if you think he/she is not well with his/her sex, bring it up to me. I am the parent.
Ignorance of the subject in this day and age is absolutely abbhorent. As a Parent, you should educate yourself.
You obviously know a lot... I love your argument...
This is so well done. Thank you for presenting these facts so clearly in the face of the UCP's disinformation campaign.
that's misinformation about female trans athletes there's no way they should be allowed in competition with biological females
It would have been more meaningful and effective to have gender dysphoric and non-gender dysphoric people, in a more even distribution, speak to these issues. The reality is that a preacher preaching to the converted (no pun intended) does not gain support from those outside the church. Unfortunately, this video comes across as just one more demonstration of a politician trying to gain votes, no better than the other political leaders including the one she tries to demonize. Hopefully, one day issues like this can gain awareness and understanding outside of politics with its ulterior motives and agendas.
Exactly there's so much disinformation on there about female trans athletes, they would destroy biological female athletes.
Didn't watch it did you? There were many people involved in this video
A woman who wants to play sports is a false comparison with trans women - read males- who want to compete against women. You can’t just spout things off, they have to be based on reality.
Thanks for producing this excellent video!
Excellent video. Thank you!!!!!
Stand with Trans people!
No, majority of Albertan's support this bill. Hence why you lost the election. Also, arresting a reporter because they were asking you questions you didn't like isn't very "democratic".
Ummmm….what???
What a load of crap. Nobody asked for or wants this garbage. It's an unnecessary, discriminatory, and just generally hateful piece of legislation.
Tyranny of the majority. The very reason we even have human rights laws.
So this is a majority rules scenario for you?
So you feel that Canadian Constitutional laws to protect human rights are wrong eh? Feeling that from now on human rights should be only if people want to via majority? That is literally the ideology of what we fought against in WW2. But here we are, fighting it again.
Thanks for putting some truth out there, I only hope people are paying attention.
Sorry Rachel… You could have 1000 so called “experts”, but nothing trumps the common sense policies Smith is putting forward. If you’re having to defend your position by calling in “experts”, you’ve already lost the argument.
There's nothing "common sense" about Smith's policies. Her's is a solution in search of a problem.
@@heronimousbrapson863 I think the polls surrounding trans gender topics in Alberta would tell a different story.
@@ericwolf2641 Polls express popular opinions, not necessarily the truth. A majority of people could express a belief that has no basis in fact.
@@heronimousbrapson863 Fair enough - but I'm not seeing any "facts" in this video, merely anecdotal opinions from random people. Please don't conflate their opinions as facts.
@@ericwolf2641 The doctor being interviewed was expressing non-professional, anecdotal opinion? In any case, we haven't seen the full impact of these transphobic policies (here in Alberta, anyway).
Wish we could share this on fb but gosh the feds won’t allow it.
This video can be shared on FB. I just posted it there.
That only applies to news. And it’s Facebook that’s chosen to ban news, rather than pay for it, not the feds.
Why? To show a greater audience how unbearable Rachel Snotley is. good idea.
You mean, FB won't allow it.