عمدہ بحث اس سلسلہ کو مزید آگے بڑھایا جائے یعنی لفظ کے وضع کی بحث کا تجزیہ کیا جائے لفظ کے معنی کا تعین کیسے ہوگا (معیارات) بھی زیر بحث لائے جائیں جزاکم اللہ🌹
Two points: 1. Ancestors of Stanley Fish , the Bani Israel, asked questions of the kind he is famous for . Their story is as a warning when commanded to sacrifice a heifer. In Surah Baqra the answers to such a generic question is answered where the basic folly of such a question is illustrated in the telling of Bani Israel’s questions about the specific meanings of the nature of the heifer to be sacrificed . Fish is merely raising similar issues. 2. The Prophet (saww) was not just a postman delivering a message, but also the decipherer of the message to his companions. Such explanations are closest to the Divine intent and as such serve as the primary explanation . As the companions passed them on, as they did the Qur’an, those explanations take precedence over subsequent techniques of understanding the divine intent.
لیکن سر قران میں یہ بات تو ھے نا کہ عام انسان بھی جب قران یا قران کا ترجمعہ پڑھتا ھے تو اس میں سے ضروری ہداٸت حاصل کر لیتا ھے ۔ باقی رہ جاتی ھے اس کتاب کو بطور علم کے پڑھنا ۔ یا اس میں غوطہ زنی کرنا یا اسکی باریکیوں کو دیکھنا ۔۔۔۔۔ ظاہر ھے یہ پھر جتی کوٸ محنت کرے گا اتنا پا لے گا ۔ اسلیۓ اکثر استاذ محترم یہ بات کرتے ھیں کہ قران آسان ترین کلام بھی ھے اور دنیا کی مشکل ترین کتاب بھی ۔۔۔۔۔۔
Respected Sajid Sahib, sir, this statement that we should not dig deep to find Truth about nature and it's related phenomenon as advised by God according to you. Sorry to say if we accept your this statement then respected sir you have to sit naked in front of naked students because only raising questions and critical thinking to thoughts in established history led us to current innovation and advancement in science and knowledge growth. Regards
💕
After a long time!
عمدہ بحث
اس سلسلہ کو مزید آگے بڑھایا جائے
یعنی لفظ کے وضع کی بحث کا تجزیہ کیا جائے
لفظ کے معنی کا تعین کیسے ہوگا (معیارات) بھی زیر بحث لائے جائیں
جزاکم اللہ🌹
Two points:
1. Ancestors of Stanley Fish , the Bani Israel, asked questions of the kind he is famous for . Their story is as a warning when commanded to sacrifice a heifer. In Surah Baqra the answers to such a generic question is answered where the basic folly of such a question is illustrated in the telling of Bani Israel’s questions about the specific meanings of the nature of the heifer to be sacrificed . Fish is merely raising similar issues.
2. The Prophet (saww) was not just a postman delivering a message, but also the decipherer of the message to his companions. Such explanations are closest to the Divine intent and as such serve as the primary explanation . As the companions passed them on, as they did the Qur’an, those explanations take precedence over subsequent techniques of understanding the divine intent.
لیکن سر قران میں یہ بات تو ھے نا کہ عام انسان بھی جب قران یا قران کا ترجمعہ پڑھتا ھے تو اس میں سے ضروری ہداٸت حاصل کر لیتا ھے ۔ باقی رہ جاتی ھے اس کتاب کو بطور علم کے پڑھنا ۔ یا اس میں غوطہ زنی کرنا یا اسکی باریکیوں کو دیکھنا ۔۔۔۔۔
ظاہر ھے یہ پھر جتی کوٸ محنت کرے گا اتنا پا لے گا ۔
اسلیۓ اکثر استاذ محترم یہ بات کرتے ھیں کہ قران آسان ترین کلام بھی ھے اور دنیا کی مشکل ترین کتاب بھی ۔۔۔۔۔۔
Respected Sajid Sahib, sir, this statement that we should not dig deep to find Truth about nature and it's related phenomenon as advised by God according to you. Sorry to say if we accept your this statement then respected sir you have to sit naked in front of naked students because only raising questions and critical thinking to thoughts in established history led us to current innovation and advancement in science and knowledge growth. Regards