What’s the point in this segment Dermot has never called out a ref for making a bad decision all he does is defend his PGMOL mates this segment is pointless
Dermot is 100% agreed with every decision referee made . It is waste of time to call him to comment as he will never never never said the referee be wrong.
100% incorrect statement there mate. On Estupinen Yellow Card: DERMOT SAYS: I think it's a red card. He's flying through the air, he's out of control. It catches him high, catches him full force with his studs. I understand the referee's position thinking the player goes across him there but I think it's a red. On Casey Red Card for Motherwell DERMOT SAYS: I don't think it's a red card at all. I think the referee has grabbed him by the throat. The VAR has quite rightly alerted him to go over and check. Turnbull shorts incident DERMOT SAYS: It's a mystery as to why it was allowed to stand. Just give a free kick, everyone would accept that, wouldn't they? These are three examples just from the 24th of December. So your statement is factually incorrect.
Im not a Villa or Newcastle fan, but that wasnt a red card. His left ankle is not stable and he cant get his foot out of the way, he is 6ft 2 as well so its harder to get his leg away from Fabian Schar's backside.
his left ankle isnt stable because he stands on the players leg, that was intentional, rash but he's looking at where his foot goes, there are 2 steps, if he planted his left on the ground it wouldn't have rolled.
I’m 6ft 3…,been in a similar situation. I didn’t stand on the player or further bring my other foot down on the player. He could have easily just tumbled. The thing that should be talked about is what’s not being talked about. The schar kick out on Duran on his way down.
@@Gunjack1440 did he hell, if you watch the whole thing he is tumbling, he doesn't control where his legs are. Seen it several times as well as live, you can tell by the reactions.
@@philscott3759 i did see it, several times actually. he stands on the back of Schars thigh and his foot goes over then because it's not a steady surface, had he put his foot on the ground he wouldn't have gone over in the first place. Now supposing his foot had contact with Schar's head when he dragged it up his back, intent or not that is dangerous play = red
First time Emery has ever questioned referees. He always avoids discussing decisions so you can see he is upset with the pathetic Anthony Taylor. You only have to look on youtube to see what other fans of numerous clubs think of Taylor.
Yes and shouldn't players like Rogers and walker be deducted wages as well for cheating and making fools of themselves do they not realise the is cameras everywhere lol
Duran is off balance, his boot comes down onto Schar's backside and then it looks like he is trying to avoid putting much weight onto that leg so he lifts the foot and falls backwards. One thing that no one else has mentioned is Schar's reaction, after briefly touching where Duran caught him he then grips the inside of his thigh and stays down, Duran was no where near his thigh. The Refs should go to the screen before sending people off, what does taking time achieve if you don't use the tech available ?
so you missed the bit where he stood on the back of his thigh? that is how he rolls his ankle, he stands on Schar, leg is not a flat surface, therefore goes over. Troy Deeny said as someone who used to leave a bit in, it's a red. Since he was a rough player, will take his word. It is intentional made to look like an accident, it's telling that no villa players complain & Emery doesn't look at him as he leaves. Go by the reactions.
@@AllyBeee1 The momentum and follow-through from Schär's sliding tackle propelled Durán to the ground, culminating in an innocuous tangling of legs between the two with Duran's misplaced landing foot saddling into Schär even potentially injuring Durán himself in the process. Never a. *V🖥R* replays in slo-mo alwys seem to amplify contact by removing nuance and context of plays in real-time
I would like to see dermot try and recover from his ankle twisting. and move his right foot out of the way. What a joke he's backing up his bum buddies
Absolute clown show of a red card ! Get a grip people. You can tell from his reaction that it’s not a red. If you think that’s a red then we should have 3 or 4 reds every game. Pathetic
That was clearly unintentional though, they both jostling for the ball and Duran was not able to catch himself as they were falling and unfortunately he tramped on his opponents back.
Dermot is 100% agreed with every decision referee made so why bother when they cant be honest about the situation you show the still at the start where Schar foot is in Durrans groin before anything Durran does so who committed the foul first referee can not see that but makes his mind up VAR does not intervene to say clear and obvious ERROR -why ? i don't think either of them meat to do it i think it was a accident
Well, look at that. I disagree. This decision should be opposed. It was not clear at all. He didn't stomp. This made it unintentional. Yessss appeal Unai. Steups.
No point do I see a change in direction apart from after first contact it looks as if he tries to move his foot away from the player to avoid hurting him
Newcastle fan here. I was really surprised when the ref pulled out the Red card. Looking back, it still seems way too harsh. It killed the game. I would've been livid if I were a Villa fan.
I don't know why they even bother getting referees on this, they will always support on field referees/VAR no matter how bad the decision is. For me it's clumsy and a yellow card, never a red.
Duran's left ankle twists as his foot plants on the ground and its only natural that he tries to balance himself with his right leg but he has no real control. Its an unfortunate incident but totally accidental and not violent conduct. Villa need to appeal this decision.
In the slow motion you can see that Schär first hits Duran's left thigh with his right foot as he falls. And? This was an unfortunate situation for both of them and neither wanted to hurt the other. But football is a contact sport. The only one who got hurt is Taylor. He ruined the game and deserved a red card🟥!
How significant is intent? In the case of a red card worthy tackle, the tackle may appear to have no intent but if the end-result is injurious enough, it is still red. If this were a court case there would really be no way to determine the player's intent, so you can only judge by the outcome of his actions. We can't focus on intent here because it is a subjective decision at best. We can see the outcome - then we should decide if the force in the part where he treads on Schar's back is sufficient for a red.
Anthony Taylor loves giving out cards, so with this being the holiday season, hes going to be extra generous. Hopefully Santa puts Anthony Taylor on his naughty list next Christmas for being the worst referee in Premier League history.
Brilliant! 😂 👏The amount of crap referees have had to endure day in day out dealing with Prima Donna footballers, arrogant managers and sanctimonious football fans. Loads of you are happy to dish it out every week. Absolute belter! Banter this and banter that until it doesn’t suit your narrative. Respect is a two way street.
The momentum and follow-through from Schär's sliding tackle propelled Durán to the ground, culminating in an innocuous tangling of legs between the two with Duran's misplaced landing foot saddling into Schär even potentially injuring Durán himself in the process. Never a . *V🖥R* replays in slo-mo alwys seem to amplify contact by removing nuance and context of plays in real-time
Extraordinary ignorance by my most ‘fans’. Look at the laws of the game. On that basis the referee would not be doing his job if he didn’t dismiss Duran. Emery’s argument is a nonsense, ie that the referee should have used VAR. VAR was used! The VAR official looks at footage and reviews it. The decision wasn’t overturned because it wasn’t clearly and obviously wrong.
It’s been appealed & upgraded to a 3 match ban instead of just 1, at least Duran gets rest now so he can kick ass in the final 2 CL games that Sky don’t want Villa to win/qualify from. To simplify it, if Saka or Son were in the same situation as Duran, they wouldn’t of even got a yellow
Whati s Dermot going on about did he see the Newcastle player kick Duran in the goin before the volla player went down. Please please sky get rid of this old has been ref off our screens as he always supports his colleagues & var issues as well. Just get lost Dermot your views are pointless as u bring nothing to our game 🙄🤔😠🙊🙉🙈
A Newcastle United fan I'm 50-50 in real time never saw why from my seat in the leazers stand watch it later I'm not sure if it's a red. If it went against us id be upset
So when Jhon gets studs to his nads that's fine? And when he is brought down by the new castle player that is OK? He lost his balance AND was kicked in the nads
He could of just fell onto his left hand side and let his leg hit Schar but he bent his leg so he could stud him in the back. It's dangerous play and a red card
But again this is what's pissing me off like refs and officials get to take as long as they want but u want to penalise the goal keepers by allowing players to over crowd them and recently the new law of only 8 secs we get Dr getting the ball in are hands but the refs allowed to take 30 nah if us players got to be quick and eratical then why can u officials do it
for me he tries to plant his left foot on Schar's leg which is why it rolls, then he steps on his back and his foot drags up his back, i think the intent is there on the left foot then the right but the drag was part of the movement, but there is intent there, he could have landed his left foot on the ground NOT on Schar's leg then he would have been stable, he is watching what he is doing the whole time!
It was a red. He had options even to fall forward on Schar. He thought he would sneakily rack his studs and claim he was off balance. He tried it on and he got caught.
Duran tries to stamp on Schar with his left foot and only makes half contact. As his right foot comes forward it is going to land to the right of Schar's body, but Duran moves his foot to the left, so that it impacts on Schar's hip area. Not content with that, Duran then rakes his right foot down Schar's back and may have even made contact with the head as well. This was not so much a foul, but a full on multiple assault, which means the straight red was well deserved.
What’s the point in this segment Dermot has never called out a ref for making a bad decision all he does is defend his PGMOL mates this segment is pointless
Dermot is 100% agreed with every decision referee made . It is waste of time to call him to comment as he will never never never said the referee be wrong.
100% incorrect statement there mate.
On Estupinen Yellow Card:
DERMOT SAYS: I think it's a red card. He's flying through the air, he's out of control. It catches him high, catches him full force with his studs. I understand the referee's position thinking the player goes across him there but I think it's a red.
On Casey Red Card for Motherwell
DERMOT SAYS: I don't think it's a red card at all. I think the referee has grabbed him by the throat. The VAR has quite rightly alerted him to go over and check.
Turnbull shorts incident
DERMOT SAYS: It's a mystery as to why it was allowed to stand. Just give a free kick, everyone would accept that, wouldn't they?
These are three examples just from the 24th of December. So your statement is factually incorrect.
100% Every.single.time.
whats the point of this show if we are not shown the footage of the incident ? Stills of the manager hardly tell the story . Do expect better from sky
Tv rights are a joke
They normally do show footage of the incidents but for this one they can’t because Amazon has the rights for the Boxing Day matches.
@@James-vv7vh Tight Sky as always, They can pay to show the footage.
I don’t (expect better)
FFS - even Eddie Howe said it was harsh - Dermot defending his mates on Duran’s red - PGMOL and their mates = corrupt
It was a red though
If duran goes down crying you can argue its red for schär for boots in the balls@ToonArmy4life
This is why fans have zero respect for refs listen to Allen Sheerer he’s got it spot on
Can't find owt from Allen Sheerer
@@westynufc90 mint hahahaha 😂
Im not a Villa or Newcastle fan, but that wasnt a red card. His left ankle is not stable and he cant get his foot out of the way, he is 6ft 2 as well so its harder to get his leg away from Fabian Schar's backside.
his left ankle isnt stable because he stands on the players leg, that was intentional, rash but he's looking at where his foot goes, there are 2 steps, if he planted his left on the ground it wouldn't have rolled.
Should've watched the incident, son.
I’m 6ft 3…,been in a similar situation. I didn’t stand on the player or further bring my other foot down on the player. He could have easily just tumbled.
The thing that should be talked about is what’s not being talked about. The schar kick out on Duran on his way down.
@@Gunjack1440 did he hell, if you watch the whole thing he is tumbling, he doesn't control where his legs are. Seen it several times as well as live, you can tell by the reactions.
@@philscott3759 i did see it, several times actually. he stands on the back of Schars thigh and his foot goes over then because it's not a steady surface, had he put his foot on the ground he wouldn't have gone over in the first place. Now supposing his foot had contact with Schar's head when he dragged it up his back, intent or not that is dangerous play = red
Never a red card what's the point of the show if dermot is gonna bumlick the ref
I am neither a Villa nor Newcastle fan, but I think it's not a red!!
And Dermot is just like a union chief for the PGMOL!!!😂😂😂😂
First time Emery has ever questioned referees. He always avoids discussing decisions so you can see he is upset with the pathetic Anthony Taylor. You only have to look on youtube to see what other fans of numerous clubs think of Taylor.
Yeah I think it was overdue of Emery to lose it. He'd been really patient until now.
no it’s not a red from an unbiased Arsenal Fan , officiating in football is embarrassing , refs should be held accountable and their wages reduced
Yes and shouldn't players like Rogers and walker be deducted wages as well for cheating and making fools of themselves do they not realise the is cameras everywhere lol
Schar tries to get him with his studs first, as he falls 😒 if Durán was sent off Schar should have been sent off too! Changed the match.
Spot on…
Not a villa fan never a red.
Not a villa fan but 100% a red (anyday of the week)
@jesperfuglsang Jhon was kicked in the nads... no one commenting on that? If that happened to you you would stumble too trust me
Duran is off balance, his boot comes down onto Schar's backside and then it looks like he is trying to avoid putting much weight onto that leg so he lifts the foot and falls backwards. One thing that no one else has mentioned is Schar's reaction, after briefly touching where Duran caught him he then grips the inside of his thigh and stays down, Duran was no where near his thigh.
The Refs should go to the screen before sending people off, what does taking time achieve if you don't use the tech available ?
so you missed the bit where he stood on the back of his thigh? that is how he rolls his ankle, he stands on Schar, leg is not a flat surface, therefore goes over. Troy Deeny said as someone who used to leave a bit in, it's a red. Since he was a rough player, will take his word. It is intentional made to look like an accident, it's telling that no villa players complain & Emery doesn't look at him as he leaves. Go by the reactions.
@@AllyBeee1 The momentum and follow-through from Schär's sliding tackle propelled Durán to the ground, culminating in an innocuous tangling of legs between the two with Duran's misplaced landing foot saddling into Schär even potentially injuring Durán himself in the process. Never a. *V🖥R* replays in slo-mo alwys seem to amplify contact by removing nuance and context of plays in real-time
I support neither team it wasn’t a red - just another ref who was bullied as a child dishing it out
why dont you cry more
@ not the brightest are you? What exactly would I be crying about here? I support neither team you doughnut.
@Geoglyph89 they said they don’t support either team, so why would they be crying? Learn to read, idiot.
I personally think its abit harsh, it was not intentional
Never a red...
Terrible call. Terrible officiating overall yesterday
Yeah 2 legitimate Newcastle goals were ruled out
Never a red, rolls his ankle, he has to balance himself or break his ankle. Ridiculous decision
The referees will always defend their stories, how bad of a mistake they do !!
pretty ridiculous tbh clearly a wrong decision and here you are sticking by it ..
PGMOL should be investigated for corruption
I would like to see dermot try and recover from his ankle twisting. and move his right foot out of the way. What a joke he's backing up his bum buddies
Its not a red
Absolutely zero insight or meaningful analysis from Gallagher, he's just a PGMOL stooge backing them up as usual
Harsh red card, and considering what was let off over the last couple of weeks, the inconsistency still doesn't add up
I think PGMOL should be disbanded.
Is nobody seeing that Schär put his studs up Duran's leg!? Should be a red for Schär, yellow for Duran.
Straight to his balls
Never a Red
I love how this ex referee shows the corrupt mindset inside the PGMOL. Why anyone would watch a fill game of football nowadays is beyond me.
Absolute clown show of a red card ! Get a grip people.
You can tell from his reaction that it’s not a red. If you think that’s a red then we should have 3 or 4 reds every game. Pathetic
Ref sticking up for a ref 😮
Estupinan almost broke someone's leg last week and got a yellow, but Duran slipping over onto someone is a 3 match ban, what an utter joke!
Shocking decision.
For Var get rid of the clowns we have and use people from cricket or rugby. Our guys just don't know what common sense is
It was not red Card for Duran
Joke to be sent off for that
That was clearly unintentional though, they both jostling for the ball and Duran was not able to catch himself as they were falling and unfortunately he tramped on his opponents back.
Dermot is 100% agreed with every decision referee made so why bother when they cant be honest about the situation you show the still at the start where Schar foot is in Durrans groin before anything Durran does so who committed the foul first referee can not see that but makes his mind up VAR does not intervene to say clear and obvious ERROR -why ? i don't think either of them meat to do it i think it was a accident
That was purely accidental.... by red card they are implying that all this was intentional.... like seriously???
Well, look at that. I disagree. This decision should be opposed. It was not clear at all. He didn't stomp. This made it unintentional. Yessss appeal Unai. Steups.
This is just protecting his former colleague, was never a pen, look again Shar sticks his foot in Duran groin which made him even more unstable.
What a surprise the media trying to brush a controversial decision under the carpet, next!
why cant you sho video this is sky sports?!?! FFS
No point do I see a change in direction apart from after first contact it looks as if he tries to move his foot away from the player to avoid hurting him
I am with you and understand you why you are upset because the referee didn't watch 👋 VAR
Useless decision honestly.
Newcastle fan here. I was really surprised when the ref pulled out the Red card. Looking back, it still seems way too harsh. It killed the game. I would've been livid if I were a Villa fan.
Alll Refs, VAR is becoming a joke of football 😅😮😮😮😅
I don't know why they even bother getting referees on this, they will always support on field referees/VAR no matter how bad the decision is. For me it's clumsy and a yellow card, never a red.
Duran's left ankle twists as his foot plants on the ground and its only natural that he tries to balance himself with his right leg but he has no real control. Its an unfortunate incident but totally accidental and not violent conduct. Villa need to appeal this decision.
In the slow motion you can see that Schär first hits Duran's left thigh with his right foot as he falls. And? This was an unfortunate situation for both of them and neither wanted to hurt the other. But football is a contact sport. The only one who got hurt is Taylor. He ruined the game and deserved a red card🟥!
How significant is intent? In the case of a red card worthy tackle, the tackle may appear to have no intent but if the end-result is injurious enough, it is still red. If this were a court case there would really be no way to determine the player's intent, so you can only judge by the outcome of his actions. We can't focus on intent here because it is a subjective decision at best. We can see the outcome - then we should decide if the force in the part where he treads on Schar's back is sufficient for a red.
Anthony Taylor loves giving out cards, so with this being the holiday season, hes going to be extra generous. Hopefully Santa puts Anthony Taylor on his naughty list next Christmas for being the worst referee in Premier League history.
Brilliant! 😂 👏The amount of crap referees have had to endure day in day out dealing with Prima Donna footballers, arrogant managers and sanctimonious football fans. Loads of you are happy to dish it out every week. Absolute belter! Banter this and banter that until it doesn’t suit your narrative. Respect is a two way street.
The momentum and follow-through from Schär's sliding tackle propelled Durán to the ground, culminating in an innocuous tangling of legs between the two with Duran's misplaced landing foot saddling into Schär even potentially injuring Durán himself in the process. Never a . *V🖥R* replays in slo-mo alwys seem to amplify contact by removing nuance and context of plays in real-time
It doesn’t matter. He did get a red, and Villa lost. End of.
Extraordinary ignorance by my most ‘fans’. Look at the laws of the game. On that basis the referee would not be doing his job if he didn’t dismiss Duran. Emery’s argument is a nonsense, ie that the referee should have used VAR. VAR was used! The VAR official looks at footage and reviews it. The decision wasn’t overturned because it wasn’t clearly and obviously wrong.
What a shocking surprise dermot agreed with his mates it wasn't dangerous play when schar kicked him in the balls
It’s been appealed & upgraded to a 3 match ban instead of just 1, at least Duran gets rest now so he can kick ass in the final 2 CL games that Sky don’t want Villa to win/qualify from. To simplify it, if Saka or Son were in the same situation as Duran, they wouldn’t of even got a yellow
Definitely a red card , player's action afterwards wasnt convincing to show not guilty
He deserved the red card for sure he lose the dual and his attitude and attention he react with aggressive to Schar
Intent doesn't matter. He was reckless and it was dangerous.
It was a red. Man tried to hurt him. Simple as that.
Whati s Dermot going on about did he see the Newcastle player kick Duran in the goin before the volla player went down. Please please sky get rid of this old has been ref off our screens as he always supports his colleagues & var issues as well. Just get lost Dermot your views are pointless as u bring nothing to our game 🙄🤔😠🙊🙉🙈
Sky should have tried a bit harder to get that red overturned. Bad show. The Premier League have now gone and chucked out Villa’s appeal.
No. Move on.
A Newcastle United fan I'm 50-50 in real time never saw why from my seat in the leazers stand watch it later I'm not sure if it's a red. If it went against us id be upset
When ever Newcastle plays at home everything goes their way. Not a new thing all their matches dey play there most be a controversial decision made
Imagine if you knew what you were talking about, Sunshine. Go back to bed.
You mean when Schar was sent off at Newcastle in the first match against Southampton when Diaz feigned injury. Ignorant.
I think you've had to many wine gums if your statement is true why was Schar sent off against Southampton?
His left ankle turned,put him off balance,he should have gone too the monitor that's what it's for
Boxing day this year it seemed everyone got a red card for Christmas
Not a red card in million years... this refs gonna ruin whole EPL....
So when Jhon gets studs to his nads that's fine? And when he is brought down by the new castle player that is OK? He lost his balance AND was kicked in the nads
most pointless football show/segment, just Dermot defending his PGMOL mates, spineless
Someone tell me the point in this segment.
This is the most pointless show ever
It's a red because saudi money says it's a red
"To send Jhon Duran to be sent off"...yh sounds about right
Taylor is a master stroke Ref , he sends players Coaches out with aRed, give unwanted reports to FA euro 😅😮
Accidental?
From B6 Birmingham never a red
Its harsh but is what it is better team won and the red made it easier for them
Who was taking Beer?
not durans fault he couldn’t of gone anywhere else
He could of just fell onto his left hand side and let his leg hit Schar but he bent his leg so he could stud him in the back. It's dangerous play and a red card
But again this is what's pissing me off like refs and officials get to take as long as they want but u want to penalise the goal keepers by allowing players to over crowd them and recently the new law of only 8 secs we get Dr getting the ball in are hands but the refs allowed to take 30 nah if us players got to be quick and eratical then why can u officials do it
No!!!!
NO
Only 1 chap who knows if it was red or not!...
His English is getting worse was he in allo allo ???? 😅
This show is never important
for me he tries to plant his left foot on Schar's leg which is why it rolls, then he steps on his back and his foot drags up his back, i think the intent is there on the left foot then the right but the drag was part of the movement, but there is intent there, he could have landed his left foot on the ground NOT on Schar's leg then he would have been stable, he is watching what he is doing the whole time!
It was a red. He had options even to fall forward on Schar. He thought he would sneakily rack his studs and claim he was off balance. He tried it on and he got caught.
And Schar got away with shoving his studs into Duran’s bollocks.
This guy is useless
So hard to understand Emery in english 😅😂
If you’re an idiot maybe
Not for people with a brain
Absolute garbage show
He knew what he was doing and tried to make it look accidental.
If u got tem studs dwn ur back u would be seeing red 😮😅 to everyone who finks it was harsh 😮
Red card
Duran tries to stamp on Schar with his left foot and only makes half contact. As his right foot comes forward it is going to land to the right of Schar's body, but Duran moves his foot to the left, so that it impacts on Schar's hip area. Not content with that, Duran then rakes his right foot down Schar's back and may have even made contact with the head as well. This was not so much a foul, but a full on multiple assault, which means the straight red was well deserved.
clear and obvious red, if you watched the game he had a vendetta against him
I watched it and saw nothing like that
The intent was there, watch him rake his studs in to Schar’s back, trying to inflict damage
Bs
That’s bollocks. Watch him roll his ankle and lose balance