8:05, 12:15, 17:08 Maybe, make a dozen or so short vids for common techniques you use so that you can link to them and refer back to them when you need to?
Bill.. can we just take a moment to appreciate the fact that your content is so wonderful that you've reached episode 60? Keep up the great work Mate!😁😁
Been awesome seeing Respite gradually built up into the fleshed out world it is now. I'm honestly surprised the yoga mat foam tiles worked that well, and they seem very durable as well! Great stuff, I eagerly await the April fools video where you and Bobby swap channels for the day and we see Bobby Making Stuff and Bill's Fingers.
The sky is orange, a hue from the rust, The townsfolk are friendly, but not ones to trust, The spaceships that failed, now part of the decor, In Bill's town, they're loved, even more than before. And I think to myself... what a wonderfully rusted world...
I'll buy you a warm beer, but only because you showed us how to make Crustard in this episode. I love that giant paintbrush that keeps on giving of itself slowly over time so that you can make grass for your builds. The tiles look great with the oil wash and Crustard on them. Great camera work on the town shots and incredible narration by Roberto Phalanges! Excellent all around!
A video goes from A to A+ whenever there's a "dry brushhhhh" whisper included. I loved seeing all the Respite builds put together like that. It's really building up nicely
Bill you're one of my favorites. I love a dry sense of humor and I think you are quintessentially British. The only thing that could make your content more British is the occasional clink of a tea cup. Music to my ears!
haha I totally sympathise with knocking over pots of runny paint! I have taken to hot gluing a chunk of plywood to the bottom of my cup so it doesnt so easily tip over , maybe that might help you too :)
I love this idea!! I think the jigsaw bits actually match the town of Respite quite well, like previous residents built the town on top of giant metal plates that over time have just collected sand and dust. Maybe you could make up some alien race that used to be there and built something underground that might affect the water/hallucinogens that you were talking about a few episodes ago with the well build?
For Aussies: these types of mats are available from Bunnings for about $10 for a pack of 4 (dunno if you can get them cheaper elsewhere). I've used them in foam prop making, to temporarily 'maintain' gaps in woodworking and to line the floor of my small workshop. Very handy things :)
Really cool to see the town as a whole. I love the traveler's journal bit at the end too! Also, the jigsaw pattern kind of looks like cracks in the ground if you squint, and personally, I don't think it's too distracting.
This scratch built terrain series for Respite is so cool! I definitely want to see you expand the town, and some other locations on the planet. It’s really neat hearing the lore slowly develop too
The piece he wrote sounds like a first-person version of the narrator's description of a village in Terry Pratchett's Discworld series. Such a nice mat/project to tie the previous ones together. I love the addition of the red mossy bits.
This just blow my mind, the ending narrated scene… man I was so deep into story and scenery! Love your works! Every time you post on instagram “video on its way” I’m excited and can’t wait! 😅
Yayyy! I’m so happy I got to see Respite come together like this! And I absolutely love the journal entries! ❤ your idea of asmr is great! Thank you for sharing.
Although: if all of these builds are within the same world, does that mean there is still a bead bot out in the scrap that rides a monstrosity as a pod-racer among the scrap piles?
Fantastic! Paint the jigsaw sections to look like metal and add rivets. Would look like the land the town sits on has been wielded together to stop it from crumbling.😅
It has been epic seeing you build your world, with each video Bill! plus the lore you have created sounds like it would be fun to do in a table top role playing game. and to another 60 plus videos
Great stuff as always. Can’t wait for the heavy sigh from the wife when she finds the partially disfigured paint brush used for long grass. Looking forward to your “Spill the wash!” Or “Don’t spill the wash!” Lines of merchandise.
Holy cow, episode 60!! My DUUUDE that’s awesome! I’ve been traveling the past 2 months so I’m catching up now. Honestly, I think the puzzle mats are a brilliant solution; definitely a good compromise for those of us with little space. Love it!! 🎉
My goodness Bill. You keep making wonderful videos. I don't know what it is but they're like... the best. Well I do know. But its so many things. The colours(the clr theme is wonderful), the music, the humour (direct and subtle), the designs themselves... It always seems to come out great. Even when it starts off looking strange, like this one, with the squeaky foam and stabbing. The mats look amazing in the end(!). And Respite looks exactly like I imagined it from your descriptions! How great! And the lore. I feel the attention you give to it makes it not just a "fun private project" or something, but is quickly creating a coherent and exciting... franchise(?), if you will. To use a modern stupid word. World(?), that really lives. With us too. Like, that book is looking VERY interesting in my eyes, and Im sure to all of us your loyal followers. And just adding grass to your old models is like "what? wait!... Oh yeah, no it works its great. Of course it is." Like, you've made a world that we care about. ... Jeez. Im fawning here. Sorry. Many words. Just trying to express appreciation precisely in a second language. Blah blah. Your videos really brighten my day. That's it. 👌Good stuff. Keep it up.
I use multiple 2x4 foot 30mm XPS foam for my gaming boards. No MDF, no plywood, no wooden wall supports. Just foam, covered in good old glue, sand and paint. Got four battlefields, each comprising of three boards: snow, desert, grass and "dead earth. I have 4 2x4 foot trestle tables with folding legs which I mount the boards on.
It's funny that I'm seeing you, BMC, and others making these, especially this version. I designed something like this out of wood with dove tails and a finishing strip to go around the board about 5-6 years ago. Never went anywhere with the design as I didn't have the money or skill to pull it off. There was also to be some that were 6x6 and 6x12 instead of 12x12 so you could add different features wherever. The closest I ever came to doing the project was making some 12x12 desert tiles with different features for Necromunda last year out of basswood. Oh, well, great minds and all.
The modular mats work pretty great. Reminds me of some tabletop games that create random maps using tile cards that are shuffled, and one new tile gets added to the game map every turn. If you're up for a LONG game you could implement similar with this and make players explore and expand the map as the game goes... might need to rent a gymnasium though.
The best way I've found to carve out the EVA foam is with a dremel using woodcarving bits, it's not particularly precise, but it's much quicker than any other way I've found. Love the video, thanks!
Kind of impressed watching you go at those Eva mats with a craft knife. I am partial to a rotary tool with a sanding drum for Eva foam because Eva foam is nemesis of the craft blade and it’s sole purpose in life is to blunt them
I've been using that twine technique for a while but I always did the painting after cutting the twine, this method is actually faster so thanks for that.
That's a rather snazzy idea Bill , we've got quite a few of those mats we used for camping, good floor covering. I think the way they interlock adds to the scenery actually . If we've got any we don't use I'm sure we could pass them on . I'll have a look (when we get better weather) .... Great narration about the Town called Respite .... l,think it woukd make a great Sci Fi novel 😊👍
💜 Great idea Bill! Very versatile and open for creativity. Love it. To answer your question about thrift stores in the US, sometimes it goes to charity. I used to shop at one that was dedicatedto helping battered women. St. Vincent de Paul is a charitable second hand store. But sometimes, they are just a privately owned small business, so it just goes to the owner.
I think it is safe to say yoga mat boards are the way of the future. Great video! I would still like to know what size of corrugated tube you used on the garden domes from the last build. I haven't been able to track them down.
How can that look so good?! The eva foam looked like hell when you were done hacking it up and the "bricks" didn't make it much better. But then a coating of crustard and an oil wash and it was incredible already!
Dremel rotary tool for carving eva foam. (Very messy though). A hot air paint stripper will seal the surface. We use it for making armour and monsters.
Awesome! It's coming together beautifully! And your short story collection is just the icing on the cake! Lol! Keep being the artistic genius that you are dude!
Another good option I've seen is canvas tarps with a calk based crusted worked into them, they are only a flat sandy textured plain but lack the puzzle piece issue.
I've been rewatching Clone Wars, and I realized that Lotho Minor is a bit like the worst bot-eat-bot areas of your planet. I've always thought that Lucas could stand to have played a lot more D&D (cause they only had D&D back in the day) to learn that planets are never JUST a city, or a droid hellscape, or a desert... Anyway, I like your world building style, it has nuance.
Hey Bill! Love the custom-sizable possibilities of your mat! So cool strolling through Respite! I wonder if a linoleum cutter would gouge out the yoga mat areas better.
You could cover the puzzle shapes by gluing thin sheets of XPS foam on top of the yoga mat tiles. Should be possible to do so and still make the tiles easy to assemble, although you will lose a bit of modularity (i.e. you may not be able to convert the 3x3 shape to the 4x2 shape).
As usual brilliant, funny, and inspiring [thanks for the coconut fiber technique!! We all had lying around Ikea coconut fiber since sqidmar said it was good for bases, but now I am really going to use it, to morph my minis for turnip and as tufts in their bases]. Loved the modular mat and the connecting paths! Keep making these amazing videos!
Hey Bill, loving your work! The travelers journal idea is top notch and I know what you mean about the seeming divergent evolution of crafting channels that are just randomly making the same things at the same time, it's spooky. Either way loved the episode and the voice over at the end was glorious, it left me wanting more from your world than ever before. I especially want to see that landing pad, it sounds like a really fun one to craft
flocking could cover those lines if it's long enough, green or tan grass and any paths use heavy layers of stone, or water/lava, a jelly compound that's ever so slightly flexible to close the gap when put together with others like it.
I feel like every TH-camr I watch must hang out on the weekends. You all seem to know each other! Respite is looking amazing Bill, would love to run jobs in it with my stargrave crew, the space miners union. Nice work!
Hey Bill! Can you do a video on how to build mecha/vehicle hangars out of simple stuff like cardboard, wires and spraypaint? So far none of the youtubers i watch managed to come up with something like that, and i feel like you'd be the best teacher.
Great video. I think the EVA mats are a good solution. If people don’t like the puzzle shape, they could just cut them off and use normal squared tiles. I currently use a DIY double sided battlemat made out of cloth and acrylic caulking but I have been using cardboard tiles for a long time.
JOIN PATREON : www.patreon.com/billmakingstuff
TIP JAR: www.paypal.com/donate?business=ALDECMAY7UVDN&item_name=donation¤cy_code=GBP
BUY ME SOMETHING: www.amazon.co.uk/hz/wishlist/ls/1Z9RZGBH79JMW?ref_=wl_share
MERCHANDISE: bill-making-stuff.creator-spring.com/
INSTAGRAM: instagram.com/billmakingstuff/
8:05, 12:15, 17:08 Maybe, make a dozen or so short vids for common techniques you use so that you can link to them and refer back to them when you need to?
There is a fine line between matness and genius ...
ehehehehehe GOOD ONE
I... I loved that one too much.
Bill.. can we just take a moment to appreciate the fact that your content is so wonderful that you've reached episode 60? Keep up the great work Mate!😁😁
👍
The whole cinematic at the end, and the Bobby Fingers narration was just masterful. Excellent job.
Thanks so much for the shoutout Bill! Respite looks great in all its glory and the mat was a great addition! Can't wait to see all the rest of Tapu...
Been awesome seeing Respite gradually built up into the fleshed out world it is now. I'm honestly surprised the yoga mat foam tiles worked that well, and they seem very durable as well! Great stuff, I eagerly await the April fools video where you and Bobby swap channels for the day and we see Bobby Making Stuff and Bill's Fingers.
We see Bill's fingers in every video though...
...heh.
@@MorganMakesThings True... and Bobby does make stuff!
I absolutely love the part where Henry caville said "wow this mat is matness" truly one of the build videos of all time
The sky is orange, a hue from the rust,
The townsfolk are friendly, but not ones to trust,
The spaceships that failed, now part of the decor,
In Bill's town, they're loved, even more than before.
And I think to myself... what a wonderfully rusted world...
I'll buy you a warm beer, but only because you showed us how to make Crustard in this episode. I love that giant paintbrush that keeps on giving of itself slowly over time so that you can make grass for your builds.
The tiles look great with the oil wash and Crustard on them. Great camera work on the town shots and incredible narration by Roberto Phalanges!
Excellent all around!
A video goes from A to A+ whenever there's a "dry brushhhhh" whisper included.
I loved seeing all the Respite builds put together like that. It's really building up nicely
getting bobby fingers in on this makes me so happy. Arguably one of the best channels out there, that's under represented.
Dude, grats on 60!
Thanks knarb
Bill you're one of my favorites. I love a dry sense of humor and I think you are quintessentially British. The only thing that could make your content more British is the occasional clink of a tea cup. Music to my ears!
haha I totally sympathise with knocking over pots of runny paint! I have taken to hot gluing a chunk of plywood to the bottom of my cup so it doesnt so easily tip over , maybe that might help you too :)
It was awesome to see the town come together. Also, I was impressed how you managed to get all of the paths to link together with the jigs. Very nice.
The town looks fantastic, with all the pieces combined! A perfect setting for tiny adventurers.
I love the idea of the portable mat! I looks great and I honestly don't think the edges are bothering at all
I love this idea!! I think the jigsaw bits actually match the town of Respite quite well, like previous residents built the town on top of giant metal plates that over time have just collected sand and dust. Maybe you could make up some alien race that used to be there and built something underground that might affect the water/hallucinogens that you were talking about a few episodes ago with the well build?
When I was watching the Black Magic Craft video I was actually wondering how Bill would tackle the same thing.
The town's looking great, can't wait to see a game played on it in the future and looking forward to more lore about it.
The reason I love your channel is that your creativity has absolutely no bounds! Thanks for another great bit of entertainment!
For Aussies: these types of mats are available from Bunnings for about $10 for a pack of 4 (dunno if you can get them cheaper elsewhere). I've used them in foam prop making, to temporarily 'maintain' gaps in woodworking and to line the floor of my small workshop. Very handy things :)
Really cool to see the town as a whole. I love the traveler's journal bit at the end too! Also, the jigsaw pattern kind of looks like cracks in the ground if you squint, and personally, I don't think it's too distracting.
I look forward to every time I receive a Bill Making Stuff video! These have been so helpful with my crafting projects.
Awesome, I think the tiles work well, the fact you can arrange them in any way to fit what ever table you've got is ingenious!
Neat idea, was planning a modular build using 4mm cork tiles, might try combining the two.
Respite reminds me a lot of Caves of Qud, maybe purely on vibes alone. Been super cool seeing it slowly come together
Bill your world is so inspired and detailed, its something i would love to just dive into. good job on respite so far!
This scratch built terrain series for Respite is so cool! I definitely want to see you expand the town, and some other locations on the planet. It’s really neat hearing the lore slowly develop too
Beautiful shots and lore at the end. The food domes and bounty board are my favorite parts of Respite so far!
The piece he wrote sounds like a first-person version of the narrator's description of a village in Terry Pratchett's Discworld series. Such a nice mat/project to tie the previous ones together. I love the addition of the red mossy bits.
The narration over the shots of the town are incredible, part and parcel amazing picture. Amazing work.
Another fabulous time, my friend. Thank you for the entertainment. Your skills are amazing, and you make it all seem so easy!! Bravo and Well done!!
This just blow my mind, the ending narrated scene… man I was so deep into story and scenery! Love your works! Every time you post on instagram “video on its way” I’m excited and can’t wait! 😅
Yayyy! I’m so happy I got to see Respite come together like this! And I absolutely love the journal entries! ❤ your idea of asmr is great! Thank you for sharing.
I’m loving this world your making, can’t wait to see more of it!
Been following this for a long while now, always top notch quality and really fun to see your world come together, here's to another 60+ vids! 🎉
Se got to see Respite! I am pleased: much pleased. Time to build some scrap thingies!!
Although: if all of these builds are within the same world, does that mean there is still a bead bot out in the scrap that rides a monstrosity as a pod-racer among the scrap piles?
Lovely build as always Bill. Exciting to see Respite in it’s full glory!
Awesome job as always. All the terrain you've made so far coming together... beautiful storytelling as well!!
I think the tiles look terrific, and I don't mind the puzzle-piece look at all, to be honest.
This is literally one of my favourite new channels I have found in a looong time! The details, the jokes, the story behind it all! AMAZING!
Fantastic! Paint the jigsaw sections to look like metal and add rivets. Would look like the land the town sits on has been wielded together to stop it from crumbling.😅
That was fabulous. I love the idea of a journal to go along with it. Combines your passions nicely. Good job❤
It's really awesome to see all the past builds together. Loved the bobby fingers cameo.
Phew... I am impressed. Not so much of the crafting (wich is good!) but of the Lore. The story telling part at the end was great!
Thanks Bill’s awesome at stuff, you taught me how to draw robots by seeing your sketches and crafts, now I can draw robots with ease!! Thanks my guy!
Bobby narrated very well, but the script itself was incredible. Love how evocative it is!
It has been epic seeing you build your world, with each video Bill! plus the lore you have created sounds like it would be fun to do in a table top role playing game. and to another 60 plus videos
Great stuff as always. Can’t wait for the heavy sigh from the wife when she finds the partially disfigured paint brush used for long grass. Looking forward to your “Spill the wash!” Or “Don’t spill the wash!” Lines of merchandise.
Holy cow, episode 60!! My DUUUDE that’s awesome! I’ve been traveling the past 2 months so I’m catching up now. Honestly, I think the puzzle mats are a brilliant solution; definitely a good compromise for those of us with little space. Love it!! 🎉
Damn! That’s a fabulously cool modular mat!!! I have enjoyed seeing it all come together!
Awesome!!! I love this! it's cool watching this town evolve over time. Please keep adding more terrain and maybe some custom minies too.
Really cool seeing respite come along over the past couple months, can't wait to make my own lil playboard thanks to you
My goodness Bill. You keep making wonderful videos. I don't know what it is but they're like... the best. Well I do know. But its so many things. The colours(the clr theme is wonderful), the music, the humour (direct and subtle), the designs themselves... It always seems to come out great. Even when it starts off looking strange, like this one, with the squeaky foam and stabbing. The mats look amazing in the end(!). And Respite looks exactly like I imagined it from your descriptions! How great! And the lore. I feel the attention you give to it makes it not just a "fun private project" or something, but is quickly creating a coherent and exciting... franchise(?), if you will. To use a modern stupid word. World(?), that really lives. With us too. Like, that book is looking VERY interesting in my eyes, and Im sure to all of us your loyal followers. And just adding grass to your old models is like "what? wait!... Oh yeah, no it works its great. Of course it is." Like, you've made a world that we care about. ... Jeez. Im fawning here. Sorry. Many words. Just trying to express appreciation precisely in a second language. Blah blah. Your videos really brighten my day. That's it. 👌Good stuff. Keep it up.
I use multiple 2x4 foot 30mm XPS foam for my gaming boards. No MDF, no plywood, no wooden wall supports. Just foam, covered in good old glue, sand and paint. Got four battlefields, each comprising of three boards: snow, desert, grass and "dead earth. I have 4 2x4 foot trestle tables with folding legs which I mount the boards on.
It's funny that I'm seeing you, BMC, and others making these, especially this version. I designed something like this out of wood with dove tails and a finishing strip to go around the board about 5-6 years ago. Never went anywhere with the design as I didn't have the money or skill to pull it off. There was also to be some that were 6x6 and 6x12 instead of 12x12 so you could add different features wherever. The closest I ever came to doing the project was making some 12x12 desert tiles with different features for Necromunda last year out of basswood. Oh, well, great minds and all.
The modular mats work pretty great. Reminds me of some tabletop games that create random maps using tile cards that are shuffled, and one new tile gets added to the game map every turn. If you're up for a LONG game you could implement similar with this and make players explore and expand the map as the game goes... might need to rent a gymnasium though.
The best way I've found to carve out the EVA foam is with a dremel using woodcarving bits, it's not particularly precise, but it's much quicker than any other way I've found. Love the video, thanks!
Kind of impressed watching you go at those Eva mats with a craft knife. I am partial to a rotary tool with a sanding drum for Eva foam because Eva foam is nemesis of the craft blade and it’s sole purpose in life is to blunt them
Wow. It's pretty impressive how you got Gabriel Byrne for the voice of Bobby Fingers. Well done.
Respite looks amazing, I loved that reveal. Interconnecting foam tiles are a brilliant solution, especially with the pathways. Really nice work.
So awesome to see everything come together, it's fantastic!
I've been using that twine technique for a while but I always did the painting after cutting the twine, this method is actually faster so thanks for that.
There IS a tour video!! So amazing! And yes, I do see cat. You haven't completely lost it...yet. 😊
Henry's titan is exquisite
..and it was for charity as well? Wow.
That's a rather snazzy idea Bill , we've got quite a few of those mats we used for camping, good floor covering. I think the way they interlock adds to the scenery actually . If we've got any we don't use
I'm sure we could pass them on . I'll have a look (when we get better weather) .... Great narration about the Town called Respite .... l,think it woukd make a great Sci Fi novel 😊👍
perfect, happy to see it all together and on a mat.
💜 Great idea Bill! Very versatile and open for creativity. Love it. To answer your question about thrift stores in the US, sometimes it goes to charity. I used to shop at one that was dedicatedto helping battered women. St. Vincent de Paul is a charitable second hand store. But sometimes, they are just a privately owned small business, so it just goes to the owner.
I think it is safe to say yoga mat boards are the way of the future. Great video! I would still like to know what size of corrugated tube you used on the garden domes from the last build. I haven't been able to track them down.
i think they were from an old mic stand
How can that look so good?! The eva foam looked like hell when you were done hacking it up and the "bricks" didn't make it much better. But then a coating of crustard and an oil wash and it was incredible already!
Dremel rotary tool for carving eva foam. (Very messy though). A hot air paint stripper will seal the surface. We use it for making armour and monsters.
I dont know how it took me so long to find your content, but its fantastic! Ur hilarious, creative, and I love your sense of style too!
Dude, using these mats as terrain is amazing!
Awesome!
It's coming together beautifully! And your short story collection is just the icing on the cake! Lol!
Keep being the artistic genius that you are dude!
Love the way your world is coming together !
Another good option I've seen is canvas tarps with a calk based crusted worked into them, they are only a flat sandy textured plain but lack the puzzle piece issue.
The Monster in My Pocket figs in the bottom right at the start gave me a nostalgia hit. Trading those was banned at my school. 😂
I could be interesting to add some oxidized copper type rust as well as the orange just to add more colour
I knew straight away that you didn't invite Cavil - not enough space in the workshop to fit him. Can't fool me, Bill!
I've been rewatching Clone Wars, and I realized that Lotho Minor is a bit like the worst bot-eat-bot areas of your planet. I've always thought that Lucas could stand to have played a lot more D&D (cause they only had D&D back in the day) to learn that planets are never JUST a city, or a droid hellscape, or a desert...
Anyway, I like your world building style, it has nuance.
You should start mixing the oil wash above whatever piece you're working on. That way it won't be a spill, you'll just skip the step of using a brush.
Stuff like jigsaw lines doesn’t bother me in the least, incredible job bill! Really loved the story too. ❤
Hey Bill! Love the custom-sizable possibilities of your mat! So cool strolling through Respite!
I wonder if a linoleum cutter would gouge out the yoga mat areas better.
It would but take even longer
Very nice to see the builds become a town 💜
You could cover the puzzle shapes by gluing thin sheets of XPS foam on top of the yoga mat tiles. Should be possible to do so and still make the tiles easy to assemble, although you will lose a bit of modularity (i.e. you may not be able to convert the 3x3 shape to the 4x2 shape).
Great idea! Only need another 3 mats to make it 4*3 which is typical for 40k
I really like your sense of humour and your vibe love hearing you talk and all that … the music and everything really amazing work keep it up
Awesome as always! Idk if you know Ian Hubert, he does a lot of 3D stuff, but I think you would like his style! Very inspiring
Nice to see it all together! Keep it up, Bill
As usual brilliant, funny, and inspiring [thanks for the coconut fiber technique!! We all had lying around Ikea coconut fiber since sqidmar said it was good for bases, but now I am really going to use it, to morph my minis for turnip and as tufts in their bases].
Loved the modular mat and the connecting paths! Keep making these amazing videos!
Oh my God, I don't believe it took me this long to figure it out! Brilliant!
Hey Bill, loving your work! The travelers journal idea is top notch and I know what you mean about the seeming divergent evolution of crafting channels that are just randomly making the same things at the same time, it's spooky. Either way loved the episode and the voice over at the end was glorious, it left me wanting more from your world than ever before. I especially want to see that landing pad, it sounds like a really fun one to craft
A rotary tool with a sanding drum or a rasp does a fairly good job of carving up eva foam.
Cat is fast becoming one of my fave internet personalities!!
flocking could cover those lines if it's long enough, green or tan grass and any paths use heavy layers of stone, or water/lava, a jelly compound that's ever so slightly flexible to close the gap when put together with others like it.
I feel like every TH-camr I watch must hang out on the weekends. You all seem to know each other!
Respite is looking amazing Bill, would love to run jobs in it with my stargrave crew, the space miners union. Nice work!
Beautiful work Bill. Love it.
Hey Bill! Can you do a video on how to build mecha/vehicle hangars out of simple stuff like cardboard, wires and spraypaint? So far none of the youtubers i watch managed to come up with something like that, and i feel like you'd be the best teacher.
Great video. I think the EVA mats are a good solution. If people don’t like the puzzle shape, they could just cut them off and use normal squared tiles. I currently use a DIY double sided battlemat made out of cloth and acrylic caulking but I have been using cardboard tiles for a long time.