Critical Role RPG Show Q&A and Battle Royale!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ค. 2016
- Catch Critical Role live Thursdays at 7PM PT on Twitch: goo.gl/D9fsrS
Listen to the Critical Role podcast: goo.gl/jVwPBr
Matt Mercer leads Ashley Johnson, Taliesin Jaffe, Marisha Ray, and Liam O'Brien in answering some questions, then they have a Battle Royale in this special Critical Role!
Go to www.lootcrate.com/criticalrole and enter code CRITICALROLE to save $3 on any new subscription
For more RPGs we love, go to bit.ly/GS_RPG
Visit us on geekandsundry.com
Subscribe to Geek and Sundry: goo.gl/B62jl
Join our community at: geekandsundry.com/community
Twitter: / geekandsundry
Facebook: / geekandsundry
Instagram: / geekandsundry
Google+: plus.google.com/+GeekandSundry/ - บันเทิง
Ashley going "I'm a monstah!" is the cutest thing
46:30
"It would be really really interesting with this group though if someone someone did have to re-roll a character. That'd be an interesting dynamic."
"I feel like it'd be like transferring high schools and you're like the new kid in class."
*thinks back to Taryon Darington's hazing*
Yeah. That actually checks out.
Taryon doesn’t show up for a while, so if you’ve just started the series, it’s looking forward to the taryon hazing.
I love watching this during the season 2 of Critical Role. Matt: "Maybe we'd start later in another part of the world." Check. Marisha: "I'd love to play Grog. Just break necks and not care about shit." Check and check. Liam: "I'd love to play Keyleth, just to get access to the whole array of spells." Double-check. These things have been brewing for so long, I love it.
Adding to that, in an earlier Q&A Laura mentioned wanting to play a Tiefling!
Max Kay she did actually play an early version of jester in a one shot
When Laura says she wants to play a Tiefling Taliesin responds with "yeah, that would be really cool"
Coming to this a couple months later, watching them talk about pc death and rerolling a character after seeing the whole Mollymauk arc.
Yaski spoiler alert (kind of)
"Are we allowed to loot the body?"
says the cleric.
You need to remember that pike slit an enemies throat with the jagged edge of her mace early on in the campaign. Looting the body is fucking tame for pike.
Remember the Roman Catholic Crusaders, Inquisition and Conquistadors weren't entirely but included Clerics and Paladins.
I'm currently playing a death cleric
I would literally loot the body.
I see nothing wrong with Ash's question. They can't use their stuff anymore, and you don't want your foes to use it, so...
fighting stealthy Liam is like playing battleships.
Fireball to D-5!
(from shadows) Miss!
Why did I laugh so much at this?
From the shadows: “... naaashty Druiiiiid...”
Evasion
I really thought that was her plan with Call Lightning...
**Vax disappears**
*Keyleth:* Every. Damn. Time.
d y i n g
17:36 Best TPK I've had? It must be the time my group was doing a space marines themed game and we had a crazed wizard who loved his random chance spell where the outcome was based on the percentage roll. So after crashing our ship, he casts the spell and rolled the outcome of "next thing the caster says to true." After much thought, he says, "we're on a new ship and in the spot we were at before we started to crash." Everything would have been fine if it wasn't for another party member saying, "Well he didn't say it had to be a space ship."
why would you do that? you monster XD
Mine has got to be accidentally nuking the party as sorcerer using a cure wounds scroll after half an hour in starting a new campaign XD
In that universe there were no other ships, it is not real life would have saved you guys :D
It’s wild watching this at the very start of 2023 and seeing how so many of their half hopes and “wouldn’t it be cool if…” have grown over the years.
I like how Overwatch was so young at the time this came out, that Matt could just say "It's High Noon" without anyone being like "oh God".
What do you mean?
@@Noah-wx7fm Many fans fell into the "hey Matt, say the thing" trend. It became a meme, and now he tends to avoid it.
@@kaitoudark1 ah, that makes total sense. I've heard of that type of thing before
I like how his characters name was still McCree lol.
@@michaelvatore6007 i don't
God, this QnA is full of so many forshadowings for Campaign two. [From min 55]
Liam talking about wanting to be a spell caster, Marisha talking about wanting to be a reckless person, punching shit.
I love it!
Worgak "murder hobo" hello caleb
Monk and wizard fit them perfectly
Also known as one of the more intense games of hide-and-seek Vox Machina ever played.
“I wanna give no fucks and kill shit”
Beau.
“I wanna do long range spells and casting.”
Caleb
“ I’ve never played a cleric before.”
Caduceus.
“I’m a barbarian too!!!”
Yasha.
3:31:43
Marisha: *screaming in frustration*
Liam: *calmly and quietly* "In another life, somewhere, i'm very much in love with you"
But not this day.
Spoilers..
The Q&A part has already been covered by others, so: battle timestamps
1:48:27 Break ends
1:49:40 Battle starts
1:55:15 Vax vanishes
2:00:00 Keyleth and lava: the beginning of a love story
2:12:00 Vax hides #2
2:13:10 Concentration vs chat
2:22:00 Cute Taliesin + Marisha hug
2:24:30 Vax hides #3
2:25:40 Goodbye chat
2:28:40 Gun breaks
2:30:30 Monstah !
2:34:00 Vax hides #4
2:35:19 Lava spreads
2:36:39 Tremor sense vs Vax's stealth
2:41:35 Pike strikes again
2:46:20 Vax hides #5
2:55:50 Character down #1
3:03:58 Death #1
3:07:30 Vax hides #6
3:23:50 Pike brings on the plague
3:28:40 Vax hides #7 (I'm fairly sure I lost count at this point)
3:30:20 Keyleth tries to smoke out Vax
3:38:15 Vax hides #8
3:39:50 Getting confused about concentration again
3:46:50 Camping
3:55:20 Stealth goggles ?
3:58:06 Hi Simon !
4:01:08 Vax vs lava
4:02:20 Character down #2
4:04:00 Death #2
4:07:33 Harm
4:11:43 Classic Keyleth move
4:19:10 Last move
4:20:12 HDYWTDT
Just did the entire Q&A one time to do this too
Boost!
Percy: I'm going to shot people.
Pike: I'm going to pray to Sarenrae for the ability to stike down my opponents.
Keyleth: I'm going to use the power of the elemets to decimate everything.
Vax: Imma just play some Hide'n'Seek.
Matt: Rouges, man.
Everyone: GODDAMMIT VAX!
I hate those damn rouges, so french and red, I hate them so much
@@Neutral_Tired Bollocks!!! You beat me to it.
@@Neutral_Tired Damn, cheaky bastards.
"Like mistform" That pause and stare at the camera was so perfect!
PvP makes you really realize how badly you DON'T want to be against your friends.
It's worth noting that clerics don't have a huge number of offensive damage spells, especially at the lower levels. But the ones they do have, and especially their high level offensive spells really really hit hard.
But can she cast inflict wounds and healing word in the same round they are both spells ?
normally you couldn't but Mercer allows it as long as one of the spells is level 2 or below
@@ToabyToastbrot He only allows it with a feat I believe. Or maybe that changed at some point. That's at least the way it is now, after the release of his own WotC campaign guide
@@dig8634 That changed with campaign 2, you're right there. In CR1 they didn't need the feat.
@@dig8634 must have warcaster feat so thats when matt allows for double cast spells but up to lvl 2 on any secondary spell casted unless it bonus action spells its at his discretion. Was in both campaigns i think
Pike deals damage: "Sorry Percy." "This sucks!" "I don't know if I like this..."
Vax deals damage: "Hee hee hee!"
XD
"Are you camping right now?"
"Yes, because this is in-tents!"
"I'm going to give you damage for that."
LOL
Poor Percy was totally screwed. Vax can hide and the other two can heal, not to mention Keyleth has two extra HP tanks. Big rip man
Love these QA sessions! So many good insights from the players and Matt.
I'm also glad the group addresses the less savory aspects of the Critter community (i.e. the rules lawyering, the KeyKey hate, and the perceived carebear DMing). Matt is completely right, we just need to chill and enjoy the D&D ride.
At 55:58 a question was brought up and it read if there was something growing between Vex and Percy? and right after that Liam step in and said why would we need to know right now when that would ruin the experience of finding out later? I couldn't have agree more to that response. Let us enjoy the ride in finding out what happens next. Personally though I could sympathize with that person wanting to know.
Antonio Nunez yea, if something is growing between the characters let it happen. as an outside party watching though, i really do want to know what that death letter said. this feels like a book to me, and if a character gets an important letter like that in a book and i don't have the opportunity to read that letter along with them i write that character off mentally. the comparison doesn't hold up entirely of course, but you should get what i mean. if pike hadn't read it immedietly the letter would have been a great secret to add to scanlan's possible death.
Antonio Nuñez and it was true
I have a feeling all the fire spells that got thrown at Liam during this caused his idea for fire trauma for Caleb in Campaign 2
Matt says "it's high noon"
I subconsciously panic and divert mid-stride in my apartment to hug a wall
reposting q&a timestamps
06:23 - What's your weirdest DND experience?
11:37 - Ashley, what classes would the characters of 'Blindspot' be?
13:11 - Would the characters of Critical Role fight each other? What would lead to such a confrontation?
15:36 - What would the characters of Critical Role be doing if they weren't part of Vox Machina?
17:14 - What's the worst/best TPL in any game you've played?
19:14 - Who assigns or comes up with the episode titles?
20:37 - Does Vax have a death wish?
22:47 - How long did it take for character creation?
24:02 - What lead to Ashley and Travis linking their back stories?
26:20 - Is Matt aware of the technicalities of 'dimension door'?
27:37 - Anything in game that has genuinely shocked Matt?
33:05 - When are you getting "Your Fun Is Wrong" t-shirts on the Geek and Sundry website?
34:24 - Is Keyleth vegetarian?
34:36 - Do 'Blindspot' writers work with Ashley to incorporate Critical Role references or do they do it on their own?
36:24 - Will Liam ever DM a one-shot?
37:14 - What's your character's biggest fault?
40:37 - When did Matt tell Taliesin about the demon in the gun?
41:36 - Is the chat working?
41:54 - Did Scanlan get XP for destroying the gun?
42:40 - Why was Keyleth hostile towards Kima?
43:41 - Does Matt discuss game events with Marisha after the episodes?
44:25 - Why is there such polarizing anger towards Keyleth?
47:53 - How do Liam and Marisha avoid real-life awkwardness?
49:30 - Ashley, do you prefer to watch things unfold or being in the driver's seat? Also, would you convert anyone to worship Sarenrae?
51:42 - Do the Vestiges still draw their power from the deities?
52:21 - How did the guests come about? How do they join?
54:14 - Percy, does Matt shut you down when it comes to sketches and inventions?
55:57 - Something growing between Vex and Percy?
56:20 - Who is Pike in love with?
59:17 - Did you put Zahra's flying cloak in Vex's broom?
1:00:44 - What inspired Vaxleth?
1:02:22 - How much world-building have you done that we haven't seen yet?
1:04:04 - If you could pick another Critical Role character to play, who would you choose?
1:06:01 - Did Gilmore start off as a caricature or a fleshed-out character? Is he based off of a real person?
1:09:05 - Matt's thoughts on LGBT relationships in his world [not a question]
1:11:16 - Origin of the 'College of the Maestro'?
1:13:33 - What's Liam's t-shirt?
1:13:51 - Why do the twins know Abyssal?
1:14:00 - Will there be a "Vegetables of the Virgins" [sic] quest-line?
1:15:11 - Who is Pike in love with? [revisited]
1:15:51 - Who do I get my PCs to not be murderhobos?
1:19:00 - What's your character's greatest virtue?
1:21:09 - Is Vax bisexual?
1:21:25 - What challenge ratings do the dragons have after your modifications?
1:23:25 - Liam, what characters do your kids play? Would you ever introduce Vox Machina into their quest?
1:24:20 - Were there ramifications of Keyleth killing a child?
1:28:06 - What character would Matt create to play with Vox Machina?
1:28:50 - Which character dying would have the biggest impact on the group?
1:29:09 - What are the dimensions of 'the cube'?
1:29:38 - Have you ever made a terrible decision while playing or dm'ing?
Thanks :)
Thanks man
Nice
Thank you!
I wish Scanlan was here for a battle royale. He'd destroy everyone. Dominate Person + nukes.
+ Banishment + Polymorph
Also seeming would mess everyone up.
We need to see the group mvp in a battle royal. If it comes to improv and creative use of spells, Scanlan is your man! Plus he would've made it so entertaining!
Stink Cloud everyone for giggles
He would just have to survive until the lava started pouring in, then cast Resilient Sphere. Trollollololololols would ensue.
"And Percy turns to ash..."
"Oh noooooo..."
Ashley is SO adorkable. Just want to hug her.
Then she pushes Keyleth's screaming face into the lava.
@@toshomni9478 still wanna hug the monstah.
I'm worried about Pike.
Well, not exactly ABOUT her... About whoever goes up against her.
She's got a mean streak.
Well. Not exactly mean.
More like "disturbing" streak.
I love it.
She just wants to be a monster sometimes. So yeah, I feel sorry for whoever is on her bad side sometimes.
I played an 18th lvl sorcerer once (3.5). A combination of time stop & delayed blast prompted a comment from another player to say I would be a very scary sociopath...but Pike is just on a whole other level.
the anime/manga nerd in me keeps whispering, "what would happen if we gave monster Pike a Death Note?"
kunohime everyone's name gets written down at some point.
SHE'S A MONSTAH!!!!!!!!
When Matt talked about his idea of a 'soundbending' bard, I literally said "That't SO cool!!" out loud. If I didn't live alone I would've definitely gotten a few strange looks lol.
Sweet baby jeebus, that harm spell though! Pike is a monsta!
Yeeeeeee!
percy multiclassing rouge would be scary
especialy with bad news
"I smell T-R-O-U-B-L-E!!!!!!!"
Bonus points if you know the song!
CountryMusicMann with a capital t
@DelPlays That's what he said, rouge.
Ethan, calling the class "Rouge" is moronic. You aren't even abbreviating. It's exactly the same number of characters and syllables.
Pretty sure it was a typo lol
What's amazing is when they talk about their characters, they could easily be talking about themselves. Very cool insights into the game.
6:23 for Q&A
1:35:30 for intro and loot crate ad
1:48:30 for BR start
I don't really have the patience to highlight any real epic/noteworthy moments so here you go
Ashley is so incredibly pure.
"I'm a monstah!"
"I don't think I like this. They're my friends!"
You are wonderful and we love you.
Also, Liam played this *so so so* well. This is *exactly* how a Rogue should be approaching these tactics.
Keyleth was my favorite character when I started watching. Now I don't really have a fav b/c I love them all so much and it would be like picking a favorite child. I love all of them so much
Picking a favorite child is easy. Grog.
+Bunny Rabbit grog and scalan they would be fucked with out them
Don't think i've ever seen anyone justify why keyleth is their favourite character. curious....
Benglish Chinese The interesting thing about personal preference: one does not NEED to justify it.
"Hey, guys, we're in Hollywood, we're all lefty communists"
i love liam omg
Re-upping the Q&A timestamps:
06:23 - What's your weirdest DND experience?
11:37 - Ashley, what classes would the characters of 'Blindspot' be?
13:11 - Would the characters of Critical Role fight each other? What would lead to such a confrontation?
15:36 - What would the characters of Critical Role be doing if they weren't part of Vox Machina?
17:14 - What's the worst/best TPL in any game you've played?
19:14 - Who assigns or comes up with the episode titles?
20:37 - Does Vax have a death wish?
22:47 - How long did it take for character creation?
24:02 - What lead to Ashley and Travis linking their back stories?
26:20 - Is Matt aware of the technicalities of 'dimension door'?
27:37 - Anything in game that has genuinely shocked Matt?
33:05 - When are you getting "Your Fun Is Wrong" t-shirts on the Geek and Sundry website?
34:24 - Is Keyleth vegetarian?
34:36 - Do 'Blindspot' writers work with Ashley to incorporate Critical Role references or do they do it on their own?
36:24 - Will Liam ever DM a one-shot?
37:14 - What's your character's biggest fault?
40:37 - When did Matt tell Taliesin about the demon in the gun?
41:36 - Is the chat working?
41:54 - Did Scanlan get XP for destroying the gun?
42:40 - Why was Keyleth hostile towards Kima?
43:41 - Does Matt discuss game events with Marisha after the episodes?
44:25 - Why is there such polarizing anger towards Keyleth?
47:53 - How do Liam and Marisha avoid real-life awkwardness?
49:30 - Ashley, do you prefer to watch things unfold or being in the driver's seat? Also, would you convert anyone to worship Sarenrae?
51:42 - Do the Vestiges still draw their power from the deities?
52:21 - How did the guests come about? How do they join?
54:14 - Percy, does Matt shut you down when it comes to sketches and inventions?
55:57 - Something growing between Vex and Percy?
56:20 - Who is Pike in love with?
59:17 - Did you put Zahra's flying cloak in Vex's broom?
1:00:44 - What inspired Vaxleth?
1:02:22 - How much world-building have you done that we haven't seen yet?
1:04:04 - If you could pick another Critical Role character to play, who would you choose?
1:06:01 - Did Gilmore start off as a caricature or a fleshed-out character? Is he based off of a real person?
1:09:05 - Matt's thoughts on LGBT relationships in his world [not a question]
1:11:16 - Origin of the 'College of the Maestro'?
1:13:33 - What's Liam's t-shirt?
1:13:51 - Why do the twins know Abyssal?
1:14:00 - Will there be a "Vegetables of the Virgins" [sic] quest-line?
1:15:11 - Who is Pike in love with? [revisited]
1:15:51 - Who do I get my PCs to not be murderhobos?
1:19:00 - What's your character's greatest virtue?
1:21:09 - Is Vax bisexual?
1:21:25 - What challenge ratings do the dragons have after your modifications?
1:23:25 - Liam, what characters do your kids play? Would you ever introduce Vox Machina into their quest?
1:24:20 - Were there ramifications of Keyleth killing a child?
1:28:06 - What character would Matt create to play with Vox Machina?
1:28:50 - Which character dying would have the biggest impact on the group?
1:29:09 - What are the dimensions of 'the cube'?
1:29:38 - Have you ever made a terrible decision while playing or dm'ing?
i always find it so funny every time marisha goes "keyleth has a hard time killing things" because according to critrolestats she's got the highest number of kills in the party
That's because, when most of the team kills its murder.
Occasionally when Keyleth kills, it's more like genocide. Case in point, the illusionary bridge in the underdark.
Keyleth only worries about the big choices in life, like how many duergar can she slaughter with a single spell.
Maybe that's her way of trying to overcome it. =P Kill them till you're immunte to guilt. Also yell at people till you're not shy anymore. And act all high and mighty to mask your inferiority complexes... P.s. I do love Marisha. :D
thats OP druids for you
>pushes a duregar on melten rock and kills a kid
It's funny how Taliesin was the only one to catch the reference of The Beyonder xD
#SorryIFlameStrikedYourChild
Keyleth reminds me of Zuko; "Why am I so bad at being good?"
Perfect example, dunno why I never noticed it, does that make Scanlan Sokka?
@@toryfox4580 Didn't they mention it would be Vax? Makes sense to me =D
Matt should cover the chat with a hood, like a fucking Palantir.
The chat is a dangerous tool.
The back seat driving from the chat would absolutely drive me up the wall 😤
Watching Taliesin roll dice with that tower is really funny.
Ashley/Pike IS SO ADORABLE!!!! Her character would of never explored if it weren't for a friend in need so she went out to help and now does NOTHING BUT HELP she's the best and everyone needs some one like her at their table haha
The fucking thumbnail... God it's hilarious.
I know, the cock jokes are real.
Matt's face is priceless.
Marisha is probably my favorite in it though.
Max Cochina?
+The River Wolf vox macockina
Really fun seeing them pitted against each other using spells you've seen before, especially Vax as you normaly haven't seen stealth from the other side. Absolutely want to see a battle royal with everyone!
everyone asks where's Waldo. nobody asks how's Waldo
Let me go one better "why is Waldo?"
"What IS Waldo?!"
So, character deaths. For a game like this that has so much epic history it can be hard to bring in a new character and have the new comer have any credibility, fame, or infamy. It all seems very manufactured. The problem is heroic groups operate in a kind of vacuum, which is true of any home game. What you had in the RPGA living games was the development of various groups who often had a reputation among other players. So at conventions or game days, you would mix with these people and characters and occasionally adventure with them. What I might suggest is each player make 1 to 3 potential PCs, just name, race, class, and gender (or not). Then begin giving rumors about these people in game. The PCs hear about their adventures from time to time. So if a character does meet their end, the player has the option to pick up one of these proto PCs who are a somewhat known quality. Just a thought. I definitely enjoy the series, keep up the good work.
This is an amazing idea and I love it and as a (hopefully) soon-to-be GM I definitely want to do this.
Have you heard the tale of Burt Reynolds....
This is genius!! We need to find a way to get matt to see this.
Sean Hillman that's a great idea.
Sean Hillman boinokbokbokboij
52:55 Dang. Missed opportunity. I bet there are scores of critters out there that wish that Mary had been part of the original group instead of Orion... Then we'd probably still have 8 players to this day... :/
I disagree, while her character is great and so is she, I loved tiberius and to an extent orian too. It is unfortunate what happened but I wouldn't trade it away
@@gaj7062 I do wonder if we would have met Tiberius in vasselheim if that happened
Just a friendly tip for those who care; when holding a spell when readying an action, the spell is actually cast, meaning you cannot choose what spell you want to release at the time of the triggering circumstance. To be nore accurate, the spell is 99% complete, with the spellcaster holding it at juuuuust the point before it would go off. Thus meaning if you take damage before the triggering event happens you have to make a concentration check.
Evil Pike is terrifying!
I can see why the joke about Taliesin being immortal has formed. Everyone else looks a lot older today, but Taliesin has not changed at all. I can hardly tell the difference between today-Taliesin and this past Taliesin. He looks like a freaking time traveller.
By far the worst thing about FATAL is the way it actually works, mechanically. Or rather, how it doesn't. All the other horrible stuff in it could just be shaped by a good GM and good players, the worst parts ignored or confronted. But the game mechanics? By the time you've fixed what's wrong with it, it's not FATAL any more.
how it should have happened
mercer: how do you want to do this ashley?
ashley: i can harness the power from the dawn of creation?
mercer: yea
ashley: i want her to experience the creation of all the starry universe. i want it to consume her mind until her brain turns to mush and runs out of her ears at the extent of the experience.
:-O ....daamn Daniel.
That’s.... a great one warlock thing.
That look on Marisha’s face when Ashley busts out the Divine Word. Priceless
MONSTAAAAAAAAHHH!!!!!!
Break ends 1:48:27
thanks!
Break ends _____ And battle starts, more or less.
The music at 1:58:06 was in my playlist for an age and then got disappeared and I've not been able to find it again. Every time it plays on this show I get just a little bit more smad about it.
use Shazam.
Or the critical role playlist on spotify im sure that has it
The Leapin' Lizard can you link it?
shailen girgenti open.spotify.com/user/geekandsundry/playlist/3gwh7QADRYbg88HWCa20Iu there you go
MonarchsFactory its amazing
06:23 - What's your weirdest DND experience?
11:37 - Ashley, what classes would the characters of 'Blindspot' be?
13:11 - Would the characters of Critical Role fight each other? What would lead to such a confrontation?
15:36 - What would the characters of Critical Role be doing if they weren't part of Vox Machina?
17:14 - What's the worst/best TPL in any game you've played?
19:14 - Who assigns or comes up with the episode titles?
20:37 - Does Vax have a death wish?
22:47 - How long did it take for character creation?
24:02 - What lead to Ashley and Travis linking their back stories?
26:20 - Is Matt aware of the technicalities of 'dimension door'?
27:37 - Anything in game that has genuinely shocked Matt?
33:05 - When are you getting "Your Fun Is Wrong" t-shirts on the Geek and Sundry website?
34:24 - Is Keyleth vegetarian?
34:36 - Do 'Blindspot' writers work with Ashley to incorporate Critical Role references or do they do it on their own?
36:24 - Will Liam ever DM a one-shot?
37:14 - What's your character's biggest fault?
40:37 - When did Matt tell Taliesin about the demon in the gun?
41:36 - Is the chat working?
41:54 - Did Scanlan get XP for destroying the gun?
42:40 - Why was Keyleth hostile towards Kima?
43:41 - Does Matt discuss game events with Marisha after the episodes?
44:25 - Why is there such polarizing anger towards Keyleth?
47:53 - How do Liam and Marisha avoid real-life awkwardness?
49:30 - Ashley, do you prefer to watch things unfold or being in the driver's seat? Also, would you convert anyone to worship Sarenrae?
51:42 - Do the Vestiges still draw their power from the deities?
52:21 - How did the guests come about? How do they join?
54:14 - Percy, does Matt shut you down when it comes to sketches and inventions?
55:57 - Something growing between Vex and Percy?
56:20 - Who is Pike in love with?
59:17 - Did you put Zahra's flying cloak in Vex's broom?
1:00:44 - What inspired Vaxleth?
1:02:22 - How much world-building have you done that we haven't seen yet?
1:04:04 - If you could pick another Critical Role character to play, who would you choose?
1:06:01 - Did Gilmore start off as a caricature or a fleshed-out character? Is he based off of a real person?
1:09:05 - Matt's thoughts on LGBT relationships in his world [not a question]
1:11:16 - Origin of the 'College of the Maestro'?
1:13:33 - What's Liam's t-shirt?
1:13:51 - Why do the twins know Abyssal?
1:14:00 - Will there be a "Vegetables of the Virgins" [sic] quest-line?
1:15:11 - Who is Pike in love with? [revisited]
1:15:51 - Who do I get my PCs to not be murderhobos?
1:19:00 - What's your character's greatest virtue?
1:21:09 - Is Vax bisexual?
1:21:25 - What challenge ratings do the dragons have after your modifications?
1:23:25 - Liam, what characters do your kids play? Would you ever introduce Vox Machina into their quest?
1:24:20 - Were there ramifications of Keyleth killing a child?
1:28:06 - What character would Matt create to play with Vox Machina?
1:28:50 - Which character dying would have the biggest impact on the group?
1:29:09 - What are the dimensions of 'the cube'?
1:29:38 - Have you ever made a terrible decision while playing or dm'ing?
I loved this! Matt is one amazing DM and the others get such apparent joy out of playing.
I'd like to see Shawn as a guest on the show! :D
Have Shawn as a Player Controlled Villain working with Matt
plz that would be great
Shawn? He has to be Gilmore, it would be Glorious.
4:03:55 - "Anakin! You were supposed to bring balance to the party, not destroy it!"
The only annoying part of playing a cleric is that people think you're a healer even if you clearly run around in heavy armor smashing skulls and throwing bolts.
Keyleth is a dork and can be a bit judgmental. I don't mind so much that people dislike her as a character, it's understandable, she's got growing to do (that's the point of making a character, to see where they go and how much they grow from their adventures), but what I don't care for is the people who talk about it like Marisha is the bad person.
When I look at Campaign 1, I see a group of friends playing an unprofessional game of DnD in a professional setting. I forgive a ton of the faults that come with it like technical issues (cameras going out), scheduling problems, personality clashes, etc. It's fine. It'll all get worked out, let's just have fun with it.
Really hate it, though, when I see people take things so seriously, especially the rules lawyers. No one says you have to play your game a certain way, but rules lawyers *insist* you only follow the rules and, conveniently, always forget about the rule that says to be willing to ignore the rules.
If the Critical Role cast *only* followed the rules to the letter, boy would this series suck.
It's so funny watching them talk about potential future characters after watching the second campaign :D
For once I actually agree with Marisha about Keyleth's worst aspect is her lack of self-confidence. This is because it relates to the part of Keyleth's character that I can't stand: the fact the she cares more about not doing the wrong thing instead of doing the right thing. Let me explain, when ever the party has to make a hard decision that effects the lives of thousands(battling K'varn or starting a rebellion in Whitestone) Keyleth is apprehensive about doing something that will result in more suffering. So she decides her best option is to do nothing. However, evil will be allowed to triumph if good men do nothing. That's my problem with Keyleth in a nutshell. She wants to help, but her confidence is so low and doubts her abilities so much, that she would rather do nothing than try. I'm not saying Keyleth would just stand there if a family was caught in a burning house, but she would if the whole world burns, she would just stand there, believing that she would only make things worse.However, that's what Vox Machina is for. They are the ones who give Keyleth the push she needs to succeed.
CJBerdomas wow, you gave a great criticism to one of my favorite characters ever. Thank you bud
She alternates between overthinking things and being impulsive.
Marisha also wrote her to be a child prodigy who has been in intensive schooling for years, little amusement, and massive expectations. She started with VM at age 20 and reached Lv 20 around age 23.
So she has massive powers even for a D&D world, a royal-adjacent background, and no life experience. And the first time she left home, she ended up with VM. She's the naive university freshman genius who ends up hanging out with superpowered badass assholes. How many 21-year-olds do you know who are confident, mature, people? I would submit that Marisha's playing her to be near-constantly intimidated by The Real World and trying to hold on to her morals while Necessity forces her to make horrible choices.
Girl's on the edge of a breakdown all the time.
I almost skipped this episode to get right back into the dragon fight. Soooo glad I decided to go ahead and watch this Q&A and battle royale! Grats to the victor.
"I'd rather try something spectacular and fail spectacularly" is so true - the last campaign I was in ended when we (somewhat deliberately) blew up a ship full of dragonshards to kill our enemy (I'd say BBEG but it was an evil campaign, so...) and we ended up essentially planeshifting the entirety of Sharn into... space, maybe? I'm not certain, tbh. It was the most *spectacular* end to the campaign we could've imagined, I fully expected that character to die bloody, and I'm shocked we actually survived.
vegetables of the virgins = critter comedy gold
This is cool to watch after the series ended! Especially where they mention plot points that "they haven't gotten to yet" (Keyleth's back story, rerolling characters (Tary counts, and this was funny because Liam said "hey! I'm the new bard! Where are my spells?"), Pike's family).
Humble beginnings. I love to see their growth.
I love that Vax's view of Scanlan, is that he's a dumbass who takes on impossible situations repeatedly, and somehow just comes out on top anyways.
wow, I did NOT expect Pike to be victorious. I'd expected Keyleth to either Firestorm everyone, Vax to assassinate everyone, but actually not Percy. Didn't expect him to win
29:40 I mean, you guys kinda did think about it, but Grog nipped in the bud multiple times by insisting that he not kill Kevdak in any kind of "cheap" or "cowardly" way and that he would just walk into the city in the open without sneaking around.
Battle royale is a great way to learn your friends attacks
Thanks for the Q&A!
uh oh Matt didn't know a rule from memory he loses dm points. he's now at 99 out of a 100
Jeremy Davis but he gets 2 plus for glorious hair.
1:09:00 Matt really got it right with that whole talk about LGBT people in his world. Making everyone straight or everyone bi are both equally akward and both scenarios come up way too often.
Plus we know that there are LGBT people in the world. Several of them aren't people you'd necessarily think just because it's not a flashing neon light above their heads - even Gilmore, on a quick glance, simply looks fashionably fabulous (or just glorious). He's treating the topic respectfully - neither denying it, pushing it, or brushing it off - which I really admire. It just "is", and thus the players are going with it the same way. Liam/Vax found himself open to reciprocating Gilmore's affection for some great roleplaying moments, but when he felt more attracted to Keyleth, he was gentle about letting Gilmore down.
Diarmuid Balfe hes a very wise man
Rewatching before the level 17 Battle Royale - Just remembered Matt worried about whether people would like McCree from Overwatch lol
I'm actually happy that another of my questions was answered during another Q&A. Mine was to Marisha at 42:18, asking why was Keyleth so hostile to Kima in the past.
Overall, the questions were interesting. But during the battle royale, I thought the chat room was overly trying to backseat DM. And unfortunately, Matt was seeing the chaos in action.
Already finished with campaign one and am part way through campaign two and decided to cath up on the one shots and hearing them as campaign one characters made me cry
I didn't see a timestamp post when scrolling down in comments so here's to future people who want to watch the episode. I hope you all have a wonderful day! :)
0:00:00 - 1:35:25 Q&A Session
1:35:25 - 1:35:30 Surprise Taliesin!
1:35:30 - 1:48:28 Break & Critical Role Intro
1:48:28 Break ends / Battle Royale starts
4:22:40 Battle Royale ends
4:22:40 - 4:30:59 Battle Royale Aftermath talk
Bidet 😘
This was so cool to watch. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I didn't expect the first elimination, but bad rolls are bad rolls.
Reminder to all D&D 5e players: Spiritual Weapon is NOT a concentration spell.
17:00 Don't Stop Believin' fits Pike and Scanlan. Oh my god.
I now consider it cannon that Scanlan smells like wine and cheap perfume. I mean, it makes sense!
I definitely agree that dying spectacularly is way better than living if it makes the game a by-the-numbers experience. In my M&M game playing the lone human Batman wannabe in a group of veritable superhuman gods, sacrificing myself to destroy an indestructible robot from the inside was way more memorable than if I went with 'I'm going to find a security room or something while you guys fight this.'
1:16:14 Now I'm just imagining a frustrated DM TPKing their players with a swarm of guards and mercenaries that have been hunting them, GTA-style, and, as they get cornered in some random back alley and brutally struck down, the DM just flips the double-bird to their players then stands up and walks out slowly backwards while still flipping them all off with a scowl on their face. xD
I never got around to finishing this series years ago and after the recent show I decided to finish and catch up so I’m very surprised to find out people hated Keyleth this entire time. I love her sincerity
just rewatched this, realizing that the seed for liam's second oneshot was planted here. #TheShrewScrewsYou
second? when was his first?
3:45 Yay, he finally acknowledged it! Little does he know at this point that McCree would become one of his most well-known and beloved roles. xD
38:50
I wanna grab Ashley and hug her and protect her from the evils of this world.
I kind of love this more casual, home-style gaming set up No screens, rolling in front of the players it's pretty cool and I like it a lot
Holy cow! This was so much fun to watch!
1:48:27 Break ends
1:49:40 Battle starts
1:55:15 Vax vanishes
2:00:00 Keyleth and lava: the beginning of a love story
2:12:00 Vax hides #2
2:13:10 Concentration vs chat
2:22:00 Cute Taliesin + Marisha hug
2:24:30 Vax hides #3
2:25:40 Goodbye chat
2:28:40 Gun breaks
2:30:30 Monstah !
2:34:00 Vax hides #4
2:35:19 Lava spreads
2:36:39 Tremor sense vs Vax's stealth
2:41:35 Pike strikes again
2:46:20 Vax hides #5
2:55:50 Character down #1
3:03:58 Death #1
3:07:30 Vax hides #6
3:23:50 Pike brings on the plague
3:28:40 Vax hides #7 (I'm fairly sure I lost count at this point)
3:30:20 Keyleth tries to smoke out Vax
3:38:15 Vax hides #8
3:39:50 Getting confused about concentration again
3:46:50 Camping
3:55:20 Stealth goggles ?
3:58:06 Hi Simon !
4:01:08 Vax vs lava
4:02:20 Character down #2
4:04:00 Death #2
4:07:33 Harm
4:11:43 Classic Keyleth move
4:19:10 Last move
4:20:12 HDYWTDT
Boost.
Incredible
I'm fairly certain Vex asked to check for traps and Matt just didn't hear her. Which is even more devastating than just rushing in without checking
dubstep bard as a warforged. speakers built in and auto mix bass dropping. badass
As i gear up awaiting the VM Vs M9 Battle Royale...i will re watch this one for the feels
its a little late now but a 40' radios is an 80' diameter which takes up nearly the entire map.
Man I loved the kashaw keyleth dynamic I found him such an interesting character
Fight starts @ 1:49:43
So glad for this Q&A. A lot of "suck it haters," only nicer because these guys are so precious QQ
Funnily enough, it also came at a good time in the story I think.